First, after that Dunstan and Oswald, with other Bishops,1 Abbots, and certain Lords & Dukes of that faction, for the maintenance of Monkery, had advanced Edward to be king against Queen Alfrith mother of Ethelred, & Alferus duke of Mercia, and certain other Nobles, which held with the contrary side of the Priests against the Monks. In process of time the monks that came after to write stories, perceiving Dunstan to be reputed in the Church of Rome for an holy Saint, and the said king Edward for an holy Martyr, and partly also to bolster up their own religion of Monkery so much as they could: to the intent therefore they would save the credit both of Dunstan and of the king, and especially bearing ⟨p. 158⟩favour to their own religion, and partly that the reputation of the church of Rome should not be distained by opening the truth of this matter, either did not see, or would not confess herein what they knew, but rather thought best to blanch the story, and colourably to hide the simple truth thereof, making the people falsely believe, that Elfleda the mother of Edward was wife to king Edgar, and Edward to be lawfully borne, and also that Editha was born after Edward, & to be the child for which the king was enjoined penance. All which is false and contrary both to the order of time above declared, and also to the plain words of Malmesbury, which speaking of king Edgars last concubine, saith in plain words:2 Dilexit unicè, integram lecto uni deferens sidem, quoad legitimam uxorem accepit Elfthride, filiam Ordgari. That is, he had a concubine whom he loved entirely, keeping true faith of his bed to her alone, until the time he married for his lawful wife Elfride the daughter of duke Ordgare, &c. Whereby we have to understand that whatsoever concubine this was which Malmesbury speaketh off, certain it is, that Edgar lived in whoredom till time he married his lawful wife. Furthermore, and finally to conclude, beside these arguments and allegations above recited,3 let this also be perpended, how the said Dunstan with his complices, after the killing of king Edward, leaving the right heir of the crown (which was Ethelred) went about, as Capgrave and their own Legend confesseth, to set up Editha the other bastard to possess the crown, but that she more wise then her brother Edward, refused the same.
First, after that Dunstane and Oswolde, wyth other Bishops,1 Abbots, and certayne Lordes & Dukes of that faction, for the maintenaunce of Monkery, had aduaunced Edward to be king against Queene Alfrith mother of Ethelred, & Alferus duke of Mercia, and certaine other Nobles, which held with the contrary side of the Priestes agaynst the Monkes. In processe of tyme the monkes that came after to write stories, perceiuing Dunstane to be reputed in the Church of Rome for an holy Saint, and the sayd king Edward for an holy Martyr, and partly also to bolster vp their owne religion of Monkery so muche as they could: to the intent therfore they would saue the credite both of Dunstane and of the kyng, and especially bearing ⟨p. 158⟩fauour to their owne religion, and partly that the reputation of the church of Rome should not be disteined by opening ye truth of this matter, either did not see, or would not confesse herein what they knew, but rather thought best to blanch the story, and colourably to hide the simple truth therof, making the people falsly beleue, that Elfleda the mother of Edward was wife to king Edgar, and Edward to be lawfully borne, and also that Editha was born after Edward, & to be the child for which the king was enioyned penance. All which is false and cōtrary both to the order of tyme aboue declared, and also to the plaine words of Malmesbury, which speaking of king Edgars last concubine, sayth in plaine wordes:2 Dilexit vnicè, integram lecto vni deferens sidem, quoad legitimam vxorem accepit Elfthride, filiam Ordgari. That is, he had a concubine whom he loued entirely, keping true faith of his bed to her alone, vntil the tyme he maried for his lawfull wife Elfride the daughter of duke Ordgare, &c. Wherby we haue to vnderstand that whatsoeuer concubine this was which Malmesbury speaketh off, certaine it is, that Edgar liued in whoredome till tyme he maried his lawfull wyfe. Furthermore, and finally to conclude, beside these arguments and allegations aboue recited,3 let this also be perpended, how the said Dunstan with his complices, after the killing of king Edward, leauing the right heyre of the crowne (which was Ethelred) went about, as Capgraue and their owne Legend cō fesseth, to set vp Editha the other bastarde to possesse the crowne, but that she more wise then her brother Edward, refused the same.
- 1The cause perpended why this story of K. Edward is so falsely corrupted in Monkish • stories.The cause perpended why thys story of K. Edward is so falsely corrupted in Monkish • stories.
- 2Malmesb. in lib. de Regibus.
- 3Dunstan suborneth Editha the bastard to take the crown from the right heyre. Ex Capgravo in vita sanctae Edithae.Dunstane suborneth Editha the bastard to take the crowne from the right heyre. Ex Capgrauo in vita sanctae Edithae.