Vigilius lib. 4. against Eutyches. 1If there be one nature of the Word and flesh, how is it, that, whereas the Word is every-where, the flesh is not also found every-where? For, when it was upon the earth, it was not in heaven; and now, because it is in heaven, it is not upon the earth: and it is so far from being here on earth, that, according to it, we expect Christ to come from heaven, whom, according to the Word, we believe to be with us on earth. Therefore, according to your opinion, either the Word is contained with the flesh in its place, or else the flesh with the Word is every-where; seeing one nature cannot receive in it self what is contrary and diverse. Now, to be circumscribed to a place, and to be every-where, are things very different and unlike: and because the Word is every-where, but the flesh is not every-where, it is apparent, that one and the same Christ hath both natures, and that he is every-where according to the nature of his divinity; and contained in a place, according ⟨p. 768⟩to the nature of his humanity; that he is created, and hath no beginning, subject to death, and cannot die; the one whereof belongs to him out of the nature of the Word, by which he is God, the other, out of the nature of the flesh, by which the same God is man: therefore one Son of God, and the same being made the Son of man, hath a beginning out of the nature of his flesh, and hath no beginning out of the nature of his divinity. He is created by the nature of his flesh, and is not created by the nature of his divinity; he is circumscribed to place by the nature of his flesh, and is not contained in any place by the nature of his divinity; he is lesser then the Angels by the nature of his flesh, and is equal to the Father by the nature of his divinity; he died by the nature of his flesh, and died not by the nature of his divinity. This is the Faith, and the Catholic Confession, which the Apostles delivered, the Martyrs confirmed, and the faithful hitherto maintain. How then darest thou, who art most impious, and infected with the poison of Eutychian Heresy, reprove Leo; whilst, out of the diversity of the actions of one Lord Christ, he teacheth the truth of both natures; that what he produceth to demonstrate both natures, thou calumniates, as if he professed two persons?
Vigilius lib. 4. against Eutyches. 1If there be one nature of the Word and flesh, how is it, that, whereas the Word is every-where, the flesh is not also found every-where? For, when it was upon the earth, it was not in heaven; and now, because it is in heaven, it is not upon the earth: and it is so far from being here on earth, that, according to it, we expect Christ to come from heaven, whom, according to the Word, we beleeve to be with us on earth. Therefore, according to your opinion, either the Word is contained with the flesh in its place, or else the flesh with the Word is every-where; seeing one nature cannot receive in it selfe what is contrary and diverse. Now, to be circumscribed to a place, and to be every-where, are things very different and unlike: and because the Word is every-where, but the flesh is not every-where, it is apparent, that one and the same Christ hath both natures, and that he is every-where according to the nature of his divinity; and contained in a place, according ⟨p. 768⟩to the nature of his humanity; that he is created, and hath no beginning, subject to death, and cannot die; the one whereof belongs to him out of the nature of the Word, by which he is God, the other, out of the nature of the flesh, by which the same God is man: therefore one Son of God, and the same being made the Son of man, hath a beginning out of the nature of his flesh, and hath no beginning out of the nature of his divinity. He is created by the nature of his flesh, and is not created by the nature of his divinity; he is circumscribed to place by the nature of his flesh, and is not contained in any place by the nature of his divinity; he is lesser then the Angels by the nature of his flesh, and is equall to the Father by the nature of his divinity; he died by the nature of his flesh, and died not by the nature of his divinity. This is the Faith, and the Catholick Confession, which the Apostles delivered, the Martyrs confirmed, and the faithfull hitherto maintaine. How then darest thou, who art most impious, and infected with the poyson of Eutychian Heresie, reprove Leo; whilst, out of the diversity of the actions of one Lord Christ, he teacheth the truth of both natures; that what he produceth to demonstrate both natures, thou calumniates, as if he professed two persons?
- 1Therefore, on the contrary, if the fl•sh be found every-where, why is there not one nature of the fl•sh & Word which is every-where.