1Object. 2. He that hath not ability to choose as well good as bad, hath not free-will and arbitrement; but man hath not ability to choose as well good as evil: Therefore he hath not free-will. Ans. The Major consisteth of a bad definition of free-will: For the liberty of reasonable creatures consisteth in the judgement and deliberation of the mind or understanding, and in the free assent of the Will; not in a power to will as well good as evil, or contrary. The good Angels, by reason of the wisdom and rightness of their judgement, and of the great and constant propension or readiness of their will to that which they know to be good and right, cannot will evil and unjust things, but only things good and honest; and yet notwithstanding they most freely choose and do those things which are just: Right so, men by reason of their in bred ignorance, and corrupt judgement of those things which are to be done, and of the end, as also by reason of the stubbornness & frowardness of their will, can will only those things which are evil, which also they follow and pursue with exceeding willingness and pleasure, until they are regenerated by Gods Spirit. Object. 3. That is free, which is ruled of none other but of it self only, or which is bound to none; Mans will is not ruled of it self only, but of another, and is bound to the Law: Therefore it is not free. Answ. The Major is true, if it be meant of that liberty which is in God; but false, being meant of mans liberty: For, man to be ruled of none, is not liberty, but a shameful barbarity, and a wretched slavery. But the true liberty of the creature is to be subject unto honest and just laws, and to obey them: It is a power of living as thou wilt, according unto the Law of God. Object. 4. That which is a servant, and in bondage, is not free; but our will is a servant, and in bondage: 2Therefore our will is not free. Answ. There is an ambiguity in this reason; for it affirmeth that to be simply so, which is but in some respect and sort so: or the conclusion fetcheth in more then was in the premisses. That which is in bondage, is not free, that is, not in that respect or consideration as it is in bondage: Our arbitrement or will is in bondage, to wit, under sin:
1Object. 2. He that hath not ability to chuse as well good as bad, hath not free-will and arbitrement; but man hath not ability to chuse as well good as evill: Therefore hee hath not free-will. Ans. The Major consisteth of a bad definition of free-will: For the liberty of reasonable creatures consisteth in the judgement and deliberation of the mind or understanding, and in the free assent of the Will; not in a power to will as well good as evill, or contrary. The good Angels, by reason of the wisdome and rightnesse of their judgement, and of the great and constant propension or readiness of their will to that which they know to be good and right, cannot will evill and unjust things, but only things good and honest; and yet notwithstanding they most freely chuse and doe those things which are just: Right so, men by reason of their in bred ignorance, and corrupt judgement of those things which are to be done, and of the end, as also by reason of the stubbornnesse & frowardnesse of their will, can will only those things which are evill, which also they follow and pursue with exceeding willingnesse and pleasure, untill they are regenerated by Gods Spirit. Object. 3. That is free, which is ruled of none other but of it selfe only, or which is bound to none; Mans will is not ruled of it self only, but of another, and is bound to the Law: Therefore it is not free. Answ. The Major is true, if it be meant of that liberty which is in God; but false, being meant of mans liberty: For, man to be ruled of none, is not liberty, but a shamefull barbarity, and a wretched slavery. But the true liberty of the creature is to be subject unto honest and just lawes, and to obey them: It is a power of living as thou wilt, according unto the Law of God. Object. 4. That which is a servant, and in bondage, is not free; but our will is a servant, and in bondage: 2Therefore our will is not free. Answ. There is an ambiguity in this reason; for it affirmeth that to be simply so, which is but in some respect and sort so: or the conclusion fetcheth in more then was in the premisses. That which is in bondage, is not free, that is, not in that respect or consideration as it is in bondage: Our arbitrement or will is in bondage, to wit, under sin:
- 1Ability to choose as well good as bad, is not necessarily joined with free-will.Ability to chuse as well good as bad, is not necessarily joyned with free-will.
- 2The will of man is servant to sin, and yet inclineth to sin freely.