THE COMMON PLACE OF THE TWO NATURES IN CHRIST.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 5 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 5 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The questions are divers, Wherefore Christ rose: and, What fruits Christs resurrection bringeth unto us. For, all the causes of Christs resurrection are not fruits of his resurrection: and after a diverse manner are the causes and the fruits of his resurrection considered: and moreover, the benefits of Christ, bestowed by his resurrection, are one way considered as causes of Christs resurrection; to wit, inasmuch as it was necessary that he should rise from death to bestow them on us: and otherwise as fruits of the same; namely, inasmuch as by the power of his resurrection he bestoweth them on us.
THe questions are divers, Wherefore Christ rose: and, What fruits Christs resurrection bringeth unto us. For, all the causes of Christs resurrection are not fruits of his resurrection: and after a diverse manner are the causes and the fruits of his resurrection considered: and moreover, the benefits of Christ, bestowed by his resurrection, are one way considered as causes of Christs resurrection; to wit, in asmuch as it was necessary that he should rise from death to bestow them on us: and otherwise as fruits of the same; namely, in asmuch as by the power of his resurrection he bestoweth them on us.
Furthermore, the fruit of Christs resurrection is of two sorts: the one respecting Christ; 1the other, us. For first (as the Apostle saith) He is declared by the resurrection to be the Son of God: even the only begotten and well-beloved Son of God, who is also God himself. For he revived by his own power, which is the property of God alone.2 In him was life. As the Father hath life in himself, so likewise hath he given to the Son to have life in himself. Again, Christs humane nature also was by his resurrection adorned with heavenly gifts, immortality, and that glory which becometh the nature of the Son of God. God wrought according to the working of his mighty power in Christ, 3when he raised him from the dead, and set him at his right hand in the heavenly places, far above all principality, and power, and might, and domination, and every name that is named, not in this world only, but also in that which is to come. And hath made all things subject under his feet, and hath appointed him over all things, to be the head of his Church. The fruit of Christs resurrection which respecteth us, is of many sorts. But, to speak in general, All the benefits of Christs death are also the fruits, which we receive by his resurrection. For Christs resurrection maketh that his death hath his effect. Christ by his resurrection doth apply unto us those benefits, which he merited for us by his death; and by this means, the same are the benefits both of his death and resurrection, which are otherwise merited for us, than they are bestowed on us. For it was not necessary that the very act of meriting and deserving should dure all the time both of the old and new Church; but only the act of bestowing or applying the same: and therefore it was necessary also that the Mediator should be continually, that he might bestow always those benefits on the Church, which he was once to merit. For this cannot be done without a Mediator: and therefore neither can the Church be for one moment without a Mediator. In the old Church Christ the Mediator did bestow on the Fathers the benefits of his death to come, by the force and efficacy of his resurrection to come: now he bestoweth them on us, by the efficacy of his resurrection already past.
Furthermore, the fruit of Christs resurrection is of two sorts: the one respecting Christ; 1the other, us. For first (as the Apostle saith) He is declared by the resurrection to be the Sonne of God: even the only begotten and wel-beloved Sonne of God, who is also God himselfe. For he revived by his owne power, which is the property of God alone.2 In him was life. As the Father hath life in himselfe, so likewise hath he given to the Sonne to have life in himselfe. Againe, Christs humane nature also was by his resurrection adorned with heavenly gifts, immortality, and that glory which becometh the nature of the Sonne of God. God wrought according to the working of his mighty power in Christ, 3when he raised him from the dead, and set him at his right hand in the heavenly places, farre above all principality, and power, and might, and domination, and every name that is named, not in this world onely, but also in that which is to come. And hath made all things subject under his feet, and hath appointed him over all things, to be the head of his Church. The fruit of Christs resurrection which respecteth us, is of many sorts. But, to speak in generall, All the benefits of Christs death are also the fruits, which we receive by his resurrection. For Christs resurrection maketh that his death hath his effect. Christ by his resurrection doth apply unto us those benefits, which he merited for us by his death; and by this meanes, the same are the benefits both of his death and resurrection, which are otherwise merited for us, than they are bestowed on us. For it was not necessary that the very act of meriting and deserving should dure all the time both of the old and new Church; but onely the act of bestowing or applying the same: and therefore it was necessary also that the Mediatour should be continually, that he might bestow alwayes those benefits on the Church, which he was once to merit. For this cannot be done without a Mediatour: and therefore neither can the Church be for one moment without a Mediatour. In the old Church Christ the Mediatour did bestow on the Fathers the benefits of his death to come, by the force and efficacy of his resurrection to come: now he bestoweth them on us, by the efficacy of his resurrection already past.
1It remaineth now that we in special reckon the chief fruits, which the resurrection of Christ bringeth unto us.
1It remaineth now that we in speciall reckon the chiefe fruits, which the resurrection of Christ bringeth unto us.
First, then by the Resurrection of Christ from the dead, We are confirmed and warranted, 1. Of his merit, That he hath fully and perfectly satisfied for our sins. For one only sin, not being satisfied for, had with-held Christ still in death. He was cast into such a prison, as that, except he had paid the utmost farthing, he had never been let go: But he was let go and dismissed; therefore he paid the utmost farthing. In regard therefore of this his merit, we have remission of sins, and are justified before God. 2. We are confirmed of the application of Christs benefits, which could not have been bestowed, if he had not risen: For, as was said before, it was ⟨p. 311⟩necessary that the self-same Mediator, being man, should merit and bestow gifts, and therefore should rise again. Whereas then he is risen, we are assured not only that he hath merited for us, but also that he is able, and doth bestow on us the fruit of his merit. Wherefore well saith Saint Paul, 1That Christ is risen again for our righteousness, that is, to confer and apply righteousness unto us.
First, then by the Resurrection of Christ from the dead, We are confirmed and warranted, 1. Of his merit, That he hath fully and perfectly satisfied for our sinnes. For one onely sinne, not being satisfied for, had with-held Christ still in death. He was cast into such a prison, as that, except he had paid the utmost farthing, he had never been let go: But he was let go and dismissed; therefore he paid the utmost farthing. In regard therefore of this his merit, we have remission of sinnes, and are justified before God. 2. We are confirmed of the application of Christs benefits, which could not have been bestowed, if he had not risen: For, as was said before, it was ⟨p. 311⟩necessary that the self-same Mediatour, being man, should merit and bestow gifts, and therefore should rise againe. Whereas then he is risen, we are assured not only that he hath merited for us, but also that he is able, and doth bestow on us the fruit of his merit. Wherfore well saith Saint Paul, 1That Christ is risen againe for our righteousnesse, that is, to conferre and apply righteousnesse unto us.
1A fruit of Christs resurrection is the gift of the holy Ghost, by whom Christ regenerateth us, and giveth us eternal life. It behoved him first to shake off death from himself, and afterwards from us: it behoved us to be engrafted into him, as into our head that from him the holy Ghost might be derived unto us. Wherefore, after his resurrection, he obtaineth the holy Ghost for us, and bestoweth it on us, and by the holy Ghost engrafteth us into himself, regenerateth and quickeneth us. Before time, the godly were also endued with the holy Ghost, and regenerated, but more sparingly than now in the New Testament, and yet both by the force and virtue of his resurrection, which was then to come. For the holy Ghost, by whose virtue and operation only we are regenerated, cannot be given but by the resurrection and ascension of Christ into heaven. The holy Ghost was not given, because that Jesus was not yet glorified.2
1A fruit of Christs resurrection is the gift of the holy Ghost, by whom Christ regenerateth us, and giveth us eternall life. It behoved him first to shake off death from himself, and afterwards from us: it behoved us to be engraffed into him, as into our head that from him the holy Ghost might be derived unto us. Wherfore, after his resurrection, he obtaineth the holy Ghost for us, and bestoweth it on us, and by the holy Ghost engraffeth us into himselfe, regenerateth and quickneth us. Before time, the godly were also endued with the holy Ghost, and regenerated, but more sparingly than now in the New Testament, and yet both by the force and vertue of his resurrection, which was then to come. For the holy Ghost, by whose vertue and operation only we are regenerated, cannot be given but by the resurrection and ascension of Christ into heaven. The holy Ghost was not given, because that Jesus was not yet glorified.2
1The resurrection of our bodies is a fruit of Christs resurrection: For Christs resurrection is a pledge for our resurrection: §11. Because Christ is our head, and we his members. Now, it is expedient for the heads glory, that the members be glorious. Christ indeed should be by himself, though he had no members, or if his members continued in death; but he should not be head, because he is not head, but in respect of his members: neither should he be a King without a kingdom, according to the nature of correlatives, whose very being dependeth upon necessary relation which one hath to the other: and, according to the nature of correlatives, a glorious head doth require glorious members, and such as are correspondent unto it. §22. Because, if Christ be risen, he hath also abolished sin: If he hath abolished sin, either he hath abolished his own sin, or ours: but not his own, therefore ours. If he hath abolished our sin, he hath abolished death also: For, if the cause be taken away, the effect likewise is taken away. The wages of sin, is death. Further,2 if he hath abolished death, and that by a sufficient satisfaction for our sins, which satisfaction he hath showed and declared by his resurrection to be sufficient; it is certain that his resurrection is a most certain testimony of our resurrection: for he having performed a sufficient satisfaction for the sins of his members, the members cannot remain in death. But the resurrection of Christ the head, is an argument of the perfect satisfaction for the sins of his members. Therefore Christs resurrection is also an argument of the perfect resurrection of his members. §33. As the first Adam received the blessings for himself, and all his posterity, and lost the same from all: So Christ, the second Adam received life, and all other gifts for himself and others, and therefore also will communicate eternal life with us. §44. Seeing the same spirit dwelleth in us which did in Christ, he shall work also the same in us, which in our head he did. For the spirit is always alike, neither could he work in the head, and sleep in the members. Therefore seeing Christ hath raised himself up by his spirit from the dead, he will verily also raise us up. If the spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead, dwell in you:
1he that raised up Christ from the dead, shall also quicken your mortal bodies, because that his Spirit dwelleth in you. §55. Because Christ is man, and our brother: for except he were man, we should have no hope of the resurrection of our flesh. For,2 by man came the resurrection. Therefore, for his tender love and affection, he will not leave us in death, and so much the rather in regard of his power and glory. For, if he, being dead, raised himself, much more being alive shall he be able to raise us up: and if in the time of his humiliation he had power to raise himself, much more may he raise us out of the grave now he reigneth in glory a• the right hand of his Father. Object. 1. Then the wicked shall not rise again: because Christs resurrection is neither an argument, nor the cause of the resurrection of the wicked, but of the godly only. Answ. There be other causes for which the wicked shall rise again; even for the just judgement of God, whereby he hath appointed them to eternal pains. For the ⟨p. 312⟩same thing may have moe effects, and diverse causes. Object. 2. These are the benefits of his death: therefore not of his resurrection. Ans. They are of his death, as by it he deserved them: of his resurrection, 1. In respect of the manifestation of them; for by his resurrection he declared, that those benefits were purchased for us: For, by escaping from this punishment, he made plain proof of his full and perfect satisfaction for sin. 2. In respect of the application of them: Because, by his resurrection he applieth his benefits unto us.3 He being rich, was made poor, and being poor, was made rich again, that he might enrich us. Object. 3. The effect is not before the cause. The cause of these benefits (which is his resurrection) was not before the first resurrection: therefore, neither the effect, that is, the benefits themselves. Answ. The resurrection was not, as touching the accomplishment thereof, but in the counsel of God, and in efficacy and virtue, it was in the Old Testament. For, then also were men received into favour, they were endued with the holy Ghost, and received the other benefits: but for and by the Mediator, which was in time appointed to be humbled and glorified.
1By it we are assured, that he now executeth the office of the Mediator, that he applieth unto us the benefit of redemption, that he preserveth us perpetually in that righteousness which he hath applied unto us, that he beginneth in us a new life. and so doth also assure and ascertain us of the consummation and accomplishment of eternal life; all which he could not do, except he had risen again.
1By it we are assured, that he now executeth the office of the Mediatour, that he applyeth unto us the benefit of redemption, that he preserveth us perpetually in that righteousnesse which he hath applied unto us, that he beginneth in us a new life. and so doth also assure and ascertain us of the consummation and accomplishment of eternall life; all which he could not doe, except he had risen againe.
1Seeing he now liveth, and reigneth for ever, we are certain that he will preserve and defend his Church.
1Seeing he now liveth, and reigneth for ever, we are certaine that he will preserve and defend his Church.
1The last, though not the least fruit of Christs resurrection, is, The consummation and perfecting of all his benefits, and the glorifying of his Church. For Christ did therefore die, and is therefore risen, and hath therefore perfectly delivered us from sin, that we may be joint heirs with him of his kingdom and glory.2 He is the first-borne of the dead. We are the heirs of God, and heirs annexed with Christ. He shall conform, and make us like unto himself, because we live by the same spirit whereby he doth. And this spirit is not unlike himself.3 If the spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you: he that raised up Christ from the dead, shall also quicken your mortal bodies, because that his spirit dwelleth in you. 4I will come again, and receive you unto my self; that where I am, there may ye be also.
1The last, though not the least fruit of Christs resurrection, is, The consummation and perfecting of all his benefits, and the glorifying of his Church. For Christ did therefore die, and is therefore risen, and hath therefore perfectly delivered us from sin, that we may be joynt heires with him of his kingdome and glory.2 He is the first-borne of the dead. We are the heires of God, and heires annexed with Christ. He shall conforme, and make us like unto himself, because we live by the same spirit whereby he doth. And this spirit is not unlike himselfe.3 If the spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you: he that raised up Christ from the dead, shall also quicken your mortall bodies, because that his spirit dwelleth in you. 4I will come againe, and receive you unto my selfe; that where I am, there may ye be also.
The sum of the fruits of Christs resurrection is, that seeing Christ is risen, it is manifest that he is declared to be the Son of God; and, as touching his humanity, is endowed with that glory which becometh the nature of the Son of God; and further, that he endueth us also with his spirit, regenerateth us by the virtue of his spirit, and will at length consummate and perfect the new life begun in us, and make us co-partners of the same his glory, felicity and everlasting life.
The summe of the fruits of Christs resurrection is, that seeing Christ is risen, it is manifest that he is declared to be the Son of God; and, as touching his humanity, is endowed with that glory which becometh the nature of the Sonne of God; and further, that he endueth us also with his spirit, regenerateth us by the vertue of his spirit, and will at length consummate and perfect the new life begun in us, and make us co-partners of the same his glory, felicity and everlasting life.
1Now, what is the meaning of this Article; I believe in Christ which rose again the third day from the dead? Answ. The meaning hereof is, that I believe, 1. That Christ did truly recall his soul into his dead body, and quickened it. 2. That he retained a true soul and true body; but both now glorified, and free from all our infirmities. 3. That he rose by his own virtue and power. 4. That he rose to this end, to make me a partaker of his righteousness, sanctification, and glorification, which he had purchased for us by his death.
1Now, what is the meaning of this Article; I beleeve in Christ which rose againe the third day from the dead? Answ. The meaning hereof is, that I beleeve, 1. That Christ did truly recall his soule into his dead body, and quickned it. 2. That he retained a true soul and true body; but both now glorified, and free from all our infirmities. 3. That he rose by his owne vertue and power. 4. That he rose to this end, to make me a partaker of his righteousnesse, sanctification, and glorification, which he had purchased for us by his death.
Answ. That Christ, his Disciples looking on, was taken up from the earth into heaven,a and yet still is there for our sakes,b and will be, until he come again to judge the quick and the dead.c
Answ. That Christ, his Disciples looking on, was taken up from the earth into heaven,a and yet still is there for our sakes,b and will be, untill he come againe to judge the quick and the dead.c
Christs ascension into heaven, is a local, true, and visible translation and removing of Christs body into that heaven, which is above all visible heavens, to that light which is not to be come unto, to the right hand of God, where he now is and remaineth, and whence he shall return to judgement. 1In this Article (as in the former touching the Resurrection) two things are to be considered: the history, and the fruit. In the history these circumstances are to be examined: 1. Who ascended: The same Christ which suffered and died. 2. According to what part of him: According to his humane nature. 3. Whither: Up into heaven, above these visible heavens. 4. By what means: By the power alone of his own God-head. 5. To what end: Even to be our head and heavenly Bishop. 6. In what manner: Visibly, his Disciples beholding him, by a true and local elevation of his body out of earth into heaven. 7. When: The fortieth day after his Resurrection. 8. Where: In Bethany, at the mount of Olives. Of the fruits we shall have fit occasion to entreat in the forty and ninth Question of the Catechism. But all these nine Questions even now proposed, may be reduced unto these five immediately following.
CHrists ascension into heaven, is a locall, true, and visible translation and removing of Christs body into that heaven, which is above all visible heavens, to that light which is not to be come unto, to the right hand of God, where he now is and remaineth, and whence he shall returne to judgement. 1In this Article (as in the former touching the Resurrection) two things are to be considered: the history, and the fruit. In the history these circumstances are to be examined: 1. Who ascended: The same Christ which suffered and died. 2. According to what part of him: According to his humane nature. 3. Whither: Up into heaven, above these visible heavens. 4. By what meanes: By the power alone of his owne God-head. 5. To what end: Even to be our head and heavenly Bishop. 6. In what manner: Visibly, his Disciples beholding him, by a true and locall elevation of his body out of earth into heaven. 7. When: The fortieth day after his Resurrection. 8. Where: In Bethany, at the mount of Olives. Of the fruits we shall have fit occasion to intreat in the forty and ninth Question of the Catechisme. But all these nine Questions even now proposed, may be reduced unto these five immediatly following.
1. Whither, or to what place Christ ascended. 2. How he ascended. 3. Wherefore he ascended. 4. What is the difference between Christs ascension and ours. 5. What are the fruits of Christs ascension.
1. Whither, or to what place Christ ascended. 2. How he ascended. 3. Wherefore he ascended. 4. What is the difference betweene Christs ascension and ours. 5. What are the fruits of Christs ascension.
Jesus Christ-man, when he was together with his Disciples in Bethany forty days after his resurrection; after he had often proved and confirmed his resurrection, his true flesh and humanity to his Apostles, ascended, in their sight, into heaven. Heaven in Scripture signifieth, 1. The air: Behold the fowls of the heaven. 2. The skyey region, and celestial Spheres; When I behold thine heavens, 1the works of thy fingers. He ascended far above all heavens, namely, these visible heavens. 3. The place of the blessed, which is that space immense, most lightsome, glorious without, and above the whole world, and the visible heavens: where God showeth himself to the blessed Angels and men, where is prepared the seat of our bliss with Christ and the Angels. God is said to dwell there, not that he is contained or circumscribed in any place, but because there doth his glory especially appear unto the blessed Angels and men. It is called in Scripture the new world, the new heaven, the heavenly Jerusalem, Paradise, the bosom of Abraham. This heaven is not everywhere, but above, separate from earth and hell Between you and us there is a great gulf set, 2so that they which would go from hence to you cannot; neither can they come from thence to us. Heaven is my seat, and earth is my foot-stool. In this third signification is heaven here taken.3 Christ then ascended into heaven, that is,4 was carried up into the place of the blessed. The holy Ghost came from heaven in the day of Pentecost.5 Elijah was taken up into heaven. Paul calleth it the third heaven. Into this heaven, namely, into the place of the blessed, Christ ascended, and now is there, and shall thence come again to judgement, as many most evident places of Scripture testify unto us, which that Devil, the subtle Sophist and deceiver, shall never be able to wrest or elude. While they beheld, he was taken up: for a cloud took him up out of their sight. 6And while they looked steadfast towards heaven, as he went, behold two men stood by them in white apparel: Which also said, Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing into heaven?
I see the heavens open, and the Son of man standing at the right hand of ⟨p. 314⟩God. He saw with his bodily eyes, endued from above with a new seeing force and sharpness, beyond, and through all the visible heavens, Christ in the same humane nature,1 in which he had been annihilated and humbled. Seek those things which are above, where Christ sitteth at the right hand of God. He ascended far above all heavens. He is entered into heaven. 2Made higher than the heavens. He is entered into very heaven, to appear now in the sight of God for us. Our conversation is in heaven, from whence also we look for the Saviour, even the Lord Jesus Christ. Object. But we converse on earth: Therefore heaven is in the earth. Answ. Our conversation is in heaven. 1. In respect of the hope and certainty we have thereof. 2. In respect of the inchoation, or beginning which we have here of that heavenly life, which is to be consummated in the world to come. In this heaven, that is, in the house of God and all the blessed, Christ ascended. God would therefore have us to know the place whereinto Christ ascended: 1. That it might be apparent that Christ is true Man, and that he vanished not away, but doth continue,3 and shall continue for ever true Man. 2. That we might know whither our cogitations were to be converted, and where we ought to invocate and call upon him, that so Idolatry might be avoided. 3. That we might know our dwelling place into which Christ will bring us, and in which we shall converse and dwell with Christ.
I see the heavens open, and the Sonne of man standing at the right hand of ⟨p. 314⟩God. He saw with his bodily eyes, indued from above with a new seeing force and sharpnesse, beyond, and through all the visible heavens, Christ in the same humane nature,1 in which he had been annihilated and humbled. Seek those things which are above, where Christ sitteth at the right hand of God. He ascended farre above all heavens. He is extred into heaven.
Christ ascended into heaven, first, not simply, but in respect of his humane nature only: 1and that the very same, which was borne of the Virgin, dead, buried, and which rose again. §1Object. 1. He that ever is in heaven, did not ascend into heaven, for then he should have been sometime out of heaven. But the Son of Man was ever in heaven: Therefore he is not ascended. Answ. He that ever was in heaven, as touching that whereby he was ever there, that is, his Divinity, did not ascend; and so we grant Christ according to his Divinity not to have ascended; for that was before in heaven: and as when Christ was on earth, the same did not therefore leave heaven: so when he is now in heaven, his Divinity doth not therefore depart from us. Cyprian saith; The Lord ascended into heaven, not where the Word of God before was not (sith he was always in heaven abiding in the Father) but the Lord ascended thither, where the Word, being made flesh, sate not before. Object. 2. That which descended, did also ascend. His Divinity did descend: Therefore it did also ascend. Ans. The signification of descending is not here proper. His Divinity is said to have descended, that is, to have opened and manifested it self in place where before it had not.
CHrist ascended into heaven, first, not simply, but in respect of his humane nature onely: 1and that the very same, which was borne of the Virgin, dead, buried, and which rose againe. §1Object. 1. He that ever is in heauen, did not ascend into heaven, for then he should have beene sometime out of heaven. But the Son of Man was ever in heaven: Therefore he is not ascended. Answ. He that ever was in heaven, as touching that whereby he was ever there, that is, his Divinity, did not ascend; and so we grant Christ according to his Divinity not to have ascended; for that was before in heaven: and as when Christ was on earth, the same did not therefore leave heaven: so when he is now in heaven, his Divinity doth not therefore depart from us. Cyprian saith; The Lord ascended into heaven, not where the Word of God before was not (sith he was alwayes in heaven abiding in the Father) but the Lord ascended thither, where the Word, being made flesh, sate not before. Object. 2. That which descended, did also ascend. His Divinity did descend: Therefore it did also ascend. Ans. The signification of descending is not here proper. His Divinity is said to have descended, that is, to have opened and manifested it selfe in place where before it had not.
2. He ascended locally or bodily, 1that is, truly going from one place to another. He translated his humane nature from a lower place, by a real and most proper translation, or removing into an higher place, even into heaven: which could not have been done, if he had been in body every-where. That Christ did ascend locally, these places of Scripture convince.2 Ye shall not have me always. If I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you. What then, if ye should see the Son of Man ascend up, where he was before? While they beheld, he was taken up. He was taken up into heaven. Seek those things which are above, where Christ sits at the right hand of God.
2. He ascended locally or bodily, 1that is, truly going from one place to another. He translated his humane nature from a lower place, by a reall and most proper translation, or removing into an higher place, even into heaven: which could not have been done, if he had been in body every-where. That Christ did ascend locally, these places of Scripture convince.2 Ye shall not have me alwayes. If I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you. What then, if yee should see the Sonne of Man ascend up, where he was before? While they beheld, he was taken up. He was taken up into heaven. Seeke those things which are above, where Christ sits at the right hand of God.
3. Christ ascended visibly into heaven. 1For his assumption and taking away from his Apostles▪ was conspicuous and apparent to the sight; While they beheld, he was taken up. And they beheld him ascending up so long, until a cloud took him up out of their sight.
3. Christ ascended visibly into heaven. 1For his assumption and taking away from his Apostles▪ was conspicuous and apparent to the sight; While they beheld, he was taken up. And they beheld him ascending up so long, untill a cloud tooke him up out of their sight.
4. He ascended by his proper power, that is, by the virtue of his God-head: as also by the same he rose from the dead.1 This Jesus by the right hand of God hath been exalted
4. He ascended by his proper power, that is, by the vertue of his God-head: as also by the same he rose from the dead.1 This Jesus by the right hand of God hath been exalted
5. He ascended when he had conversed on the earth forty days after his resurrection: and that therefore,1 1. That he might assure men of his Resurrection: and of the truth of this flesh. To whom also he presented himself alive, after that he had suffered, by many infallible tokens. 2. That he might instruct his Disciples concerning his Kingdom,2 and recall into their minds that which he had spoken before, and farther add some other things: and so might ascertain not them only, but us also of ⟨p. 315⟩his Resurrection and of the truth of his flesh, or humane nature.3 Forty days was he seen of them, speaking of those things which appertain to the Kingdom.
5. He ascended when he had conversed on the earth forty dayes after his resurrection: and that therefore,1 1. That he might assure men of his Resurrection: and of the truth of this flesh. To whom also he presented himselfe alive, after that he had suffered, by many infallible tokens. 2. That he might instruct his Disciples concerning his Kingdome,2 and recall into their minds that which he had spoken before, and farther adde some other things: and so might ascertaine not them only, but us also of ⟨p. 315⟩his Resurrection and of the truth of his flesh, or humane nature.3 Forty dayes was he seene of them, speaking of those things which appertaine to the Kingdome.
6. He so ascended, that he returns not before the day of Judgement. He shall so come, as ye have seen him go into heaven. Whom the heavens must contain, till, &c. 1Object. 1. Beyond heaven there is no place: 2Therefore the ascension into heaven is no local translation. Ans. Beyond heaven there is no natural place, such as Aristotle defineth to be a superficial extremity of a body containing, and yielding to a body contained: but there is a supernatural or heavenly place: which, what manner of thing it is, cannot here be learned by discourse of mans wit and reason, but only by a celestial view and beholding, which the Angels already enjoy, and we shall one day have in heaven. Sufficient it is for us, that we, leaving to search curiously, what it is, now know and believe that such a place there is, according to these testimonies of Scripture: I go to prepare a place for you. I will come again, and receive you unto my self, that where I am, there may ye be also: And, Whither I go, ye know. Father, 3I will that where I am, they which thou hast given me, be with me. Seek those things which are above, where Christ sitteth at the right-hand of God. These and the like testimonies do teach us, that the heaven whereinto Christ ascended, and which is above these visible heavens, is truly a place. For the particles, Above, Whither, and Where, do express a place: This kind of place Aristotle neither knew, nor believed, seeing he knew not the Scriptures. Repl. Yet at least (say the Ubiquitaries) Christ was translated out of a place into that which is not a place; whence we thus conclude: That which is not in any place, is every-where: Christ is not in any place, 4because he ascended above and beyond the visible heavens, beyond which there is not any place: Therefore Christ is every-where. Answ. 1. We deny the Major, that the same is every-where which is not in any place. For the highest or farthest heaven is not in any place, neither yet is it every-where. 2. The Minor is true of a natural place; which is defined to be the superficial extremity of a body so compassing and containing any thing within it, as it self also is compassed and contained within another. We grant, Christ is translated thither where is no place, to wit, natural; and Christ is now in no place, that is, no natural place.
But these assertions are false, if we speak of a supernatural place, which doth contain, but is not it self contained; and such a supernatural place is beyond the visible heavens, and in it Christ now is according to the Scriptures.
But these assertions are false, if we speak of a supernaturall place, which doth containe, but is not it selfe contained; and such a supernaturall place is beyond the visible heavens, and in it Christ now is according to the Scriptures.
3. Their supposition, or ground, whereon they build their argument, is in every part denied by us. That Christ was taken or translated out of a place, we have many main proofs; whether he were translated into a place, or that which is no place, it skilleth not: This followeth, Therefore he changed place. So then Christs humane nature is finite, and doth change place; and therefore is not every-where. For, To be every-where, and to change place, are contradictory. And therefore also his God-head, which alone is infinite, eternal, and every-where, is not said to change place. But here the Ubiquitaries seek a shift, that they may not be hurt by this weapon; That which changeth place is not every-where. Christs body changeth place: Therefore that is not every-where. They grant the Major of this Syllogism to be true, taking the words after one manner; but here they contend, that the words are taken after a diverse manner: As, that Christs body is every-where, that is, after a manner of majesty, or in manner as it is a majestical body; it changeth place, in manner of a natural body, or as it is a natural body. But they escape not a contradiction by this cavil. For the diverse manner which taketh away a contradiction, must not fall into the same, and be all one with the words themselves, for the clearing of which they are brought. For so it is made a mere Tautology, or speaking of the same thing, and a begging of that which is in question: as if I, imitating them, should say, This air is light, according to the manner of light; and it is dark, as touching the manner of darkness. Again, This man is poor, as touching the manner of poverty; and is rich, as touching the manner of riches. Thus is the same affirmed of the same. For, the manner of poverty, is nothing else but poverty: and the manner of riches, nothing but riches. So also these manners, which they feign and imagine in the Major proposition, are altogether the same with the things which are affirmed: that is, the same in them is affirmed of ⟨p. 316⟩the same, and so these manners are that in which lieth the contradiction: For they say, Christs body is every where, according to the manner of majesty. Being demanded what they mean by majesty, they answer, omnipotency and immensity.
3. Their supposition, or ground, whereon they build their argument, is in every part denied by us. That Christ was taken or translated out of a place, wee have many maine proofes; whether he were translated into a place, or that which is no place, it skilleth not: This followeth, Therefore he changed place. So then Christs humane nature is finite, and doth change place; and therefore is not every-where. For, To be every-where, and to change place, are contradictory. And therefore also his God-head, which alone is infinite, eternall, and every-where, is not said to change place. But here the Ubiquitaries seek a shift, that they may not be hurt by this weapon; That which changeth place is not every-where. Christs body changeth place: Therefore that is not every-where. They grant the Major of this Syllogisme to be true, taking the words after one manner; but here they contend, that the words are taken after a diverse manner: As, that Christs body is every-where, that is, after a manner of majesty, or in manner as it is a majesticall body; it changeth place, in manner of a naturall body, or as it is a naturall body. But they escape not a contradiction by this cavill. For the diverse manner which taketh away a contradiction, must not fall into the same, and be all one with the words themselves, for the clearing of which they are brought. For so it is made a meer Tautology, or speaking of the same thing, and a begging of that which is in question: as if I, imitating them, should say, This aire is light, according to the manner of light; and it is dark, as touching the manner of darknesse. Againe, This man is poore, as touching the manner of poverty; and is rich, as touching the manner of riches. Thus is the same affirmed of the same. For, the manner of poverty, is nothing else but poverty: and the manner of riches, nothing but riches. So also these manners, which they feigne and imagine in the Major proposition, are altogether the same with the things which are affirmed: that is, the same in them is affirmed of
To say then, Christs body is every-where, as touching the manner of majesty, not as touching the manner of a natural body, is nothing else even by their own judgment, than Christs body to be every-where according to the manner of immensity, or infinity; and not to be every-where according to the manner of finiteness. Now verily they trimly take away the contradiction by thus distinguishing: For the manner of immensity, is nothing else but immensity: and immensity, and, to be immense, are both affirmed of the same. Wherefore, as these are contradictory, To be every-where, and, To change place, or, Not to be every-where: so are these also contradictory, The same body to be immense, and, To be finite: Immensity and finiteness to agree unto the same; or, the same body to be every-where, or immense, according to the manner of immensity or majesty, and not to be every-where, but to change place, and to be finite, according to the manner of finiteness, or a natural body. Wherefore it is manifest, which was before also confirmed, That Christ ascended locally, and that therefore this Article is to be understood of Christs local ascension.
To say then, Christs body is every-where, as touching the manner of majesty, not as touching the mannor of a naturall body, is nothing else even by their owne judgment, than Christs body to be every-where according to the manner of immensity, or infinity; and not to be every-where according to the manner of finitenesse. Now verily they trimly take away the contradiction by thus distinguishing: For the manner of immensity, is nothing else but immensity: and immensity, and, to be immense, are both affirmed of the same. Wherefore, as these are contradictory, To be every-where, and, To change place, or, Not to be every-where: so are these also contradictory, The same body to be immense, and, To be finite: Immensity and finitenesse to agree unto the same; or, the same body to be every-where, or immense, according to the manner of immensity or majesty, and not to be every-where, but to change place, and to be finite, according to the manner of finitenesse, or a naturall body. Wherefore it is manifest, which was before also confirmed, That Christ ascended locally, and that therefore this Article is to be understood of Christs locall ascension.
Object. 2. Contraries or opposites ought to be expounded after the same manner, that the contrariety and opposition may be kept; But these Articles, He ascended into heaven; He descended into hell; are opposed one to the other: Therefore as the Article of Christs descension is taken in a figurative meaning, that is, of his great humiliation; so ought also the Article of his ascension to be taken of his great majesty, not of any local motion. Answ. We answer, first to the Major: Opposites are to be expounded after the same manner; except such manner of explication be disagreeing from the Articles of faith, and from other places of Scripture: But this Article the Scripture it self understandeth of a local ascension, 1He shall so come, as ye have seen him go into heaven: howsoever it understand that other of a spiritual, as we have heretofore proved. And that thus we understand both these Articles, the Analogy of faith requireth. 2. We deny the Minor. For these two Articles are not opposed: For his ascension into heaven is not the furthest degree of his glory, as his descension into hell is the furthest degree of his humiliation. But the furthest and highest degree of his glory, is his sitting at the right hand of the Father. Therefore as touching this Article, of his sitting at the right hand of his Father, we grant the Major; For unto this Article is the descension into hell opposed: whereupon also the Scripture doth not interpret properly, but figuratively, these two Articles of Christs descension into hell, and of his sitting at the right hand of his Father. 3. If Christs ascension be construed of any equalling of his man-hood with his God-head, all the other Articles, concerning the true humanity of Christ, shall be utterly overthrown.
Object. 2. Contraries or opposites ought to be expounded after the same manner, that the contrariety and opposition may be kept; But these Articles, Hee ascended into heaven; Hee descended into hell; are opposed one to the other: Therefore as the Article of Christs descension is taken in a figurative meaning, that is, of his great humiliation; so ought also the Article of his ascension to be taken of his great majesty, not of any locall motion. Answ. We answer, first to the Major: Opposites are to be expounded after the same manner; except such manner of explication be disagreeing from the Articles of faith, and from other places of Scripture: But this Article the Scripture it selfe understandeth of a locall ascension, 1
This Question is a prevention of an objection of the Ubiquitaries, who argue thus: Object. But Christ promised, that he would be with us until the end of the world: Therefore he did not so ascend into heaven, but that he is now also on earth, and that every-where in his humane nature. Answ. They infer more in their conclusion then the premisses enforce. Christ is with us in that spiritual union, whereby we his members are ⟨p. 317⟩joined to him our head. And further, he speaketh of the presence of his whole person, to which he attributeth that which is proper unto the God-head. In like manner he saith before his passion, when as yet he conversed on earth with his Disciples; I and my Father will come unto him, and will dwell with him: this he speaketh,1 as touching his God head, which was, and is in heaven, and by which, as the Father is with us, so he is: otherwise we might reason also thus, I go away, saith Christ: Therefore he is not at all with us. But it is attributed improperly to his other nature, namely, to his humanity, 2that he abideth with us in respect of that personal union, which is the secret and wonderful indissoluble uniting and knitting of the two most diverse natures of Christ, divine and humane, into one person, so that these two natures, being in such wise linked and conjoined, absolve the essence of Christs person, and one nature should be destroyed, if it were sundered from the other; both notwithstanding retaining their peculiar and several properties, whereby one is distinguished from another. Saint Augustine's Explication is on this manner: That which Christ saith Lo,3 I am with you always unto the end of the world, is fulfilled according to his Majesty, Providence, and unspeakable Goodness: But as concerning that flesh which the Word took, and after which he was borne of the Virgin, taken by the Jews, crucified on the Cross, taken down from the Cross, wrapped in linen clothes, laid in the Sepulchre, manifested in the resurrection; as concerning it, ye shall not have him always with you. Why so? Because, as concerning the presence of his body, he conversed forty days with his Disciples; and they accompanying him to see him, not to follow him, he ascended into heaven, and is no longer here. For, He is there; sitting at the right hand of God: and, He is here; for the presence of his Majesty hath not left us.
Again, according to the presence of Christs majesty, we have Christ always: according to the presence of his flesh, it was truly said unto the Disciples; Ye shall not have me always. For the Church enjoyed him a few days, as concerning the presence of his flesh; now it layeth hold on him by faith, but seeth him not with corporal eyes. Christ therefore is present with us, 1. By his spirit and God-head. 12. As touching our faith and confidence, wherewith we behold him. 3. In mutual dilection and love, because he loveth us, and we him, so that he doth not forget us. 4. In respect of his union with humane nature; that is, in the conjunction of the soul with the body: For the same spirit is in us, and in him, who joineth and knitteth us unto him. 5. In respect of that hope, which we have of our consummation; that is, that certain hope which we have of coming unto him.
Againe, according to the presence of Christs majesty, we have Christ alwayes: according to the presence of his flesh, it was truly said unto the Disciples; Yee shall not have me alwayes. For the Church injoyed him a few dayes, as concerning the presence of his flesh; now it layeth hold on him by faith, but seeth him not with corporall eyes. Christ therefore is present with us, 1. By his spirit and God-head. 12. As touching our faith and confidence, wherewith we behold him. 3. In mutuall dilection and love, because he loveth us, and we him, so that he doth not forget us. 4. In respect of his union with humane nature; that is, in the conjunction of the soule with the body: For the same spirit is in us, and in him, who joyneth and knitteth us unto him. 5. In respect of that hope, which we have of our consummation; that is, that certaine hope which we have of coming unto him.
Answ. No: For, seeing his divinity is incomprehensible, and every-where present;a it followeth necessarily, that the same is without the bounds of his humane nature, which he took to him,b and yet it is nevertheless in it, and abideth personally united to it.
Answ. No: For, seeing his divinity is incomprehensible, and every-where present;a it followeth necessarily, that the same is without the bounds of his humane nature, which he took to him,b and yet it is neverthelesse in it, and abideth personally united to it.
1The resurrection of our bodies is a fruit of Christs resurrection: For Christs resurrection is a pledge for our resurrection: §11. Because Christ is our head, and we his members. Now, it is expedient for the heads glory, that the members be glorious. Christ indeed should be by himselfe, though he had no members, or if his members continued in death; but he should not be head, because he is not head, but in respect of his members: neither should he be a King without a kingdome, according to the nature of correlatives, whose very being dependeth upon necessary relation which one hath to the other: and, according to the nature of correlatives, a glorious head doth require glorious members, and such as are correspondent unto it. §22. Because, if Christ be risen, he hath also abolished sinne: If he hath abolished sin, either he hath abolished his owne sinne, or ours: but not his owne, therefore ours. If he hath abolished our sin, he hath abolished death also: For, if the cause be taken away, the effect likewise is taken away. The wages of sinne, is death. Further,2 if he hath abolished death, and that by a sufficient satisfaction for our sins, which satisfaction he hath shewed and declared by his resurrection to be sufficient; it is certain that his resurrection is a most certain testimony of our resurrection: for he having performed a sufficient satisfaction for the sins of his members, the members cannot remain in death. But the resurrection of Christ the head, is an argument of the perfect satisfaction for the sinnes of his members. Therefore Christs resurrection is also an argument of the perfect resurrection of his members. §33. As the first Adam received the blessings for himselfe, and all his posterity, and lost the same from all: So Christ, the second Adam received life, and all other gifts for himselfe and others, and therefore also will communicate eternall life with us. §44. Seeing the same spirit dwelleth in us which did in Christ, he shall work also the same in us, which in our head he did. For the spirit is alwayes alike, neither could he work in the head, and sleep in the members. Therefore seeing Christ hath raised himselfe up by his spirit from the dead, he will verily also raise us up. If the spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead, dwell in you:
1he that raised up Christ from the dead, shall also quicken your mortall bodies, because that his Spirit dwelleth in you. §55. Because Christ is man, and our brother: for except he were man, we should have no hope of the resurrection of our flesh. For,2 by man came the resurrection. Therefore, for his tender love and affection, he will not leave us in death, and so much the rather in regard of his power and glory. For, if he, being dead, raised himselfe, much more being alive shall he be able to raise us up: and if in the time of his humiliation he had power to raise himselfe, much more may he raise us out of the grave now he reigneth in glory a• the right hand of his Father. Object. 1. Then the wicked shall not rise againe: because Christs resurrection is neither an argument, nor the cause of the resurrection of the wicked, but of the godly onely. Answ. There be other causes for which the wicked shall rise againe; even for the just judgement of God, whereby he hath appointed them to eternall paines. For the ⟨p. 312⟩same thing may have moe effects, and diverse causes. Object. 2. These are the benefits of his death: therefore not of his resurrection. Ans. They are of his death, as by it he deserved them: of his resurrection, 1. In respect of the manifestation of them; for by his resurrection he declared, that those benefis were purchased for us: For, by escaping from this punishment, he made plaine proofe of his full and perfect satisfaction for sinne. 2. In respect of the application of them: Because, by his resurrection he applieth his benefits unto us.3 He being rich, was made poore, and being poore, was made rich againe, that he might enrich us. Object. 3. The effect is not before the cause. The cause of these benefis (which is his resurrection) was not before the first resurrection: therefore, neither the effect, that is, the benefits themselves. Answ. The resurrection was not, as touching the accomplishment thereof, but in the counsell of God, and in efficacy and vertue, it was in the Old Testament. For, then also were men received into favour, they were indued with the holy Ghost, and received the other benefits: but for and by the Mediatour, which was in time appointed to be humbled and glorified.
JEsus Christ-man, when he was together with his Disciples in Bethania forty dayes after his resurrection; after he had often proved and confirmed his resurrection, his true flesh and humanity to his Apostles, ascended, in their sight, into heaven. Heaven in Scripture signifieth, 1. The aire: Behold the fowles of the heaven. 2. The skiey region, and celestiall Spheres; When I behold thine heavens, 1the works of thy fingers. He ascended farre above all heavens, namely, these visible heavens. 3. The place of the blessed, which is that space immense, most lightsome, glorious without, and above the whole world, and the visible heavens: where God sheweth himselfe to the blessed Angels and men, where is prepared the seat of our blisse with Christ and the Angels. God is said to dwell there, not that he is contained or circumscribed in any place, but because there doth his glory especially appeare unto the blessed Angels and men. It is called in Scripture the new world, the new heaven, the heavenly Jerulem, Paradise, the bosome of Abraham. This heaven is not everywhere, but above, separate from earth and hell Betweene you and us there is a great gulfe set, 2so that they which would go from hence to you cannot; neither can they come from thence to us. Heaven is my seat, and earth is my foot-stoole. In this third signification is heaven here taken.3 Christ then ascended into heaven, that is,4 was carried up into the place of the blessed. The holy Ghost came from heaven in the day of Pentecost.5 Elias was taken up into heaven. Paul calleth it the third heaven. Into this heaven, namely, into the place of the blessed, Christ ascended, and now is there, and shall thence come againe to judgement, as many most evident places of Scripture testifie unto us, which that Divell, the subtle Sophist and deceiver, shall never be able to wrest or elude. While they beheld, he was taken up: for a cloud took him up out of their sight. 6And while they looked stedfast towards heaven, as he went, behold two men stood by them in white apparell: Which also said, Ye men of Galilee, why stand yee gazing into heaven? 7This Jesus which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come, as yee have seene him go into heaven. In my Fathers house are many dwelling places: that is, many houses, in which we may dwell and remaine. I go to prepare a place for you. He was taken up into heaven. 8He was taken up.
6. He so ascended, that he returnes not before the day of Judgement. He shall so come, as yee have seene him go into heaven. Whom the heavens must containe, till, &c. 1Object. 1. Beyond heaven there is no place: 2Therefore the ascension into heaven is no locall translation. Ans. Beyond heaven there is no naturall place, such as Aristotle defineth to be a superficiall extremity of a body containing, and yeelding to a body contained: but there is a supernaturall or heavenly place: which, what manner of thing it is, cannot here be learned by discourse of mans wit and reason, but onely by a celestiall view and beholding, which the Angels already injoy, and we shall one day have in heaven. Sufficient it is for us, that we, leaving to search curiously, what it is, now know and beleeve that such a place there is, according to these testimonies of Scripture: I go to prepare a place for you. I will come againe, and receive you unto my selfe, that where I am, there may ye be also: And, Whither I go, ye know. Father, 3I will that where I am, they which thou hast given me, be with me. Seeke those things which are above, where Christ sitteth at the right-hand of God. These and the like testimonies doe teach us, that the heaven whereinto Christ ascended, and which is above these visible heavens, is truly a place. For the particles, Above, Whither, and Where, doe expresse a place: This kind of place Aristotle neither knew, nor beleeved, seeing he knew not the Scriptures. Repl. Yet at least (say the Ubiquitaries) Christ was translated out of a place into that which is not a place; whence we thus conclude: That which is not in any place, is every-where: Christ is not in any place, 4because he ascended above and beyond the visible heavens, beyond which there is not any place: Therefore Christ is every-where. Answ. 1. We deny the Major, that the same is every-where which is not in any place. For the highest or farthest heaven is not in any place, neither yet is it every-where. 2. The Minor is true of a naturall place; which is defined to be the superficiall extremity of a body so compassing and containing any thing within it, as it selfe also is compassed and contained within another. We grant, Christ is translated thither where is no place, to wit, naturall; and Christ is now in no place, that is, no naturall place.
THis Question is a prevention of an objection of the Ubiquitaries, who argue thus: Object. But Christ promised, that hee would be with us untill the end of the world: Therefore hee did not so ascend into heaven, but that hee is now also on earth, and that every-where in his humane nature. Answ. They inferre more in their conclusion then the premisses inforce. Christ is with us in that spirituall union, whereby wee his members are ⟨p. 317⟩joyned to him our head. And further, he speaketh of the presence of his whole person, to which he attributeth that which is proper unto the God-head. In like manner he saith before his passion, when as yet he conversed on earth with his Disciples; I and my Father will come unto him, and will dwell with him: this he speaketh,1 as touching his God head, which was, and is in heaven, and by which, as the Father is with us, so he is: otherwise we might reason also thus, I go away, saith Christ: Therefore he is not at all with us. But it is attributed improperly to his other nature, namely, to his humanity, 2that he abideth with us in respect of that personall union, which is the secret and wonderfull indissoluble uniting and knitting of the two most diverse natures of Christ, divine and humane, into one person, so that these two natures, being in such wise linked and conjoyned, absolve the essence of Christs person, and one nature should be destroyed, if it were sundered from the other; both notwithstanding retaining their peculiar and severall properties, whereby one is distinguished from another. Saint Augustines Explication is on this manner: That which Christ saith Loe,3 I am with you alwayes unto the end of the world, is fulfilled according to his Majesty, Providence, and unspeakable Goodnesse: But as concerning that flesh which the Word tooke, and after which he was borne of the Virgin, taken by the Jewes, crucified on the Crosse, taken downe from the Crosse, wrapped in linnen clothes, laid in the Sepulchre, manifested in the resurrection; as concerning it, yee shall not have him alwayes with you. Why so? Because, as concerning the presence of his body, he conversed forty dayes with his Disciples; and they accompanying him to see him, not to follow him, he ascended into heaven, and is no longer here. For, He is there; sitting at the right hand of God: and, He is here; for the presence of his Majesty hath not left us.