The Catholic Faith, concerning the Incarnation of the Son of GOD, our Lord JESUS CHRIST; According to the Creed of ATHANASIUS, briefly declared and asserted.The Catholick Faith, concerning the Incarnation of the Son of GOD, our Lord JESUS CHRIST; According to the Creed of ATHANASIUS, briefly declared and asserted.
pp. 759–76973 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
A Question proposed to DAVID PARRY, By Mr. MOSES VASHARHELINUS, Rector of the famous Schoole of PATACHIN in Hungary, An. 1601. a. d. 14. August. Gregor.
The Catholic Faith, concerning the Incarnation of the Son of GOD, our Lord JESUS CHRIST; According to the Creed of ATHANASIUS, briefly declared and asserted.
The Catholick Faith, concerning the Incarnation of the Son of GOD, our Lord JESUS CHRIST; According to the Creed of ATHANASIUS, briefly declared and asserted.
1. But it is necessary.] This necessity is every where delivered in Scripture: John 3.36. He that believeth in the Son, hath everlasting life; and he that believeth not the Son, shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him. Joh. 6.14. This is the will of him that sent me, that all that see the Son, and believe in him, may have life eternal. John 17.3. This is life eternal, to know thee the only true God, and whom thou hast sent Jesus Christ. 1 John 4.3. And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is not of God. Acts 4.12. Neither is there salvation in any other: for there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved. Acts 10.43. To him give all the Prophets witness, that whosoever believeth in his Name, shall receive remission of sins by his Name. By faith then in the Son of God made man, it behooveth all to be saved, and without this faith no man can be saved.
1. BƲt it is necessary.] This necessity is every where delivered in Scripture: John 3.36. He that beleeveth in the Son, hath everlasting life; and he that beleeveth not the Son, shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him. Joh. 6.14. This is the will of him that sent me, that all that see the Son, and beleeve in him, may have life eternall. John 17.3. This is life eternall, to know thee the onely true God, and whom thou hast sent Jesus Christ. 1 John 4.3. And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is not of God. Acts 4.12. Neither is there salvation in any other: for there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved. Acts 10.43. To him give all the Prophets witnesse, that whosoever beleeveth in his Name, shall receive remission of sins by his Name. By faith then in the Son of God made man, it behooveth all to be saved, and without this faith no man can be saved.
2. Incarnation also.] In Greek [Greek or Hebrew], his inhumanation, [Greek or Hebrew], his incorporation; of the causes, truth, and manner of which, Athanasius lest a famous Book entitled, The inhumanation of the Word of God; other Greeks commonly call this, The Incarnation: which word is made out of the sayings of Scripture, in which the Incarnation of the Son of God is chiefly grounded, John 1.14. The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us. 1 Tim. 3.16. God was manifested in the flesh. Heb. 2.14. Because children are partakers of flesh and blood, the Son of God himself was made partaker of the same; and ver. 16. He took not on him the nature of Angels, but he took on him the flesh, is of God. To this purpose are the Angels words to the Virgin Mary, Luke 1.35. The holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the virtue of the most High shall over-shadow thee; therefore that holy thing that shall be borne of thee, shall be called the Son of God. And that of the Apostle, Gal. 4.4. God sent his Son, made of a woman: out of which is understood, that this Incarnation is the miraculous assumption of humane flesh or nature, by the operation of the holy Ghost in the Virgins womb, being performed by the Son of God, into the unity of his personality.
2. Incarnation also.] In Greek 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, his inhumanation, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, his incorporation; of the causes, truth, and manner of which, Athanasius lest a famous Booke entituled, The inhumanation of the Word of God; other Greeks commonly call this, The Incarnation: which word is made out of the sayings of Scripture, in which the Incarnation of the Son of God is chiefly grounded, John 1.14. The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us. 1 Tim. 3.16. God was manifested in the flesh.
3. Believe faithfully.] In the Greek it is firmly;1 in the last Article it is faithfully and firmly; of which, the first respects the sincerity of this faith, purified from error, denial and heresy whatsoever, concerning this mystery: the latter requires ⟨p. 760⟩an assurance and confidence of salvation in the Son of God incarnate, 2being opposite to doubt and conjectural opinion.
3. Beleeve faithfully.] In the Greek it is firmely;1 in the last Article it is faithfully and firmely; of which, the first respects the sincerity of this faith, purified from errour, deniall and heresie whatsoever, concerning this mystery: the latter requires ⟨p. 760⟩an assurance and confidence of salvation in the Son of God incarnate, 2being opposite to doubt and conjecturall opinion.
4. Right faith.] The right faith concerning the Incarnation of the Son of God, is briefly set out in two heads: The first is of the very mystery of the Incarnation, or of the person of the Son of God incarnate. The later is concerning his office, or the mystery of our redemption, which was performed, and to be performed by him in the flesh. It is equally necessary to salvation to believe both; and the first for the later. The faith of which, except it be held entire and untainted, as the Gospel declares it, to believe Christ to be God and man (which the devils also believe, and tremble) will help nothing to salvation.
4. RIght faith.] The right faith concerning the Incarnation of the Son of God, is briefly set out in two heads: The first is of the very mysterie of the Incarnation, or of the person of the Son of God incarnate. The later is concerning his office, or the mysterie of our redemption, which was performed, and to be performed by him in the flesh. It is equally necessary to salvation to beleeve both; and the first for the later. The faith of which, except it be held entire and untainted, as the Gospel declares it, to beleeve Christ to be God and man (which the divels also beleeve, and tremble) will help nothing to salvation.
5. That we may believe.] We must believe and confess, because with the heart we believe unto righteousness, and with the mouth we confess to salvation.
5. That we may beleeve.] We must beleeve and confesse, because with the heart we beleeve unto righteousnesse, and with the mouth we confesse to salvation.
6. Our Lord.] So the Angel calls him the same day he was borne, Luke 2.11. There is borne to us this day a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord: And the New Testament in very many places, chiefly 1 Cor. 8.6. We have one Lord, Jesus Christ. And he will be so called of us; John 13.13. You call me Lord, and you say well: for so I am. Hence, in the Creed, we believe in Jesus Christ our Lord. The Septuagint everywhere express the word [Greek or Hebrew], Lord, by Gods proper name [Greek or Hebrew], which is worth the observing; because it affords an ample argument of the true Deity of our Lord Jesus Christ: For, if [Greek or Hebrew], be the same that Jehovah, surely [Greek or Hebrew], our Lord, is God Jehovah. The Son of God then is our Lord by a two-fold dominion; one of his Deity, common to him, with the Father and holy Ghost, which is his absolute power over all things: the other is of mediation, proper to himself; by which, as he is the Mediator between God and men, he alone is at the right hand of God, appointed head of the Church over all things, Ephes. 1.22.
6. Our Lord.] So the Angell calls him the same day he was borne, Luke 2.11. There is borne to us this day a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord: And the New Testament in very many places, chiefly 1 Cor. 8.6. We haue one Lord, Jesus Christ. And he will be so called of us; John 13.13. You call mee Lord, and you say well: for so I am. Hence, in the Creed, we beleeve in Jesus Christ our Lord. The Septuagint everywhere expresse the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Lord, by Gods proper name 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which is worth the observing; because it affords an ample argument of the true Deitie of our Lord Jesus Christ: For, if 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, be the same that Jehovah, surely , our Lord, is God Jehovah. The Son of God then is our Lord by a two-fold dominion; one of his Deitie, common to him, with the Father and holy Ghost, which is his absolute power over all things: the other is of mediation, proper to himselfe; by which, as he is the Mediatour between God and men, he alone is at the right hand of God, appointed head of the Church over all things,
7. He is the Son of God.] Not a son by the grace of creation, as the Angels are Gods Sons, Job 1.6. nor a son by the grace of adoption, as those that are predestinate, are adopted to be sons by Jesus Christ, Ephes. 1.5. but the proper Son of God, Rom. 8.32. The only begotten of the Father, John 1.14. Begotten before all created things, from eternity, Prov. 8.23, 25. Whose going forth from the beginning, from the days of eternity, Mich. 5.4. By whom all things were made, and without whom nothing was made that was made, John 1.3.
7. He is the Son of God.] Not a son by the grace of creation, as the Angels are Gods Sons, Job 1.6. nor a son by the grace of adoption, as those that are predestinate, are adopted to be sons by Jesus Christ, Ephes. 1.5. but the proper Son of God, Rom. 8.32. The onely begotten of the Father, John 1.14. Begotten before all created things, from eternitie, Prov. 8.23, 25. Whose going forth from the beginning, from the dayes of eternitie, Mich. 5.4. By whom all things were made, and without whom nothing was made that was made, John 1.3.
8. God and man.] Not God alone; for so he were not truly Christ, that is, anointed: for, God alone is the anointer, not the anointed: Nor man alone; for so he were not truly Jesus, that is, a Saviour: for, man alone is not the Saviour, but the saved; but God and man, one and the same Son, consisting of two natures, the divine and the humane, in the unity of the hypostasis.
8. God and man.] Not God alone; for so he were not truly Christ, that is, anointed: for, God alone is the anointer, not the anointed: Nor man alone; for so he were not truly Jesus, that is, a Saviour: for, man alone is not the Saviour, but the saved; but God and man, one and the same Son, consisting of two natures, the divine and the humane, in the unitie of the hypostasis.
Furthermore, why the Son of God, the second person of the blessed Trinity, rather then any of the other persons, to wit, the Father, or the holy Ghost, united humane flesh to himself, although that humane reason should stand amazed, Christian faith should humbly adore, and not search this mystery; some reasons, notwithstanding, are unfolded by Divines, not improbable; to wit, that it was fit, that he, who was the Son of God, begotten of the Father before the world, should likewise be the Son of man, borne in time, of the substance of his mother: First, lest by the Incarnation, the denomination of the divine persons should be changed, or a confusion introduced; which had happened, if either the Father, or the holy Ghost, or all together, by the dispensation of the flesh, had challenged to themselves ⟨p. 761⟩the name of Son. Secondly, the benefit of the Incarnation was by God ordained, and bestowed upon men, for this end, that we might become the sons of God: for it was meet, that we should be made Gods adopted sons by him, who is Gods natural Son. Thirdly, it was most convenient, that he, who had obtained a middle place among the creatures, should be repaired by the middle person of the Trinity, that there might be a decent correspondency between the middle and middle. Now, man hath a middle place among the creatures, having obtained to be under the spiritual, and above the corporeal creatures; it was then fit, that man should be repaired by the middle person of the Trinity. Lastly, there is nothing more decent, than that decayed nature should be restored by him, by whom it was created; because all things were made by him, John 1.3. therefore man was to be repaired and restored to his former dignity by the Son of God.
Furthermore, why the Son of God, the second person of the blessed Trinitie, rather then any of the other persons, to wit, the Father, or the holy Ghost, united humane flesh to himselfe, although that humane reason should stand amazed, Christian faith should humbly adore, and not search this mysterie; some reasons, notwithstanding, are unfolded by Divines, not improbable; to wit, that it was fit, that he, who was the Son of God, begotten of the Father before the world, should likewise be the Son of man, borne in time, of the substance of his mother: First, lest by the Incarnation, the denomination of the divine persons should be changed, or a confusion introduced; which had hapned, if either the Father, or the holy Ghost, or all together, by the dispensation of the flesh, had challenged to themselves
9. He is God, 10. of the substance of his Father, 11. begotten before the world: and man 12. of the substance of his mother. 13. Borne in the world. 14. Perfect God. 15. Perfect man, of a reasonable soul and humane flesh subsisting. 16. Equal to the Father, according to his Divinity: 17. inferior to the Father, according to his humanity.
9. He is God, 10. of the substance of his Father, 11. begotten before the world: and man 12. of the substance of his mother. 13. Borne in the world. 14. Perfect God. 15. Perfect man, of a reasonable soule and humane flesh subsisting. 16. Equall to the Father, according to his Divinitie: 17. inferiour to the Father, according to his humanitie.
9. He is God.] It is as evident, that the proper and only begotten Son of God, is God; as the proper and only begotten son of man, is man: which the Scripture in innumerable places confirmeth.
9. HEe is God.] It is as evident, that the proper and onely begotten Son of God, is God; as the proper and onely begotten son of man, is man: which the Scripture in innumerable places confirmeth.
10. Of the substance of his Father.] This also the Scripture confirmeth, as often as it witnesseth the Son of God to be begotten, and the only begotten of the Father. For, when an intelligent nature is said to beget, it is properly to bring forth an issue out of its own substance, that is, the begetter to that which is begot, the father to the son communicates his own substance.
10. Of the substance of his Father.] This also the Scripture confirmeth, as often as it witnesseth the Son of God to be begotten, and the onely begotten of the Father. For, when an intelligent nature is said to beget, it is properly to bring forth an issue out of its owne substance, that is, the begetter to that which is begot, the father to the son communicates his owne substance.
11. Begotten before the world.] Wisdom, which is the Son of God,1 three or four times plainly restifieth, that she was begot before time, and before the world was made. And this, among sensible or rational men, (not to speak of godly men) ought not to be doubted. For, how could God be a Father before the world, if he begot not his Son before the world? The Church confesseth, that the manner of this generation is ineffable. Rufinus in his Exposition of the Creed (which is commonly attributed to Cyprian) saith thus,2 I will not have thee discuss how God the Father begot his Son, neither search too curiously into the depth of this mystery, lest perhaps, whilst thou art making too strict a scrutiny, to find out the splendour of this inaccessible light, thou forfeit that small and weak sight, which, by divine bounty is bestowed upon men. Know, that the mystery of this divine generation is as far different and eminent above all things that are in us, as the Creator is more potent then the creature, and the Artificer more excellent then his work, &c. When thou hearest of this Son, I would not have thee think of a carnal nativity; but remember, that these things are spoken of the simple nature of an incorporeal substance. For, if in that word, which the heart; or in that meaning, which the mind; or in that brightnesses which the light begets of it self; if, I say, there is no weakness in that generation: how much purer must our thoughts be of him, who is the Creator of all these? By this manner then of subsisting proper to himself, is the Son of God distinguished in the holy Trinity, from the Father and holy Ghost, because he alone is begotten of the Father before the world: and therefore he only assumed mans flesh, and was borne of the Virgin in time.
11. Begotten before the world.] Wisdome, which is the Son of God,1 three or foure times plainly restifieth, that she was begot before time, and before the world was made. And this, among sensible or rationall men, (not to speak of godly men) ought not to be doubted. For, how could God be a Father before the world, if he begot not his Son before the world? The Church confesseth, that the manner of this generation is ineffable. Rufinus in his Exposition of the Creed (which is commonly attributed to Cyprian) saith thus,
12. Of the substance of his mother.] As the Angel said to the Virgin Mary, Luke 1.35. That holy thing which shall be borne of thee, that is, of thy substance and womb, shall be called the Son of God. For, the Son of God should have been the son of David, ⟨p. 762⟩according to the promise, 1 Chron. 22.10. Hebr. 1.5. Math. 1.1. Of the seed of David, according to the flesh, Rom. 1.3. Hence he is called the fruit of Mary's womb, Luke 1.42. But the fruit is begot of the substance of the tree; which is flat against the madness of Valentinus, affirming, that Christ was sent by the Father, and brought with him an heavenly body, and that he assumed nothing of the Virgin Mary; but that he past through her, as through a channel or pipe, without taking any flesh of her, August. de haeres. 10.
12. Of the substance of his mother.] As the Angel said to the Virgin Mary, Luke 1.35. That holy thing which shall be borne of thee, that is, of thy substance and wombe, shall be called the Son of God. For, the Son of God should have been the son of David, ⟨p. 762⟩according to the promise, 1 Chron. 22.10. Hebr. 1.5. Math. 1.1. Of the seed of David, according to the flesh, Rom. 1.3. Hence hee is called the fruit of Maries womb,
13. In the world.] That is, in time, or in the fullness of time, to wit, prefixed by God, Gala•. 4.4. which was in the 42. year of Augustus his reign, and in the year of the world 3928. according to Beroaldus his best account.
13. In the world.] That is, in time, or in the fulnesse of time, to wit, prefixed by God, Gala•. 4.4. which was in the 42. yeare of Augustus his reigne, and in the year of the world 3928. according to Beroaldus his best account.
14. Perfect God.] In Greek, perfect God is the same that 1 John 5.20. the true God: for, there is but that one and eternal God by nature, [Greek or Hebrew] who calls himself,1 the God of sufficiency or perfection. He is not then God equivocally, in respect of the excellency of his gifts and office, as Angels, Psal. 97.7. Or, as Princes, Psal. 82.6. as Samosatenus and Photinus of old blasphemed; and of late, the Servetians and Socinians, affirming Christ to have taken his beginning from Mary, and not to have had any being before her. Neither a factitious or created God before all things of non-entities, as Arius madly said. For no creature can attain to the perfection of the Creator, whereas every creature proceeds from non-entitie to entity; but not to be, is absolutely repugnant to God, and to his perfection.
14. Perfect God.] In Greek, perfect God is the same that 1 John 5.20. the true God: for, there is but that one and eternall God by nature, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 who calls himselfe,1 the God of sufficiency or perfection. He is not then God equivocally, in respect of the excellencie of his gifts and office, as Angels, Psal. 97.7. Or, as Princes, Psal. 82.6. as Samosatenus and Photinus of old blasphemed; and of late, the Servetians and Socinians, affirming Christ to have taken his beginning from Mary, and not to have had any being before her. Neither a factitious or created God before all things of non-entities, as Arius madly said. For no creature can attaine to the perfection of the Creatour, whereas every creature proceeds from non-entitie to entitie; but not to be, is absolutely repugnant to God, and to his perfection.
15. Perfect man.] A true and entire man, consisting of a reasonable soul, and a humane body; which is contrary to the heresy of Marcion and Manichoeus, affirming, that Christ came in the later times to deliver souls, not bodies; and that he was not truly in the flesh, but only to delude humane senses, he made show of humane flesh. This is also against the error of Apollinaris the Syrian, affirming the Son of God to have assumed the flesh without the soul, and that the Word was in stead of the soul in him, August. de haeres. 46.55. Christ himself did pithily refute both these: the former, when, rising from the dead, he showed himself to his disciples, who, being affrighted with his sight, supposed they had seen a spirit; to whom Christ faith, Why are you troubled? See my hands and feet: for I am the same. Touch me and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as you see me have, Luke 24.39. But the later he refels, when, in the garden, in his fear and agony, he cried out, My soul is heavy unto death, Matth. 26.38. Now, the Word could not either be troubled with passions of the mind, or with the fear of death; because the nature of man, being assumed into the hypostasis, doth not subsist by it self, but in the person of the Word, which is so far from diminishing mans perfection, that it rather perfects it. As for mans person, to be, or to subsist, it is the perfection of a mere man, which, indeed, should make Christ to be merely man: But to subsist in the person of the Word of God, is the perfection of him that is both God and man; or of man assumed into the Godhead, as Athanasius speaks in the following Article.
15. Perfect man.] A true and entire man, consisting of a reasonable soule, and a humane body; which is contrary to the heresie of Marcion and Manichoeus, affirming, that Christ came in the later times to deliver soules, not bodies; and that he was not truly in the flesh, but onely to delude humane senses, hee made shew of humane flesh. This is also against the errour of Apollinaris the Syrian, affirming the Son of God to have assumed the flesh without the soule, and that the Word was in stead of the soule in him, August. de haeres. 46.55. Christ himselfe did pithily refute both these: the former, when, rising from the dead, he shewed himselfe to his disciples, who, being affrighted with his sight, supposed they had seen a spirit; to whom Christ faith, Why are you troubled? See my hands and feet: for I am the same. Touch me and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as you see mee have,
16. Equal to the Father.] That Christ was the Son of God, and God, the forenamed Heretics of old did not, and the modern do not deny; but they did, as they do at this day, trifle with an equivocation, affirming a factitious god, in respect of gifts and divine operations; or a God created before all things, but lesser and inferior to the Father: which is directly against the assertors of the Christian faith, amongst whom Athanasius was not the meanest: who, by evident testimonies out of Scripture, and arguments, did demonstrate, that the Son of God was God, equal and consubstantial with the Father. Here let a few serve: We are inaugurated by baptism equally in the name of the Father, Son, and holy Ghost, as in the name of one true God. The Jews themselves did acknowledge Christ, when he said, John 5.17. My Father worketh hitherto, and I work, that he called God his own Father, and that he made himself equal with God; which Christ was so far from denying or reproving, that through the whole Chapter he confirms it by notable documents, taken from the equality and identity, both of his own and ⟨p. 763⟩Fathers works and operations, power and authority, honour and worship: Whatsoever (saith he) the Father doth, the Son doth the same also. For, as the Father raiseth the dead, and quickeneth them; so doth the Son quicken those whom he will, &c. The Father hath committed all judgement to the Son, that all may honour the Son, as they honour the Father. As the Father hath life in himself, so he hath given to the Son to have life in himself, &c. There needs no more: Christs own witness alone of himself is sufficient to confirm our faith, and to overthrow heresies;1 For if (saith he) I testify of my self, my testimony is true: but he testifieth of himself, that God is his proper Father, and that he is equal with God the Father; therefore his testimony of himself is true. Hence the malicious stupidity of Heretics, derogating authority from his testimony, is more to be detested, then that of the Jews.
16. Equall to the Father.] That Christ was the Son of God, and God, the forenamed Hereticks of old did not, and the moderne doe not deny; but they did, as they doe at this day, trifle with an equivocation, affirming a factitious god, in respect of gifts and divine operations; or a God created before all things, but lesser and inferiour to the Father: which is directly against the assertors of the Christian faith, amongst whom Athanasius was not the meanest: who, by evident testimonies out of Scripture, and arguments, did demonstrate, that the Son of God was God, equall and consubstantiall with the Father. Here let a few serve: We are inaugurated by baptism equally in the name of the Father, Son, and holy Ghost, as in the name of one true God. The Jewes themselves did acknowledge Christ, when he said,
According to his divinity.] Not according to his humanity; otherwise he were not true man: therefore the doctrine of Schwenckfeldius if false, which equals Christs humanity in all things to God; or, which makes Christs humanity equal to God.
According to his divinity.] Not according to his humanity; otherwise hee were not true man: therefore the doctrine of Schwenckfeldius if false, which equals Christs humanity in all things to God; or, which makes Christs humanity equall to God.
17. Lesser then the Father.] And this Christ witnesseth of himself, saying, My Father is greater then I, John 14.28. to wit, by reason of my Incarnation, as man, I am lesser then the Father. Which, because Arius drew this to the inequality of the divinity, he brought in the heresy of the Anomaei, Cyril. l. 2. thes. c. 3. So far is the Son equal to the Father, in that he is by nature God; but in that he was made man, and as a man was crucified and died, he is less then the Father. The definition of Chalcedon afterwards against Eutyches thus declares it, Consubstantial to the Father, according to the divinity; consubstantial to us, according to the humanity. In all things like to us, except the filth of sin, Hebr. 2.17. and 4.15.
17. Lesser then the Father.] And this Christ witnesseth of himselfe, saying, My Father is greater then I, John 14.28. to wit, by reason of my Incarnation, as man, I am lesser then the Father. Which, because Arius drew this to the inequalitie of the divinitie, hee brought in the heresie of the Anomaei, Cyril. l. 2. thes. c. 3. So far is the Son equall to the Father, in that he is by nature God; but in that he was made man, and as a man was crucified and died, he is lesse then the Father. The definition of Chalcedon afterwards against Eutyches thus declares it, Consubstantiall to the Father, according to the divinity; consubstantiall to us, according to the humanity. In all things like to us, except the filth of sin, Hebr. 2.17. and 4.15.
18. Who, though he be God and man, yet he is not two, but one Christ. 19. One, not by converting of the divinity into flesh, 20. but by assuming of the humanity into God. 21. One altogether, not by conversion of the substance, 22. but by unity of the person. 23. For, as the reasonable soul and flesh are one man, so God and man is one Christ.
18. Who, though he be God and man, yet he is not two, but one Christ. 19. One, not by converting of the divinitie into flesh, 20. but by assuming of the humanitie into God. 21. One altogether, not by conversion of the substance, 22. but by unitie of the person. 23. For, as the reasonable soule and flesh are one man, so God and man is one Christ.
18. Who, though God.] Hitherto of the truth of the two natures of the Son of God incarnate: now, of their union; or of the personal unity. The Article in the beginning hath a Prolepsis or anticipation: whereas God and man are two divers subsistences; therefore, if Christ be God and man, he will not be one, but two. Yet one Christ, God and man, not two;1 because of the union of the natures. God, indeed, and man are different subsistences, without the personal union; but Christ is God and man in the personal unity. Upon this part of the Article pitcheth that heresy, which, about an hundred years after Athanasius, Nestorius, the Patriarch of Constantinople, brought into the Church; but was condemned by the Council of Ephesus.
18. WHo, though God.] Hitherto of the truth of the two natures of the Son of God incarnate: now, of their union; or of the personall unitie. The Article in the beginning hath a Prolepsis or anticipation: whereas God and man are two divers subsistances; therefore, if Christ be God and man, hee will not be one, but two. Yet one Christ, God and man, not two;1 because of the union of the natures. God, indeed, and man are different subsistences, without the personall union; but Christ is God and man in the personall unitie. Upon this part of the Article pitcheth that heresie, which, about an hundred years after Athanasius, Nestorius, the Patriarch of Constantinople, brought into the Church; but was condemned by the Councell of Ephesus.
19. One, not by conversion.] The reason of the unity consisteth not in the conversion of the divinity into flesh, which heresy was devised two hundred years after Athanasius, by Eutyches a Monk of Constantinople, who expounded the words of John, The word was made flesh, of the conversion of the word into flesh: As the water is said to be made wine, that is, converted into wine, John 2.8. affirming, that after the incarnation, not two natures did remain, but one only; to wit, the flesh made of the Word. But not without cause he was suppressed by the authority of the Council of Chalcedon: For, how can the divinity be turned into flesh? or an uncreated nature, void of mutation, be converted into a creature? By this means, ⟨p. 764⟩Christ should neither be God nor man truly; because he must lose both the Divinity and the humanity together.
19. One, not by conversion.] The reason of the unitie consisteth not in the conversion of the divinitie into flesh, which heresie was devised two hundred yeares after Athanasius, by Eutyches a Monk of Constantinople, who expounded the words of John, The word was made flesh, of the conversion of the word into flesh: As the water is said to be made wine, that is, converted into wine, John 2.8. affirming, that after the incarnation, not two natures did remaine, but one onely; to wit, the flesh made of the Word. But not without cause he was suppressed by the authority of the Councell of Chalcedon: For, how can the divinity be turned into flesh? or an uncreated nature, void of mutation, be converted into a creature? By this meanes, ⟨p. 764⟩Christ should neither be God nor man truly; because he must lose both the Divinity and the humanity together.
20. But by assuming the humanity into God.] In the Greek, into the Deity; yet not absolutely, but into one of the persons of the Deity, or of the Word. For this alone, not the Father, not holy Ghost, assumed humane flesh into the unity of the hypostasis. See the 8. and 1. Note. Of this assumption the Apostle thus, Hebr. 2.14. He was made partaker of flesh and blood. And ver. 16. He took not on him the nature of Angels: but he took on him the seed of Abraham; that is, he united it to himself personally, as the Schools speak, that there might be one hypostasis of the Word and flesh. The true reason or manner then of the unity of Christs person, is not the conversion of the Word into flesh, but the hypostatical union of the Word with flesh.
20. But by assuming the humanity into God.] In the Greek, into the Deity; yet not absolutely, but into one of the persons of the Deity, or of the Word. For this alone, not the Father, not holy Ghost, assumed humane flesh into the unitie of the hypostasis. See the 8. and 1. Note. Of this assumption the Apostle thus, Hebr. 2.14. He was made partaker of flesh and bloud. And ver. 16. He took not on him the nature of Angels: but he took on him the seed of Abraham; that is, he united it to himselfe personally, as the Schooles speak, that there might be one hypostasis of the Word and flesh. The true reason or manner then of the unitie of Christs person, is not the conversion of the Word into flesh, but the hypostaticall union of the Word with flesh.
21. Not by confusion of the substance.] That is, not by commixtion of the nature and natural properties of them both, into some third thing, such as is the confusion of water and honey in Metheglin, which was the heresy afterward of the Monophysits sprung out of Eutyches his follies, against which Damascene disputes at large, lib. 3. orthod. fidei. c. 3.
21. Not by confusion of the substance.] That is, not by commixtion of the nature and naturall properties of them both, into some third thing, such as is the confusion of water and honey in Metheglin, which was the heresie afterward of the Monophysits sprung out of Eutyches his follies, against which Damascen disputes at large, lib. 3. orthod. fidei. c. 3.
22. But by unity of the person.] To wit, of God-man, or the Word incarnate: the natures of the Word & flesh, and their essential properties remaining distinct and safe; as, after Athanasius, the Council of Chalcedon, Act. 20. hath more fully explained, in these words, We all acknowledge our Lord Jesus Christ in two natures inconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably; the diversity of the two natures being no ways made void, by reason of the union: rather the propriety of each nature, agreeing in one person, is preserved; so that he is not divided or severed into two natures, but Jesus Christ is one, and the same only begotten Son, God the Word.
22. But by unity of the person.] To wit, of God-man, or the Word incarnate: the natures of the Word & flesh, and their essentiall properties remaining distinct and safe; as, after Athanasius, the Councell of Chalcedon, Act. 20. hath more fully explained, in these words, We all acknowledge our Lord Jesus Christ in two natures inconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably; the diversity of the two natures being no waies made void, by reason of the union: rather the propriety of each nature, agreeing in one person, is preserved; so that he is not divided or severed into two natures, but Jesus Christ is one, and the same only begotten Son, God the Word.
23. For as the reasonable soul.] The manner of the union of the Word & flesh is illustrated by a Simile, which, before Athanasius, Justin Martyr, a very ancient Writer, in his Exposition of the Faith, did make use of, whose words we thought good to set down that we may understand how much they agree: Let no man (saith he) enquire of me the manner of this union; for I am not ashamed to confess my ignorance: yet I will rather glory, that I believe those hidden mysteries, with which I was initiated, which are not perceptible to reason and understanding. Some there are, who understand this union, as they do that of the soul and body, and so they teach. And the example agrees, if not in all, yet in parts: For, as man, being one, hath two different natures; and with one part he consulteth, and with the other he puts his counsel in execution; with his mind he decrees to build a ship, with his hands he puts in practise the work which he decreed: So one Son, being of two natures; according to the one he works miracles, according to the other, he takes upon him all sort of humility: For, as he is of the Father, and God, he works miracles; as he is of the Virgin, and man, of his own accord he did naturally undergo the cross and passion, and such like. Hitherto if one compare, the similitude doth well agree; on the other side, if he compare the whole with the whole, he takes away the difference: For, though man consist of body and soul, yet he is not the same with these, but some other thing; as he is man, he consisteth in the union of body and soul, and so existeth some other third thing: But Christ is not made of the Deity and humanity, when he is not different from these two, but both, God and man. Again, the soul is always affected with the body, which no Orthodox man, that is well in his wits, dare say or think of Christs divinity: therefore this example of man is partly to be received, partly to be avoided.
23. For as the reasonable soule.] The manner of the union of the Word & flesh is illustrated by a Similie, which, before Athanasius, Justin Martyr, a very ancient Writer, in his Exposition of the Faith, did make use of, whose words we thought good to set down that we may understand how much they agree: Let no man (saith he) enquire of me the maner of this union; for I am not ashamed to confesse my ignorance: yet I will rather glory, that I beleeve those hidden mysteries, with which I was initiated, which are not perceptible to reason and understanding. Some there are, who understand this union, as they doe that of the soule and body, and so they teach. And the example agrees, if not in all, yet in parts: For, as man, being one, hath two different natures; and with one part he consulteth, and with the other he puts his counsell in execution; with his mind he decrees to build a ship, with his hands he puts in practise the work which he decreed: So one Son, being of two natures; according to the one he workes miracles, according to the other, he takes upon him all sort of humility: For, as he is of the Father, and God, he works miracles; as he is of the Virgin, and man, of his owne accord he did naturally undergoe the crosse and passion, and such like. Hitherto if one compare, the similitude doth well agree; on the other side, if he compare the whole with the whole, he takes away the difference: For, though man consist of body and soule, yet he is not the same with these, but some other thing; as he is man, he consisteth in the union of body and soule, and so existeth some other third thing: But Christ is not made of the Deity and humanity, when he is not different from these two, but both, God and man. Againe, the soule is alwaies affected with the body, which no Orthodox man, that is well in his wits, dare say or think of Christs divinity: therefore this example of man is partly to be received, partly to be avoided.
By which words we understand, that the similitude consists in two things, and in so many is discrepant. It agrees first, that as the reasonable soul is coupled with mans body into one person of man; so God the Word, with the nature of man, is coupled in the one person of God and man, and that by an unspeakable way. Again, as the union of the soul with the body is made, the essential properties of both natures remaining entire; for, the soul remains in the union invisible, spiritual, immortal, rational, impartible; but the body is visible, tangible, mortal, void of reason, and partable. The union also is made without transfusion of the essential ⟨p. 765⟩properties of the one nature into the other: The soul is not made visible corporeal, mortal, irrational, partible, for being united to the body: The body is not made invisible, spiritual, immortal, rational, impartible, because united to the soul. The union notwithstanding is made with the communion of the essential properties of body and soul, really transient into the person of man, in respect of each nature: As man really becomes immortal, rational, according to his soul; so he becomes mortal, and void of reason, according to his body. So the union of God the Word was made, the properties of both natures remaining entire. God the Word remained in this union eternal, uncreated, most simple, infinite, omnipresent, omnipotent, omniscient, impassible, immortal, &c. The flesh in time was created, compounded, finite, in respect of place, power, knowledge, passible, mortal, &c. The union also was made without transfusion of the essential properties of God the Word into the flesh, or of the flesh into God the Word. The Word was not made temporary, was not created, nor compounded, nor finite in place, power, and knowledge, nor passible, or mortal, by the union with the flesh: So the flesh was not made eternal, uncreated, uncompounded, infinite, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, impassible, immortal, by the union with the Word; yet the union was made with the communion of the essential properties of the Word and flesh, really transient into the person of Christ, God and man, or the Word incarnate, in respect of each nature (which Damascene calls the manner of alternation, lib. 3. orthod fid. cap. 4.)
By which words we understand, that the similitude consists in two things, and in so many is discrepant. It agrees first, that as the reasonable soule is coupled with mans body into one person of man; so God the Word, with the nature of man, is coupled in the one person of God and man, and that by an unspeakable way. Again, as the union of the soule with the body is made, the essentiall properties of both natures remaining entire; for, the soule remaines in the union invisible, spirituall, immortall, rationall, impartible; but the body is visible, tangible, mortall, void of reason, and partable. The union also is made without transfusion of the essentiall
As Christ-God becomes man really in time,1 created and borne, compounded, finite in place, power, and knowledge, and was passible, mortal, suffered, died, according to the nature assumed; so Christ-man is really God, eternal, uncreated, most simple, finite, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, according to the divinity assuming.
As Christ-God becomes man really in time,1 created and borne, compounded, finite in place, power, and knowledge, and was passible, mortall, suffered, died, according to the nature assumed; so Christ-man is really God, eternall, uncreated, most simple, finite, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, according to the divinity assuming.
1[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
Heb. 2.14
. Because children are partakers of flesh and blood, the Son of God himselfe was made partaker of the same; and ver. 16. He tooke not on him the nature of Angels, but he tooke on him the flesh, is of God. To this purpose are the Angels words to the Virgin Mary,
. The holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the vertue of the most High shall over-shadow thee; therefore that holy thing that shall be borne of thee, shall be called the Son of God. And that of the Apostle,
. God sent his Son, made of a woman: out of which is understood, that this Incarnation is the miraculous assumption of humane flesh or nature, by the operation of the holy Ghost in the Virgins womb, being performed by the Son of God, into the unity of his personality.
the name of Son. Secondly, the benefit of the Incarnation was by God ordained, and bestowed upon men, for this end, that wee might become the sons of God: for it was meet, that we should be made Gods adopted sons by him, who is Gods naturall Son. Thirdly, it was most convenient, that he, who had obtained a middle place among the creatures, should be repaired by the middle person of the Trinitie, that there might be a decent correspondencie between the middle and middle. Now, man hath a middle place among the creatures, having obtained to be under the spirituall, and above the corporeall creatures; it was then fit, that man should be repaired by the middle person of the Trinitie. Lastly, there is nothing more decent, than that decayed nature should be restored by him, by whom it was created; because all things were made by him, John 1.3. therefore man was to be repaired and restored to his former dignitie by the Son of God.
I will not have thee discusse how God the Father begot his Son, neither search too curiously into the depth of this mysterie, lest perhaps, whilst thou art making too strict a scrutiny, to find out the splendor of this inaccessible light, thou forfeit that small and weak sight, which, by divine bounty is bestowed upon men. Know, that the mysterie of this divine generation is as far different and eminent above all things that are in us, as the Creatour is more potent then the creature, and the Artificer more excellent then his worke, &c. When thou hearest of this Son, I would not have thee think of a carnall nativity; but remember, that these things are spoken of the simple nature of an incorporeall substance. For, if in that word, which the heart; or in that meaning, which the mind; or in that brightnesses which the light begets of it selfe; if, I say, there is no weaknesse in that generation: how much purer must our thoughts be of him, who is the Creatour of all these? By this manner then of subsisting proper to himselfe, is the Son of God distinguished in the holy Trinitie, from the Father and holy Ghost, because he alone is begotten of the Father before the world: and therefore hee onely assumed mans flesh, and was borne of the Virgin in time.
. But the fruit is begot of the substance of the tree; which is flat against the madnesse of Valentinus, affirming, that Christ was sent by the Father, and brought with him an heavenly bodie, and that he assumed nothing of the Virgin Mary; but that hee past through her, as through a channell or pipe, without taking any flesh of her, August. de haeres. 10.
. Now, the Word could not either be troubled with passions of the mind, or with the feare of death; because the nature of man, being assumed into the hypostasis, doth not subsist by it selfe, but in the person of the Word, which is so far from diminishing mans perfection, that it rather perfects it. As for mans person, to be, or to subsist, it is the perfection of a meere man, which, indeed, should make Christ to be meerly man: But to subsist in the person of the Word of God, is the perfection of him that is both God and man; or of man assumed into the Godhead, as Athanasius speakes in the following Article.
. My Father worketh hitherto, and I worke, that he called God his owne Father, and that he made himselfe equall with God; which Christ was so far from denying or reproving, that through the whole Chapter he confirmes it by notable documents, taken from the equality and identity, both of his owne and
⟨p. 763⟩
Fathers workes and operations, power and authoritie, honour and worship: Whatsoever (saith he) the Father doth, the Son doth the same also. For, as the Father raiseth the dead, and quickneth them; so doth the Son quicken those whom he will, &c. The Father hath committed all judgement to the Son, that all may honour the Son, as they honour the Father. As the Father hath life in himselfe, so he hath given to the Son to have life in himselfe, &c. There needs no more: Christs owne witnesse alone of himselfe is sufficient to confirme our faith, and to overthrow heresies;
For if (saith he) I testifie of my selfe, my testimony is true: but hee testifieth of himselfe, that God is his proper Father, and that he is equall with God the Father; therefore his testimony of himselfe is true. Hence the malicious stupiditie of Hereticks, derogating authoritie from his testimony, is more to be detested, then that of the Jewes.
properties of the one nature into the other: The soule is not made visible corporeall, mortall, irrationall, partible, for being united to the body: The body is not made invisible, spirituall, immortall, rationall, impartible, because united to the soule. The union notwithstanding is made with the communion of the essentiall properties of body and soule, really transient into the person of man, in respect of each nature: As man really becomes immortall, rationall, according to his soule; so he becomes mortall, and void of reason, according to his body. So the union of God the Word was made, the properties of both natures remaining entire. God the Word remained in this union eternall, uncreated, most simple, infinite, omnipresent, omnipotent, omniscient, impassible, immortall, &c. The flesh in time was created, compounded, finite, in respect of place, power, knowledge, passible, mortall, &c. The union also was made without transfusion of the essentiall properties of God the Word into the flesh, or of the flesh into God the Word. The Word was not made temporary, was not created, nor compounded, nor finite in place, power, and knowledge, nor passible, or mortall, by the union with the flesh: So the flesh was not made eternall, uncreated, uncompounded, infinite, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, impassible, immortall, by the union with the Word; yet the union was made with the communion of the essentiall properties of the Word and flesh, really transient into the person of Christ, God and man, or the Word incarnate, in respect of each nature (which Damascen calls the manner of alternation, lib. 3. orthod fid. cap. 4.)