OF THE LORDS SUPPER.
pp. 426–498279 passagespart 6 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 426–498279 passagespart 6 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Cyril upon John saith, By natural participation, not only spiritually, but also corporally: not only according to the spirit, but also according to the flesh corporally and essentially. Answ. Cyril speaketh not of the manner of eating, but of the thing which was to be eaten. He showeth that we are made partakers not only of Christs spirit, but also of his humane nature. Now he understandeth a spiritual communion: 1. Because he citeth those places concerning it, John 6. & 1 Cor. 10. where no mention is made of corporal eating. 2. He speaketh of the presence of Christ, not in the bread, but in us. 3. He proveth the abiding of Christ in us, by the use of the Supper, not by any corporal eating. 4. He so describeth it, that he saith, It shall continue in the life to come. 5. He speaketh of that ⟨p. 476⟩communion which is proper unto the saints. Now this is spiritual, for otherwise it should befall also to the wicked. The shifts of Consubstantiaries, whereby they go about to elude and shift off certain of our objections, not all; for moe are objected against them. 1. We make not, say they, any Capernaiticall eating. Ans. We demand of them whether Christ be eaten by the bodily mouth; be it after a gross, or after a finer manner. But how ever they answer; in that opinion which they hold there is too too much idolatry: for Christ refuting the Capernaites, doth not distinguish the eating of him into a gross and a finer manner; but saith simply, That his body cannot be eaten with the bodily mouth: for he saith, that he must ascend: And, that the words which he speaketh are spirit and life. 2. We maintain not Ubiquity, for there is not a word thereof to be found. Ans. Here is to be observed the dissension of the adversaries about Ubiquity. But neither is a word to be found hereof, That the body of Christ is together in two places. And further, of this their opinion followeth Ubiquity: For he that is together and at one time in moe places, must needs be infinite, and therefore every-where. 3. We overthrow not the article of Christs ascension. Ans. Yea, but they do overthrow it. For, while they hold that as often as the Supper is celebrated, Christ is corporally eaten, they must needs say that he remaineth and is invisible on earth.
Cyril upon John saith, By naturall participation, not onely spiritually, but also corporally: not onely according to the spirit, but also according to the flesh corporally and essentially. Answ. Cyril speaketh not of the manner of eating, but of the thing which was to be eaten. He sheweth that we are made partakers not only of Christs spirit, but also of his humane nature. Now he understandeth a spirituall communion: 1. Because hee citeth those places concerning it, John 6. & 1 Cor. 10. where no mention is made of corporall eating. 2. He speaketh of the presence of Christ, not in the bread, but in us. 3. He proveth the abiding of Christ in us, by the use of the Supper, not by any corporall eating. 4. He so describeth it, that hee saith, It shall continue in the life to come. 5. Hee speaketh of that ⟨p. 476⟩communion which is proper unto the saints. Now this is spirituall, for otherwise it should befall also to the wicked. The shifts of Consubstantiaries, whereby they go about to elude and shift off certain of our objections, not all; for moe are objected against them. 1. WEe make not, say they, any Capernaiticall eating. Ans. We demand of them whether Christ be eaten by the bodily mouth; be it after a grosse, or after a finer manner. But how ever they answer; in that opinion which they hold there is too too much idolatry: for Christ refuting the Capernaites, doth not distinguish the eating of him into a grosse and a finer manner; but saith simply, That his body cannot be eaten with the bodily mouth: for he saith, that he must ascend: And, that the words which he speaketh are spirit and life. 2. We maintain not Ubiquity, for there is not a word thereof to be found. Ans. Here is to be observed the dissention of the adversaries about Ubiquity. But neither is a word to be found hereof, That the body of Christ is together in two places. And further, of this their opinion followeth Ubiquity: For he that is together and at one time in moe places, must needs be infinite, and therefore every-where. 3. Wee overthrow not the article of Christs ascension. Ans. Yea, but they doe overthrow it. For, while they hold that as often as the Supper is celebrated, Christ is corporally eaten, they must needs say that he remaineth and is invisible on earth.
But he is said to have left the world, to have ascended from a lower place into an higher, and to remain in heaven until he come to judgement. Now, that some except, that Christ doth descend from heaven as often as the Supper is administered, it is already refuted. 4. We take not away the doctrine of the properties of Christs humanity. Ans. They altogether take it away. For, they will have his humane nature to be such as is not seen, nor felt, nor limited in place. Rep. But Christ did put off these infirmities and retained the essential properties. Ans. But these are very essential properties, which being taken away, the verity also and truth of his humane nature is taken away. Augustine saith, Take away from bodies their spaces, and they shall be no where. 5. We abolish not the doctrine concerning the communicating of properties of both natures. Ans. Yea, but they endeavour it: For they apply those properties of his divine nature, which are affirmed of the whole person in the concrete, to both natures. I will be with you to the end of the world: This they understand of both natures; which is all one, as if, when it is said, Christ, God and man, was circumcised, one should thus conclude: Therefore the God-head of Christ was circumcised as well as his flesh. Repl. This only we add, That those articles belong not unto them. Ans. After this sort all sects may shift off all testimonies of Scriptures. But they belong hither, and that by a double right: 1. Because they are written of the body of Christ: But the body of Christ belongeth to the Supper: Therefore these articles also belong hither, for they show how Christs body is to be eaten. 2. They belong hither, because no article of faith is at variance with another. So belongeth hither also the doctrine of Justification, because in the Supper no other justice or righteousness is to be sought for, but by the blood of Christ. 6. The manner how we eat it is not to be defined. Ans. They commit a double fault in so saying: 1. When they deny that the manner is to be defined, and so contradict and gainsay the Scripture, which defineth it, and showeth that it is spiritual, and that there is wrought an union with Christ by faith, through the holy Ghost. 2. They themselves define the manner, as it clearly appeareth by their writing. 7. The saying of Durandus is true: We hear the words; we perceive the motions;
But he is said to have left the world, to have ascended from a lower place into an higher, and to remain in heaven untill he come to judgement. Now, that some except, that Christ doth descend from heaven as often as the Supper is administred, it is already refuted. 4. We take not away the doctrine of the properties of Christs humanity. Ans. They altogether take it away. For, they will have his humane nature to be such as is not seen, nor felt, nor limited in place. Rep. But Christ did put off these infirmities and retained the essentiall properties. Ans. But these are very essentiall properties, which being taken away, the verity also and truth of his humane nature is taken away. Augustine saith, Take away from bodies their spaces, and they shall be no where. 5. Wee abolish not the doctrine concerning the communicating of properties of both natures. Ans. Yea, but they endeavour it: For they apply those properties of his divine nature, which are affirmed of the whole person in the concrete, to both natures. I will be with you to the end of the world: This they understand of both natures; which is all one, as if, when it is said, Christ, God and man, was circumcised, one should thus conclude: Therefore the God-head of Christ was circumcised as well as his flesh. Repl. This only we adde, That those articles belong not unto them. Ans. After this sort all sects may shift off all testimonies of Scriptures. But they belong hither, and that by a double right: 1. Because they are written of the body of Christ: But the body of Christ belongeth to the Supper: Therefore these articles also belong hither, for they shew how Christs body is to be eaten. 2. They belong hither, because no article of faith is at variance with another. So belongeth hither also the doctrine of Justification, because in the Supper no other justice or righteousnesse is to be sought for, but by the bloud of Christ. 6. The manner how we eat it is not to be defined. Ans. They commit a double fault in so saying: 1. When they deny that the manner is to be defined, and so contradict and gainsay the Scripture, which defineth it, and sheweth that it is spirituall, and that there is wrought an union with Christ by faith, through the holy Ghost. 2. They themselves define the manner, as it cleerly appeareth by their writing. 7. The saying of Durandus is true: We hear the words; wee perceive the motions;
we know not the manner; we believe the presence. Ans. Durandus maketh nought either for you, or against us, or for himself, because he was a Papist. And again, if his saying be rightly understood, we may admit it: We hear the words, This is my body; not that we eat with our mouth the body of Christ in the bread. We perceive the motions: that is, we perceive the bread to enter into our mouth, not the body of Christ. We know not the manner: that is, not perfectly, to wit, after what manner the holy ⟨p. 477⟩Ghost is every where whole in Christ, and in all the Saints, and how he uniteth us in Christ. We believe the presence: namely, such as is the eating, and as is the union of the members and in the head. 8. We teach this only, That the body and blood of Christ, is truly, substantially, and naturally exhibited. We grant that we eat the true body of Christ. So then is their disputation vain and frivolous: 1. Because they confess that we are made partakers of the true body of Christ, and that we must not question of the manner, for this we grant. 2. Because the reasons and refutation which they bring, are of no weight or moment. Certain reasons whereby is proved, That the body of Christ is not present, either In, or Under, or At the bread of the Lords Supper, neither is corporally eaten Under, With, In, or At the bread. 1. Because he took a true humane nature. Whereupon we add also, that we cannot eat him otherwise than his disciples did in the first Supper. 2. He truly ascended out of earth into heaven. 3. Such is our eating of him, as his abiding is in us. 4. All the Saints of the Old and New Testament have the same union with Christ. 5. Christ only is able to offer himself unto the Father. Now it is necessary in the use of the Supper, to crave of God remission of sins. Wherefore, if he be present at the bread, we must crave of him, and so we offer the bread. But in the New Testament it is not lawful to direct our prayer to any certain place. 6. The blessings which are promised unto the godly only, are spiritual.
we know not the manner; we beleeve the presence. Ans. Durandus maketh nought either for you, or against us, or for himself, because he was a Papist. And again, if his saying be rightly understood, we may admit it: We hear the words, This is my body; not that we eat with our mouth the body of Christ in the bread. We perceive the motions: that is, we perceive the bread to enter into our mouth, not the body of Christ. Wee know not the manner: that is, not perfectly, to wit, after what manner the holy ⟨p. 477⟩
Unto these and other fore-alleged reasons cometh the consent of the ancient Fathers, Ambrose, Athanasius, Augustine, Basil, Bede, Bertram, Chrysostom, Clement Alexandrinus, the Council of Nice, Cyprian, Cyril, Denis, Gelasius, Gregory the Great, Gregory Nazianzene, Hesichius, Hierom, Hilary, Irenaeus, Justine, Leo, Macarius, Origen, Procopius, Gaza, Tertullian, and so forth. THE SECOND APPENDIX OR ADDITION. Arguments, whereby the opinion of the Ubiquitaries is refelled, and the truth of sound doctrine confirmed. THE FIRST ARGUMENT. THE Marcionites and Manichees imagined that Christ had not a true and solid body, but only made show of the shape of a body, so that he seemed only to have flesh and bones, whereas indeed he had them not. And further, that the very incarnation, and all the motions and operations of Christ, did but only seem so in outward appearance, whereas in the truth of the thing there was no such thing done. Now the opinion of the Ubiquity, and of the real communicating of the properties of both natures, doth raise again from hell that fantastical dotary and frenzy of those heretics. Therefore it is no less to be abandoned and banished out of the Church to hell, than that heresy of the Manichees. That this opinion of Ubiquity doth give life again to the former, we prove. The Ubiquitaries are of opinion, and so teach, that all the properties of the God-head were presently, from the very point of Christs conception, really effused from the God-head of the Word into the humane nature which Christ took. Hence these absurdities will follow: 1. Christ shall not be truly born of the Virgin, if as touching the nature of his humanity, he was truly and essentially without the womb of his Mother before he was born; and after he was born he remained no less truly and substantially, as touching his humanity, in that self same womb, than before. 2. Christ was not truly weak in his humane nature, and subject to passions, if he were then also as touching the same nature partaker of the divine majesty and omnipotency. 3. He was not truly dead, if also in the time of his death, as touching his soul and body, he were essentially present every where together with his God-head:
Unto these and other fore-alledged reasons cometh the consent of the ancient Fathers, Ambrose, Athanasius, Austine, Basil, Bede, Bertram, Chrysostome, Clement Alexandrinus, the Councell of Nice, Cyprian, Cyril, Denis, Gelasius, Gregorie the Great, Gregorie Nazianzene, Hesichius, Hierom, Hilary, Irenaeus, Justine, Leo, Macarius, Origen, Procopius, Gaza, Tertullian, and so forth. THE SECOND APPENDIX OR ADDITION. Arguments, whereby the opinion of the Ʋbiquitaries is refelled, and the truth of sound doctrine confirmed. THE FIRST ARGUMENT. THE Marcionites and Manichees imagined that Christ had not a true and solid body, but onely made shew of the shape of a body, so that hee seemed onely to have flesh and bones, whereas indeed hee had them not. And further, that the very incarnation, and all the motions and operations of Christ, did but onely seeme so in outward appearance, whereas in the truth of the thing there was no such thing done. Now the opinion of the Ʋbiquity, and of the reall communicating of the properties of both natures, doth raise againe from hell that fantasticall dotary and frensie of those heretickes. Therefore it is no lesse to be abandoned and banished out of the Church to hell, than that heresie of the Manichees. That this opinion of Ubiquity doth give life againe to the former, wee prove. The Ubiquitaries are of opinion, and so teach, that all the properties of the God-head were presently, from the very point of Christs conception, really effused from the God-head of the Word into the humane nature which Christ took. Hence these absurdities will follow: 1. Christ shall not be truly born of the Virgin, if as touching the nature of his humanity, hee was truly and essentially without the wombe of his Mother before hee was born; and after hee was born hee remained no lesse truly and substantially, as touching his humanity, in that selfe same womb, than before. 2. Christ was not truly weak in his humane nature, and subject to passions, if hee were then also as touching the same nature partaker of the divine majesty and omnipotency. 3. Hee was not truly dead, if also in the time of his death, as touching his soul and body, hee were essentially present every where together with his God-head:
For, the soul being every where present, could not be really separated, in ⟨p. 478⟩distance of places from the body, which also should be every-where present, and so neither could the body die, but only in outward appearance and imagination. 4. He ascended not truly into heaven: but it shall be said to have been only a vain and imaginary, and fantastical spectacle, if he were in his body substantially there, before he visibly ascended thither: and after he was ascended thither, he remained yet in the substantial presence of the same body, no less truly than before on the earth, yea, & in the very bodies also of the faithful. If these things so fell out in the truth of the thing; it will follow that the same body of Christ was indeed at once and together, both weak and omnipotent, base and glorious, subject to sufferings, and not subject, dead and alive, limited and unlimited; which is horrible to affirm. For avoiding therefore of these prodigious and impious absurdities, they will except, that he was not as touching his body, otherwise than limited, weak subject to passions, and mortal in the time of his humiliation; because he had debased himself, and would not show forth that Majesty, communicated unto his body, before his resurrection. Ans. They interpret amiss that debasing of himself, of all the glory and Majesty of his humanity hidden and kept close for a time: whereas it is to be understood in respect of the Divinity of the Word, in that he would take the form of a servant, that is, the mass of our nature, and become man. Moreover, it will follow that Christ did show forth the communicated power and Majesty of his flesh, even then, when he was indeed weak and limited, or circumscribed in body: as when, shedding tears, he raised Lazarus from the dead, and when being apprehended by the Jews, he healed Malcus, whom Peter wounded. Now, what is it else to raise the Marcionites up again from hell, or in the greatest matter of all others impiously to blaspheme, if this be not? The second Argument. The blasphemy of Samosatenus, Arrius, and the late Anti-trinitarians, is this: That Christ-man, is not properly and by nature God, but only by an accidental participation of Divine properties, majesty, honour, power, and virtue.
For, the soul being every where present, could not be really separated, in ⟨p. 478⟩distance of places from the body, which also should be every-where present, and so neither could the body die, but onely in outward appearance and imagination. 4. Hee ascended not truly into heaven: but it shall be said to have been onely a vaine and imaginarie, and fantasticall spectacle, if he were in his body substantially there, before he visibly ascended thither: and after he was ascended thither, he remained yet in the substantiall presence of the same body, no lesse truly than before on the earth, yea, & in the very bodies also of the faithfull. If these things so fell out in the truth of the thing; it will follow that the same body of Christ was indeed at once and together, both weak and omnipotent, base and glorious, subject to sufferings, and not subject, dead and alive, limited and unlimited; which is horrible to affirm. For avoiding therefore of these prodigious and impious absurdities, they will except, that hee was not as touching his body, otherwise than limited, weak subject to passions, and mortall in the time of his humiliation; because hee had debased himself, and would not shew forth that Majesty, communicated unto his body, before his resurrection. Ans. They interpret amisse that debasing of himself, of all the glory and Majesty of his humanity hidden and kept close for a time: whereas it is to be understood in respect of the Divinity of the Word, in that he would take the forme of a servant, that is, the masse of our nature, and become man. Moreover, it will follow that Christ did shew forth the communicated power and Majestie of his flesh, even then, when he was indeed weak and limited, or circumscribed in body: as when, shedding tears, he raised Lazarus from the dead, and when being apprehended by the Jews, he healed Malcus, whom Peter wounded. Now, what is it else to raise the Marcionites up againe from hell, or in the greatest matter of all others impiously to blaspheme, if this be not? The second Argument. THe blasphemie of Samosatenus, Arrius, and the late Anti-trinitaries, is this: That Christ-man, is not properly and by nature God, but onely by an accidentall participation of Divine properties, majesty, honour, power, and vertue.
The Ubiquitaries also maintain the same consideration of the God-head of Christ-man, while they define the personal union by his communicating alone of properties, whereby the flesh of Christ is made omnipotent and every where. So that now that man is, and is called God; not that he is properly and by nature God, but because in finite power, majesty, and glory is given him from God, and all the gifts of the holy Ghost are bestowed on him without measure. Now this accidental bestowing of the God head and all the properties, doth not make Christ to be properly and by nature God, but only by divine grace, or God unproperly so called: because it is not the very essential God-head of the Word, but a certain participation thereof, in virtue and efficacy. And therefore the sounder Fathers objected unto the Arians, that they took away the true and eternal God-head of Christ, when they made him a God, not by nature but by grace b participation only of dignity and majesty. Therefore, seeing the Ubiquitaries also equalling our Immanuel with God, by participation of properties only▪ take away his true and eternal God-head, we do disclaim and accurse this their doctrine as blasphemous and heretical. And, that they do this, their own words and opinions witness; 1as Brentius, and Jacobus Andraeas, and others of them in their writings. Whence we conclude, that the Ubiquitaries hold the same opinion with the Arians and the Anti-trinitarians, of the God-head of Christ-man: that is, that all esteem him for God, not by nature but only by grace of participation, new, temporary, created, adopted. If these things be true, Christ shall not be God and man,2 but a divine man, such as the Ubiquitaries repute him, who (as Servetus) hold this opinion: That God can communicate the fullness of his God-head give his divinity, majesty, power, and glory unto man. But we execrate and detest the same blasphemy of both. The third Argument. Nestorius taught, That the union of God the Word with man was wrought by the participation only of equality, as touching majesty, honour, power, virtue, and operation. ⟨p. 479⟩Neither doth he make the difference of the dwelling of the Word in mans nature, which himself took, and in other Saints, to consist in any other thing, than in those gifts and graces bestowed by God on man.
The self same also do the Ubiquitaries teach, because they cry that there is no difference between the inhabiting and dwelling of the God head in Peter, and in Christ; except it be taken from the communication of the gifts or properties of the God-head: and they contend, that by this means, this man, which was taken by the Word, is God, because the Word doth nothing without him, but all things by him. This is nothing else, than to make Christ man, only God by an accident: Wherefore, the doctrine of Ubiquity is altogether the same with Nestorius his heresy. 1Tertullian saith: If Christ be man only, how then is he present every-where, being called upon and invocated, seeing this is not the nature of man, but of God, to be able to be present in all places? By this testimony is refuted the Ubiquity of the humane nature in Christ. Object. But the union of the divine and humane nature in Christ is unseparable: Therefore wheresoever the divine nature is, there is also the humane nature. Ans. It is true which is said, that the union is unseparable. The Word never forsaketh the nature once assumed and taken. But the Word is not in the humane nature, as the soul is included in my body. Wheresoever my body is, there must my soul needs be; neither is my soul at the same time without my body. But the Word is not so in Christ-man: But he is so unseparably and personally in the humane nature, as that he is together also without the humane nature in all the parts of the world, as he filleth all; and in holy men and Angels by his special presence. The personal union of both natures doth not evert the general action and working of his presence and majesty; neither doth it let or hinder the special working of his presence: because the Word is effectual, and worketh forcibly in the regenerate. The general points wherein the Churches, which profess the Gospel, agree or disagree in the controversy concerning the Lords Supper. They agree in these points: §11. That as well the Supper of the Lord, as Baptism, is a visible pledge and testimony annexed by Christ himself to the promise of grace, to this end chiefly, that our faith in this promise might be confirmed and strengthened. §22.
The selfe same also doe the Ʋbiquitaries teach, because they cry that there is no difference between the inhabiting and dwelling of the God head in Peter, and in Christ; except it be taken from the communication of the gifts or properties of the God-head: and they contend, that by this meanes, this man, which was taken by the Word, is God, because the Word doth nothing without him, but all things by him. This is nothing else, than to make Christ man, onely God by an accident: Wherefore, the doctrine of Ʋbiquity is altogether the same with Nestorius his heresie.
That in the true use of the Supper, as well as in all other Sacraments, two things are given by God unto us, and are received of us, namely, earthly, external and visible signs, are bread and wine; and besides these, also heavenly, internal, and invisible gifts, as are the true body of Jesus Christ, together with all his gifts and benefits, and heavenly treasures. §33. That in the Supper we are made partakers not only of the Spirit of Christ and his satisfaction, justice, virtue, and operation; but also of the very substance and essence of his true body and blood, which was given for us to death on the Cross, and which was shed for us; and are truly fed with the self same unto eternal life: and that this very thing Christ should teach, and make known unto us by this visible receiving of this bread and wine in this Supper. §44. That the bread and wine are not changed into the flesh and blood of Christ, but remain true and natural bread and wine: that also the body and blood of Christ are not shut up in the bread and wine; and therefore the bread and wine are called the body of Christ, his body and blood, in this sense; for that his body and blood are not only signified by these, and set before our eyes, but also because as often as we eat or drink this bread and wine, in the true and right use, Christ himself giveth us his body and blood indeed to be the meat and drink of eternal life. §55. That without the right use, this receiving of bread and wine is no Sacrament; neither any thing, but an empty and vain ceremony and spectacle, and such as men abuse to their own damnation. §66. That there is no other true and lawful use of the Supper, besides that which Christ himself hath instituted and commanded to be ketp, namely, this; that this bread and this wine be eaten and drunken in remembrance of him, and to show forth his death. §77. That Christ in his Supper doth not command and require a dissembled and hypocritical remembrance of him, and publishing of his death; but such as embraceth his Passion and death, ⟨p. 480⟩and all his benefits obtained by these for us, by a true and lively faith, and with earnest and ardent thankfulness, and applieth them unto those which eat and drink, as proper unto them. §8
That Christ will dwell in believers only, and in them, who not through contempt, but through necessity, cannot come to the Lords Supper, yea, in all believers, even from the beginning of the world, to all eternity, even as well, and after the same manner, as he will dwell in them, who came unto the Lords Supper. They disagree in these points: 1 That one part contendeth, that these words of Christ, This is my body, must be understood, as the words sound, which yet that part it self doth not prove: but the other part, that those words must be understood sacramentally, according to the declaration of Christ and Paul, according to the most certain and infallible rule and level of the Articles of our Christian faith. 2. That one part will have the body and blood of Christ to be essentially In, or With the bread and the wine, and so be eaten, as that together with the bread and the wine, out of the hand of the Minister, it entereth by the mouth of the receivers into their bodies: but the other part will have the body of Christ, which in the first Supper sate at the table by the Disciples, now to be and continue, not here on earth, but above in the heavens above and without this visible world and heaven, until he descend thence again to judgement, and yet that we notwithstanding here on earth, as oft as we eat this bread with a true faith, are so fed with his body, and made to drink of his blood, that not only through his passion and blood shed, we are cleansed from our sins; but are also in such sort coupled, knit, and incorporated into his true, essential, humane body, by his Spirit dwelling both in him and us, that we are flesh of his flesh, and bone of his bones; and are more nearly and firmly knit and united with him, than the members of our body are united with our head, and so we draw and have in him and from him everlasting life. 3. That one part will have all, whosoever come to the Lords Supper, and eat and drink that bread and wine, whether they be believers, or unbelievers, to eat and drink corporally, and with their bodily mouth the flesh and blood of Christ: believers to life and salvation; unbelievers to damnation and death:
That Christ will dwell in beleevers only, and in them, who not through contempt, but through necessity, cannot come to the Lords Supper, yea, in all beleevers, even from the beginning of the world, to all eternitie, even as well, and after the same manner, as he will dwell in them, who came unto the Lords Supper. They disagree in these points: 1 THat one part contendeth, that these words of Christ, This is my body, must be understood, as the wordes sound, which yet that part it selfe doth not prove: but the other part, that those words must be understood sacramentally, according to the declaration of Christ and Paul, according to the most certain and infallible rule and levell of the Articles of our Christian faith. 2. That one part will have the body and bloud of Christ to be essentially In, or With the bread and the wine, and so be eaten, as that together with the bread and the wine, out of the hand of the Minister, it entreth by the mouth of the receivers into their bodies: but the other part will have the body of Christ, which in the first Supper sate at the table by the Disciples, now to be and continue, not here on earth, but above in the heavens above and without this visible world and heaven, untill he descend thence again to judgement, and yet that we notwithstanding here on earth, as oft as we eat this bread with a true faith, are so fed with his body, and made to drink of his bloud, that not only through his passion and bloud shed, we are cleansed from our sins; but are also in such sort coupled, knit, and incorporated into his true, essentiall, humane body, by his Spirit dwelling both in him and us, that we are flesh of his flesh, and bone of his bones; and are more neerly and firmely knit and united with him, than the members of our body are united with our head, and so we draw and have in him and from him everlasting life. 3. That one part will have all, whosoever come to the Lords Supper, and eat and drink that bread and wine, whether they be beleevers, or unbeleevers, to eat and drink corporally, and with their bodily mouth the flesh and bloud of Christ: beleevers to life and salvation; unbeleevers to damnation and death:
the other holdeth, that unbelievers abuse indeed the outward signs, bread and wine, to their damnation, but that the faithful only can eat and drink by a true faith, and the fore-alleged working of the holy Ghost, the body and blood of Christ unto eternal life.
the other holdeth, that unbeleevers abuse indeed the outward signes, bread and wine, to their damnation, but that the faithfull only can eat and drink by a true faith, and the fore-alledged working of the holy Ghost, the body and bloud of Christ unto eternall life.
1Ans. Preaching of the Gospel, and Ecclesiastical discipline: by which heaven is opened to the believers, and is shut against the unbelievers.
1Ans. Preaching of the Gospel, and Ecclesiasticall discipline: by which heaven is opened to the beleevers, and is shut against the unbeleevers.
Answ. When by the commandment of Christ it is publicly declared to all and every one of the faithful, that all their sins are pardoned them of God, for the merit of Christ, so often as they embrace by a lively faith the promise of the Gospel: but contrarily is denounced to all Infidels and Hypocrites, that so long the wrath of God and everlasting damnation doth lie on them, as they persist in their wickednessa: according to which testimony of the Gospel, God will judge them, as well in this life, as in the life to come.
Answ. When by the commandement of Christ it is publikely declared to all and every one of the faithfull, that all their sins are pardoned them of God, for the merit of Christ, so often as they imbrace by a lively faith the promise of the Gospel: but contrarily is denounced to all Infidels and Hypocrites, that so long the wrath of God and everlasting damnation doth lie on them, as they persist in their wickednessea: according to which testimony of the Gospel, God will judge them, as well in this life, as in the life to come.
Ans. When, according to the commandment of Christ, they who in name are Christians, but in their doctrine and life show themselves aliens from Christb, after they have been some time admonished, will not depart from their errors or wickedness, are made known unto the Church, or to them that are appointed for that matter and purpose, of the Church; and if neither then they obey their admonition, are of the same men by interdiction from the Sacraments shut out from the Congregation of the Church, and by God himself, out of the Kingdom of heaven. And again, if they profess, and indeed declare amendment of life, are received as members of Christ, and his Churchc.
Ans. When, according to the commandement of Christ, they who in name are Christians, but in their doctrine and life shew themselves aliens from Christb, after they have been some time admonished, will not depart from their errours or wickednesse, are made knowne unto the Church, or to them that are appointed for that matter and purpose, of the Church; and if neither then they obey their admonition, are of the same men by interdiction from the Sacraments shut out from the Congregation of the Church, and by God himselfe, out of the Kingdome of heaven. And againe, if they professe, and indeed declare amendment of life, are received as members of Christ, and his Churchc.
Seeing it hath bin showed in the Treatise next going before who are to be admitted by the Church unto the Lords Supper; very commodiously and fitly shall this doctrine follow, concerning the power of the keys: wherein, besides other things, this chiefly is taught; How they who are not to be admitted, must be restrained and excluded from the Sacraments lest, approaching unto them, they profane them.
SEeing it hath bin shewed in the Treatise next going before who are to be admitted by the Church unto the Lords Supper; very commodiously and fitly shall this doctrine follow, concerning the power of the keyes: wherein, besides other things, this chiefly is taught; How they who are not to be admitted, must be restrained and excluded from the Sacraments lest, approaching unto them, they profane them.
The chief questions are: 1. What the power of the keys given unto the Church is, and what are the parts thereof. 2. Whether Ecclesiastical discipline and excommunication be necessary. 3. To whom that power is committed: against whom, and in what order to be used. 4. To what ends it is to be directed, and what abuses therein are to be avoided. 5. What that power of the keys committed unto the Church differeth from the Civill power.
The chiefe questions are: 1. What the power of the keyes given unto the Church is, and what are the parts thereof. 2. Whether Ecclesiasticall discipline and excommunication be necessary. 3. To whom that power is committed: against whom, and in what order to be used. 4. To what ends it is to be directed, and what abuses therein are to be avoided. 5. What that power of the keyes committed unto the Church differeth from the Civill power.
The power of the keys of the Kingdom of heaven, which Christ gave to his Church, is the preaching of the Gospel, and Ecclesiastical discipline, whereby heaven is opened to the believing, and shut up against the unbelieving and unfaithful. Or it is, the office or charge imposed on the Church by Christ, of denouncing, by the preaching of the Gospel and Church discipline, Gods will; and even of declaring the grace of God, and remission of sins unto the penitent, that is, to them who live in true faith, and repentance: but of denouncing unto the wicked the wrath of God, and exclusion or banishment from the Kingdom of Christ, and of casting such out of the Church, as long as they shall show themselves in doctrine and life estranged from Christ: and of receiving them again into the Church, when afterwards they shall repent. It is called the power of the keys by a Metaphor or borrowed speech, taken from the Stewards of mens houses,1 to whom the keys are delivered in charge: and the keys import a Steward-ship by a Metonymy or change of names between the sign and the thing signified thereby; as we use to say, The Sceptre or Crown of any Country, when we intimate and signify thereby the Kingdom of that Country: Wherefore Paul saith,2 The Church is the house of the living God. The Ministers of the Church are Gods Stewards. For look what a faithful Steward is in his Masters house, ordering all things at his Masters beck; the same a faithful Minister is in Gods Church. Wherefore the denouncing of Gods will in his Church, is executed by the Ministers, as the Stewards in his name. ⟨p. 482⟩God himself is author of this Ministry, who gave this power and privilege to his Church, and entitled it by the name of the Keys, saying unto Peter; I will give unto thee the Keys of the Kingdom of heaven: that is, the office or power of shutting and opening the Kingdom of God: and unto all his Disciples, Whatsoever ye bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, 3and whatsoever ye loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. So then the Keys are that power of opening and shutting, binding and loosing; and are called Keys from the efficacy of this power. For the Church verily by the Word of God in Christs name (whose place the Ministers supply) doth open and shut heaven, bind and loose men; and the holy Ghost works powerfully by the Word,
Whosesoever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whosesoever sins ye retain, they are retained.
Now the chief and principal parts of this power of the Keys are two: The preaching of the Gospel, 1or Ministry of the Word; and Church judgement, which is called also spiritual Discipline or Jurisdiction, whereunto Excommunication belongeth. With either of these two parts the Church shutteth and openeth, bindeth and looseth. By the preaching of the Word it shutteth and bindeth, when it denounceth to Hypocrites and Infidels Gods wrath and eternal damnation, until they repent: and it openeth and looseth, when it preacheth to the faithful and penitent remission of sins and Gods favour through Christ. By Ecclesiastical judgement it shutteth and bindeth, when it excommunicateth outrageous and refractary, or stubborn persons; that is, excludeth them from the communion of the Sacraments, the Church and Kingdom of God: Again, it openeth and looseth thereby, when it receiveth the same persons, upon their repentance, as members of Christ and his Church.
Now the chiefe and principall parts of this power of the Keyes are two: The preaching of the Gospel, 1or Ministery of the Word; and Church judgement, which is called also spirituall Discipline or Jurisdiction, whereunto Excommunication belongeth. With either of these two parts the Church shutteth and openeth, bindeth and looseth. By the preaching of the Word it shutteth and bindeth, when it denounceth to Hypocrites and Infidels Gods wrath and eternal damnation, untill they repent: and it openeth and looseth, when it preacheth to the faithfull and penitent remission of sinnes and Gods favour through Christ. By Ecclesiasticall judgement it shutteth and bindeth, when it excommunicateth outragious and refractary, or stubborne persons; that is, excludeth them from the communion of the Sacraments, the Church and Kingdom of God: Againe, it openeth and looseth thereby, when it receiveth the same persons, upon their repentance, as members of Christ and his Church.
Here we are to observe a difference in the order of these two parts: For in the preaching of the Gospel the Keys do first loose and afterwards bind: but in Ecclesiastical discipline they first bind, and afterwards loose. Again, in the former they bind and loose the same or divers parties; in the latter they bind and loose the same persons only Now,1 Excommunication is the banishing of a grievous transgressor, or an open ungodly & obstinate person from the fellowship of the faithful, by the judgement of the Elders or Chief men, and by the consent of the whole Church, exercised and executed in the name and authority of Christ, and of the holy Ghost, to the end that the offender, being put to shame, may repent, and scandals in the Church may be prevented. This exclusion or exile is not only from the Sacraments, but even from the whole communion of the faithful, whereunto the obstinate pertain not at all.2 It is two-fold; Internal, which concerneth God only: and External, which belongeth to the Church. The internal excommunication is manifested to men on earth by the external; and the external is ratified in heaven by the internal, according to Christs promise: Whatsoever ye bind on earth, 3shall be bound in heaven.
Here we are to observe a difference in the order of these two parts: For in the preaching of the Gospel the Keyes doe first loose and afterwards binde: but in Ecclesiasticall discipline they first binde, and afterwards loose. Againe, in the former they bind and loose the same or divers parties; in the latter they binde and loose the same persons only Now,1 Excommunication is the banishing of a grievous transgressour, or an open ungodly & obstinate person from the fellowship of the faithfull, by the judgement of the Elders or Chief men, and by the consent of the whole Church, exercised and executed in the name and authority of Christ, and of the holy Ghost, to the end that the offender, being put to shame, may repent, and scandals in the Church may be prevented. This exclusion or exile is not only from the Sacraments, but even from the whole communion of the faithfull, whereunto the obstinate pertain not at all.2
Concerning the Ministry of the Word, there is no doubt but all the Prophets, Christ, and the Apostles have preached: and whereas Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction hath a necessary co-herence with the Ministry of Gods Word, it is not to be doubted thereof, inasmuch as God himself, and Christ, and the Apostle Paul, have both by precepts and practice confirmed and established it.1 And verily, if no Territory, no City can stand without discipline, laws, and punishment; the Church also, which is the House of the living God, hath need of some spiritual policy and discipline, though it much differ from civill Jurisdiction. Church-discipline therefore is necessary: §11. In respect of Gods general commandment, of preventing the profanation of his Sacraments, both in the Old and New Testament. In the Old Testament God would not that the rebellious should be reputed so much as members of his people, but would have them cut off: much less would he endure, that they should be admitted to his Sacraments.2 The person that doth ought presumptuously, ⟨p. 483⟩whether born in the land, or a stranger, the same blasphemeth the Lord: Therefore that person shall be cut off from among his people. Because he hath despised the Word of the Lord, and hath broken his commandment, that person shall be utterly cut off. God would that all should come unto the Passover, that is, all the members of his people: but the rebellious and obstinate breakers of his Covenant he utterly disclaimed and renounced from being members of his people: therefore he permitted them not to come thereunto. That man that will do presumptuously, 3not hearkening unto the Priest (that standeth before the Lord thy God to minister there) or unto the Judge, that man shall dye, and thou shalt take away evil from Israel. By these two places God will have those cut off, which are rebellious against his law, and that even from the civill state and Common-wealth: neither doth he permit them to be any members of his people: much less then will he have them to be accounted members of his visible Church, and admitted to the Sacraments. The civill or judicial law indeed is taken away, as also are the ceremonies: but that especial difference between the Citizens of the Church and others, is not taken away.
In the first of Isaiah is a whole Sermon against the wicked, which offered sacrifices unto God, and there God will not that they should sacrifice unto him: therefore now also he will not that such men be admitted to the Sacraments. Bring no more oblations (saith God) in vain. Object. God will that all should celebrate the Passover: Therefore here-hence he excluded not the wicked. Ans. God will that all celebrate his Passover; that is, all such as he will have accounted for members of his Church and people: not the obstinate, whom he commanded to be sequestered from his congregation. Again, Isaiah 66. he detesteth such as persist in their wickedness; and yet offer sacrifices unto him: He that killeth a bullocks, is as if he slew a man: he that sacrificeth a sheep, 1as if he cut off a dogs neck: he that offereth an oblation, as if he offered swines blood: he that remembereth incense, as if he blessed an Idol. 2In the sixth of Jeremiah he sharply reproveth those, who, being defiled with their abominations, yet durst appear in his Temple. Ezekiel the 20. he threateneth that he will not answer,3 when he is asked by them who go after other gods, and then present themselves in Gods Temple, when they are polluted. In the same Chapter he saith,4 that they profane his Sabbaths, and pollute his Sanctuary, who, when they have gone a whoring after Idols, appear in his Temple. Amos the fifth,5 he rejecteth the sacrifices and worship of transgressors: I hate and abhor your feast-days, and will not smell in your solemn assemblies. Haggai the second, he prohibiteth the unclean in soul once to touch holy things, where he speaketh of moral and ceremonial uncleanness.6 The sacrifice of the wicked is abomination to the Lord. In the New Testament John admitteth them only to baptism, who confessed their sins, and repented: Bring forth fruits worthy amendment of life. Leave thine offering before the Altar, and go thy way; 7
If thou believest with all thine heart, thou mayest be baptised: Therefore, if thou believest not, thou mayest not. The things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to devils, and not unto God. Ye cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the Table of Devils. Whosoever eateth unworthily, is guilty of the Lords body: But the wicked, eating without faith and repentance, eat unworthily: Therefore they are guilty. We ought not to partake in other mens sins: and we ought not to wink at any mans destruction: therefore we may not admit the wicked to the Sacrament, lest they eat unto themselves damnation.
If thou beleevest with all thine heart, thou mayest be baptised: Therefore, if thou beleevest not, thou mayest not. The things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to divels, and not unto God. Yee cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the Table of Divels. Whosoever eateth unworthily, is guilty of the Lords body: But the wicked, eating without faith and repentance, eate unworthily: Therefore they are guilty. We ought not to partake in other mens sins: and we ought not to wink at any mans destruction: therefore wee may not admit the wicked to the Sacrament, lest they eat unto themselves damnation.
2. In respect of Christ and his Apostles special commandment: If thy brother trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between him and thee alone: 1if he hear thee, thou hast won thy brother. But if he hear thee not, take yet with thee one or two, that by the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be confirmed. And if he will not vouchsafe to hear them, tell it unto the Church: and if he refuse to hear the Church also, ⟨p. 484⟩let him be unto thee as an Heathen man, and a Publican. Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever ye loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven. But Christ will not that his Sacraments, which he instituted for the faithful alone, be made common with Pagans and Publicans. And lest this Mandate might be understood of some private and special judgement, it is expressly added: Whatsoever ye shall bind, &c. which words cannot be otherwise understood, but of the public power of the Keys. I verily, as absent in body, but present in spirit, 2have determined already, as though I were present, that he that hath done this thing, when ye are gathered together, and my spirit, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that such one, I say, by the power of our Lord Jesus Christ, be delivered unto Satan, for the destruction of the flesh, 3that the spirit may be saved in the day of our Lord Jesus. And again: With such a one eat not. Put away therefore from your selves that wicked man. For what concord hath Christ with Belial? 4or what part hath the Believer with the Infidels? We command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye, withdraw your selves from every brother that walketh inordinately, and not after the instruction which ye received of us. If any man obey not our sayings, note him by a letter, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed. 5If there come any unto you, and bring not this doctrine, receive him not to house, neither bid him, God speed: for, he that biddeth him God speed, is partaker of his evil deeds.
3. The power of the Keys is necessary in respect of Gods glory. For God is reproached and despited, if without difference wicked blasphemers go in the number of his Children, and his Kingdom, and the devils be confounded.
3. The power of the Keyes is necessary in respect of Gods glory. For God is reproached and despited, if without difference wicked blasphemers goe in the number of his Children, and his Kingdom, and the divels be confounded.
4. Lest the Sacraments be profaned, and that given the wicked in the Supper, which is denied them in the Word.
5. That the purity of Gods doctrine and worship be preserved.
6. For the safety of the Church, which shall be punished, if she wittingly and willingly profane Christs Sacraments, or suffer them to be profaned.
7. For the safety of the sinners, that they, being often admonished and put to shame, may return to repentance.
7. For the safety of the sinners, that they, being often admonished and put to shame, may returne to repentance.
8. For avoiding of offence in the Church, that others, weaklings, be not corrupted by evil example.1 Know ye not that a little leaven leaveneth the whole lump?
8. For avoiding of offence in the Church, that others, weaklings, be not corrupted by evill example.1 Know ye not that a little leaven leaveneth the whole lump?
9. For avoiding of offence among those that are without, lest they, who are not as yet members of the Church, come not to it.
10. That the name of God might not be blasphemed, and evil spoken of by others, and his Covenant despited and reproached.
10. That the name of God might not be blasphemed, and evill spoken of by others, and his Covenant despited and reproached.
11. That from the sinners themselves punishment may be averted, because the wicked, approaching unto the Lords Table, eat their own damnation. Wherefore, that this may not come to pass, the Church is bound to provide, that such approach not thither.
11. That from the sinners themselves punishment may be averted, because the wicked, approaching unto the Lords Table, eate their owne damnation. Wherefore, that this may not come to passe, the Church is bound to provide, that such approach not thither.
12. They who deny the faith and doctrine of Christ, are to be excluded from the Church, and from the use of the Sacraments: For the Faithful, or Christians are not to be confounded, or mingled with those, who are not members of the Church, or with those, who are professed ungodly persons, blasphemers, revolters to Arianism, Mahumetanisme, and the like. But they that deny, and refuse to repent, deny the faith and doctrine; They profess that they know God, but by works they deny him. And he that denieth the faith,1 is worse than Infidels: Therefore they who persist in their wickedness, and deny to repent, are to be shut out of the Church; neither are they to be admitted to the use of the Sacraments.
12. They who deny the faith and doctrine of Christ, are to be excluded from the Church, and from the use of the Sacraments: For the Faithfull, or Christians are not to be confounded, or mingled with those, who are not members of the Church, or with those, who are professed ungodly persons, blasphemers, revolters to Arrianisme, Mahumetanisme, and the like. But they that deny, and refuse to repent, deny the faith and doctrine; They professe that they know God, but by workes they deny him. And he that denieth the faith,1 is worse than Infidels: Therefore they who persist in their wickednes, and deny to repent, are to be shut out of the Church; neither are they to be admitted to the use of the Sacraments.
13. And here hath place that saying of Christ, Give not that which is holy to dogs. Wherefore, neither to the Sacraments are dogs to be admitted, namely, those which persist in their wickedness, and make a mock of Gods Word. For if Christ speaketh this of his audible Word, to wit, the Word preached, which yet was instituted for the converted and unconverted, or such as were yet to be converted; much more shall this likewise be spoken of his visible Word, namely, of the Sacraments, which were ordained and instituted for the converted only.
13. And here hath place that saying of Christ, Give not that which is holy to dogges. Wherefore, neither to the Sacraments are dogges to be admitted, namely, those which persist in their wickednesse, and make a mocke of Gods Word. For if Christ speaketh this of his audible Word, to wit, the Word preached, which yet was instituted for the converted and unconverted, or such as were yet to be converted; much more shall this likewise be spoken of his visible Word, namely, of the Sacraments, which were ordained and instituted for the converted only.
That in the true use of the Supper, as well as in all other Sacraments, two things are given by God unto us, and are received of us, namely, earthly, externall and visible signes, are bread and wine; and besides these, also heavenly, internall, and invisible gifts, as are the true body of Jesus Christ, together with all his gifts and benefits, and heavenly treasures. §33. That in the Supper we are made partakers not only of the Spirit of Christ and his satisfaction, justice, vertue, and operation; but also of the very substance and essence of his true body and bloud, which was given for us to death on the Crosse, and which was shed for us; and are truly fed with the self same unto eternall life: and that this very thing Christ should teach, and make known unto us by this visible receiving of this bread and wine in this Supper. §44. That the bread and wine are not changed into the flesh and bloud of Christ, but remain true and naturall bread and wine: that also the body and bloud of Christ are not shut up in the bread and wine; and therefore the bread and wine are called the body of Christ, his body and bloud, in this sense; for that his body and bloud are not only signified by these, and set before our eies, but also because as often as we eat or drink this bread and wine, in the true and right use, Christ himself giveth us his body and bloud indeed to be the meat and drink of eternall life. §55. That without the right use, this receiving of bread and wine is no Sacrament; neither any thing, but an emptie and vaine ceremony and spectacle, and such as men abuse to their owne damnation. §66. That there is no other true and lawfull use of the Supper, besides that which Christ himself hath instituted and commanded to be ketp, namely, this; that this bread and this wine be eaten and drunken in remembrance of him, and to shew forth his death. §77. That Christ in his Supper doth not command and require a dissembled and hypocriticall remembrance of him, and publishing of his death; but such as imbraceth his Passion and death, ⟨p. 480⟩and all his benefits obtained by these for us, by a true and lively faith, and with earnest and ardent thankfulnesse, and applieth them unto those which eat and drinke, as proper unto them. §88.
THe power of the keyes of the Kingdome of heaven, which Christ gave to his Church, is the preaching of the Gospell, and Ecclesiasticall discipline, whereby heaven is opened to the beleeving, and shut up against the unbeleeving and unfaithfull. Or it is, the office or charge imposed on the Church by Christ, of denouncing, by the preaching of the Gospell and Church discipline, Gods will; and even of declaring the grace of God, and remission of sins unto the penitent, that is, to them who live in true faith, and repentance: but of denouncing unto the wicked the wrath of God, and exclusion or banishment from the Kingdome of Christ, and of casting such out of the Church, as long as they shall shew themselves in doctrine and life estranged from Christ: and of receiving them againe into the Church, when afterwards they shall repent. It is called the power of the keyes by a Metaphor or borrowed speech, taken from the Stewards of mens houses,1 to whom the keyes are delivererd in charge: and the keyes import a Steward-ship by a Metonymy or change of names between the signe and the thing signified thereby; as we use to say, The Scepter or Crowne of any Countrey, when wee intimate and signifie thereby the Kingdome of that Countrey: Wherefore Paul saith,2 The Church is the house of the living God. The Ministers of the Church are Gods Stewards. For look what a faithfull Steward is in his Masters house, ordering all things at his Masters beck; the same a faithfull Minister is in Gods Church. Wherefore the denouncing of Gods will in his Church, is executed by the Ministers, as the Stewards in his name. ⟨p. 482⟩God himself is authour of this Ministry, who gave this power and priviledge to his Church, and intituled it by the name of the Keys, saying unto Peter; I will give unto thee the Keys of the Kingdom of heaven: that is, the office or power of shutting and opening the Kingdome of God: and unto all his Disciples, Whatsoever yee binde on earth shall be bound in heaven, 3and whatsoever yee loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. So then the Keyes are that power of opening and shutting, binding and loosing; and are called Keyes from the efficacy of this power. For the Church verily by the Word of God in Christs name (whose place the Ministers supply) doth open and shut heaven, binde and loose men; and the holy Ghost workes powerfully by the Word,4 as Christ promised:
COncerning the Ministery of the Word, there is no doubt but all the Prophets, Christ, and the Apostles have preached: and whereas Ecclesiasticall Jurisdiction hath a necessary co-herence with the Ministery of Gods Word, it is not to be doubted thereof, inasmuch as God himself, and Christ, and the Apostle Paul, have both by precepts and practice confirmed and established it.1 And verily, if no Territory, no City can stand without discipline, lawes, and punishment; the Church also, which is the House of the living God, hath need of some spirituall policy and discipline, though it much differ from civill Jurisdiction. Church-discipline therefore is necessary: §11. In respect of Gods generall commandement, of preventing the profanation of his Sacraments, both in the Old and New Testament. In the Old Testament God would not that the rebellious should be reputed so much as members of his people, but would have them cut off: much lesse would he indure, that they should be admitted to his Sacraments.2 The person that dothought presumptuously, ⟨p. 483⟩whether born in the land, or a stranger, the same blasphemeth the Lord: Therefore that person shall be cut off from among his people. Because hee hath despised the Word of the Lord, and hath broken his commandement, that person shall be utterly cut off. God would that all should come unto the Passeover, that is, all the members of his people: but the rebellious and obstinate breakers of his Covenant he utterly disclaimed and renounced from being members of his people: therefore hee permitted them not to come thereunto. That man that will doe presumptuously, 3not harkening unto the Priest (that standeth before the Lord thy God to minister there) or unto the Judge, that man shall dye, and thou shalt take away evill from Israel. By these two places God will have those cut off, which are rebellious against his law, and that even from the civill state and Common-wealth: neither doth he permit them to be any members of his people: much lesse then will he have them to be accounted members of his visible Church, and admitted to the Sacraments. The civill or judiciall law indeed is taken away, as also are the ceremonies: but that especiall difference between the Citizens of the Church and others, is not taken away.
In the first of Esay is a whole Sermon against the wicked, which offered sacrifices unto God, and there God will not that they should sacrifice unto him: therefore now also he will not that such men be admitted to the Sacraments. Bring no more oblations (saith God) in vaine. Object. God will that all should celebrate the Passeover: Therefore here-hence hee excluded not the wicked. Ans. God will that all celebrate his Passeover; that is, all such as he will have accounted for members of his Church and people: not the obstinate, whom hee commanded to be sequestred from his congregation. Againe, Esay 66. he detesteth such as persist in their wickednesse; and yet offer sacrifices unto him: Hee that killeth a bullocks, is as if he slew a man: hee that sacrificeth a sheep, 1as if he cut off a dogges necke: hee that offereth an oblation, as if hee offered swines bloud: hee that remembreth incense, as if hee blessed an Idoll. 2In the sixth of Jeremy he sharply reproveth those, who, being defiled with their abominations, yet durst appeare in his Temple. Ezekiel the 20. he threatneth that he will not answer,3 when he is asked by them who goe after other gods, and then present themselves in Gods Temple, when they are polluted. In the same Chapter he saith,4 that they profane his Sabbaths, and pollute his Sanctuary, who, when they have gone a whoring after Idols, appeare in his Temple. Amos the fifth,5 hee rejecteth the sacrifices and worship of transgressors: I hate and abhorre your feast-dayes, and will not smell in your solemne assemblies. Haggai the second, he prohibiteth the uncleane in soule once to touch holy things, where he speaketh of morall and ceremoniall uncleanenesse.6 The sacrifice of the wicked is abomination to the Lord. In the New Testament John admitteth them only to baptisem, who confessed their sins, and repented: Bring forth fruits worthy amendement of life. Leave thine offering before the Altar, and goe thy way; 7first be reconciled to thy brother, and then come and offer thy gift: Therefore whosoever reconcileth not first himself unto his brother, hee is to be debarred the Sacraments. For Christ will that all submit themselves first unto God, according to all his commandements, before they approach to any Sacrament: For by the name of Altar, here are understood any Sacraments whatsoever. Amend your lives, 8and be baptised every one of you.
2. In respect of Christ and his Apostles speciall commandement: If thy brother trespasse against thee, goe and tell him his fault between him and thee alone: 1if hee heare thee, thou hast wonne thy brother. But if he heare thee not, take yet with thee one or two, that by the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be confirmed. And if he will not vouchsafe to heare them, tell it unto the Church: and if he refuse to heare the Church also, ⟨p. 484⟩let him be unto thee as an Heathen man, and a Publican. Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever yee bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever ye loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven. But Christ will not that his Sacraments, which he instituted for the faithfull alone, be made common with Pagans and Publicans. And lest this Mandate might be understood of some private and speciall judgement, it is expresly added: Whatsoever yee shall bind, &c. which words cannot be otherwise understood, but of the publike power of the Keys. I verily, as absent in body, but present in spirit, 2have determined already, as though I were present, that hee that hath done this thing, when ye are gathered together, and my spirit, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that such one, I say, by the power of our Lord Jesus Christ, be delivered unto Sathan, for the destruction of the flesh, 3that the spirit may be saved in the day of our Lord Jesus. And againe: With such a one eate not. Put away therefore from your selves that wicked man. For what concord hath Christ with Belial? 4or what part hath the Beleever with the Infidels? We command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that yee, withdraw your selves from every brother that walketh inordinately, and not after the instruction which yee received of us. If any man obey not our sayings, note him by a letter, and have no company with him, that hee may be ashamed. 5If there come any unto you, and bring not this doctrine, receive him not to house, neither bid him, God speed: for, he that biddeth him God speed, is partaker of his evill deeds.