DISCOURSE. SECT. IV.
pp. 241–25441 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 241–25441 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. First, that many of them which believe and defend this opinion, are Godly and holy men, and therefore it doth not of it self open a way to liberty; but through the wickedness of men, who pervert the sweetest, and the surest truths revealed in Gods word, to their own damnation.
1. First, that many of them which believe and defend this opinion, are Godly and holy men, and therefore it doth not of it selfe open a way to liberty; but through the wickednesse of men, who pervert the sweetest, and the surest truths revealed in Gods word, to their own damnation.
Resp. It cannot (I confess) be denied, that many of this opinion are Godly men, but it is no thanks to their opinion, that they are so; (the true and natural genius of which is to breed sloth, to drown men in carnal security, and to countenance carnal liberty.) but to some thing else, either to Gods providence, (who will not suffer this doctrine for his own glory and the good of men, to have any great stroke in their lives;) or to mens incogitancy, who think not of reducing it ad praxim, or drawing conclusions out of it, but rest in the naked speculation of it, as they do of many others; or lastly to some good practical conclusions, which they meet with in the word of God, and apply to their lives (as they do not the former deductions) such as these are for example; Be ye holy as I an holy. Without holiness no man shall see God. If ye consent and obey, ye shall eat the good things of the land. Godliness hath the promise of this life and of the life to come, and such like. And hence we may learn to measure this opinion, not by some few of the men that hold it, but by the sequels, which the Logic even of simple men, if they should apply their brains to ponder and consider it, would fetch out of it. No man that hath thoroughly sucked it in, and understood the force of it, but will either relinquish it, or live according to the natural importment of it, that is, licentiously.
Resp. It cannot (I confesse) be denyed, that many of this opinion are Godly men, but it is no thankes to their opinion, that they are so; (the true and naturall genius of which is to breed sloth, to drowne men in carnall security, and to countenance carnall liberty.) but to some thing else, either to Gods providence, (who will not suffer this doctrine for his own glory and the good of men, to have any great stroake in their lives;) or to mens incogitancy, who think not of reducing it ad praxim, or drawing conclusions out of it, but rest in the naked speculation of it, as they doe of many others; or lastly to some good practicall conclusions, which they meet with in the word of God, and apply to their lives (as they doe not the former deductions) such as these are for example; Be ye holy as I an holy. Without holinesse no man shall see God. If ye consent and obey, ye shall eat the good things of the land. Godlinesse hath the promise of this life and of the life to come, and such like. And hence we may learne to measure this opinion, not by some few of the men that hold it, but by the sequels, which the Logick even of simple men, if they should apply their braines to ponder and consider it, would fetch out of it. No man that hath thoroughly suckt it in, and understood the force of it, but will either relinquish it, or live according to the naturall importment of it, that is, licentiously.
2. Secondly, it is said, that albeit this Doctrine doth teach, that men are absolutely elected, or absolutely rejected; yet it tells no man who in particular is elected, who rejected, (that must appear by themselves and their lives) and so it doth not stifle holy endeavours in any, but rather encourage them in every man, because it makes them to be signs, whereby men must and may get the knowledge of their election.
2. Secondly, it is said, that albeit this Doctrine doth teach, that men are absolutely elected, or absolutely rejected; yet it tells no man who in particular is elected, who rejected, (that must appeare by themselves and their lives) and so it doth not stifle holy endeavours in any, but rather encourage them in every man, because it makes them to be signes, whereby men must and may get the knowledge of their election.
Resp. For answer to this (in my judgement or the present) the ignorance of a mans particular case doth not alter the case a jot. For he that believes in general, that many and they the greatest company without comparison, are inevitably ordained to destruction, and a few others unto salvation; is able out of these two general propositions, to make these particular conclusions, and to reason thus with himself; Either I am absolutely chosen to grace and glory, or absolutely cast off from both, If I be chosen, I must of necessity believe and be saved; If I be cast off I must as necessarily not believe and be damned, Therefore what need I take thought either way about means or end? My end is pitched in Heaven, and the means too; my final perseverance in faith and my salvation; or my continuance in unbelief and my damnation. If I lye under this necessity of believing, and being saved, or of dying in unbelief, and being damned, in vain do I trouble my self about means or end, I have my supersedeas, I may take mine ease, and so I will, it is enough for me to sit down and wait what God will do unto me.
Resp. For answer to this (in my judgement or the present) the ignorance of a mans particular case doth not alter the case a jot. For he that believes in generall, that many and they the greatest company without comparison, are inevitably ordained to destruction, and a few others unto salvation; is able out of these two generall propositions, to make these particular conclusions, and to reason thus with himselfe; Either I am absolutely chosen to grace and glory, or absolutely cast off from both, If I be chosen, I must of necessity believe and be saved; If I be cast off I must as necessarily not believe and be damned, Therefore what need I take thought either way about meanes or end? My end is pitched in Heaven, and the meanes too; my finall perseverance in faith and my salvation; or my continuance in unbeliefe and my damnation. If I lye under this necessity of believing, and being saved, or of dying in unbeliefe, and being damned, in vaine doe I trouble my selfe about meanes or end, I have my supersedeas, I may take mine ease, and so I will, it is enough for me to sit downe and waite what God will doe unto me.
And in this manner (it is to be feared) do too many reason in their hearts, and by this very ground (though they will not perhaps acknowledge it) encourage themselves to profaneness. Though men cannot hide their wickedness, yet they will hide their grounds which flesh them in it, either through modesty, or to avoid some farther ignominy. The fool hath said in his heart there is no God: Psal. 40. Suetonius de Vita Tiberii c. 69. p. 180. Says of Tiberius that he was circa Deos & religiones negligentior, quippe addictus Mathematicae, persuasionibus plenus omnia fato agi.
And in this manner (it is to be feared) doe too many reason in their hearts, and by this very ground (though they will not perhaps acknowledge it) encourage themselves to prophanenesse. Though men cannot hide their wickednesse, yet they will hide their grounds which flesh them in it, either through modesty, or to avoyde some farther ignominy. The foole hath said in his heart there is no God: Psal. 40. Suetonius de Vita Tiberii c. 69. p. 180. Saies of Tiberius that he was circa Deos & religiones negligentior, quippe addictus Mathematicae, persuasionibus plenus omnia fato agi.
I have already made answer to his objections after my manner; it remains I consider what he delivereth in debilitating those answers which he takes in to consideration.
I have already made answer to his objections after my maner; it remaines I consider what he delivereth in debilitating those answers which he takes in to consideration.
1. This answer was made by our Britain Divines in the Synod of Dort upon the first Article, but so, as that they proposed it not by it self alone, but jointly with showing that neither the Nature of our Doctrine doth any way prove any hinderance unto piety; as formerly I have made mention thereof.
1. This answer was made by our Brittaine Divines in the Synod of Dort upon the first Article, but so, as that they proposed it not by it selfe alone, but joyntly with shewing that neither the Nature of our Doctrine doth any way prove any hinderance unto pietie; as formerly I have made mention therof.
Whereas he saith that many of this (our) opinion are Godly men but that is no thanks to their opinion that they are so. I answer, that neither do we give the glory of our Godliness to our good opinion, nor have cause to thank it therefore; but we give God the Glory both of leading us into this truth amongst many others, and for that Godliness that is in us also. For we acknowledge that God is able to convict our consciences of that trueth hereof, and yet refuse to lead us thereby into any Holiness at all. Yet let every sober man judge who are in a fairer way to true Holiness, or who are more likely to be in the state of true Holiness, they that oppose the grace of God in working our wills to faith and repentance, or they that acknowledge it. They who maintain that God of the mere pleasure of his will, regenerates us, endueth us with the spirit of faith and repentance; or they who maintain that God doth not give faith and repentance to whom he will. Neither is it the meaning of St Paul where he sayeth God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth; but rather where he finds an absolute disposition or work in one, which he finds not in an other. Again consider I pray indifferently, who are more likely to be partakers of Gods grace; they who truly magnify it as the Author of their faith and repentance and of every good work performed by them, and that in a preventing manner; or they that pretend to make Gods grace to be the Author of their faith and repentance and every good work only by giving them power to believe, if they will (which we are able to prove both by the judgment of Austin and by clear reason to be mere nature and not grace) and accordingly exhorting them to believe, and last of all concurring with them to the producing of the act of faith in them in case they will; And seeing grace proves effectual only by this subsequent manner of operation; whether they do not plainly mock God in making him the Author of grace, seeing in respect of this effectual operation they might as well make him the Author of every sinful act as of every gracious act, For it is agreed on all hands that God concurs as well to every sinful act as any gracious act. Whereas he saith, The true and natural genius of our Tenet is to breed sloth, and to drown men in carnal security, and to countenance carnal liberty.
Whereas he sayth that many of this (our) opinion are Godly men but that is no thankes to their opinion that they are so. I answer, that neither doe we give the glory of our Godlinesse to our good opinion, nor have cause to thanke it therefore; but we give God the Glory both of leading us into this truth amongst many others, and for that Godlinesse that is in us also. For we acknowledge that God is able to convict our consciences of that trueth hereof, and yet refuse to lead us thereby into any Holinesse at all. Yet let every sober man judge who are in a fairer way to true Holinesse, or who are more likely to be in the state of true Holinesse, they that oppose the grace of God in working our wills to faith and repentance, or they that acknowledge it. They who maintaine that God of the meere pleasure of his will, regenerates us, endueth us with the spirit of faith and repentance; or they who maintaine that God doth not give faith and repentance to whom he will. Neither is it the meaning of St Paul where he sayeth God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth; but rather where he findes an absolute disposition or worke in one, which he finds not in an other. Againe consider I pray indifferently, who are more likely to be partakers of Gods grace; they who truly magnifie it as the Author of their faith and repentance and of every good worke performed by them, and that in a preventing manner; or they that pretend to make Gods grace to be the Author of their faith and repentance and every good worke only by giving them power to believe, if they will (which we are able to prove both by the judgment of Austin and by cleare reason to be meere nature and not grace) and accordingly exhorting them to believe, and last of all concurring with them to the producing of the act of faith in them in case they will; And seeing grace proves effectuall only by this subsequent manner of operation; whether they doe not plainely mocke God in making him the Author of grace, seing in respect of this effectuall operation they might as well make him the Author of every sinfull act as of every gratious act, For it is agreed on all hands that God concurres as well to every sinfull act as any gratious act. Whereas he sayth, The true and naturall genius of our Tenet is to breed sloth, and to drowne men in carnall security, and to countenance carnall libertie.
I answer these words of his are but wind, his reasons I have already considered, and proved them to be of no weight. For they depend partly upon a vain supposition, as if we maintained that God hath appointed men unto Salvation though they live as they list, whereas our doctrine is directly contradictious here unto. For we teach that God ordains no man of ripe years to obtain Salvation but by Sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth as we are plainly taught 2 Thess. 2. 13. And the Evangelist signifies as much, where he sayeth. As many believed as were ordained to Everlasting Life. Act. 13. 48. It may be as well said that as many repented, as many gave themselves to work out their Salvation with fear and trembling to purge themselves from all pollutions of flesh and spirit, and to perfect Holiness in the fear of God, as were ordained to Salvation: partly because we maintain that God gives faith and repentance and regeneration to whom he will, that is only to those whom he hath chosen, denying the same grace and that absolutely; unto all others, which if it be not true; but that God doth grant it, or ordain it according to mens works, then we must all turn Pelagians, whom Austin calls inimicos gratiae Dei; And in such a case judge I pray whether it be possible that such can be partakers of Gods grace, namely, if they are the enemies of Gods grace. Is ⟨p. 243⟩it possible that he who partakes of Gods sanctifying grace should stand out in hostile opposition against it? Can we be at once both friends of the Bridegroom and enemies of his grace? Further consider more particularly wherein doth this consist, which he imputes unto us, of drowning men in carnal security, is it in denying unto man any grace that he attributes unto him? Surely well we may deny unto every Reprobate such a grace as he himself hates, and impugns to wit, grace effectually preventing the will, and making man to believe and repent, but if you scan every particular of those which he calleth grace, you shall find that we deny not any one of them unto Reprobates more then he doth. This perhaps may seem strange unto you; therefore it deserves the more carefully to be considered; for I doubt not but to make it good.
I answer these words of his are but wind, his reasons I have already considered, and proved them to be of no weight. For they depend partly upon a vaine supposition, as if we maintained that God hath oppointed men unto Salvation though they live as they list, whereas our doctrine is directly contradictious here unto. For we teach that God ordaines no man of ripe yeares to obtaine Salvation but by Sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth as we are plainly taught 2 Thess. 2. 13. And the Evangelist signifies as much, where he saieth. As many believed as were ordained to Everlasting Life. Act. 13. 48. It may be as well said that as many repented, as many gave themselves to worke out their Salvation with feare and trembling to purge themselues from all pollutions of flesh and spirit, and to perfect Holinesse in the feare of God, as were ordained to Salvation: partly because we maintaine that God gives faith and repentance and regeneration to whom he will, that is only to those whom he hath chosen, denying the same grace and that absolutely; unto all others, which if it be not true; but that God doth grant it, or ordaine it according to mens workes, then we must all turne Pelagians, whom Austin calls inimicos gratiae Dei; And in such a case judge I pray whether it be possible that such can be partakers of Gods grace, namely, if they are the enemies of Gods grace. Is ⟨p. 243⟩it possible that he who partakes of Gods sanctifying grace should stand out in hostile opposition against it? Can we be at once both friends of the Bridegroom and enimies of his grace? Further consider more particularly wherein doth this consist, which he imputes unto us, of drowning men in carnall securitie, is it in denying unto man any grace that he attributes unto him? Surely well we may deny unto every Reprobate such a grace as he himselfe hates, and impugnes to wit, grace effectually preventing the will, and making man to believe and repent, but if you scanne every particular of those which he calleth grace, you shall find that we deny not any one of them unto Reprobates more then he doth. This perhaps may seeme strange unto you; therefore it deserves the more carefully to be considered; for I doubt not but to make it good.
Grace subsequent is the only effectual grace with them, and that consists in Gods concurrence to the working of faith in the heart of man, if man will work it in him self. Now dare they say we deny, this namely, Gods concourse to the act of faith, whereas we maintain with them that God concurs to every act, even to the most sinful act, that ever was committed since the world began; only we are a shamed to call this concurrence grace, because it is found to have course as well in the producing of evil actions, as in the producing of good. So that if every man in the world should believe, we deny not but that God should concur with him to the working of that belief, we profess that if every Reprobate in the world will believe, God is ready to concur with him to the act of that will of that belief. From the consideration of their grace subsequent I arise to the consideration of their grace prevenient, and that is two fold, one is the grace exciting, to wit, by moral admonition, suasion, exhortation, This act we are willing to call and account a gracious act, & we do as willingly acknowledge that God affords it unto all Reprobates (as well as to the elect) within the pale of the Church. For every one that appears in any Congregation is equally exhorted to believe, to repent, to turn from their wicked ways. So that hitherto we find no difference. We willingly acknowledge that Reprobates are partakers of these operations divine as well as the elect. One grace prevenient remains, which is habitual, and which our adversaries will have to be universal and it consists in a power to believe and repent, and to will any spiritual good whereunto they were excited, and accordingly they call it the enlivening of mans will. This I deliver by experience of what I have seen under the hands of some of them. Yet they will not acknowledge that all are regenerate; yet what is regeneration, but the infusion of life spiritual, and that chiefly into the will; And they will have the will to be enlivened by grace, which cannot be spoken in respect of life natural, therefore it must proceed of life spiritual, unless they will devise a life intermediate between life natural, and life spiritual. Some times they call it a power to believe if they will, and such a power Austin acknowledgeth common to all, lib. 1. Gen. ad litre: cap 3.
Grace subsequent is the only effectuall grace with them, and that consists in Gods concurrence to the working of faith in the heart of man, if man will worke it in him selfe. Now dare they say we deny, this namely, Gods concourse to the act of faith, whereas we maintaine with them that God concurres to every act, even to the most sinfull act, that ever was committed since the world began; only we are a shamed to call this concurrence grace, because it is found to have course as well in the producing of evill actions, as in the producing of good. So that if every man in the world should believe, we deny not but that God should concurre with him to the working of that belief, we professe that if every Reprobate in the world will believe, God is ready to concurre with him to the act of that will of that belief. From the consideration of their grace subsequent I arise to the consideration of their grace prevenient, and that is two fold, one is the grace exciting, to wit, by morall admonition, suasion, exhortation, This act we are willing to call and account a gratious act, & we doe as willingly acknowledge that God affords it unto all Reprobates (as well as to the elect) within the pale of the Church. For every one that appeares in any Congregation is equally exhorted to believe, to repent, to turne from their wicked wayes. So that hitherto we find no difference. We willingly acknowledge that Reprobates are partakers of these operations divine as well as the elect. One grace prevenient remaines, which is habituall, and which our adversaries will have to be universall and it consistes in a power to believe and repent, and to will any spirituall good whereunto they were excited, and accordingly they call it the enlivening of mans will. This I deliver by experience of what I have seen under the hands of some of them. Yet they will not acknowledge that all are regenerate; yet what is regeneration, but the infusion of life spirituall, and that chiefly into the will; And they will have the will to be enlivened by grace, which cannot be spoken in respect of life naturall, therefore it must proceed of life spirituall, unlesse they will devise a life intermediate between life naturall, and life spirituall. Some times they call it a power to believe if they will, and such a power Austin acknowledgeth common to all, lib. 1. Gen. ad liter: cap 3.
And justifies it in his Retract. lib. 16. Now this seems somewhat strange, considering the very regenerate have not such strength of goodness, as whereby they are enabled to do what good they would, as Rom. 7. 18. To will is present with me but I find, not to perform that which is good. And Gal: 5. 17. The flesh lusteth against the spirit, and the spirit against the flesh, and these are contrary one to the other, so that ye cannot do the same things that ye would. To help this and to clear Austin from contradiction to express Scripture in this; I find that posse si velit is one thing, posse simply delivered is another thing. And this I find distinguished in that very place of Austin's Retractations; For whereas as he had said in that lib. 1. de Gen. contr. Man. cap 3. That, Omnes homines possunt si velint, both credere, and ab amore visibilium rerum & temporalium se ad Dei praecerta implenda converter. And coming to retract this, and perceiving what advantage the Pelagians might s•atch hence for the countenancing of their cause, in extolling the power of nature, he wisely prevents that by expounding himself, and clearing his own meaning thus. Non existiment novi haeretici Pelagiani secundum eos esse dictum; manifesting thereby that this was the Pelagian Tenet yet were they not to be blamed for this, but only because they called not in Gods grace for further help then this, save only in the way of instruction. For Austin concurred with them still in this particular even then when he wrote his books of Retractations, as there it follows in these words Verum est enim omnino (mark by this Emphasis with what assurance of faith he delivered this) Omnes homines hoc posse si velint: Thus far he goes along with them: but then mark wherein he goes beyond them in these words following; Sed praeparatur voluntas a Domino & tantum augetur munere charitatis ut possint; When he sayeth, praeparatur voluntas a Domino, ⟨p. 244⟩the effect thereof undoubtedly is ut velint which is the state and condition of the regenerate, who yet may complain that they cannot do that which they would as the Apostle formerly signifies, that is that simply and effectually they have not yet power enough to what they will; therefore Austin adds to the preparation of the will, ut velint, an augmentation of strength ut possint, saying tantumque augetur munere charitatis ut possint;
And justifies it in his Retract. lib. 16. Now this seemes somewhat strange, considering the very regenerate have not such strength of goodnesse, as whereby they are inabled to doe what good they would, as Rom. 7. 18. To will is present with me but I find, not to performe that which is good. And Gal: 5. 17. The flesh lusteth against the spirit, and the spirit against the flesh, and these are contrary one to the other, so that ye cannot doe the same things that ye would. To helpe this and to cleare Austin from contradiction to expresse Scripture in this; I find that posse si velit is one thing, posse simply delivered is another thing. And this I find distinguished in that very place of Austines Retractations; For whereas as he had sayd in that lib. 1. de Gen. contr. Man. cap 3. That, Omnes homines possunt si velint, both credere, and ab amore visibilium rerum & temporalium se ad Dei praecerta implenda convertere. And comming to retract this, and perceiving what advantage the Pelagians might s•atch hence for the countenancing of their cause, in extolling the power of nature, he wisely prevents that by expounding himselfe, and clearing his owne meaning thus. Non existiment novi haeretici Pelagiani secundum eos esse dictum; manifesting thereby that this was the Pelagian Tenet yet were they not to be blamed for this, but only because they called not in Gods grace for further helpe then this, save only in the way of instruction. For Austin concurred with them still in this particular even then when he wrote his books of Retractations, as there it followes in these words Verum est enim omnino (marke by this Emphasis with what assurance of faith he delivered this) Omnes homines hoc posse si velint: Thus farre he goes along with them: but then marke wherin he goes beyond them in these words following; Sed praeparatur voluntas a Domino & tantum augetur munere charitatis ut possint; When he sayeth, praeparatur voluntas a Domino, ⟨p. 244⟩the effect thereof undoubtedly is ut velint which is the state and condition of the regenerate, who yet may complaine that they cannot doe that which they would as the Apostle formerly signifies, that is that simply and effectually they have not yet power enough to what they will; therefore Austin addes to the preparation of the will, ut velint, an augmentation of strength ut possint, saying tantumque augetur munere charitatis ut possint;
that is; not only to will that which is good, but so intensely to will it, as to prevail over the flesh lusting against the spirit, whereby it comes, ut non modo velint, sed & possint; and consequently & efficiant quod velint. So that posse simpliciter doth include veil; and adds such strength thereto as now to go on to the doing of that it wills without restraint from the flesh. And that this posse is but an augmentation of the gracious disposition of the will, appears by the same Austin de corrept. & gratia. cap. 11. Prima gratia est qua sit ut habeat homo justitiam si velit, secunda ergo plus potest, qua etiam sit ut velit, & tantum velit tantoque ardore diligat, ut carnis voluntatem contraria concupiscentem voluntate spiritus vincat. The first grace is that whereby a man may have righteousness if he will, therefore the second grace is of more power, as whereby a man is made to will and that in such measure, as by the will of the spirit to overcome the will of the flesh affecting that which is contrary thereunto. And in the very next chapter, c. 12. He calls this prevailing will, Posse simply, Tantum spiritu sancto accenditur voluntas eorum, ut ideo possint, quia sic velint, & ideo velint, quia Deus sic operatur ut velint; Their will is in such measure inflamed with the Holy Spirit, that therefore they are able (to do that which is good) because they will in such a measure, & therefore they will in such a measure because God so works as to make them willing in such measure: Austin goes on in this manner Nam si in tanta infirmitate vitae hujus ipsis relinqueretur voiuntas sua, ut in adjutorio Dei manerent si vellent, nec Deus in iis operaretur ut vellent inter tot & tantas tentations infirmitate sua voluntas ipsa succumberet, & ideo perseverare non possent, quia deficientes infirmitate nec vellent, aut non ita vellent infirmitate voluntatis ut possent. For if in so great infirmity of this life, their will were left unto them, that in the help of God they might continue if they would, & God should not work in them that they would, amongst so many and so great tentations, this will it self would sink (under the burden of them) and therefore could not persevere, because failing through infirmity they would not, or (at least) they would not in such a measure, through the wills infirmity, as to be able to stand.
that is; not only to will that which is good, but so intensely to will it, as to prevaile over the flesh lusting against the spirit, whereby it comes, ut non modo velint, sed & possint; and consequently & efficiant quod velint. So that posse simpliciter doth include velle; and addes such strength thereto as now to goe on to the doing of that it wills without restraint from the flesh. And that this posse is but an augmentation of the gratious disposition of the will, appeares by the same Austin de corrept. & gratia. cap. 11. Prima gratia est qua sit ut habeat homo justitiam si velit, secunda ergo plus potest, qua etiam sit ut velit, & tantum velit tantoque ardore diligat, ut carnis voluntatem contraria concupiscentem voluntate spiritus vincat. The first grace is that whereby a man may have righteousnesse if he will, therfore the second grace is of more power, as whereby a man is made to will and that in such measure, as by the will of the spirit to overcome the will of the flesh affecting that which is contrary thereunto. And in the very next chapter, c. 12. He calles this prevailing will, Posse simply, Tantum spiritu sancto accenditur voluntas eorum, ut ideo possint, quia sic velint, & ideo velint, quia Deus sic operatur ut velint; Their will is in such measure inflamed with the Holy Spirit, that therefore they are able (to doe that which is good) because they will in such a measure, & therefore they will in such a measure because God so works as to make them willing in such measure: Austin goes on in this manner Nam si in tanta infirmitate vitae hujus ipsis relinqueretur voiuntas sua, ut in adjutorio Dei manerent si vellent, nec Deus in iis operaretur ut vellent inter tot & tantas tentationes infirmitate sua voluntas ipsa succumberet, & ideo perseverare non possent, quia deficientes infirmitate nec vellent, aut non ita vellent infirmitate voluntatis ut possent. For if in so great infirmitie of this life, their will were left unto thē, that in the helpe of God they might continue if they would, & God should not work in them that they would, amongst so many and so great tentations, this will it selfe would sinke (under the burthen of them) and therefore could not persevere, because failing through infirmity they would not, or (at least) they would not in such a measure, through the wills infirmity, as to be able to stand.
So that posse simpliciter still with Austin includes the will, and is a denomination of the will, arising from the strength of it prevailing above the flesh, lusting to the contrary. In like sort Honorius Augustodunensis de praedest. & lib. arbit: diverse times ascribes posse to grace subsequent, like as he ascribes veil to grace prevenient, as when he sayth; Deus operatur in electis suis sua gratia praeveniendo velle, & subseqendo posse. And again, gratiam accipimus, cum nos Deus praevenit, ut velimus, & subsequitus ut possimus. And againe Gratia Dei praevenit ut bonum quod sprevit cupiat, & sequitur ut illud implere praevaleat. So that in effect this posse comes to be all one with agere or perficere quod volumus. For when we not only will that which is good, but so affectionately will it, as to prevail over the flesh lusting against it, all inward impediments being thus mastered, the perfecting of that we will must needs follow. But as for that posse si velint, this goes before the willing of it And I see no reason to the contrary but that we may with Austin acknowledge such a power common to all; which in the disputations between Austin and Pelagius was called possibilitas agendi quod bonum est; and Austin was so far from excepting against it as maintained by Pelagius, that more then once; he professeth, that in case like as he acknowledged posse to be from God, so he would acknowledge veil and agere to be from God he should be received for a good Catholic in this, by Austins judgment. I will cite a passage or two out of Austin expressly signifying this, & that out of his book de gratia Christi, contra Pelag: & Caelest: The first is cap 6. Pelagius his words are these. Qui ipsius voluntatis & operis possibilitatem dedit whereupon Austin writeth thus Hanc autem possibilitatem in natura eum ponere, de verbis ejus superioribus clarum est. Sed ne nihil de grati a dixisse videretur, adjunxit, Quique ipsam possibilitatem gratiae suae adjuvat semper auxilio; non ait, ipsam voluntatem vel ipsam operationem, quod si diceret, non abhorrere a doctrina Apostolica videretur: as much as to say, did he acknowledge this he should be a good Catholique; Now ad juvare voluntatem & operationem, in Austins phrase is effectually, operari ut velit & operetur homo quod bonum est; as appeares by that which followeth.
So that posse simpliciter still with Austin includes the will, and is a denomination of the will, arising from the strength of it prevailing above the flesh, lusting to the contrary. In like sort Honorius Augustodunensis de praedest. & lib. arbit: diverse times ascribes posse to grace subsequent, like as he ascribes velle to grace prevenient, as when he sayth; Deus operatur in electis suis sua gratia praeveniendo velle, & subseqendo posse. And againe, gratiam accipimus, cum nos Deus praevenit, ut velimus, & subsequitus ut possimus. And againe Gratia Dei praevenit ut bonum quod sprevit cupiat, & sequitur ut illud implere praevaleat. So that in effect this posse comes to be all one with agere or perficere quod volumus. For when we not only will that which is good, but so affectionately will it, as to prevaile over the flesh lusting against it, all inward impediments being thus mastered, the perfecting of that we will must needes follow. But as for that posse si velint, this goes before the willing of it And I see no reason to the contrary but that we may with Austin acknowledge such a power common to all; which in the disputations between Austin and Pelagius was called possibilitas agendi quod bonum est; and Austin was so farre from excepting against it as maintained by Pelagius, that more then once; he professeth, that in case like as he acknowledged posse to be from God, so he would acknowledge velle and agere to be from God he should be received for a good Catholique in this, by Austins judgment. I will cite a passage or two out of Austin expresly signifying this, & that out of his booke de gratia Christi, contra Pelag: & Caelest: The first is cap 6. Pelagius his words are these. Qui ipsius voluntatis & operis possibilitatem dedit whereupon Austin writeth thus Hanc autem possibilitatem in natura eum ponere, de verbis ejus superioribus clarum est. Sed ne nihil de grati a dixisse videretur, adjunxit, Quique ipsam possibilitatem gratiae suae adjuvat semper auxilio; non ait, ipsam voluntatem vel ipsam operationem, quod si diceret, non abhorrere a doctrina Apostolica videretur: as much as to say, did he acknowledge this he should be a good Catholique; Now ad juvare voluntatem & operationem, in Austins phrase is effectually, operari ut velit & operetur homo quod bonum est; as appeares by that which followeth.
Sed ait (to wit Pelagius) ipsam possibilitatem illud videlicet ex tribus quod in natura locavit gratiae suae adjuvat semper auxilio. Now mark Austins interpretation of him thus, ut scilicet in voluntate & actione non ideo laus sit Dei & hominis quia sic vult homo, ut tamen ejus voluntati ⟨p. 245⟩Deus ardorem dilectionis inspiret; so that adjuvare voluntatem in Austins phrase, is inspirare voluntati dilectationis ardorem. So then I see no reason, but that we may well grant unto our adversaries, that all men have a power to believe if they will, and from the love of temporal things, to convert themselves to the keeping of Gods commandments; But this is mere nature in Austins judgement; for he calls it in that very chapter, naturalem possibilitatem, and cap. 47. coming to an issue: Si ergo consenserit nobis, non solam possibilitatem, sed ipsam quoque voluntatem & actionem divinitus adjuvari, & sic adjuvari, ut sine ullo adjutorio nihil bene velimus & agamus, eamque esse gratiam Dei per Jesum Christum, nihil de adjutorio gratiae Dei, quantum arbitror, inter nos controversiae relinquetur. And indeed to say that a man hath power to believe and repent if he will; this is not to maintain any universal grace otherwise; then as nature may be called grace. For grace is goodness, but goodness doth not consist in a power to do good if we will; but it is an habitual disposing of the will to that which is good only, how much more is it so of grace which we count supernatural goodness. Neither is the maintenance of such a power to do good, any contradiction to holy Scripture, testifying that Men cannot believe, cannot repent, cannot please God, cannot be subject to the law of God, cannot do good; For, this impotency is only moral, and the subject of this impotency is only the will and it consists in the corruption thereof, being wholly turned away from God, and converted to the creature in an inordinate manner; Enemies and strangers from God, their minds being set on evil things. Col. 1. 21. And to say that a man can believe if he will, can from the love of visible and temporal things, convert himself to the observation of Gods precepts if he will, which Austin in his latter days, even then when he wrote his Retractations, professeth to be true omninò. And in his Book ad Marcellinum De Spiritu & litera. cap. 31.
Sed ait (to wit Pelagius) ipsam possibilitatem illud videlicet ex tribus quod in natura locavit gratiae suae adjuvat semper auxilio. Now marke Austins interpretation of him thus, ut scilicet in voluntate & actione non ideo laus sit Dei & hominis quia sic vult homo, ut tamen ejus voluntati ⟨p. 245⟩Deus ardorem dilectionis inspiret; so that adjuvare voluntatem in Austins phrase, is inspirare voluntati dilectationis ardorem. So then I see no reason, but that wee may well grant unto our adversaries, that all men have a power to believe if they will, and from the love of temporall things, to convert themselves to the keeping of Gods commandements; But this is meere nature in Austins judgement; for he calls it in that very chapter, naturalem possibilitatem, and cap. 47. coming to an issue: Si ergo consenserit nobis, non solam possibilitatem, sed ipsam quoque voluntatem & actionem divinitus adjuvari, & sic adjuvari, ut sine ullo adjutorio nihil bene velimus & agamus, eamque esse gratiam Dei per Jesum Christum, nihil de adjutorio gratiae Dei, quantum arbitror, inter nos controversiae relinquetur. And indeed to say that a man hath power to believe and repent if he will; this is not to maintaine any universall grace otherwise; then as nature may be called grace. For grace is goodnesse, but goodnesse doth not consist in a power to do good if we will; but it is an habituall disposing of the will to that which is good only, how much more is it so of grace which we count supernaturall goodnesse. Neither is the maintenance of such a power to doe good, any contradiction to holy Scripture, testifying that Men cannot believe, cannot repent, cannot please God, cannot be subject to the law of God, cannot doe good; For, this impotency is only morall, and the subject of this impotency is only the will and it consists in the corruption thereof, being wholly turned away from God, and converted to the creature in an inordinate manner; Enemies and strangers from God, their minds being set on evill things. Col. 1. 21. And to say that a man can believe if he will, can from the love of visible and temporall things, convert himselfe to the observation of Gods precepts if he will, which Austin in his latter daies, even then when he wrote his Retractations, professeth to be true omninò. And in his Book ad Marcellinum De Spiritu & litera. cap. 31.
Professeth it an absurd thing to deny this namely, that every one may believe if he will. Vide nunc utrum quisque credat si noluerit aut non credat si voluerit. Quod si absurdum est &c. And cap. 32. Cum ergo fides in potestate sit, quoniam cum vult quisque credit, & cum credit volens credit. I say to affirm this (namely that a man can believe if he will) is no more then to say, that a dead man can speak if he were alive. For as the Scripture teacheth, that all men are dead in sin, 'till the spirit of regeneration comes to breath into our hearts, the breath of a spiritual life; So this deadness is to be found no where so much, as in the will. And therefore Aquinas professeth, that a man is more corrupt, quoad appetitum boni, then quoad intellectum very. The Heathen could profess, Video meliora proboque deteriora sequor. And in my experience I find that Arminians do not satisfy themselves with this universality of grace, as to say, A man can do good if he will, unless they add, that also potest velle; as I have observed in Corvinus. And those whom I have in private been acquainted with do not rest in this, that All men can believe if they will, but they say also, that by universal grace, the will is enlivened, as I have seen under their hands, and thereby enabled to the willing of any spiritual good, whereto they shall be excited. So that if they rested here, to wit, in saying, that by universal grace all men may believe if they will, there is no grace acknowledged by them, tending to the furtherance of the good of mankind, but we acknowledge it as well as they, and make the extension of it as large as they. And therefore the more vain and void of all reason is their pretence, that we for want of acknowledging such an universality of grace as they do, do drown men in carnal security, and countenance carnal liberty. Only though we grant the reality of that which they maintain, yet we deny that it deserves to be called grace, as touching the first prevenient grace as they call it, which we with Austin say deserves to be called nature rather then grace, as we speak of grace, to wit, as distinct from nature, and indeed supernatural. And as for grace subsequent, that consisting only in concourse, we deny that to be grace;
Professeth it an absurd thing to deny this namely, that every one may believe if he will. Vide nunc utrum quisque credat si noluerit aut non credat si voluerit. Quod si absurdum est &c. And cap. 32. Cum ergo fides in potestate sit, quoniam cum vult quisque credit, & cum credit volens credit. I say to affirme this (namely that a man can believe if he will) is no more then to say, that a dead man can speake if he were alive. For as the Scripture teacheth, that all men are dead in sinne, 'till the spirit of regeneration comes to breath into our hearts, the breath of a spirituall life; So this deadnesse is to be found no where so much, as in the will. And therefore Aquinas professeth, that a man is more corrupt, quoad appetitum boni, then quoad intellectum veri. The Heathen could professe, Video meliora proboque deteriora sequor. And in my experience I find that Arminians doe not satisfie themselves with this universality of grace, as to say, A man can doe good if he will, unlesse they adde, that also potest velle; as I have observed in Corvinus. And those whom I have in private been acquainted with doe not rest in this, that All men can believe if they will, but they say also, that by universall grace, the will is enlivened, as I have seen under their hands, and thereby enabled to the willing of any spirituall good, whereto they shall be excited. So that if they rested here, to wit, in saying, that by universall grace all men may believe if they will, there is no grace acknowledged by them, tending to the furtherance of the good of mankind, but we acknowledge it as well as they, and make the extension of it as large as they. And therefore the more vaine and voyd of all reason is their pretence, that we for want of acknowledging such an universality of grace as they doe, doe drowne men in carnall security, and countenance carnall liberty. Only though we grant the reality of that which they maintaine, yet we deny that it deserves to be called grace, as touching the first prevenient grace as they call it, which we with Austin say deserves to be called nature rather then grace, as we speake of grace, to wit, as distinct from nature, and indeed supernaturall. And as for grace subsequent, that consisting only in concourse, we deny that to be grace;
for as much as Gods concourse is granted as well to any sinful act, as to any gracious act, as now adays is commonly acknowledged on all sides. But as for the enlivening of all mens wills, and enabling them to will any spiritual good whereto they shall be excited (for this is their very form of words) we utterly deny this, and are ready to demonstrate the unreasonableness thereof. For first seeing this cannot be understood of life natural but of life spiritual, it followeth that all men by this doctrine are regenerated; and as they confess this disposition continues in all unto death, so it followeth, that all and every one should dye in the state of regeneration also: Secondly, seeing there are but three sorts of qualities in the soul of a reasonable creature, as Aristotle hath observed, to wit, powers, passions, and habits; it followeth that this enlivening of the will must consist, ⟨p. 246⟩either in giving it new powers, or new passions, or new habits, which it had not before. But neither of these can be affirmed with any sobriety, neither do I find that they look to be called to any such account, but in their aerial contemplations of Gods attributes, especially of his mercy and justice, shaped at pleasure, do conceive hand over head, that such an enlivening there must be of the will of man in all, without troubling themselves to enquire wherein it consists. But let us proceed in our trial of the soundness of it, by the touch-stone of rational and Christian discourse. First therefore, I say it can be no new power infused into the will by this enlivening; For the will it self is a power; and it was never heard that potentia can be subjectum potentiae, a power can be the subject of a power; and that a power should be in a power, as an accident in the subject thereof. Rational powers are but two, the power of understanding, and the power of willing, and both these are naturall, following ex principiis speciei, from the very nature of the humane soul, as all confess. But some may say, are there not supernatural powers bestowed on man as well as natural? I answer, these supernatural powers, are but the elevating of the natural powers unto supernatural objects; as the understanding by enlightening it, and the will by sanctifying it.
for as much as Gods concourse is granted as well to any sinfull act, as to any gracious act, as now adaies is commonly acknowledged on all sides. But as for the enlivening of all mens wills, and enabling them to will any spirituall good whereto they shall be excited (for this is their very forme of words) we utterly deny this, and are ready to demonstrate the unreasonablenesse thereof. For first seeing this cannot be understood of life naturall but of life spirituall, it followeth that all men by this doctrine are regenerated; and as they confesse this disposition continues in all unto death, so it followeth, that all and every one should dye in the state of regeneration also: Secondly, seeing there are but three sorts of qualities in the soule of a reasonable creature, as Aristotle hath observed, to wit, powers, passions, and habits; it followeth that this enlivening of the will must consist, ⟨p. 246⟩either in giving it new powers, or new passions, or new habits, which it had not before. But neither of these can be affirmed with any sobriety, neither doe I find that they look to be called to any such account, but in their aëriall contemplations of Gods attributes, especially of his mercy and justice, shaped at pleasure, doe conceive hand over head, that such an enlivening there must be of the will of man in all, without troubling themselves to enquire wherein it consists. But let us proceed in our triall of the soundnesse of it, by the touch-stone of rationall and Christian discourse. First therefore, I say it can be no new power infused into the will by this enlivening; For the will it selfe is a power; and it was never heard that potentia can be subjectum potentiae, a power can be the subject of a power; and that a power should be in a power, as an accident in the subject thereof. Rationall powers are but two, the power of understanding, and the power of willing, and both these are naturall, following ex principiis speciei, from the very nature of the humane soule, as all confesse. But some may say, are there not supernaturall powers bestowed on man as well as naturall? I answer, these supernaturall powers, are but the elevating of the naturall powers unto supernaturall objects; as the understanding by enlightning it, and the will by sanctifying it.
Never was it said, I presume, that a man regenerate had two understandings in him, by the one to understand things natural, and by the other to understand things spiritual; but that by the same understanding he understands both, but by light of nature the one, by light of grace the other. The holy Ghost saith, That they who are accustomed to do evil, can no more do good, then a Blackemore can change his skin, and a Leopard his spots: Yet when men of evil become good, they get not new powers properly, but new dispositions rather of their natural powers, which we call habits, and may be called moral powers, but not of indifferency to do good or evil, such as the natural power of the will is, but such as whereby is wrought in the will, a good liking of that which is good, an abhorring of that which is evil; so that indeed these moral powers do not make the will able to will, but rather actually willing of that which is good in general, which general willingness is specified according to objects present, and opportunities offered of doing good in one kind rather then another. Like as justice makes a man willing unto just actions, which willingness is exercised this way or that way, according to emergent occasions. Secondly, no new passions are given by this enlivening of the will; well our passions may be ordered aright, both touching their objects, and touching the season, and touching the measure, & touching the rule of them; and in respect of this gracious ordering of them, they may be called new; like as a man regenerate is called a new man, though as he hath the same members of his body, nor more nor less, so he hath still the same faculties and passions of the soul, no more nor no less; but these faculties are better seasoned, these passions are better ordered, and in like sort, these members of the body, are better employed then they were before; before they were made weapons of unrighteousness unto sin, now they are made, weapons of righteousness unto God. Rom. 6. 13. Thirdly, let us enquire whether by this pretended enlivening of the will common to all men, there are any new habits engendered. For that is the most probable.
Never was it said, I presume, that a man regenerate had two understandings in him, by the one to understand things naturall, and by the other to understand things spirituall; but that by the same understanding he understands both, but by light of nature the one, by light of grace the other. The holy Ghost saith, That they who are accustomed to doe evill, can no more doe good, then a Blackemore can change his skinne, and a Leopard his spots: Yet when men of evill become good, they get not new powers properly, but new dispositions rather of their naturall powers, which we call habits, and may be called morall powers, but not of indifferency to doe good or evill, such as the naturall power of the will is, but such as whereby is wrought in the will, a good likeing of that which is good, an abhorring of that which is evill; so that indeed these morall powers doe not make the will able to will, but rather actually willing of that which is good in generall, which generall willingnesse is specified according to objects present, and opportunities offered of doing good in one kind rather then another. Like as justice makes a man willing unto just actions, which willingnesse is exercised this way or that way, according to emergent occasions. Secondly, no new passions are given by this enlivening of the will; well our passions may be ordered aright, both touching their objects, and touching the season, and touching the measure, & touching the rule of them; and in respect of this gracious ordering of them, they may be called new; like as a man regenerate is called a new man, though as he hath the same members of his body, nor more nor lesse, so he hath still the same faculties and passions of the soule, no more nor no lesse; but these faculties are better seasoned, these passions are better ordered, and in like sort, these members of the body, are better employed then they were before; before they were made weapons of unrighteousnesse unto sinne, now they are made, weapons of righteousnesse unto God. Rom. 6. 13. Thirdly, let us enquire whether by this pretended enlivening of the will common to all men, there are any new habits engendred. For that is the most probable.
And so we commonly say that in regeneration, besides the receiving of the spirit of God to dwell in our hearts, which is a great mystery, there are certain habits whereby our natural powers are elevated unto supernatural objects, and thereby fitted to perform supernatural acts; and these are but three, (and accordingly but three sorts of supernatural acts) and commonly accounted the three Theological virtues, Faith, Hope, and Charity; And all moral virtues, which for the substance of them, in reference to their acts whereby they are acquired, and which they do bring forth, are found in natural men, do become Christian graces, as they are sanctified by these three, and as their actions do proceed from these. By faith we apprehend things beyond the compass of reason, by hope we wait for the enjoying of such things, which neither eye hath seen, &c. And by charity, we love God (whom yet we have not seen) even to the contempt of our selves. Now I presume they will not say that these habits of Faith, Hope, and Charity, are bestowed upon all and every one, by that feigned universal grace of theirs. And what other habits they do or can devise, I have had as yet no experience, neither am I able to comprehend. And indeed faith doth not leave a man in indifferency to believe or no; nor hope to wait, or no; nor charity to love God, or no: but they do all dispose the heart of man to believe only, to wait upon God only, to love God only; they ⟨p. 248⟩being the curing of infidelity, and despair, & hatred of God, or rather the removing of them, yet but in part, as regeneration in this life is but in part, there being still a flesh in us lusting against the spirit. Gal. 5. 17.
And so we commonly say that in regeneration, besides the receiving of the spirit of God to dwell in our hearts, which is a great mistery, there are certaine habits whereby our naturall powers are elevated unto supernaturall objects, and thereby fitted to performe supernaturall acts; and these are but three, (and accordingly but three sorts of supernatuall acts) and commonly accounted the three Theologicall vertues, Faith, Hope, and Charity; And all morall vertues, which for the substance of them, in reference to their acts whereby they are acquired, and which they doe bring forth, are found in naturall men, doe become Christian graces, as they are sanctified by these three, and as their actions doe proceed from these. By faith we apprehend things beyond the compasse of reason, by hope we wait for the enjoying of such things, which neither eye hath seen, &c. And by charity, we love God (whom yet we have not seene) even to the contempt of our selves. Now I presume they will not say that these habits of Faith, Hope, and Charity, are bestowed upon all and every one, by that fained universall grace of theirs. And what other habits they doe or can devise, I have had as yet no experience, neither am I able to comprehend. And indeed faith doth not leave a man in indifferency to believe or no; nor hope to wait, or no; nor charity to love God, or no: but they doe all dispose the heart of man to believe only, to wait upon God only, to love God only; they ⟨p. 248⟩being the curing of infidelity, and despaire, & hatred of God, or rather the removing of them, yet but in part, as regeneration in this life is but in part, there being still a flesh in us lusting against the spirit. Gal. 5. 17.
Thus we may maintain, that albeit every man hath power to believe if he will, and repent if he will, a will to believe and a will to repent being the greatest work in the work of grace, I mean the renovation of the will, and making it willing to that which is good, though it requires strength also to master the lusting of the flesh, whereby it grows simply and absolutely potent to do every good thing, without any effectual impediment from within, yet nevertheless, till this renovation be wrought by the hand of God, we may well say there is an utter impotency moral to do any thing that is good and pleasing in the sight of God, whereby they cannot believe, they cannot repent, they cannot be subject to the law of God, And if to Preach this doctrine be to breed sloth, to drown men in carnal security, and to countenance carnal liberty; then our Saviour did breed sloth &c. when he told his hearers plainly, He that is of God heareth Gods words, ye therefore hear them not, because ye are not of God, Joh. 8. 47. As likewise when he Preached unto them in this manner. No man can come to me, except the Father which sent me draw him. Joh. 6. 44. And the Evangelist also in saying, He hath blinded their eyes, and hardened their hearts, that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their hearts, and should be converted, and I should heal them. Joh. 12. 40. And none more then Moses, when he tells the people of Israel in the Wilderness, saying, Ye have seen all that the Lord did before your eyes in the land of Egypt, unto Pharaoh and unto all his servants, and to all his land. The great temptations which thine eyes have seen, those great miracles and wonders, yet the Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive, and eyes to see, and ears to hear unto this day. Yet this Author confesseth that our Saviours hearers, and Moses his hearers, many of them might be Godly men;
Thus we may maintaine, that albeit every man hath power to believe if he will, and repent if he will, a will to believe and a will to repent being the greatest worke in the work of grace, I meane the renovation of the will, and making it willing to that which is good, though it requires strength also to master the lusting of the flesh, whereby it growes simply and absolutely potent to doe every good thing, without any effectuall impediment from within, yet neverthelesse, till this renovation be wrought by the hand of God, we may well say there is an utter impotency morall to doe any thing that is good and pleasing in the sight of God, whereby they cannot believe, they cannot repent, they cannot be subject to the law of God, And if to Preach this doctrine be to breed sloth, to drowne men in carnall security, and to countenance carnall liberty; then our Saviour did breed sloth &c. when he told his hearers plainly, He that is of God heareth Gods words, ye therefore heare them not, because ye are not of God, Ioh. 8. 47. As likewise when he Preached unto them in this maner. No man can come to me, except the Father which sent me draw him. Ioh. 6. 44. And the Evangelist also in saying, He hath blinded their eyes, and hardned their hearts, that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their hearts, and should be converted, and I should heale them. Ioh. 12. 40. And none more then Moses, when he tells the people of Israel in the Wildernesse, saying, Ye have seen all that the Lord did before your eyes in the land of Egypt, unto Pharaoh and unto all his servants, and to all his land. The great temptations which thine eyes have seen, those great miracles and wonders, yet the Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive, and eyes to see, and eares to heare unto this day. Yet this Author confesseth that our Saviours hearers, and Moses his hearers, many of them might be Godly men;
but no thanks to this doctrine of theirs that they were so (the true and natural genius whereof (to wit, of Christs doctrine and Moses his doctrine, for it is apparent, that it is the same with ours in this particular we now speak of) is to breed sloth, to drown men in carnal security, and to countenance carnal liberty) but to some thing else, either to Gods providence who will not suffer this Doctrine (for his own glory and the good of men) to have any great stroke in their lives; or to mens incogitancy, who think not of reducing it, ad praxim, or drawing conclusions out of it, but rest in the naked speculation of it, as they do of many others; or lastly to some good practical conclusions, which they meet with in Gods word, and apply to their lives (as they do not the former deductions) such as these are. Be ye holy as I am holy: without holiness no man shall see God: Spectatum admissi risum teneatis amici? Yet I pray restrain that, and give your sorrow course rather in beholding such profane aspersions cast upon the holy Doctrine of Christ, his Prophets and Apostles; as if thereby sloth were bred, and men drowned in carnal security, and carnal liberty countenanced. We are of another mind, for Wisdom is justified of her Children; we observe the wisdom of God herein to prevent the greatest illusions of Satan; and such Doctrines as stand in most opposition unto grace. The morality of Heathen men was admirable; yet were it far greater, we conceive no greater opposition unto grace, then to look for justification by it. In the next place, we conceive there is no greater opposition unto grace, then for a man to arrogate unto himself, ability to do that which is pleasing in the sight of God. Our Saviour hath said. John 15. 4. that, As the branch cannot bear fruit of it self, except it abide in the Vine, so neither can we except we abide in him. So that either all the World must be engrafted into Christ or else it is not possible they should bring forth sweet grapes. Yet these men will have all and every one, to have their wills enlivened and enabled to will any spiritual good, whereby they shall be excited. Is this doctrine of theirs fit to humble them, and not rather to puff them up with a conceit of their own sufficiency?
but no thankes to this doctrine of theirs that they were so (the true and naturall genius whereof (to wit, of Christs doctrine and Moses his doctrine, for it is apparent, that it is the same with ours in this particular we now speake of) is to breed sloth, to drowne men in carnall security, and to countenance carnall liberty) but to some thing else, either to Gods providence who will not suffer this Doctrine (for his own glory and the good of men) to have any great stroake in their lives; or to mens incogitancy, who think not of reducing it, ad praxim, or drawing conclusions out of it, but rest in the naked speculation of it, as they doe of many others; or lastly to some good practicall conclusions, which they meet with in Gods word, and apply to their lives (as they doe not the former deductions) such as these are. Be ye holy as I am holy: without holinesse no man shall see God: Spectatum admissi risum teneatis amici? Yet I pray restraine that, and give your sorrow course rather in beholding such prophane aspersions cast upon the holy Doctrine of Christ, his Prophets and Apostles; as if thereby sloth were bred, and men drowned in carnall security, and carnall liberty countenanced. We are of another mind, for Wisedome is justified of her Children; we observe the wisedome of God herein to prevent the greatest illusions of Satan; and such Doctrines as stand in most opposition unto grace. The morality of Heathen men was admirable; yet were it farre greater, we conceive no greater opposition unto grace, then to look for justification by it. In the next place, we conceive there is no greater opposition unto grace, then for a man to arrogate unto himselfe, ability to doe that which is pleasing in the sight of God. Our Saviour hath said. Iohn 15. 4. that, As the branch cannot beare fruit of it selfe, except it abide in the Vine, so neither can wee except we abide in him. So that either all the World must be engrafted into Christ or else it is not possible they should bring forth sweet grapes. Yet these men will have all and every one, to have their wills enlivened and enabled to will any spirituall good, whereby they shall be excited. Is this doctrine of theirs fit to humble them, and not rather to puffe them up with a conceit of their own sufficiency?
Is not our doctrine far more fit to humble us, and to what other end tendeth that of Moses, The Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive, eyes to see, and ears to hear unto this day, But to beat them out of the conceit of any sufficiency in them, to profit either by Gods word, or by his works, so as to be drawn thereby to do any thing that was pleasing in the sight of God; and can there be any true holiness where humility is wanting? Again, they are only thankful unto God for giving them power to believe, to repent, and for exciting them hereunto; and concurring with them to the act of faith and repentance, for they acknowledge no other grace but this; We are bound by our doctrine to be thankful, not only for these operations, but also for causing us to walk in his statutes, to keep his judgements and do them, for healing our ways, our back-slidings, our Rebellions, they by their ⟨p. 248⟩Doctrine, are bound to be thankful unto God, for no other grace in the way of grace prevenient, then such as he vouchsafeth to reprobates, and did vouchsafe to Cain, to Judas, and to the Devils themselves; how is it that they are not stricken with fear, least in this case their condition be no better, then the condition of reprobates though God in good time may provide better things for them, then their opinions, have any congruity unto, having course only to the obscuring and defacing of Gods grace? We by our doctrine are bound to give God thanks for ruling us with a mighty hand, and making us to pass under the rod, and bringing us unto the bond of the 1Covenant; for taking away our stony heart, and giving us an heart of flesh; for circumcising our hearts to love him with all our heart; for raising us out of the dead, when he found us dead in sin; for working in us both the will, and the deed of every good work, not according to any thing in us, but according to his good pleasure:
Is not our doctrine farre more fit to humble us, and to what other end tendeth that of Moses, The Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive, eyes to see, and eares to heare unto this day, But to beat them out of the conceit of any sufficiency in them, to profit either by Gods word, or by his works, so as to be drawn thereby to doe any thing that was pleasing in the sight of God; and can there be any true holinesse where humility is wanting? Againe, they are only thankfull unto God for giving them power to believe, to repent, and for exciting them hereunto; and concurring with them to the act of faith and repentance, for they acknowledge no other grace but this; We are bound by our doctrine to be thankfull, not only for these operations, but also for causing us to walke in his statutes, to keepe his judgements and doe them, for healing our wayes, our back-slidings, our Rebellions, they by their ⟨p. 248⟩Doctrine, are bound to be thankfull unto God, for no other grace in the way of grace prevenient, then such as he vouchsafeth to reprobates, and did vouchsafe to Cain, to Judas, and to the Divells themselves; how is it that they are not stricken with feare, least in this case their condition be no better, then the condition of reprobates though God in good time may provide better things for them, then their opinions, have any congruity unto, having course only to the obscuring and defacing of Gods grace? We by our doctrine are bound to give God thanks for ruling us with a mighty hand, and making us to passe under the rod, and bringing us unto the bond of the 1Covenant; for taking away our stony heart, and giving us an heart of flesh; for circumcising our hearts to love him with all our heart; for raising us out of the dead, when he found us dead in sinne; for working in us both the will, and the deed of every good worke, not according to any thing in us, but according to his good pleasure:
And this is so far from breeding sloth in us, or to drown us in carnal security in the Apostles judgement as that upon this very ground, as by a forcible inducement he exhorts us to work out our Salvation with fear and trembling, manifestly implying, that when men are of another opinion, as namely to think that the will and deed of any good thing is their own work, or if they do acknowledge it to be Gods work, yet if they do not acknowledge it to be wrought by God, according to his good pleasure, but according to some disposition whereby they dispose themselves thereunto; that is the high-way to make them carnally secure, and how but by a carnal confidence that they have power to turn to God when they list, to believe and repent when they will, and withal that their wills are as pliable to good as to evil, and so make it an easy matter at any time to turn to God. I appeal to the judgment of every sober conscience to judge between us which of our Doctrines most tends to the countenancing of carnal security, according to the Tenor of the Apostles exhortation in this place and that in coherence with the reason whereby he doth enforce it, theirs, or ours. But to proceed, they acknowledge Christ to have merited for them only a power to believe and repent and means to excite them hereunto, and concourse divine to the act of believing and repenting in case they will; we acknowledge not only all this, but over and above that Christ hath merited for us, the working of our wills effectually and predominantly hereunto, and that God makes us perfect to every good work, working in us that which is pleasing in his sight through Jesus Christ. Nay what will you say, if the Remonstrants 1now a days openly profess, that Christ merited not for any man faith and regeneration, and I commend them for their ingenuity, in dealing fairly and plainly confessing that which their opinion doth manifestly drive unto. Lastly we confess that God hath power as to show mercy on whom he will, and harden whom he will, so to make whom he will a vessel of mercy, and whom he will a vessel of wrath, this we clearly profess, namely, that God hath such power even over our selves, and our children and all those that are near and dear unto us, as over any others: But this these adversaries of ours now a days utterly deny;
And this is so farre from breeding sloth in us, or to drowne us in carnall security in the Apostles judgement as that upon this very ground, as by a forceable inducement he exhorts us to worke out our Salvation with feare and trembling, manifestly implying, that when men are of another opinion, as namely to thinke that the will and deed of any good thing is their owne worke, or if they doe acknowledge it to be Gods work, yet if they doe not acknowledge it to be wrought by God, according to his good pleasure, but according to some disposition whereby they dispose themselves thereunto; that is the high-way to make them carnally secure, and how but by a carnall confidence that they have power to turne to God when they list, to believe and repent when they will, and withall that their wills are as pliable to good as to evill, and so make it an easy mater at any time to turne to God. I appeale to the judgment of every sober conscience to judge betweene us which of our Doctrines most tends to the countenancing of carnall security, according to the Tenor of the Apostles exhortation in this place and that in coherence with the reason whereby he doth enforce it, theirs, or ours. But to proceed, they acknowledge Christ to have merited for them only a power to believe and repent and meanes to excite them hereunto, and concourse divine to the act of believing and repenting in case they will; we acknowledge not only all this, but over and above that Christ hath merited for us, the working of our wills effectually and predominantly hereunto, and that God makes us perfect to every good worke, working in us that which is pleasing in his sight through Jesus Christ. Nay what will you say, if the Remonstrants 1now a dayes openly professe, that Christ merited not for any man faith and regeneration, and I commend them for their ingenuity, in dealing fairly and plainly confessing that which their opinion doth manifestly drive unto. Lastly we confesse that God hath power as to shew mercy on whom he will, and harden whom he will, so to make whom he will a vessell of mercy, and whom he will a vessell of wrath, this we clearely professe, namely, that God hath such power even over our selves, and our childeren and all those that are neere and deare unto us, as over any others: But this these adversaries of ours now a days utterly deny;
now I pray consider whose doctrine savoureth of greater holiness in acknowledging the sovereignty of God over his creatures, theirs or ours? But it will not be labour lost altogether to consider those causes whereunto he is pleased to impute that Godliness, which is found in us. The first is Gods providence; and indeed I find them liberal enough in acknowledging Gods providence in general terms, and as forward to blast it when they come to particulars. Now as for that providence which is the cause of Godliness, we like plain fellows commonly call it grace, and the ground of this Authors subtlety in calling it providence and not grace, I comprehend not. But what is that operation of providence divine or grace which is the cause of Godliness? Is it any other in his opinion then that universal grace whereby they have power to be Godly and which grace God affords unto Reprobates, and that exciting grace whereby God persuades them to be Godly, and his readiness to concur to any act of Godliness in case we will: and is not all this afforded (in his opinion) to Reprobates as well as to the elect, to them that have no Godliness at all in them, as to them that have? And why may not this doctrine of ours whereby we maintain, that God works in us both the will and the deed according to his good pleasure, be a means to make us set our selves to the working out of our Salvation with fear and trembling, considering that the Apostle professeth this doctrine of Gods energetical operation of every good thing in us as a strong inducement to work out our Salvation with fear and trembling; and wherein consists ⟨p. 249⟩any mans Godliness if not in this, to wit, in working out his Salvation with fear and trembling? And is it not apparent that we maintain this doctrine. namely, that God is he who works in us both the will and the deed, and every good thing, and that according to his good pleasure in far more undoubted manner then they do. And how can it appear that they do acknowledge this? To give us power to will that which i good (which is the effect of that universal grace they talk of) is this to work in us either the will or the deed? To excite us by persuasion and exhortation to will & do that which is good, to believe and to repent, is to work either in us the will or deed of that which is good, of faith of repentance?
now I pray consider whose doctrine savoreth of greater holinesse in acknowledging the soveraignty of God over his creatures, theirs or ours? But it will not be labour lost altogether to consider those causes whereunto he is pleased to impute that Godlinesse, which is found in us. The first is Gods providence; and indeed I find them liberall enough in acknowledging Gods providence in generall termes, and as forward to blast it when they come to particulars. Now as for that providence which is the cause of Godlinesse, we like plaine fellowes comonly call it grace, and the ground of this Authors subtility in calling it providence and not grace, I comprehend not. But what is that operation of providence divine or grace which is the cause of Godlinesse? Is it any other in his opinion then that universall grace whereby they have power to be Godly and which grace God affords unto Reprobates, and that exciting grace whereby God perswades them to be Godly, and his readinesse to concurre to any act of Godlinesse in case we will: and is not all this afforded (in his opinion) to Reprobates as well as to the elect, to them that have no Godlinesse at all in them, as to them that have? And why may not this doctrine of ours whereby we maintaine, that God workes in us both the will and the deed according to his goodpleasure, be a meanes to make us set our selves to the working out of our Salvation with feare and trembling, considering that the Apostle professeth this doctrine of Gods energeticall operation of every good thing in us as a strong inducement to worke out our Salvation with feare and trembling; and wherein consists ⟨p. 249⟩any mans Godlinesse if not in this, to wit, in working out his Salvation with feare and trembling? And is it not apparent that we maintaine this doctrine. namely, that God is he who workes in us both the will and the deed, and every good thing, and that according to his good pleasure in farre more undoubted manner then they doe. And how can it appeare that they doe acknowledge this? To give us power to will that which i good (which is the effect of that universall grace they talke of) is this to worke in us either the will or the deed? To excite us by perswasion and exhortation to will & doe that which is good, to believe and to repent, is to worke either in us the will or deed of that which is good, of faith of repentance?
Lastly to be ready to concur with us to the will or deed of faith and repentance if so be we will concur with him to the same, or to concur with us to the producing of the act of willing & the act of doing that which is good, in case we produce the same act of willing and doing that which is good, is this to work in us both the will and the deed? Consider I pray is it not true that God is as ready to concur with us to any sinful act, in case we will concur with him; and doth he not concur with man to the producing of any sinful act, in case man at that time doth produce it; And will any sober man say that this is also for God to work in him both the will and the deed of every sinful act? And why might we not say so, if God works it only by concourse? Lastly to work in us both the will and the deed provided that man will concur to the working hereof not otherwise, is this to work it according to his good pleasure, and not rather according to mans good pleasure? And how I pray, or in what sense doth he say that God by his providence will not suffer this doctrine to have any stroke in our lives? For if he suffers it not, then he hinders it; let it therefore be made appear how he hinders it; To concur with us, if we will concur with him in the producing of any act of Godliness, is this to hinder our carnal security? If so then to concur with us to the producing of any sinful act is to hinder our Godliness. Surely to give power whereby men are enabled to do any spiritual good if they will is not to hinder carnal security, for such a power is given to all by universal grace, yet this doth nothing hinder the carnal security of many thousands. Or doth he hinder it by exciting us to the contrary? Yet if this doctrine (as we conceive) be apt to drown us in carnal security, how can he be said to hinder us from it? For either the doctrine must yield to such excitations & exhortations from carnal security; or such exhortations must yield to the doctrine, especially considering what Austin saith, that if there be any difference between docere and suadere or exhortari; yet even this doctrinae generalitate comprehenditur. And for incogitancy, which is a second device, pretended as the cause why this doctrine doth not expose us to carnality, is it not incredible, these points being so much ventilated by them as none more?
Lastly to be ready to concurre with us to the will or deed of faith and repentance if so be we will concurre with him to the same, or to concurre with us to the producing of the act of willing & the act of doing that which is good, in case we produce the same act of willing and doing that which is good, is this to worke in us both the will and the deed? Consider I pray is it not true that God is as ready to concurre with us to any sinfull act, in case we will concurre with him; and doth he not concurre with man to the produceing of any sinfull act, in case man at that time doth produce it; And will any sober man say that this is also for God to worke in him both the will and the deed of every sinfull act? And why might we not say so, if God workes it only by concourse? Lastly to worke in us both the will and the deed provided that man will concurre to the working hereof not otherwise, is this to worke it according to his good pleasure, and not rather according to mans good pleasure? And how I pray, or in what sence doth he say that God by his providence will not suffer this doctrine to have any stroke in our lives? For if he suffers it not, then he hinders it; let it therefore be made appeare how he hinders it; To concurre with us, if we will concurre with him in the producing of any act of Godlinesse, is this to hinder our carnall security? If so then to concurre with us to the producing of any sinfull act is to hinder our Godlinesse. Surely to give power whereby men are enabled to doe any spirituall good if they will is not to hinder carnall security, for such a power is given to all by universall grace, yet this doth nothing hinder the carnall security of many thousands. Or doth he hinder it by exciting us to the contrary? Yet if this doctrine (as we conceive) be apt to drowne us in carnall security, how can he be sayd to hinder us from it? For either the doctrine must yeeld to such excitations & exhortations from carnall security; or such exhortations must yeeld to the doctrine, especially considering what Austin sayth, that if there be any difference betweene docere and suadere or exhortari; yet even this doctrinae generalitate comprehenditur. And for incogitancy, which is a second device, pretended as the cause why this doctrine doth not expose us to carnality, is it not incredible, these poynts being so much ventilated by them as none more?
The Church of God having been exercised with none more (as I think) these hundred years; that men should not think of, or consider of those dangerous consequences in manners, as these do forge in their own brains. And as for the last, imputing our Godliness to some good practical conclusions; may I not justly say, that if ever any man wrote with the spirit of giddiness, this Author deserves to have a chief place amongst them: For compare his answer to the second objection with this; There he saith such dissolute conclusions as these following, do arise out of this doctrine of ours: If I be chosen, I must of necessity believe and be saved; If I be cast off, I must as necessarily not believe and be damned; what need I therefore take thought either way about means or end. Now will it not as well follow, what need I therefore take thought of holiness, of obedience? For even these are as good practical conclusions. Believe and thou shalt be saved. Repent and thou shalt be saved, and whosoever bebelieveth not shall be damned. As these, Be ye holy as I am holy. Without holiness no man shall see God. If ye consent and obey, ye shall eat the good things of the Land. And by the way observe I pray, with what judgement he calls them practical conclusions; whereas all save two of them, are exhortations rather then conclusions; And those two; to wit, Without holiness no man shall see God, and, Godliness hath the promises, both of this life &c. I should take them to be principles rather then conclusions. Whether simple men do apply their brains to ponder and consider this doctrine or no, I know not; but certainly the learned and Godly maintainers of it, have had cause enough to ponder it, and consider it throughly, and have given evidence enough of their thorough consideration of it; yet have they fetched no such sequels out of it. If simple men do, and our adversaries be of the number of them, and content themselves with such simplicity; yet is it not ⟨p. 250⟩enough for us that the Apostle doth not? the holy Apostle S. Paul? but expressly enforceth the contrary there from; namely; that because of God worketh in us the will and the deed according to his good pleasure, therefore it becomes us to work out our Salvation with fear and trembling?
The Church of God having been exercised with none more (as I think) these hundred yeares; that men should not think of, or consider of those dangerous consequences in manners, as these doe forge in their own braines. And as for the last, imputing our Godlinesse to some good practicall conclusions; may I not justly say, that if ever any man wrote with the spirit of giddinesse, this Author deserves to have a chiefe place amongst them: For compare his answer to the second objection with this; There he saith such dissolute conclusions as these following, doe arise out of this doctrine of ours: If I be chosen, I must of necessity believe and be saved; If I be cast off, I must as necessarily not believe and be damned; what need I therefore take thought either way about meanes or end. Now will it not as well follow, what need I therefore take thought of holinesse, of obedience? For even these are as good practicall conclusions. Believe and thou shalt be saved. Repent and thou shalt be saved, and whosoever bebelieveth not shall be damned. As these, Be ye holy as I am holy. Without holinesse no man shall see God. If ye consent and obey, ye shall eate the good things of the Land. And by the way observe I pray, with what judgement he calls them practicall conclusions; whereas all save two of them, are exhortations rather then conclusions; And those two; to wit, Without holinesse no man shall see God, and, Godlinesse hath the promises, both of this life &c. I should take them to be principles rather then conclusions. Whether simple men doe apply their braines to ponder and consider this doctrine or no, I know not; but certainly the learned and Godly maintainers of it, have had cause enough to ponder it, and consider it throughly, and have given evidence enough of their thorough consideration of it; yet have they fetcht no such sequells out of it. If simple men doe, and our adversaries be of the number of them, and content themselves with such simplicity; yet is it not ⟨p. 250⟩enough for us that the Apostle doth not? the holy Apostle S. Paul? but expressely enforceth the contrary there from; namely; that because of God worketh in us the will and the deed according to his good pleasure, therefore it becomes us to worke out our Salvation with feare and trembling?
Now which of us do most exactly concur with the Apostle in mainning that God doth work in us both the will and the deed according to his good pleasure, I am very well content, that all the World both wise and simple, both Learned and unlearned may judge.
Now which of us doe most exactly concurre with the Apostle in mainning that God doth worke in us both the will and the deed according to his good pleasure, I am very well content, that all the World both wise and simple, both Learned and unlearned may judge.
2. As touching the second; First let us consider how the objection is shaped. Secondly, as it lies, with what judgement and sobriety it is impugned.
1. It is true men are absolutely elected or absolutely rejected; but we content not our selves with generalities, wherein as Aristotle hath observed, do lurk many equivocations: Neither do we delight in confounding things that differ. Election and rejection or reprobation, and in general the will of God, may be considered, either Quoad actum voluntis, as touching the act of God willing, or as touching the things willed. Of this distinction this Author takes no notice; It is fit for some and advantageous to fish in troubled waters. Now as touching the act of God willing; both Aquinas hath proved, that there can be no cause thereof; and withal professeth, that never was any so mad as to say That merits can be the cause of predestination, quoad actum praedestinantis, as touching the act of God predestinating. And Bradwardine hath curiously disputed this way that no will of God is conditional, to will quoad actum volentis, And Piscator against Vorstius hath proved the same after his way; and by variety of demonstration this way may be convinced, as in part I have showed in this discourse, both on the part of election, and on the part of reprobation. And both Dr Jackson in his book of Providence, professeth that the distinction of Voluntas antecedens and consequens, or antecedent and consequent will in God is to be understood quoad res volitas as touching the things willed, as much as to say, non quoad actum volentis. And Gerardus Vossius drawing the distinction of will antecedent and will consequent unto the distinction of will absolute and will conditional, applies it only quoad res 1volitas, and so interpreteth Fathers discourse thereof; And of a conditional will gives this instance; God will have men to be Saved, in case they believe where faith is clearly made the condition of Salvation, a temporal thing the condition of a temporal thing, not the condition of Gods will to save; it being no way fit that a temporal thing should be made the condition of a thing eternal, such as is Gods will to save. And this is more apparent by the reading of Vossius himself. Histor: Pelag: l: 7. treating of Gods will to save all. Now if we speak thus of Gods will quoad res volitas as touching the things willed; these things willed being very different, we have reason to consider them distinctly also.
1. It is true men are absolutely elected or absolutely rejected; but we content not our selves with generalities, wherein as Aristotle hath observed, doe lurke many equivocations: Neither doe we delight in confounding things that differ. Election and rejection or reprobation, and in generall the will of God, may be considered, either Quoad actum voluntis, as touching the act of God willing, or as touching the things willed. Of this distinction this Author takes no notice; It is fit for some and advantagious to fish in troubled waters. Now as touching the act of God willing; both Aquinas hath proved, that there can be no cause thereof; and withall professeth, that never was any so mad as to say That merites can be the cause of predestination, quoad actum praedestinantis, as touching the act of God predestinating. And Bradwardine hath curiously disputed this way that no will of God is conditionall, to will quoad actum volentis, And Piscator against Vorstius hath proved the same after his way; and by variety of demonstration this way may be convinced, as in part I have shewed in this discourse, both on the part of election, and on the part of reprobation. And both Dr Jackson in his booke of Providence, professeth that the distinction of Voluntas antecedens and consequens, or antecedent and consequent will in God is to be understood quoad res volitas as touching the things willed, as much as to say, non quoad actum volentis. And Gerardus Vossius drawing the distinction of will antecedent and will consequent unto the distinction of will absolute and will conditionall, applyes it only quoad res 1volitas, and so interpriteth Fathers discourse thereof; And of a conditionall will gives this instance; God will have men to be Saved, in case they believe where faith is clearely made the condition of Salvation, a temporall thing the condition of a temporall thing, not the condition of Gods will to save; it being no way fit that a temporall thing should be made the condition of a thing eternall, such as is Gods will to save. And this is more apparent by the reading of Vossius himselfe. Histor: Pelag: l: 7. treating of Gods will to save all. Now if we speake thus of Gods will quoad res volitas as touching the things willed; these things willed being very different, wee have reason to consider them distinctly also.
Now these things are either grace or glory commonly called Salvation, And as touching grace, to wit, the grace of regeneration, the grace of faith and repentance, we willingly confess that Gods will to confer them is so absolute, that he hath determined to confer them according to the mere pleasure of his will, not according to mans works (which is plain Pelagianism and condemned in the Synod of Palestine above 1200 years ago) and as he gives them to whom he will, so he denies them to whom he will according to that Rom. 9. 18. He hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth. But as touching Salvation or damnation in which respect this Author usually speaks of the absolute or conditional will of God; we utterly deny, that God in the dispensation or administration, or execution of these proceeds or ever did decree to proceed according to the mere pleasure of his own will, but altogether according to their works. For albeit God hath made no law according whereto he means to proceed in giving or denying grace, yet hath he made a law according whereto he proceeds in bestowing Salvation, and inflicting damnation. And the law is this: Whosever believeth shall be Saved, Whosoever believeth not shall be damned 2 Cor. 5. 10. We must all appear before the Judgement Seat of Christ, that every man may receive the things, which are done in his body according to that he hath done, whether good or evil. So that according to that sense wherein this Author usually speaks of the absolute and conditional will of God, we utterly deny that God doth absolutely elect any man to Salvation, or reject any man unto damnation; though he doth absolutely elect some unto grace, that is to the grace of regeneration; to the grace of faith and repentance, and absolutely reject others there from. For as much as he bestows these graces on some and denies them unto others not according to their works, but according to the mere pleasure ⟨p. 251⟩of his own will, but he doth not inflict damnation or bestow Salvation according to the mere pleasure of his will, but according unto mans works. And as he carrieth himself in the execution of Salvation and damnation, after the same manner he did from everlasting decree to carry himself, namely to Save no man of ripe years but by way of reward of their faith, repentance, and good works;
Now these things are either grace or glory cō monly called Salvation, And as touching grace, to wit, the grace of regeneration, the grace of faith and repentannee, we willingly confesse that Gods will to conferre them is so absolute, that he hath determined to conferre them according to the meere pleasure of his will, not according to mans workes (which is plaine Pelagianisme and condemned in the Synod of Palestine above 1200 yeares agoe) and as he gives them to whom he will, so he denyes them to whom he will according to that Rom. 9. 18. He hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth. But as touching Salvation or damnation in which respect this Author usually speakes of the absolute or conditionall will of God; we uttererly deny, that God in the dispensation or administration, or execution of these proceeds or ever did decree to proceed according to the meere pleasure of his owne will, but altogether according to theire workes. For albeit God hath made no law according whereto he meanes to proceed in giving or denying grace, yet hath he made a law according whereto he proceeds in bestowing Salvation, and inflicting damnation. And the law is this: Whosever believeth shall be Saved, Whosoever believeth not shall bedamned 2 Cor. 5. 10. We must all appeare before the Judgement Seate of Christ, that every man may receive the things, which are done in his body according to that he hath done, whether good or evill. So that according to that sence wherein this Author usually speakes of the absolute and conditionall will of God, we utterly deny that God doth absolutely elect any man to Salvation, or reject any man unto damnation; though he doth absolutely elect some unto grace, that is to the grace of regeneration; to the grace of faith and repentance, and absolutely reject others there from. For as much as he bestowes these graces on some and denies them unto others not according to their workes, but according to the meere pleasure ⟨p. 251⟩of his owne will, but he doth not inflict damnaton or bestow Salvation according to the meere pleasure of his will, but according unto mans works. And as he carrieth himselfe in the execution of Salvation and damnation, after the same manner he did from everlasting decree to carry himselfe, namely to Save no man of ripe yeares but by way of reward of their faith, repentance, and good workes;
so to damn none but for their infidelity, impenitency and evil works. As for the manifestation of Gods will of election and reprobation unto any, we say, that ordinarily, man may be assured of his election. For the spirit of God is given to this very end even to shed the love of God in our hearts, that is, Gods love towards us. Rom: 5. 5. And what is the shedding therefore in our hearts, but his working in us a sense and feeling thereof, especially considering that the sense of Gods love to us is the cause of our love to wards God; according to that 1 John. 4. 19. We love him because he loved us first: and accordingly the spirit is said to testify unto our spirits that we are the sons Rom. 8. And if sons then heirs, even heirs of God, and heirs annexed with Christ. And the Apostle St Peter exhorts us to give diligence to make our election & vocation sure; implying manifestly 1that men may be sure of their election; otherwise why should our Saviour wish his Disciples to rejoice not in this that Devils were subdued unto them, but that their names were written in Heaven. And by what means may a man be assured hereof, but either 2immediately by the testimony of the spirit, or mediately by the fruits of the spirit as the fruits of our election; one where of is faith plainly so signified Act, 13. 48. As many believed as were ordained to everlasting Life. And Act. 2. last. God added daily to the Church such as should be Saved; And repentance is another: Act. 11. 18. Then hath God unto the Gentiles also given repentance unto life. Giving to understand that as many as to whom God giveth repentance, he hath ordained them unto life. And indeed by the work of our faith, and labour of our love, and the patience of our hope, others come to be assured of our election (how much more our selves, no man knowing the things of man so as the spirit of man 1 Cor: 2.) Thus St Paul professeth his assurance of the election of the Thessalonians 1 Thess. 1. 3, 4. We remember the work of your faith, and the labour of your love &c. Knowing beloved brethren that ye are elect of God. And hereupon he proceeds to assure them, that Antichrist by all his deceivableness of unrighteousness shall never prevail over them; in as much as he prevails only over them that perish 2 Thess: 2. 10. But as for them they are the elect of God; And how doth he know that?
so to damne none but for their infidelity, impenitency and evill works. As for the manifestation of Gods will of election and reprobation unto any, we say, that ordinarily, man may be assured of his election. For the spirit of God is given to this very end even to shed the love of God in our hearts, that is, Gods love towards us. Rom: 5. 5. And what is the shedding therefore in our hearts, but his working in us a sense and feeling thereof, especially considering that the sence of Gods love to us is the cause of our love to wards God; according to that 1 John. 4. 19. We love him because he loved us first: and accordingly the spirit is sayd to testifie unto our spirits that we are the sonnes Rom. 8. And if sonnes then heyres, even heyres of God, and heyres annexed with Christ. And the Apostle St Peter exhorts us to give diligence te make our election & vocation sure; implying manifestly 1that men may be sure of their election; otherwise why should our Saviour wish his Disciples to rejoyce not in this that Divells were subdued unto them, but that their names were writen in Heaven. And by what meanes may a man be assured hereof, but either 2immediatly by the testimony of the spirit, or mediatly by the fruits of the spirit as the fruits of our election; one where of is faith plainly so signified Act, 13. 48. As many believed as were ordained to everlasting Life. And Act. 2. last. God added daily to the Church such as should be Saved; And repentance is another: Act. 11. 18. Then hath God unto the Gentiles also given repentance unto life. Giving to understand that as many as to whom God giveth repentance, he hath ordained them unto life. And indeed by the worke of our faith, and labour of our love, and the patience of our hope, others come to be assured of our election (how much more our selves, no man knowing the things of mā so as the spirit of man 1 Cor: 2.) Thus St Paul professeth his assurance of the election of the Thessalonians 1 Thess. 1. 3, 4. We remember the worke of your faith, and the labour of your love &c. Knowing beloved bretheren that ye are elect of God. And hereupon he proceeds to assure them, that Antichrist by all his deceiveablenesse of unrighteousnesse shall never prevaile over them; in as much as he prevailes only over them that perish 2 Thess: 2. 10. But as for them they are the elect of God; And how doth he know that?
Surely by their faith and sanctification which were visible in them v: 13. But we ought to give God thanks always for you, brethren beloved of the Lord, because that God hath from the beginning chosen you unto Salvation by sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth. But as for reprobation we say that no man can by any ordinary way be assured thereof, seeing nothing but final perseverance in infidelity or impenitency is the infallible sign thereof, whence it follows that no way of desperation is open to one, but the way of assurance and abundance of consolation is opened to the other, and thereby encouragement to proceed cheerfully in the ways of Godliness, being assured that the more holy they are the greater shall be their reward. And surely if certainty of salvation were a means of licentiousness, the Apostle S. Peter would never have exhorted us, to give diligence to make our calling and election sure. And we manifestly seem to perceive strength 1of encouragement hereby unto Godliness; as being assured that Christ dyed for us, to the end we might live unto him. And God receives us as Sons and Daughters to this end, that we should purge our selves from all pollutions of flesh and spirit, and perfect holiness in the fear of God. As also being assured, that God will not lay our infirmities and 2sins unto our charge, and will be ready to keep us from presumptuous sins, and however it fares with us, Yet sin shall not have dominion over us, (and consequently we shall have the victory over it, either by obedience, or by repentance) because we are not under the law but under grace. Rom. 6. 12. Now what encouragement is this to the Soldiers of Christ, to go on cheerfully and courageously in fighting the Lords battles against the world, the flesh and the Devil, seeing we are assured the day of victory and the glory of it shall be ours in the end: God keeping us by his power through faith unto Salvation 1 Pet. 1. And delivering us from every evil work (to wit either by obedience or by repentance) and preserving us to his heavenly kingdom; and that either, by delivering us from the hour aftentation which comes all over the world Revel: 3. Or delivering us out of it 2 Pet: 2. 9. Or having an eye to our strength so to order it that we shall be able to bear it 1 Cor: 10. 14.
Surely by their faith and sanctification which were visible in them v: 13. But we ought to give God thankes allwayes for you, bretheren beloved of the Lord, because that God hath from the begining chosen you unto Salvation by sanctification of the spirit and faith of the truth. But as for reprobation we say that no man can by any ordinary way be assured thereof, seing nothing but finall perseverance in infidelity or impenitency is the infallible signe thereof, whence it followes that no way of desperation is open to one, but the way of assurance and abundance of consolation is opened to the other, and thereby encouragement to proceed cheerefully in the wayes of Godlinesse, being assured that the more holy they are the greater shall be their reward. And surely if certainty of salvation were a meanes of licentiousnesse, the Apostle S. Peter would never have exhorted us, to give diligence to make our calling and election sure. And we manifestly seem to perceive strength 1of encouragement hereby unto Godlinesse; as being assured that Christ dyed for us, to the end we might live unto him. And God receives us as Sonnes and Daughters to this end, that we should purge our selves from all pollutions of flesh and spirit, and perfect holinesse in the feare of God. As also being assured, that God will not lay our infirmities and 2sinnes unto our charge, and will be ready to keepe us from presumptuous sinnes, and however it fares with us, Yet sinne shall not have dominion over us, (and consequently we shall have the victory over it, either by obedience, or by repentance) because we are not under the law but under grace. Rom. 6. 12. Now what encouragement is this to the Souldiers of Christ, to goe on chearefully and couragiously in fighting the Lords battailes against the world, the flesh and the Divell, seing we are assured the day of victory and the glory of it shall be ours in the end: God keeping us by his power through faith unto Salvation 1 Pet. 1. And delivering us from every evill worke (to wit either by obedience or by repentance) and preserving us to his heavenly kingdome; and that either, by delivering us from the houre aftentation which comes all over the world Revel: 3. Or delivering us out of it 2 Pet: 2. 9. Or having an eye to our strength so to order it that we shall be able to beare it 1 Cor: 10. 14.
As for those that have not yet any comfortable evidence of their election; yet considering that they may have it, and albeit the number of ⟨p. 252⟩the elect are by far, fewer then the reprobate; yet considering how few have the Gospel in comparison to those that enjoy it not; though Turks & Saracens and Heathens are without hope Eph. 2. 12. and 1 Thess. 4. 13. Yet we Christians are not yea, albeit of them that are called, but few are chosen Mat. 20. 16. and 22, 14. Yet considering how many corrupt ways there are amongst Christians, Nestorians, Armenians, Abyssines or Coptites, who join circumcision with the Gospel, as in Egypt and Ethiopia, (the Greek Church denying the proceeding of the Holy Ghost from the Son) and corrupted with many other superstitions. Lastly considering how far Antichristanity is spread and the abominable Idolatry of the Church of Rome, we whom God hath delivered out of Babylon have no cause (I mean any particular person) to project, that because the elect are but few, therefore we are not of the number of them, and thereupon give over all care of hearkening to Gods word, which is the power of God unto Salvation and may show its power upon us also we know not how soon, but rather as our Saviour answered (being demanded of his disciples whether there were but few that should be saved) saying strive [you] to enter in at the strait gate, plainly giving to understand, that as the gate is said to be strait that leadeth unto Life, so there be but few that enter thereat & therefore they should strive so much the more to be of the number of those few. For what if along time we have little or nothing profited, what if we have cause to doubt whether we have any true faith or no; such doubts maybe better signs then we are aware of; otherwise why should the Apostle exhort the Corinthians to examine themselves and prove whether they were in the faith or no? But however it fairs with us doth not the Apostle plainly teach us, that God calls some at the first hour of the day, some at the the third, some at 1the last?
As for those that have not yet any comfortable evidence of their election; yet considering that they may have it, and albeit the number of ⟨p. 252⟩the elect are by farre, fewer then the reprobate; yet considering how few have the Gospell in comparison to those that enjoy it not; though Turkes & Saracens and Heathens are without hope Eph. 2. 12. and 1 Thess. 4. 13. Yet we Christians are not yea, albeit of them that are called, but few are chosen Mat. 20. 16. and 22, 14. Yet considering how many corrupt wayes there are amongst Christians, Nestorians, Armenians, Abyssines or Coptites, who joyne circumcision with the Gospel, as in Egypt and Ethiopia, (the Greek Church denying the proceeding of the Holy Ghost from the sonne) and corrupted with many other superstitions. Lastly considering how farre Antichristanity is spred and the abominable Idolatry of the Church of Rome, we whom God hath delivered out of Babylon have no cause (I meane any particular person) to project, that because the elect are but few, therefore we are not of the number of them, and thereupon give over all care of hearkening to Gods word, which is the power of God unto Salvation and may shew its power upon us also we knowe not how soone, but rather as our Saviour answered (being demanded of his disciples whether there were but few that should be saved) saying strive [you] to enter in at the streight gate, plainly giving to understand, that as the gate is said to be streight that leadeth unto Life, so there be but few that enter thereat & therefore they should strive so much the more to be of the number of those few. For what if along time we have little or nothing profited, what if we have cause to doubt whether we have any true faith or no; such doubts maybe better signes then we are awar of; otherwise why should the Apostle exhort the Corinthians to examine themselves and prove whether they were in the faith or no? But however it fairs with us doth not the Apostle plainely teach us, that God calls some at the first houre of the day, some at the the third, some at 1the last?
2. Now I come to the consideration of his answer to the objection, as himself hath formed it. And first I observe, that whereas he pretends to build his answer upon consideration of the number of Reprobates without comparison greater then the number of the elect, yet the absurd reasoning which he brings hereupon, doth nothing at all depend on that. For albeit the number of the elect, were greater then the number of such as are Reprobates, and that without comparison; yet the reasoning here deduced from the contrary proposition hath equally place, as in the contrary case, As namely, to reason thus: Either I am absolutely chosen to grace and glory or absolutely cast off from both. Secondly the joining of grace and glory together, as this Author doth join them in this reasoning shaped by him is a miserable confounding of things that differ. For to be absolutely chosen unto grace is to be ordained to have grace conferred upon him not according to any work of his, but merely according to the good pleasure of Gods will, answerably to that of the Apostle, God hath mercy on whom he will, but no man is so chosen unto glory, as namely to be ordained to have Salvation bestowed upon him not according unto works, but according to the mere pleasure of God, if we speak of men of ripe years. For God hath ordained to bestow Salvation on such only by way of reward of their faith, repentance, and good works. So on the other side to be absolutely cast off from grace, is to be ordained to have grace denied him; not according to any work of his, but merely according to the good pleasure of Gods will, like as Paul professeth, that the Lord hardeneth whom he will, But no man is so castaway from Glory, or unto damnation, as namely, to be ordained to be deprived of Glory and to be damned, merely for the good pleasure of God, but altogether for his infidelity, impenitency and evil works. Thirdly, no such thing follows as here is inferred from the supposition of election unto Salvation. For seeing no man is elected to obtain Salvation, whether he believe or no, but only in case he believe, hereupon men are rather excited to labour for faith, then to be careless thereof; and farther we say, that as God hath ordained to bring them to Salvation, so he hath ordained to bring them hereunto by sanctification and faith. 2 Thess. 2. 13.
2. Now I come to the consideration of his answer to the objection, as himself hath formed it. And first I observe, that whereas he pretends to build his answer upon consideration of the number of Reprobats without comparison greater then the number of the elect, yet the absurd reasoning which he brings hereupon, doth nothing at all depend on that. For albeit the number of the elect, were greater then the number of such as are Reprobats, and that without comparison; yet the reasoning here deduced from the contrary proposition hath equally place, as in the contrary case, As namely, to reason thus: Either I am absolutely chosen to grace and glory or absolutely cast off from both. Secondly the joyning of grace and glory together, as this Author doth joyne them in this reasoning shaped by him is a miserable confounding of things that differ. For to be absolutely chosen unto grace is to be ordained to have grace conferred upon him not according to any worke of his, but meerely according to the good pleasure of Gods will, answerably to that of the Apostle, God hath mercy on whom he will, but no man is so chosen unto glory, as namely to be ordained to have Salvation bestowed upon him not according unto workes, but according to the meere pleasure of God, if we speake of men of ripe yeares. For God hath ordained to bestow Salvation on such only by way of reward of their faith, repentance, and good workes. So on the other side to be asolutely cast off from grace, is to be ordained to have grace denied him; not according to any worke of his, but meerely according to the good pleasure of Gods will, like as Paul professeth, that the Lord hardeneth whom he will, But no man is so castaway from Glory, or unto damnation, as namely, to be ordained to be deprived of Glory and to be damned, meerely for the good pleasure of God, but altogether for his infidelity, impenitency and evill workes. Thirdly, no such thing followes as here is inferred from the supposition of election unto Salvation. For seing no man is elected to obtaine Salvation, whether he believe or no, but only in case he believe, hereupon men are rather excited to labour for faith, then to be carelesse thereof; and farther we say, that as God hath ordained to bring them to Salvation, so he hath ordained to bring them hereunto by sanctification and faith. 2 Thess. 2. 13.
And the word of God is a powerful means to work them hereunto, even to the working out of their Salvation with fear and trembling, & that because they are given to understand that God is he who worketh in them both the will 1and the deed according to his good pleasure. On the other side if a man be ordained to damnation, yet seeing no man is ordained to be damned but for despising the means of grace in case he hear the Gospel; & for ought any man knows he may as well be ordained to salvation as to damnation; this I should think, is rather an excitement not to despise or neglect the means of grace, then to despise or neglect them. Suppose God should ⟨p. 253⟩not damn any man, but annihilate them, and suppose this were known unto us; by the same argumentation it would follow, that a man should have no care of good works: But this consequent is notoriously untrue. For seeing the perfection of my reasonable nature, whereby I differ from brute Beasts, consisteth in knowledge and moral virtues; and there is no knowledge that doth more ennoble us, then the knowledge of God, and no better rule of morality, then the law of God; surely it stood me upon in reason, to strive according to my power to know God, and to be obedient rather then otherwise; although I know for certain, that after certain years, both body and soul should be returned unto nothing. Come we now to the consideration of this reasoning, in respect of grace. Suppose God hath elected me unto grace; yet seeing he bestows not grace but by his word, therefore there is no reason I should neglect the use of his word, but rather good reason why I should embrace it, and that with all earnestness. Like as in case God hath ordained I shall have Children, doth it hence follow that I need not use the company of a Woman; because seeing God hath decreed I shall have Children, therefore I may be sure to have them, whether I company with a Woman or no, belike right as Capons come by Chicken? On the other side, suppose God hath not ordained me unto grace; yet hence it followeth not, that I should neglect all care of moral virtue, yea or the use of Gods word. First not of moral virtue; for next unto grace, moral virtue commends a man, and like as many heathens were famous for morality, without any sanctifying grace; so may I be in the same kind of reputation also.
And the word of God is a powerfull meanes to worke them hereunto, even to the working out of their Salvation with feare and trembling, & that because they are given to understand that God is he who wroketh in them both the will 1and the deed according to his good pleasure. On the other side if a man be ordained to damnatiō, yet seeing no man is ordained to be damned but for despising the means of grace in case he heare the Gospel; & for ought any man knowes he may as well be ordained to salvation as to damnation; this I should think, is rather an excitement not to despise or neglect the meanes of grace, then to despise or neglect them. Suppose God should ⟨p. 253⟩not damne any man, but annihilate them, and suppose this were known unto us; by the same argumentation it would follow, that a man should have no care of good workes: But this consequent is notoriously untrue. For seeing the perfection of my reasonable nature, whereby I differ from brute Beasts, consisteth in knowledge and morall vertues; and there is no knowledge that doth more ennoble us, then the knowledge of God, and no better rule of morality, then the law of God; surely it stood me upon in reason, to strive according to my power to know God, and to be obedient rather then otherwise; although I know for certaine, that after certaine yeares, both body and soule should be returned unto nothing. Come wee now to the consideration of this reasoning, in respect of grace. Suppose God hath elected me unto grace; yet seeing he bestowes not grace but by his word, therefore there is no reason I should neglect the use of his word, but rather good reason why I should embrace it, and that with all earnestnesse. Like as in case God hath ordained I shall have Children, doth it hence follow that I neede not use the company of a Woman; because seeing God hath decreed I shall have Children, therefore I may be sure to have them, whether I company with a Woman or no, belike right as Capons come by Chicken? On the other side, suppose God hath not ordained me unto grace; yet hence it followeth not, that I should neglect all care of morall vertue, yea or the use of Gods word. First not of morall vertue; for next unto grace, morall vertue commends a man, and like as many heathens were famous for morality, without any sanctifying grace; so may I be in the same kind of reputation also.
And seeing no better rules of morality are to be found, then in the Scriptures, therefore may I well be moved to give my self to the study thereof. And Austin telleth us, that some, even of reprobates, by the word of God may Proficere ad exteriorem vitae emendationem, quò mitius puniantur. Last of all, consider how the like objections were made against that destiny, which was maintained by the Stoics. Carneades was a great oppugner of the Stoics, yet was ashamed of such a kind of Argumentation as this Author affecteth. For it was commonly accounted ignava ratio; and thus Turnebus writes of it, Ignava autem ista ratio, captiosa cum esset, & calumniae plena, a Carneade non probabatur, alioque argumento factum sine ulla caption oppugnabat. He had other manner of reasons to oppose Fate Stoical, then by so sorry an argumentation as this. And this is delivered by Turnebus, upon that passage in Cicero's book De Fato, Where he showeth how Chrysippus did make answer unto this very argument in effect above 1600 years a go; Take the words as they lye in Cicero, Nec nos impediet illa ignava ratio quae dicitur: Appellatur enim quidem a Philosophis [Greek or Hebrew], cui si pare amus, nihil est omnino quod agamus in vita. Hic enim interrogant (now I beseech you mark the argument well) si fatum tibi est ex hoc morbo convalescere, sive medicum adhibueris, sive non, convalesces. Item si fatum tibi est ex hoc morbo non convalescere sive tu Medicum adhibueris, sive non, non convalesces. If it be destined that you shall recover out of this disease, whether you use the help of a Physician or no, you shall recover. Again, if it be destined that you shall not recover out of this disease, whether you use a Physician or no, you shall not recover. Now compare this, I pray, with this Authors argumentation in this place; If I am chosen I must of necessity believe and be saved; What need therefore to take thought either about means or end? as much as to say, either of believing or of salvation. Again, If I be cast off, I must as necessarily not believe and be damned; In vain therefore do I trouble my self about means, or end; as much as to say, about labouring and endeavouring for Faith, whereby I may avoid damnation: And judge, I pray, whether there be one hairs breadth of difference, between these argumentations.
And seeing no better rules of morality are to be found, then in the Scriptures, therefore may I well be moved to give my selfe to the study thereof. And Austin telleth us, that some, even of reprobates, by the word of God may Proficere ad exteriorem vitae emendationem, quò mitius puniantur. Last of all, consider how the like objections were made against that destiny, which was maintained by the Stoicks. Carneades was a great oppugner of the Stoicks, yet was ashamed of such a kind of Argumentation as this Author affecteth. For it was commonly accounted ignava ratio; and thus Turnebus writes of it, Ignava autem ista ratio, captiosa cum esset, & calumniae plena, a Carneade non probabatur, alioque argumento factum sine ulla captione oppugnabat. He had other manner of reasons to oppose Fate Stoicall, then by so sorry an argumentation as this. And this is delivered by Turnebus, upon that passage in Cicero's book De Fato, Where he sheweth how Chrysippus did make answer unto this very argument in effect above 1600 yeares a goe; Take the words as they lye in Cicero, Nec nos impediet illa ignava ratio quae dicitur: Appellatur enim quidem a Philosophis 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, cui si pare amus, nihil est omnino quod agamus in vita. Hic enim interrogant (now I beseech you marke the argument well) si fatum tibi est ex hoc morbo convalescere, sive medicum adhibueris, sive non, convalesces. Item si fatum tibi est ex hoc morbo non convalescere sive tu Medicum adhibueris, sive non, non convalesces. If it be destined that you shall recover out of this disease, whether you use the help of a Physitian or no, you shall recover. Againe, if it be destined that you shall not recover out of this disease, whether you use a Physitian or no, you shall not recover. Now compare this, I pray, with this Authors argumentation in this place; If I am chosen I must of necessity believe and be saved; What need therefore to take thought either about meanes or end? as much as to say, either of believing or of salvation. Againe, If I be cast off, I must as necessarily not believe and be damned; In vaine therefore doe I trouble my selfe about meanes, or end; as much as to say, about labouring and endeavouring for Faith, whereby I may avoyd damnation: And judge, I pray, whether there be one hayres breadth of difference, between these argumentations.
For like as it is unreasonable to conceive, that man is destined to recover out of sickness, but by use of means, such as is the use of a Physician; in like sort, as unreasonable it is to conceive, that God hath destined any man of ripe years to be brought to salvation, but by faith in Christ; or that God hath appointed any man to be damned, but for want of faith, or want of repentance. Observe I pray the censure that is passed upon it in Cicero, Rectè hoc genus interrogationis ignavum atque iners nominatur, quod eadem ratione, omnis è vita tollitur actio. And farther he showeth how that the same argument, if there were any force in it, might have place, without all mention of Fate. Licet etiam immutare (saith he,) ut Fati nomen non adjunges, & eandem tamen teneas sententiam hoc modo, si ex eternitate verum hoc fuit, ex iste morbo convalesces, sive adhibueris medicum sive non, convalesces. Itemque si ex aeternitate ⟨p. 254⟩hoc falsum fuerit, ex isto morbo convalesces, sive adhibuer is medicum, sive non adhibuer is, non convalesces; deinde caetera. In the next place there it is showed how Chrysippus made answer to this argument. Haecratio a Crysipo reprehenditur: Quaedam enim sunt (inquit) in rebus simplicia, quaedam copulata: simplex est moretur eo die Socrates, Hinc sive quid fecerit, sive non fecerit, finitus est moriendi dies. At si ita fatum sit, Nascetur Oedipus Laio, non poterit dici, sive Laius fuerit cum muliere, sive non fuerit. Copulata enim res est & confatalis; sic enim appellat qui a ita fatum sit, & concubiturum cum Uxore Laium & ex eo Oedipum procreaturum. Then he illustrateth the absurdity of the deduction in another manner thus, Ut si esset dictum, luctabitur Olympiis Milo, & referret aliquis, Ergo sive habuerit adversarium sive non habuerit, luctabitur, erraret. Est enim copulatum, luctabitur, quia sine adversario nulla luctatio est. And he concludes all of this kind to be but captious argumentations, and that they admit the same solution. Omnes igitur istius generis captions, eodem modo refelluntur. Sive tu medicum adhibueris, sive non adhibueris, captiosum: tam enim fatale est medicum adhibere quam convalescere. Haec, ut dixi, confatalia ille appellat.
For like as it is unreasonable to conceive, that man is destined to recover out of sicknesse, but by use of meanes, such as is the use of a Physitian; in like sort, as unreasonable it is to conceive, that God hath destined any man of ripe yeares to be brought to salvation, but by faith in Christ; or that God hath appoynted any man to be damned, but for want of faith, or want of repentance. Observe I pray the censure that is passed upon it in Cicero, Rectè hoc genus interrogationis ignavum atque iners nominatur, quod eadem ratione, omnis è vita tollitur actio. And farther he sheweth how that the same argument, if there were any force in it, might have place, without all mention of Fate. Licet etiam immutare (saith he,) ut Fati nomen non adjunges, & eandem tamen teneas sententiam hoc modo, si ex eternitate verum hoc fuit, ex iste morbo convalesces, sive adhibueris medicum sive non, convalesces. Itemque si ex aeternitate ⟨p. 254⟩hoc falsum fuerit, ex isto morbo convalesces, sive adhibuer is medicum, sive non adhibuer is, non convalesces; deinde caetera. In the next place there it is shewed how Chrysippus made answer to this argument. Haecratio a Crysipo reprehenditur: Quaedam enim sunt (inquit) in rebus simplicia, quaedam copulata: simplex est moretur eo die Socrates, Hinc sive quid fecerit, sive non fecerit, finitus est moriendi dies. At si ita fatum sit, Nascetur Oedipus Laio, non poterit dici, sive Laius fuerit cum muliere, sive non fuerit. Copulata enim res est & confatalis; sic enim appellat qui a ita fatum sit, & concubiturum cum Uxore Laium & ex eo Oedipum procreaturum. Then he illustrateth the absurdity of the deduction in another manner thus, Ut si esset dictum, luctabitur Olympiis Milo, & referret aliquis, Ergo sive habuerit adversarium sive non habuerit, luctabitur, erraret. Est enim copulatum, luctabitur, quia sine adversario nulla luctatio est. And he concludes all of this kind to be but captious argumentations, and that they admit the same solution. Omnes igitur istius generis captiones, eodem modo refelluntur. Sive tu medicum adhibueris, sive non adhibueris, captiosum: tam enim fatale est medicum adhibere quam convalescere. Haec, ut dixi, confatalia ille appellat.
And this manner of solution was so sufficient, that Carneades disdained to press the Stoics with this kind of argumentation, though opposite enough to their opinion, as forthwith Cicero expresseth it. Carneades hoc totum genus non probabat, & minùs inconsiderate concludi hanc rationem putabat: itaque premebat alio modo, nec ullam adhibebat calumniam. So that he condemned this as a calumnious argumentation against the Stoics, though himself were a sore adversary of theirs.
And this manner of solution was so sufficient, that Carneades disdained to presse the Stoicks with this kind of argumentation, though opposite enough to their opinion, as forthwith Cicero expresseth it. Carneades hoc totum genus non probabat, & minùs inconsiderate concludi hanc rationem putabat: itaque premebat alio modo, nec ullam adhibebat calumniam. So that he condemned this as a calumnious argumentation against the Stoicks, though himselfe were a sore adversary of theirs.