For to this end and use are they given of God, that they may (as it were) effectually show to our outward senses, that which is promised in the Word, and performed by the holy Ghost in our hearts, that they may be visible testimonies and pledges of the promise of grace exhibited and applied. Whence is that saying of Augustine: a Sacrament is a visible word: And,1 it is a visible form of invisible grace. And, A sign is a thing besides that form which it presenteth to our senses, causing something else by it self to come into the knowledge. And, the signs indeed of divine things are visible, but the things themselves are invisible. And that of Prosper; The sacrifice of the Church consisteth in two things: in the visible form of elements, and the invisible flesh and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ: in the Sacrament or sign, and in the thing of the Sacrament; that is, the body of Christ. Therefore no thing or action which is invisible, insensible, and not natural, can make the nature or appellation of a Sacrament. And consequently they, who will have Christs flesh in, under, or with the bread to be a Sacrament, or will have the bread to be transubstantiated into his flesh, let them show us a visible or sensible eating of it in the Supper, lest they seem to dissent from the ancient Fathers. 2. There must be an analogy and proportion between the sign or Sacrament, and the thing signified, or the thing of the Sacrament. For, Except the Sacraments (saith Augustine) had some similitude of those things, whereof they are Sacraments, they were not verily and Sacraments. Now,2 if Christ flesh be also a Sacrament, and the thing of those Sacraments be invisible grace; what proportion then and similitude shall there be between the two Sacraments? but seeing there can be none, it followeth, that Christs flesh may not be called a Sacrament; as being no less the thing it self of the Sacrament, then eternal salvation signified, by way of proportion, by visible bread, as by a sign. Wherefore the sacramental eating, which is done naturally by the mouth, doth not belong unto the body of Christ, considered by it self, in any physical or natural respect: because unto this sacramental eating the external signs only are object in their own nature. S. Augustine demanding how bread is the body of Christ, and wine his blood:
For to this end and use are they given of God, that they may (as it were) effectually shew to our outward senses, that which is promised in the Word, and performed by the holy Ghost in our hearts, that they may be visible testimonies and pledges of the promise of grace exhibited and applyed. Whence is that saying of Austine: a Sacrament is a visible word: And,1 it is a visible forme of invisible grace. And, A signe is a thing besides that forme which it presenteth to our senses, causing something else by it selfe to come into the knowledge. And, the signes indeed of divine things are visible, but the things themselves are invisible. And that of Prosper; The sacrifice of the Church consisteth in two things: in the visible forme of elements, and the invisible flesh and bloud of our Lord Jesus Christ: in the Sacrament or signe, and in the thing of the Sacrament; that is, the body of Christ. Therefore no thing or action which is invisible, insensible, and not naturall, can make the nature or appellation of a Sacrament. And consequently they, who will have Christs flesh in, under, or with the bread to be a Sacrament, or will have the bread to be transsubstantiated into his flesh, let them shew us a visible or sensible eating of it in the Supper, lest they seeme to dissent from the ancient Fathers. 2. There must be an analogy and proportion betweene the signe or Sacrament, and the thing signified, or the thing of the Sacrament. For, Except the Sacraments (saith Austine) had some similitude of those things, whereof they are Sacraments, they were not verily and Sacraments. Now,2 if Christ flesh be also a Sacrament, and the thing of those Sacraments be invisible grace; what proportion then and similitude shall there be between the two Sacraments? but seeing there can be none, it followeth, that Christs flesh may not be called a Sacrament; as being no lesse the thing it selfe of the Sacrament, then eternall salvation signified, by way of proportion, by visible bread, as by a signe. Wherefore the sacramentall eating, which is done naturally by the mouth, doth not belong unto the body of Christ, considered by it selfe, in any physicall or naturall respect: because unto this sacramentall eating the externall signes only are object in their owne nature. S. Austine demanding how bread is the body of Christ, and wine his bloud:
- 1Lib. 19. cap. 18. cont. Fault. & lib. 2. cap. 1. De Doct. Christ. & de Catech-rud. ca. 26. Prosp. in sentent.
- 2Epist. 23. ad Bonifacium.