THE COMMON PLACE OF THE TWO NATURES IN CHRIST.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 1 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 1 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Next after the Article of the Conception and Nativity of Christ, for the better understanding thereof, followeth not unfitly the Common place, Of the Incarnation of the Son of God, or, Of the two natures in Christ, and their personal union; wherein these questions following are more copiously to be discussed.
NExt after the Article of the Conception and Nativity of Christ, for the better understanding thereof, followeth not unfitly the Common place, Of the Incarnation of the Son of God, or, Of the two natures in Christ, and their personall union; wherein these questions following are more copiously to be discussed.
1. Whether there be two natures in the Mediator. 2. Whether they be one, or two persons. 3. If they be one person, what manner of union that is of them, and how made. 4. Why this personal union was necessary to be made.
1. Whether there be two natures in the Mediatour. 2. Whether they be one, or two persons. 3. If they be one person, what manner of union that is of them, and how made. 4. Why this personall union was necessary to be made.
1That there are two natures in Christ, this one reason shows by good demonstrance: Essential properties which are opposite, cannot be in the same, nor be affirmed of the same thing in respect of the same nature or cause. Vigil.2 One nature doth not receive in it self a thing contrary and diverse. But in one and the same Christ are, and are affirmed of him properties diverse and contrary, divine and humane, finite, infinite, passible, impassible, and such like: Therefore there must needs be divers natures in him, humane and divine. And that the very divine nature, Creatress of all things, is in Christ, hath been already proved. It remaineth that we show, a true humane nature to be in him, and that such as ours is, and perfect, consisting of a body, and a reasonable soul, of which, 3as of essential parts, is made a third substance, to wit, this particular humanity, which the Word, having taken once into the unity of the person, doth never lay away again. Which we are to hold against Heretics both old and new, Marcionites and Schwenkfeldians; whereof some deny Christs flesh to have been formed of the Virgins substance, but will have it brought down from heaven into the Virgin, or begotten in her, of the substance of the holy Ghost. Others fancy Christ to have, instead of true flesh, the likeness, semblance, and apparency of a mans body. Others acknowledge indeed, that he hath a true body, but not an humane soul, the room whereof is supplied by the Word united unto the body.
1THat there are two natures in Christ, this one reason shewes by good demonstrance: Essentiall properties which are opposite, cannot be in the same, nor be affirmed of the same thing in respect of the same nature or cause. Vigil.2 One nature doth not receive in it selfe a thing contrary and diverse. But in one and the same Christ are, and are affirmed of him properties diverse and contrary, divine and humane, finite, infinite, passible, impassible, and such like: Therefore there must needs be divers natures in him, humane and divine. And that the very divine nature, Creatresse of all things, is in Christ, hath been already proved. It remaineth that we shew, a true humane nature to be in him, and that such as ours is, and perfect, consisting of a body, and a reasonable soule, of which, 3as of essentiall parts, is made a third substance, to wit, this particular humanity, which the Word, having taken once into the unity of the person, doth never lay away againe. Which we are to hold against Hereticks both old and new, Marcionites and Swenkfieldians; whereof some deny Christs flesh to have been formed of the Virgins substance, but will have it brought down from heaven into the Virgin, or begotten in her, of the substance of the holy Ghost. Others fancie Christ to have, instead of true flesh, the likenesse, semblance, and apparency of a mans body. Others acknowledge indeed, that he hath a true body, but not an humane soule, the roome whereof is supplied by the Word united unto the body.
Against these and the like errors,1 the sentence and doctrine of the Church is confirmed By plain places of Scripture, which testify, Christ, Mary's §12Son, to have been made like unto us in all things, that is, in essence, in properties, in infirmities, sin only excepted. Lo, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bear a Son. Seeing then the Virgin conceived this her Son in her womb, bare it until the usual time of delivery, and was delivered of it, as other women use to be of their children; it followeth, that his flesh was nor brought from heaven, or else-where taken, which should but pass only through the womb of the Virgin, but was formed in the Virgins ⟨p. 274⟩womb, of her seed and substance. He that sanctifieth, and they which are sanctified, are all of one: 3wherefore he is not ashamed to call them brethren. And a little after: For as much as the children were partakers of flesh and blood, he also himself likewise took part with them. Again, In all things it became him to be like to his brethren: Therefore he hath a humane nature of the same kind wholly with ours: Hereof he is called, The fruit of Mary's womb, 4The first begotten Son of Mary, Made of a woman, The seed of Abraham, Made of the seed of David, Borne of the Jews concerning the flesh, The Son of Abraham, of David, and the Son of man. And also his pedigree and stock, concerning the flesh, is deduced unto Adam: Therefore he was begotten of the substance of his mother, and issued from the same seed of Adam, from which we did. Christ proveth himself to be a true man, and not a spirit, by this, that a spirit hath no flesh and bones, as he hath, and retaineth, even after his resurrection. Apollinaris the Heretic said,5 That Christs body indeed was a true body; but instead of a soul, he had the Word only. But this man is easily refuted, because Christ should not then have been like unto his brethren in all things, except sin. And Christ himself doth plainly confess,6
Hitherto belongeth also that, Father, 1into thine hands I commend my spirit. And when he had thus said, he gave up the ghost. This cannot be said of Christs God-head: For, that being immense and infinite, is every where; neither doth a removing from one place to another agree unto it: it is not laid down, and taken up again; that is, it never departed, or was severed from the body, but remaineth always united unto it. Wherefore, there must needs be in Christ, besides his body and his God-head, a true humane soul, which did truly suffer and abide in Christ these changes, and the like.
Hitherto belongeth also that, Father, 1into thine hands I commend my spirit. And when he had thus said, he gave up the ghost. This cannot be said of Christs God-head: For, that being immense and infinite, is every where; neither doth a removing from one place to another agree unto it: it is not laid downe, and taken up againe; that is, it never departed, or was severed from the body, but remaineth alwayes united unto it. Wherefore, there must needs be in Christ, besides his body and his God-head, a true humane soule, which did truly suffer and abide in Christ these changes, and the like.
1It is confirmed by divine promises and prophecies. For the Messiah in the Old Testament was promised to be such a one, as should be the seed of the woman, of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, &c. But this Jesus, the Son of the Virgin Mary, is that promised Messiah: Therefore he must needs be the true man, issuing of the blood and posterity of the Woman and the Fathers, and therefore to have been indeed begotten of the substance of Mary, and to have taken true flesh.
1It is confirmed by divine promises and prophecies. For the Messias in the Old Testament was promised to be such a one, as should be the seed of the woman, of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, &c. But this Jesus, the Son of the Virgin Mary, is that promised Messias: Therefore he must needs be the true man, issuing of the bloud and posterity of the Woman and the Fathers, and therefore to have been indeed begotten of the substance of Mary, and to have taken true flesh.
1The office of the Mediator confirmeth the same. The sin of men, in respect of Gods truth and justice, could not be punished in any other nature, than in a humane nature, which should be of the same kind with ours. But in the Mediator, which is Jesus Christ alone, our sins were to be punished: Therefore he must needs be true man who hath humane flesh, not created of nothing, or borne else-whence, but sprung from the blood of Adam, as well as ours. Moreover, it was necessary for Christ, not only to take, but also to retain our nature for ever: because God hath decreed to bestow, and doth bestow the benefits, which Christ by his death hath purchased for us, by this man Christ, upon them only who are, and remain engrafted into his mass and flesh, as members into their head, or branches into their Vine.2 For since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead. If a man abide not in me, he is cast forth as a branch, and withereth. Lastly, It behooved Christ to be made, and to continue our brother for ever; that as he is flesh of our flesh, so we also of the other side might be flesh and bones of his flesh and bones, by the same spirit dwelling in us.3 We are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones. Wherefore, except Christ had indeed taken our nature, without which he cannot be our brother, we should lose that comfort ever needful and necessary for us, which consisteth in the brotherhood only of Christ with us: I am of his flesh, and of his bones.
1The office of the Mediatour confirmeth the same. The sinne of men, in respect of Gods truth and justice, could not be punished in any other nature, than in a humane nature, which should be of the same kind with ours. But in the Mediatour, which is Jesus Christ alone, our sinnes were to be punished: Therefore he must needs be true man who hath humane flesh, not created of nothing, or borne else-whence, but sprung from the bloud of Adam, as well as ours. Moreover, it was necessary for Christ, not onely to take, but also to retaine our nature for ever: because God hath decreed to bestow, and doth bestow the benefits, which Christ by his death hath purchased for us, by this man Christ, upon them onely who are, and remaine ingraffed into his masse and flesh, as members into their head, or branches into their Vine.
Object. 1. The flesh of Adam (that is, humane flesh issuing from Adam by generation unto his posterity) is sinful. The flesh of Christ is not sinful: Therefore the flesh of Christ is not the flesh of Adam. Answ. The Major proposition hath a fallacy of the accident. For it is not necessary, that of whatsoever the accident of a thing is denied, of the ⟨p. 275⟩same, the thing also, or subject of the accident should be denied: because an accident doth so cleave to the thing wherein it is, as it may be separated from it.1 Sin is not of the essence and nature of humane flesh (for that was created pure of God) but sin came otherwise, by the defection and falling of our first Parents from God. Seeing then the flesh of Adam is sinful only by an accident, it followeth that the flesh of Christ is only in respect of that accident, not the flesh of Adam, but is, as touching the substance, the same flesh with the flesh of Adam. Wherefore, they deal like Sophisters, who deny the flesh of Christ, for that it is void of sin, to be the same in substance, or essence, or kind, with the flesh of Adam. For he that could in the beginning create humane flesh pure of nothing, he is able also by his omnipotent power, and special working, so to form it of the substance of the Virgin, being a sinner, as withal, to let and stop any issuing of sin thereunto; that is, to make it pu•e and holy. There is no new or strange thing therefore, if the omnipotent Lord hath taken humane substance, without the accident sin, into the unity of his person. Wherefore this their argument shall be rather thus inverted: The flesh of Adam is true flesh. Christs flesh is the flesh of Adam: and therefore Christs flesh is true flesh, and, by a consequent, Christ is true man.
Object. 1. The flesh of Adam (that is, humane flesh issuing from Adam by generation unto his posterity) is sinfull. The flesh of Christ is not sinfull: Therefore the flesh of Christ is not the flesh of Adam. Answ. The Major proposition hath a fallacy of the accident. For it is not necessary, that of whatsoever the accident of a thing is denied, of the ⟨p. 275⟩same, the thing also, or subject of the accident should be denied: because an accident doth so cleave to the thing wherein it is, as it may be separated from it.
1Object. 2. That which is conceived and begotten of another, is of the same substance with him. The flesh of Christ was conceived of the holy Ghost: Therefore the flesh of Christ is no creature, but came down from heaven, issuing from the substance of God. Answ. There is a fallacy in the diverse understanding of the particle of: For that in the Major signi••eth the matter or material cause, in the Minor the efficient cause only, that is; That which is conceived or begotten of another, transfusing, or passing his substance, or part of his substance into the thing begotten; this is of the same essence with him who begot it: Christs flesh was conceived by the holy Ghost; not that he transfused, or passed his substance into flesh begotten, but because in miraculous sort he formed in the Virgins womb of her substance the body of Christ, so that it should not be contaminated or polluted with original sin.
1Object. 2. That which is conceived and begotten of another, is of the same substance with him. The flesh of Christ was conceived of the holy Ghost: Therefore the flesh of Christ is no creature, but came downe from heaven, issuing from the substance of God. Answ. There is a fa••acy in the diverse understanding of the particle of: For that in the Major signi••eth the matter or materiall cause, in the Minor the efficient cause onely, that is; That which is conceived or begotten of another, transfusing, or passing his substance, or part of his substance into the thing begotten; this is of the same essence with him who begot it: Christs flesh was conceived by the holy Ghost; not that he transfused, or passed his substance into flesh begotten, but because in miraculous sort he formed in the Virgins womb of her substance the body of Christ, so that it should not be contaminated or polluted with originall sin.
Object. 3. In God are not two natures. Christ is God: Therefore there are not two natures in him. Ans. Mere particulars do in force nothing. For if the Major be taken universally, it is false: Whosoever is God, in him are not two natures: this general proposition is false. The Major therefore is true, as touching God the Father, and God the holy Ghost, but not as touching God the Son incarnate. Repl. 1. But nothing can be added unto God, by reason of the great perfection and simplicity of his nature. Christ is God▪ Therefore the humanity could not be added to his divine nature. Answ. Nothing can be added to God by way of perfection, that is, whereby his essence may be changed and perfected: but by way of copulation or union. Now, in that God the Word joined the humane nature unto him personally, there came no change or great perfection thereby to the Word which took it, but to the nature which was taken. Repl. 2. Humane nature cannot come unto him, 1who dwelleth in the light that none can come unto. Answ. This is true, if so God of special grace doth not assume and take it unto him. Repl. 3. But it is ignominious for God to be a creature. Christ-man, is God. Answ. The changing of the God-head into a creature, would have been ignominious and reproachful unto the Word, but that the God-head should be united unto a creature, is most glorious unto God, as who by that means hath demonstrated and made known his infinite both goodness, and wisdom, and justice and power, to the whole world.
Object. 3. In God are not two natures. Christ is God: Therefore there are not two natures in him. Ans. Meere particulars doe in force nothing. For if the Major be taken universally, it is false: Whosoever is God, in him are not two natures: this generall proposition is false. The Major therefore is true, as touching God the Father, and God the holy Ghost, but not as touching God the Son incarnate. Repl. 1. But nothing can be added unto God, by reason of the great perfection and simplicity of his nature. Christ is God▪ Therefore the humanity could not be added to his divine nature. Answ. Nothing can be added to God by way of perfection, that is, whereby his essence may be changed and perfected: but by way of copulation or union. Now, in that God the Word joyned the humane nature unto him personally, there came no change or great perfection thereby to the Word which took it, but to the nature which was taken. Repl. 2. Humane nature cannot come unto him,
IN Christ are two perfect natures, whole and distinct: and double properties also and operations natural: but one person, which subsisting in both these natures, divine, and humane, is truly designed by the concrete terms or voices of both natures. For it is requisite that one and the same should be Mediator both by merit, and by power or efficacy. But they who make two persons, make also ⟨p. 276⟩two Christs with Marcion and Nestorius, 1The one a man passive and crucified, the other God, not crucified, and only assisting the man Christ by his grace.
IN Christ are two perfect natures, whole and distinct: and double properties also and operations naturall: but one person, which subsisting in both these natures, divine, and humane, is truly designed by the concrete termes or voyces of both natures. For it is requisite that one and the same should be Mediatour both by merit, and by power or efficacy. But they who make two persons, make also ⟨p. 276⟩two Christs with Marcion and Nestorius, 1The one a man passive and crucified, the other God, not crucified, and only assisting the man Christ by his grace.
Object. 1. In whom are two things, which in themselves make two whole persons, in him also are two persons. But in Christ are two things which make two whole persons: (namely, the Word, which is by it self a person, subsisting from all eternity, and the body and soul, which being united, make likewise a person) Therefore, in Christ are two persons. Answ. We deny that part of the Minor, to wit, That the body and humane soul do, as in other men, so also in Christ, concur to make a created person of the humane nature, and diverse from the person increate and eternal of the Word. For albeit the humane nature in Christ, compounded of a body and reasonable soul, is an individual and particular, or singular substance, as being from other individuals of the same nature distinguished by certain properties and accidents: yet neither was it, or is it a person of subsistence: For, 1. A person is that which is not only a particular, or singular thing, but also it self consisteth, and subsisteth in it self, and by it self, not sustained in, or of any other: but Christs humane nature, now from the very first beginning thereof, dependeth, and is sustained by the person of the Word: For, it was at once both formed and assumed of the Word into unity of person, and made proper unto the Word: before, and without which assumption, or personal Union, it neither was, nor had been, nor should be; so that this Union being dissolved and loosed, it must needs follow, that this flesh, and this soul should be brought to nothing: Therefore Christs humane nature hath not any subsistence, or person proper unto it self. 2. It belongeth to the nature or definition of a person, that it be an individual, incommunicable, and also no part of another. But the nature, which the Word took and assumed, belongeth to the substance of one Christ, a part also of whom it is after a sort: Therefore in it self, and by it self, it is no person.
Object. 1. In whom are two things, which in themselves make two whole persons, in him also are two persons. But in Christ are two things which make two whole persons: (namely, the Word, which is by it selfe a person, subsisting from all eternity, and the body and soule, which being united, make likewise a person) Therefore, in Christ are two persons. Answ. We deny that part of the Minor, to wit, That the body and humane soule doe, as in other men, so also in Christ, concurre to make a created person of the humane nature, and diverse from the person increate and eternall of the Word. For albeit the humane nature in Christ, compounded of a body and reasonable soule, is an individuall and particular, or singular substance, as being from other individuals of the same nature distinguished by certain properties and accidents: yet neither was it, or is it a person of subsistence: For, 1. A person is that which is not only a particular, or singular thing, but also it selfe consisteth, and subsisteth in it selfe, and by it selfe, not sustained in, or of any other: but Christs humane nature, now from the very first beginning thereof, dependeth, and is sustained by the person of the Word: For, it was at once both formed and assumed of the Word into unity of person, and made proper unto the Word: before, and without which assumption, or personall Union, it neither was, nor had been, nor should be; so that this Union being dissolved and loosed, it must needs follow, that this flesh, and this soule should be brought to nothing: Therefore Christs humane nature hath not any subsistence, or person proper unto it selfe. 2. It belongeth to the nature or definition of a person, that it be an individuall, incommunicable, and also no part of another. But the nature, which the Word took and assumed, belongeth to the substance of one Christ, a part also of whom it is after a sort: Therefore in it selfe, and by it selfe, it is no person.
Repl. That which appertaineth to the substance of a person, and is a part thereof, cannot be a person. The Word appertaineth and belongeth to the substance of Christ, and is after a sort a part of him, as well as the humanity: Therefore neither shall the Word be by this reason a person. Answ. That which is part only of a person (that is, is so a part, that besides of it self it is no person) is no person: or, that which is a part of a person, is not a person; true, it is not that person, whose part it is. Thus the Major proposition, if it be understood simply, or universally, is false. For a reasonable soul existing in the body, is not a person, but a part of a humane person, which the soul, together with the body doth make: yet notwithstanding the same soul, being loosed from the body, is a person by it self; not that compound and mortal person, whereof it was a part, that is, an humane person, but a person most simple and immortal, as are the Angels; because it subsisteth our of the body by it self, neither is a part of another: So may it be said of the Word, if it be construed aright, and with indifferency, That the Word in it self, and by it self, is not the whole person of Christ, or the Mediator, as he is Christ and Mediator: that is, is not that whole thing, which is Christ, who is not only God, but also man: and yet is in it self, and by it self, the perfect and whole person of the God head, truly subsisting before the flesh was that is, the only begotten Son of God. For this self fame person existing in it self from everlasting, and remaining for ever most simple and uncompound, is, by the assuming of mans nature, made in time after a sort compound, that is, the Word incarnate. Wherefore, in respect of the person considered in Union, or incarnate, the Word is rather considered as a nature; and both it self, and the humane nature may be called as it were, the parts of whole Christ, and are so called also of many of the ancient Fathers, which were sound in faith; not that the flesh assumed did add any part to the subsistence of the Word: or, as if of the persons of the Word and the humane nature, as being imperfect parts, were made another perfect person of a certain third essence; consubstantial with neither of those two natures, of which it is compounded;
Repl. That which appertaineth to the substance of a person, and is a part thereof, cannot be a person. The Word appertaineth and belongeth to the substance of Christ, and is after a sort a part of him, as well as the humanity: Therefore neither shall the Word be by this reason a person. Answ. That which is part onely of a person (that is, is so a part, that besides of it selfe it is no person) is no person: or, that which is a part of a person, is not a person; true, it is not that person, whose part it is. Thus the Major proposition, if it be understood simply, or universally, is false. For a reasonable soule existing in the body, is not a person, but a part of a humane person, which the soule, together with the body doth make: yet notwithstanding the same soule, being loosed from the body, is a person by it selfe; not that compound and mortall person, whereof it was a part, that is, an humane person, but a person most simple and immortall, as are the Angels; because it subsisteth our of the body by it selfe, neither is a part of another: So may it be said of the Word, if it be construed aright, and with indifferency, That the Word in it selfe, and by it selfe, is not the whole person of Christ, or the Mediatour, as he is Christ and Mediatour: that is, is not that whole thing, which is Christ, who is not only God, but also man: and yet is in it selfe, and by it selfe, the perfect and whole person of the God head, truly subsisting before the flesh was that is, the onely begotten Sonne of God. For this selfe fame person existing in it selfe from everlasting, and remaining for ever most simple and uncompound, is, by the assuming of mans nature, made in time after a sort compound, that is, the Word incarnate. Wherefore, in respect of the person considered in Union, or incarnate, the Word is rather considered as a nature; and both it selfe, and the humane nature may be called as it were, the parts of whole Christ, and are so called also of many of the ancient Fathers, which were sound in faith; not that the flesh assumed did adde any part to the subsistence of the Word: or, as if of the persons of the Word and the humane nature, as being imperfect parts, were made another perfect person of a certain third essence; consubstantiall with neither of those two natures, of which it is compounded;
but because the person of the Word altogether one and the same, which, before the flesh was taken, consisted in the divine nature only, doth now after ⟨p. 277⟩the taking of the flesh, subsist in two perfect natures, divine and humane, suffering no commixtion, confusion, or mutation: that is, The person of the Mediator is said to be constituted of two natures, divine and humane, as it were of parts, because these two are necessarily required, and do concur to the absolving and accomplishing of the work of our redemption. In this sense therefore, both by ancient and later Divines, and also by the Schoolmen, are used well, and without danger, these phrases and speeches: Christs person is compounded: The two natures are, as it were, the parts of Christ: The person of Christ is, consisteth is constituted, is made of, or in the two natures of God and man: The two natures concur, or come together into one person and subsistence: They make one hypostasis, or subsistence: Both natures belong, and concur to the substance of one Christ: Both are of the substance of belong, and concur to the substance of one Christ: Both are of the substance of Christ: The humanity with the Word; or contrary, The divine person or subsistence with the humane nature, doth constitute, or make the substance of one Christ. Of the Word and the flesh assumed, as of substantial parts, doth one Christ consist. By these and the like phrases of speech used of this mystery, singular, and surpassing all capacity of mans wit, the Orthodoxall, that is, men of a right and sound judgement in points of faith, will signify, and some way express this only: That the two natures are so united, and linked in that one person of Christ, as that they exist wholly in that one person or subsistence, which is, perfect and whole, proper to the Word from everlasting by nature; and is, whole, made in time the person of humanity also now assumed and destitute of the proper personality thereof: and this is made by grace of union; so that the divine subsistence, or person of the Word, being in it self most simple, and most perfect, doth notwithstanding subsist truly and individually in the two natures. Wherefore, seeing the thing it self is clear, and agreed upon among them who are of right judgement, and sound in faith, we are not odiously to jar about words;
but because the person of the Word altogether one and the same, which, before the flesh was taken, consisted in the divine nature onely, doth now after ⟨p. 277⟩
especially, sith that concerning these supernatural things, no words of humane speech can be found, which may at all suffice for the expressing of them. But as it is not well said, The person took the person, or the nature took the person: So these speeches are true, and agreeable to faith; The person took the nature: Likewise, The nature took the nature. For the divine Nature is not here considered absolutely, or essentially, but in person of the Word, or personally.
especially, sith that concerning these supernaturall things, no words of humane speech can be found, which may at all suffice for the expressing of them. But as it is not well said, The person took the person, or the nature took the person: So these speeches are true, and agreeable to faith; The person took the nature: Likewise, The nature took the nature. For the divine Nature is not here considered absolutely, or essentially, but in person of the Word, or personally.
Object. 2. God and man are two persons. Christ is God and man: Therefore there are two persons in him. Answ. The Major is true, if we understand it of God and man, as they are not united. But Christ is God and man by Union. In this therefore there is a fallacy of mis-joining some words, and dis joining others. For in the Major God and man are taken dis-junctively, or, both apart: but in the Minor con-junctively, or, both together. Repl. The Word united to it self a body and soul: Therefore a person. Answ. True it is, he united them to himself, but this he did by a personal union: not that this body and soul should as a person subsist apart, or by themselves, but that they might subsist in his person. Repl. 2. If he united the essential parts of a person, he also united a person. But he united the essential parts of a person: Therefore also a person. Answ. The Major is true only of such parts, as subsist by themselves: but Christs body and soul had not subsisted at all, not do subsist now, save in this union of the Word with them. Repl. 3. That which subsisteth not by it self, is more imperfect than that which subsisteth by it self. Christ his humanity doth not subsist by it self. Therefore Christs humanity is more imperfect than ours. Answ. 1. If that which subsisteth by it self be opposed to this, To be an accident, which existeth by being in another, this part of the Minor proposition is false, That Christs humanity doth not subsist by it self: because that also is a substance. But in this disputation, Subsisting by it self, is opposed to that, which is indeed substance, but yet dependeth of another, and consisteth in another, So we say, that man-kind, and the universal, or general kinds of all things do not subsist in themselves, but in their singulars, as the common nature of all men subsisteth not by it self, but in particular men. Wherefore, for further answer, we say, that the Major proposition, being simply and generally taken, is false. For the soul of man being loosed from the body, doth subsist by it self: the same, while it remaineth in the body, subsisteth not by it self, but united with the body: neither ⟨p. 278⟩yet is it therefore to be thought more imperfect, when this rather doth most make to the perfection thereof.
Object. 2. God and man are two persons. Christ is God and man: Therefore there are two persons in him. Answ. The Major is true, if we understand it of God and man, as they are not united. But Christ is God and man by Ʋnion. In this therefore there is a f•llacy of mis-joyning some words, and dis joyning others. For in the Major God and man are taken dis-junctively, or, both apart: but in the Minor con-junctively, or, both together. Repl. The Word united to it selfe a body and soule: Therefore a person. Answ. True it is, he united them to himselfe, but this he did by a personall union: not that this body and soule should as a person subsist apart, or by themselves, but that they might subsist in his person. Repl. 2. If he united the essentiall parts of a person, he also united a person. But he united the essentiall parts of a person: Therefore also a person. Answ. The Major is true only of such parts, as subsist by themselves: but Christs body and soule had not subsisted at all, not doe subsist now, save in this union of the Word with them. Repl. 3. That which subsisteth not by it selfe, is more imperfect than that which subsisteth by it selfe. Christ his humanity doth not subsist by it selfe. Therefore Christs humanity is more imperfect than ours. Answ. 1. If that which subsisteth by it selfe be opposed to this, To be an accident, which existeth by being in another, this part of the Minor proposition is false, That Christs humanity doth not subsist by it selfe: because that also is a substance. But in this disputation, Subsisting by it selfe, is opposed to that, which is indeed substance, but yet dependeth of another, and consisteth in another, So we say, that man-kind, and the universall, or generall kinds of all things doe not subsist in themselves, but in their singulars, as the common nature of all men subsisteth not by it selfe, but in particular men. Wherefore, for further answer, we say, that the Major proposition, being simply and generally taken, is false. For the soule of man being loosed from the body, doth subsist by it selfe: the same, while it remaineth in the body, subsisteth not by it selfe, but united with the body: neither
For it is created of God to this purpose, that it should, together with the body, constitute and absolve the essence of man, and should be a part thereof. So the soul and body of Christ were created to that end, as to be the proper soul and body of the Son of God, and to depend personally of him. That therefore Christs humanity hath his subsistence not in a created person proper unto it by nature, but in the eternal hypostasis and person of the Word, it is so far from bringing any imperfection thereunto (for the subsistence or manner of subsisting doth not change the nature or essence of a thing) that rather the greatest ornament, glory, and eminency cometh thereby unto it: and this is the chief and principal difference, whereby it differeth and is discerned from all men, and also from the blessed Angels.
For it is created of God to this purpose, that it should, together with the body, constitute and absolve the essence of man, and should be a part thereof. So the soule and body of Christ were created to that end, as to be the proper soule and body of the Son of God, and to depend personally of him. That therefore Christs humanity hath his subsistence not in a created person proper unto it by nature, but in the eternall hypostasis and person of the Word, it is so farre from bringing any imperfection thereunto (for the subsistence or manner of subsisting doth not change the nature or essence of a thing) that rather the greatest ornament, glory, and eminency cometh thereby unto it: and this is the chiefe and principall difference, whereby it differeth and is discerned from all men, and also from the blessed Angels.
Object.1 3. A dead and an everliving thing are not the same subsistent, or person. Christ was dead, and yet everliving: Therefore he is not one person. Ans. The Major is either particular: or being taken generally, it is false. For one and the same subsistent, truly and individually subsisting in divers natures, even as Christ is, may be said to be dead and everliving: as one and the same man, is both mortal and immortal in respect of divers natures, whereof he is made and doth consist.
Object.1 3. A dead and an everliving thing are not the same subsistent, or person. Christ was dead, and yet everliving: Therefore he is not one person. Ans. The Major is either particular: or being taken generally, it is false. For one and the same subsistent, truly and individually subsisting in divers natures, even as Christ is, may be said to be dead and everliving: as one and the same man, is both mortall and immortall in respect of divers natures, whereof he is made and doth consist.
The Union of the flesh with the Word was not made in the essence or nature, or in any essential property, but in the person of the Word. That this may be the better understood, we must observe: 1. What it is to be united in nature, or into nature. 2. What likewise to be united in person, or into, or unto one person, or according to subsistence.
THe Union of the flesh with the Word was not made in the essence or nature, or in any essentiall property, but in the person of the Word. That this may be the better understood, we must observe: 1. What it is to be united in nature, or into nature. 2. What likewise to be united in person, or into, or unto one person, or according to subsistence.
1First, Those things are said to be united in nature or essence, which, as essential parts, are coupled to the full perfection or constitution of one nature, or essence, or kind; that is,§1 which make a perfect and whole essence or kind, and are one essence or substance. So the soul and body are united to constitute or make the kind, or essence, or nature of man; that is, are some one and perfect man. Whatsoever things then are essential parts of a perfect thing, they are said to be united in nature, and unto, or into one nature. §2Secondly, those things also are said to be united in nature or essence, which are one in nature, essence, or kind; or, which are one essence, or of one essence & nature: or, have one common essence or unity of nature; or, are joined and agree in one essence. So two men are said to be united in nature; that is, are one in kind, or of the same humane nature. The three persons of the God-head are united in essence; that is, are one in essence, or are of one and the same divine essence in number, or have the same God-head in common. So likewise, To be united in properties or perfections natural, or essential, is to get or have the same,2 or like equal properties essential. Which is indeed nothing else, than to be made, and be one nature, or moe substances of the same nature and essence. So two men are united in natural properties and perfections, because they have the same in kind, or the like, and therefore are of the same humane nature. The air in the chimney, which getteth the perfections or qualities of the fire as being now become a flame, and the fire of the burning coals, which fireth and inflameth the air next unto it, are two substances of the same properties, and fiery nature, and therefore are said to be united in nature and essential properties; that is, they are two fires in number, but in kind and nature they are one. Likewise the three divine persons are united in essential properties; that is, have the same essential properties: which is nothing else, but that they are one essence, one and the same God.
1First, Those things are said to be united in nature or essence, which, as essentiall parts, are coupled to the full perfection or constitution of one nature, or essence, or kind; that is,§1
Those things are said to be united in person, which are one person; that is, which although they differ in natural properties, yet exist in one and the same individual subsistence: or have altogether the same subsistence. So the soul and body of man are united and concur unto one person, because they being united, do make one person, or one subsistent, incommunicable, not sustained in another, or of another. The Father, the Son, and the holy Ghost, are not united in person, or personal properties: because they have these, not the same, but distinct. By this which hath been said, it is manifest, that the Union in nature and natural perfections, is an equality of properties and nature; but the personal union is, when two unlike natures are coupled, so that each retaineth his natural properties and operations whole and distinct, but yet have both one and the same subsistence wholly: or, it is the joining of two natures different in properties, to constitute the substance of one individual, or person; that is, such a connection or knitting of them together, as they are one individual, subsisting by it self, or the substance of one individual.
THose things are said to be united in person, which are one person; that is, which although they differ in naturall properties, yet exist in one and the same individuall subsistence: or have altogether the same subsistence. So the soule and body of man are united and concurre unto one person, because they being united, doe make one person, or one subsistent, incommunicable, not sustained in another, or of another. The Father, the Sonne, and the holy Ghost, are not united in person, or personall properties: because they have these, not the same, but distinct. By this which hath been said, it is manifest, that the Union in nature and naturall perfections, is an equality of properties and nature; but the personall union is, when two unlike natures are coupled, so that each retaineth his naturall properties and operations whole and distinct, but yet have both one and the same subsistence wholly: or, it is the joyning of two natures different in properties, to constitute the substance of one individuall, or person; that is, such a connexion or knitting of them together, as they are one individuall, subsisting by it selfe, or the substance of one individuall.
But that in Christ the Union of the flesh with the Word is not essential, 1made in the nature, or any essential property of the God head, is showed by these reasons: §11. Of the God-head and flesh assumed, there ariseth not any third Essence: but each is, and abideth an Essence so perfect and whole, as neither (especially the Divine, as being in it self a person, and simply void of all change) cometh into the composition or compounding (as we properly take this word) of the other. §22. If the Union of the flesh with the word were essential, it would follow, that the humanity, once assumed and taken, was equalled with the God-head in essential properties, & so by a consequent, to be made of the same nature and essence with the Word. So Vigilius showeth,2 that the Eutychians held two substances to be in Christ of the same nature. Wherefore, they who will have the essential properties of the God-head to be really communicated and common with the flesh, so that the flesh should truly and really be, and be called omnipotent, omniscient, and whatsoever else the God-head is: they indeed (howsoever in words they mightily stand against it) hold this Union to be made in essential properties and in nature, and both with Eutyches and Swenckfield, they confound both natures, and take away the difference between the creature and the Creator: and also with Nestorius, they frame and make two persons, and so bring in a quaternity. For albeit they say, that they in their confusion, or (as themselves call it with their Master Swenckfield) deifying and majestical exaltation of the flesh, do retain the substance of the flesh: yet two substances, having really the same and like perfections, are two subsistents or persons of one nature, as are two men, and whatsoever other individuals of the same kind or nature. Lastly, with Sabellius and the Patripassians they incarnate the whole Trinity. For there is one and the same essence in number of the divine person, and the same essential properties. Wherefore, that which is united, and equalled with one of these three according to essence, must needs be also united, and equalled with the rest.
But that in Christ the Ʋnion of the flesh with the Word is not essentiall, 1
Wherefore the Union of both natures in Christ is personal, or, according to the subsistence proper unto the Word, both natures keeping and retaining in that Union, their properties whole and unconfounded. For the Word did not, by uniting humane nature unto it, make the same God-head, or God, and omnipotent, immense, and infinite: but it took the manhood, which retaineth still the properties belonging unto it, and so did join and knit it unto it self, as to be one person with it, and the substance of one Christ. Neither is it absurd, that a thing which neither is made, or is one with another in kind, neither any Homogeneall part thereof, should yet exist in the same subsistence with it, or should subsist in it self, wherewith it is united. For a graft hath his subsisting in a tree of another nature or kind. The same is the subsistence both of the sprig engrafted, & of the tree sustaining the sprig: that is, they are one and the same individual tree; yet have they, and so do reaine ⟨p. 280⟩natures in properties most diverse. The like reason is there in the two natures of Christ, both subsisting in, or of the same person of the Son. Object. The humane nature is united with the Word in person, but not in nature: Therefore the person is divorced and sundered from the nature. Again, The person only of the Son is united with the humane nature: Therefore not the divine nature it self of the Word. Answ. In both these arguments is a fallacy from that which is no cause, as if it were a cause, and both offend in this: for that they, who so reason against the maintainers of true doctrine, and men sound in faith, either know not, or are not willing to distinguish between these two phrases of speech, To be united in nature, and to be united to, or with a nature: when notwithstanding, the difference is very great, and most familiar, and known unto the Schoolmen. For, To be united in nature is to be equalled, that is, to be made one essence or nature with another: To be united to, or with a nature, is to be coupled and joined therewith to one subsistence or personality. Wherefore the flesh is united to, or with the Word, not in nature, or in essential properties;
Wherefore the Union of both natures in Christ is personall, or, according to the subsistence proper unto the Word, both natures keeping and retaining in that Union, their properties whole and unconfounded. For the Word did not, by uniting humane nature unto it, make the same God-head, or God, and omnipotent, immense, and infinite: but it took the manhood, which retaineth still the properties belonging unto it, and so did joyn and knit it unto it selfe, as to be one person with it, and the substance of one Christ. Neither is it absurd, that a thing which neither is made, or is one with another in kind, neither any Homogeneall part thereof, should yet exist in the same subsistence with it, or should subsist in it self, wherwith it is united. For a graffe hath his subsisting in a tree of another nature or kind. The same is the subsistence both of the sprig ingraffed, & of the tree sustaining the sprig: that is, they are one and the same individuall tree; yet have they, and so doe reaine
that is, it is not made with the Word one essence, neither made equal unto it in omnipotency, wisdom, and nature (for so should the whole Trinity be incarnate) Yet it is united to the omnipotency, wisdom, nature, and essence of God, not simply, but of God the Word. Now, this is nothing else, than the flesh to be united to the person of the Son, or to the Word in person, which person is the very divine nature or essence, omnipotent, wise, and whatsoever else is proper to the God-head.
that is, it is not made with the Word one essence, neither made equall unto it in omnipotency, wisdome, and nature (for so should the whole Trinity be incarnate) Yet it is united to the omnipotencie, wisdome, nature, and essence of God, not simply, but of God the Word. Now, this is nothing else, than the flesh to be united to the person of the Sonne, or to the Word in person, which person is the very divine nature or essence, omnipotent, wise, and whatsoever else is proper to the God-head.
But albeit the flesh taken or assumed is truly united, both to the person, and to the nature of the Word. (For the person is not any several thing, or really differing from the essence, but is the essence it self): yet is it well said, that the flesh is united to the Word in person only: and likewise, that the person only of the Word is incarnate. The reasons hereof are, 1. Because, not the Father, nor the holy Ghost were incarnate, but the Son only. 2. Because the first and nearest term of this union is the person only of the Word, assuming and taking the flesh, but not the God-head. For the person only is proper unto the Word: the essence of the God-head is common to him, and the same with the Father and the holy Ghost. This is plainly taught by the sixth Toletan Council,1 in these words: in these words: The Son only took the humanity in singularity of person, not in the unity of divine nature; that is, in that which is proper unto the person, not which is common to the Trinity. And Rusticus in his Dialogue against the Acephalists: Not God the Word by the divine nature; but the divine nature by the person of God the Word, is said to be united to the flesh. And a little after: Wherefore both God the Word and his nature is incarnate: he by himself, and in that he is in himself: his nature not so, but by the person. God the Word then as touching himself, is united to the flesh; for he is made one person, and one subsistence with the flesh: but as touching his nature, he is conjoined rather than united; because there remain still two natures.
But albeit the flesh taken or assumed is truly united, both to the person, and to the nature of the Word. (For the person is not any severall thing, or really differing from the essence, but is the essence it selfe): yet is it well said, that the flesh is united to the Word in person onely: and likewise, that the person onely of the Word is incarnate. The reasons hereof are, 1. Because, not the Father, nor the holy Ghost were incarnate, but the Sonne onely. 2. Because the first and neerest terme of this union is the person only of the Word, assuming and taking the flesh, but not the God-head. For the person onely is proper unto the Word: the essence of the God-head is common to him, and the same with the Father and the holy Ghost. This is plainly taught by the sixth Toletan Councell,1 in these words: in these words: The Sonne onely took the humanity in singularity of person, not in the unity of divine nature; that is, in that which is proper unto the person, not which is common to the Trinity. And Rusticus in his Dialogue against the Acephalists: Not God the Word by the divine nature; but the divine nature by the person of God the Word, is said to be united to the flesh. And a little after: Wherefore both God the Word and his nature is incarnate: he by himselfe, and in that he is in himselfe: his nature not so, but by the person. God the Word then as touching himselfe, is united to the flesh; for he is made one person, and one subsistence with the flesh: but as touching his nature, he is conjoyned rather than united; because there remaine still two natures.
Wherefore either foul and shameful is the folly, or notorious the malice and slander of certain smatterers, that of this very Orthodoxall and sound position, not of the Schoolmen only, but of Councils also, and ancient Fathers, (viz. The flesh is united to the Word, in person only, or according to subsistence, and this only maketh the proper difference of personal union) they infer, that by this means the divine nature of the Word is drawn away from the personal union. But let them again, and again look unto it, lest by that their real communicating of the essential properties of the God-head (which are the very divine Essence common to the Son with the Father and the holy Ghost) which communication they will have to be the personal union, which they define by it, they overthrow as well the eternal God-head of Christ, man, as also the manhood it self; and withal plainly incarnate the whole Trinity.
Wherefore either foule and shamefull is the folly, or notorious the malice and slander of certaine smatterers, that of this very Orthodoxall and sound position, not of the Schoolemen onely, but of Councels also, and ancient Fathers, (viz. The flesh is united to the Word, in person onely, or according to subsistence, and this onely maketh the proper difference of personall union) they inferre, that by this meanes the divine nature of the Word is drawne away from the personall union. But let them againe, and againe look unto it, lest by that their reall communicating of the essentiall properties of the God-head (which are the very divine Essence common to the Sonne with the Father and the holy Ghost) which communication they will have to be the personall union, which they define by it, they overthrow as well the eternall God-head of Christ, man, as also the manhood it selfe; and withall plainly incarnate the whole Trinity.
That then one and the same Christ is, and is called truly and really the very eternal God, immense, omnipotent, Creator; and true natural man, finite, weak, subject to passion, and sufferings, and a creature: the only cause is the unity of person subsisting in two natures perfect, whole, and really distinct, divine & humane. For every individual ⟨p. 281⟩and person is denominated or named of the natures or forms, and their properties and operations concurring or subsisting in it. Wherefore, seeing in the same individual person of the Word do truly subsist, and belong to the substance of one Christ, these two most divers natures; unto one and the same Christ, of which soever nature he be called, do agree, and are affirmed of him all the attributes and properties, both divine and humane, but after a diverse manner: For, the attributes which agree to Christ in respect of the personal union, are of two sorts: some are attributes or properties of the natures, others of his office. The natural attributes are those, which are proper to each nature; whether the same be essential, belonging to the essence of the thing, or which necessarily follow and accompany it, without which the nature cannot consist: or accidental, which may be away and wanting without the destruction of the nature. The essential properties and perfections of the God-head are, To be eternal, uncreate, immense, every where present, not to be circumscribed in place, omnipotent, omniscient, and the like; which are the very essence of the God-head; as also to create, to give the holy Ghost, to regenerate. The essential attributes of the humanity are, To have a soul understanding, immortal, and a body compounded of the elements, consisting of skin, blood, flesh, bones, veins and sinews, having a certain and definite greatness figure, proportion, and collocation, or locablenesse of parts: and therefore to be circumscribed in one place, to be solid, visible, palpable, and such like. These Christ retaineth for ever, because without these, nothing can be a humane nature. The accidental properties of the humanity are those infirmities which ensued upon sin: which infirmities, Christ, together with the humane nature it self, assumed, and took without sin. For he took the form of a servant, which by his Resurrection and Ascension he laid down again.
That then one and the same Christ is, and is called truly and really the very eternall God, immense, omnipotent, Creatour; and true naturall man, finite, weak, subject to passion, and sufferings, and a creature: the only cause is the unity of person subsisting in two natures perfect, whole, and really distinct, divine & humane. For every individuall
The attributes of his office are called those, which agree not to one nature only, but to both together; that is, it agreeth to the whole person, according to both natures, as being the compound of both.
The attributes of his office are called those, which agree not to one nature onely, but to both together; that is, it agreeth to the whole person, according to both natures, as being the compound of both.
Both natures, and their properties are truly and really affirmed of the person and of themselves interchangeably, in concrete terms or voices: yet so, that the proper predicate, which is proper unto one nature, is attributed to the person, not according to both natures, but according to that only, to which it is proper. The reason is, for that one and the same persons subsisting in two natures, hath, and retaineth for ever, really, the properties of both natures: and also, because one and the same person is signified by the concrete voices of both natures. And therefore one and the same man is living and corporeal according to diverse natures, and the corporeal is living by the soul only; and contrarily, the living is corporeal by the body only (for both soul and body are of the substance and essence of the same man): so likewise one and the same Christ is God eternal, immense, omnipotent, according to the God-head only: is man, the Virgins Son, created, finite, infirm, and did suffer, according to his humanity only: so likewise, God is man, borne of a Virgin, anointed with the holy Ghost, and suffered, according to the flesh; And, man is God, eternal, creator, omnipotent, giveth the holy Ghost, not according to the humane nature, but according to the divine. For the sense and meaning of these speeches is: The person which is God, Creator of all things, omnipotent, by reason of the God-head; the self same person is man, a creature, infirm, by reason of the flesh subsisting in it.
BOth natures, and their properties are truly and really affirmed of the person and of themselves interchangeably, in concrete terms or voyces: yet so, that the proper predicate, which is proper unto one nature, is attributed to the person, not according to both natures, but according to that onely, to which it is proper. The reason is, for that one and the same persons subsisting in two natures, hath, and retaineth for ever, really, the properties of both natures: and also, because one and the same person is signified by the concrete voyces of both natures. And therefore one and the same man is living and corporeall according to diverse natures, and the corporeall is living by the soule only; and contrarily, the living is corporeall by the body onely (for both soule and body are of the substance and essence of the same man): so likewise one and the same Christ is God eternall, immense, omnipotent, according to the God-head onely: is man, the Virgins Son, created, finite, infirme, and did suffer, according to his humanity onely: so likewise, God is man, borne of a Virgin, annointed with the holy Ghost, and suffered, according to the flesh; And, man is God, eternall, creatour, omnipotent, giveth the holy Ghost, not according to the humane nature, but according to the divine. For the sense and meaning of these speeches is: The person which is God, Creatour of all things, omnipotent, by reason of the God-head; the selfe same person is man, a creature, infirme, by reason of the flesh subsisting in it.
But, notwithstanding, one nature, and the properties thereof, whether they be uttered in abstract, or in concrete voices, cannot be affirmed of the other nature or form, truly and really. The reason is: Because the union is not made in the nature; that is, two natures are not made one nature: and because in neither nature, the properties of the other do really exist, neither can exist. For the natures do not communicate each to other their essential properties, as neither do these impart their essence; that is, one nature doth not receive the properties of both natures. Wherefore these kinds of speeches are false: The God-head is the man-hood, or man; was conceived, borne, did ⟨p. 282⟩suffer, was dead: and again, these: The man-hood is the God-head, or God, is eternal, immense, uncircumscribed in place, omnipotent, giveth the holy Ghost, doth regenerate. For all these are no more true, and to be admitted than those, A soul is a body, or corporeal, mortal, visible; and a body is a soul, or a spirit, invisible, immortal.
But, notwithstanding, one nature, and the properties thereof, whether they be uttered in abstract, or in concrete voyces, cannot be affirmed of the other nature or forme, truly and really. The reason is: Because the union is not made in the nature; that is, two natures are not made one nature: and because in neither nature, the properties of the other doe really exist, neither can exist. For the natures doe not communicate each to other their essentiall properties, as neither doe these impart their essence; that is, one nature doth not receive the properties of both natures. Wherefore these kinds of speeches are false: The God-head is the man-hood, or man; was conceived, borne, did ⟨p. 282⟩suffer, was dead: and againe, these: The man-hood is the God-head, or God, is eternall, immense, uncircumscribed in place, omnipotent, giveth the holy Ghost, doth regenerate. For all these are no more true, and to be admitted than those, A soule is a body, or corporeall, mortall, visible; and a body is a soule, or a spirit, invisible, immortall.
Object. 1. The whole person of Christ is really omnipotent, everywhere, eternal, &c. The humanity and the God-head are the whole person of Christ: Therefore both are really omnipotent, every where, eternal, &c. Answ. This argument the Ubiquitaries, who most of all ground upon it, and often use it, have borrowed from Schwenkfeldians, who commonly in their books reason thus: Whole Christ is the natural and only begotten Son of God, is the true and the same God, of the same infinite power and majesty with the eternal Father, conceived, borne of the Virgin, suffered, was dead, rose again, ascendeth into heaven, sendeth the holy Ghost. But both natures belong to the whole person of Christ: Therefore Christ, according to his humanity also, is the natural Son of God, begotten of the substance of the Father from everlasting, and consubstantial with the Father, and the same God with the Father, who is Creator of all. If then the Ubiquitaries collection be lawful also and sound, this doubtless of the Schwenkfeldians, is lawful also and sound: but if the Schwenkfeldians collection be corrupt, and smelling of Eutyches heresy, then that of the Ubiquitaries cannot be at all good and sound. But indeed, both collections are Eutychian and Sophistical. They are Eutychian because two natures, which are made equal in properties essential, or, which get, and have the same, or equal essential properties, are indeed made one nature and substance, or are two substances of one nature: both which opinions take clean away the nature of the humanity, and trans-form it into the God-head: but the latter doth further make two persons in Christ of the same nature. They are also Sophistical: because, whether the person of Christ be considered in it self, as it was a person being but one and perfect, and before the incarnation, subsisting in one nature only: or whether it be considered, as it is incarnate, and now subsisting in two natures; yet still the transition and passing from the person to the nature, is faulty and Sophistical. For neither is it necessary that what is truly in, and attributed unto a person, the same also should be really in all things concurring in that person, and be affirmed of all. The reason is, because the parts, or natures, though united in the same person, yet retain their properties and operations unconfounded.
Object. 1. The whole person of Christ is really omnipotent, everywhere, eternall, &c. The humanity and the God-head are the whole person of Christ: Therefore both are really omnipotent, every where, eternall, &c. Answ. This argument the Ubiquitaries, who most of all ground upon it, and often use it, have borrowed from Swenkfieldians, who commonly in their books reason thus: Whole Christ is the naturall and onely begotten Sonne of God, is the true and the same God, of the same infinite power and majesty with the eternall Father, conceived, borne of the Virgin, suffered, was dead, rose againe, ascendeth into heaven, sendeth the holy Ghost. But both natures belong to the whole person of Christ: Therefore Christ, according to his humanity also, is the naturall Sonne of God, begotten of the substance of the Father from everlasting, and consubstantiall with the Father, and the same God with the Father, who is Creatour of all. If then the Ubiquitaries collection be lawfull also and sound, this doubtlesse of the Swenkfieldians, is lawfull also and sound: but if the Swenkfieldians collection be corrupt, and smelling of Eutyches heresie, then that of the Ubiquitaries cannot be at all good and sound. But indeed, both collections are Eutychian and Sophisticall. They are Eutychian because two natures, which are made equall in properties essentiall, or, which get, and have the same, or equall essentiall properties, are indeed made one nature and substance, or are two substances of one nature: both which opinions take clean away the nature of the humanity, and trans-form it into the God-head: but the latter doth further make two persons in Christ of the same nature. They are also Sophisticall: because, whether the person of Christ be considered in it selfe, as it was a person being but one and perfect, and before the incarnation, subsisting in one nature onely: or whether it be considered, as it is incarnate, and now subsisting in two natures; yet still the transition and passing from the person to the nature, is faulty and Sophisticall. For neither is it necessary that what is truly in, and attributed unto a person, the same also should be really in all things concurring in that person, and be affirmed of all. The reason is, because the parts, or natures, though united in the same person, yet retaine their properties and operations unconfounded.
Wherefore, that which is proper unto the God-head, cannot agree unto the person, in respect of the flesh also, but only in respect of the God-head. Whole man understandeth, discourseth, and hath motion of will; yet he doth not this by his finger or body, but by his mind only: whole man is mortal, and doth go, eat, and drink; yet none but a mad-man, or an Epicure, will therefore say, that the soul also is mortal, or doth go, eat, or drink. So not half, but the whole person of Christ was before Abraham, and from everlasting did create, and doth preserve all things, and took flesh: But the flesh neither was from everlasting, neither did create, nor doth preserve all things, nor took flesh, but was created; and being assumed and taken, is sustained of the Word, and in it. So whole Christ was wounded and dead, yet not his God-head, nor his soul. This is well and learnedly declared and explicated by Damascene, in these words, Whole Christ is perfect God, but not the whole of Christ: that is, not both natures are God. For he is not God only, 1but also man. And Whole Christ is the perfect man, but not the Whole of Christ is man. For he is not man only, but God too. For the Whole, signifieth the nature: Whole, the person.
Wherefore, that which is proper unto the God-head, cannot agree unto the person, in respect of the flesh also, but only in respect of the God-head. Whole man understandeth, discourseth, and hath motion of will; yet he doth not this by his finger or body, but by his mind only: whole man is mortall, and doth go, eat, and drink; yet none but a mad-man, or an Epicure, will therefore say, that the soule also is mortall, or doth go, eat, or drink. So not halfe, but the whole person of Christ was before Abraham, and from everlasting did create, and doth preserve all things, and took flesh: But the flesh neither was from everlasting, neither did create, nor doth preserve all things, nor took flesh, but was created; and being assumpted and taken, is sustained of the Word, and in it. So whole Christ was wounded and dead, yet not his God-head, nor his soule. This is well and learnedly declared and explicated by Damascene, in these words, Whole Christ is perfect God, but not the whole of Christ: that is, not both natures are God. For he is not God onely, 1but also man. And Whole Christ is the perfect man, but not the Whole of Christ is man. For he is not man onely, but God too. For the Whole, signifieth the nature: Whole, the person.
Wherefore if the Ubiquitaries will at all have the illation and enforcing of their conclusion on these premisses to be necessary; the Major proposition must be expounded after this sort: The person is God, creator, omnipotent, every where whole, that is, as concerning all that, which it is, or in which it doth subsist, or which doth belong unto it. But the Major taken in this sense, is false, and most absurd, as was showed a little before: For the true sense thereof is this; The person is every where whole, that is, without division or sundering of natures, or subsisting undividably in two natures. But the humanity is not that whole subsisting in two natures. Not every thing then that agreeth really to the person, agreeth also really to the flesh. And albeit ⟨p. 283⟩the person doth subsist in the humanity and the God-head mutually, united one to the other: yet, as it hath been said, it is not hereof enforced, that, because the person is every where, therefore the humanity should be, in proper substance, present every where. For this is proper to the God-head, neither is it really communicated to any creature, or is in any. Rep. The divinity is one person in all places, but especially with the Church. The divinity is but half Christ: therefore only half Christ is present with the Church. Answ. 1. There is an ambiguity and doubtfulness in the words, half Christ: For, if by half Christ, they understand one nature, which is united to the other in the same person, the whole reason may be granted: namely, that not both, but one nature only of Christ, though united to the other, that is, his God-head, is present with us, and all things, in his proper substance, in all places, and at all times. But they, by half Christ, understand, craftily and sophistically, the one nature separated from the other: as if the God-head were made to be with us bare and naked, and not incarnate. But in this sense the Minor is false, and the Ubiquitaries own invention. For the same Word, by reason of the immenseness, and infinity of his essence, is whole every where, without his manhood; yet so, that he withal is, and abideth whole in his manhood, personally united thereunto. Wherefore, the Word neither is, nor worketh any where not united to the flesh;
Wherefore if the Ubiquitaries will at all have the illation and enforcing of their conclusion on these premisses to be necessary; the Major proposition must be expounded after this sort: The person is God, creatour, omnipotent, every where whole, that is, as concerning all that, which it is, or in which it doth subsist, or which doth belong unto it. But the Major taken in this sense, is false, and most absurd, as was shewed a little before: For the true sense thereof is this; The person is every where whole, that is, without division or sundring of natures, or subsisting undividably in two natures. But the humanity is not that whole subsisting in two natures. Not every thing then that agreeth really to the person, agreeth also really to the flesh. And albeit
Against these and the like errors,1 the sentence and doctrine of the Church is confirmed By plaine places of Scripture, which testifie, Christ, Maries §12Son, to have been made like unto us in all things, that is, in essence, in properties, in infirmities, sin only excepted. Loe, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and beare a Son. Seeing then the Virgin conceived this her Son in her womb, bare it untill the usuall time of delivery, and was delivered of it, as other women use to be of their children; it followeth, that his flesh was nor brought from heaven, or else-where taken, which should but passe onely through the womb of the Virgin, but was formed in the Virgins ⟨p. 274⟩womb, of her seed and substance. He that sanctifieth, and they which are sanctified, are all of one: 3wherefore he is not ashamed to call them brethren. And a little after: For as much as the children were partakers of flesh and bloud, he also himselfe likewise took part with them. Againe, In all things it became him to be like to his brethren: Therefore he hath a humane nature of the same kinde wholly with ours: Hereof he is called, The fruit of Maries womb, 4The first begotten Sonne of Mary, Made of a woman, The seed of Abraham, Made of the seed of David, Borne of the Jewes concerning the flesh, The Sonne of Abraham, of David, and the Sonne of man. And also his pedegree and stock, concerning the flesh, is deduced unto Adam: Therefore he was begotten of the substance of his mother, and issued from the same seed of Adam, from which we did. Christ proveth himselfe to be a true man, and not a spirit, by this, that a spirit hath no flesh and bones, as he hath, and retaineth, even after his resurrection. Apollinaris the Heretick said,5 That Christs body indeed was a true body; but instead of a soule, he had the Word onely. But this man is easily refuted, because Christ should not then have been like unto his brethren in all things, except sinne. And Christ himselfe doth plainly confesse,6 My soule is very heavie, even unto the death. He is said to have increased in wisdome, and stature, and in favour with God and men: and, to lay downe his soule, and take it againe. But, to increase in wisdome, and, To be heavie and sad, doe neither agree unto a body, which is a reasonlesse thing: neither unto the Godhead, which is not obnoxious to changes and passions.