OF SIN IN GENERAL.OF SIN IN GENERALL.
pp. 48–103215 passagespart 6 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 48–103215 passagespart 6 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. No:a For God hath made man such a one as he might perform it;b but man, by the impulsion of the Devil,c and his own stubbornness, bereaved himself, and all his posterity of those divine graces.
Answ. No:a For God hath made man such a one as hee might performe it;b but man, by the impulsion of the Divell,c and his own stubbornnesse, bereaved himselfe, and all his posterity of those divine graces.
This question is an objection framed by humane reason against the question here proposed: For, if man be so corrupt, that he is no way apt to do any thing well, in vain God seemeth and unjustly to require at his hands perfect obedience to the Law. Object. He that requireth or commandeth that which is impossible, is unjust; God in the Law requireth of man that which is impossible, to wit, perfect obedience, which he is not able to perform: Therefore God seemeth to be unjust. Ans. The Major is to be distinguished. He is unjust that commandeth things impossible: 1. Except himself first gave an ability to perform those things which he commanded. 2. Except man, who is commanded, covet that impotency and unability, and of his own accord hath purchased it unto himself. 3. Except the commandment, which is impossible, be a spur unto him, who is commanded, of acknowledging and bewailing his insufficiency. But God by creating man after his Image, gave him possibility, that is, a power of performing ⟨p. 100⟩that obedience which in right he requireth of him: Wherefore, if man, by his own fault and folly, lost and cast away this his good ability, and procured unto himself this unability of obeying God; God hath not therefore lost his right to require due obedience of him. Nay rather, because we have rejected this good, by transgressing Gods commandment, and because God threatened punishment to the transgressors, therefore he justly punisheth us. Repl. But not we, but Adam drew on us this sin. Answ. Our first Parents, being fallen, lost this ability both unto themselves and to their posterity; like as they received it for themselves and their posterity. If a Prince give unto a noble man a Lordship, and he traitorously rebel against him, he loseth his Lordship not only from himself, but also from his posterity: neither doth the Prince any injury to his children, if he restore no• unto them the Lordship lost by their fathers fault and disobedience; and if he do restore it, he doth it of free grace and mercy. Repl. He that commandeth things impossible, 1doth in vain command them; but God commandeth things impossible to be performed by man now after his fall: Therefore in vain he commandeth them. Answ. 1. In this reason there is a fallacy from that which is spoken and verified but in part:
THis question is an objection framed by humane reason against the question here proposed: For, if man be so corrupt, that he is no way apt to do any thing well, in vain God seemeth and unjustly to require at his hands perfect obedience to the Law. Object. He that requireth or commandeth that which is impossible, is unjust; God in the Law requireth of man that which is impossible, to wit, perfect obedience, which hee is not able to performe: Therefore God seemeth to be unjust. Ans. The Major is to be distinguished. He is unjust that commandeth things impossible: 1. Except himselfe first gave an ability to perform those things which he commanded. 2. Except man, who is commanded, covet that impotency and unability, and of his own accord hath purchased it unto himselfe. 3. Except the commandement, which is impossible, be a spur unto him, who is commanded, of acknowledging and bewailing his insufficiency. But God by creating man after his Image, gave him possibility, that is, a power of performing
as, God doth not in vain command, though we perform not that which he commandeth; because there are other ends besides of the commandment, both in the godly and ungodly: For the commandment requireth of the godly, §11. That they acknowledge their own weakness and impotency: By the Law cometh the knowledge of sin. §212. That they know what they were before the fall. §33. That they know what they ought chiefly to ask of God, to wit, the renewing of their nature. §44. That they understand and conceive what Christ hath performed on their behalf, I mean, that he hath satisfied for us, and regenerateth us. §55. That a new kind of obedience be begun in us: because it teacheth us how we ought to behave and carry our selves towards God in lieu of this benefit of freedom; or what God requireth again on our part.2 Again, the ungodly are commanded obedience: §11. That the justice of God in condemning them may be made manifest and conspicuous, because they know what they ought to do. Whereas then they do it not, they are justly condemned;3 That servant that knew his Masters will, and did it not, &c. §22. That at least outward order and discipline might be observed amongst them. §33. That such amongst them as are to be converted, may be converted. Ans. 2. We answer to the Major of this syllogism, thus distinguishing: In vain he commandeth, who commandeth things impossible; if withal he give not the possibility: But God, commanding the elect the performance of these things, giveth them also power of obeying, beginning it now by the doctrine of the Gospel▪ and in the end perfecting it. Augustine, Give, 4Lord, what thou commandest, and command what thou wilt: and thou shalt not in vain command it. Therefore this impossible exigent is the greatest benefit, because it is the high-way to attain possibility.
Answ. No: but is angry in most dreadful manner,a as well for the sins wherein we are borne, as also for those which our selves commit; and in most just judgement punisheth them with temporal and eternal punishmentsb, as himself pronounceth; Cursed be he that confirmeth not all the words of this Law to do them.c
Answ. No: but is angry in most dreadfull manner,a as well for the sins wherein we are borne, as also for those which our selves commit; and in most just judgement punisheth them with temporall and eternall punishmentsb, as himselfe pronounceth; Cursed be he that confirmeth not all the words of this Law to doe them.c
IN this question is handled the other part of mans misery, even the evil of pain and punishment: and it is said, that God doth most grievously, most justly, and most certainly punish sin. Most grievously: that is, with present and eternal pains for the greatness of sin, because the infinite good is offended thereby. Most justly; because every, even the least, sin violateth Gods Law; and therefore by the order of Gods justice meriteth eternal punishment and abjection. Most certainly; because God is true, and never changeth his sentence denounced in the Law: Cursed is he that continueth not in all, &c. Object. But the wicked flourish here, 1and carry many things clear without punishment: Therefore all sins are not punished. Ans. Yea, but they shall at length be paid home for them; yea,2 and in this life they are punished: 1. In conscience, with whose gnawings the wicked are tortured. 2. In those good things which they use with greatest pleasure; and verily so much the more, how much the less they know and acknowledge themselves to be punished: For it is a most grievous punishment, not to receive Gods gifts in respect of Gods promise, not to know the right use of them, neither with his gifts to receive a will and ability also to use them well: For if these things concur not in the fruition of good things, mens sins and punishment must needs be the more increased and exasperated; and thereby, except there come conversion, eternal destruction or death is certainly purchased. 3. They are afflicted with other punishments also most grievous oftentimes, yet with more grievous in the life to come, where it shall be a continual death, not to be dead. Object. 2. God made not evil, and death: Therefore he will not so grievously punish sin with them. Answ. He made them not in the beginning; yet when sin was committed, he in his just judgement inflicted death as a punishment on sinners, according to his commination, Thou shalt die the death. 3Whence it is also said: Shall there be evil in a City, and the Lord hath not done it? Obj. 3. If God punish sin with present and everlasting punishments, he punisheth the same twice, and is unjust; but he is not unjust, neither punisheth he the same offence twice: Therefore he will not punish sin with temporal and eternal pains. Ans. The Major is denied:
IN this question is handled the other part of mans misery, even the evill of paine and punishment: and it is said, that God doth most grievously, most justly, and most certainly punish sin. Most grievously: that is, with present and eternall paines for the greatnesse of sin, because the infinite good is offended thereby. Most justly; because every, even the least, sin violateth Gods Law; and therefore by the order of Gods justice meriteth eternall punishment and abjection. Most certainly; because God is true, and never changeth his sentence denounced in the Law: Cursed is hee that continueth not in all, &c. Object. But the wicked flourish here,
For the punishment which God inflicteth on the wicked in this life, and in the life to come, is but one punishment, but hath several parts: For present punishments are but the beginning• of everlasting; neither are they a distinct or entire punishment severally, because they are not sufficient to satisfy Gods justice. Object. 4. If God punish sins with eternal punishments, then either all of us perish, or Gods justice is not satisfied. Ans. If God should punish our sins in us with eternal punishments, we should all perish indeed: but he doth not punish them in us with eternal pains, neither yet is his justice impeached or violated, because he punisheth our sins in Christ with a punishment temporal, but yet equivalent to everlasting. This equability doth the Gospel add unto the Law. Repl. If he punish them in Christ, and be just, he ought no further to punish them in us: Therefore the godly are unjustly afflicted in this life. Ans. The afflictions of the godly are not punishments and satisfactions for their sins, but only fatherly chastisements, and the Cross, whereby they are brought to humility. Which that it may be the better understood, we are here necessarily to speak of afflictions or calamities: but first, the next question is to be expounded.
For the punishment which God inflicteth on the wicked in this life, and in the life to come, is but one punishment, but hath severall parts: For present punishments are but the beginning• of everlasting; neither are they a distinct or entire punishment severally, because they are not sufficient to satisfie Gods justice. Object. 4. If God punish sins with eternall punishments, then either all of us perish, or Gods justice is not satisfied. Ans. If God should punish our sins in us with eternall punishments, wee should all perish indeed: but he doth not punish them in us with eternall paines, neither yet is his justice impeached or violated, because hee punisheth our sins in Christ with a punishment temporall, but yet equivalent to everlasting. This equability doth the Gospel adde unto the Law. Repl. If he punish them in Christ, and be just, he ought no further to punish them in us: Therefore the godly are unjustly afflicted in this life. Ans. The afflictions of the godly are not punishments and satisfactions for their sinnes, but only fatherly chastisements, and the Crosse, whereby they are brought to humility. Which that it may be the better understood, we are here necessarily to speak of afflictions or calamities: but first, the next question is to be expounded.
Ans. Yea verily he is merciful,a but so, that he is also just.b Wherefore his justice requireth, that the same which is committed against the divine Majesty of God, should also be recompensed with extreme, that is, everlasting punishments both of body and soul.
Ans. Yea verily he is mercifull,a but so, that he is also just.b Wherefore his justice requireth, that the same which is committed against the divine Majesty of God, should also be recompenced with extreme, that is, everlasting punishments both of body and soule.
This question of the Catechism is an objection against that doctrine, That God punisheth all and every sin with everlasting pains; and thus it is framed. Object. It is the property of him that is exceeding merciful, to remit somewhat of extreme justice; but God is exceeding merciful: Therefore he will remit somewhat of extreme justice, and will not punish sin with eternal pains. Answ. We answer to the Major on this wise: It is the point of him that is merciful to remit something, but without breach of justice, if he be exactly just. Now God is so exceeding merciful, that he is also exactly just: Therefore he will so exercise mercy, that not withstanding he will not impair his justice. And the justice of God exacteth, that all sins committed against his sovereign majesty should be punished with most exquisite, that is, everlasting pains both of body and soul, that there may be some proportion between the crime and the penalty. Repl. 1. Exceeding strict justice doth not stand with exceeding mercy; in God there is exceeding mercy: Therefore in God exceeding strict justice standeth not with it. Answ. The Major is denied. Repl. Thus it is proved, Exceeding mercy admitteth mitigating equity; but strict and exact justice, such as is in God, admitteth not this: Ergo, &c. Ans. Yes, the justice of God admitteth mitigating equity and favourableness, not by omitting, but by transferring the punishment on some other. Repl. 2. With him that followeth extreme or strict justice, mercy and equity hath no place; but God doth strictly execute his Law: Therefore with him mercy hath no place. Or thus, He who remitteth nought of extreme right, he is not merciful, but only just; but God remitteth nought of his right, because he punisheth all sin with sufficient punishment. Ans. 1. We deny the Minor: For God remitteth a great deal of his strict right, though he punish sins with eternal pains. For, as touching the reprobate, he useth much favourable dealing towards them, whiles he both now deferreth their punishments, & inviteth them by many benefits unto repentance, and in the eternity it self of their punishment will punish them more mildly then they deserved.
THis question of the Catechisme is an objection against that doctrine, That God punisheth all and every sin with everlasting paines; and thus it is framed. Object. It is the property of him that is exceeding mercifull, to remit somewhat of extreme justice; but God is exceeding mercifull: Therefore he will remit somewhat of extreme justice, and will not punish sin with eternall paines. Answ. We answer to the Major on this wise: It is the point of him that is mercifull to remit something, but without breach of justice, if he be exactly just. Now God is so exceeding mercifull, that he is also exactly just: Therefore he will so exercise mercy, that not withstanding he will not impaire his justice. And the justice of God exacteth, that all sins committed against his soveraigne majesty should be punished with most exquisite, that is, everlasting paines both of body and soule, that there may be some proportion between the crime and the penalty. Repl. 1. Exceeding strict justice doth not stand with exceeding mercy; in God there is exceeding mercy: Therefore in God exceeding strict justice standeth not with it. Answ. The Major is denied. Repl. Thus it is proved, Exceeding mercy admitteth mitigating equity; but strict and exact justice, such as is in God, admitteth not this: Ergo, &c. Ans. Yes, the justice of God admitteth mitigating equity and favourablenesse, not by omitting, but by transferring the punishment on some other. Repl. 2. With him that followeth extreme or strict justice, mercy and equity hath no place; but God doth strictly execute his Law: Therefore with him mercy hath no place. Or thus, He who remitteth nought of extreme right, he is not mercifull, but only just; but God remitteth nought of his right, because he punisheth all sin with sufficient punishment. Ans. 1. We deny the Minor: For God remitteth a great deale of his strict right, though he punish sins with eternall paines. For, as touching the reprobate, he useth much favourable dealing towards them, whiles he both now deferreth their punishments, & inviteth them by many benefits unto repentance, and in the eternity it self of their punishment wil punish them more mildly then they deserved.
And as touching the elect, he useth much toleration again towards them, because he giveth us his Son, and subjecteth him unto punishment on our behalf of his mere mercy, obliged & bound thereto by no right or merit of ours. 2. The Major is denied as false in respect of him, who for his wisdom knoweth means of exercising mercy without breach of his justice: also in respect of him, who whilst he executeth his justice, yet rejoiceth not in the destruction of man, but had rather he were saved: As, when a Judge condemneth a robber to the wheel, and yet rejoiceth not in his punishment; he though he seem to execute the extremity of Law, yet useth lenity. Much more God mingleth marvellous equity with his justice: For he is not delighted with the destruction of the ungodly (because he will not the death of a sinner) and though he punish all sins with everlasting pains,1 yet he also taketh pity on us, in deriving the punishment from us, and laying it on his Son. Repl. 3. The Prophet Jeremiah saith, Forgive not their iniquity, neither put out their sin from thy sight: The mercy therefore of God is not extended to the Reprobate. Answ. 1. It is true, when God denieth his mercy unto them repenting;2 and except he have just cause why he doth not save all. But God hath most just cause why he suffereth them to perish, even the manifestation of his justice and power in punishing the wicked. 2. It is to be understood of that degree of his mercy, which he showeth towards his chosen, even of his mercy, whereby he giveth them remission of sins, his holy Spirit, and life everlasting: but it is not to be granted, concerning that general mercy, whereby he guideth and governeth all creatures. Repl. 4. The Lord saith in Isaiah: Ah, I will ease me of mine adversaries: Therefore God is delighted with the destruction of his enemies. Answ. These and the like speeches are spoken after the order of men, by an Anthropopathy, or humane affection, and by them is signified, that God will the execution of his justice, but is not delighted with the death or destruction of men, as being his creatures. Repl. 5. Nay, neither on the penitent doth God ⟨p. 103⟩exercise mercy: For if God punish all sins with sufficient punishment in Christ, he is not merciful. Answ. I deny the consequence of this Proposition, because he gave us his Son freely, who should satisfy for us.
This satisfaction did the Gospel add.
This satisfaction did the Gospel adde.
as, God doth not in vain command, though wee performe not that which hee commandeth; because there are other ends besides of the commandement, both in the godly and ungodly: For the commandement requireth of the godly, §11. That they acknowledge their owne weaknesse and impotency: By the Law cometh the knowledge of sin. §212. That they know what they were before the fall. §33. That they know what they ought chiefly to ask of God, to wit, the renewing of their nature. §44. That they understand and conceive what Christ hath performed on their behalf, I mean, that he hath satisfied for us, and regenerateth us. §55. That a new kind of obedience be begun in us: because it teacheth us how wee ought to behave and carry our selves towards God in lieu of this benefit of freedome; or what God requireth again on our part.2 Again, the ungodly are commanded obedience: §11. That the justice of God in condemning them may be made manifest and conspicuous, because they know what they ought to do. Whereas then they doe it not, they are justly condemned;3 That servant that knew his Masters will, and did it not, &c. §22. That at least outward order and discipline might be observed amongst them. §33. That such amongst them as are to be converted, may be converted. Ans. 2. We answer to the Major of this syllogisme, thus distinguishing: In vaine he commandeth, who commandeth things impossible; if withall he give not the possibility: But God, commanding the elect the performance of these things, giveth them also power of obeying, beginning it now by the doctrine of the Gospel▪ and in the end perfecting it. Augustine, Give, 4Lord, what thou commandest, and command what thou wilt: and thou shalt not in vaine command it. Therefore this impossible exigent is the greatest benefit, because it is the high-way to attaine possibility.