The Objection of Papists for Transubstantiation, out of the words of the Supper.
pp. 8143 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Objection of Papists for Transubstantiation, out of the words of the Supper.
That which Christ gave, and the Priest consecrates, is Christs body; Ergo it is not bread: It follows, because these are disparata; As, this thing is a man; Ergo it is not an ox. I answer, by denying that this argument is grounded upon the position of one species, to the removing of the disparate species of the same genus; because it is vicious proceeding, from the position of a sacramental relation, to the negation of the subject, or fundamental: Such, as if I would say, This man is a father; Ergo he is not a man. This man is Cesar; Ergo he is not a man: So they, This bread is Christs body; Ergo it is not bread. It is therefore fallacia accidentis, no less absurd, then if you should reason from the position of the form, to the negation of the matter: This thing is a table; Ergo it is not wood: For, though Christs body is not the form, or accident of bread; yet the relation, which the bread, by virtue of the promise, hath to Christs body, is the form of the Sacrament. So it doth not follow, The Dove is the holy Ghost; Ergo this is not a Dove. Circumcision is the covenant; Ergo it is not circumcision. The cup is the New Testament: Ergo, it is not the cup.