The Explication.
pp. 569–57524 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 569–57524 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In these two questions the doctrine touching swearing is expounded and set down at large.
In these two questions the doctrine touching swearing is expounded and set downe at large.
OF AN OATH, OR SWEARING. The chief questions concerning an oath or swearing, are, 1. What an oath is. 2. By whom we are to swear. 3. Whether a Christian may swear. 4. Of what things we must swear. 5. Whether all oaths are to be kept.
OF AN OATH, OR SWEARING. The chiefe questions concerning an oath or swearing, are, 1. What an oath is. 2. By whom we are to sweare. 3. Whether a Christian may sweare. 4. Of what things we must sweare. 5. Whether all oathes are to be kept.
The three last appertain to the declaration of the 101. Question of the Catechism: the two former belong to the declaration and unfolding of the 102. Question.
The three last appertaine to the declaration of the 101. Question of the Catechisme: the two former belong to the declaration and unfolding of the 102. Question.
AN oath is oftentimes understood and taken in Scripture for the whole worship of God: 1as it is said of the worship of God in the Old Testament; Thou shalt swear by his name. In that day shall five Cities in the Land of Egypt speak the language of Canaan, and shall swear by the Lord of Hosts. Every knee shall bow unto me, and every tongue shall swear by me. And of the worship of God in the New Testament: He ⟨p. 570⟩that shall bless in the earth, shall bless himself in the true God, and he that sweareth in the earth, shall swear by the true God. If they will learn the ways of my people, to swear by my Name; then shall they be built in the middest of my people. The reason is, because by whom we swear,2 the same we profess to account for God. But properly an oath is an Invocating on God, whereby is desired that God, who is the viewer of the hearts, would give testimony unto the truth, and punish him that sweareth, if wittingly he deceive. So doth the Catechism define it, and the definition is desumed or borrowed from that form of swearing which the Apostle useth: I call God for a record unto my soul, that to spare you, I came not as yet unto Corinthus. It is said in the definition, that God would give testimony; namely, by saving and doing good to him that sweareth, if he swear aright: but by punishing and destroying him, if he wittingly deceive. For an Oath was ordained by God, that it might be the bond of truth between men, and a testimony or record that God is the Author and defender of the truth.
AN oath is oftentimes understood and taken in Scripture for the whole worship of God: 1as it is said of the worship of God in the Old Testament; Thou shalt sweare by his name. In that day shall five Cities in the Land of Egypt speake the language of Canaan, and shall sweare by the Lord of Hoasts. Every knee shall bow unto me, and every tongue shall sweare by me. And of the worship of God in the New Testament: He ⟨p. 570⟩that shall blesse in the earth, shall blesse himselfe in the true God, and he that sweareth in the earth, shall sweare by the true God. If they will learne the waies of my people, to sweare by my Name; then shall they be built in the middest of my people. The reason is, because by whom we sweare,2 the same we professe to account for God. But properly an oath is an Invocating on God, whereby is desired that God, who is the viewer of the hearts, would give testimony unto the truth, and punish him that sweareth, if wittingly he deceive. So doth the Catechisme define it, and the definition is desumed or borrowed from that forme of swearing which the Apostle useth: I call God for a record unto my soule, that to spare you, I came not as yet unto Corinthus. It is said in the definition, that God would give testimony; namely, by saving and doing good to him that sweareth, if he sweare aright: but by punishing and destroying him, if he wittingly deceive. For an Oath was ordained by God, that it might be the bond of truth between men, and a testimony or record that God is the Author and defender of the truth.
We must swear by the name of the only true God:1 §12Because God hath commanded us to swear by him only, as he alone is to be feared and worshipped. Thou shalt fear the Lord thy God, thou shalt serve him, and thou shalt cleave unto him, and shalt swear by his name. §23God expressly forbiddeth, that we swear by any other name: Ye shall make no mention of the name of other gods. §34God will have invocation to be used to himself only, and he condemneth such as in their oaths join the creatures with God. Now an Oath is a kind of invocation of God, as appeareth out of the definition thereof.§4 5An Oath doth give and ascribe unto him by whom we swear, the inspection and viewing of hearts, infinite wisdom, and knowledge of all things, presence in all places, &c. (And indeed, infinite wisdom, and the searching of hearts is required in him by whom we swear, because in oaths we treat not of manifest matters, or whereof there is good evidence; but of hidden and uncertain difficulties, and in which he only can judge whether men deceive who is the beholder of hearts.) But God alone is the searcher of hearts, omniscient, and every where present. Hence issueth a proof that Christ is true God, and that we are to swear by him;6 Because he knoweth all men, and hath no need that any should testify of man: for he knoweth what is in man. So also is it said of the holy Ghost, The spirit searcheth all things. §57By whom we swear, unto him we give and ascribe the execution of punishment, and unto him we attribute omnipotency, as whereby he must maintain the truth, and punish him that lieth. But God alone is omnipotent and executor of punishment:8 Fear ye not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both body and soul in hell. Men cannot be revengers of perjury, because such as swear falsely escape the judgement of men, seeing men are not the intelligencers of mens hearts, to see whether they who swear, deceive or no; or because perjured persons are sometimes mightier then that they may be drawn to punishment by men. Hence followeth it, that such oaths that are sworn by Saints or other creatures are Idolatrous, and forbidden of God.
WEe must sweare by the name of the onely true God:1 §12Because God hath commanded us to sweare by him onely, as he alone is to be feared and worshipped. Thou shalt feare the Lord thy God, thou shalt serve him, and thou shalt cleave unto him, and shalt sweare by his name. §23God expresly forbiddeth, that we sweare by any other name: Ye shall make no mention of the name of other gods. §34God will have invocation to be used to himselfe onely, and he condemneth such as in their oathes joyne the creatures with God. Now an Oath is a kinde of invocation of God, as appeareth out of the definition thereof.§4 5An Oath doth give and ascribe unto him by whom we sweare, the inspection and viewing of hearts, infinite wisdome, and knowledge of all things, presence in all places, &c. (And indeed, infinite wisdome, and the searching of hearts is required in him by whom we sweare, because in oathes we treat not of manifest matters, or whereof there is good evidence; but of hidden and uncertaine difficulties, and in which he onely can judge whether men deceive who is the beholder of hearts.) But God alone is the searcher of hearts, omniscient, and every where present. Hence issueth a proofe that Christ is true God, and that we are to sweare by him;6 Because he knoweth all men, and hath no need that any should testifie of man: for he knoweth what is in man. So also is it said of the holy Ghost, The spirit searcheth all things. §57By whom we sweare, unto him we give and ascribe the execution of punishment, and unto him we attribute omnipotency, as whereby he must maintaine the truth, and punish him that lyeth. But God alone is omnipotent and executor of punishment:8 Feare ye not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soule: but rather feare him which is able to destroy both body and soule in hell. Men cannot be revengers of perjury, because such as sweare falsely escape the judgement of men, seeing men are not the intelligencers of mens hearts, to see whether they who sweare, deceive or no; or because perjured persons are sometimes mightier then that they may be drawne to punishment by men. Hence followeth it, that such oathes that are sworne by Saints or other creatures are Idolatrous, and forbidden of God.
Object.1 But Joseph sware by the life of Pharaoh: Therefore it is lawful to swear also by man or creatures. Ans. Some grant that he sinned in so doing, namely, that he erred, following the custom of the Gentiles, who were wont to swear by Kings, that thereby he might keep close from his brethren who he was: but we may make answer otherwise also; namely, that it was not properly an Oath, but only an asseveration made for to show the evidence of the thing, comparing it with a thing which was certain and evident: so that the tenure and meaning of such asseveration is, that those things which are avouched, are as certain, as that man certainly liveth, whom he assevereth to live; namely, as being known, and yet living: or so certain as he, who assevereth, certainly wisheth that man to live, whom he nameth. So also shall the meaning of Joseph's asseveration be, As Pharaoh liveth; that is, as truly as Pharaoh liveth, or is in safety, or as truly as I wish him to live, and ⟨p. 571⟩to be in safety, so truly say I these things. The same sense and meaning is to be rendered of the like asseverations: as the asseveration of Hannah, 2As thy soul liveth my Lord, namely Ely: and of Abner, As thy soul liveth O King, meaning Saul: and of David, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soul liveth, speaking to Jonathan: And of Abigail, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soul liveth, speaking to David.
Object.1 But Joseph sware by the life of Pharaoh: Therefore it is lawfull to sweare also by man or creatures. Ans. Some grant that he sinned in so doing, namely, that he erred, following the custome of the Gentiles, who were wont to sweare by Kings, that thereby he might keep close from his brethren who he was: but we may make answer othewise also; namely, that it was not properly an Oath, but only an asseveration made for to shew the evidence of the thing, comparing it with a thing which was certaine and evident: so that the tenure and meaning of such asseveration is, that those things which are avouched, are as certaine, as that man certainely liveth, whom he assevereth to live; namely, as being knowne, and yet living: or so certaine as he, who assevereth, certainely wisheth that man to live, whom he nameth. So also shall the meaning of Joseph's asseveration be, As Pharaoh liveth; that is, as truely as Pharaoh liveth, or is in safety, or as truely as I wish him to live, and ⟨p. 571⟩to be in safety, so truly say I these things. The same sense and meaning is to be rendred of the like asseverations: as the asseveration of Hannah, 2As thy soule liveth my Lord, namely Ely: and of Abner, As thy soule liveth O King, meaning Saul: and of David, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soule liveth, speaking to Jonathan: And of Abigail, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soule liveth, speaking to David.
1That a Christian may without breach of piety swear by the name of God; namely, if the Magistrate exact an oath at his hands, or otherwise if necessity so require, is here proved by four arguments: §12That Gods glory may thereby be advanced: For truth, and the manifestation thereof, is a thing glorious unto God. §23That the safety of others may thereby be procured: For our safety consisteth in the truth, especially in that heavenly truth. §34Because a lawful oath is authorised by Gods word. §45Because it hath been heretofore rightly taken by the Saints of God. Here the Anabaptists except against us; saying, that of ancient it was lawful for the Fathers in the Old Testament under the Law to swear, but it is prohibited us in the New Testament. Therefore to the former reasons we are to add these for proof of the contrary unto their opinion. §56Christ saith, I am not come to destroy the Law, but to fulfil it. Now he speaketh this of the Moral Law, whereunto an oath belongeth. Therefore the taking of an oath was not repealed by Christ. §67The Moral worship of God is perpetual. But a lawful oath is a part of the Moral worship of God, for it is an invocating of God. Therefore it is perpetual. §78The Prophets describing the worship of the new Church, term it a swearing by the name of God. He that sweareth in the earth shall swear by the true God. Therefore the new Church may swear by the name of the true God. §89The confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates is profitable, lawful and necessary for Church and Commonwealth, and glorious unto God. But an oath is a confirmation of faith and truth, and a deciding of debates: An oath for confirmation is an end of all strife. Therefore an oath is not only lawful for Christians, but also necessary. §910We have herein the example of Christ and the Saints in the New Testament. For, Christ himself not once, but often used a form of swearing for confirmation of his doctrine; Verily, Verily, I say unto you: And Paul in the same case often interposeth an oath: God is my witness, whom I serve in my spirit, in the Gospel of his Son, that &c. I say the truth in Christ, I lye not, my conscience bearing me witness in the holy Ghost. I call God for a record upon my soul, &c. God is my record, how I long after you all. Ye are witnesses, and God also, how holily, and justly, and unblameably we behaved our selves among you.
1THat a Christian may without breach of piety swear by the name of God; namely, if the Magistrate exact an oath at his hands, or otherwise if necessity so require, is here proved by foure arguments: §12That Gods glory may thereby be advanced: For truth, and the manifestation thereof, is a thing glorious unto God. §23That the safety of others may thereby be procured: For our safety consisteth in the truth, especially in that heavenly truth. §34Because a lawfull oath is authorised by Gods word. §45Because it hath been heretofore rightly taken by the Saints of God. Here the Anabaptists except against us; saying, that of ancient it was lawfull for the Fathers in the Old Testament under the Law to sweare, but it is prohibited us in the New Testament. Therefore to the former reasons we are to adde these for proofe of the contrary unto their opinion. §56Christ saith, I am not come to destroy the Law, but to fulfill it. Now he speaketh this of the Morall Law, whereunto an oath belongeth. Therefore the taking of an oath was not repealed by Christ. §67The Morall worship of God is perpetuall. But a lawfull oath is a part of the Morall worship of God, for it is an invocating of God. Therefore it is perpetuall. §78The Prophets describing the worship of the new Church, terme it a swearing by the name of God. He that sweareth in the earth shall sweare by the true God. Therefore the new Church may sweare by the name of the true God. §89The confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates is profitable, lawfull and necessary for Church and Commonwealth, and glorious unto God. But an oath is a confirmation of faith and truth, and a deciding of debates: An oath for confirmation is an end of all strife. Therefore an oath is not onely lawfull for Christians, but also necessary.
These, and the like arguments and examples do sufficiently show, that doubtless, To swear lawfully, is granted unto Christians, even now also in the new Covenant.
These, and the like arguments and examples do sufficiently shew, that doubtlesse, To sweare lawfully, is granted unto Christians, even now also in the new Covenant.
The Anabaptists object against us that saying of Christ: Object. But I say unto you, 1Swear not at all: neither by heaven, for it is the throne of God; nor yet by the earth, for it is his foot-stool; neither by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King; neither shalt thou swear by thine head, for thou canst not make one hair white or black. But let your communication be, Yea, Yea; Nay, Nay. For whatsoever is more then these, cometh of evil. 2And that of James: Before all things, my brethren, swear not, neither by heaven, nor by earth, nor by any other oath: but let your Yea, be Yea; and your Nay, Nay; lest ye fall into condemnation.
The Anabaptists object against us that saying of Christ: Object. But I say unto you, 1Sweare not at all: neither by heaven, for it is the throne of God; nor yet by the earth, for it is his foot-stoole; neither by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King; neither shalt thou sweare by thine head, for thou canst not make one haire white or black. But let your communication be, Yea, Yea; Nay, Nay. For whatsoever is more then these, cometh of evill. 2And that of James: Before all things, my brethren, sweare not, neither by heaven, nor by earth, nor by any other oath: but let your Yea, be Yea; and your Nay, Nay; lest ye fall into condemnation.
Answ. That by those places alleged, not all oaths, but rash and unnecessary oaths are forbidden, is manifest both by conference of other places and examples of the Old and new Testament, and especially by the purpose and scope of Christ; who, freeing the true meaning and sentence of the law from the corruptions of the Pharisees,1 and taxing their hypocrisy, showeth, that by the third Commandment is condemned not only all perjury, but also all rash oaths, superfluous and unnecessary: and in them not only those that are direct oaths, in which the name it self of God is expressed; but also indirect or oblique oaths, in which the name of God is understood, being dissembled and cloaked by uttering in place thereof the names of creatures. For ⟨p. 572⟩such kind of oaths were then commonly used in ordinary and daily speech: and hypocrites,2 who did exercise those indirect or oblique forms of swearing, By the Temple, By the Altar, By Heaven, &c. excused them, 1. As if, swearing on this wise, they profaned not the name of God, inasmuch as they expressed not the name of God in their oath. 2. As if they were not perjured and forsworn, if when they expressed not the name of God in their oath, they afterwards brake their faith and oath given in that indirect form of swearing: But Christ showeth, that even then also the name of God is sworn by, when heaven and earth is named; because there is no part of the world, no creature, wherein God hath not engraven some work of his glory. And when men swear by heaven and earth,3 in the sight and hearing of the framer of them both, the religion of the oath is not in the creatures by whom they swear, but God himself only is called to record and for a witness, by the citing of these symbols and badges of his glory. Neither doth God stick in the words, but respecteth the mind of him that sweareth: neither doth the honour or dishonour of Gods name consist so much in the naked and bare letters and syllables, as in the sentence and meaning of those signs and symbols; like as Christ also teacheth the same in express words, Matthew 23.4 which words are to be conferred with this place which now we have expounded. The meaning of S. James in the place alleged out of his Epistle, is also all one with the meaning of Christ already expressed. Repl. But Christ saith: Swear not at all. And James saith: Nor by any other oath.
Answ. That by those places alledged, not all oathes, but rash and unnecessary oathes are forbidden, is manifest both by conference of other places and examples of the Old and new Testement, and especially by the purpose and scope of Christ; who, freeing the true meaning and sentence of the law from the corruptions of the Pharisees,1 and taxing their hypocrisie, sheweth, that by the third Commandment is condemned not onely all perjury, but also all rash oathes, superfluous and unnecessary: and in them not only those that are direct oathes, in which the name it selfe of God is expressed; but also indirect or oblique oathes, in which the name of God is understood, being dissembled and cloaked by uttering in place thereof the names of creatures. For ⟨p. 572⟩such kind of oathes were then commonly used in ordinary and dayly speech: and hypocrites,2 who did exercise those indirect or oblique formes of swearing, By the Temple, By the Altar, By Heaven, &c. excused them, 1. As if, swearing on this wise, they profaned not the name of God, inasmuch as they expressed not the name of God in their oath. 2. As if they were not perjured and forsworne, if when they expressed not the name of God in their oath, they afterwards brake their faith and oath given in that indirect forme of swearing: But Christ sheweth, that even then also the name of God is sworne by, when heaven and earth is named; because there is no part of the world, no creature, wherein God hath not engraven some worke of his glory. And when men sweare by heaven and earth,3 in the sight and hearing of the framer of them both, the religion of the oath is not in the creatures by whom they sweare, but God himselfe onely is called to record and for a witnesse, by the citing of these symboles and badges of his glory. Neither doth God stick in the words, but respecteth the mind of him that sweareth: neither doth the honour or dishonour of Gods name consist so much in the naked and bare letters and syllables, as in the sentence and meaning of those signes and symboles; like as Christ also teacheth the same in expresse words, Matthew 23.4 which words are to be conferred with this place which now we have expounded. The meaning of S. James in the place alledged out of his Epistle, is also all one with the meaning of Christ already expressed. Repl. But Christ saith: Sweare not at all. And James saith: Nor by any other oath.
Therefore all oaths are forbidden amongst Christians. Answ. Here is a fallacy of Composition; namely, a mis-joining of words in this clause, or sentence, which are not to be joined together. For that particle, at all, is referred to the diverse forms of rash swearing, which the Pharisees averred to be lawful, not to the very word of swearing it self: as if he should say, Swear not falsely, or rashly at all; to wit, neither directly, nor indirectly. So saith S. James, nor by any other oath, to wit, rash, or false; by naming of certain kinds whereof, he showeth that all such like are forbidden. Else should Christ himself offend against his own commandment,1 whereas he here saith: Let your communication be Yea, Yea; and Nay, Nay: and yet else-where oftentimes, in his most grave and reverend speech and doctrine, useth this asseveration, Verily, Verily, I say unto you. Likewise else should James condemn Paul, who by an oath took God to witness unto his soul: and the holy Ghost should contradict himself in condemning all manner of oaths by James, and commending an oath by another Apostle as a ready remedy, profitable, and necessary for the preservation of humane society, to determine and end all strifes and controversies, from which in this frailty mans life cannot be free. Repl. 2. The permission of oaths in Scripture, and the examples of such as have taken them, concern public oaths only, that is, such as are given and taken in some public behalf: Therefore at least private oaths, such as pass between private men, are wholly forbidden. 2Ans. 1. We deny the Antecedent, because this restraint is not only not found specified in these grants and examples in Scripture, but farther also can have no places in either of them, as the view and scanning of the places doth prove. 2. There are manifest examples of a private oath, as of Jacob and Laban, Boos, Obadiah, Abigail and David. 3. The same is proved also by the end of an oath: for the end thereof, which is the confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates, belongeth privately also to all Christians; and therefore so doth an oath it self also, whereby we confirm and establish faith and truth.
Therefore all oathes are forbidden amongst Christians. Answ. Here is a fallacy of Composition; namely, a mis-joyning of words in this clause, or sentence, which are not to be joyned together. For that particle, at all, is referred to the diverse formes of rash swearing, which the Pharisees averred to be lawfull, not to the very word of swearing it selfe: as if he should say, Sweare not falsly, or rashly at all; to wit, neither directly, nor indirectly. So saith S. James, nor by any other oath, to wit, rash, or false; by naming of certaine kinds whereof, he sheweth that all such like are forbidden. Else should Christ himselfe offend against his owne commandement,1 whereas he here saith: Let your communication be Yea, Yea; and Nay, Nay: and yet else-where oftentimes, in his most grave and reverend speech and doctrine, useth this asseveration, Verily, Verily, I say unto you. Likewise else should James condemne Paul, who by an oath tooke God to witnesse unto his soule: and the holy Ghost should contradict himselfe in condemning all manner of oathes by James, and commending an oath by another Apostle as a ready remedy, profitable, and necessary for the preservation of humane society, to determine and end all strifes and controversies, from which in this frailty mans life cannot be free. Repl. 2. The permission of oathes in Scripture, and the examples of such as have taken them, concerne publique oathes onely, that is, such as are given and taken in some publique behalfe: Therefore at least private oathes, such as passe betweene private men, are wholly forbidden. 2Ans. 1. We deny the Antecedent, because this restraint is not only not found specified in these grants and examples in Scripture, but farther also can have no places in either of them, as the view and scanning of the places doth prove. 2. There are manifest examples of a private oath, as of Jacob and Laban, Boos, Abdias, Abigail and David. 3. The same is proved also by the end of an oath: for the end thereof, which is the confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates, belongeth privately also to all Christians; and therefore so doth an oath it self also, whereby we confirme and establish faith and truth.
1Those oaths only are lawful, which disagree not with Gods word, and which are taken of things true, certainly known, lawful, possible, weighty, necessary, profitable, and worthy of such and so great a confirmation; that is, such as require a confirmation by oath, for the glory of God, and safety of our neighbour. Of these only must we swear.2 Unlawful oaths, are such as are contrary to Gods word, and ⟨p. 573⟩are taken of things either false, or uncertain, or unlawful, or impossible, or light and frivolous. Of such things we may not swear. For he that sweareth of things that are false, maketh God witness of a lie: He that sweareth of uncertain things, sweareth with an evil conscience, and with a contempt of God, when as he dareth to make God a witness of that thing, which he knoweth not whether it be a truth, or a lie: and he that so sweareth, it is all one to him whether he make God witness of a lie, or of a truth: and withal he desireth, that either God will bear witness to a lie, or if he will not be accounted the witness of a lie, that then he will punish him that sweareth. He that sweareth of unlawful things, maketh God both a favourer and an approver of that which he hath forbidden in his law, and so he maketh God contrary to himself; because he desireth God to punish him, if he do that which God commandeth; or if he do not that which God hath forbidden: and furthermore, either he hath a purpose to do against Gods commandment, or if he swear in earnest, he allegeth God for a witness of a lie. He that sweareth of impossible things, either is mad, or mocketh and derideth God and Men; seeing he cannot have an earnest purpose of performing that which he sweareth; or sweareth hypocritically, and so sweareth of a lie: namely, he sweareth that he will do that, which neither he will do, neither shall at all be done. He that sweareth lightly, showeth no reverence that he hath of God; and he that doth easily swear, doth easily also forswear. But the principal and chief cause of an oath ought to be, 1. The glory of God.3 2. The safety and welfare, as well private as public, of our neighbours. Object. Of uncertain things we may not swear. Things to come, such as those are which men promise to perform, are uncertain: Therefore we must not swear of things to come. Ans.
1THose oathes onely are lawfull, which disagree not with Gods word, and which are taken of things true, certainely knowne, lawfull, possible, weighty, necessary, profitable, and worthy of such and so great a confirmation; that is, such as require a confirmation by oath, for the glory of God, and safety of our neighbour. Of these only must we sweare.2 Ʋnlawfull oathes, are such as are contrary to Gods word, and ⟨p. 573⟩are taken of things either false, or uncertaine, or unlawfull, or impossible, or light and frivolous. Of such things we may not sweare. For he that sweareth of things that are false, maketh God witnesse of a lie: He that sweareth of uncertaine things, sweareth with an evill conscience, and with a contempt of God, when as he dareth to make God a witnesse of that thing, which he knoweth not whether it be a truth, or a lie: and he that so sweareth, it is all one to him whether he make God witnesse of a lie, or of a truth: and withall he desireth, that either God will beare witnesse to a lie, or if he will not be accounted the witnesse of a lie, that then he will punish him that sweareth. He that sweareth of unlawfull things, maketh God both a favourer and an approver of that which he hath forbidden in his law, and so he maketh God contrary to himselfe; because he desireth God to punish him, if he doe that which God commandeth; or if he doe not that which God hath forbidden: and furthermore, either he hath a purpose to doe against Gods commandement, or if he swear in earnest, he alledgeth God for a witnesse of a lie. He that sweareth of impossible things, either is mad, or mocketh and derideth God and Men; seeing he cannot have an earnest purpose of performing that which he sweareth; or sweareth hypocritically, and so sweareth of a lie: namely, he sweareth that he will doe that, which neither he will doe, neither shall at all be done. He that sweareth lightly, sheweth no reverence that he hath of God; and he that doth easily sweare, doth easily also forsweare. But the principall and chiefe cause of an oath ought to be, 1. The glory of God.3 2. The safety and welfare, as well private as publike, of our neighbours. Object. Of uncertaine things we may not sweare. Things to come, such as those are which men promise to performe, are uncertaine: Therefore we must not sweare of things to come. Ans.
We must not indeed swear of the event, as which is not at all in our power; but of our own present will of doing, either now, or hereafter, that which is just and lawful, and of the present and future binding of our selves to it, whereof every man may and ought to be certain. And so sware Abraham, Isaac, Abimelech, David, Jonathan, Boaz, and others, binding themselves to a future performance of certain duties.
We must not indeed sweare of the event, as which is not at all in our power; but of our owne present will of doing, either now, or hereafter, that which is just and lawfull, and of the present and future binding of our selves to it, whereof every man may and ought to be certaine. And so sware Abraham, Isaac, Abimelech, David, Jonathan, Booz, and others, binding themselves to a future performance of certaine duties.
Oaths conceived, or made rightly of things lawful, true, certain, weighty, and possible, are necessarily to be kept. For if once thou hast acknowledged and testified thy self to be justly bound to keep thy promise, and hast called God to record hereof; when as afterwards thou wittingly and willingly breakest thine oath, thou doest violate and break a just bond, and doest either accuse God, the witness and maintainer of this bond, of vanity and lightness, or provoke him to punish thee in that thou art a perjured person: He that sweareth to his own hinderance, and changeth not, shall never be moved. Whosoever voweth a vow unto the Lord, 1or sweareth an oath to bind himself by bond, he shall not break his promise, but shall do according to all that proceedeth out of his mouth. But oaths that are made of unlawful things, either by an error, or by ignorance, or through infirmity, or against the conscience, it is sin to keep them. And therefore such oaths are to be retracted, and re-called by repenting and surceasing a wicked purpose; not to be continued by persisting and practising it, lest we add thereby sins unto sins. In the Lords eyes a vile person is contemned, 2he that sweareth to his own hinderance, and changeth not. For, he that keepeth an oath made of unlawful things, heapeth sin upon sin, both in that he sware amiss, and so hath a will to sin; and also in that he endeavoureth to do that which he sware amiss, and so confirmeth that will of sinning by an oath: according to the common rule, Ill sworn, and worse kept; for, what things God forbiddeth, those things he will not have men, either sworn or unsworn, to perform: and what he forbiddeth us to will, or promise, or swear; so much the more doth he forbid us to do the same, how much the more grievous a thing it is to do them, than to will or promise them. They therefore who keep that which they have ill sworn, heap sin upon sin; as did Herod, putting John Baptist to death by pretence of keeping his oath: And likewise such as keep Monastical vows, whereby they have sworn Idolatry, and impious single living. Neither ⟨p. 574⟩is this argument of any force; An oath is necessary to be kept. But they have swor• these things: therefore they must needs keep them: For the Major is true of a lawful oath. But an oath, which is made of a thing forbidden by God, is not to be kept:
OAthes conceived, or made rightly of things lawfull, true, certaine, weighty, and possible, are necessarily to be kept. For if once thou hast acknowledged and testified thy selfe to be justly bound to keep thy promise, and hast called God to record hereof; when as afterwards thou wittingly and willingly breakest thine oath, thou doest violate and breake a just bond, and doest either accuse God, the witnesse and maintainer of this bond, of vanity and lightnesse, or provoke him to punish thee in that thou art a perjured person: Hee that sweareth to his owne hinderance, and changeth not, shall never be moved. Whosoever voweth a vow unto the Lord, 1or sweareth an oath to binde himselfe by bond, hee shall not breake his promise, but shall doe according to all that proceedeth out of his mouth. But oaths that are made of unlawfull things, either by an errour, or by ignorance, or through infirmity, or against the conscience, it is sin to keep them. And therefore such oathes are to be retracted, and re-called by repenting and surceasing a wicked purpose; not to be continued by persisting and practising it, lest we adde thereby sins unto sins. In the Lords eyes a vile person is contemned, 2hee that sweareth to his owne hinderance, and changeth not. For, hee that keepeth an oath made of unlawfull things, heapeth sin upon sin, both in that he sware amisse, and so hath a will to sin; and also in that hee endeavoureth to doe that which he sware amisse, and so confirmeth that will of sinning by an oath: according to the common rule, Ill sworne, and worse kept; for, what things God forbiddeth, those things he will not have men, either sworn or unsworn, to performe: and what he forbiddeth us to will, or promise, or swear; so much the more doth he forbid us to doe the same, how much the more grievous a thing it is to doe them, than to will or promise them. They therefore who keep that which they have ill sworne, heap sin upon sin; as did Herod, putting John Baptist to death by pretence of keeping his oath: And likewise such as keep Monasticall vowes, whereby they have sworne Idolatry, and impious single living. Neither ⟨p. 574⟩is this argument of any force; An oath is necessary to be kept. But they have swor• these things: therefore they must needs keep them: For the Major is true of a lawfull oath. But an oath, which is made of a thing forbidden by God, is not to be kept:
because it is not a lawful oath; which also is amended and corrected by repenting thereof, and by desisting from an evil purpose, not by persisting: therein, or by performing it: according as it is said; Let him that stole steal no more: and according to the example and doctrine of David, 1who sweareth that he will destroy. Nabal, together with his family, saying; So, and more do God unto the enemies of David: for surely I will not leave of all that he hath, 2by the dawning of the day, any that pisseth against the wall. But after he had heard Abigail speak, he giveth thanks to God, that the executing and fulfilling of his oath was hindered by her, and confirmeth by a new oath, that this is Gods blessing and benefit: saying, Blessed be the Lord God of Israel, 3which sent thee this day to meet me, and blessed be thy counsels, and blessed be thou, which hast kept me this day from coming to shed blood, and that mine hand hath not saved me. For indeed, as the Lord God of Israel liveth, who hath kept me back from hurting thee, &c. Object. 1. He that sweareth to do a thing, which is in his power to do, and yet doth it not, maketh God witness of a lie. But he that sweareth to make a slaughter, sweareth that which is in his power to do: Therefore he which sweareth to slay, and doth it not, maketh God witness of a lie; and God may not be made witness of a lie: Therefore sworn slaughter must be executed▪ Answ. The Major is true, if it be understood of a thing, which both is in our power; and is also lawful: but it is false, if we understand it of any thing, which being in our power, is unlawful. He that sweareth indeed ought that is lawful, and is in his power, and doth it not, maketh God witness of a lie: but if it be an evil thing which he sweareth, the recalling thereof is better than the keeping. For an unlawful oath being broken, maketh not God witness of a lie, because the revoking of it is good, as appeareth in the revoking of that oath which David had made to destroy Nabal with all his household. Object. 2. The oath of peace which was made to the Gibeonites, 4was against the Commandment of God: It is lawful therefore to keep an oath made of things unlawful. Answ. 1. We deny the Antecedent, namely, that that oath of peace was unlawful, and against the Commandment of God:
because it is not a lawfull oath; which also is amended and corrected by repenting thereof, and by desisting from an evill purpose, not by persisting: therein, or by performing it: according as it is said; Let him that stole steale no more: and according to the example and doctrine of David, 1who sweareth that he will destroy. Nabal, together with his family, saying; So, and more doe God unto the enemies of David: for surely I will not leave of all that he hath, 2by the dawning of the day, any that pisseth against the wall. But after hee had heard Abigail speake, hee giveth thankes to God, that the executing and fulfilling of his oath was hindered by her, and confirmeth by a new oath, that this is Gods blessing and benefit: saying, Blessed be the Lord God of Israel, 3which sent thee this day to meet mee, and blessed be thy counsels, and blessed be thou, which hast kept mee this day from coming to shed bloud, and that mine hand hath not saved mee. For indeed, as the Lord God of Israel liveth, who hath kept mee back from hurting thee, &c. Object. 1. He that sweareth to doe a thing, which is in his power to doe, and yet doth it not, maketh God witnesse of a lie. But hee that sweareth to make a slaughter, sweareth that which is in his power to doe: Therefore hee which sweareth to slay, and doth it not, maketh God witnesse of a lie; and God may not be made witnesse of a lie: Therefore sworne slaughter must be executed▪ Answ. The Major is true, if it be understood of a thing, which both is in our power; and is also lawfull: but it is false, if we understand it of any thing, which being in our power, is unlawfull. He that sweareth indeed ought that is lawfull, and is in his power, and doth it not, maketh God witnesse of a lie: but if it be an evill thing which he sweareth, the recalling thereof is better than the keeping. For an unlawfull oath being broken, maketh not God witnesse of a lie, because the revoking of it is good, as appeareth in the revoking of that oath which David had made to destroy Nabal with all his houshold. Object. 2. The oath of peace which was made to the Gibeonites, 4was against the Commandement of God: It is lawfull therefore to keep an oath made of things unlawfull. Answ. 1. We deny the Antecedent, namely, that that oath of peace was unlawfull, and against the Commandement of God:
For they were not excluded from peace, if any of those Nations, which God had commanded to be destroyed, did ask peace of the Israelites, and did embrace their religion. Now the Gibeonites desired peace, and are adjudged to serve the Tabernacle for wood-cleavers, and drawers of water perpetually. Therefore the peace which was promised them, albeit it was obtained by fraud and guile, yet was it not repugnant to Gods Commandment. 2. In this Reason is a fallacy of alleging a false cause. The Israelites do not therefore keep this oath, as that they were bound thereby, because they sware it, being deceived, and thinking the Gibeonites to have bin of another country: but, 1. For avoiding of offence, whereby the Name of God might be disgraced among the Heathen,1 if the Jews had not kept their oath. 2. Because it was lawful and just to save them, which desired peace, and embraced their religion, although no oath had been made at all.
For they were not excluded from peace, if any of those Nations, which God had commanded to be destroyed, did aske peace of the Israelites, and did imbrace their religion. Now the Gibeonites desired peace, and are adjudged to serve the Tabernacle for wood-cleavers, and drawers of water perpetually. Therefore the peace which was promised them, albeit it was obtained by fraud and guile, yet was it not repugnant to Gods Commandement. 2. In this Reason is a fallacy of alledging a false cause. The Israelites doe not therefore keep this oath, as that they were bound thereby, because they sware it, being deceived, and thinking the Gibeonites to have bin of another countrey: but, 1. For avoiding of offence, whereby the Name of God might be disgraced among the Heathen,1 if the Jewes had not kept their oath. 2. Because it was lawfull and just to save them, which desired peace, and imbraced their religion, although no oath had been made at all.
Out of those things which have been spoken, concerning the keeping of lawful oaths, answer is made unto this Question; Whether oaths extorted from men against their wills are to be kept. Extorted oaths are to be kept, if they contain nothing in them that is unlawful, or, if they have the fore alleged conditions, although they be unprofitable and hurtful to us. But unto wicked oaths no man ought to be forced: neither verily should wicked oaths be extorted by any tortures from us, but we must choose to die rather. But if any wicked and impious oaths be made, through fear or infirmity against our conscience, those do not bind, and are to be recalled; because, what is impious to be done, that is impious to be sworn, neither is one sin to be heaped on another. Now, extorted oaths, that are not impious, which are made of things lawful and possible, though hurtful and hard are doubtless to be kept; but if any impossibility afterwards happen, they bind not at all. If otherwise there happen no impossibility afterwards, they are doubtless to be kept, because thou art bound by Gods Law to choose the lesser evil. If it be just to do, which thou through constraint hast promised, it is just also for thee to promise by oath to do ⟨p. 575⟩it. For what we may lawfully do, the same also we may lawfully promise by an oath to do: As, if a man, falling into the hands of a thief, should be required of the thief to give a piece of money for the redeeming of his life, verily he not only may, but also ought, if he be able, to perform that which the thief requireth. And if this be lawfully performed unto a thief, it is lawfully also performed unto him by an oath. Likewise, it is lawful also to promise by an oath silence unto the thief: and such an oath made for the keeping of silence promised unto the thief, both may and ought to be kept. Object. That which is hurtful to the Common-wealth is not to be promised, or, if it have been promised, not to be kept. Such silence promised unto the thief is hurtful to the Common-wealth: Therefore it is not to be promised, or, if it have been promised, it is not to be kept. Ans. 1. That which is hurtful to the Common-wealth, is not to be promised, that is, if we may do it without hazard and danger of our life.
Out of those things which have been spoken, concerning the keeping of lawfull oathes, answer is made unto this Question; Whether oathes extorted from men against their wils are to be kept. Extorted oathes are to be kept, if they containe nothing in them that is unlawfull, or, if they have the fore alledged conditions, although they be unprofitable and hurtfull to us. But unto wicked oathes no man ought to be forced: neither verily should wicked oathes be extorted by any tortures from us, but wee must choose to die rather. But if any wicked and impious oathes be made, through feare or infirmity against our conscience, those doe not binde, and are to be re called; because, what is impious to be done, that is impious to be sworne, neither is one sin to be heaped on another. Now, extorted oathes, that are not impious, which are made of things lawfull and possible, though hurtfull and hard are doubtlesse to be kept; but if any impossibility afterwards happen, they binde not at all. If otherwise there happen no impossibility afterwards, they are doubtlesse to be kept, because thou art bound by Gods Law to choose the lesser evill. If it be just to doe, which thou through constraint hast promised, it is just also for thee to promise by oath to doe ⟨p. 575⟩it. For what we may lawfully doe, the same also wee may lawfully promise by an oath to doe: As, if a man, falling into the hands of a thiefe, should be required of the thiefe to give a peece of mony for the redeeming of his life, verily hee not only may, but also ought, if hee be able, to performe that which the thiefe requireth. And if this be lawfully performed unto a thiefe, it is lawfully also performed unto him by an oath. Likewise, it is lawfull also to promise by an oath silence unto the thiefe: and such an oath made for the keeping of silence promised unto the thiefe, both may and ought to be kept. Object. That which is hurtfull to the Common-wealth is not to be promised, or, if it have been promised, not to be kept. Such silence promised unto the thiefe is hurtfull to the Common-wealth: Therefore it is not to be promised, or, if it have been promised, it is not to be kept. Ans. 1. That which is hurtfull to the Common-wealth, is not to be promised, that is, if wee may doe it without hazzard and danger of our life.
And further, if at that instant, when a man is in such danger of his life, he be not rather to provide for his own safety, than to reveal such a thing. 2. It is rather profitable, than hurtful to the Common-wealth, to promise silence unto the thief, and to keep promise: For he which hath promised silence by an oath to the thief, is by this means saved. Moreover, if he should not promise by oath silence unto the thief threatening him death, he should thereby neither profit the Common-wealth, nor himself. Wherefore, to promise silence by an oath unto the thief, and to keep it; seeing it is a lesser evil, then that a Citizen should be slain, is, of the two, rather to be chosen.
And further, if at that instant, when a man is in such danger of his life, he be not rather to provide for his own safety, than to reveale such a thing. 2. It is rather profitable, than hurtfull to the Common-wealth, to promise silence unto the thief, and to keep promise: For he which hath promised silence by an oath to the thiefe, is by this meanes saved. Moreover, if he should not promise by oath silence unto the thiefe threatning him death, he should thereby neither profit the Common-wealth, nor himselfe. Wherefore, to promise silence by an oath unto the thiefe, and to keep it; seeing it is a lesser evill, then that a Citizen should be slain, is, of the two, rather to be chosen.