Obj. 1. Divers or contrary causes have contrary effects: The effects of election are good works: Therefore evil works are the effects of reprobation. Answ. The Major is not always true in voluntary causes, which can work diversly, and yet produce no contrary effects; as in this place there is a dissimilitude: Because God purposed only to permit evil works, but to work good in us. But the proper cause of evil works is the devil and evil men. Obj. 2. But God hardeneth and blindeth men: Blindness is an effect of reprobation, and a sin: Therefore sin is an effect of reprobation. Ans. Blindness is a sin in respect of men who admit it, and as it is received of them, and purchased by their own demerit; but as it is inflicted of God, it is a just punishment: and, that God doth deliver some from that blindness, is of his mercy. Obj. 3. Hardness or induration is an effect of reprobation, and is a sin: God is author of reprobation: Therefore of hardness also and of sin. Ans. Hardness is an effect of reprobation; but so, that it is done according to reprobation, but cometh not from it. Hardness, and blindness, or excecation are according to reprobation, or according to predestination, as they are sins: but they are effects of reprobation or predestination, as they are most just punishments.
Obj. 1. Divers or contrary causes have contrary effects: The effects of election are good works: Therefore evill works are the effects of reprobation. Answ. The Major is not alwaies true in voluntry causes, which can work diversly, and yet produce no contrary effects; as in this place there is a dissimilitude: Because God purposed only to permit evill works, but to work good in us. But the proper cause of evill works is the divell and evill men. Obj. 2. But God hardeneth and blindeth men: Blindnesse is an effect of reprobation, and a sin: Therefore sin is an effect of reprobation. Ans. Blindnesse is a sin in respect of men who admit it, and as it is received of them, and purchased by their own demerit; but as it is inflicted of God, it is a just punishment: and, that God doth deliver some from that blindnesse, is of his mercy. Obj. 3. Hardnesse or induration is an effect of reprobation, and is a sin: God is authour of reprobation: Therefore of hardnesse also and of sin. Ans. Hardnesse is an effect of reprobation; but so, that it is done according to reprobation, but cometh not from it. Hardnesse, and blindnesse, or excecation are according to reprobation, or according to predestination, as they are sins: but they are effects of reprobation or predestination, as they are most just punishments.