[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 1 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms]
ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms]
ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
These positions of Hunnius have in their front and title honey cunningly couched, but in the belly very gall. The front extends almost to the 17. Thesis; so far orthodoxally enough, (if you except the ambushes) they confute the old Heresies, by proving that Christ is a person God and Man, consisting of two natures, true and entire; to wit, the divine and the humane; and that the Son of God, the Word, was made flesh, not by conversion of the deity into flesh, but by assumption of the divinity into God; to which, who freely and heartily subscribes not, he is not Orthodox.
THese positions of Hunnius have in their front and title honey cunningly couched, but in the belly very gall. The front extends almost to the 17. Thesis; so far orthodoxally enough, (if you except the ambushes) they confute the old Heresies, by proving that Christ is a person God and Man, consisting of two natures, true and intire; to wit, the divine and the humane; and that the Son of God, the Word, was made flesh, not by conversion of the deity into flesh, but by assumption of the divinity into God; to which, who freely and heartily subscribes not, he is not Orthodox.
The belly swells with Ubiquitary poison in the next Thesis to the 39. for, he layeth certain hypotheses or suppositions, concerning the manner and force of the union, as it were foundations of the future Disputation, concerning the real communication of the properties, and of the omnipresence of his flesh, which he paints with wonderful Sophistry; but all of them are false; to wit, That the whole Word did assume the whole flesh so, that as the flesh is never without the Word, so the Word is never without the flesh; that is, without the dimensions of the flesh: that such an union is the dwelling of the whole fullness of the deity within the flesh, that without the flesh, the deity of the Word is no where: that finally, the flesh hath most eminently transcended all locality, being in the illocall person of the Word, and that it hath truly obtained an illocall manner of existing; that is, to be illocall in the union. In the interim, he cunningly conceals the definition and form of the hypostatical union, which he ought first to ⟨p. 771⟩have explained, as being the head of the whole dispute, and not delude people with a lying title. But this he did, lest the manifest falsehood of the specific difference should have weakened and shaken his cause before its time.
The belly swels with Ubiquitary poyson in the next Thesis to the 39. for, he layeth certaine hypotheses or suppositions, concerning the manner and force of the union, as it were foundations of the future Disputation, concerning the reall communication of the properties, and of the omnipresence of his flesh, which he paints with wonderfull Sophistry; but all of them are false; to wit, That the whole Word did assume the whole flesh so, that as the flesh is never without the Word, so the Word is never without the flesh; that is, without the dimensions of the flesh: that such an union is the dwelling of the whole fulnesse of the deity within the flesh, that without the flesh, the deity of the Word is no where: that finally, the flesh hath most eminently transcended all locality, being in the illocall person of the Word, and that it hath truly obtained an illocall manner of existing; that is, to be illocall in the union. In the interim, he cunningly conceales the definition and forme of the hypostaticall union, which he ought first to ⟨p. 771⟩have explained, as being the head of the whole dispute, and not delude people with a lying title. But this he did, lest the manifest falshood of the specificall difference should have weakened and shaken his cause before its time.
The tail again shows the honey, but hides the sting; for he deduceth four consectaries or corollaries: 1. That the union should be defined by the true and solid communion. 2. That the person of the Word be communicated and conferred upon the flesh ineffably. 3. That the deity of the person of the Word, or the whole fullness of the deity, be communicated to the humanity. 4. That finally, under this plenitude of the whole deity, the majesty of the properties of the Word be infallibly understood. No Orthodox man will contradict these points, if they be meant of the true union of the natures, and communion of the properties in the concrete; but that both these, and the precedent passages, for the most part, all of them are nothing else then treacherous subterfuges of Ubiquity, even those that have but weak eyes may see; and this in a brief examination shall be showed.
The taile againe shews the honey, but hides the sting; for he deduceth foure consectaries or corollaries: 1. That the union should be defined by the true and solid communion. 2. That the person of the Word be communicated and conferred upon the flesh ineffably. 3. That the deity of the person of the Word, or the whole fulnesse of the deity, be communicated to the humanity. 4. That finally, under this plenitude of the whole deity, the majesty of the properties of the Word be infallibly understood. No Orthodox man will contradict these points, if they be meant of the true union of the natures, and communion of the properties in the concret; but that both these, and the precedent passages, for the most part, all of them are nothing else then treacherous subterfuges of Ubiquity, even those that have but weake eyes may see; and this in a briefe examination shall be shewed.
Jesus Christ, in the true knowledge of whom consisteth our eternal salvation, is God and man; that is, a person subsisting of two natures; to wit, the divine and the humane.
Jesus Christ, in the true knowledge of whom consisteth our eternall salvation, is God and man; that is, a person subsisting of two natures; to wit, the divine and the humane.
1Thus speak some of the Fathers, and almost all the School-men, that the person of Christ doth consist, is made up, is constituted, is compounded, is made of two natures, the divine and humane; or of three substances, the deity, the soul, and the body: but so they explain this, that they neither make any confusion of natures, nor any imperfection of the person of the Word, before the Incarnation; nor yet a quaternity of the persons in the divinity; for they teach, that diverse ways one thing may be made up of two or three things: One way is, when of two or more things remaining entire and perfect, one thing is made up; as in those,2 the form whereof is composition, order, or figure: so a heap of wheat is made up of many grains, and a City of many Citizens. Another way is, when one thing is made up of others which remain not in their perfection, but are changed; as when a mixed body is made up of the elements; Metheglen is made of water, and honey. The third way is, when some third thing different specifically is made up of two imperfect things without mixture, as of matter and form; as man is composed of the reasonable soul and the body. None of these ways is the person of Christ said to consist of two natures, or properly composed of them: for, the hypostatical union, is not the confusion of the natures, or only an ordered disposition between themselves, as was that Nestorian parastasis, rather then hypostasis: 3neither is it a permixtion (for some of the Ancients improperly called it a mixtion:) neither is it a composition of matter and form into one third thing which is neither of them: for the Word is not the form of the flesh, nor is this the matter of the Word; neither again, was the Word, by assuming the flesh, made a person, or an other person, which the 8. and 12. Thesis confess. The fourth way is, when improperly, and at large, a thing is said to consist of many, in which many things are put together; and so at length they say in this sense, that the person of Christ consisteth, or is compounded of two natures, whereas a composition, in a large sense, is the position of many things together; for, so they call the hypostatical union a composition. Wherefore, to avoid error, they speak more warily, and they say, that the person of Christ subsisteth in two natures: which phrase the Orthodox Writers retain, as being more proper;
The divine nature, and so this word [God] is not here taken absolutely (for so the whole ⟨p. 772⟩Trinity should be incarnate) but relatively is understood the second person, the only begotten Son; who, in the bosom of the Father, and with the Father, is one and the same, John 1. and 10. The Image of the invisible God. Col. 1. The brightness of the Fathers glory, and the character of his substance, Heb. 1. God the Word, John 1. The mighty God, Isaiah 9. God blessed for ever, Rom. 9.
The divine nature, and so this word [God] is not here taken absolutely (for so the whole ⟨p. 772⟩Trinity should be incarnate) but relatively is understood the second person, the onely begotten Son; who, in the bosome of the Father, and with the Father, is one and the same, John 1. and 10. The Image of the invisible God. Col. 1. The brightnesse of the Fathers glory, and the character of his substance, Heb. 1. God the Word, John 1. The mighty God, Isaiah 9. God blessed for ever, Rom. 9.
Damascene, and the Ancients write, that the divine nature assumed the flesh in one of the persons, or in the person of the Word. It is rightly said then, that the divine nature in Christ is not to be understood absolutely, as a nature; but relatively, as a person: Therefore Thomas, and the School-men, use rather to say, that the person of the Word assumed the nature, then that the nature assumed the nature; or, the nature assumed the nature mediately, the person immediately assumed the nature; because, as they speak, the union is immediately terminated in the person, mediately in the divine nature.
Damascen, and the Ancients write, that the divine nature assumed the flesh in one of the persons, or in the person of the Word. It is rightly said then, that the divine nature in Christ is not to be understood absolutely, as a nature; but relatively, as a person: Therefore Thomas, and the Schoole-men, use rather to say, that the person of the Word assumed the nature, then that the nature assumed the nature; or, the nature assumed the nature mediately, the person immediately assumed the nature; because, as they speake, the union is immediatly terminated in the person, mediatly in the divine nature.
The humanity in Christ is not a person subsisting in it self, but a nature having no proper personality; but, by reason of the union, fully capable and participant of the person of the Word.
The humanity in Christ is not a person subsisting in it selfe, but a nature having no proper personality; but, by reason of the union, fully capable and participant of the person of the Word.
It is rightly said, that the humanity wants a proper personality: for, a personality is a subsistence, or the power of subsisting by it self without any other, and without any other suppositum or supporting subject of a rational nature, which power the humanity neither had,1 nor hath; but, it is a new, improper and deceitful saying, that by force of the union, the flesh is made fully capable and partaker of the person of the Word. It is first new, because, neither the Scripture, nor the Church speaketh thus, that the flesh is capable of the person. 2. Improper, because the flesh neither contains, nor encloseth the person of the Word, as the place is said to be capable of the thing placed:2 neither becomes it the person it self, or is it informed by the personality, as the subject is capable of the form. 3. Deceitful, because the Sophister useth this phrase, as a preparative for the real communication of the properties in the natures; to wit, that he may say, that the flesh is after the same manner capable and partaker of the deity and omnipresence, as it is (according to his saying) partaker and capable of the personality; and that therefore, not by its own, but by the deity and immensity of the Word, it is God and omnipresent, even as not by its own, but by the personality of the Word it subsisteth. But orthodox men confess, with Damascene, that the person of the Word, by reason of the union, is common to both natures; that now the humanity subsisteth in Christ by the same personality that the divinity doth: but, they deny that the flesh is made so capable and partaker of the person, as if it were the person it self: as they also deny, that it is made so partaker of the deity and omnipresence, as if it were the deity of God himself, the omnipresence, or omnipresent, &c. neither do they grant, that it is otherwise partaker of the person, of the deity, of the omnipresence, or can be, then by the union, which maketh not that the humanity, but that man is the person is God, is omnipresent; in which sense the Apostle saith, That the Son of God was made partaker of the flesh and blood of the children; to wit,3 by assuming the seed of Abraham into his personality, or by the hypostatical union; whereby, not the deity of the Son, but God the Son is made flesh and blood; that is to say, true man.
It is rightly said, that the humanity wants a proper personality: for, a personality is a subsistence, or the power of subsisting by it selfe without any other, and without any other suppositum or supporting subject of a rationall nature, which power the humanity neither had,
In this sense also it may be rightly said, that the flesh, or humanity of Christ, is partaker of the person of the deity, of omnipresence; to wit, by the union with the divine person, and omnipresent; which union, makes not that the humanity of Christ, but that the man Christ is a person, is God, is omnipresent.
This in the Scripture is called flesh: by which word not the only corporeal mass is understood, but the full and entire humanity, consisting of a true body, and a reasonable soul.
This in the Scripture is called flesh: by which word not the onely corporeall masse is understood, but the full and entire humanity, consisting of a true body, and a reasonable soule.
He saith well, That under the term of flesh, is meant the entire humanity, consisting of a true body and soul, so he would add these words, With the true properties of both, and withal the infirmities, except sin: For, if he be like his brethren in all things, then surely in locality and circumscription he is made like to them, and that in the union, and in the Word. For, without the union, and without the Word, the flesh hath neither being nor subsistence at any time: Therefore that is false, which he affirms in the 36. Thesis, That the flesh, by power of the union, hath, in a most eminent way, transcended all locality, in the illocall Word, and that it hath obtained an illocall manner of existence.
He saith well, That under the terme of flesh, is meant the entire humanity, consisting of a true body and soule, so he would adde these words, With the true properties of both, and withall the infirmities, except sin: For, if he be like his brethren in all things, then surely in locality and circumscription hee is made like to them, and that in the union, and in the Word. For, without the union, and without the Word, the flesh hath neither being nor subsistence at any time: Therefore that is false, which he affirmes in the 36. Thesis, That the flesh, by power of the union, hath, in a most eminent way, transcended all locality, in the illocall Word, and that it hath obtained an illocall manner of existence.
Therefore the Word did not assume an imaginary, but a true and solid body, consisting of flesh and bones, Luke 24. of flesh and blood, John 16. which also in glory remains a true body, conformable to the glorified bodies of the Saints, both in substance and qualities.
Therefore the Word did not assume an imaginary, but a true and solid body, consisting of flesh and bones, Luke 24. of flesh and bloud, John 16. which also in glory remaines a true body, conformable to the glorified bodies of the Saints, both in substance and qualities.
1. For, if the Word assumed not a fantastical, but a true and solid body; then, doubtless, it assumed a body endued with quantity, dimension, visibility, and locality: For, that is not a true body, but an imaginary, that wants quantity; nor can that be solid, which wants dimensions; and that hath no dimensions,1 which is indivisible & illocall; for, an uncircumscribed nature is invisible, saith Theodoret. Now, such a body as the Word did assume, such a body assumed is in the Word: Therefore it is false, That the body of Christ in the Word, which is illocall, did obtain an illocall way of subsisting; that is, that it is made, and becomes illocall.
1. For, if the Word assumed not a fantasticall, but a true and solid body; then, doubtlesse, it assumed a body endued with quantitie, dimension, visibilitie, and localitie: For, that is not a true body, but an imaginary, that wants quantitie; nor can that be solid, which wants dimensions; and that hath no dimensions,1 which is indivisible & illocall; for, an uncircumscribed nature is invisible, saith Theodoret. Now, such a body as the Word did assume, such a body assumed is in the Word: Therefore it is false, That the body of Christ in the Word, which is illocall, did obtaine an illocall way of subsisting; that is, that it is made, and becomes illocall.
2. If the body, assumed by the Word, consisteth of flesh and bones, Luke 24. of flesh and blood, Hebr. 2. certainly, that body which is feigned to lurk in a crust of bread, or under the accidents of bread, and to be eaten by the mouth, is not that true and solid body assumed by the Word; because it hath not flesh and bones.
2. If the body, assumed by the Word, consisteth of flesh and bones, Luke 24. of flesh and bloud, Hebr. 2. certainly, that body which is feigned to lurk in a crust of bread, or under the accidents of bread, and to be eaten by the mouth, is not that true and solid body assumed by the Word; because it hath not flesh and bones.
3. If also it remains in glory such a body, to wit, solid and true, consisting of flesh and bones, having dimensions; then, doubtless, in glory it retains the definition of a true body: from which definition, the three dimensions, and, by reason of these, circumscription and locality can be no more separated, then rationality from man.
3. If also it remaines in glory such a bodie, to wit, solid and true, consisting of flesh and bones, having dimensions; then, doubtlesse, in glory it retaines the definition of a true bodie: from which definition, the three dimensions, and, by reason of these, circumscription and locality can be no more separated, then rationality from man.
4. If it be conformable to the glorified bodies of the Saints in substance and qualities, it cannot then be illocall, immense, every-where: for, our bodies shall not be illocall, nor every-where; but shall have their Ubs, by Christs own testimony. John 17.24. Father, I will, that they whom thou hast given to me, may be with me where I am, John 14.2, 3. I go to prepare a place for you; and if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto my self, that where I am, there you may be.
4. If it be conformable to the glorified bodies of the Saints in substance and qualities, it cannot then be illocall, immense, every-where: for, our bodies shall not be illocall, nor every-where; but shall have their Ʋbs, by Christs owne testimony. John 17.24. Father, I will, that they whom thou hast given to me, may be with me where I am, John 14.2, 3. I goe to prepare a place for you; and if I goe and prepare a place for you, I will come againe, and receive you unto my selfe, that where I am, there you may be.
They need not then cavil thus, That the body is such in its own substance; but in the Word, by reason of the union, it is not such: for, whereas it hath its being not in it self, but in the Word, which assumeth it, and always had; doubtless it is, and remaineth such in the Word, and in the union, as it was assumed. Nor can there be any true reason of that union, which destroyeth the reason of the substance of flesh: but that reason of the union which he feigns, by a certain contradiction, destroyeth the reason of the substance; because it makes that which is local, to be illocall; that which hath dimensions, to have no dimensions; that which hath quantity, to have no quantity; a body, to be no body; and, a substance, no substance.
They need not then cavill thus, That the body is such in its owne substance; but in the Word, by reason of the union, it is not such: for, whereas it hath its being not in it selfe, but in the Word, which assumeth it, and alwaies had; doubtlesse it is, and remaineth such in the Word, and in the union, as it was assumed. Nor can there be any true reason of that union, which destroyeth the reason of the substance of flesh: but that reason of the union which he feignes, by a certaine contradiction, destroyeth the reason of the substance; because it makes that which is locall, to be illocall; that which hath dimensions, to have no dimensions; that which hath quantity, to have no quantity; a body, to be no body; and, a substance, no substance.
But he also assumed a soul: for he said, My soul is heavy unto the death, Mat. 26. which also he breathed out on the Cross, Mat. 27. to wit, an intelligent soul, which after ⟨p. 774⟩death should remain, and which might grow in wisdom, in the time of his humiliation, Luke 2.
But he also assumed a soule: for he said, My soule is heavie unto the death, Mat. 26. which also he breathed out on the Crosse, Mat. 27. to wit, an intelligent soule, which after ⟨p. 774⟩death should remaine, and which might grow in wisdome, in the time of his humiliation, Luke 2.
This Thesis is right opposed, 1. To the error of Apollinaris, feigning, that the Word assumed flesh without a soul, and that he himself was in stead of a soul. See Ambrose de Incay. l. 1. c. 7.
This Thesis is right opposed, 1. To the errour of Apollinaris, feigning, that the Word assumed flesh without a soule, and that hee himselfe was in stead of a soule. See Ambrose de Incay. l. 1. c. 7.
2. To that Papistical fiction of such a perfection in Christs soul, as from its creation, was so replenished with knowledge and grace, that it could not learn any knowledge (or grow therein) which it knew not before. See Bellarm de Christo, l. 4. c. 1, 2, 3, 4.
2. To that Papisticall fiction of such a perfection in Christs soule, as from its creation, was so replenished with knowledge and grace, that it could not learne any knowledge (or grow therein) which it knew not before. See Bellarm de Christo, l. 4. c. 1, 2, 3, 4.
Thus speake some of the Fathers, and almost all the Schoole-men, that the person of Christ doth consist, is made up, is constituted, is compounded, is made of two natures, the divine and humane; or of three substances, the deity, the soule, and the body: but so they explaine this, that they neither make any confusion of natures, nor any imperfection of the person of the Word, before the Incarnation; nor yet a quaternity of the persons in the divinity; for they teach, that diverse wayes one thing may be made up of two or three things: One way is, when of two or more things remaining entire and perfect, one thing is made up; as in those,
the forme whereof is composition, order, or figure: so a heape of wheat is made up of many graines, and a City of many Citizens. Another way is, when one thing is made up of others which remaine not in their perfection, but are changed; as when a mixed body is made up of the elements; Metheglen is made of water, and honey. The third way is, when some third thing different specifically is made up of two imperfect things without mixture, as of matter and forme; as man is composed of the reasonable soule and the body. None of these wayes is the person of Christ said to consist of two natures, or properly composed of them: for, the hypostaticall union, is not the confusion of the natures, or onely an ordered disposition betweene themselves, as was that Nestorian parastasis, rather then hypostasis:
neither is it a permixtion (for some of the Ancients improperly called it a mixtion:) neither is it a composition of matter and forme into one third thing which is neither of them: for the Word is not the forme of the flesh, nor is this the matter of the Word; neither againe, was the Word, by assuming the flesh, made a person, or an other person, which the 8. and 12. Thesis confesse. The fourth way is, when improperly, and at large, a thing is said to consist of many, in which many things are put together; and so at length they say in this sense, that the person of Christ consisteth, or is compounded of two natures, whereas a composition, in a large sense, is the position of many things together; for, so they call the hypostaticall union a composition. Wherefore, to avoid errour, they speake more warily, and they say, that the person of Christ subsisteth in two natures: which phrase the Orthodox Writers retaine, as being more proper;
1How the person of Christ is made up of two natures.
2A thing is said diversly to be made up of more things.
3[Greek or Hebrew]. See Cassian l. 1. de Incar.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. See Cassian l. 1. de Incar.
nor hath; but, it is a new, improper and deceitfull saying, that by force of the union, the flesh is made fully capable and partaker of the person of the Word. It is first new, because, neither the Scripture, nor the Church speaketh thus, that the flesh is capable of the person. 2. Improper, because the flesh neither containes, nor incloseth the person of the Word, as the place is said to be capable of the thing placed:
neither becomes it the person it selfe, or is it informed by the personality, as the subject is capable of the forme. 3. Deceitfull, because the Sophister useth this phrase, as a preparative for the reall communication of the properties in the natures; to wit, that he may say, that the flesh is after the same manner capable and partaker of the deity and omnipresence, as it is (according to his saying) partaker and capable of the personality; and that therefore, not by its owne, but by the deity and immensity of the Word, it is God and omnipresent, even as not by its owne, but by the personality of the Word it subsisteth. But orthodox men confesse, with Damascen, that the person of the Word, by reason of the union, is common to both natures; that now the humanity subsisteth in Christ by the same personality that the divinity doth: but, they deny that the flesh is made so capable and partaker of the person, as if it were the person it selfe: as they also deny, that it is made so partaker of the deity and omnipresence, as if it were the deity of God himselfe, the omnipresence, or omnipresent, &c. neither doe they grant, that it is otherwise partaker of the person, of the deity, of the omnipresence, or can be, then by the union, which maketh not that the humanity, but that man is the person is God, is omnipresent; in which sense the Apostle saith, That the Son of God was made partaker of the flesh and bloud of the children; to wit,
by assuming the seed of Abraham into his personality, or by the hypostaticall union; whereby, not the deity of the Son, but God the Son is made flesh and blood; that is to say, true man.
1Whether, and how the flesh is capable of the person.
2He begins to speak thus Thes. 44.He begins to speake thus Thes. 44.