8. Whether the Elect may fall from the Church, and the Reprobate abide always in the Church.8. Whether the Elect may fall from the Church, and the Reprobate abide alwayes in the Church.
pp. 359–3602 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1This question is declared and laid open by those things which are spoken of the unchangeableness of Election, and of the perseverance of the Saints and godly. The Elect, when they are once indeed come unto the Church of the Saints, they may sometimes fall from it, but wholly and finally forsake it they never can. Not wholly: because they never so defect or fall, that they can become enemies of God and the Church. Not finally; because they persist not in this Apostasy, but at length return to repentance. They went out from us, but they were not of us:
for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us. A bruised reed shall he not break: and the smoking flax shall he not quench. No man shall pluck my sheep out of my hand. All the reprobate and hypocrites do at length finally depart from the Church, and,
together with those gifts which they had, they lose also those gifts which they seem to have. Object. The godly also oftentimes fall away, as David and Peter. Answ. They fall, but neither wholly, nor finally: Which also befell unto Peter; for he retained still in his mind the love of Christ, although for fear of danger he denied him. He acknowledged also afterwards his offence, and did truly repent him thereof. Saint Augustine prettily saith: Peters faith failed not in his heart, when open confession with the mouth failed him. David also did not wholly fall away, but being rebuked of the Lord by the Prophet, he truly repented, and showed that his
⟨p. 360⟩
faith was not quite dead, but in a slumber rather for a season: therefore he prayeth on this wise;
Take not thine holy Spirit from me. Wherefore the saints and the elect of God never fall away; but hypocrites and the reprobate do at length wholly and finally revolt and fall away; for they do so at last fall away, that they never return to repentance: And because the true love of God was never in them, and so neither themselves ever were of the number of Gods elect saints; therefore no marvel though at length they wholly and altogether depart and fall away from the Church.
1THis question is declared and laid open by those things which are spoken of the unchangeablenesse of Election, and of the perseverance of the Saints and godly. The Elect, when they are once indeed come unto the Church of the Saints, they may sometimes fall from it, but wholly and finally forsake it they never can. Not wholly: because they never so defect or fall, that they can become enemies of God and the Church. Not finally; because they persist not in this Apostasie, but at length returne to repentance. They went out from us, but they were not of us: 2for if they had beene of us, they would have continued with us. A bruised reed shall he not break: and the smoaking flaxe shall he not quench. No man shall pluck my sheep out of my hand. All the reprobate and hypocrites do at length finally depart from the Church, and,3 together with those gifts which they had, they lose also those gifts which they seeme to have. Object. The godly also oftentimes fall away, as David and Peter. Answ. They fall, but neither wholly, nor finally: Which also befell unto Peter; for he retained still in his mind the love of Christ, although for fear of danger he denied him. He acknowledged also afterwards his offence, and did truly repent him thereof. Saint Angustine prettily saith: Peters faith failed not in his heart, when open confession with the mouth failed him. David also did not wholly fall away, but being rebuked of the Lord by the Prophet, he truly repented, and shewed that his ⟨p. 360⟩faith was not quite dead, but in a slumber rather for a season: therefore he prayeth on this wise;4 Take not thine holy Spirit from me. Wherefore the saints and the elect of God never fall away; but hypocrites and the reprobate doe at length wholly and finally revolt and fall away; for they doe so at last fall away, that they never return to repentance: And because the true love of God was never in them, and so neither themselves ever were of the number of Gods elect saints; therefore no marvell though at length they wholly and altogether depart and fall away from the Church.
1The Elect cannot fall wholly and finally from the Church.