Object. 2. The honour which is given unto the sign, is the honour of the thing signified. Images are a sign of God. Therefore the honour which is given unto Images, is also given unto God. Answ. We again deny the Minor, or distinguish of the Major thus; The honour of the sign is also the honour of the thing signified, namely, when the sign is a true sign, that is, ordained by him who hath authority to ordain it, and when also that honour is given to the sign which the right and lawful author of it will have done to the sign. For not the will of him that honoureth, but of him that is honoured, is the rule which must prescribe the due honour. Now whereas God hath forbidden both these, namely, that Images should be erected to him; and, that himself should be honoured at Images erected to him, or to any creatures; he is not honoured, but contumeliously wronged, and reproached, when any honour done to images is fastened on him. Repl. Whatsoever contumely is done to the sign, that redoundeth on God, although the sign be not instituted by his commandment. Therefore the honour also that is given to the sign, redoundeth on God, although that honour be not commanded to be given to the sign. Answ. This reason doth not follow, because then are contrary things rightly attributed to contraries, when the contrariety of the attributes dependeth of that, according to which the subject is opposed, and not of some other thing. So we grant that contumely against God followeth indeed the contumely against the sign, albeit the sign were not instituted by God; but not simply in respect of the sign it self, unto which that contumely was done, but in respect of his corrupt and bad will, who by showing contumely against the sin, which is thought to represent God, purposeth himself, and is minded to despite with contumely and reproach God himself. For to the showing of despite and contumely against God, it sufficeth, if there be any intent or purpose of departing from his commandment. But if through a desire that we have to avoid Idolatry, we detest Images, and other false reputed signs of God, by this contumely done to the signs, we rather promote, further, and advance Gods glory. But the honour of God doth not follow the honour of the sign, except both the honour and the sign be ordained by God:
Object. 2. The honour which is given unto the signe, is the honour of the thing signified. Images are a signe of God. Therefore the honour which is given unto Images, is also given unto God. Answ. We againe deny the Minor, or distinguish of the Major thus; The honour of the signe is also the honour of the thing signified, namely, when the signe is a true signe, that is, ordained by him who hath authority to ordaine it, and when also that honour is given to the signe which the right and lawfull author of it will have done to the signe. For not the will of him that honoureth, but of him that is honoured, is the rule which must prescribe the due honour. Now whereas God hath forbidden both these, namely, that Images should be erected to him; and, that himselfe should be honoured at Images erected to him, or to any creatures; he is not honoured, but contumeliously wronged, and reproached, when any honour done to images is fastned on him. Repl. Whatsoever contumely is done to the signe, that redoundeth on God, although the signe be not instituted by his commandement. Therefore the honour also that is given to the signe, redoundeth on God, although that honour be not commanded to be given to the signe. Answ. This reason doth not follow, because then are contrary things rightly attributed to contraries, when the contrariety of the attributes dependeth of that, according to which the subject is opposed, and not of some other thing. So we grant that contumely against God followeth indeed the contumely against the signe, albeit the signe were not instituted by God; but not simply in respect of the signe it selfe, unto which that contumely was done, but in respect of his corrupt and bad will, who by shewing contumely against the sinne, which is thought to represent God, purposeth himselfe, and is minded to despite with contumely and reproach God himselfe. For to the shewing of despite and contumely against God, it sufficeth, if there be any intent or purpose of departing from his commandement. But if through a desire that we have to avoide Idolatry, we detest Images, and other false reputed signes of God, by this contumely done to the signes, we rather promote, further, and advance Gods glory. But the honour of God doth not follow the honour of the signe, except both the honour and the signe be ordained by God: