Besides these objections heretofore recited out of Irenaeus, Ambrose, Augustine, and Theodoritus, our adversaries yet object and heap up against us: moreover, examples of the primitive time of the church, testimonies of general Councils, and opinions of ancient writers, taken out of the book of Councils, & Epistles decretal, whereby their intent is to prove, the foresaid terms (of the head of the church, ruler of the church, chief of all other Priests) to be applied not only to Peter, but also to the Bishop of Rome within the compass of the primitive time. And here cometh in the testimony cited of Vincentius Lirinensis. 1Of the Epistle of Paschasius and his fellows, writing to Leo from the Council of Chalcedon. The testimony also of Justinian the Emperor in his Codex: where Joannes then Pope was called caput omnium Ecclesiarum Epist. inter claras cap. De summa Trinit & fide Cath. The testimony also of Athanasius, with his fellow bishops of Egypt, of Thebaida, and Libya, in their Epistles to Pope Marcius, Liberius & Felix. Likewise the testimony of Hierome, In praef. in 4. Evang. Item Epist. 42. Tom. 1. Item Epist. 41. Tom. 2. Of S. Ambrose, 1. Tim 3. Of S. Augustina to Boniface. Ad Bonifac. contra duas Epist. Pelagian. Lib. 1. cap. 1. Item, Lib. 2. De Baptism. cap. 1. Of Theodoritus in his Epistle to Pope Leo. Epist Commentar. in Pauli Epist. praefixa. Of Chrysostome, Epist ad Innocentium, Tom. 5. &c. By which testimonies our adversaries would prove S. Peter, and after him the Bishop of Rome to be called and taken for head of the church, chief bishop, prince and ruler of the whole Clergy. To all which objections fully and exactly to answer in order, would require a whole volume by it self. In the mean time, leaving the rest unto them unto whom it doth more properly appertain, briefly with this one short distinction.2 I answer these & all such other like places, where S. Peter with his successors are called: head of the church, chief of Bishops, Prince of the Apostles, &c. In which places, this word head, chief, and Prince of the Apostles, may be taken two manner of ways: to note, either dominion, or else commendation. For so we read sometime Caput, 3and princeps, to be words not of authority, but of excellency, whereby is declared the chiefest and worthiest part among many parts, and not possessor and governor of the whole.
Besides these obiections heretofore recited out of Irenaeus, Ambrose, Augustine, and Theodoritus, our aduersaries yet obiect and heape vp against vs: moreouer, examples of the primitiue time of the church, testimonies of generall Councels, and opinions of auncient writers, taken out of the booke of Councels, & Epistles decretall, wherby their intent is to prooue, the foresayd termes (of the head of the church, ruler of the church, chiefe of all other Priestes) to bee applied not onely to Peter, but also to the Bishop of Rome within the compasse of the primitiue time. And here commeth in the testimonie cited of Vincentius Lirinensis. 1Of the Epistle of Paschasius and his fellowes, writing to Leo from the Councel of Chalcedon. The testimonie also of Iustinian the Emperour in his Codex: where Ioannes then Pope was called caput omnium Ecclesiarum Epist. inter claras cap. De summa Trinit & fide Cath. The testimonie also of Athanasius, with his fellow bishops of Egypt, of Thebaida, and Libia, in their Epistles to Pope Marcius, Liberius & Felix. Likewise the testimonie of Hierome, In praef. in 4. Euang. Item Epist. 42. Tom. 1. Item Epist. 41. Tom. 2. Of S. Ambrose, 1. Tim 3. Of S. Augustina to Boniface. Ad Bonifac. contra duas Epist. Pelagian. Lib. 1. cap. 1. Item, Lib. 2. De Baptism. cap. 1. Of Theodoritus in his Epistle to Pope Leo. Epist Commentar. in Pauli Epist. praefixa. Of Chrysostome, Epist ad Innocentium, Tom. 5. &c. By which testimonies our aduersaries would prooue S. Peter, and after him the Bishop of Rome to be called and taken for head of the church, chiefe bishop, prince and ruler of the whole Clergy. To all which obiections fully and exactly to aunswer in order, would require a whole volume by it selfe. In the meane time, leauing the rest vnto them vnto whom it doth more properly appertain, briefly with this one short distinction.2 I answer these & all such other like places, where S. Peter with his successours are called: head of the church, chiefe of Bishops, Prince of the Apostles, &c. In which places, this worde head, chiefe, and Prince of the Apostles, may be taken two maner of waies: to note, either dominiō, or els commendation. For so we read sometime Caput, 3and princeps, to be wordes not of authoritie, but of excellencie, wherby is declared the chiefest and worthiest part among many parts, and not possessour and gouernour of the whole.
- 1Testimonies alleged for the principality of the Pope.Testimonies alledged for the principalitie of the Pope.
- 2Answer by a distinction.Aunswere by a distinction.
- 3Caput and Princeps, have a double understanding.Caput and Princeps, haue a double vnderstanding.