The fifth Days proceedings, July the 1. 1651,The fifth Dayes proceedings, July the 1. 1651,
pp. 95–120252 passagespart 2 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sir Tho. Witherington. For that that M. Hales objects to the Indictment, it stands with a great deal of justice; for if a prisoner lays hold of part of an Indictment, and say there is a mistake in it, there is reason it should be so, because the Court must judge it whether it be so or not, therefore there is necessity of it that there should be a copy of so much; but I think he never knew that all the Indictment was, but that part, and that is of necessity for the Court, that they may see whether the Exceptions accord with the Indictment or no; if there be any Exception to an Indictment, if that Exception remains not as a doubt or question, there shall be no copy of so much of the Indictment given: if he shall raise a doubt that there is any doubt in law, or any question and variance between the Acts and the Charge, if he shall raise any such doubt, then I think according to the old law he may have that part of the Charge; but we desire he may raise some doubt to the Court.
Sir Tho. Witherington. For that that M. Hales objects to the Inditement, it stands with a great deal of justice; for if a prisoner layes hold of part of an Inditement, and say there is a mistake in it, there is reason it should be so, because the Court must judge it whether it be so or not, therefore there is necessity of it that there should be a copy of so much; but I think he never knew that all the Inditement was, but that part, and that is of necessity for the Court, that they may see whether the Exceptions accord with the Inditement or no; if there be any Exception to an Inditement, if that Exception remains not as a doubt or question, there shall be no copy of so much of the Inditement given: if he shall raise a doubt that there is any doubt in law, or any question and variance between the Acts and the Charge, if he shall raise any such doubt, then I think according to the old law he may have that part of the Charge; but we desire he may raise some doubt to the Court.
M. Hales. My Lord, we have raised the doubts, and we are ready to deliver in those that we conceive to be Exceptions to the Charge, if we be over-ruled in them, we have no more to say; but if your lordship upon the view of these things we have offered, think them worthy to be spoken to before your Lordship, then surely that is agreeable with that very rule which the Council of the State is pleased to state; that is, that in case we allege that which the Court shall think fit for us to debate before them, that then we may have that whereby it may appear whether we debate upon that which is, or is not.