SUBSECT. I.
pp. 145–15124 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 145–15124 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Lord, saith David, is righteous in all his waies, Psal. 145. The judgements of the Lord, saith Solomon, are weight and measure, Prov. 16. 11. That is, exact and without all exception. So just is God, that he offers the justice of his decrees and waies, to the triall of humane understanding. Isai. 5. 3. Judge I pray you, between me and my vineyard: and Ezech. 18. 25. He is content to prove himselfe just by plain arguments, through the whole chapter; Are not my waies equall, and your waies unequall? And he permitted Abraham, when he was in his greatest humility, acknowledging himselfe to be but Dust and Ashes, to reason with him about the equity of his doings; Wilt thou slay the righteous with the wicked. Shall not the judge of all the earth doe right? Gen. 18. 23, 25. And Moses also, Num. 16. 22. is suffered to argue Gods justice in the same manner; Shall one man sinne, and wilt thou •e ••oth with all the Congregation▪ In a word; so evidently just is God in all his proceedings, that many both good and bad, who have felt his justice have cleared God, and deepely charged themselves, witnesse, Ezra, Nehemiah, and Daniell in their ninth Chapters, and Adonibezek, Judges 1. •. and the Emperour Mauricius, who having seen his children butchered, and waiting every 1minute for the bloudy stroake of death, brake out into these words; Justus es Domine, & justum est judicium tuum. Righteous art thou O Lord, and just is thy judgement. With this inviolable justice of God, absolute reprobation (of such especially as are commanded to believe and called to Salvation) cannot be reconciled. My reasons are these.
1. Because it makes God to punish the righteous with the wicked, as it is taught the Supralapsarian way, directly, as it is defended the Sublapsarian way by good consequence.
The Sublapsarians present man to God in his decrees of reprobation considered without sin and will have God to determine the infliction of unspeakable misery upon millions of men, without consideration of any evil in them original or actual (as I have touched before) and so they make him plainly to be a destroyer of the righteous.
The Sublapsarians present man to God in his decrees of reprobation considered without sinne and will have God to determine the infliction of unspeakable misery upon millions of men, without consideration of any evill in them originall or actuall (as I have touched before) and so they make him plainly to be a destroyer of the righteous.
The Sublapsarians (for against their way have I tied my self to bend my reasons) present man to God, considered indeed in original sin, which is a sin (so far as it concerns Adams posterity) made ours only by Gods order and appointment, and so in effect they say, 1. That God did lay upon every man a necessity of being borne in original sin. 2. That he hath determined for that sin, to cast away the far greater part of Mankind for ever; and so they make God to do by two acts, the one accompanying the other, which the other say he did by one: and they will not stick, if they be put to it, to say as D. Twice doth, Quod Deus potest intercedente libera sua ••stitutione, illud 1etiam absolute poterit, vel sine ali ••• constitution intercedent•. That is God may decree men to hell (for that is the thing he speaks of) for Adams sin, which is derived to them by the only constitution of God, he may as well do it absolutely, without any such constitution. It is all one in substance, to decree the misery of an innocent man, and to purpose, that he shall be involved in a sin, that so he may be brought to misery: neither of these Decrees are just. Non justitia justa dicetur (saith Fulgentius) si puniendum reum non invenisse sed fecisse dicatur: major vero e•it iniustitia, si lapso Deus retribuat 2poenam, quem stantem praedestinasse dicitur ad ruinam.
The Sublapsarians (for against their way have I tied my selfe to bend my reasons) present man to God, considered indeed in originall sinne, which is a sinne (so farre as it concernes Adams posterity) made ours only by Gods order and appointment, and so in effect they say, 1. That God did lay upon every man a necessity of being borne in originall sinne. 2. That he hath determined for that sinne, to cast away the farre greater part of Mankind for ever; and so they make God to doe by two acts, the one accompanying the other, which the other say he did by one: and they will not stick, if they be put to it, to say as D. Twisse doth, Quod Deus potest intercedente libera sua ••stitutione, illud 1etiam absolute poterit, vel sine ali ••• constitutione intercedent•. That is God may decree men to hell (for that is the thing he speaks of) for Adams sinne, which is derived to them by the only constitution of God, he may as well doe it absolutely, without any such constitution. It is all one in substance, to decree the misery of an innocent man, and to purpose, that he shall be involved in a sinne, that so he may be brought to misery: neither of these Decrees are just. Non iustitia iusta dicetur (saith Fulgentius) si puniendum reum non invenisse sed fecisse dicatur: major vero e•it iniustitia, si lapso Deus retribuat 2poenam, quem stantem praedestinasse dicitur ad ruinam.
With us Christians there is no doubt or question made of the truth of this, that God is righteous in all his ways: yea though he command Abraham to sacrifice his son; and though he caused not only Achan to be stoned for his trespassing about the excommunicate thing, but his children also with him; and though he visit the sin of Fathers upon the Children to the third and fourth generation of them that hate him. And though in the drowning of the World, he caused Infants to perish with their parents, some in their Mothers womb, some hanging on their Mothers breasts: And so in the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah with fire from heaven. And not so only, but the righteous God hath given us power over inferior creatures, to wear them out in serving our turns with them, yea and to knock them in the heads, to cut their throats, and strangle them as we think good: and we are no whit the more unrighteous in executing this power, which God hath given us upon them: yea in giving his own and holy Son to be reviled, blasphemed, betrayed, condemned, crucified, so to make his soul an offering for our sins. In all these ways the Lord is righteous, and holy in all his works, Solomon saith, Prov. 16. 11. That a just weight and balance are the Lords, all the weights of the bag are his work. And the same Solomon in the same chapter saith, v. 4. The Lord hath made all things for himself, yea even the w••ed against the day of evil. This revives in me the remembrance of a pretty story; An odd fellow came to his Neighbour to borrow a bushel of Malt, saying, the merciful is righteous and lendeth; the other answered him in the same element saying, The ungodly borroweth and payeth not again; Where is that saith the borrower? Where is yours saith the other? Why, saith he, the place I mentioned is in the 37 Psahne. So is mine too, saith the other. But proceed we along with him: Whereas he saith Gods judgements are without exception, that is untrue, for we find the Apostle Saint Paul to take notice of exceptions made against the ways of God in some particular casts; as when God hath mercy on 1whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth: upon the proposal of this Doctrine the Apostle takes notice of such an exception as this. Thou wilt say then, why doth he yet complain, for who hath resisted his will:
VVIth us Christians there is no doubt or question made of the truth of this, that God is righteous in all his waies: yea though he command Abraham to sacrifice his sonne; and though he caused not only Achan to be stoned for his trespassing about the excommunicate thing, but his children also with him; and though he visit the sinne of Fathers upon the Children to the third and fourth generation of them that hate him. And though in the drowning of the World, he caused Infants to perish with their parents, some in their Mothers wombe, some hanging on their Mothers breasts: And so in the destruction of Sodome and Gomorrah with fire from heaven. And not so only, but the righteous God hath given us power over inferiour creatures, to weare them out in serving our turnes with them, yea and to knock them in the heads, to cut their throats, and strangle them as we think good: and we are no whit the more unrighteous in executing this power, which God hath given us upon them: yea in giving his own and holy Sonne to be reviled, blaspheamed, betrayed, condemned, crucified, so to make his soule an offering for our sinnes. In all these waies the Lord is righteous, and holy in all his works, Solomon saith, Prov. 16. 11. That a just weight and ballance are the Lords, all the weights of the bagge are his worke. And the same Solomon in the same chapter saith, v. 4. The Lord hath made all things for himselfe, yea even the w••ed against the day of evill. This revives in me the remembrance of a pretty story; An odde fellow came to his Neighbour to borrow a bushell of Malt, saying, the mercifull is righteous and lendeth; the other answered him in the same element saying, The ungodly borroweth and payeth not againe; Where is that saith the borrower? Where is yours saith the other? Why, saith he, the place I mentioned is in the 37 Psahne. So is mine too, saith the other. But proceed we along with him: Whereas he saith Gods judgements are without exception, that is untrue, for we find the Apostle Saint Paul to take notice of exceptions made against the waies of God in some particular casts; as when God hath mercy on 1whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth: upon the proposall of this Doctrine the Apostle takes notice of such an exception as this. Thou wilt say then, why doth he yet complaine, for who hath resisted his will:
and the justification hereof, the Apostle derives from no other consideration then this, that God is our Creator, and we are his creatures: And that as the Potter hath power over the clay of the same lump, to make one vessel to honour, and another to dishonour; so hath God. O man (saith Paul) who art thou that disputest with God, shall the thing formed, say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the Potter power over the clay? And as the Psalmist saith, That Gods judgements are like a great deep: So the Apostle professeth, That his judgements are unsearchable, and his ways past finding out. And in the common opinion this is 1delivered as touching the depth of Gods counsel in reprobation and predestination; and by the coherence of the words, with that which goes before it, appears to be spoken upon Gods dispensing and denying grace to whom he will, and when he will; As for example; like as there was a time when God had a Church in the World, without distinction of Jews and Gentiles, so afterwards the providence of God was to display it self after three several ways, the first was in gathering a Church unto himself out of the World, from out of the posterity of Abraham, these were called the Jews, in distinction from the Gentiles, who for a long time had not obtained mercy, as the Apostle speaks, Rom. 11. 30. In as much as they believed not: And this dispensation of grace peculiar unto the Jews, with rejection of the Gentiles, continued for about 1600 years. Then God gathered a Church among the Gentiles, with rejection of the Jews, as the Apostle signifies in the place before alleged, saying, now you have obtained mercy through their unbelief. And this dispensation of Gods grace peculiar unto the Gentiles, hath continued now, for about 1600 years. And we believe a time shall come, for the calling of the Jews, and then the Church of God shall consist both of ⟨p. 147⟩Jews and Gentiles, and the general calling of them, as the Apostle signifies, Rom. 11. 12. If the fall of them be the riches of the World, and the diminishing of them the riches of the Gentiles, how much more their fullness: and v. 15. If the casting away of them be the reconciling of the World, what shall the receiving of them be but life from the dead: and v. 31.
and the justification hereof, the Apostle derives from no other consideration then this, that God is our Creator, and we are his creatures: And that as the Potter hath power over the clay of the same lump, to make one vessell to honour, and another to dishonour; so hath God. O man (saith Paul) who art thou that disputest with God, shall the thing formed, say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the Potter power over the clay? And as the Psalmist saith, That Gods judgements are like a great deepe: So the Apostle professeth, That his judgements are unsearcheable, and his waies past finding out. And in the common opinion this is 1delivered as touching the depth of Gods counsell in reprobation and predestination; and by the coherence of the words, with that which goes before it, appears to be spoken upon Gods dispensing and denying grace to whom he will, and when he will; As for example; like as there was a time when God had a Church in the World, without distinction of Jewes and Gentiles, so afterwards the providence of God was to display it selfe after three severall waies, the first was in gathering a Church unto himselfe out of the World, from out of the posterity of Abraham, these were called the Jewes, in distinction from the Gentiles, who for a long time had not obtained mercy, as the Apostle speaks, Rom. 11. 30. In as much as they believed not: And this dispensation of grace peculiar unto the Jewes, with rejection of the Gentiles, continued for about 1600 years. Then God gathered a Church among the Gentiles, with rejection of the Jewes, as the Apostle signifies in the place before alleadged, saying, now you have obtained mercy through their unbeliefe. And this dispensation of Gods grace peculiar unto the Gentiles, hath continued now, for about 1600 years. And we believe a time shall come, for the calling of the Jewes, and then the Church of God shall consist both of ⟨p. 147⟩Jewes and Gentiles, and the generall calling of them, as the Apostle signifies, Rom. 11. 12. If the fall of them be the riches of the World, and the diminishing of them the riches of the Gentiles, how much more their fulnesse: and v. 15. If the casting away of them be the reconciling of the World, what shall the receiving of them be but life from the dead: and v. 31.
Even so have these also now not believed, that through your (Gentiles) mercy, they also (the Jews) might obtain mercy. For God hath concluded them all under unbelief, that he might have mercy on all. And hereupon it is, that the Apostle breaks forth into admiration of this various providence of God, and different dispensation of his grace, saying, O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God, how unsearchable are his judgements, and his ways past finding out? So that albeit the justice of God, be apparent to the understanding of man in some of his ways, yet not in all. Neither doth it follow, that because God offers the justice of his courses, to the trial of humane understanding in some particulars, therefore he offers it to the same trial in all; or that the understanding of man is able to comprehend it in all. Not only carnal men cry out sometimes, Where is the God of judgement? Mal. 2. 17. Again, it is in vain to serve God, and what profit is it that we have kept his commandments, that we have walked humbly before the Lord of hosts? But even the children of wisdom, which are apt to justify her, are yet sometimes offended through weakness of faith, or want of judgement to comprehend the depth of Gods providence, when they have considered the strange prosperity of the wicked, as Job. 21. 6, 7, 8. and David, Psal. 73. and Jeremiah, Jer. 12.
Even so have these also now not believed, that through your (Gentiles) mercy, they also (the Jewes) might obtain mercy. For God hath concluded them all under unbeliefe, that he might have mercy on all. And hereupon it is, that the Apostle breaks forth into admiration of this various providence of God, and different dispensation of his grace, saying, O the depth of the riches both of the wisdome and knowledge of God, how unsearcheable are his judgements, and his waies past finding out? So that albeit the justice of God, be apparent to the understanding of man in some of his waies, yet not in all. Neither doth it follow, that because God offers the justice of his courses, to the triall of humane understanding in some particulars, therefore he offers it to the same triall in all; or that the understanding of man is able to comprehend it in all. Not only carnall men cry out sometimes, Where is the God of judgement? Mal. 2. 17. Again, it is in vain to serve God, and what profit is it that we have kept his commandements, that we have walked humbly before the Lord of hosts? But even the children of wisdome, which are apt to justify her, are yet sometimes offended through weaknesse of faith, or want of judgement to comprehend the depth of Gods providence, when they have considered the strange prosperity of the wicked, as Job. 21. 6, 7, 8. and David, Psal. 73. and Jeremy, Jer. 12.
But to consider punctually the instances here particulated. First not one of them treats of Gods decrees, though this Author boldly claps then in amongst the ways of God: And these places throughout entreat not of the decrees themselves, but of the executions of Gods decrees. As that Isaiah 5. 3. Judge I pray you between me and my vineyard; yet this was mere grace and not justice; but the laying of it wast, (as there he threateneth) for the unfruitfulness thereof, was just even in the conscience of man: So likewise the ways of God mentioned, Ezech. 18. 25. are most equal, as namely in rewarding the obedient, and punishing the disobedient. In like sort there is no question to be made of Gods decrees, concerning the rewarding the one, and punishing the other. And it is as true, that all this is nothing to the purpose. The main question being touching Gods decree, to give the grace of obedience to one, and deny it unto others; and of the execution hereof, in showing mercy on whom he will, and 1hardening whom he will. No reason hereof can be devised by man without falling into manifest absurdity, or manifest heresy, or both. It is true God will not slay the righteous with the wicked: for the Infants of wicked Parents, until God be pleased to regenerate them, are not to be accounted righteous, as being borne children of wrath. Ephes. 2. 3. And therefore as in the conflagration of Sodom, God took a course to save righteous Lot, yet the Infant children of the Sodomites were consumed 2in the same fire with their Parents. And in like manner I answer to that of Moses. Num. 16. 22. Shall one man sin, and wilt thou be angry with all the congregation? You know though Korah might be, and in likelihood he was the principal instigator yet Dathan and Abiram the sons of Eliab, and On, the son of Peleth, the sons of Reuben joined with him in the separation, and with these were joined no less then 250 Captains of the assembly, and they famous in the congregation and men of renown. Nor did those alone perish in this their separation, but their families also. So that whereas when Moses exhorted all the rest to depart from the tents of those wicked men, and thereupon Dathan and Abiram came out and stood in the door of the Tent, with their Wives, and their Sons, and their little Children, all these were swallowed up, and went down quick into the pit:
But to consider punctually the instances here particulated. First not one of them treats of Gods decrees, though this Author boldly claps then in amongst the waies of God: And these places throughout entreat not of the decrees themselves, but of the executions of Gods decrees. As that Isaiah 5. 3. Judge I pray you between me and my vineyard; yet this was meere grace and not justice; but the laying of it wast, (as there he threatneth) for the unfruitfulnesse thereof, was just even in the conscience of man: So likewise the waies of God mentioned, Ezech. 18. 25. are most equall, as namely in rewarding the obedient, and punishing the disobedient. In like sort there is no question to be made of Gods decrees, concerning the rewarding the one, and punishing the other. And it is as true, that all this is nothing to the purpose. The main question being touching Gods decree, to give the grace of obedience to one, and deny it unto others; and of the execution hereof, in shewing mercy on whom he will, and 1hardning whom he will. No reason hereof can be devised by man without falling into manifest absurdity, or manifest heresy, or both. It is true God will not slay the righteous with the wicked: for the Infants of wicked Parents, untill God be pleased to regenerate them, are not to be accounted righteous, as being borne children of wrath. Ephes. 2. 3. And therefore as in the conflagration of Sodome, God took a course to save righteous Lot, yet the Infant children of the Sodomites were consumed 2in the same fire with their Parents. And in like manner I answere to that of Moses. Num. 16. 22. Shall one man sinne, and wilt thou be angry with all the congregation? You know though Korah might be, and in likelihood he was the principall instigator yet Dathan and Abiram the sonnes of Eliab, and On, the sonne of Peleth, the sonnes of Reuben joyned with him in the separation, and with these were joyned no lesse then 250 Captains of the assembly, and they famous in the congregation and men of renowne. Nor did those alone perish in this their separation, but their families also. So that whereas when Moses exhorted all the rest to depart from the tents of those wicked men, and thereupon Dathan and Abiram came out and stood in the doore of the Tent, with their Wives, and their Sonnes, and their little Children, all these were swallowed up, and went downe quick into the pit:
and do you think their little Children were partners with them in this conspiracy? And is not this judgement strange? What can justify this, but the power of God, is Lord over his creature, together with that original corruption that is found in every one when they come into the world? Guess, I pray, how happy this Author is in his observations. This makes me remember, how at my first coming into this place, having to deal with certain Brownists, being willed thereunto by our Diocesan: An old man among the rest, was willing to confer, so we would give him liberty to open his mind at full; we willingly condescended unto him, and thereupon he began to allege places of Scripture to justify his separation; and wheresoever he found the word separate, that he took up for an argument on his side (like him that did set down every ship that ⟨p. 148⟩arrived in the harbour at Athens, as one of his ships) and amongst the rest, this 16 chapter of Numbers afforded him one authority v. 21. where the Lord speaks unto Moses and Aaron, saying, separate your selves from among this congregation; whereunto I answered; here indeed is a separation commanded, but from whom? Surely from those who rose up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron: Now if you can prove us to be such, as rise up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron, then, in the name of God separate your selves from us: But if we are not the men that rise up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron, but you rather, then are not you commanded to separate from us, but we rather are commanded to separate from you; yet we desire only, that you will not separate from us, and all shall be well. But to return, what doth this author think? Was God in a passion, or something precipitate when he said, separate your selves from among this congregation, that I may consume them all at once, and did Moses moderate him as being more-staid of the two? I hope, if God had done as much as he offered to do, his action had been justifiable, as well in the one as in the other. Certainly God should be just, even in turning his holy Angels into nothing: and was just in exposing his holy Son to tortures unexpressable upon the cross; other manner of proceedings, then were those which were used towards Adonibezek and Mauricius: they justified God from consideration of their former sins:
and doe you think their little Children were partners with them in this conspiracy? And is not this judgement strange? What can justify this, but the power of God, is Lord over his creature, together with that originall corruption that is found in every one when they come into the world? Guesse, I pray, how happy this Author is in his observations. This makes me remember, how at my first coming into this place, having to deale with certain Brownists, being willed thereunto by our Diocesan: An old man among the rest, was willing to conferre, so we would give him liberty to open his mind at full; we willingly condescended unto him, and thereupon he began to alleadge places of Scripture to justify his separation; and wheresoever he found the word seperate, that he took up for an argument on his side (like him that did set downe every ship that ⟨p. 148⟩arrived in the harbour at Athens, as one of his shipps) and amongst the rest, this 16 chapter of Numbers afforded him one authority v. 21. where the Lord speaks unto Moses and Aaron, saying, separate your selves from among this congregation; whereunto I answered; here indeed is a separation commanded, but from whom? Surely from those who rose up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron: Now if you can prove us to be such, as rise up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron, then, in the name of God separate your selves from us: But if we are not the men that rise up in rebellion against Moses and Aaron, but you rather, then are not you commanded to separate from us, but we rather are commanded to separate from you; yet we desire only, that you will not separate from us, and all shall be well. But to returne, what doth this author think? Was God in a passion, or something precipitate when he said, separate your selves from among this congregation, that I may consume them all at once, and did Moses moderate him as being more-staid of the two? I hope, if God had done as much as he offered to doe, his action had been iustifiable, as well in the one as in the other. Certainly God should be just, even in turning his holy Angells into nothing: and was just in exposing his holy Sonne to tortures unexpressable upon the crosse; other manner of proceedings, then were those which were used towards Adonibezek and Mauricius: they justified God from consideration of their former sinnes:
No such course of justification could have place in annihilating Angels, or had course in breaking the Holy Son of God for our iniquities. Yet these instances are remarkable to observe therein, the felicity of this Authors discourse. For first, was it God indeed that executed this judgement upon Adonibezek? Now the Text saith, the children of Judah were 1they that dealt thus with him: did God then use their free wills, as his instruments for the execution of this judgement? And how was this? Was it by working them hereunto, or only by concurring with them to this act, as foreseeing they would do such an act, and thereupon decreeing to concur to the producing of that act? If God did work them hereunto, then can God work the will of any man to the doing of any free act freely: for who dares say that the children of Israel did not as freely do this as ought else? But if God only concurred with them, to the doing of it modo vellent, and only, upon foresight that they would do it, decreed to concur to the doing of it, calls he this Gods execution of judgement, depending merely upon the pleasure of man foreseen by God?
No such course of justification could have place in annihilating Angells, or had course in breaking the Holy Sonne of God for our iniquities. Yet these instances are remarkable to observe therein, the felicity of this Authors discourse. For first, was it God indeed that executed this judgement upon Adonibezek? Now the Text saith, the children of Judah were 1they that dealt thus with him: did God then use their free wills, as his instruments for the execution of this judgement? And how was this? Was it by working them hereunto, or only by concurring with them to this act, as foreseeing they would doe such an act, and thereupon decreeing to concurre to the producing of that act? If God did work them hereunto, then can God work the will of any man to the doing of any free act freely: for who dares say that the children of Israel did not as freely doe this as ought else? But if God only concurred with them, to the doing of it modo vellent, and only, upon foresight that they would doe it, decreed to concurre to the doing of it, calls he this Gods execution of judgement, depending meerely upon the pleasure of man foreseen by God?
As for the out-rage executed upon Mauricius by Phocas, this was no less then abominable villainy, as committed by him. Yet if God used him as an instrument herein, to execute his judgement, then God by the sinful act of one, can and doth punish the same of another, and consequently God must be the Author of that sinful act, whereby he punisheth another, and that by Arminius his rule, which is this, Omnis paena non permittitur sed infligitur a Deo, & habet Deum authorem. Now I come to consider his accommodation of so impertinent a discourse. He saith absolute reprobation cannot be reconciled with this justice Divine: we say there is no need at all of reconcilement: for what an insipid thing is it, to talk of a course of reconciling them, who were never at odds? But he takes upon him to prove the repugnancy between them by three reasons.
As for the out-rage executed upon Mauricius by Phocas, this was no lesse then abominable villany, as committed by him. Yet if God used him as an instrument herein, to execute his iudgement, then God by the sinfull act of one, can and doth punish the same of another, and consequently God must be the Author of that sinfull act, whereby he punisheth another, and that by Arminius his rule, which is this, Omnis paena non permittitur sed infligitur a Deo, & habet Deum authorem. Now I come to consider his accommodation of so impertinent a discourse. He saith absolute reprobation cannot be reconciled with this justice Divine: we say there is no need at all of reconcilement: for what an insipid thing is it, to talke of a course of reconciling them, who were never at odds? But he takes upon him to prove the repugnancy between them by three reasons.
1. The first whereof is this. It makes God to punish the righteous with the wicked, as it is taught the Supralapsarian way directly. I confess here is a direct somewhat, but whether a direct truth, or a direct lye, let the indifferent judge. He adventureth the proof of it thus: The Supralapsarians present man in his decree of Reprobation considered without sin: that is true I confess, and it is as true that they present him considered without righteousness also; and for good reason, because Gods decree was eternal, and the creature at that time had no being & to consider a thing that hath no being, as having being, is not so much considerare, to consider, as errare or finger, to err or feign, this I have delivered in my Vindiciae gratiae Dei, and that in the first part of the first book. And this Author pretends he hath read the second, yet he takes no course to refute this or ought else. But let him go on. God (he saith) is made by them to determine the infliction of misery on men without consideration of sin, either Original or actual. First, let it be granted, yet herehence it followeth not, that he is made to be a destroyer of the righteous, or to punish the righteous with the wicked, which was that he affirmed. To determine punishment is one thing, to punish is another thing. Certainly in the opinion of those he speaks of, God punisheth none but the wicked; the very conscience of this Author cannot but convict him of falsehood in this crimination: For certainly by their opinion it doth ⟨p. 151⟩not follow but that every one is found wicked, when God doth punish him. I may as well say in most absolute congruity, that by their opinion, God doth punish men, before they have any being by creation: for such they were indeed, and neither wicked nor righteous, when God passed the decree of reprobation upon them. But neither do these Divines maintain, that God did decree to damn any man but for sin. Nay, I go farther: let the object of reprobation be men not yet created, and so considered, as I have proved it to be so, herehence it no way follows, that the decree of reprobation, is in any moment of reason or nature, before the consideration or citra considerationem peccati: and this also have I proved.
1. The first whereof is this. It makes God to punish the righteous with the wicked, as it is taught the Supralapsarian way directly. I confesse here is a direct somewhat, but whether a direct truth, or a direct lye, let the indifferent judge. He adventureth the proofe of it thus: The Supralapsarians present man in his decree of Reprobation considered without sinne: that is true I confesse, and it is as true that they present him considered without righteousnesse also; and for good reason, because Gods decree was eternall, and the creature at that time had no being & to consider a thing that hath no being, as having being, is not so much considerare, to consider, as errare or fingere, to erre or feign, this I have delivered in my Vindiciae gratiae Dei, and that in the first part of the first book. And this Author pretends he hath read the second, yet he takes no course to refute this or ought else. But let him goe on. God (he saith) is made by them to determine the infliction of misery on men without consideration of sinne, either Originall or actuall. First, let it be granted, yet herehence it followeth not, that he is made to be a destroyer of the righteous, or to punish the righteous with the wicked, which was that he affirmed. To determine punishment is one thing, to punish is another thing. Certainly in the opinion of those he speaks of, God punisheth none but the wicked; the very conscience of this Author cannot but convict him of falshood in this crimination: For certainly by their opinion it doth ⟨p. 151⟩not follow but that every one is found wicked, when God doth punish him. I may as well say in most absolute congruity, that by their opinion, God doth punish men, before they have any being by creation: for such they were indeed, and neither wicked nor righteous, when God passed the decree of reprobation upon them. But neither doe these Divines maintain, that God did decree to damne any man but for sinne. Nay, I goe farther: let the object of reprobation be men not yet created, and so considered, as I have proved it to be so, herehence it no way followes, that the decree of reprobration, is in any moment of reason or nature, before the consideration or citra considerationem peccati: and this also have I proved.
This Author boldly supposeth the contrary to be true, without any proof, yet pretends he hath read my Vindiciae Gratiae Dei farther off then where I have handled this. I say he pretends it, but I do not know how he comes by this, it may be as Capons come by Chickens.
This Author boldly supposeth the contrary to be true, without any proofe, yet pretends he hath read my Vindiciae Gratiae Dei farther off then where I have handled this. I say he pretends it, but I doe not know how he comes by this, it may be as Capons come by Chickens.
Hence he proceeds to the Sublapsarians also, the whole Synod of Dort (as 'tis supposed) our Britain Divines, and all; for against their way he hath tied himself to bend his reasons, but so, that as the Pope by his grants, doth never bind his own hands, for this Author hath power to untie himself at pleasure, and to fly out against the Supralapsarians also: as Scanderbeg did against the two Persian challengers; but he was put thereunto, because they contrary to the compact, set both at once on him. But this champion like a tall fellow, and of a brave spirit, as if he should not have his hands full of a whole Synod, lets fly at all: They indeed, I mean the Sublapsarians, consider mankind in original sin; this he may well suppose: but he goes farther, and supposeth also, that this sin is made ours only by Gods order and appointment: For so, saith he, they in effect do say.
Hence he proceeds to the Sublapsarians also, the whole Synod of Dort (as 'tis supposed) our Brittain Divines, and all; for against their way he hath tyed himselfe to bend his reasons, but so, that as the Pope by his grants, doth never bind his own hands, for this Author hath power to untye himselfe at pleasure, and to fly out against the Supralapsarians also: as Scanderbeg did against the two Persian challengers; but he was put thereunto, because they contrary to the compact, set both at once on him. But this champion like a tall fellow, and of a brave spirit, as if he should not have his hands full of a whole Synod, lets fly at all: They indeed, I mean the Sublapsarians, consider mankind in originall sinne; this he may well suppose: but he goes farther, and supposeth also, that this sinne is made ours only by Gods order and appoyntment: For so, saith he, they in effect doe say.
1. That God did lay upon every man, a necessity of being borne in Original sin. But in this also he speaks at pleasure, quoting no passage of any Author. God may be said to lay upon man a necessity of eternal condemnation, dying in sin unrepented of: yet no sober man will say, that God is the author of a mans condemnation, by Gods only order and pleasure; For this implies, that there is no meritorious cause of condemnation in man. God (we say) of mere pleasure, bestows the grace of repentance on whom he will; because he finds all equal in natural corruption, and no difference in any, whereby to move God to bestow grace on him rather then on another. The case is not alike when God comes to bestow salvation and inflict damnation; for some he finds dying in sins, others dying in the Lord: yet we deny not but by power absolute, and secluding the determination of his own will, he could annihilate the righteous as well as the wicked. In like sort the whole course of nature depends merely upon the pleasure of God: yet we say it is natural for a Leprous person, to beget a Leprous person: and so as natural it is, for that which is borne of the flesh to be flesh, though each depends upon the constitution of God. For albeit Adam lost the spirit of God by his transgression, and all supernatural graces wherewith he was endued; yet like as God by regeneration, of his mere pleasure restored them afterwards to Adam, and in due time doth restore them to every one of his Elect: so in their very conception, if it pleased God, he could for Christs sake infuse them; notwithstanding the sin of Adam; and consequently it is the free act of God, in refusing after this manner to deal with them. Yet this nothing hinders, but that the propagation of spiritual corruption unto all Adams posterity, may be as natural as the propagation of any hereditary disease from the Father to the child: and over and above, that it is not in the way of mere pleasure, but in the way of justice; for the sin of Adam, which was the sin of our nature, bereaving him of that original righteousness wherein he was •reated: and causing all mankind to be, 1. Derived from him, whereas he could have otherwise provided, 2. And that from Adam after his nature was corrupt with sin, whereas he could have derived posterity from him before his fall, had it pleased him.
1. That God did lay upon every man, a necessity of being borne in Originall sinne. But in this also he speaks at pleasure, quoting no passage of any Author. God may be said to lay upon man a necessity of eternall condemnation, dying in sinne unrepented of: yet no sober man will say, that God is the author of a mans condemnation, by Gods only order and pleasure; For this implies, that there is no meritorious cause of condemnation in man. God (we say) of meer pleasure, bestowes the grace of repentance on whom he will; because he finds all equall in naturall corruption, and no difference in any, whereby to move God to bestow grace on him rather then on another. The case is not alike when God comes to bestow salvation and inflict damnation; for some he finds dying in sinnes, others dying in the Lord: yet we deny not but by power absolute, and secluding the determination of his own will, he could annihilate the righteous as well as the wicked. In like sort the whole course of nature depends meerely upon the pleasure of God: yet we say it is naturall for a Leprous person, to beget a Leprous person: and so as naturall it is, for that which is borne of the flesh to be flesh, though each depends upon the constitution of God. For albeit Adam lost the spirit of God by his transgression, and all supernaturall graces wherewith he was endued; yet like as God by regeneration, of his meere pleasure restored them afterwards to Adam, and in due time doth restore them to every one of his Elect: so in their very conception, if it pleased God, he could for Christs sake infuse them; notwithstanding the sinne of Adam; and consequently it is the free act of God, in refusing after this manner to deale with them. Yet this nothing hinders, but that the propagation of spirituall corruption unto all Adams posterity, may be as naturall as the propagation of any hereditary disease from the Father to the child: and over and above, that it is not in the way of meer pleasure, but in the way of justice; for the sinne of Adam, which was the sinne of our nature, bereaving him of that originall righteousnesse wherein he was •reated: and causing all mankind to be, 1. Derived from him, whereas he could have otherwise provided, 2. And that from Adam after his nature was corrupt with sinne, whereas he could have derived posterity from him before his fall, had it pleased him.
And therefore I approve the second Canon of the Synod of Dort, whereunto our English Divines with many others subscribed: where they profess, that the corruption derived from Adam to his posterity was, per vitiosae naturae propagationem justo Dei judicio derivata. This I take to be much different from saying, Adams sin is made ours by mere pleasure, or by imputation only. So the fifteenth Article in the confession Ecclesiarum Belgicarum runs thus; Credimus Adami in obedientiâ, peccatum originis in totum genus humanum diffusum esse: quod est totius naturae corruptio, & vitium haereditarium, quo & ipsi infantes in matris suae utero polluti sunt, quodque veluti radix omne peccatorum genus in homine producit; ideoque ita ⟨p. 150⟩foedum & execrabile est coram Deo, ut ad generis humani condemnationem sufficiat. Our Britain Divines, in their second Thesis upon the third and fourth Articles, explicate themselves concerning the condition of original sin in this manner. Lapsae voluntati inest non tantum peccandi possibilitas, sed etiam praeceps ad peccandum inclinatio; Nec aliter se potest res habere in homine corrupto, nondum per divinam justitiam restaurato: cùm ea sit natura voluntatis, ut nuda manere nequeat, sed ab uno, cui adhaeserat, objecto excidens, aliud quaerat, quod cupidè amplectatur, ideo per spontaneam defectionem habitualiter adversa a Deo creatore, in creaturam effraeni impetu fertur, ac cum ea libidinose ac turpiter fornicatur, semper avida fruendi utendis, ac vetita moliendi ac patrandi. Quid mirum ergo si talis voluntas sit Diaboli maneipium? I find indeed in Corvinus such a profession of his, namely, that ex puro Dei arbitrio, qui Adami peccatum nobis imputare voluit, etiam in nos reatus derivatus est. And Walaeus in answer unto him writes thus; Nec quinto illo ad Rom. Capite, ad quod nos hic Corvinus remittit, quicquam tale dicitur aut innuitur, nempe quod ex mero Dei arbittio pendeat haec primi peccati imputatio.
And therefore I approve the second Canon of the Synod of Dort, whereunto our English Divines with many others subscribed: where they professe, that the corruption derived from Adam to his posterity was, per vitiosae naturae propagationem justo Dei iudicio derivata. This I take to be much different from saying, Adams sinne is made ours by meer pleasure, or by imputation only. So the fifteenth Article in the confession Ecclesiarum Belgicarum runs thus; Credimus Adami in obedientiâ, peccatum originis in totum genus humanum diffusum esse: quod est totius naturae corruptio, & vitium haereditarium, quo & ipsi infantes in matris suae utero polluti sunt, quodque veluti radix omne peccatorum genus in homine producit; ideoque ita ⟨p. 150⟩foedum & execrabile est coram Deo, ut ad generis humani condemnationem sufficiat. Our Brittain Divines, in their second Thesis upon the third and fourth Articles, explicate themselves concerning the condition of originall sinne in this manner. Lapsae voluntati inest non tantum peccandi possibilitas, sed etiam praeceps ad peccandum inclinatio; Nec aliter se potest res habere in homine corrupto, nondum per divinam justitiam restaurato: cùm ea sit natura voluntatis, ut nuda manere nequeat, sed ab uno, cui adhaeserat, objecto excidens, aliud quaerat, quod cupidè amplectatur, ideo per spontaneam defectionem habitualiter adversa a Deo creatore, in creaturam effraeni impetu fertur, ac cum ea libidinose ac turpiter fornicatur, semper avida fruendi utendis, ac vetita moliendi ac patrandi. Quid mirum ergo si talis voluntas sit Diaboli maneipium? I find indeed in Corvinus such a profession of his, namely, that ex puro Dei arbitrio, qui Adami peccatum nobis imputare voluit, etiam in nos reatus derivatus est. And Walaeus in answer unto him writes thus; Nec quinto illo ad Rom. Capite, ad quod nos hic Corvinus remittit, quicquam tale dicitur aut innuitur, nempe quod ex mero Dei arbittio pendeat haec primi peccati imputatio.
2. The Second thing he puts upon our Divines is, That God hath determined for that sin, to cast away the far greater part of mankind for ever: and so they make God to do that by two acts, the one accompanying the other, which the other say he did by one. To which I answer, First, that if they say that God doth no more by two acts, then, the other say, God did by one, seeing I have proved that the other do no way maintain that God doth punish the righteous with the wicked, which is his immodest and unshamefac't crimination; no nor do they maintain, that God determined to damn any but for sin, and which is more then that, supposing humanum genus nondum conditum, to be the object of reprobation, yet doth it not follow, that in any moment of nature, the decree of damnation is before the consideration of sin; surely neither will it follow, by the Sublapsarian Doctrine, that God doth not decree to punish any man with damnation, but for those sins wherein he dyeth unrepented of; much less that God doth punish the righteous with the wicked, which is the crimination of this Author, proposed, I doubt, against his own conscience. Tis true, some perish only in original sin, and that justly: for if they be borne children of wrath, is it strange if they dye children of wrath? And is it not just with God to inflict eternal death on them, whom this Author professeth to be guilty of eternal death? only he saith, that God of his mere pleasure, makes them guilty of eternal death: That is his saying, not ours: For though we say original sin makes a man guilty of eternal death, by the free constitution of God; yet we say not, that this free constitution of God was made of his mere pleasure, but justo Dei judicio▪ like as whosoever believes not shall be damned, here damnation is by the free constitution of God, made the portion of unbelievers: but dares this Author infer herehence, that it is not made so justo Dei judicio? indeed God gives grace according to the mere pleasure of his will: but no wise man will say, that he damns men according to the mere pleasure of his will; for this phrase implies, that there is no cause thereof on mans part:
2. The Second thing he puts upon our Divines is, That God hath determined for that sinne, to cast away the farre greater part of mankind for ever: and so they make God to doe that by two acts, the one accompanying the other, which the other say he did by one. To which I answer, First, that if they say that God doth no more by two acts, then, the other say, God did by one, seeing I have proved that the other doe no way maintain that God doth punish the righteous with the wicked, which is his immodest and unshamefac't crimination; no nor doe they maintain, that God determined to damne any but for sinne, and which is more then that, supposing humanum genus nondum conditum, to be the object of reprobation, yet doth it not follow, that in any moment of nature, the decree of damnation is before the consideration of sinne; surely neither will it follow, by the Sublapsarian Doctrine, that God doth not decree to punish any man with damnation, but for those sinnes wherein he dyeth unrepented of; much lesse that God doth punish the righteous with the wicked, which is the crimination of this Author, proposed, I doubt, against his own conscience. Tis true, some perish only in originall sinne, and that justly: for if they be borne children of wrath, is it strange if they dye children of wrath? And is it not just with God to inflict eternall death on them, whom this Author professeth to be guilty of eternall death? only he saith, that God of his meer pleasure, makes them guilty of eternall death: That is his saying, not ours: For though we say originall sinne makes a man guilty of eternall death, by the free constitution of God; yet we say not, that this free constitution of God was made of his meer pleasure, but justo Dei judicio▪ like as whosoever believes not shall be damned, here damnation is by the free constitution of God, made the portion of unbelievers: but dares this Author inferre herehence, that it is not made so justo Dei judicio? indeed God gives grace according to the meere pleasure of his will: but no wise man will say, that he damnes men according to the meere pleasure of his will; for this phrase implies, that there is no cause thereof on mans part:
And indeed there is no cause on mans part, why God should give him grace, but there is cause enough on mans part, why God should inflict damnation on him, and yet this work of God though just, is never a whit the less free. So in damning for original sin only, though Gods constitution hereof be just, yet is it never a whit the less free; and though it be free, yet it is never a whit the less just: And like as damnation is inflicted on final impenitents, sola Dei constitutione, only by virtue of this constitution Divine, whosoever repents not of his sin shall be damned; (for it is apparent, God might have annihilated them, had it so pleased him) yet is it never a whit the less just. In like sort it is by the sole constitution of God, that original sin is propagated to all men, Christ excepted. for God could have derived mankind from another stock after Adams fall: and as he doth regenerate men usually by his word, so he might if it pleased him, in their very conception give them his spirit, and those supernatural graces, whereof Adam was deprived by sin: yet the propagation of sin from Adam to posterity. is never a whit the less just; no nor any whit the less natural; like as the whole course of nature, depends upon the alone constitution of God. But when I say that God can without respect of sin, inflict any torment upon his creature, this is delivered of power absolute. This power the Lord did execute upon his own son: for what was his sin? Was he not the spotless lamb of God? Yet what agonies did he suffer in the garden, what torments and terrors upon the cross, when he cried out My God, my God, Why hast thou forsaken me? But the ⟨p. 151⟩like power he doth not execute on us, only he gives us authority to exercise the like power over other creatures: if the powder of an Hare burnt alive in an Oven, be found to be wholesome for us, he gives us leave thus to deal with him, and the like: yet have not these creatures sinned either against God, or against us. Of this absolute power of God, I have discoursed more sparingly in the place cited by him, Lib. 1. p. 2. De Electione, digres. 3. If this Author hath any mind to except against it, either in whole or in part, he might have tried his strength, and not contented himself, with showing his teeth only.
And indeed there is no cause on mans part, why God should give him grace, but there is cause enough on mans part, why God should inflict damnation on him, and yet this work of God though just, is never a whit the lesse free. So in damning for originall sinne only, though Gods constitution hereof be just, yet is it never a whit the lesse free; and though it be free, yet it is never a whit the lesse just: And like as damnation is inflicted on finall impenitents, sola Dei constitutione, only by vertue of this constitution Divine, whosoever repents not of his sinne shall be damned; (for it is apparent, God might have annihilated them, had it so pleased him) yet is it never a whit the lesse just. In like sort it is by the sole constitution of God, that originall sinne is propagated to all men, Christ excepted. for God could have derived mankind from another stock after Adams fall: and as he doth regenerate men usually by his word, so he might if it pleased him, in their very conception give them his spirit, and those supernaturall graces, whereof Adam was deprived by sinne: yet the propagation of sinne from Adam to posterity. is never a whit the lesse just; no nor any whit the lesse naturall; like as the whole course of nature, depends upon the alone constitution of God. But when I say that God can without respect of sinne, inflict any torment upon his creature, this is delivered of power absolute. This power the Lord did execute upon his own sonne: for what was his sinne? Was he not the spotlesse lamb of God? Yet what agonies did he suffer in the garden, what torments and terrours upon the crosse, when hee cryed out My God, my God, Why hast thou forsaken mee? But the ⟨p. 151⟩like power he doth not execute on us, only he gives us authority to exercise the like power over other creatures: if the powder of an Hare burnt alive in an Oven, be found to be wholsome for us, he gives us leave thus to deale with him, and the like: yet have not these creatures sinned either against God, or against us. Of this absolute power of God, I have discoursed more sparingly in the place cited by him, Lib. 1. p. 2. De Electione, digres. 3. If this Author hath any mind to except against it, either in whole or in part, he might have tried his strength, and not contented himselfe, with shewing his teeth only.
Yet by his leave, whether those he speaks of, will concur with me in this, it is more then I know, but to serve his turn at this present against those whom he hath tied himself to oppose, as he professeth, he cares little what he avoucheth to save himself of farther pains. By the way let me take notice of one argument more then I dreamt of, for the maintenance of Gods absolute power to inflict any pain upon a creature, and that of his mere pleasure, which this Author ere he is aware suggests unto me; And accordingly thus I dispute. If God can out of his mere pleasure make a man guilty of eternal death, surely it seems that of his mere pleasure he may inflict eternal death on any. But God can of his mere pleasure make a man guilty of eternal death, as I prove out of this Author, who professeth that God out of his mere pleasure, made all mankind guilty of eternal death: Now we commonly say, that ab actu ad potentiam valet argumentum. And see farther how miserably he overlasheth. The highest degree whereunto he can improve the harshness of our Doctrine is this, that we should teach, that God doth decree the misery of an innocent man. Now I pray consider, is it not as harsh, that God should decree the death, the agonies, the sorrows, and tortures of an innocent man? And is it not apparent, that God decreed the death and those unspeakable sorrows of his innocent son? Yet we say not that God decreed any other mans death or damnation, but only for sin. But it is all one in his opinion to say, God decrees the misery of an innocent man, and to purpose that he shall be involved in a sin, that so he may be brought to misery. First, I say his opinion is no Oracle, if it were, the world would soon grow wild. Secondly, this sufficeth not to prove his crimination, which was this, that by our Doctrine, we make God to punish the righteous with the wicked, not that we make God to do that which is all one in substance. Thirdly, his best arguments are his phrases, whereby he hopes to season others affections as well as his own; as in saying God purposed man shall be involved in sin: For if he speak of mankind, made guilty of the sin of Adam, he forgets his own Tenet; that God of his mere pleasure makes Adams sin the sin of his posterity, and thereby of his mere pleasure makes them guilty of eternal death.
Yet by his leave, whether those he speaks of, will concurre with me in this, it is more then I know, but to serve his turne at this present against those whom he hath tyed himselfe to oppose, as he professeth, he cares little what he avoucheth to save himselfe of farther pains. By the way let me take notice of one argument more then I dreamt of, for the maintenance of Gods absolute power to inflict any pain upon a creature, and that of his meer pleasure, which this Author ere he is aware suggests unto me; And accordingly thus I dispute. If God can out of his meer pleasure make a man guilty of eternall death, surely it seems that of his meer pleasure he may inflict eternall death on any. But God can of his meer pleasure make a man guilty of eternall death, as I prove out of this Author, who professeth that God out of his meer pleasure, made all mankind guilty of eternall death: Now we commonly say, that ab actu ad potentiam valet argumentum. And see farther how miserably he overlasheth. The highest degree whereunto he can improve the harshnesse of our Doctrine is this, that we should teach, that God doth decree the misery of an innocent man. Now I pray consider, is it not as harsh, that God should decree the death, the agonics, the sorrowes, and tortures of an innocent man? And is it not apparent, that God decreed the death and those unspeakable sorrowes of his innocent sonne? Yet we say not that God decreed any other mans death or damnation, but only for sinne. But it is all one in his opinion to say, God decrees the misery of an innocent man, and to purpose that he shall be involved in a sinne, that so he may be brought to misery. First, I say his opinion is no Oracle, if it were, the world would soon grow wild. Secondly, this sufficeth not to prove his crimination, which was this, that by our Doctrine, we make God to punish the righteous with the wicked, not that we make God to doe that which is all one in substance. Thirdly, his best arguments are his phrases, whereby he hopes to season others affections as well as his own; as in saying God purposed man shall be involved in sinne: For if he speake of mankind, made guilty of the sinne of Adam, he forgets his own Tenet; that God of his meer pleasure makes Adams sinne the sinne of his posterity, and thereby of his meer pleasure makes them guilty of eternall death.
And as touching our Tenet herein, is there any such harshness in saying, that God causeth a leprous child to be borne of Leprous parents? But if he speak it in general of any sin, for which any man is damned, our Doctrine is, that the sins which come to pass, must needs be permitted by God, and for God to permit any sin, is to will that such a sin shall come to pass by Gods permission. Arminius himself professing, that if God permit a man to will that which is evill, Necesse est ut nullo argumentorum genere persuadeatur ad nolendum. And the Scripture is express as touching the foulest actions that ever were committed by man, to wit, in the most contumelious usages of the Son of God, namely that both Herod, and Pontius Pilate, together with the Gentiles, and people of Israel were gathered together, to do what Gods hand, and Gods Counsel had predetermined to be done. And when Fulgentius saith, that God had been unjust, if he had predestinated stantem ad ruinam; ad ruinam here is ad peccatum, and Predestination in the Fathers sense, is only eorum quae Deus ipse facturus erat, which God himself meant to effect, not what he meant to suffer. That they took predestination in this sense, it appears by Austin. lib. 2. de bono persever. c. 17. his words are these. In sua quae falli mutarique non potest praescientia opera sua futura disponere, illud omnino, nec aliud quicquam est praedestinare. Mark it well, opera sua, his works, now sin is no work of God, but a work of the creature only.
And as touching our Tenet herein, is there any such harshnesse in saying, that God causeth a leprous child to be borne of Leprous parents? But if he speak it in generall of any sinne, for which any man is damned, our Doctrine is, that the sinnes which come to passe, must needs be permitted by God, and for God to permit any sinne, is to will that such a sinne shall come to passe by Gods permission. Arminius himselfe professing, that if God permit a man to will that which is evill, Necesse est ut nullo argumentorum genere persuadeatur ad nolendum. And the Scripture is expresse as touching the foulest actions that ever were committed by man, to wit, in the most contumelious usages of the sonne of God, namely that both Herod, and Pontius Pilate, together with the Gentiles, and people of Israell were gathered together, to doe what Gods hand, and Gods Counsell had predetermined to be done. And when Fulgentius saith, that God had been unjust, if he had predestinated stantem ad ruinam; ad ruinam here is ad peccatum, and Predestination in the Fathers sense, is only eorum quae Deus ipse facturus erat, which God himselfe meant to effect, not what he meant to suffer. That they took predestination in this sense, it appears by Austin. lib. 2. de bono persever. c. 17. his words are these. In sua quae falli mutarique non potest praescientia opera sua futura disponere, illud omnino, nec aliud quicquam est praedestinare. Marke it well, opera sua, his works, now sinne is no work of God, but a work of the creature only.
I come to his second reason.