Further, as concerning those places of Scripture before alledged, De fractione panis, that is, of breaking of bread, whereupon they think themselves so sure that the Sacrament was then ministered but in one kind: To answer thereunto, first we say, it may be doubted whether all those places in Scripture, De fractione panis, 1are to be referred to the Sacrament. Secondly, the same being given unto them, yet can they not infer thereby, because one part is mentioned, that the full Sacrament therefore was not ministered. The common manner of the Hebrew phrase is, under breaking of bread to signify generally the whole feast or supper: as in the Prophet Isaiah, these words, Frange esurienti panem tuum, do signify as well giving drink as bread, &c. And thirdly howsoever those places, De fractione panis be taken, yet it maketh little for them, but rather against them. For if the Sacrament were administered amongst them in fraction panis. i. in breaking of bread, then must they needs grant, that if bread was there broken. Ergo, there was bread,2 forasmuch as neither the accidences of bread without bread can be broken, neither can the natural body of Christ be subject to any fraction or breaking by the Scripture, which sayeth:3 And ye shall break no bone of him. &c. Wherefore take away the substance of bread, and there can be no fraction. And take away fraction, how then do they make a Sacrament of this breaking, whereas neither the substance of Christs body, neither yet the accidences without their substance can be broken, neither again will they admit any bread there remaining to be broken? And what then was it in this their Fraction panis ▪ that they did break, if it were not Panis, that is, Substantia panis quae frangebatur? To conclude, if they say that this fraction of bread was a Sacramental breaking of Christs body, so by the like figure let them say that the being of Christs natural body in the Sacrament is a Sacramental being, and we are agreed.
Further, as concerning those places of Scripture before alledged, De fractione panis, that is, of breaking of bread, wherupon they thinke themselues so sure that the Sacrament was then ministred but in one kinde: To aunswere thereunto, first we say, it may be doubted whether all those places in Scripture, De fractione panis, 1are to be referred to the Sacrament. Secondly, the same beyng geuen vnto them, yet can they not inferre thereby, because one parte is mentioned, that the full Sacrament therefore was not ministred. The common maner of the Hebrue phrase is, vnder breaking of bread to signifye generally the whole feaste or supper: as in the Prophete Esay, these woordes, Frange esurienti panem tuum, doe signifie as well geuyng drinke as bread, &c. And thirdly howsoeuer those places, De fractione panis be taken, yet it maketh little for them, but rather against them. For if the Sacrament were administred amongst them in fractione panis. i. in breakinge of breade, then must they nedes graūt, that if bread was there broken. Ergo, there was breade,2 forasmuche as neither the accidences of bread without breade can be broken, neither can the naturall body of Christ be subiect to any fraction or breakyng by the Scripture, which sayeth:3 And yee shall breake no bone of him. &c. Wherfore take away the substance of breade, and there can be no fraction. And take away fraction, how then do they make a Sacrament of this breaking, whereas neither the substance of Christes body, neither yet the accidences wythout their substance can be broken, neither agayne will they admit any bread there remaining to be broken? And what then was it in thys their Fractione panis ▪ that they did breake, if it were not Panis, that is, Substantia panis quae frangebatur? To conclude, if they say that this fraction of bread was a Sacramentall breaking of Christes bodye, so by the like figure let them saye that the being of Christes naturall body in the Sacrament is a Sacramental being, and we are agreed.
- 1In fraction panis.In fractione panis.
- 2Exod. 12.
- 3The natural body of Christ may not be broken. Accidences no man can break. No bread is there to be broken: Ergo, there is nothing in the Sacrament broken.The natural body of Chryst may not be broken. Accidences no man can breake. No bread is there to be brokē: Ergo, there is nothing in the Sacrament broken.