Therefore all oaths are forbidden amongst Christians. Answ. Here is a fallacy of Composition; namely, a mis-joining of words in this clause, or sentence, which are not to be joined together. For that particle, at all, is referred to the diverse forms of rash swearing, which the Pharisees averred to be lawful, not to the very word of swearing it self: as if he should say, Swear not falsely, or rashly at all; to wit, neither directly, nor indirectly. So saith S. James, nor by any other oath, to wit, rash, or false; by naming of certain kinds whereof, he showeth that all such like are forbidden. Else should Christ himself offend against his own commandment,1 whereas he here saith: Let your communication be Yea, Yea; and Nay, Nay: and yet else-where oftentimes, in his most grave and reverend speech and doctrine, useth this asseveration, Verily, Verily, I say unto you. Likewise else should James condemn Paul, who by an oath took God to witness unto his soul: and the holy Ghost should contradict himself in condemning all manner of oaths by James, and commending an oath by another Apostle as a ready remedy, profitable, and necessary for the preservation of humane society, to determine and end all strifes and controversies, from which in this frailty mans life cannot be free. Repl. 2. The permission of oaths in Scripture, and the examples of such as have taken them, concern public oaths only, that is, such as are given and taken in some public behalf: Therefore at least private oaths, such as pass between private men, are wholly forbidden. 2Ans. 1. We deny the Antecedent, because this restraint is not only not found specified in these grants and examples in Scripture, but farther also can have no places in either of them, as the view and scanning of the places doth prove. 2. There are manifest examples of a private oath, as of Jacob and Laban, Boos, Obadiah, Abigail and David. 3. The same is proved also by the end of an oath: for the end thereof, which is the confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates, belongeth privately also to all Christians; and therefore so doth an oath it self also, whereby we confirm and establish faith and truth.
Therefore all oathes are forbidden amongst Christians. Answ. Here is a fallacy of Composition; namely, a mis-joyning of words in this clause, or sentence, which are not to be joyned together. For that particle, at all, is referred to the diverse formes of rash swearing, which the Pharisees averred to be lawfull, not to the very word of swearing it selfe: as if he should say, Sweare not falsly, or rashly at all; to wit, neither directly, nor indirectly. So saith S. James, nor by any other oath, to wit, rash, or false; by naming of certaine kinds whereof, he sheweth that all such like are forbidden. Else should Christ himselfe offend against his owne commandement,1 whereas he here saith: Let your communication be Yea, Yea; and Nay, Nay: and yet else-where oftentimes, in his most grave and reverend speech and doctrine, useth this asseveration, Verily, Verily, I say unto you. Likewise else should James condemne Paul, who by an oath tooke God to witnesse unto his soule: and the holy Ghost should contradict himselfe in condemning all manner of oathes by James, and commending an oath by another Apostle as a ready remedy, profitable, and necessary for the preservation of humane society, to determine and end all strifes and controversies, from which in this frailty mans life cannot be free. Repl. 2. The permission of oathes in Scripture, and the examples of such as have taken them, concerne publique oathes onely, that is, such as are given and taken in some publique behalfe: Therefore at least private oathes, such as passe betweene private men, are wholly forbidden. 2Ans. 1. We deny the Antecedent, because this restraint is not only not found specified in these grants and examples in Scripture, but farther also can have no places in either of them, as the view and scanning of the places doth prove. 2. There are manifest examples of a private oath, as of Jacob and Laban, Boos, Abdias, Abigail and David. 3. The same is proved also by the end of an oath: for the end thereof, which is the confirming of faith and truth, and the deciding of debates, belongeth privately also to all Christians; and therefore so doth an oath it self also, whereby we confirme and establish faith and truth.
- 1Mat. 5.37.
- 2Isaiah 65.16. Jer. 4.2.Esay 65.16. Jer. 4.2.