3. How many kinds of sins there are.
pp. 50–74104 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 50–74104 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The first division is this; All sin is either Original or Actual. This distinction is expressed Rom. 5.14. and 7.20. and 9.11.
THe first division is this; All sin is either Originall or Actuall. This distinction is expressed Rom. 5.14. and 7.20. and 9.11.
Original sin is the guilt of all mankind, 1by reason of the fall of our first Parents, and a privation of the knowledge of God and his will in our mind, and of all inclination to obey God with our will and heart; and of the contrary, in these there remaineth a wicked inclination to those things which God forbiddeth, and backwardness in those things which he commandeth, ensuing upon the fall of our first Parents, and derived from them unto all their posterity, and so corrupting their whole nature, that all by reason of this corruption are become guilty of the everlasting anger of God, neither can they do any thing pleasing and acceptable to God, 2except remission be granted for the Son of God the Mediator, and a renewing of their nature by the holy Ghost. Of this sin it is said, Death reigned even over them also that sinned not after the like manner of the transgression of Adam. In sin hath my mother conceived me. Original sin then containeth two things:§1 3The guilt of eternal damnation for the sin of our first Parents. §24The corruption of mans whole nature after the fall. Of both these Paul saith, By one man sin entered into the world, 5and death by sin; and so death went over all men, forasmuch as all men have sinned. ⟨p. 51⟩The vulgar definition passing under Anselmus his name, containeth the same in effect with this our definition, save that it more obscurely thus propoundeth it: Original sin is a want of original righteousness which should be in us: 6For original righteousness was not only a conformity of our nature with the Law of God, but also it comprehendeth in it Gods acceptation and approbation of this righteousness. Now by the fall of man, in stead of conformity, there succeeded in mans nature deformity and corruption; and guiltiness, in stead of approbation. Such is that definition also of Hugo Cardinal: Original sin as that which we draw from our birth, 7through ignorance in our understanding, and concupiscence in our flesh.
ORiginall sinne is the guilt of all mankind, 1by reason of the fall of our first Parents, and a privation of the knowledge of God and his will in our mind, and of all inclination to obey God with our will and heart; and of the contrary, in these there remaineth a wicked inclination to those things which God forbiddeth, and backwardnesse in those things which he commandeth, ensuing upon the fall of our first Parents, and derived from them unto all their posterity, and so corrupting their whole nature, that all by reason of this corruption are become guilty of the everlasting anger of God, neither can they doe any thing pleasing and acceptable to God, 2except remission be granted for the Sonne of God the Mediatour, and a renewing of their nature by the holy Ghost. Of this sinne it is said, Death reigned even over them also that sinned not after the like manner of the transgression of Adam. In sin hath my mother conceived mee. Originall sinne then containeth two things:§1 3The guilt of eternall damnation for the sinne of our first Parents. §24The corruption of mans whole nature after the fall. Of both these Paul saith, By one man sinne entred into the world, 5and death by sinne; and so death went over all men, forasmuch as all men have sinned. ⟨p. 51⟩The vulgar definition passing under Anselmus his name, containeth the same in effect with this our definition, save that it more obscurely thus propoundeth it: Originall sinne is a want of originall righteousnesse which should be in us: 6For originall righteousnesse was not onely a conformity of our nature with the Law of God, but also it comprehendeth in it Gods acceptation and approbation of this righteousnesse. Now by the fall of man, in stead of conformity, there succeeded in mans nature deformity and corruption; and guiltinesse, in stead of approbation. Such is that definition also of Hugo Cardinall: Originall sin as that which we draw from our birth, 7through ignorance in our understanding, and concupiscence in our flesh.
1Against this doctrine of Original sin in times past did the Pelagians strive, as at this day the Anabaptists do, denying that there is any Original sin, because that neither the posterity are guilty by reason of the first Parents fall; neither is sin derived into them from their ancestors by propagation, but every one sinneth, and becometh faulty by imitation only of the first Parents. These Pelagians Saint Augustine hath confuted in many books.
1Against this doctrine of Originall sin in times past did the Pelagians strive, as at this day the Anabaptists doe, denying that there is any Originall sin, because that neither the posterity are guilty by reason of the first Parents fall; neither is sin derived into them from their ancestors by propagation, but every one sinneth, and becometh faulty by imitation onely of the first Parents. These Pelagians Saint Augustine hath confuted in many bookes.
Others grant, that all became faulty by reason of the fall of our first Parents; but they deny that such corruption was bred in us, as might deserve condemnation: for, the defects, as they think, with which we are borne, are no sin. But against these Sectaries and Schismatics we are to hold these four Theorems or Positions: 1. That all mankind is held guilty of Gods everlasting wrath, 1for the disobedience of our first Parents. 2. That there are in us, besides this guilt, defects and inclinations repugnant to the Law of God, even from the hour of our birth. 3. That these defects and inclinations are sins, and deserve the eternal wrath of God. 4. That these evils are derived not by imitation, but by the propagation of a corrupt nature from our first Parents unto all their posterity, except Christ only. The first, second, and third are sufficiently confirmed in that which hath already been spoken.
Others grant, that all became faulty by reason of the fall of our first Parents; but they deny that such corruption was bred in us, as might deserve condemnation: for, the defects, as they think, with which we are borne, are no sin. But against these Sectaries and Schismaticks wee are to hold these foure Theoremes or Positions: 1. That all mankind is held guilty of Gods everlasting wrath, 1for the disobedience of our first Parents. 2. That there are in us, besides this guilt, defects and inclinations repugnant to the Law of God, even from the houre of our birth. 3. That these defects and inclinations are sins, and deserve the eternall wrath of God. 4. That these evils are derived not by imitation, but by the propagation of a corrupt nature from our first Parents unto all their posterity, except Christ only. The first, second, and third are sufficiently confirmed in that which hath already been spoken.
The fourth is thus proved:§1 1By testimonies of Scripture; We are by nature the children of wrath, as well as others. By the offence of one the fault came upon all men to condemnation. By one mans disobedience many were made sinners. Who can bring a clean thing out of filthiness? I was borne in wickedness. Except a man be borne of water and of the spirit, he cannot enter into the Kingdom of God. §22Infants dye, and are to be baptised; therefore they have sin: But they cannot as yet sin by imitation. It must needs be then that sin is bred in them. Whence it is said: I called thee a transgressor from the womb. The heart of man is evil from his youth. And Ambrose saith; Who is just in the sight of God, whereas an infant of a day old cannot be clear from sin? Every thing which is borne carrieth with it the nature of that which bare it,3 as touching the substance and accidents proper to that special kind: But we are all born of corrupt and guilty Parents: We therefore all draw by nature in our birth their corruption and guilt.§4 4By the death of Christ, who is the second Adam, we receive a double grace, Justification, and Regeneration: therefore it followeth, that out of the first Adam there issued and flowed a double evil, the guilt, I mean, and corruption of our nature; otherwise we had not stood in need of a double grace and remedy.
The fourth is thus proved:§1 1By testimonies of Scripture; Wee are by nature the children of wrath, as well as others. By the offence of one the fault came upon all men to condemnation. By one mans disobedience many were made sinners. Who can bring a cleane thing out of filthinesse? I was borne in wickednesse. Except a man be borne of water and of the spirit, hee cannot enter into the Kingdome of God. §2
11. Object. If sin be propagated from the Parents unto their posterity, it passeth to the off-spring, either by their body, or by their soul. Not by the body, because that is bestial, and unreasonable; nor by the soul, because that is not derived by deduction out of the soul of the Parents, whereas it is a spiritual substance, which may not be severed into parts; neither is it created corrupt by God, whereas God is not the author of sin: Wherefore certainly original sin passeth not by nature from the Parents unto the children. 1. Answ. We deny the Major: because the soul, being created by God pure and undefiled, may draw naughtiness and corruption from the body, though it be brutish, into which it is infused. Neither is it absurd to say, that the evil disposed temperature of the body is an unfit instrument for the good actions of the soul, and corrupteth the soul, not being established in her righteousness; so that it presently falleth from her integrity as soon as it is infused and united unto the body: 2. Answ. We likewise deny the consequence and coherence of the Major, because in ⟨p. 52⟩it there is not made a sufficient account and reckoning of the parts by which Original sin passeth: For it passeth neither by the body, nor by the soul, but by the offence of our Parents, in regard whereof God, even whilst he createth mans soul, bereaveth it of Original righteousness, and other such like gifts, which he gave on that condition to our first Parents, that they should continue, or lose them to posterity, according as they themselves either kept, or lost them. Neither is God in so doing either unjust, or the cause of sin: for this privation or want of righteousness is in respect of God, which inflicteth it for the offence of our first Parents, no sin, but a most just punishment: although in respect of the Parents, which draw it unto themselves and their posterity, it be a sin. Wherefore, if the whole Major be laid down thus, Original sin passeth unto posterity either by the Body, or by the Soul, or by the Sin of Parents, and merit of this privation of righteousness; If the Major, I say, be thus proposed, the fault of the Argument is soon espied: for, as Original sin first sprung in our Parents by their offence; so by the same it is conveyed unto posterity.
11. Object. If sinne be propagated from the Parents unto their posterity, it passeth to the off-spring, either by their body, or by their soule. Not by the body, because that is bestiall, and unreasonable; nor by the soule, because that is not derived by deduction out of the soule of the Parents, whereas it is a spirituall substance, which may not be severed into parts; neither is it created corrupt by God, whereas God is not the authour of sin: Wherefore certainly originall sinne passeth not by nature from the Parents unto the children. 1. Answ. We deny the Major: because the soule, being created by God pure and undefiled, may draw naughtinesse and corruption from the body, though it be brutish, into which it is infused. Neither is it absurd to say, that the evill disposed temperature of the body is an unfit instrument for the good actions of the soule, and corrupteth the soule, not being established in her righteousnesse; so that it presently falleth from her integrity as soone as it is infused and united unto the body: 2. Answ. We likewise deny the consequence and coherence of the Major, because in
This is not that little chink of which the Schoolmen so doubtfully dispute, to wit, of the deduction of our soul from our sinful Parents, and of the pollution of the soul by means of the body coupled therewith; but this is that wide gate, by which original sin violently rusheth into our nature, as Paul witnesseth, By one mans disobedience many were made sinners. Reply. 1. The privation or want of original righteousness is sin: 1But God inflicteth this punishment of privation, creating our soul in us bereft of those gifts, which otherwise he would have endowed it withal, if Adam had not sinned: Therefore herein God is the author of sin. Answ. There is in the Major a fallacy of Accident. This privation is sin in respect of Adam and us, sith that by his and our fault with might and main we pull it unto us, and greedily receive it; for that the creature should be destitute of righteousness and conformity with God, it is repugnant to the Law, and is sin: But in respect of God, it is a most just punishment of Adams and our disobedience, agreeable unto nature and the Law of God. Reply. 2. Yea, but God ought not to punish Adams offence with such a punishment, whereby he knew the destruction of all mankind would follow and ensue. Answ. Yea rather let Gods justice be satisfied, and let the whole world perish and come to nought. It behoved God, in regard of his exact justice and truth, to take vengeance in this sort on the pride of man; because the offending and displeasing of the highest good merited the most extreme punishment, that is, the eternal destruction of the creature; and God hath said, Thou shalt die the death. Now it is of his free mercy that out of this general ruin he saveth some, I mean the Elect through Christ.
This is not that little chinke of which the Schoolmen so doubtfully dispute, to wit, of the deduction of our soule from our sinfull Parents, and of the pollution of the soule by meanes of the body coupled therewith; but this is that wide gate, by which originall sinne violently rusheth into our nature, as Paul witnesseth, By one mans disobedience many were made sinners. Repli. 1. The privation or want of originall righteousnesse is sinne: 1But God inflicteth this punishment of privation, creating our soule in us bereft of those gifts, which otherwise he would have endowed it withall, if Adam had not sinned: Therefore herein God is the authour of sinne. Answ. There is in the Major a fallacy of Accident. This privation is sinne in respect of Adam and us, sith that by his and our fault with might and maine we pull it unto us, and greedily receive it; for that the creature should be destitute of righteousnesse and conformity with God, it is repugnant to the Law, and is sinne: But in respect of God, it is a most just punishment of Adams and our disobedience, agreeable unto nature and the Law of God. Repli. 2. Yea, but God ought not to punish Adams offence with such a punishment, whereby he knew the destruction of all mankind would follow and ensue. Answ. Yea rather let Gods justice be satisfied, and let the whole world perish and come to nought. It behoved God, in regard of his exact justice and truth, to take vengeance in this sort on the pride of man; because the offending and displeasing of the highest good merited the most extreme punishment, that is, the eternall destruction of the creature; and God hath said, Thou shalt die the death. Now it is of his free mercy that out of this generall ruine he saveth some, I meane the Elect through Christ.
Object. 2. The desiring of their proper objects is naturally incident to each faculty and appetite: Therefore it is no sin. Answ. The ordinate desires of their objects, which God appointed them, are no sins; but the inordinate, and such as are against the Law, they are sins: For simply or merely to desire, is of it self no sin; and the appetite or desire is good, because it is natural: but to desire contrary to the Law, this is sin.
Object. 2. The desiring of their proper objects is naturally incident to each faculty and appetite: Therefore it is no sinne. Answ. The ordinate desires of their objects, which God appointed them, are no sins; but the inordinate, and such as are against the Law, they are sinnes: For simply or meerly to desire, is of it selfe no sinne; and the appetite or desire is good, because it is naturall: but to desire contrary to the Law, this is sinne.
Object. 3. Original sin is taken away from the Saints of God: Therefore they cannot derive it unto their posterity. Answ. We answer to this Antecedent, that original sin is taken away from the Saints of God, as concerning the guilt of it, which is remitted unto them by Christ: but yet, as concerning the pure essence thereof, that is, as it is a sin repugnant to the Law, so it remaineth in them. For although they be withal regenerated by the holy Ghost, unto whomsoever their sin is forgiven; yet that renewing is not perfected in this life. Wherefore the godly also do derive such a corrupt nature to their posterity as themselves have. Reply. That which the Parents themselves have not, they cannot derive unto their posterity: But the guilt of Original sin is taken away from regenerate Parents: 1Therefore at least the guilt is not derived. Answ. We must distinguish of the Major. The Parents indeed convey not that to their posterity which by nature they have not. But they are freed from the guilt of sin, not by nature, but by the grace and benefit of Christ. ⟨p. 53⟩Wherefore Parents by nature derive unto their posterity, not righteousness, which is freely imputed; but unrighteousness and damnation, unto which themselves by nature are subject. And the cause why they derive their guilt unto them,2 and not their righteousness, is this: Because their posterity are not borne of them according to grace, but according to nature; neither is grace and justification tied to carnal propagation, but to the most free election of God. Examples hereof we have Jacob and Esau, &c.
Object. 3. Originall sinne is taken away from the Saints of God: Therefore they cannot derive it unto their posterity. Answ. We answer to this Antecedent, that originall sinne is taken away from the Saints of God, as concerning the guilt of it, which is remitted unto them by Christ: but yet, as concerning the pure essence thereof, that is, as it is a sinne repugnant to the Law, so it remaineth in them. For although they be withall regenerated by the holy Ghost, unto whomsoever their sinne is forgiven; yet that renewing is not perfected in this life. Wherefore the godly also doe derive such a corrupt nature to their posterity as themselves have. Repli. That which the Parents themselves have not, they cannot derive unto their posterity: But the guilt of Originall sinne is taken away from regenerate Parents:
Austin illustrateth this point by two similitudes: the one is of the grains of corn, which though they are sown, purged by threshing from their stalk, chaff, beard, and ear; yet spring again from out of the earth with all these: and this cometh to pass, because the purging is not natural to the grain, but is the work of mans industry. The other is of a circumcised father, who though himself have no fore-skin; yet he begetteth a son with a fore-skin: and this cometh to pass, because Circumcision was not by nature in the father, but by the Covenant.
Austin illustrateth this point by two similitudes: the one is of the graines of corn, which though they are sown, purged by threshing from their stalke, chaffe, beard, and eare; yet spring againe from out of the earth with all these: and this cometh to passe, because the purging is not naturall to the graine, but is the work of mans industry. The other is of a circumcised father, who though himselfe have no fore-skin; yet he begetteth a son with a fore-skin: and this cometh to passe, because Circumcision was not by nature in the father, but by the Covenant.
Object. 4. If the root be holy, the branches also are holy: 1Therefore the children of the Saints are holy, and without original sin. Answ. Here is committed a fallacy of ambiguity: for holiness in this place signifieth not a freedom from sin, or integrity and uprightness of nature; but that prerogative and privilege of Abraham's posterity, whereby God, for his league made with Abraham, had appointed always to convert some of his posterity, and to endow them with true and inward holiness; and because all the posterity of Abraham had obtained the right and title of the external Church.
Object. 4. If the root be holy, the branches also are holy: 1Therefore the children of the Saints are holy, and without originall sinne. Answ. Here is committed a fallacy of ambiguity: for holinesse in this place signifieth not a freedome from sinne, or integrity and uprightnesse of nature; but that prerogative and priviledge of Abrahams posterity, whereby God, for his league made with Abraham, had appointed alwayes to convert some of his posterity, and to endow them with true and inward holinesse; and because all the posterity of Abraham had obtained the right and title of the externall Church.
Object. 5. Your children are holy: Therefore without original sin. 1Answ. This is a fallacy drawn from the abuse of a common manner of speech. They are holy, not that all the children of holy men are regenerate, or have holiness from carnal propagation: for it is said, When they had neither done good nor evil, I have loved Jacob, 2and have hated Esau: but the children of the godly are holy, in respect of the external fellowship of the Church; that is to say, they are to be counted for Members or Citizens of the Church, and so also for the chosen and sanctified of God, except themselves, when they come to age, declare themselves to be others by their unbelief and impiety.
Object. 5. Your children are holy: Therefore without originall sinne. 1Answ. This is a fallacy drawne from the abuse of a common manner of speech. They are holy, not that all the children of holy men are regenerate, or have holiness from carnall propagation: for it is said, When they had neither done good nor evill, I have loved Jacob, 2and have hated Esau: but the children of the godly are holy, in respect of the externall fellowship of the Church; that is to say, they are to be counted for Members or Citizens of the Church, and so also for the chosen and sanctified of God, except themselves, when they come to age, declare themselves to be others by their unbeliefe and impiety.
Object. 6. They are more miserable unto whom the sins of all their ancestors are derived, then they unto whom have stretched but the sins of some of their ancestors: But if sin pass from the Parents unto the children, then unto the latest of their posterity come the sins of all the ancestors; unto the former only their sins that lived before them: So then the latter are more miserable then all the rest, which would be absurd, and not agreeable to the justice of God. Answ. 1. It were not absurd, although God would punish more heavily, and more forsake the latter of the posterity then the former: For how many more sins are committed and heaped up by mankind, so much the more vehemently is his wrath kindled, and the punishment is more aggravated: whereupon are those sayings; The wickedness of the Amorites is not yet full. 1That upon you may come all the righteous blood, &c. Answ. 2. We deny also the Minor: For although God suffer original sin, that is, the corruption and guilt of nature to pass unto all posterity; yet, together with this, he of his mere mercy doth set bounds and limits for sin, that the posterity may not always pay for the actual sins of their ancestors, or imitate them, and that it may not be of necessity that the children of evil Parents should be evil, or worse, or more miserable then their Parents.
Object. 6. They are more miserable unto whom the sins of all their ancestors are derived, then they unto whom have stretched but the sins of some of their ancestors: But if sin passe from the Parents unto the children, then unto the latest of their posterity come the sins of all the ancestors; unto the former only their sins that lived before them: So then the latter are more miserable then all the rest, which would be absurd, and not agreeable to the justice of God. Answ. 1. It were not absurd, although God would punish more heavily, and more forsake the latter of the posterity then the former: For how many more sins are committed and heaped up by mankind, so much the more vehemently is his wrath kindled, and the punishment is more aggravated: whereupon are those sayings; The wickednesse of the Amorites is not yet full. 1That upon you may come all the righteous bloud, &c. Answ. 2. We deny also the Minor: For although God suffer originall sin, that is, the corruption and guilt of nature to passe unto all posterity; yet, together with this, he of his meer mercy doth set bounds and limits for sinne, that the posterity may not alwaies pay for the actuall sins of their ancestors, or imitate them, and that it may not be of necessity that the children of evill Parents should be evill, or worse, or more miserable then their Parents.
Object. 7. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father: 1Therefore it is injustice, that Adams posterity should bear the punishment of the sin of Adam. Ans. True it is, the son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, or shall not satisfy for his fathers mis-doing, but with this condition; If himself approve not, or fall not into the same, but disliketh and avoideth it: But we justly bear the sin of Adam;2 1. Because we all approve of the offence, and imitate the same. 2. Because the fault is so Adams, that it also becometh ours: for we were all in Adam when he sinned; and therefore, as the Apostle witnesseth, We all sinned in him. 3. Whereas Adams whole nature was guilty, and we, as a part of him, proceed out of his substance and mass, 3we ⟨p. 54⟩cannot but be guilty also our selves. 4. Because Adam received the gifts of God to be imparted unto us on that condition, if himself did retain them: or lose them unto us, if himself lost them. Whereas then Adam lost them he lost them not only in himself, but in all his posterity also.
Object. 7. The sonne shall not beare the iniquity of the father: 1Therefore it is injustice, that Adams posterity should beare the punishment of the sin of Adam. Ans. True it is, the son shall not beare the iniquity of the father, or shall not satisfie for his fathers mis-doing, but with this condition; If himselfe approve not, or fall not into the same, but disliketh and avoideth it: But wee justly beare the sinne of Adam;2 1. Because wee all approve of the offence, and imitate the same. 2. Because the fault is so Adams, that it also becometh ours: for wee were all in Adam when hee sinned; and therefore, as the Apostle witnesseth, We all sinned in him. 3. Whereas Adams whole nature was guilty, and wee, as a part of him, proceed out of his substance and masse, 3
Object. 8. All sin is committed with the will; but Infants want will: Therefore they commit no sin. Answ. 1. We grant this argument, if it proceed on actual sin, not on original, which is the corruption of nature. Ans. 2. We deny the Minor, because Infants want not the faculty and power of will; and though in act they will not sin, yet they will it by inclination. Reply. on the first answer. The corruption and defects of nature rather deserve pardon and commiseration, then punishment and reprehension, as Aristotle testifieth in these words: 1No man reprehendeth the defects of nature; but original sin is a defect of nature: Therefore it deserveth not punishment. Answ. The Major is currant in such defects of nature as are gotten not by negligence or misdemeanour; as, if a man become blind, either by nature, or by some disease, or stroke, he is rather to be pitied for it, then upbraided: But such defects as are procured by some misdemeanour,2 as original sin was; these all men worthily reprove, as Aristotle himself there addeth: But every man checks such a one as becometh blind through wine-bibbing, or any other mis-behaviour. And thus much touching original sin.
Object. 8. All sin is committed with the will; but Infants want will: Therefore they commit no sin. Answ. 1. We grant this argument, if it proceed on actuall sin, not on originall, which is the corruption of nature. Ans. 2. We deny the Minor, because Infants want not the faculty and power of will; and though in act they will not sin, yet they will it by inclination. Repli. on the first answer. The corruption and defects of nature rather deserve pardon and commiseration, then punishment and reprehension, as Aristotle testifieth in these words: 1No man reprehendeth the defects of nature; but originall sin is a defect of nature: Therefore it deserveth not punishment. Answ. The Major is currant in such defects of nature as are gotten not by negligence or misdemeanour; as, if a man become blind, either by nature, or by some disease, or stroke, he is rather to be pitied for it, then upbraided: But such defects as are procured by some misdemeanour,2 as originall sinne was; these all men worthily reprove, as Aristotle himselfe there addeth: But every man checks such a one as becometh blinde through wine-bibbing, or any other mis-behaviour. And thus much touching originall sinne.
1Actual sin is every inward and outward action which was repugnant to the Law of God, as well in the understanding, will, and heart, as in outward actions: and the omitting of those things which the Law commandeth; as to think, to will, to follow, and to do evil; or not to know, not to will, to fly, to omit that which is good. Hitherto belongeth that division into sins of commission or fact, and sins of omission.
1ACtuall sin is every inward and outward action which was repugnant to the Law of God, as well in the understanding, will, and heart, as in outward actions: and the omitting of those things which the Law commandeth; as to thinke, to will, to follow, and to doe evill; or not to know, not to will, to flye, to omit that which is good. Hitherto belongeth that division into sins of commission or fact, and sins of omission.
The second division of sin is thus:1 There is reigning sin, and sin not reigning. Reigning sin is that in which the sinner maketh no resistance by the grace of the holy Spirit, and is therefore subject to everlasting death, unless he repent, and purchase pardon by the death of Christ. Or, sin reigning is all sin which is repented of, and which is not resisted by the grace of the holy Spirit; and for which, not only according to the order of Gods justice, but also for the thing it self, he is guilty of eternal punishment who hath it. Of this it is said,2 Let not sin reign in your mortal bodies. Also, He that committeth sin, that is to say, he which of purpose sinneth, and delighteth therein, is of the Devil; where John speaketh of Reigning sin. It is called Reigning: 1. Because we pamper it, and become slaves unto it. 32. Because it hath rule over man, and maketh him guilty of eternal damnation.
THe second division of sin is thus:1 There is reigning sin, and sin not reigning. Reigning sin is that in which the sinner maketh no resistance by the grace of the holy Spirit, and is therefore subject to everlasting death, unlesse he repent, and purchase pardon by the death of Christ. Or, sin reigning is all sin which is repented of, and which is not resisted by the grace of the holy Spirit; and for which, not onely according to the order of Gods justice, but also for the thing it selfe, he is guilty of eternall punishment who hath it. Of this it is said,2 Let not sin reigne in your mortall bodies. Also, He that committeth sin, that is to say, he which of purpose sinneth, and delighteth therein, is of the Divell; where John speaketh of Reigning sin. It is called Reigning: 1. Because we pamper it, and become slaves unto it. 32. Because it hath rule over man, and maketh him guilty of eternall damnation.
Such are all sins in the unregenerate, and some also in the regenerate; as errors in the foundation of faith, and slidings and fallings against their conscience, wherewith a sure confidence of remission of sins, and true and lively comfort cannot consist, unless they repent: for that they very regenerate may run head long into reigning sin, the doleful falls of those most holy men, Aaron and David, do sufficiently declare.1 Sin not reigning is that which the sinner resisteth by the grace of the holy Spirit, and is therefore exempt from eternal death, because he repenteth, and obtaineth remission by Christ. Such kind of sins are all the defects, inclinations, wicked desires, and many sins of ignorance, omission, and infirmity, which remain in the faithful, as long as they are in this life; which notwithstanding they acknowledge, bewail, and hate in themselves, yea they resist them, and pray daily that they may be forgiven them through Christ their Mediator, saying, Forgive us our debts: and therefore in these they hold fast and embrace faith and consolation in their Saviour ⟨p. 55⟩and Redeemer. If we say we have no sin, we deceive our selves, 2and there is no truth in us. It is no more I that do it, but the sin that dwelleth in me. There is no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus, which walk after the Spirit. Who can tell how oft he offendeth? Lord, cleanse thou me from my secret faults. That vulgar distinction of sin into Mortal and Venial sin, may be reduced unto this distinction of Reigning, 3and not reigning sin: For although all sin in his proper nature be Mortal, that is, deserveth everlasting death; yet Reigning sin may most fitly so be called, wherein whosoever persevereth, finally perisheth. Now it becometh Venial, that is to say, it effecteth not everlasting death, when in the regenerate resisting it by the grace of Christ it waxeth not reigning: not that of it self it deserveth remission, or that it is not worthy of punishment; but because it is by grace through Christs satisfaction pardoned unto them that believe, and is not imputed to them unto condemnation: according as it is said,4 There is no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus, &c. And in this sense the distinction of Mortal and Venial sin may be retained; but by no means in that sense in which it is used of the Popes Favourites:
as,1 if that were Mortal sin, which for the grievousness thereof deserveth eternal death; that Venial, which for the lightness thereof deserveth not eternal death at Gods hands, but some temporal punishment only. I had rather, in stead of Mortal and Venial sin, use the names of Reigning and Not reigning sin: 21. Because the names of Mortal and Venial sin are obscure and doubtful: For all sins are Mortal; and John also calleth Mortal sin, or sin to death, the sin against the holy Ghost. 2. Because the Scripture useth not these terms, especially the name of Venial sin. 3. Because of the errors of the Papists, who term Venial sins those which are light, and deserve not eternal pains: whereas the Scripture saith. Cursed is every one that bideth not in all, &c. 3He which faileth in one point, is guilty of all. The wages of sin is death. Whosoever shall break one of these least commandments, and teach men so, he shall be called the least in the Kingdom of Heaven. In a word, every sin is in his own nature Mortal, to wit, it deserveth everlasting death; but it is made Venial, that is, it accomplisheth not death eternal in the regenerate, by grace through Christ.
as,1 if that were Mortall sinne, which for the grievousnesse thereof deserveth eternall death; that Veniall, which for the lightnesse thereof deserveth not eternall death at Gods hands, but some temporall punishment onely. I had rather, in stead of Mortall and Veniall sin, use the names of Reigning and Not reigning sin: 21. Because the names of Mortall and Veniall sin are obscure and doubtfull: For all sins are Mortall; and John also calleth Mortall sin, or sin to death, the sin against the holy Ghost. 2. Because the Scripture useth not these termes, especially the name of Veniall sin. 3. Because of the errours of the Papists, who terme Veniall sins those which are light, and deserve not eternall paines: whereas the Scripture saith. Cursed is every one that bideth not in all, &c. 3He which faileth in one point, is guilty of all. The wages of sin is death. Whosoever shall break one of these least commandements, and teach men so, he shall be called the least in the Kingdome of Heaven. In a word, every sin is in his owne nature Mortall, to wit, it deserveth everlasting death; but it is made Veniall, that is, it accomplisheth not death eternall in the regenerate, by grace through Christ.
Object. 1. But the Elect fall not from grace. Answ. Finally they do not: But they who sin mortally, and do not repent, perish. This falleth not to the Elect, that they should fall finally; but before the end, they fall easily and often.
Object. 1. But the Elect fall not from grace. Answ. Finally they doe not: But they who sin mortally, and doe not repent, perish. This falleth not to the Elect, that they should fall finally; but before the end, they fall easily and often.
Object. 2. The will of God is unchangeable; but he will the salvation of the Elect: Therefore it is unchangeable. Answ. I grant that it is true, concerning the purpose and counsel of God, but not concerning our affiance, which we have of the remission of sins: for our comfort standeth not together with errors, which are contrary to the foundation, and with sin committed against our consciences. For then are we said to have remission of our sins, when we apply these benefits to our selves. Now in Christ Jesus ye which once were far off, are made near by the the blood of Christ. 1I will say to them which were not my people, Thou art my people: And they shall say, Thou art my God.
Object. 2. The will of God is unchangeable; but hee will the salvation of the Elect: Therefore it is unchangeable. Answ. I grant that it is true, concerning the purpose and counsell of God, but not concerning our affiance, which we have of the remission of sins: for our comfort standeth not together with errours, which are contrary to the foundation, and with sinne committed against our consciences. For then are wee said to have remission of our sinnes, when wee apply these benefits to our selves. Now in Christ Jesus ye which once were farre off, are made neere by the the bloud of Christ. 1I will say to them which were not my people, Thou art my people: And they shall say, Thou art my God.
1Object. 3. He that is borne of God, sinneth not: Therefore the regenerate sin not. Answ. 1. He sinneth not to death: For the Elect do not wholly forsake God, albeit they sin against their consciences; but they retain still some beginning of true godliness, by which, as by sparkles, they are stirred again to repentance: as David, Peter, and others. 2. He sinneth not as he is regenerated: but he sinneth as long as he abideth in this life, sin not reigning in him, and yet sometimes reigning too, as he is not regenerated by the Spirit of God, but is as yet carnal:2 For regeneration, or the renewing of us to the image of God, is not perfected in an instant, but is begun only in this life, and in the life to come is at length finished. For so doth John himself pronounce of himself, and all the Saints in this life:3 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive our selves, and the truth is not in us. If we acknowledge our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. This is therefore the meaning of John, that the regenerate indeed do sin, but yet not so, that they make much of their sin, or do so at any time yield and assent to evil desires, that they cast away all love of godliness, and repent not: ⟨p. 56⟩For always in the regenerate there remaineth some remnant of a regenerate nature, which causeth either a strife against sin, or else true repentance: that is, it suffereth them not to sin to death, or everlasting destruction, or wholly to forsake God. And this consolation so long they enjoy, as they know themselves to be regenerated, that is, as they keep faith and a good conscience.
1Object. 3. Hee that is borne of God, sinneth not: Therefore the regenerate sinne not. Answ. 1. He sinneth not to death: For the Elect do not wholly forsake God, albeit they sinne against their consciences; but they retaine still some beginning of true godlinesse, by which, as by sparkles, they are stirred again to repentance: as David, Peter, and others. 2. He sinneth not as he is regenerated: but he sinneth as long as he abideth in this life, sinne not reigning in him, and yet sometimes reigning too, as he is not regenerated by the Spirit of God, but is as yet carnall:
Object. 4.1 It is said, His seed remaineth in him, neither can he sin, because he is borne of God. And, being borne anew, not of mortal seed, but of immortal, by the word of God, who liveth and endureth for ever. If therefore the seed of Gods word never dieth in them that are borne anew, they ever remain regenerate, and ever retain grace, neither ever fall into reigning sin. 2Answ. 1. The regenerate may lose, and do often lose grace and the holy Spirit, as concerning some gifts, sometimes mo, sometimes fewer; although they lose it not, if we respect all the gifts: For there abideth in them some beginning or print of true faith and conversion, which although when they yield to evil inclinations or desires, it is so oppressed and darkened, that it neither can be known of others, neither confirm them of the grace of God, and their own salvation for the present; yet it suffereth them not wholly to forsake God and the known truth, and to cast away their purpose of embracing by faith the merit of the Son of God.3 So David prayeth, Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me. Again, Restore me to the joy of thy salvation. He had lost therefore cleanness of heart, rightness and newness of spirit, and the joy of salvation, which he beggeth of God to be restored unto him; and yet did he not wholly want them: for otherwise he would not have asked, neither would he have looked for from God this renewing and restoring. 2. The seed of God, that is, the word of God, working true faith and conversion in the Elect, abideth, and dyeth not in the regenerate, as concerning their conversion and final perseverance, how ever they fall often grievously before their end:4 If they had been of us, they would have continued with us.
Object. 4.1 It is said, His seed remaineth in him, neither can he sin, because hee is borne of God. And, being borne anew, not of mortall seed, but of immortall, by the word of God, who liveth and endureth for ever. If therefore the seed of Gods word never dieth in them that are borne anew, they ever remaine regenerate, and ever retaine grace, neither ever fall into reigning sin.
Object. 5.1 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit. Answ. It cannot, as it is good: For, if it be simply good, all the fruit thereof is good; which shall come so to pass in the life to come: But if it be partly good, and partly evil, such is the fruit also; which we have trial and experience of in this life.
Object. 5.1 A good tree cannot bring forth evill fruit. Answ. It cannot, as it is good: For, if it be simply good, all the fruit thereof is good; which shall come so to pass in the life to come: But if it be partly good, and partly evill, such is the fruit also; which we have triall and experience of in this life.
Heretofore it hath been said,1 That all sins are in their own nature mortal. Against this sentence some oppose that which is said, I will confess my wickedness unto the Lord, and thou forgavest the punishment of my sin. And A just man falleth seven times, and riseth again. Whence they gather, that there are some sins, the committers whereof continue still just; and therefore deserve not eternal death. But they reason amiss from that which befalleth to sin, but by an accident, to that which is by it self in sin: For it is true indeed, that there are many sins, for which the Saints do not lose holiness and righteousness, neither become obnoxious to the wrath of God. But this cometh to pass, not by the smallness, or nature of the sin, whatsoever it be, but by the grace of God, who doth not impute, neither will punish with eternal death those sins, which yet in their own nature deserved it. This doth the Prophet most evidently show in the same Psalm,2 when he saith, Blessed is he whose wickedness is forgiven. Enter not into judgement with thy servant: for in thy sight shall none that liveth be justified.
Heretofore it hath been said,1 That all sins are in their owne nature mortall. Against this sentence some oppose that which is said, I will confesse my wickednesse unto the Lord, and thou forgavest the punishment of my sin. And A just man falleth seven times, and riseth againe. Whence they gather, that there are some sinnes, the committers whereof continue still just; and therefore deserve not eternall death. But they reason amisse from that which befalleth to sinne, but by an accident, to that which is by it selfe in sin: For it is true indeed, that there are many sins, for which the Saints doe not lose holi••sse and righteousnesse, neither become obnoxious to the wrath of God. But this cometh to passe, not by the smalnesse, or nature of the sin, whatsoever it be, but by the grace of God, who doth not impute, neither will punish with eternall death those sins, which yet in their owne nature deserved it. This doth the Prophet most evidently shew in the same Psalme,2 when he saith, Blessed is he whose wickednesse is forgiven. Enter not into judgement with thy servant: for in thy sight shall none that liveth be justified.
Object. 2.1 It is said Whosoever is angry with his brother unadvisedly, shall be culpable of judgement. And whosoever saith unto his brother, Racha, shall be worthy to be punished by the Council. And whosoever shall say, Fool, shall be worthy to be punished with hell fire. Whence they conclude, Seeing Christ himself maketh degrees of punishments and sins, so that of these former, he threateneth hell fire but unto the third only: therefore there are some sins smaller then those which deserve eternal punishment. But the answer unto this is manifest out of the words themselves: which is, that Christ doth not speak of civill judgements and punishments, when he mentioneth Judgement and a Council: For he doth not here speak of the civill order, but disputeth against the corruptions of the Pharisees, concerning the true meaning of Gods Law; and concerning the judgement of God against both inward and outward sins: For neither ⟨p. 57⟩can, nor ought to be punished by the Magistrate with corporal punishment; either such gestures, as signify some bitterness or contempt; or bad affections, if they have not accompanying them an endeavour to do any man injury. Now, whereas in the third place he nameth hell fire, he doth not exempt the other two kinds of sin from eternal punishments, but signifieth that the third shall receive a sharper punishment at Gods hand then the other.
Object. 2.1 It is said Whosoever is angry with his brother unadvisedly, shall be culpable of judgement. And whosoever saith unto his brother, Racha, shall be worthy to be punished by the Councell. And whosoever shall say, Foole, shall be worthy to be punished with hell fire. Whence they conclude, Seeing Christ himselfe maketh degrees of punishments and sins, so that of these former, hee threatneth hell fire but unto the third onely: therefore there are some sins smaller then those which deserve eternall punishment. But the answer unto this is manifest out of the words themselves: which is, that Christ doth not speak of civill judgements and punishments, when he mentioneth Judgement and a Councell: For he doth not here speak of the civill order, but disputeth against the corruptions of the Pharisees, concerning the true meaning of Gods Law; and concerning the judgement of God against both inward and outward sins: For neither ⟨p. 57⟩
Object. 3. It is said, Every sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men, 1but the blasphemy against the holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men, neither in this world, nor in the world to come. Hence they will gather, That some sins are forgiven in this world, some in the world to come, that is, in Purgatory; and some are never forgiven: of which these be Mortal, but the others Venial in their own nature. Answ. 1. But, Neither here, neither else-where doth Christ teach, that some sins are forgiven in the world to come. 2For that all other sins are forgiven not in the world to come, but in this world, both Christ signifieth in this place, and the Scripture else-where teacheth, because it is certain, that sins are not remitted, but only to those who repent:3 But he denieth that the sin against the holy Ghost is remitted, either in this world, or in the world to come, that he might more significantly express the denial of pardon to it. 2. Whether they say forgiveness to be in this world, or in the world to come; yet this standeth immovable, that it cometh not of the nature or corruption of the sin, but of free mercy for Christs sake. And if every sin be so grievous, that it could not be purged, but by the blood of the Son of God; then doubtless they do great despite and contumely unto that blood, who so extenuate any sin, as to deny that it deserveth eternal punishment, unto which the death of the Son of God is equivalent. 3. Even by their own confession, there are many mortal sins, which notwithstanding are forgiven in this life. Wherefore, either they must make all these to be even in their own nature Venial, or they will never prove out of this place, that the ••nalnesse of the sin is the cause of forgiveness.
Object. 3. It is said, Every sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men, 1but the blasphemy against the holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men, neither in this world, nor in the world to come. Hence they will gather, That some sinnes are forgiven in this world, some in the world to come, that is, in Purgatory; and some are never forgiven: of which these be Mortall, but the others Veniall in their owne nature. Answ. 1. But, Neither here, neither else-where doth Christ teach, that some sins are forgiven in the world to come.
Object. 4. It is said, The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness. 1And, Know ye not, that the unrighteous shall not inherit the Kingdom of God? 2Out of these and the like places they gather, that seeing they are mortal sins which shut men out of the Kingdom of God, and all sins do not so: therefore there are some sins, which in their own nature are not mortal. But they conclude more then followeth by force of reason: For that some sins are Venial; there is no doubt;3 but that cometh by grace remitting those sins, which, without remission, would shut men doubtless from the Kingdom of God.
Object. 4. It is said, The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodlinesse. 1And, Know yee not, that the unrighteous shall not inherit the Kingdome of God? 2Out of these and the like places they gather, that seeing they are mortall sins which shut men out of the Kingdome of God, and all sins do not so: therefore there are some sins, which in their owne nature are not mortall. But they conclude more then followeth by force of reason: For that some sins are Veniall; there is no doubt;3 but that cometh by grace remitting those sins, which, without remission, would shut men doubtlesse from the Kingdome of God.
Object. 5. It is said, If any mans work burn, he shall lose; but he shall be safe himself, nevertheless, yet as it were by fire: Therefore say they, some sins cast men into fire, that is, into some punishment, but not eternal. This also we grant, not in respect of the nature of sin, but in respect of pardon, which befalleth to those who hold the foundation, which is Christ: For, to build on the foundation wood and stubble (that is, to patch the Word of God with unnecessary questions, humane opinions and traditions, which often are occasions of Schisms in the Church, and often of Idolatry and errors) it is not so light a sin as they deem it who doit, but deserveth eternal malediction, except remission be made by the Son of God, as it is declared in the Revelation, Chap. 22.
Object. 5. It is said, If any mans work burne, he shall lose; but he shall be safe himselfe, neverthelesse, yet as it were by fire: Therefore say they, some sins cast men into fire, that is, into some punishment, but not eternall. This also we grant, not in respect of the nature of sin, but in respect of pardon, which befalleth to those who hold the foundation, which is Christ: For, to build on the foundation wood and stubble (that is, to patch the Word of God with unnecessary questions, humane opinions and traditions, which often are occasions of Schismes in the Church, and often of Idolatry and errors) it is not so light a sin as they deem it who doit, but deserveth eternall malediction, except remission be made by the Son of God, as it is declared in the Revelation, Chap. 22.
Object. 6. It is said, A high Priest taken from among men is bound to offer for sins, 1as well for his own part, as for the peoples. Ans. This place showeth, that the sins of the Priest are not Venial by themselves, or of their own nature, but for the sacrifice of Christ, which was signified by the typical sacrifices: and therefore it quite and clean overthroweth the opinion of our adversaries. For, if all sins even of a righteous Priest are in the sight of God so great, that they cannot be purged, but by the death of the Son of God; it necessarily followeth, that they of their own nature deserved everlasting death.
Object. 6. It is said, A high Priest taken from among men is bound to offer for sinnes, 1as well for his owne part, as for the peoples. Ans. This place sheweth, that the sins of the Priest are not Veniall by themselves, or of their owne nature, but for the sacrifice of Christ, which was signified by the typicall sacrifices: and therefore it quite and cleane overthroweth the opinion of our adversaries. For, if all sins even of a righteous Priest are in the sight of God so great, that they cannot be purged, but by the death of the Son of God; it necessarily followeth, that they of their owne nature deserved everlasting death.
Ob. 7. It is said, When lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin; 1and sin when it is finished bringeth forth death. Here, say they, James saith, that there is one sin finished, when as the will upon deliberation consenteth to evil lust: another not finished, when a man sinneth ⟨p. 58⟩without deliberation) and to sin finished he ascribeth, that it bringeth forth death. We answer, that the consequence of this is not o• force, because that a property which belongeth to divers kinds, when it is ascribed to one kind, it followeth not thereof, that it is to be removed from the other.2 For S. James distinguisheth the kinds or degrees of sins, Original and Actual: and saith, that death followeth after Actual; not as if death did not follow after Original, but because that actual is a middle between Original sin and death, as a cause of this, and an effect of that, and doth aggravate death or punishment, which already was purchased by Original sin. Neither doth he chiefly speak of the degrees of punishments, but of the cause and original of them to be sought in the corruption of our own nature.
Ob. 7. It is said, When lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin; 1and sin when it is fini••ed bringeth forth death. Here, say they, James saith, that there is one sin finished, when as the will upon deliberation consenteth to evill lust: another not finished, when a man sinneth ⟨p. 58⟩without deliberation) and to sin finished he ascribeth, that it bringeth forth death. We answer, that the consequence of this is not o• force, because that a property which belongeth to divers kinds, when it is ascribed to one kind, it followeth not thereof, that it is to be removed from the other.2 For S. James distinguisheth the kinds or degrees of sins, Originall and Actuall: and saith, that death followeth after Actuall; not as if death did not follow after Originall, but because that actuall is a middle between Originall sin and death, as a cause of this, and an effect of that, and doth aggravate death or punishment, which already was purchased by Originall sin. Neither doth he chiefly speak of the degrees of punishments, but of the cause and originall of them to be sought in the corruption of our owne nature.
Object. 8. It is said,1 In many things we sin all. Hence our adversaries will prove. That the sins of the just are Venial, because they fall either into few sins, or into no mortal sins. To this, as also to most of that which hath gone before, we answer, that the sins of the just, who by faith retain or receive righteousness, are Venial, not of their own nature, but by grace.
Object. 8. It is said,1 In many things we sin all. Hence our adversaries will prove. That the sins of the just are Veniall, because they fall either into few sins, or into no mortall sins. To this, as also to most of that which hath gone before, we answer, that the sins of the just, who by faith retain or receive righteousnesse, are Veniall, not of their owne nature, but by grace.
1Object. 9. God is not cruel, but merciful, n•••her light in his love, but constant: Wherefore he doth not for every light sin judge a man worthy of eternal punishments. Answ. But they imagine, that the judgement of God concerning sin is at variance with his mercy: which two are not at variance, but do very well agree: For God is in such wise merciful, as he is also just. Now the justice of God requireth that he judge all, even the least offence and contempt of his majesty, worthy of eternal damnation. This judgement against every sin, the mercy and constancy of Gods love doth not take away; but for the showing and declaring thereof it is sufficient, that he rejoiceth not at the destruction of them that perish, and that for testimony thereof, he inviteth all to repentance, and forgiveth them who repent their sins, which by themselves were worthy of everlasting death: that is, he punisheth them, and causeth satisfaction for them not in the sinners, but in his own Son sent to take flesh, by punishment answering and satisfying his justice.
1Object. 9. God is not cruell, but mercifull, n•••her light in his love, but constant: Wherefore he doth not for every light sin judge a man worthy of eternall punishments. Answ. But they imagine, that the judgement of God concerning sinne is at variance with his mercy: which two are not at variance, but do very well agree: For God is in such wise mercifull, as he is also just. Now the justice of God requireth that hee judge all, even the least offence and contempt of his majesty, worthy of eternall damnation. This judgement against every sin, the mercy and constancy of Gods love doth not take away; but for the shewing and declaring thereof it is sufficient, that hee rejoyceth not at the destruction of them that perish, and that for testimony thereof, he inviteth all to repentance, and forgiveth them who repent their sins, which by themselves were worthy of everlasting death: that is, hee punisheth them, and causeth satisfaction for them not in the sinners, but in his owne Son sent to take flesh, by punishment answering and satisfying his justice.
Object. 10. It is said,1 Whosoever shall break one of these least commandments, and teach men so, he shall be called the least in the Kingdom of Heaven. This they interpret after this sort, That he, who both by sin and teaching doth against the Law, is fallen from the Kingdom of God; and not he, who in teaching subscribeth to the Law, although sometimes he doth a little contrary to that he teacheth. But the opposition or contrariety which Christ addeth, But whosoever shall observe and teach them, the same shall be called great in the Kingdom of God, doth show, that Christ in the former part of the speech doth understand those who break, that is, violate the Law which they teach: so that the meaning is, Although one teach well, and yet violate one of these commandments, which the Pharisees term the least, that is, of the commandments of the Decalogue; he shall find these commandments so not to be the least, but the greatest, as himself thereby shall become the least, that is, in no place in the Kingdom of God. Albeit it be granted unto them, that in the words of Christ, to teach so, is the same, that to teach contrary to the Law; yet can it not at all be gathered thence, that they alone shall be the least in the Kingdom of God, who by teaching and sinning break the Law, and not they also, who by sinning only, and not teaching,2 transgress it. The first reason is in the very words of Christ: because he calleth those commandments the least, by a figure of speech called Imitation, which are the greatest; and the breach whereof, whether it be committed in deed, or in doctrine, or in both, God judgeth worthy the shutting out of his Kingdom, even by our adversaries confession; that is, the whole Decalogue, which the Pharisees did set behind their traditions. The second reason is in the words which Christ addeth: For I say unto you, Except your righteousness exceed the righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees, ye shall not enter into the Kingdom of heaven. In these words Christ showeth, that a far other righteousness is required by the Law of God, then the Pharisees thought of; and that those sins also are so great, that they shut men out of the Kingdom of heaven, which the Pharisees accounted either for light, or no sins: as, to be angry with thy brother unadvisedly: to say unto him, Racha, or fool:
Object. 10. It is said,1 Whosoever shall break one of these least commandements, and teach men so, he shall be called the least in the Kingdome of Heaven. This they interpret after this sort, That he, who both by sin and teaching doth against the Law, is fallen from the Kingdome of God; and not he, who in teaching subscribeth to the Law, although sometimes he doth a little contrary to that he teacheth. But the opposition or contrariety which Christ addeth, But whosoever shall observe and teach them, the same shall be called great in the Kingdome of God, doth shew, that Christ in the former part of the speech doth understand those who breake, that is, violate the Law which they teach: so that the meaning is, Although one teach well, and yet violate one of these commandements, which the Pharisees terme the least, that is, of the commandements of the Decalogue; hee shall find these commandements so not to be the least, but the greatest, as himselfe thereby shall become the least, that is, in no place in the Kingdome of God. Albeit it be granted unto them, that in the words of Christ, to teach so, is the same, that to teach contrary to the Law; yet can it not at all be gathered thence, that they alone shall be the least in the Kingdome of God, who by teaching and sinning break the Law, and not they also, who by sinning only, and not teaching,
to be troubled ⟨p. 59⟩with an evil affection, or desire of revenge; for even these things also he saith are to be avoided, if we will avoid hell fire, and be the children of our heavenly Father: Therefore he saith, Whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her, 1hath committed adultery with her already in his heart. And, Whosoever hateth his brother is a man-slayer: and ye know that no man-slayer hath eternal life abiding in him. 2And therefore not they only which commit the greater sins, but they also who commit the lesser, cannot escape everlasting death, but by the satisfaction of Christ imputed to them.
to be troubled ⟨p. 59⟩with an evill affection, or desire of revenge; for even these things also he saith are to be avoided, if we will avoid hell fire, and be the children of our heavenly Father: Therefore he saith, Whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her, 1hath committed adultery with her already in his heart. And, Whosoever hateth his brother is a man-slayer: and yee know that no man-slayer hath eternall life abiding in him. 2And therefore not they only which commit the greater sins, but they also who commit the lesser, cannot escape everlasting death, but by the satisfaction of Christ imputed to them.
Such are all sins in the unregenerate, and some also in the regenerate; as errours in the foundation of faith, and slidings and fallings against their conscience, wherewith a sure confidence of remission of sins, and true and lively comfort cannot consist, unlesse they repent: for that they very regenerate may run head long into reigning sin, the dolefull falls of those most holy men, Aaron and David, doe sufficiently declare.1 Sin not reigning is that which the sinner resisteth by the grace of the holy Spirit, and is therefore exempt from eternall death, because he repenteth, and obtaineth remission by Christ. Such kind of sins are all the defects, inclinations, wicked desires, and many sins of ignorance, omission, and infirmity, which remaine in the faithfull, as long as they are in this life; which notwithstanding they acknowledge, bewaile, and hate in themselves, yea they resist them, and pray daily that they may be forgiven them through Christ their Mediatour, saying, Forgive us our debts: and therefore in these they hold fast and imbrace faith and consolation in their Saviour ⟨p. 55⟩and Redeemer. If we say wee have no sin, we deceive our selves, 2and there is no truth in us. It is no more I that doe it, but the sin that dwelleth in me. There is no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus, which walk after the Spirit. Who can tell how oft hee offendeth? Lord, cleanse thou me from my secret faults. That vulgar distinction of sinne into Mortall and Veniall sin, may be reduced unto this distinction of Reigning, 3and not reigning sin: For although all sin in his proper nature be Mortall, that is, deserveth everlasting death; yet Reigning sin may most fitly so be called, wherein whosoever persevereth, finally perisheth. Now it becometh Veniall, that is to say, it effecteth not everlasting death, when in the regenerate resisting it by the grace of Christ it waxeth not reigning: not that of it selfe it deserveth remission, or that it is not worthy of punishment; but because it is by grace through Christs satisfaction pardoned unto them that beleeve, and is not imputed to them unto condemnation: according as it is said,4 There is no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus, &c. And in this sense the distinction of Mortall and Veniall sin may be retained; but by no meanes in that sense in which it is used of the Popes Favourites: