THE COMMON PLACE OF THE TWO NATURES IN CHRIST.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 14 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 14 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1The perfect fulfilling of the law performed by Christ for us, is made ours, or applied unto us, through the alone and free mercy of God, as who from everlasting did predestinate us to this grace, and freely chose us in Christ, to whom he might apply, of his mere grace of faith, that justice and righteousness at his appointed time, according to the good pleasure of his will, as the Apostle speaketh: that is, according to his mere good pleasure, not being moved with any holiness which he foresaw ⟨p. 385⟩would be in us. The reason is, because there can be no good thing in us, except God first work in us. Wherefore all imagination and affirmation of merit is to be taken away, as which fighteth with the grace of God, and is a denial of his divine grace: For the grace and mercy of God is the only cause of both applications. He of his goodness, infinite and passing measure, applieth Christs merit unto us, and maketh that we also may apply the same unto us. The cause therefore why this application is wrought, is in God alone; but not at all in us, that is, it is neither any thing foreseen in us, neither also our apprehension and receiving of this justice; for all the gifts and graces which are in us, are effects of the application of Christs merit: and therefore that merit of Christ is no way applied unto us for the works sake which we do; but this is done, as the Apostle teacheth,2 According to the good pleasure of his will. Whereupon also it is said, What hast thou that thou hast not received? 3By grace are ye saved through faith, and that not of your selves; it is the gift of God.4
1THe perfect fulfilling of the law performed by Christ for us, is made ours, or applyed unto us, through the alone and free mercy of God, as who from everlasting did predestinate us to this grace, and freely chose us in Christ, to whom he might apply, of his meere grace of faith, that justice and righteousnesse at his appointed time, according to the good pleasure of his will, as the Apostle speaketh: that is, according to his meere good pleasure, not being moved with any holinesse which hee foresaw ⟨p. 385⟩would be in us. The reason is, because there can be no good thing in us, except God first worke in us. Wherefore all imagination and affirmation of merit is to be taken away, as which fighteth with the grace of God, and is a deniall of his divine grace: For the grace and mercy of God is the only cause of both applications. He of his goodnes, infinite and passing measure, applyeth Christs merit unto us, and maketh that we also may apply the same unto us. The cause therefore why this application is wrought, is in God alone; but not at all in us, that is, it is neither any thing foreseen in us, neither also our apprehension and receiving of this justice; for all the gifts and graces which are in us, are effects of the application of Christs merit: and therefore that merit of Christ is no way applied unto us for the works sake which wee doe; but this is done, as the Apostle teacheth,2 According to the good pleasure of his will. Whereupon also it is said, What hast thou that thou hast not received? 3By grace are yee saved through faith, and that not of your selves; it is the gift of God.4
Christ is then in respect of our justification, 1. As the subject and matter wherein our justice is. 2. As the impellent cause, because he obtaineth it. 3. As the chief efficient, because he together with his Father doth justify us, and giveth us faith, whereby we believe and apprehend it. The mercy of God is as the impellent cause thereof in God: Christs satisfaction is the formal cause of our justification, giving the very life and being unto it: Our faith is the instrumental cause, apprehending and applying unto us the justice or righteousness of Christ. We must note therefore,1 that we are justified by the grace of God, by the merit of Christ, and by faith, but by each of these in a several sense and meaning. The first position is understood of the impulsive cause, which is in God: the second of the formal cause, in Christ: the third of the instrumental cause, in us. We are justified by the mercy or grace of God, as a principal impellent cause, wherewith God being urged and moved, justifieth and saveth us. We are justified by the merit of Christ, partly as by the formal cause of our justification, inasmuch as by Christs obedience applied unto us, we are accepted of God, and being clothed as it were with this raiment, are reputed just: partly as by an impulsive and meritorious cause, inasmuch as God absolveth us for his sake. We are justified by faith, as by an instrumental cause, whereby we apprehend Christs righteousness imputed unto us.
Christ is then in respect of our justification, 1. As the subject and matter wherein our justice is. 2. As the impellent cause, because he obtaineth it. 3. As the chief efficient, because he together with his Father doth justifie us, and giveth us faith, whereby wee beleeve and apprehend it. The mercy of God is as the impellent cause thereof in God: Christs satisfaction is the formall cause of our justification, giving the very life and being unto it: Our faith is the instrumentall cause, apprehending and applying unto us the justice or righteousnesse of Christ. We must note therefore,1 that we are justified by the grace of God, by the merit of Christ, and by faith, but by each of these in a severall sense and meaning. The first position is understood of the impulsive cause, which is in God: the second of the formall cause, in Christ: the third of the instrumentall cause, in us. We are justified by the mercy or grace of God, as a principall impellent cause, wherewith God being urged and moved, justifieth and saveth us. We are justified by the merit of Christ, partly as by the formall cause of our justification, inasmuch as by Christs obedience applied unto us, we are accepted of God, and being clothed as it were with this raiment, are reputed just: partly as by an impulsive and meritorious cause, inasmuch as God absolveth us for his sake. Wee are justified by faith, as by an instrumentall cause, whereby we apprehend Christs righteousnesse imputed unto us.
The common received opinion saith; We are justified by faith correlatively: that is, we are justified by that whereunto faith hath relation, to wit, the merit of Christ, which faith apprehendeth: For faith, and the satisfaction of Christ, are correlatives, that is, have a mutual respect each to other; the one being that which receiveth, and the other that which is received. This kind of speech is well and probably used; because hereby faith is understood of the formal cause of justification, that so the sense may be; Christs merit justifieth us, and not faith it self: that which is apprehended doth justify us, and not the instrument which doth apprehend. Nevertheless, this proposition, We are justified by faith, may be understood also without relation, to wit, we are justified by faith, as a mean. But this proposition of the Apostle, Faith was imputed to him for righteousness, and other the like,1 are necessarily to be understood with a relation to Christs merit and justice. Faith was imputed unto him for righteousness, as faith is the apprehending instrument of righteousness apprehended; faith being as it were the hand, wherewith the justice of Christ is received.
The common received opinion saith; We are justified by faith correlatively: that is, we are justified by that whereunto faith hath relation, to wit, the merit of Christ, which faith apprehendeth: For faith, and the satisfaction of Christ, are correlatives, that is, have a mutuall respect each to other; the one being that which receiveth, and the other that which is received. This kind of speech is well and probably used; because hereby faith is understood of the formall cause of justification, that so the sense may be; Christs merit justifieth us, and not faith it selfe: that which is apprehended doth justifie us, and not the instrument which doth apprehend. Neverthelesse, this proposition, We are justified by faith, may be understood also without relation, to wit, we are justified by faith, as a meane. But this proposition of the Apostle, Faith was imputed to him for righteousnesse, and other the like,1 are necessarily to be understood with a relation to Christs merit and justice. Faith was imputed unto him for righteousnesse, as faith is the apprehending instrument of righteousnesse apprehended; faith being as it were the hand, wherewith the justice of Christ is received.
Answ. Not for that I please God through the worthiness of mere faith; but because only the satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ is my righteousness before Goda: and I cannot take hold of it, or apply it unto my self and other way than by faithb
Answ. Not for that I please God through the worthinesse of meere faith; but because onely the satisfaction, righteousnesse, and holinesse of Christ is my righteousnesse before Goda: and I cannot take hold of it, or apply it unto my selfe and other way than by faithb
1WE say, we are justified by faith alone: §11. Because we are justified by the object of faith only, to wit, by the merit of Christ, alone, besides which, there is no justice of ours, nor any part thereof. For we are justified freely for Christs sake, without works. There is nothing which can be our justice and righteousness before God, either in whole, or in part, besides Christs merit: only by receiving and believing another's justice we are justified; not by working, nor by meriting, but by an apprehension and acceptation only we are just and righteous. All works are excluded, yea faith it self as it is a virtue or work. §22. Because the proper act and operation of faith is, for a man to apprehend and apply unto himself Christs righteousness: yea, faith is nothing else than the acceptation it self, or apprehension of another's justice, or, of the merit of Christ. §33. Because faith only is the instrument, which apprehendeth Christs satisfaction. Hence it is evident, for what causes we are to retain the exclusive particle Only, 2and to maintain it against the Papists: namely, 1. For declaration of that which Paul speaketh, We are justified freely by grace, without works: likewise of that which Christ saith, Only believe. 2. That whatsoever works and merits of ours, or of others, may be excluded from being causes of justification; and faith may be understood only with relation and respect to Christs merit, which is our justice. 3. That not only our merits, but even faith it self may be wholly excluded from that which is received by faith: and the sense may be, we are justified by faith alone, that is, not by meriting, but only by receiving: as when we say; This poor man is enriched only by receiving the alms of charitable disposed people: where all works and merits, yea, the very receiving of alms (if it be considered as a merit) are excluded. Therefore Paul saith always, that we are justifieda by faith, andb through faith, as by an instrument; but no where faith,c
For, if for faith we were just and righteous, then faith were now no longer an acceptation of another's righteousness, but were a merit and cause of our own justice; neither should it receive another's satisfaction, which now it should have no need of. 4. That we may know what necessity there is of faith unto justification, and may understand, that we are not justified by the merit of faith, and yet are not justified without faith apprehending the justice of Christ; because it is the proper act of faith, to lay hold on his righteousness. 5. The Orthodoxall or right believing Fathers oft-times urge the exclusive particle,1 by faith only. Origen: The Apostle saith that the justification of faith only is sufficient; so that if a man believe only, he may be justified; yea, though he perform no work. Ambrose: They are justified freely, who working nothing, and rendering no recompense, are justified by faith only through the gift of God. Again Ambrose: How then may the Jews think themselves to be justified by the works of the law, with the justification of Abraham, where they see that Abraham was not justified by the works of the law, but by faith only? The law therefore needeth not, when a sinner is justified before God by faith only. 2And, in the same place, the exclusive particle Only is often reiterated. The same Ambrose saith: Because this is decreed by God, that he which believeth in Christ should be saved without any work▪ receiving freely by faith only remission of sins. We are therefore justified by faith only, that is, by Christs merit only received by faith: This we must constantly maintain and defend, 1. For Gods glory, that Christs sacrifice be not extenuated. 2. For our own comfort, that we may be assured, that our righteousness dependeth not on our works (for so should we lose it many thousand times) but only on the sacrifice and merit of Christ.
For, if for faith we were just and righteous, then faith were now no longer an acceptation of anothers righteousnesse, but were a merit and cause of our own justice; neither should it receive anothers satisfaction, which now it should have no need of. 4. That we may know what necessity there is of faith unto justification, and may understand, that we are not justified by the merit of faith, and yet are not justified without faith apprehending the justice of Christ; because it is the proper act of faith, to lay hold on his righteousnesse. 5. The Orthodoxall or right beleeving Fathers oft-times urge the exclusive particle,
Ans. Because that righteousness, which must stand fast before the judgement of God, must be in all points perfect and agreeable to the law of Goda Now our works, even the best of them, are imperfect in this life, and defiled with sinb.
Ans. Because that righteousnesse, which must stand fast before the judgement of God, must be in all points perfect and agreeable to the law of Goda Now our workes, even the best of them, are imperfect in this life, and defiled with sinb.
IN the former Questions the true doctrine of Justification hath been made manifest and confirmed. It followeth that we proceed to the confutation of the Popish doctrine, affirming that we are justified by works, or, partly by faith, and partly by works. The argument is thus framed: The justice which may stand in Gods judgement must be perfectly absolute, and agreeable on all parts with Gods Law. But our very best works in this life are imperfect, and stained with sin: Therefore our very best works cannot be our justice in the judgment of God, neither in part nor wholly. The Major of this Syllogism is evidently proved out of the law: He that doth these things, shall live in them. Cursed is every one, which abideth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them. The Minor is out of doubt:1 seeing we do many evil things, which we ought to leave undone; and we leave many good works undone, which we should do: yea, we mingle much evil with that good we do, that is, we do it amiss. The complaints and daily prayers of Saints are witness hereof: Forgive us our sins. Enter not into judgment with thy servant. Wherefore imperfect works can make no perfect righteousness.2 This is the first cause why we cannot be justified by our works; namely,3 §11. Because our justice should by this means be imperfect, seeing our works are imperfect. Many other causes there are: For, §22. Though our works were perfect, yet are they due debt, so that by them we cannot acquit our sins that are past. When ye have done all those things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that which was our duty to do. §33. They are none of ours but Gods▪ who worketh them in us. §44. They are temporary, and have no proportion with eternal rewards: 4whereas between a merit and reward there must be some proportion. §5
Answ. That reward is not given of merit, but of gracea.
IN this Question is contained a prevention of an argument of the Papists, brought for justification before God for our works and merits. Obj. 1. Reward presupposeth merit; so that where reward is, there is also merit: for Reward and Merit are correlatives; whereof if one be put, the other is put also. But everlasting life is proposed as a reward for good works: Therefore also the merit of good works is everlasting life. Answ. The Major is sometimes ⟨p. 388⟩true as concerning creatures, as when men may merit or deserve of men. But neither always among men doth it follow that there is merit where there is reward: for men also oftentimes give rewards not of merit or desert. Now it is unproperly said of God, that he proposeth eternal life unto our works as a reward: for we can merit nothing at Gods hand by our works. Or if they thus press and urge their reason: Object. That is a merit whereunto a reward appertaineth: But a reward appertaineth to good works: Therefore by order of justice good works are merits. Answ. That is a merit whereunto a reward appertaineth by force of covenant or bond. But the reward of good works is of grace. In reward two things are to be considered: 1. Obligation, or binding. 2. Compensation, or recompensing. Here is no obligation, but compensation followeth works through grace. There is therefore a reward of works, because compensation followeth them; and God for this cause especially promiseth to reward our works: 1. To testify unto us, that good works please him. 12. To teach us that eternal life is proposed only to them that strive and labour painfully. 3. Because he will as surely give us a reward, as if we had deserved it. Hither may be referred all such like arguments of the Papists, whereby they labour to establish the merit of works.
IN this Question is contained a prevention of an argument of the Papists, brought for justification before God for our workes and merits. Obj. 1. Reward presupposeth merit; so that where reward is, there is also merit: for Reward and Merit are correlatives; whereof if one be put, the other is put also. But everlasting life is proposed as a reward for good workes: Therefore also the merit of good workes is everlasting life. Answ. The Major is sometimes ⟨p. 388⟩true as concerning creatures, as when men may merit or deserve of men. But neither alwaies among men doth it follow that there is merit where there is reward: for men also oftentimes give rewards not of merit or desert. Now it is unproperly said of God, that he proposeth eternall life unto our works as a reward: for we can merit nothing at Gods hand by our works. Or if they thus presse and urge their reason: Object. That is a merit whereunto a reward appertaineth: But a reward appertaineth to good workes: Therefore by order of justice good workes are merits. Answ. That is a merit whereunto a reward appertaineth by force of covenant or bond. But the reward of good works is of grace. In reward two things are to be considered: 1. Obligation, or binding. 2. Compensation, or recompensing. Here is no obligation, but compensation followeth works through grace. There is therefore a reward of workes, because compensation followeth them; and God for this cause especially promiseth to reward our workes: 1. To testifie unto us, that good workes please him.
Object. 2. We are justified by faith. Faith is a work: Therefore we are justified by works. Ans. 1. The consequence of this reason is denied, because more is in the conclusion than in the premisses: of which premisses this only followeth; Therefore we are justified by that work: which we grant, to wit, as by an instrument or mean, not as any impellent cause, as themselves understand it: for we are justified by faith, as by a mean of attaining our justification: and we are not justified for faith, that is for the merit of faith. 2. The kind of affirmation is diverse: For in the Major, faith is understood with relation to Christs merit, in the Minor it is taken absolutely and properly.
Object. 2. Wee are justified by faith. Faith is a worke: Therefore wee are justified by workes. Ans. 1. The consequence of this reason is denied, because more is in the conclusion than in the premisses: of which premisses this onely followeth; Therefore wee are justified by that worke: which wee grant, to wit, as by an instrument or meane, not as any impellent cause, as themselves understand it: for wee are justified by faith, as by a meane of attaining our justification: and wee are not justified for faith, that is for the merit of faith. 2. The kind of affirmation is diverse: For in the Major, faith is understood with relation to Christs merit, in the Minor it is taken absolutely and properly.
Object. 3. Our justice is that whereby we are formally or essentially just: Therefore we are by faith formally and essentially just. Answ. The consequence of this reason is to be denied, because the kind of affirmation is diverse. For the Major is meant properly, but the Minor correlatively, and figuratively, *else it were false: For properly, not faith, but the correlative object of faith, namely, Christs merit (which faith beholdeth, and applieth to it self) is our justice. 2. Either there are four terms in this Syllogism, because the Major treateth of Legal justice, the Minor of Evangelical: or else the Major is false: For Evangelical justice is not formally in us, as whiteness is in a wall; but is without us, even in Christ, and is made ours by imputation and application through faith.
Object. 3. Our justice is that whereby wee are formally or essentially just: Therefore wee are by faith formally and essentially just. Answ. The consequence of this reason is to be denied, because the kinde of affirmation is diverse. For the Major is meant properly, but the Minor correlatively, and figuratively, *else it were false: For properly, not faith, but the correlative object of faith, namely, Christs merit (which faith beholdeth, and applieth to it selfe) is our justice. 2. Either there are foure termes in this Syllogisme, because the Major treateth of Legall justice, the Minor of Evangelicall: or else the Major is false: For Evangelicall justice is not formally in us, as whiteness is in a wall; but is without us, even in Christ, and is made ours by imputation and application through faith.
Object. 4. That which is imputed unto us for righteousness, for it we are righteous. Faith is imputed to us for righteousness, as Paul saith: Therefore, For faith we are righteous, and not only By faith. Ans. Again, the kind of affirmation is, of proper in the Major proposition, made figurative in the Minor. The Major is true of that which is properly and by it self imputed for righteousness: The Minor is true of that which is correlatively imputed for righteousness, because, by faith is correlatively understood the object of faith, unto which faith hath relation; for Christs merit, which is apprehended by faith, is properly our justice, and the formal cause of our justice. The efficient of our justice is God, applying that merit of Christ unto us. The instrument all cause of our justice is faith: And therefore this proposition, we are justified by faith, being Legally understood with the Papists, is not true, but blasphemous: but being taken correlatively, that is, Evangelically, with relation to Christs merit, it is true: For the correlative of faith is the merit of Christ, which faith also as a joint Relative or correlative respecteth, and as an instrument apprehendeth.
Object. 4. That which is imputed unto us for righteousnesse, for it we are righteous. Faith is imputed to us for righteousnesse, as Paul saith: Therefore, For faith we are righteous, and not only By faith. Ans. Againe, the kind of affirmation is, of proper in the Major proposition, made figurative in the Minor. The Major is true of that which is properly and by it selfe imputed for righteousnesse: The Minor is true of that which is correlatively imputed for righteousnesse, because, by faith is correlatively understood the object of faith, unto which faith hath relation; for Christs merit, which is apprehended by faith, is properly our justice, and the formall cause of our justice. The efficient of our justice is God, applying that merit of Christ unto us. The instrument all cause of our justice is faith: And therefore this proposition, we are justified by faith, being Legally understood with the Papists, is not true, but blasphemous: but being taken correlatively, that is, Evangelically, with relation to Christs merit, it is true: For the correlative of faith is the merit of Christ, which faith also as a joynt Relative or correlative respecteth, and as an instrument apprehendeth.
Object. 5. Evil works condemn: Therefore good works justify. Ans. 1. These contraries are not matches: For our evil works are perfectly evil; our good works are imperfectly good. 2. Although our good works were perfectly good, yet should they not deserve eternal life, because they are debts. Unto evil works a reward is due by order of justice: unto good works not so, because we are obliged and bound to do them: For the creature is obliged to his Creator, neither may ⟨p. 389⟩he of the contrary bind God unto him by any works or means to benefit him. And evil works in their very intent despite God; but good works yield him no profit or delight.
Object. 5. Evill workes condemne: Therefore good workes justifie. Ans. 1. These contraries are not matches: For our evill workes are perfectly evill; our good workes are imperfectly good. 2. Although our good workes were perfectly good, yet should they not deserve eternall life, because they are debts. Unto evill workes a reward is due by order of justice: unto good works not so, because wee are obliged and bound to do them: For the creature is obliged to his Creator, neither may ⟨p. 389⟩hee of the contrary binde God unto him by any workes or meanes to benefit him. And evill workes in their very intent despight God; but good works yield him no profit or delight.
Object. 6. He that doth righteousness, is righteous: Therefore not he that believeth. Answ. 1. He is righteous before men: that is, by doing righteousness,1 he declareth himself righteous to others: but before God we are righteous, not by doing righteousness, but by believing: as it is written;2 By the works of the Law shall no flesh be justified in his sight. 2. John showeth there, not how we are righteous, but what the righteous are: as if he should say, that he that is regenerated, is also justified; because, by doing righteousness, he testifieth to the world that he is justified; So then in this reason, the fallacy is a taking that which is no cause of justification, instead of the true cause thereof.
Object. 6. Hee that doth righteousnesse, is righteous: Therefore not hee that beleeveth. Answ. 1. Hee is righteous before men: that is, by doing righteousnesse,1 hee declareth himselfe righteous to others: but before God wee are righteous, not by doing righteousnesse, but by beleeving: as it is written;2 By the workes of the Law shall no flesh be justified in his sight. 2. John sheweth there, not how wee are righteous, but what the righteous are: as if he should say, that he that is regenerated, is also justified; because, by doing righteousnesse, he testifieth to the world that he is justified; So then in this reason, the fallacy is a taking that which is no cause of justification, instead of the true cause thereof.
Object. 7. Christ saith, Many sins are forgiven her, because she loved much: 1Therefore good works are the cause of justification. Ans. 1. Christ here reasoneth from the latter to the former; from the effect which cometh after, to the cause which goeth before. In that the woman loved Christ much, Christ thence gathereth that many sins were forgiven her: and because there was a great feeling in that woman of the benefit, it must needs therefore be that the benefit is great, and many sins are forgiven her. That this is the meaning of Christs words, appeareth by the parable which he there useth. 2. Not every thing that is the cause of Consequence in reason, is also the cause of the Consequent, or thing it self which followeth in that consequence of reason. Wherefore it is a fallacy of the Consequent, if it be concluded, Therefore for her love many sins are forgiven her: For the particle (because) which Christ useth, doth no• always signify the cause of the thing following. It followeth not, The Sun is risen because it is day: Therefore the day is the cause of the rising of the Sun. The contrary rather is true.
Object. 7. Christ saith, Many sins are forgiven her, because shee loved much: 1Therefore good workes are the cause of justification. Ans. 1. Christ here reasoneth from the latter to the former; from the effect which cometh after, to the cause which goeth before. In that the woman loved Christ much, Christ thence gathereth that many sins were forgiven her: and because there was a great feeling in that woman of the benefit, it must needs therefore be that the benefit is great, and many sins are forgiven her. That this is the meaning of Christs words, appeareth by the parable which he there useth. 2. Not every thing that is the cause of Consequence in reason, is also the cause of the Consequent, or thing it selfe which followeth in that consequence of reason. Wherefore it is a fallacy of the Consequent, if it be concluded, Therefore for her love many sins are forgiven her: For the particle (because) which Christ useth, doth no• alwaies signifie the cause of the thing following. It followeth not, The Sun is risen because it is day: Therefore the day is the cause of the rising of the Sun. The contrary rather is true.
This Question of the Catechism is a prevention of the Papists slander against the doctrine of Justification by faith. Ob. 1. Doctrine which maketh men secure and profane is not true, and therefore not to be delivered. But this doctrine of free justification by faith, maketh men secure and profane: Therefore it is not true, nor to be taught or delivered in the Church. Ans. Here is a fallacy of accident. If the doctrine of free justification by faith make men secure, this happeneth by accident. The natural effect of this doctrine, is an earnest desire of showing our thankfulness towards God. But this accident, objected by the adversaries of this truth falleth out, not because men do apply, but because men do not apply to themselves the doctrine of grace. Repl. 1. Even those things which fall out to be evil by an accident, are to be eschewed. But this doctrine maketh men by an accident evil: Therefore it is to be eschewed. Ans. Those things which fall out to be evils by an accident, are to be eschewed, if there remain no greater and weightier cause for which they are not to be omitted, which become evil to men through their own default. But we have necessary and weighty cause why this doctrine ought to be delivered, and by no means to be omitted: namely, the commandment and glory of God, and the salvation of the Elect. Repl. 2. That which cannot hart, we need not to eschew. But according to the doctrine of justification by faith, sins to come cannot hurt us: (because Christ hath satisfied for all, both which are past, and which are to come.) Therefore we need not to beware of sins to come. Now this is apparently absurd: Therefore the doctrine, whence this Consequent ariseth, is likewise absurd. ⟨p. 390⟩Ans. 1. We answer to the Major of this reason, that we need not beware and take heed of that which cannot hurt, namely, whether it be taken heed of, or no. But sins to come hurt not, that is, hurt not them which are heedful and penitent; yet they hurt them who are careless and unrepentant. 2. Therefore we also deny the Minor: for God is always offended with sins, and his displeasure is the greatest hurt that can befall man. Further, sins bereave us of conformity with God, and purchase bodily pains unto the faithful, howsoever eternal pains be remitted unto them.
THis Question of the Catechisme is a prevention of the Papists slander against the doctrine of Justification by faith. Ob. 1. Doctrine which maketh men secure and profane is not true, and therefore not to be delivered. But this doctrine of free justification by faith, maketh men secure and profane: Therefore it is not true, nor to be taught or delivered in the Church. Ans. Here is a fallacy of accident. If the doctrine of free justification by faith make men secure, this happeneth by accident. The naturall effect of this doctrine, is an earnest desire of shewing our thankfulnesse towards God. But this accident, objected by the adversaries of this truth falleth out, not because men doe apply, but because men doe not apply to themselves the doctrine of grace. Repl. 1. Even those things which fall out to be evill by an accident, are to be eschewed. But this doctrine maketh men by an accident evill: Therefore it is to be eschewed. Ans. Those things which fall out to be evils by an accident, are to be eschewed, if there remaine no greater and weightier cause for which they are not to be omitted, which become evill to men through their owne default. But wee have necessarie and weighty cause why this doctrine ought to be delivered, and by no meanes to be omitted: namely, the commandement and glory of God, and the salvation of the Elect. Repl. 2. That which cannot hart, wee need not to eschew. But according to the doctrine of justification by faith, sinnes to come cannot hurt us: (because Christ hath satisfied for all, both which are past, and which are to come.) Therefore wee need not to beware of sinnes to come. Now this is apparently absurd: Therefore the doctrine, whence this Consequent ariseth, is likewise absurd.
Hither belong other arguments of the Papists, wherewith they oppugn this doctrine of Justification by faith: such as are these following;
Hither belong other arguments of the Papists, wherewith they oppugne this doctrine of Justification by faith: such as are these following;
Object. 2. That which is not in the Scripture, is not to be taught or retained. That we are justified by faith only is not in the Scripture: Therefore it is not to be retained. Ans. To the Major we say, that which is not in the Scripture, neither in words▪ nor in sense, is not to be retained: But, that we are justified by faith only, is contained in Scripture, as touching the sense thereof; for we are said to be justified freely by grace, without the works of the law, 1without the law, not of works, not of our selves, not of any righteousness which we have done; by faith without merit. Also the blood of Christ is said to cleanse us from all sin: And these are all one, To be justified by faith alone, and, To be justified by the blood and merit of Christ apprehended by faith, only by receiving and believing, deserving nothing by faith, or other works. Now the reasons why we are to retain against the Papists the exclusive particle [only] have been heretofore declared and enlarged.
Object. 2. That which is not in the Scripture, is not to be taught or retained. That wee are justified by faith only is not in the Scripture: Therefore it is not to be retained. Ans. To the Major we say, that which is not in the Scripture, neither in words▪ nor in sense, is not to be retained: But, that we are justified by faith only, is contained in Scripture, as touching the sense thereof; for we are said to be justified freely by grace, without the works of the law, 1without the law, not of works, not of our selves, not of any righteousnesse which wee have done; by faith without merit. Also the bloud of Christ is said to cleanse us from all sin: And these are all one, To be justified by faith alone, and, To be justified by the bloud and merit of Christ apprehended by faith, only by receiving and beleeving, deserving nothing by faith, or other works. Now the reasons why we are to retain against the Papists the exclusive particle [only] have been heretofore declared and inlarged.
Object. 3. That which is not alone, doth not justify alone. Faith is not alone: Therefore faith doth not justify alone. Ans. If the conclusion be so understood, as it followeth out of the premisses, on this wise; Faith therefore doth not justify alone, that is, being alone; the argument is of force: For justifying faith is never alone, without works as her effects. Faith justifieth alone, but is not alone when it justifieth; having works accompanying it, as effects of it, but not as joint causes with it of justification. But if it be thus understood, Therefore faith alone doth not justify, meaning, that it hath not alone the act of justifying, which is the apprehending of Christs justice; then either the conclusion containeth more than the premisses enforce, or the Major is evidently false: For I alone may speak in a hot-house, and yet not be alone there. A thing may be not alone, but joined with others, and yet may alone have this, or that act. For example; The will is not alone, but joined with the understanding: yet it willeth alone. A mans soul is not alone, but joined with the body; yet it understandeth alone. It is commonly, and that rightly, called a fallacy of Composition, the reason being deceitfully composed. For the word, alone, is composed and joined in the conclusion with the Predicate, which is the word justify, but in the premisses it is joined with the Verb, is.
Object. 3. That which is not alone, doth not justifie alone. Faith is not alone: Therefore faith doth not justifie alone. Ans. If the conclusion be so understood, as it followeth out of the premisses, on this wise; Faith therefore doth not justifie alone, that is, being alone; the argument is of force: For justifying faith is never alone, without works as her effects. Faith justifieth alone, but is not alone when it justifieth; having works accompanying it, as effects of it, but not as joynt causes with it of justification. But if it be thus understood, Therefore faith alone doth not justifie, meaning, that it hath not alone the act of justifying, which is the apprehending of Christs justice; then either the conclusion containeth more than the premisses enforce, or the Major is evidently false: For I alone may speak in a hot-house, and yet not be alone there. A thing may be not alone, but joyned with others, and yet may alone have this, or that act. For example; The will is not alone, but joyned with the understanding: yet it willeth alone. A mans soule is not alone, but joyned with the body; yet it understandeth alone. It is commonly, and that rightly, called a fallacy of Composition, the reason being deceitfully composed. For the word, alone, is composed and joyned in the conclusion with the Predicate, which is the word justifie, but in the premisses it is joyned with the Verb, is.
Object. 4. That which is required in those who are to be justified; without the same, faith doth not justify: Good works are required in those who are to be justified: Therefore without good works faith doth not justify: and so faith alone doth not justify. Ans. Here also is the same fallacy.1 For the particle without, is ambiguously and doubtfully taken. For in the Major it is taken thus: Faith without it, that is, being without it, doth not justify. For though it be not, or exist not alone, but is always united and coupled with charity, whereby it worketh: yet it justifieth alone, that is, it alone hath the act of embracing and applying to it self Christs merit. The Minor also of this objection is more at large to be explained, that it may the better be rightly conceived. In them who are to be justified faith and works are required, but not after the same manner. Faith with her proper work (without which it cannot be considered) is required as a necessary instrument, whereby we apply Christs merit unto us. But good works are not required, that by them we may apprehend Christs merit, and much less that for them we should be justified; but that by them we may show our faith, which without good works is dead, and is not known but by them: that is, good works are required as effects of faith, and, as it were a testimony of our thankfulness towards God. Whatsoever is necessarily co-herent with the cause, that is not therefore necessarily required to the producing of the proper effect of that cause. So good ⟨p. 391⟩works, although they are necessarily coherent and joined with faith, yet are they not necessary for the apprehension of Christs merit, that we should (over and besides faith) by them also apply the same unto us.
Object. 4. That which is required in those who are to be justified; without the same, faith doth not justifie: Good works are required in those who are to be justified: Therefore without good works faith doth not justifie: and so faith alone doth not justifie. Ans. Here also is the same fallacy.1 For the particle without, is ambiguously and doubtfully taken. For in the Major it is taken thus: Faith without it, that is, being without it, doth not justifie. For though it be not, or exist not alone, but is alwaies united and coupled with charity, whereby it worketh: yet it justifieth alone, that is, it alone hath the act of imbracing and applying to it selfe Christs merit. The Minor also of this objection is more at large to be explained, that it may the better be rightly conceived. In them who are to be justified faith and workes are required, but not after the same manner. Faith with her proper work (without which it cannot be considered) is required as a necessary instrument, whereby we apply Christs merit unto us. But good works are not required, that by them we may apprehend Christs merit, and much less that for them we should be justified; but that by them we may shew our faith, which without good works is dead, and is not known but by them: that is, good works are required as effects of faith, and, as it were a testimony of our thankfulnesse towards God. Whatsoever is necessarily co-herent with the cause, that is not therefore necessarily required to the producing of the proper effect of that cause. So good
Object. 5. Where moe things are required, there the exclusive particle (only) may not be used: In them that are to be justified, besides faith, good works are required: Therefore we cannot say that faith only justifieth. Answ. This argument is all one with the former, and therefore the answer unto it is the same. In them that are to be justified more things are required, but in a diverse manner: faith, as a mean or instrument apprehending another's justice; good works, as a testimony of our faith and thankfulness.
Object. 5. Where moe things are required, there the exclusive particle (onely) may not be used: In them that are to be justified, besides faith, good workes are required: Therefore we cannot say that faith onely justifieth. Answ. This argument is all one with the former, and therefore the answer unto it is the same. In them that are to be justified more things are required, but in a diverse manner: faith, as a meane or instrument apprehending anothers justice; good works, as a testimony of our faith and thankfulnesse.
Object. 6. He that is justified by two things, is not justified by one only: But we, besides that we are justified by faith, are justified by the merit and obedience of Christ: Therefore, not by faith only. Ans. Again we must yield the same answer. He that is justified by two things, is not justified by one only: that is, after one and the same manner. But we are justified by two things after a divers manner: For we are justified by faith, as by an instrument apprehending justice; but by the merit of Christ, as by the formal cause of our justice.
Object. 6. He that is justified by two things, is not justified by one only: But we, besides that we are justified by faith, are justified by the merit and obedience of Christ: Therefore, not by faith only. Ans. Againe we must yield the same answer. He that is justified by two things, is not justified by one only: that is, after one and the same manner. But we are justified by two things after a divers manner: For we are justified by faith, as by an instrument apprehending justice; but by the merit of Christ, as by the formall cause of our justice.
Object. 7. Knowledge doth not justify: Faith is a knowledge: therefore faith doth not justify Ans. Knowledge alone doth not justify: But justifying faith is not a knowledge only, but also a confidence and sure persuasion, whereby, as a mean, we apply Christs merit unto us. And furthermore, knowledge and this sure persuasion are much different. Knowledge is in the Understanding, but this is in the Will:1 Therefore a sure persuasion or confidence is not only a knowledge of a thing; but also a will and purpose of doing or applying that which we know, and of resting in it; so that we are thereby secure, and take joy of heart therein. So then, to believe in God, is not only to acknowledge God, but also to have confidence in him. Else the Devil also hath a knowledge of God, and of his promises, but without confidence: Therefore his knowledge is no justifying faith, but historical only, whereof S. James speaketh, saying: The Devils believe and tremble. 2Of such a faith we easily grant the Papists argument, but not of a true and justifying faith.
Object. 7. Knowledge doth not justifie: Faith is a knowledge: therefore faith doth not justifie Ans. Knowledge alone doth not justifie: But justifying faith is not a knowledge only, but also a confidence and sure perswasion, whereby, as a mean, we apply Christs merit unto us. And furthermore, knowledge and this sure perswasion are much different. Knowledge is in the Understanding, but this is in the Will:1 Therefore a sure perswasion or confidence is not only a knowledge of a thing; but also a will and purpose of doing or applying that which we know, and of resting in it; so that wee are thereby secure, and take joy of heart therein. So then, to beleeve in God, is not only to acknowledge God, but also to have confidence in him. Else the Divel also hath a knowledge of God, and of his promises, but without confidence: Therefore his knowledge is no justifying faith, but historicall only, whereof S. James speaketh, saying: The Divels beleeve and tremble. 2Of such a faith we easily grant the Papists argument, but not of a true and justifying faith.
Object. 8. S. James saith, Ye see then, how that of works a man is justified, and not of faith only: Therefore faith only justifieth not. 1Ans. There is a double ambiguity in the words: and first in the word justified. For S. Jam. speaketh not of that justice whereby we are justified before God; that is, whereby we are reputed of God just for unjust: but he speaketh of that justice, whereby through our works we are justified before men; that is, are approved just, or are found to be justified. This is proved, 1. Out of the 18. verse; Show me thy faith by thy works, and I will show thee my faith by my works. Show it me (saith he) to wit, who am a man. Wherefore, he speaketh of manifesting our faith and righteousness before men. 2. Out of the 21. verse; Was not Abraham our Father justified through works, when he offered his Son upon the altar? 2This cannot be understood of justification before God. For the story testifieth that Abraham was reputed just by God, long before the offering of his Son. And Paul saith: Abraham was justified before God, not by works, but by faith. S. James his meaning is, that Abraham was justified before God, because it is written: Abraham believed God, and it was imputed to him for righteousness: 3but by good works and obedience towards God, he witnessed his justice before men. This is the first ambiguity in the word justified. The second ambiguity is in the word faith: For S. James, when he taketh away justification of faith, speaketh not of a true or lively faith, as Paul doth; but of a dead faith, which is a bare knowledge without confidence or works. This appeareth in those words: Even so faith, if it have not works, is dead in it self: and such faith he ascribeth to devils, who, questionless, have not true justifying faith. Lastly, in the 16. ver. he compareth that faith which he denieth to justify, with a dead body: but such is not true and justifying faith. The sum of all is: If the word justified in this text of James be understood properly of justification before God, then the name of faith there signifieth a dead faith: If faith be taken for true justifying faith, then the ambiguity rests in the word justified.
Object. 8. S. James saith, Yee see then, how that of works a man is justified, and not of faith only: Therefore faith only justifieth not.
Object. 9. That which is not required unto justification, is not necessary to be done: but it is necessary that good works be done: Therefore they are required to justification. Ans. The Major is false, because there may be many ends of one thing. Though good works are not required to justification: yet they are required in token of thankfulness, and to the setting forth of Gods glory: As it is said, Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, 1and glorify your Father which is in heaven. For this cause good works are necessary to be done. More causes of them shall hereafter, in the doctrine of mans thankfulness, be alleged and declared.
Object. 9. That which is not required unto justification, is not necessary to be done: but it is necessary that good works be done: Therefore they are required to justification. Ans. The Major is false, because there may be many ends of one thing. Though good works are not required to justification: yet they are required in token of thankfulnesse, and to the setting forth of Gods glory: As it is said, Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, 1and glorifie your Father which is in heaven. For this cause good works are necessary to be done. More causes of them shall hereafter, in the doctrine of mans thankfulnesse, be alledged and declared.
Obj. 10. It is said that Phinehas work and deed was imputed unto him for righteousness: Therefore good works justify: 1Ans. This is a mis-construing of the phrase used in the place alleged. For the meaning of it is, that God approved of this work, but not that he was justified by that work:2 For, by the works of the law shall no flesh be justified in his sight.
Obj. 10. It is said that Phinees work and deed was imputed unto him for righteousnesse: Therefore good works justifie: 1Ans. This is a mis-construing of the phrase used in the place alledged. For the meaning of it is, that God approved of this work, but not that he was justified by that work:2 For, by the works of the law flall no flesh be justified in his sight.
Object. 11. Ten crowns are part of an hundred crowns in payment of a debt: Therefore good works may be some part of our justice before God. Ans. There is a dissimilitude in these examples: For, 1. Ten crowns are a whole part of an hundred crowns, and being ten times multiplied make up the whole sum of the debt: but our works are not a whole and perfect part, but an imperfect part of the obedience we owe; and being multiplied an hundred thousand times, yet never make any perfect obedience. 2. Ten Crowns may be accepted by the Creditor for a part of the debt due unto him, because there may be some hope of payment of the rest: but good works are not accepted by God as a part of our justice, because there is no hope of full payment to be made by us; and all imperfection or defect is condemned by the law.
Object. 11. Ten crownes are part of an hundred crownes in payment of a debt: Therefore good works may be some part of our justice before God. Ans. There is a dissimilitude in these examples: For, 1. Ten crowns are a whole part of an hundred crowns, and being ten times multiplyed make up the whole summe of the debt: but our workes are not a whole and perfect part, but an imperfect part of the obedience we owe; and being multiplyed an hundred thousand times, yet never make any perfect obedience. 2. Ten Crownes may be accepted by the Creditour for a part of the debt due unto him, because there may be some hope of payment of the rest: but good works are not accepted by God as a part of our justice, because there is no hope of full payment to be made by us; and all imperfection or defect is condemned by the law.
Object. 12. The justice or righteousness which Christ brought is eternal: 1For the Messiah (as Daniel saith) bringeth everlasting righteousness. But imputed righteousness is not eternal. Therefore imputed righteousness is not given by Christ. Ans. We deny the Minor; for imputed justice is eternal, 1. By perpetual continuation of imputation in this life. 2. By perfection of that justice which is begun in us. For both that righteousness which is imputed unto us, and that which is begun in us, is the righteousness of Christ; and both of them shall be eternal. For we shall be acceptable and pleasing unto God for ever through his Son Christ: Therefore imputation also shall be continued, or rather shall be changed into our own justice and righteousness. Repl. Where sin is not, there is no place for remission or imputation. In the life to come sin shall not be: Therefore there shall be no place there for remission or imputation. Ans. We grant the whole reason, if it be conceived aright. In the life to come shall not be remission of any sin then present: yet there shall be a remission of sins past; inasmuch as the remission which was once granted in this life, shall continue and endure for ever: that is, our sins, which were long since forgiven us in this life, shall never be imputed to us again. And moreover, that conformity which we shall have with God in the life to come, shall be an effect of this imputation.
Object. 12. The justice or righteousnesse which Christ brought is eternall: 1For the Messias (as Daniel saith) bringeth everlasting righteousnesse. But imputed righteousnesse is not eternall. Therefore imputed righteousnesse is not given by Christ. Ans. We deny the Minor; for imputed justice is eternall, 1. By perpetuall continuation of imputation in this life. 2. By perfection of that justice which is begun in us. For both that righteousnesse which is imputed unto us, and that which is begun in us, is the righteousnesse of Christ; and both of them shall be eternall. For we shall be acceptable and pleasing unto God for ever through his Son Christ: Therefore imputation also shall be continued, or rather shall be changed into our owne justice and righteousnesse. Repl. Where sin is not, there is no place for remission or imputation. In the life to come sin shall not be: Therefore there shall be no place there for remission or imputation. Ans. We grant the whole reason, if it be conceived aright. In the life to come shall not be remission of any sin then present: yet there shall be a remission of sins past; inasmuch as the remission which was once granted in this life, shall continue and endure for ever: that is, our sins, which were long since forgiven us in this life, shall never be imputed to us againe. And moreover, that conformity which we shall have with God in the life to come, shall be an effect of this imputation.
1WE say, we are justified by faith alone: §11. Because we are justified by the object of faith onely, to wit, by the merit of Christ, alone, besides which, there is no justice of ours, nor any part thereof. For we are justified freely for Christs sake, without works. There is nothing which can be our justice and righteousnesse before God, either in whole, or in part, besides Christs merit: only by receiving and beleeving anothers justice we are justified; not by working, nor by meriting, but by an apprehension and acceptation only we are just and righteous. All works are excluded, yea faith it selfe as it is a vertue or work. §22. Because the proper act and operation of faith is, for a man to apprehend and apply unto himself Christs righteousnesse: yea, faith is nothing else than the acceptation it self, or apprehension of anothers justice, or, of the merit of Christ. §33. Because faith only is the instrument, which apprehendeth Christs satisfaction. Hence it is evident, for what causes we are to retain the exclusive particle Onely, 2and to maintaine it against the Papists: namely, 1. For declaration of that which Paul speaketh, Wee are justified freely by grace, without works: likewise of that which Christ saith, Onely beleeve. 2. That whatsoever works and merits of ours, or of others, may be excluded from being causes of justification; and faith may be understood only with relation and respect to Christs merit, which is our justice. 3. That not only our merits, but even faith it self may be wholly excluded from that which is received by faith: and the sense may be, we are justified by faith alone, that is, not by meriting, but only by receiving: as when wee say; This poor man is enriched only by receiving the almes of charitable disposed people: where all works and merits, yea, the very receiving of almes (if it be considered as a merit) are excluded. Therefore Paul saith alwaies, that we are justifieda by faith, andb through faith, as by an instrument; but no where faith,c for faith, as the Papists say, who will admit both these manners of speaking, as if faith were not indeed the application, whereby we apply unto our selves Christs justice; but were also besides a certain work or merit, whereby we deserve to be just: which is quite repugnant to the nature of faith:
IN the former Questions the true doctrine of Justification hath been made manifest and confirmed. It followeth that we proceed to the confutation of the Popish doctrine, affirming that we are justified by workes, or, partly by faith, and partly by works. The argument is thus framed: The justice which may stand in Gods judgement must be perfectly absolute, and agreeable on all parts with Gods Law. But our very best workes in this life are imperfect, and stained with sin: Therefore our very best workes cannot be our justice in the judgment of God, neither in part nor wholly. The Major of this Syllogisme is evidently proved out of the law: Hee that doth these things, shall live in them. Cursed is every one, which abideth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to doe them. The Minor is out of doubt:1 seeing wee doe many evill things, which we ought to leave undone; and we leave many good works undone, which we should doe: yea, we mingle much evill with that good we doe, that is, we doe it amisse. The complaints and daily prayers of Saints are witnesse hereof: Forgive us our sins. Enter not into judgment with thy servant. Wherefore imperfect works can make no perfect righteousnesse.2 This is the first cause why we cannot be justified by our works; namely,3 §11. Because our justice should by this meanes be imperfect, seeing our works are imperfect. Many other causes there are: For, §22. Though our workes were perfect, yet are they due debt, so that by them we cannot acquit our sins that are past. When ye have done all those things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that which was our duty to doe. §33. They are none of ours but Gods▪ who worketh them in us. §44. They are temporary, and have no proportion with eternall rewards: 4whereas between a merit and reward there must be some proportion. §55. They are the effects of justification; therefore not the cause. §66. If by them we were justified, we should have whereof to boast: but the Scripture saith, Not of workes, lest any man should boast himselfe. §77. The conscience should be destitute of solid or sure comfort. §88. Christ should have died without a cause. §99. There should not be the same way to salvation in both Testaments, if Abraham were justified by faith onely, and wee by works, 5whether by works alone, or works joyned with faith, it skilleth not. §1010.