3. How many kinds of sins there are.
pp. 50–74104 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 50–74104 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But as our adversaries accuse this sentence of too much rigour,1 That all sins are by themselves of their own nature Mortal, that is, deserve eternal death; so also the other sentence, That sins are made Venial to those that repent, which of their own nature are Mortal, they reprehend as too gentle, and repugnant to Gods justice: because to call that Venial which is Mortal, is contrary to truth and justice. But the answer is ready, That God, if we respect the nature of sin, adjudgeth all sin worthy of everlasting death; and giveth pardon to none but of free grace, for the intercession and satisfaction of his Son our Mediator.
But as our adversaries accuse this sentence of too much rigour,1 That all sinnes are by themselves of their owne nature Mortall, that is, deserve eternall death; so also the other sentence, That sins are made Veniall to those that repent, which of their owne nature are Mortall, they reprehend as too gentle, and repugnant to Gods justice: because to call that Veniall which is Mortall, is contrary to truth and justice. But the answer is ready, That God, if we respect the nature of sin, adjudgeth all sin worthy of everlasting death; and giveth pardon to none but of free grace, for the intercession and satisfaction of his Son our Mediatour.
There is sin against the conscience, and sin not against the conscience. 1Sin against the conscience is, when a man, knowing the will of God, of set purpose doth expressly against the same. Or, it is a sin committed of those who wittingly and willingly sin, as David wittingly committed adultery and murder, contrary to the Law.2 Sin not against the conscience is that, which we either not willing, or not witting commit: or, which is indeed acknowledged to be sin, and is lamented of by the offender, but cannot perfectly be avoided in this life: such as is Original sin, and many sins of omission, ignorance and infirmity. For we omit many good things, and commit evil, being suddenly overcome and overtaken by infirmities: as Peter of infirmity in imminent danger is overcome, and denieth Christ, wittingly indeed, but not willingly: therefore he weepeth bitterly, and loseth not utterly his faith, according to Christs promise, I have prayed for thee that thy faith fail not. It was not reigning sin,3 much less the sin against the holy Ghost, because he loved Christ no less when he denied him, then when he bewailed his offence, though that affection did not at that time for fear of imminent danger show it self. Such sin Paul acknowledgeth in himself, and lamenteth it, I do not the good which I would, but the evil which I would not, 4that do I, &c. His blasphemy also, and persecution and violence against the Church was a sin of ignorance: For, I did it ignorantly, saith he, therefore God had mercy on me. 5This third division of sin, and the definition of both sins, Christ hath expressly delivered, saying, The servant that knew his Masters will, and prepared not himself, 6neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes: but he that knew it not, and yet did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes.7
THere is sin against the conscience, and sin not against the conscience. 1Sin against the conscience is, when a man, knowing the will of God, of set purpose doth expresly against the same. Or, it is a sinne committed of those who wittingly and willingly sinne, as David wittingly committed adultery and murder, contrary to the Law.2 Sin not against the conscience is that, which we either not willing, or not witting commit: or, which is indeed acknowledged to be sinne, and is lamented of by the offender, but cannot perfectly be avoided in this life: such as is Originall sin, and many sins of omission, ignorance and infirmity. For we omit many good things, and commit evill, being suddenly overcome and overtaken by infirmities: as Peter of infirmity in imminent danger is overcome, and denieth Christ, wittingly indeed, but not willingly: therefore hee weepeth bitterly, and loseth not utterly his faith, according to Christs promise, I have prayed for thee that thy faith faile not. It was not reigning sin,3 much lesse the sin against the holy Ghost, because he loved Christ no lesse when he denied him, then when he bewailed his offence, though that affection did not at that time for feare of imminent danger shew it selfe. Such sin Paul acknowledgeth in himselfe, and lamenteth it, I doe not the good which I would, but the evill which I would not, 4that doe I, &c. His blasphemy also, and persecution and violence against the Church was a sin of ignorance: For, I did it ignorantly, saith he, therefore God had mercy on me. 5This third division of sin, and the definition of both sins, Christ hath expresly delivered, saying, The servant that knew his Masters will, and prepared not himselfe, 6neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes: but hee that knew it not, and yet did commit things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes.7
There is sin unpardonable: or, a sin against the holy Ghost: or, a sin unto death. 1There is also sin pardonable: or, not against the holy Ghost: or, not unto death. This distinction is deduced out of Matthew 12.31. Mark 3.29. 1 John 5.16. Sin unpardonable, or sin against the holy Ghost, and unto death, is a denial and oppugning of the known truth of God, and his will and works, of which mens consciences and minds are fully ascertained and convicted by the testimony of the holy Ghost; not of fear or infirmity, but of set purpose and hatred of the truth, and of a despiteful malicious stomach conceived against the same: which sin whosoever commit, they are punished of God with a perpetual blindness, 2that they can never return to God by true repentance in this life, and by consequent can obtain no pardon. It is called unpardonable, not that by the grievousness thereof it exceedeth the worth of Christs merit; but because he who offendeth herein, is punished with sinful blindness▪ and hath not the gift of repentance: For, because it is a peculiar kind of sin, a peculiar kind ⟨p. 60⟩of punishment is also inflicted thereon: namely, final blindness and impenitency. And without repentance,3 there is no remission: Whosoever shall speak against the holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, nor in the world to come. And, Whosoever blasphemeth against the holy Ghost, shall never have forgiveness, but is culpable of eternal damnation. 4It is called sin against the holy Ghost, not as if the holy Ghost might be offended by any man, and not the Father also, and the Son, but by an eminent significancy of speech, because it is in a special manner committed against the holy Ghost: that is, against his proper and immediate office or operation, which is the enlightening of their minds.
1The sin against the holy Ghost is not found in every reprobate person, but in those only who are lightened by the holy Ghost, and convicted in conscience of the truth: as Saul, Judas. &c. Object. Every unpardonable sin is a sin against the holy Ghost, because Christ saith, 2that the sin against the holy Ghost is unpardonable; but final perseverance in whatsoever sin without repentance, is remitted to no man: And therefore it is a sin against the holy Ghost; and by a consequent, all that perish sin against the holy Ghost. Answ. The ambiguity of unpardonable sin maketh four terms in this Syllogism: For in the Major it signifieth that kind of sin which is never remitted to any; because whosoever commit it, whether at the end, or before the end of their life, they persevere in it even to the end without repentance: But in the Minor it signifieth not a certain kind of sin, but all their sins who repent not; which indeed are not remitted to them, because they persevere in them to the end without repentance: and they are unpardonable, not before the end, but in the very end of their life; yet are they remitted to others who persevere not in them, but repent: For, perseverance in sin is nothing else then the sins themselves, which are continued unto the end; and therefore this is the meaning of the Minor: Sins, in which men persevere without repentance unto the end, are not pardoned them who persevere in them; but now all men do not persevere in them, as they persevere in the sin against the holy Ghost, even whosoever once fall into it. And Christ in this speech showeth not, for what sins men are punished with everlasting death: For it is certain, that it befalleth for all sins of which men repent not; but he showeth what sins are such, as whosoever do commit them, they do never repent. This he affirmeth of no kind of sin, but only of blasphemy against the holy Ghost.
1The sin against the holy Ghost is not found in every reprobate person, but in those only who are lightned by the holy Ghost, and convicted in conscience of the truth: as Saul, Judas. &c. Object. Every unpardonable sin is a sin against the holy Ghost, because Christ saith, 2that the sin against the holy Ghost is unpardonable; but finall perseverance in whatsoever sin without repentance, is remitted to no man: And therefore it is a sinne against the holy Ghost; and by a consequent, all that perish sinne against the holy Ghost. Answ. The ambiguity of unpardonable sin maketh foure terms in this Syllogism: For in the Major it signifieth that kind of sinne which is never remitted to any; because whosoever commit it, whether at the end, or before the end of their life, they persevere in it even to the end without repentance: But in the Minor it signifieth not a certaine kind of sinne, but all their sinnes who repent not; which indeed are not remitted to them, because they persevere in them to the end without repentance: and they are unpardonable, not before the end, but in the very end of their life; yet are they remitted to others who persevere not in them, but repent: For, perseverance in sin is nothing else then the sinnes themselves, which are continued unto the end; and therefore this is the meaning of the Minor: Sins, in which men persevere without repentance unto the end, are not pardoned them who persevere in them; but now all men doe not persevere in them, as they persevere in the sin against the holy Ghost, even whosoever once fall into it. And Christ in this speech sheweth not, for what sins men are punished with everlasting death: For it is certaine, that it befalleth for all sinnes of which men repent not; but he sheweth what sinnes are such, as whosoever doe commit them, they doe never repent. This he affirmeth of no kind of sin, but onely of blasphemy against the holy Ghost.
1Every sin against the holy Ghost is Reigning sin, and sin against conscience; but not contrariwise every Reigning sin, sin against the holy Ghost: For it may fall out, that some man either ignorantly, or else wittingly and willingly may patronize some errors, or make breach of some commandment by reason of weakness, terror of present torment, or fear of danger; and yet not oppugn of purpose and malice the truth known unto him, or make an utter Apostasy from Religion and Piety, and persevere in a sensual senseless contempt, but retire unto repentance in this life: Wherefore Reigning sin, or the sin against the holy Ghost differ as a general from a particular; the latter of them intimating a precedency of the former, but not the former a consequence of the latter.
1Every sin against the holy Ghost is Reigning sin, and sin against conscience; but not contrariwise every Reigning sin, sin against the holy Ghost: For it may fall out, that some man either ignorantly, or else wittingly and willingly may patronize some errours, or make breach of some commandement by reason of weaknesse, terrour of present torment, or feare of danger; and yet not oppugne of purpose and malice the truth knowne unto him, or make an utter Apostasie from Religion and Piety, and persevere in a sensuall senslesse contempt, but retire unto repentance in this life: Wherefore Reigning sin, or the sin against the holy Ghost differ as a generall from a particular; the latter of them intimating a precedency of the former, but not the former a consequence of the latter.
1The sin against the holy Ghost is not incident unto the Elect, and those who are truly converted; because the Elect can never perish, but are certainly saved by God: My sheep shall no man pluck out of my hands; with the like places. They then who thus offend, were never truly converted and chosen: They went out from us, because they were not of us.
1The sin against the holy Ghost is not incident unto the Elect, and those who are truly converted; because the Elect can never perish, but are certainly saved by God: My sheep shall no man plucke out of my hands; with the like places. They then who thus offend, were never truly converted and chosen: They went out from us, because they were not of us.
That many of the Reprobate are said to be lightened, and to be made partakers ⟨p. 61⟩of the holy Ghost, to have tasted the heavenly gift, the good Word of God, and of the powers of the world to come,1 and last of all to have been sanctified with the blood of the Testament. Likewise in Peter, to have escaped from the filthiness of the world: the Apostles themselves show that this is to be understood of the knowledge of the truth, and the fore-going and detestation of errors and vices for a season; and lastly, of the sufficiency of Christs merits, even for the wiping away of their sins also, and the offer thereof made to them by his Word and Sacraments: which they show, when they interpret that lightning and taste to be the knowledge of the truth and righteousness, and call them dogs and swine, not made so again, but returning to their vomit, and wallowing in the mire; and compare them to the earth, drinking in the rain, but bringing forth, in stead of good herbs, thorns and briars: For these things agree not to true faith and conversion.
That many of the Reprobate are said to be lightened, and to be made partakers ⟨p. 61⟩of the holy Ghost, to have tasted the heavenly gift, the good Word of God, and of the powers of the world to come,1 and last of all to have been sanctified with the bloud of the Testament. Likewise in Peter, to have escaped from the filthinesse of the world: the Apostles themselves shew that this is to be understood of the knowledge of the truth, and the fore-going and detesiation of errours and vices for a season; and lastly, of the sufficiency of Christs merits, even for the wiping away of their sins also, and the offer thereof made to them by his Word and Sacraments: which they shew, when they interpret that lightning and taste to be the knowledge of the truth and righteousnesse, and call them dogs and swine, not made so again, but returning to their vomit, and wallowing in the mire; and compare them to the earth, drinking in the raine, but bringing forth, in stead of good herbs, thornes and bryars: For these things agree not to true faith and conversion.
1We are not rashly to pronounce who they be that sin against the holy Ghost: and we may not judge of this sin, until the end, that is, until we know them who once had the truth, and confess themselves to be convicted and persuaded of it, with hatred thereof to persecute and reproach it, or to end their life in hatred and despite against it. The reason hereof is manifest, because we are not the beholders of mens hearts. If it be objected, that there is a sin unto death, I say not, that thou shouldest pray for it: if he will not that we shall pray for those who sin to death, it must needs be, that we may discern them from others. We answer, that John doth not universally forbid that we pray for any so sinning; but at such time, as that is manifest unto us, either by some divine testimony, or by manifest arguments, and the sinners own profession. But, before this is certain and manifest unto us, we ought to desire of God the conversion of all men; and, as much as in us lieth, to endeavour it, as it is said: I exhort, that first of all, supplications, prayers, intercessions, 2and giving of thanks be made for all men. And, The servant of the Lord must not strive, but must be gentle toward all men, apt to teach, suffering the evil men patiently, instructing them with meekness that are contrary minded; proving if God at any time will give them repentance, that they may know the truth, and that being delivered out of the snare of the Devil, of whom they are taken, they may come to amendment, and perform his will. And, Pray for them which hurt you, and persecute you. And, Lord, lay not this sin to their charge. If it be replied, That so it will come to pass that our prayer shall be contrary to the will of God if not knowing of it, we pray for them who sin against the holy Ghost: The answer is ready, That prayer is made for them with a condition,3 by which we submit our will and desires to the counsel of God, that he will convert and save the adversaries of the truth, if they may be recovered; but that he will repress them and punish them, if he have not appointed to recover them. By the same answer is this argument dissolved, Their sin is not unpardonable for whom we must pray; but we must pray for all men: Therefore no mans sin is unpardonable. 1. We deny the Minor:
because, if it appeareth by any divine testimony, or by manifest arguments and their own profession that they are cast away, whether they sin against the holy Ghost, or otherwise do not repent, we must not pray for them. 2. Neither is the Major true: For, if we know not whether they sin against the holy Ghost, or are rejected of God or no, we must pray for them, but with that condition, if they may be recovered. Our of these things also which have been spoken, answer is made to this Object. He that must fear lest he hath any unpardonable sin, 1can never be assured of remission of his sins and life everlasting; but if there be any sin unpardonable, which is committed before the end of a mans life, no man can be assured that he hath not, or shall not have such sin: Therefore there is either no such sin, or no man can be assured of the grace of God, and his own salvation: For the Minor of this reason is false, concerning those who believe: for they must certainly think, that they neither had, nor have the sin against the holy Ghost; because there is no condemnation to them who are in Christ: neither that they shall have this sin, because that no man can pluck the sheep of Christ out of his hand.
because, if it appeareth by any divine testimony, or by manifest arguments and their owne profession that they are cast away, whether they sinne against the holy Ghost, or otherwise do not repent, we must not pray for them. 2. Neither is the Major true: For, if we know not whether they sin against the holy Ghost, or are rejected of God or no, we must pray for them, but with that condition, if they may be recovered. Our of these things also which have been spoken, answer is made to this Object. He that must feare lest he hath any unpardonable sin, 1can never be assured of remission of his sins and life everlasting; but if there be any sin unpardonable, which is committed before the end of a mans life, no man can be assured that he hath not, or shall not have such sin: Therefore there is either no such sin, or no man can be assured of the grace of God, and his owne salvation: For the Minor of this reason is false, concerning those who beleeve: for they must certainly thinke, that they neither had, nor have the sinne against the holy Ghost; because there is no condemnation to them who are in Christ: neither that they shall have this sin, because that no man can pluck the sheep of Christ out of his hand.
Obj. 1. Adam and Peter obtained remission of sins: Adam and Peter sinned against the holy Ghost, because they denied the manifest and known truth of God: Therefore some men ⟨p. 62⟩sinning against the holy Ghost obtain remission of sins. Answ. The proof of the Minor is a false definition: For, not every denial or rejection of the truth is sin against the holy Ghost, but that only which hath accompanying it an inward hatred of the truth, and which of a purposed intent, and with horrible fury endeavoureth to oppress it: which hatred of truth was not in Adam or Peter: Augustine therefore saith, Faith failed not Peter in his heart, when confession failed him in his mouth.
Obj. 1. Adam and Peter obtained remission of sins: Adam and Peter sinned against the holy Ghost, because they denied the manifest and knowne truth of God: Therefore some men ⟨p. 62⟩sinning against the holy Ghost obtaine remission of sins. Answ. The proofe of the Minor is a false definition: For, not every deniall or rejection of the truth is sin against the holy Ghost, but that onely which hath accompanying it an inward hatred of the truth, and which of a purposed intent, and with horrible fury endevoureth to oppresse it: which hatred of truth was not in Adam or Peter: Augustine therefore saith, Faith failed not Peter in his heart, when confession failed him in his mouth.
1Object. 2. The sin of Cain was not unpardonable, because God would not have him killed, therefore he pardoned him his sin; but Cains sin was committed against the holy Ghost: Therefore some sin against the holy Ghost is not unpardonable. Answ. In the proof of the Major is a fallacy, putting that which is no cause, as if it were a cause. For the cause why God would not have him killed, was not, for that he had pardoned Cain his sin, not repenting him of it; but that the murderer might be the longer tormented with the furies of his conscience, that in so long time not repenting, he might be made inexcusable: and further also, that murders might not wax rife among men.
1Object. 2. The sinne of Cain was not unpardonable, because God would not have him killed, therefore he pardoned him his sinne; but Cains sinne was committed against the holy Ghost: Therefore some sinne against the holy Ghost is not unpardonable. Answ. In the proofe of the Major is a fallacy, putting that which is no cause, as if it were a cause. For the cause why God would not have him killed, was not, for that hee had pardoned Cain his sinne, not repenting him of it; but that the murderer might be the longer tormented with the furies of his conscience, that in so long time not repenting, he might be made inexcusable: and further also, that murders might not wax rife among men.
1Object. 3. They who are altogether ignorant of Christ, sin not against the holy Ghost; but all that know not Christ have unpardonable sin, because it is never pardoned them: Therefore some unpardonable sin is not against the holy Ghost. Answ. We grant the whole reason, if in the Minor and Conclusion thereof be understood by unpardonable sin, those sins of the unregenerate, which are not indeed remitted unto them, for that they persist in those sins to the end without repentance; yet to others they are remitted, who persist not in them, but repent of them in this life: For not all who commit them, persist in them. But if that kind of sin be understood, it is never remitted to any man, because all they who commit it, persist in it to the end of their life without repentance; then is the Minor false: And so is there no consequence in this reason.
1Object. 3. They who are altogether ignorant of Christ, sin not against the holy Ghost; but all that know not Christ have unpardonable sinne, because it is never pardoned them: Therefore some unpardonable sinne is not against the holy Ghost. Answ. We grant the whole reason, if in the Minor and Conclusion thereof be understood by unpardonable sinne, those sinnes of the unregenerate, which are not indeed remitted unto them, for that they persist in those sinnes to the end without repentance; yet to others they are remitted, who persist not in them, but repent of them in this life: For not all who commit them, persist in them. But if that kind of sinne be understood, it is never remitted to any man, because all they who commit it, persist in it to the end of their life without repentance; then is the Minor false: And so is there no consequence in this reason.
There is some sin which is of it self sin, and some which cometh to be sin by an accident. Sins of themselves, and in their own nature, are all those things which are forbidden in the Law of God; 1as are inclinations, motions, and actions disagreeing from the Law of God: yet they are not sins, as they are motions, nor in respect of God moving all things: (For motions, as they are mere motions, are good in themselves, and proceed from God, in whom we live, move, and have our being) but they are sins in regard of us, as they are committed by us against the Law of God: For in this sense of themselves, and in their own nature, they are sins. Sins by an accident are the actions of the unregenerate and hypocrites, which are indeed prescribed and commanded by God; 2but yet are displeasing unto him, because they are done without Faith and Repentance. Of this kind are all actions also of indifferency, which are effected with scandal: Whatsoever is not of faith, is sin. To them that are de•iled and unbelieving is nothing pure. 3Without faith it is impossible to please God: Wherefore all the virtues of the unregenerate; as the chastity of Scipio, the valour of Julius Cesar, the fidelity of Regulus, the justice of Aristides, &c. howsoever in themselves they are good actions, and enjoined by God, yet by occasion and accident they are sin, and displease God; both because the person, from whom those actions proceed, pleaseth not God, neither is reconciled unto God: and also because the actions themselves are not done after the same manner, neither to the same end which God would have them to be done; that is, they are not grounded on faith, nor wrought to the glory of God, which conditions and circumstances are so necessarily required to a good work, that without them our best actions are defects and sins: as, it is sin when a wicked man or an hypocrite prayeth, giveth alms, offereth sacrifice, &c. because he doth it not of faith, nor referreth it unto Gods glory: Hypocrites give, 4&c. He that killeth a bullock, &c.
THere is some sinne which is of it selfe sinne, and some which cometh to be sinne by an accident. Sinnes of themselves, and in their owne nature, are all those things which are forbidden in the Law of God;
There is then a main difference between the virtues of the regenerate and the unregenerate: For 1. The good works of the regenerate are wrought, 1having Faith for their harbinger, and are accepted of God. But it fareth not so with the unregenerate. 2. The regenerate do all things to the glory of God; the unregenerate and hypocrites to their own praise and glory. 3. The works of the regenerate are linked with inward obedience, and a true desire of pleasing God: the unregenerate and hypocrites only perform an outward discipline and homage, without the inward obedience; therefore their virtues are mere masks of hypocrisy, and no true virtues. 4. The imperfection of the works of the regenerate is covered by the satisfaction and intercession of Christ; and the spots of sin wherewith they are stained, are not imputed unto them, neither is it objected unto them that they defile the gifts of God with their sins: The virtues of the unregenerate being in themselves good, notwithstanding become and continue sins by accident, and are polluted with many other sins. 5. The good works of the unregenerate are adorned by God with temporal rewards only, and that, not as if they pleased God, but that by this means he might invite both them and others to honesty and outward discipline of civility, necessary for mankind. But the good works of the godly, God accepteth for Christs sake, and crowneth them with temporal and eternal rewards; as it is said, 2Godliness hath the promise of the life present, and that that is to come. 6. The unregenerate by practising good works enacted by God, obtain indeed mitigation of their punishment, lest they should with other wicked Imps suffer more exquisite tortures in this life: but the good works of the godly serve not only for this, that they may suffer lighter and easier punishments, but also that they may be quite freed from all evil. Object. We may not do that which is sin: 3The works of the unregenerate, though civilly good, are sins: therefore we may not do them. Answ. Here is a fallacy of accident. The Major is true, of sins which are in themselves sins; The Minor, of sins which are sins by accident. Now those things which are in themselves sin, ought simply to be omitted:
There is then a main difference betweene the vertues of the regenerate and the unregenerate: For 1. The good workes of the regenerate are wrought,
but those which are sins by accident ought not to be omitted, but to be reformed, and performed after the manner, and the end which God hath prescribed.
External discipline therefore is necessary even in the unregenerate: 1. In respect of the commandment of God. 2. For avoiding the grievousness of punishments which ensue upon the breach of discipline. 3. For the preservation of the peace and society of mankind. 4. For a way and entrance of conversion, which is stopped by persevering and persisting in manifest offences.
Externall discipline therefore is necessary even in the unregenerate: 1. In respect of the commandement of God. 2. For avoiding the grievousnesse of punishments which ensue upon the breach of discipline. 3. For the preservation of the peace and society of mankind. 4. For a way and entrance of conversion, which is stopped by persevering and persisting in manifest offences.
If instance be given: Hypocrisy is sin of it self, and is to be avoided, as Mat. 6. it is said, Be not as Hypocrites; but the discipline or outward behaviour of the wicked is hypocrisy: Therefore it is sin of it self, and they should omit it. We answer to the Major,1 by distinguishing the diversity of Hypocrisy. There is a double Hypocrisy: one is in works not commanded of God, done for ostentation sake, or to deceive, as those which Christ mentioneth, Matth. 6. to make a Trumpet to be blown before him when he giveth alms, to pray standing in the Synagogues, and in the corners of the streets, to look sourly, and disfigure his face in fasting, and all other superstitious and humane traditions, which appertain not to the edifying of the Church. That these things are to be omitted and left undone, there is no doubt: as it is said, In vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men. And therefore they are here expressly condemned and forbidden of Christ. There is another hypocrisy in works commanded of God, but not done after that manner which God requireth. These are not to be left undone, but to be corrected, and to be done without hypocrisy, that is, with true faith and godliness: as in the same place Christ teacheth of alms, prayer, fasting, not to be omitted of the godly, but to be otherwise performed then they were of Hypocrites.
If instance be given: Hypocrisie is sin of it selfe, and is to be avoided, as Mat. 6. it is said, Be not as Hypocrites; but the discipline or outward behaviour of the wicked is hypocrisie: Therefore it is sin of it selfe, and they should omit it. We answer to the Major,1 by distinguishing the diversity of Hypocrisie. There is a double Hypocrisie: one is in workes not commanded of God, done for ostentation sake, or to deceive, as those which Christ mentioneth, Matth. 6. to make a Trumpet to be blowne before him when he giveth almes, to pray standing in the Synagogues, and in the corners of the streets, to look sowerly, and disfigure his face in fasting, and all other superstitious and humane traditions, which appertaine not to the edifying of the Church. That these things are to be omitted and left undone, there is no doubt: as it is said, In vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandements of men. And therefore they are here expresly condemned and forbidden of Christ. There is another hypocrisie in workes commanded of God, but not done after that manner which God requireth. These are not to be left undone, but to be corrected, and to be done without hypocrisie, that is, with true faith and godlinesse: as in the same place Christ teacheth of almes, prayer, fasting, not to be omitted of the godly, but to be otherwise performed then they were of Hypocrites.
So also is there a great difference between the sins of regenerate men and unregenerate: for, as it hath been heretofore (especially in the second distinction of sin) said; In all the regenerate there remain as yet many relics of sin: as, 1. Original sin. 2. Many actual sins, as of ignorance, omission, and infirmity, which nevertheless they acknowledge and bewail, and strive and struggle with them; and therefore lose not a good conscience, nor endanger the remission of their sins. ⟨p. 64⟩3. Some also sometimes fall into errors, which fight with the foundation it self, or into sins against their conscience, for which they lose a good conscience, and many gifts of the holy Ghost, and should be condemned, if they persevered in them unto the end; but they perish not in them, because they repent in this life. In the mean time there resteth a three-fold difference,1 whereby the regenerate differ in sinning from the wicked: 1. Because the purpose of God is to keep the Elect for ever. 2. In the regenerate, when they offend, there is assured and certain repentance in the end. 3. In these, when they slip, there remaineth some spark of true faith and repentance, which is sometimes greater and mightier, and so wrestleth against sin, that they fall not into Reigning sin, or errors repugnant to the foundation: sometimes less and weaker, and is for a time overcome of temptation; but yet it prevaileth so far, that they who are once truly turned unto God, make not a final Apostasy from him: as appeareth in David, Peter, &c. In the unregenerate, when they sin, none of these is found, but the contrary altogether. By this which hath been spoken it is manifest for what cause this difference of sins, which are of themselves sins, 2and by an accident sins, is necessary: 1. Lest that a false persuasion of their own righteousness or merits should rest in mens minds: 2. Lest with sins, which are of themselves sins, should be cast away also good things which come to be sins but by an accident, and so should be increased and heaped up the sins and punishments of mankind.
So also is there a great difference between the sins of regenerate men and unregenerate: for, as it hath been heretofore (especially in the second distinction of sin) said; In all the regenerate there remain as yet many reliques of sin: as, 1. Originall sin. 2. Many actuall sins, as of ignorance, omission, and infirmity, which neverthelesse they acknowledge and bewaile, and strive and struggle with them; and therefore lose not a good conscience, nor endanger the remission of their sinnes.
GOD is the cause of no sin, as is proved: 1. By testimonies of Scripture, God saw those things which he had made, 1and they were very good. Thou art the God that hast no pleasure in wickedness, &c. 2. Because God is exactly and perfectly good and holy, so that no effect of his is evil. 3. Because he forbiddeth all sin in his Law. 4. He punisheth all sin most severely, which he could not rightly do, if he wrought or caused it. 5. He himself destroyeth not his own Image in man: therefore he causeth not sin, which is the destruction of this Image. The proper and only efficient cause of sin is the will of Devils and men,2 whereby they freely fell from God, and robbed and spoiled themselves of the Image of God. Through envy of the Devil came death into the world. But death is the punishment of sin: Ye are of your father the Devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do: he hath been a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lye, 3then speaketh he of his own: for he is a liar, and the father thereof. He that committeth sin, is of the Devil: for the Devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose appeared the Son of God, 4that he might loose the work of the Devil. By one man sin entered into the world.
GOD is the cause of no sinne, as is proved: 1. By testimonies of Scipture, God saw those things which he had made, 1and they were very good. Thou art the God that hast no pleasure in wickednesse, &c. 2. Because God is exactly and perfectly good and holy, so that no effect of his is evill. 3. Because he forbiddeth all sinne in his Law. 4. He punisheth all sin most severely, which he could not rightly do, if he wrought or caused it. 5. He himselfe destroyeth not his owne Image in man: therefore he causeth not sinne, which is the destruction of this Image. The proper and onely efficient cause of sinne is the will of Divels and men,2 whereby they freely fell from God, and robbed and spoiled themselves of the Image of God. Through envie of the Divell came death into the world. But death is the punishment of sinne: Ye are of your father the Divell, and the lusts of your father ye will do: hee hath beene a murtherer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When hee speaketh a lye,
12The Devil then was the cause of the first sin, or of the fall of our first Parents in Paradise, provoking man to sin; §23and with the Devil mans will freely declining from God, and yielding obedience to the Devil. §34That first fall of Adam is the efficient cause of Original sin both in Adam and in his posterity: By one mans disobedience many were made sinners; and the precedent and (as it were) preparative cause of all actual sins in posterity, is original sin. The sin that dwelleth in me doth evil. When lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin. The accidentary or casual motives to sin, are those objects which solicit men to sin: Sin took an occasion by the commandment, §45and wrought in me all manner of concupiscence. Actual sins precedent, are the causes of other actual sins which follow: whereas the Scripture lessoneth us, that God plagueth and scourgeth sin with sin, and the sins which follow, are the punishments of sins which went before.§5 6Wherefore also God gave them up to their hearts lust, unto uncleanness they wrought filthiness, and received in themselves such recompense of their error as was meet: §67Therefore God shall send them strong delusions, that they should believe lies, &c. But whereas the wit of man (to such a height of insolency it is grown) is accustomed to frame the like arguments for the excusing of it self, and shifting and posting it from it self unto God: we must here enter ⟨p. 65⟩some large discourse of the causes of sin, and shake off mans frivolous pretences in his own behalf.
1Some derive the original cause of sin from the destiny of the Stars, saying:2 I have sinned, because I was borne under an unlucky Planet. §23Others when they sin, and are rebuked for their sin, they make answer, Not I, but the Devil was in fault that committed this deed. §34Others, leaving excuses, directly cast the fault upon God, saying: God would have it so; for if he would not, I should not have sinned. §45Others, When God (say they) might have hindered me, and yet did not, himself is the author of my sin. With these and the like pretences it is no new thing for men to sharpen their blasphemous tongues against God: For our first Parents, when they had sinned, and were accused of their sin by God, they translate and pass over the fault committed from themselves to others, neither ingenuously confess the truth. Adam returneth the fault not so much upon his wife, as upon God himself: The woman (saith he) which thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, 6and I did eat: as if he should say, Except thou hadst joined her to me, I had not sinned. The woman simply imputeth the fault to the Devil, saying: The Serpent beguiled me, and I did eat. These are the false, impious, and detestable judgements concerning the original of sin, whereby the majesty, truth, and justice of God is grievously offended. For the nature of man is not the cause of sin: for, God created it good and perfect, according as it is said, And God saw all things which he had made, and lo they were very good. Sin is an accessary quality which took possession of man after the fall, and no substantial property; although after the fall it became natural, and is fitly so termed by Augustine, because now we are all borne in sin, 7and are by nature the children of wrath as well as others. But this point would be more amplified and enlarged.
1. They who make Destiny a cloak for sin, define Destiny to be a linked order through all eternity, and a certain perpetual necessity of intents and works, according to the counsel of God, or according to the evil Planets. Now if you ask them, Who made the Planets? God, say they: Therefore these men lay their evil to Gods charge; but such a destiny did not all the sounder Philosophers maintain,1 much less Christians. Saint Augustine against two Epistles of the Pelagians unto Boniface: They, saith he, who hold destiny, maintain that not only actions and events, but also our wills themselves depend on the position of the Planets, at the time of every ones conception or nativity, which they call constellations: But the grace of God surpasseth not only all the stars, and all the heavens, but also the Angels. Let us conclude these things with the word of the Lord by his Prophet Jeremiah, pronouncing to this sense:2 Thus saith the Lord, Learn not the way of the Heathen, and be not afraid for the signs of heaven, though the Heathen be afraid of such: for the customs of the people are vain. Wherefore that the Astrologers call the Planet of Saturn unmerciful, sharp, and cruel; and the Planet of Venus favourable and gentle, it is the vanity of vanities: for the stars have no force of doing good or ill; and therefore the fault of sinners ought not to be imputed unto them.
1. They who make Destiny a cloak for sinne, define Destiny to be a linked order through all eternity, and a certaine perpetuall necessity of intents and workes, according to the counsell of God, or according to the evill Planets. Now if you aske them, Who made the Planets? God, say they: Therefore these men lay their evill to Gods charge; but such a destiny did not all the sounder Philosophers maintaine,1 much lesse Christians. Saint Augustine against two Epistles of the Pelagians unto Boniface: They, saith he, who hold destiny, maintaine that not only actions and events, but also our wils themselves depend on the position of the Planets, at the time of every ones conception or nativity, which they call constellations: But the grace of God surpasseth not onely all the stars, and all the heavens, but also the Angels. Let us conclude these things with the word of the Lord by his Prophet Jeremy, pronouncing to this sense:
2. That the Devil is not the only author of sin, who when as we commit sin,1 should bear alone the blame of the sin, and our selves be free from fault, it is most of all declared in this, that he is able to induce and entice a man to evil, but not to compel him: For God keepeth under the Devil by his power, that he cannot do what he will; but only what, and so much as God permitteth him. Nay, he hath not so much as power over filthy Swine, much less over the most noble Souls of men. He hath indeed a subtlety & great force in persuading; but God is stronger, who also never ceaseth himself to put good motions into mans mind: neither permitteth he more to Satan, then he maketh profitable for man. Which we may see in that most holy man Job, in the example of Paul, and in his words:2 God is faithful, which will not suffer you to be tempted above that you be able: Wherefore they are vain men, who unload the blame of their wickedness on the Devils shoulders.
2. That the Divell is not the onely authour of sin, who when as wee commit sin,1 should beare alone the blame of the sin, and our selves be free from fault, it is most of all declared in this, that he is able to induce and entice a man to evill, but not to compell him: For God keepeth under the Divell by his power, that he cannot doe what he will; but only what, and so much as God permitteth him. Nay, hee hath not so much as power over filthy Swine, much lesse over the most noble Soules of men. He hath indeed a subtilty & great force in perswading; but God is stronger, who also never ceaseth himself to put good motions into mans mind: neither permitteth he more to Sathan, then he maketh profitable for man. Which wee may see in that most holy man Job, in the example of Paul, and in his words:2 God is faithfull, which will not suffer you to be tempted above that you be able: Wherefore they are vain men, who unload the blame of their wickednesse on the Divels shoulders.
3. It remaineth that we show also, that God is not the author of sin.1 God, say these miscreants, would have it so: for, if he would not, I should not have sinned. Again, ⟨p. 66⟩When he might have hindered me, and yet did not, himself is the author of my sin. These are mere cavils, and foisty Sophisms of the impious rout. God might by his absolute power hinder evil; but he will not corrupt his creature man, being just and righteous: Wherefore he dealeth with man after the order of man; he proposeth laws unto him, he proposeth rewards and punishments, he willeth him to embrace good, and fly evil. To the doing of which thing, neither denieth he his grace, without which we can do nothing; neither refuseth he our diligence and labour. Here if a man cease and give over, the sin and negligence is ascribed to man, not to God, though he could have hindered it and did not; because he ought not to hinder it, lest he should trouble his appointed and settled order, and destroy his own work: Wherefore God is not author of evil or sin.
3. It remaineth that we shew also, that God is not the authour of sin.1 God, say these miscreants, would have it so: for, if hee would not, I should not have sinned. Againe, ⟨p. 66⟩When he might have hindered me, and yet did not, himselfe is the author of my sin. These are meere cavils, and foisty Sophismes of the impious rout. God might by his absolute power hinder evill; but he will not corrupt his creature man, being just and righteous: Wherefore he dealeth with man after the order of man; he proposeth lawes unto him, he proposeth rewards and punishments, he willeth him to imbrace good, and flye evill. To the doing of which thing, neither denieth he his grace, without which we can do nothing; neither refuseth he our diligence and labour. Here if a man cease and give over, the sinne and negligence is ascribed to man, not to God, though he could have hindred it and did not; because he ought not to hinder it, lest he should trouble his appointed and settled order, and destroy his owne work: Wherefore God is not author of evill or sin.
Now in the process of this our discourse, we will gather in one the testimonies of Scripture, resolve certain doubts, and discover the very fountain and original of sin. Many are the testimonies of Scripture which teach us, that God is not the author of sin; of which it shall suffice to propose only some few: God made not death, 1neither hath he pleasure in the destruction of the living. I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way, and live: For thou art not a God that loveth wickedness, neither shall evil dwell with thee. The foolish shall not stand in thy sight. God made man righteous, 2but they have sought many inventions. Our unrighteousness commendeth the righteousness of God. 3By one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin. I know that in me there dwelleth no good thing. Of this we conclude, that God is not the author of sin, but that the original of evil springeth from man himself, by the instigation of the Devil; yet so nevertheless, that we say, that the Devil, being at the first corrupted, did corrupt man; but could have done nothing, except man of his own accord had consented to evil.4 Here are we to remember again the fall of our father Adam. God made Adam to his own image and similitude; that is, he made him most good, uncorrupt, holy, righteous, and immortal; he furnished him with most excellent gifts, that nothing might be wanting unto him to all blessedness in God: Wherefore his Understanding was wholly divine, his Will most free, and most holy, he had power of doing good and evil; a law was given him of God, which showed him what he should do, or what he should not do: For the Lord said,5 Thou shalt not eat of the tree of knowledge both of good and evil. God simply required of him Obedience and Faith, and that the whole Adam should depend of him, and that not constrained by necessity, but should do it freely.6 God made man from the beginning, and left him in in the hand of his counsel, saying: If thou wilt, thou shalt observe the commandments, and testify thy good will. Therefore when the Serpent tempted man, and counselled him to taste of the forbidden tree, man was not ignorant that the counsel of the Serpent did not agree with the commandment of God:
Wherefore it was in the hand of his counsel to ear, or not to eat: God declared unto him his will, plainly charging him that he should not eat; and adding the peril, he did withdraw him from eating, lest perhaps thou die. Satan also (as neither could he) did not use any force, but did probably move him unto it, and at length did overcome him: for when the will of the woman declined to the word of the Devil, her mind departed from the word of God, and rejecting a good law, she committeth an evil work. Afterwards she drew on her husband, willingly following her, to be partaker of her sin. That doth the Scripture inculcate in these words:1 So the woman (seeing that the tree was good for meat, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to get knowledge) took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also to her husband with her, and he did eat. Here have you the beginning of evil, the Devil, and that which moved the Will of man, that is, the false commendation of the Devil; and even as a mere lye, and the delectable show and sightliness of the tree: Wherefore Adam and Eve do of their own accord that which they do, being led with a hope of more excellent wisdom, which the Seducer had lyingly promised them.
Wherefore it was in the hand of his counsell to ear, or not to eat: God declared unto him his will, plainly charging him that he should not eat; and adding the perill, he did withdraw him from eating, lest perhaps thou die. Satan also (as neither could he) did not use any force, but did probably move him unto it, and at length did overcome him: for when the will of the woman declined to the word of the Divell, her mind departed from the word of God, and rejecting a good law, she committeth an evill work. Afterwards she drew on her husband, willingly following her, to be partaker of her sinne. That doth the Scripture inculcate in these words:1 So the woman (seeing that the tree was good for meat, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to get knowledge) took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also to her husband with her, and he did eat. Here have you the beginning of evill, the Divell, and that which moved the Will of man, that is, the false commendation of the Divell; and even as a meere lye, and the delectable shew and sightlinesse of the tree: Wherefore Adam and Eve doe of their owne accord that which they doe, being led with a hope of more excellent wisdome, which the Seducer had lyingly promised them.
We conclude therefore, that sin hath his beginning not from God, who forbideth ⟨p. 67⟩evil, but from the Devil, and the free electron of man, 1which was corrupted by the Devils falsehood: And therefore the Devil, and mans corrupted will obeying him, are the most true cause of sin. This evil floweth from our first Parents unto all their posterity, so that sin hath not else-whence his beginning then from our selves, and our corrupt judgement and wicked will, and the suggestion of Satan: For an evil root, and that first corruption, bringeth forth of it a rotten branch agreeable to the nature thereof, which Satan now also setteth forward, and laboureth it, as it were plants, by his guiles and lies: but in vain doth he labour, except we yield our selves to be fashioned and dressed by him. That is called Original sin, which proceedeth from the first Original, that is, was derived from the first Patents into all by propagation or generation: for this sin we bring with us in our nature out of our mothers womb into this life; I was borne in iniquity 2and in sin hath my mother conceived me. And of the Devil Christ speaketh thus: He hath been a murderer from the beginning, 3and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lye, he speaketh of his own: For he is a liar, and the father thereof.
We conclude therefore, that sinne hath his beginning not from God, who forbideth ⟨p. 67⟩evill, but from the Divell, and the free electron of man, 1which was corrupted by the Divels falshood: And therefore the Divell, and mans corrupted will obeying him, are the most true cause of sinne. This evill floweth from our first Parents unto all their pos•erity, so that sinne hath not else-whence his beginning then from our selves, and our corrupt judgement and wicked will, and the suggestion of Sathan: For an evill root, and that first corruption, bringeth forth of it a rotten branch agreeable to the nature thereof, which Sathan now also setteth forward, and laboureth it, as it were plants, by his guiles and lies: but in vaine doth hee labour, except we yeeld our selves to be fashioned and dressed by him. That is called Originall sinne, which proceedeth from the first Originall, that is, was derived from the first Patents into all by propagation or generation: for this sin we bring with us in our nature out of our mothers womb into this life; I was borne in iniquitie
To this may be added this reason,1 That sin cannot be a proper and natural effect of any cause, but of that which hath power to do against the Law; but this no nature hath power to do, besides the nature of Angels and of men: for God is a Law unto himself, and cannot do or intend any thing against his Law. And other creatures, whereas they are not endued with reason, and therefore the Law not made for them, they cannot commit sin; because, take away the Law, and there is no place left for sin: Wherefore it necessarily followeth, that sin is such an effect, as agreeth to those Angels alone who fell, and to men.
To this may be added this reason,1 That sin cannot be a proper and naturall effect of any cause, but of that which hath power to doe against the Law; but this no nature hath power to doe, besides the nature of Angels and of men: for God is a Law unto himselfe, and cannot doe or intend any thing against his Law. And other creatures, whereas they are not endued with reason, and therefore the Law not made for them, they cannot commit sin; because, take away the Law, and there is no place left for sin: Wherefore it necessarily followeth, that sin is such an effect, as agreeth to those Angels alone who fell, and to men.
If humane reason do here object, That God is the author and causer of punishment: 1If therefore sins be the punishments of sins, it followeth, that God is the cause of sins. We answer, that there is a fallacy of the accident in the Minor: For it cometh to pass by an accident, that is, by the fault of those who sin, that when by the just judgement of God, either themselves or others are punished by evil men, they in the mean season (God permitting, that is, not showing them that he would have those things to be done by them for to punish them. which things yet he hateth, and which he will punish both in this life and the life to come) do fulfil their desires, swerving from the Law of God, and estranging themselves more and more from God by sinning, do purchase more grievous punishments unto themselves. Or if we will distinguish the Major, it is in effect the same: For punishments come from God, as author and causer of them, as they are punishments: but inasmuch as they are sins, so they come, God neither willing them, nor approving them, nor causing, but only permitting: For to permit this kind of punishments, which sinners by sinning inflict either upon themselves or others, is nothing else then not to cause that evil men should do this, which God would have done for punishment, to the same end, that they may obey this will of God.
If humane reason doe here object, That God is the author and causer of punishment: 1If therefore sins be the punishments of sins, it followeth, that God is the cause of sins. We answer, that there is a fallacy of the accident in the Minor: For it cometh to passe by an accident, that is, by the fault of those who sin, that when by the just judgement of God, either themselves or others are punished by evill men, they in the meane season (God permitting, that is, not shewing them that hee would have those things to be done by them for to punish them. which things yet hee hateth, and which he will punish both in this life and the life to come) do fulfill their desires, swerving from the Law of God, and estranging themselves more and more from God by sinning, do purchase more grievous punishments unto themselves. Or if we will distinguish the Major, it is in effect the same: For punishments come from God, as author and causer of them, as they are punishments: but inasmuch as they are sins, so they come, God neither willing them, nor approving them, nor causing, but only permitting: For to permit this kind of punishments, which sinners by sinning inflict either upon themselves or others, is nothing else then not to cause that evill men should do this, which God would have done for punishment, to the same end, that they may obey this will of God.
So also we answer to that argument, The privation or want of righteousness and divine wisdom, God inflicteth as a punishment upon men; but that privation is sin: Therefore God is the causer of sin: For this privation is not sin, as by the just judgement of God it is inflicted; but as it is of men themselves, voluntarily brought upon them by their own misdeeds and demerits, and is admitted or received into the mind, will, and heart; even as evil actions are not sins, as they are governed by God, but as they are done by man.
So also we answer to that argument, The privation or want of righteousnesse and divine wisdome, God inflicteth as a punishment upon men; but that privation is sin: Therefore God is the causer of sin: For this privation is not sin, as by the just judgement of God it is inflicted; but as it is of men themselves, voluntarily brought upon them by their owne misdeeds and demerits, and is admitted or received into the mind, will, and heart; even as evill actions are not sins, as they are governed by God, but as they are done by man.
They say further, He that mindeth the end, mindeth also the means: God mindeth the ends of sin, that is, punishment, 1and the showing of justice and wrath in punishment: Wherefore he mindeth sin also, by which those ends are come unto. But the Minor is to be denied, that Punishment and the Manifestation of the glory of God are the ends of sin: For the end is that which moveth the efficient cause to bring forth an effect; but Punishment, or the Manifestation of the glory of God, do not move the sinners to sin: These cannot therefore be said to be the ends of sin. But those are the proper ends of sin, which the Devils and men respect in sinning: ⟨p. 68⟩that is, the destruction of men, the fulfilling of evil desires, the oppression and reproach of God, and his truth.
They say further, Hee that mindeth the end, mindeth also the meanes: God mindeth the ends of sin, that is, punishment, 1and the shewing of justice and wrath in punishment: Wherefore hee mindeth sinne also, by which those ends are come unto. But the Minor is to be denied, that Punishment and the Manifestation of the glory of God are the ends of sinne: For the end is that which moveth the efficient cause to bring forth an effect; but Punishment, or the Manifestation of the glory of God, do not move the sinners to sin: These cannot therefore be said to be the ends of sin. But those are the proper ends of sinne, which the Divels and men respect in sinning: ⟨p. 68⟩that is, the destruction of men, the fulfilling of evill desires, the oppression and reproach of God, and his truth.
1If they reply, That men indeed have not those ends, but that God respecteth them: For that which God permitteth, to show his justice by punishing it, the end which God proposeth thereof, is the punishment of the sinners, and his own glory; but he permitteth sin to punish it, and to declare himself just by punishing it: Therefore these are the ends of sin, in respect of the purpose and intent of God. We deny the Major: for God, suffering sin to be committed, respecteth as the end (not of another's work, that is, of the sin of Devils or men; but of his own work, that is, of his permission of sin) the punishment of sin, and the manifestation of his own justice: For sin is one thing, and the permission of sin another,2 whereof is spoken, For this cause have I appointed thee, to show my power in thee, 3and to declare my name throughout all the world. The Lord hath made all things for his own sake: yea even the wicked man for the day of evil. God, being willing to show his truth, 4and to make his power known, hath suffered with long patience the vessels of wrath prepared to destruction: Wherefore punishment is not the end, but the consequent or proper effect of sin; and an accidentary effect thereof is the manifestation of the glory of God:5 as Paul showeth, For, if the verity of God hath more abounded through my lie to his glory, &c.
1If they reply, That men indeed have not those ends, but that God respecteth them: For that which God permitteth, to shew his justice by punishing it, the end which God proposeth thereof, is the punishment of the sinners, and his owne glory; but he permitteth sin to punish it, and to declare himselfe just by punishing it: Therefore these are the ends of sin, in respect of the purpose and intent of God. We deny the Major: for God, suffering sinne to be committed, respecteth as the end (not of anothers work, that is, of the sinne of Divels or men; but of his own work, that is, of his permission of sin) the punishment of sin, and the manifestation of his owne justice: For sin is one thing, and the permission of sin another,
1If here again they reply, He that will the Consequent, will also the Antecedent; but God will these things which are the Consequents of sins, that is, Punishment and Execution of his justice: Therefore he will also the Antecedent, that is, Sin it self, without which these should not follow, or be Consequents. We deny the whole consequence of this reason: For nothing followeth, or can be concluded in reason, when both the former propositions are mere particular. For the Major of this reason is not universally true, but only then holdeth it, when as the Antecedent, together with the Consequent, agreeth with the nature of him which will the Consequent; and not when only the Consequent agreeth, and not the Antecedent: For when it falleth thus out, then is the Consequent by his will, but the Antecedent is not by his will, but only by permission: For God is said to will those things which he liketh, as agreeing with his nature and rightness; but to permit those things which yet he disliketh, abhorreth, and condemneth, but nevertheless for just causes hindereth them not from being done. And therefore it is said in the Scripture, that he will, and causeth life everlasting, which is the Consequent; and the conversion of men, which is the Antecedent, and goeth before: and that he will not, but only permitteth punishment, as it is sin, which followeth, and is the Consequent of sins: as is delivered in holy Scripture.
1If here againe they reply, He that will the Consequent, will also the Antecedent; but God will these things which are the Consequents of sins, that is, Punishment and Execution of his justice: Therefore he will also the Antecedent, that is, Sin it selfe, without which these should not follow, or be Consequents. We deny the whole consequence of this reason: For nothing followeth, or can be concluded in reason, when both the former propositions are meere particular. For the Major of this reason is not universally true, but only then holdeth it, when as the Antecedent, together with the Consequent, agreeth with the nature of him which will the Consequent; and not when only the Consequent agreeth, and not the Antecedent: For when it falleth thus out, then is the Consequent by his will, but the Antecedent is not by his will, but only by permission: For God is said to will those things which he liketh, as agreeing with his nature and rightnesse; but to permit those things which yet he disliketh, abhorreth, and condemneth, but neverthelesse for just causes hindereth them not from being done. And therefore it is said in the Scripture, that he will, and causeth life everlasting, which is the Consequent; and the conversion of men, which is the Antecedent, and goeth before: and that he will not, but only permitteth punishment, as it is sin, which followeth, and is the Consequent of sins: as is delivered in holy Scripture.
If again they urge,1 He that forbiddeth not sin, when he may forbid it to be committed, in him is some cause and fault of sin; but God permitteth it, when he might forbid it: Therefore there is some cause and fault of sin in him. We deny the Consequent, because the Major is not universally true: For it is only true of him who doth not perfectly hate sin,2 and therefore forbiddeth it not, when he may; and who is bound to hinder sin, that it be not committed: But it is not true of God, who with unspeakable anger accurseth and condemneth sin, neither yet hindereth is from being committed; because he is neither bound to do so, neither doth he permit it, without most good and just causes.
If againe they urge,1 He that forbiddeth not sin, when he may forbid it to be committed, in him is some cause and fault of sinne; but God permitteth it, when he might forbid it: Therefore there is some cause and fault of sin in him. We deny the Consequent, because the Major is not universally true: For it is onely true of him who doth not perfectly hate sinne,2 and therefore forbiddeth it not, when hee may; and who is bound to hinder sin, that it be not committed: But it is not true of God, who with unspeakable anger accurseth and condemneth sin, neither yet hindereth is from being committed; because he is neither bound to do so, neither doth he permit it, without most good and just causes.
THere is sinne unpardonable: or, a sinne against the holy Ghost: or, a sin unto death. 1There is also sinne pardonable: or, not against the holy Ghost: or, not unto death. This distinction is deduced out of Matthew 12.31. Mark 3.29. 1 John 5.16. Sinne unpardonable, or sinne against the holy Ghost, and unto death, is a deniall and oppugning of the knowne truth of God, and his will and workes, of which mens consciences and minds are fully ascertained and convicted by the testimony of the holy Ghost; not of feare or infirmity, but of set purpose and hatred of the truth, and of a despitefull malicious stomacke conceived against the same: which sinne whosoever commit, they are punished of God with a perpetuall blindnesse, 2that they can never returne to God by true repentance in this life, and by consequent can obtain no pardon. It is called unpardonable, not that by the grievousness thereof it exceedeth the worth of Christs merit; but because he who offendeth herein, is punished with sinfull blindnesse▪ and hath not the gift of repentance: For, because it is a peculiar kind of sin, a peculiar kind ⟨p. 60⟩of punishment is also inflicted thereon: namely, finall blindnesse and impenitencie. And without repentance,3 there is no remission: Whosoever shall speak against the holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, nor in the world to come. And, Whosoever blasphemeth against the holy Ghost, shall never have forgivenesse, but is culpable of eternall damnation. 4It is called sinne against the holy Ghost, not as if the holy Ghost might be offended by any man, and not the Father also, and the Son, but by an eminent significancy of speech, because it is in a speciall manner committed against the holy Ghost: that is, against his proper and immediate office or operation, which is the enlightning of their minds.5 It is called sin unto death by John, not that this alone is mortall, or deserveth death; but by an emphaticall significancy of speech, because it especially deserveth death, and all they who commit this sin assuredly die therein, because none of them repenteth of it: Therefore John will that we pray not for it; because (forsooth) in vaine the remission thereof is craved at Gods hands. The Scripture elsewhere speaketh of this sin, as Hebr. 6.4, 5, 6, 7, 8. chapt. 10.26, 27, 28, 29. and Tit. 3.10, 11.
1Some derive the originall cause of sin from the destiny of the Stars, saying:2 I have sinned, because I was borne under an unluckie Planet. §23Others when they sin, and are rebuked for their sinne, they make answer, Not I, but the Divell was in fault that committed this deed. §34Others, leaving excuses, directly cast the fault upon God, saying: God would have it so; for if he would not, I should not have sinned. §45Others, When God (say they) might have hindered me, and yet did not, himselfe is the authour of my sin. With these and the like pretences it is no new thing for men to sharpen their blasphemous tongues against God: For our first Parents, when they had sinned, and were accused of their sin by God, they translate and passe over the fault committed from themselves to others, neither ingenuously confesse the truth. Adam returneth the fault not so much upon his wife, as upon God himselfe: The woman (saith he) which thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, 6and I did eate: as if he should say, Except thou hadst joyned her to me, I had not sinned. The woman simply imputeth the fault to the Divell, saying: The Serpent beguiled me, and I did eate. These are the false, impious, and detestable judgements concerning the originall of sinne, whereby the majesty, truth, and justice of God is grievously offended. For the nature of man is not the cause of sinne: for, God created it good and perfect, according as it is said, And God saw all things which he had made, and lo they were very good. Sin is an accessary quality which took possession of man after the fall, and no substantiall property; although after the fall it became naturall, and is fitly so termed by Augustine, because now we are all borne in sinne, 7and are by nature the children of wrath as well as others. But this point would be more amplified and enlarged.
Now in the processe of this our discourse, wee will gather in one the testimonies of Scripture, resolve certain doubts, and discover the very fountain and originall of sin. Many are the testimonies of Scripture which teach us, that God is not the author of sin; of which it shall suffice to propose only some few: God made not death, 1neither hath he pleasure in the destruction of the living. I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turne from his way, and live: For thou art not a God that loveth wickednesse, neither shall evill dwell with thee. The foolish shall not stand in thy sight. God made man righteous, 2but they have sought many inventions. Our unrighteousnesse commendeth the righteousnesse of God. 3By one man sin entred into the world, and death by sin. I know that in me there dwelleth no good thing. Of this we conclude, that God is not the author of sinne, but that the originall of evill springeth from man himselfe, by the instigation of the Divell; yet so neverthelesse, that wee say, that the Divell, being at the first corrupted, did corrupt man; but could have done nothing, except man of his owne accord had consented to evill.4 Here are we to remember againe the fall of our father Adam. God made Adam to his owne image and similitude; that is, he made him most good, uncorrupt, holy, righteous, and immortall; he furnished him with most excellent gifts, that nothing might be wanting unto him to all blessednesse in God: Wherefore his Understanding was wholly divine, his Will most free, and most holy, he had power of doing good and evill; a law was given him of God, which shewed him what hee should doe, or what hee should not doe: For the Lord said,5 Thou shalt not eat of the tree of knowledge both of good and evill. God simply required of him Obedience and Faith, and that the whole Adam should depend of him, and that not constrained by necessity, but should doe it freely.6 God made man from the beginning, and left him in in the hand of his counsell, saying: If thou wilt, thou shalt observe the commandements, and testifie thy good will. Therefore when the Serpent tempted man, and counselled him to taste of the forbidden tree, man was not ignorant that the counsell of the Serpent did not agree with the commandement of God:7 Yee shall not eat of the tree, neither shall yee touch it, lest ye die.