pp. 1799–1802112 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Boner. I pray you, master Philpot, what faith were you of twenty years ago? This man will have every year a new faith.1
Boner. I pray you, mayster Philpot, what faith were you of twenty yeares ago? This man will haue euery yeare a new fayth.1
Phil. My Lord, to tell you plain, I think I was of no faith: for I was then a wicked liver, and knew not God then, as I ought to do, God forgive me.
Phil. My Lorde, to tell you playne, I thinke I was of no fayth: for I was then a wicked liuer, and knewe not God then, as I ought to do, God forgeue me.
Boner. No were? that is not so. I am sure you were of some faith.
Boner. No were? that is not so. I am sure you were of some fayth.
Phil. My lord, I have declared to you on my conscience what I then was and judge of my self. And what is that to the purpose of the thing I desire to be satisfied of you?
Phil. My lord, I haue declared to you on my cōsciēce what I then was and iudge of my selfe. And what is that to the purpose of the thing I desire to be satisfied of you?
Boner. Master Doctor Cole, I pray you say your mind to him.
Boner. Mayster Doctour Cole, I pray you say your mind to him.
Cole. What will you say, if I can prove that it was decreed by an universal council in Athanasius time? that all the christen church should follow the determination of the church of Rome? but I do not now remember were.
Cole. What will you say, if I can proue that it was decreed by an vniuersall coūcell in Athanasius time? that all the christen church should folow the determinatiō of ye church of Rome? but I do not now remember were.
Phil. If you Master Doctor can show me the same, granted to the Sea of Rome, by the authority of the scripture, I will gladly hearken thereto. But I think you be not able to show any such thing: for Athanasius was President of Nicene council, and there was no such thing decreed, I am sure.
Phil. If you Mayster Doctour canne shewe me the same, graunted to the Sea of Rome, by the authority of the scripture, I will gladly harken thereto. But I thinke you be not able to shewe any suche thinge: for Athanasius was President of Nicene councell, and there was no such thing decreed, I am sure.
Cole. Though it were not then, it might be at an other time.
Cole. Though it were not then, it might bee at an other time.
Phil. I desire to see the proof thereof. And upon this M. Harpsfield Chancellor to the Bishop of London, brought in a book of Ireneus, with certain leaves turned in, and laid it before the Bishops to help them in their perplexity, if it might be: the which after the Bishops of Bath and Gloucester had read together, the Bishop of Gloucester gave me the book.
Phil. I desire to see the proofe thereof. And vpon this M. Harpsfield Chauncellor to the Bishop of Londō, brought in a booke of Ireneus, with certaine leaues turned in, and layd it before the Bishops to helpe them in theyr perplexity, if it might be: the which after the Bishops of Bath and Glocester had read together, the Bishop of Glocester gaue me the booke.
Gloc. Take the book, M. Philpot, and look upon that place, and there may you see how the church of Rome is to be followed of all men.
Gloc. Take the booke, M. Philpot, and looke vppon that place, and there may you see how the church of Rome is to be folowed of all men.
Phil. I took the Book, and read the place, the which after I had read, I said it made nothing against me,1 but against the Arians and other Heretics, against whom Ireneus wrote, proving that they were not to be credited, because they did teach and follow after strange doctrine in Europa, and that the chief Church of the same was founded by Peter and Paul, and had to this time continued by faithful succession of the faithful Bishops in preaching the true Gospel, as they had received of the Apostles, and nothing like to the late sprung Heretics. &c. Whereby he concludeth against them, that they were not to be heard, neither to be credited, the which thing if you my Lords be able to prove now of the Church of Rome, then had you as good authority against me in my cause now, as Ireneus had against those heretics. But the church of Rome hath swerved from the truth and simplicity of the Gospel,2 which it maintained in Ireneus time, and was uncorrupted from that which it is now: wherefore your Lordships can not justly apply the authority of Ireneus to the Church of Rome now, which is so manifestly corrupted from the Primitive Church.
Phil. I tooke the Booke, and read the place, the which after I had read, I sayd it made nothing agaynst me,1 but agaynst the Arians and other Heretickes, agaynst whome Ireneus wrote, prouing that they were not to be credited, because they did teach and folowe after straunge doctrine in Europa, and that the chiefe Churche of the same was founded by Peter and Paule, and had to this time continued by faythfull succession of the faythfull Bishoppes in preaching the true Gospell, as they had receiued of the Apostles, and nothing like to the late sprong Heretickes. &c. Whereby hee concludeth agaynste them, that they were not to be heard, neither to bee credited, the whiche thing if you my Lordes be able to prooue nowe of the Churche of Rome, then had you as good authoritye agaynst me in my cause now, as Ireneus had agaynst those heretickes. But the church of Rome hath swarued from the truth and simplicitye of the Gospell,2 whiche it mainteined in Ireneus time, and was vncorrupted from that whiche it is nowe: wherefore your Lordships can not iustly apply the authority of Ireneus to the Church of Rome now, which is so manifestly corrupted from the Primitiue Church.
Boner. So will you say still, it maketh nothing for the purpose, whatsoever authority we bring, and will never be satisfied.
Boner. So will you saye still, it maketh nothinge for the purpose, whatsoeuer authority wee bring, and will neuer be satisfied.
Phil. My Lord, when I do by just reason, prove that the authorities which be brought against me do not make to the purpose (as I have already proved) I trust you will receive mine answer.
Phil. My Lorde, when I doe by iust reason, proue that the authorities which be brought agaynst me doe not make to the purpose (as I haue alredy proued) I trust you will receiue mine aunswere.
Worc. It is to be proved most manifestly by all ancient writers,1 that the Sea of Rome hath always followed the truth, and never was deceived, until of late certain heretics had defaced the same.
Worc. It is to be prooued most manifestly by all auncient writers,1 that the Sea of Rome hath alwayes folowed the truth, and neuer was deceiued, vntill of late certayne heretickes had defaced the same.
Phil. Let that be proved, and I have done.
Phil. Let that be proued, and I haue done.
Worcest. Nay, you are of such arrogancy, singularity, and vain glory, that you will not see it, be it never so well proved.
Worcest. Nay, you are of suche arrogancy, singularitye, and vayne glory, that you will not see it, be it neuer so wel proued.
Phil. Ha, my Lords, is it now time (think you) for me to follow singularity or vain glory, since it is now upon danger of my life and death, not only presently, but also before God to come? and I know, if I dye not in the true faith, I shall dye everlastingly, and again I know, if I do not as you would have me, you will kill me and many thousands moe: yet had I lever perish at your hands, then to perish eternally. And at this time I have lost all my commodities of this world, and now lye in a coalhouse, where a man would not lay a dog, with the which I am well contented.
Phil. Ha, my Lordes, is it nowe time (thinke you) for me to folow singularity or vayne glory, since it is now vpon daunger of my life and death, not onely presently, but also before God to come? and I know, if I dye not in the true fayth, I shall dye euerlastingly, and agayne I knowe, if I do not as you would haue me, you will kill me and many thousandes moe: yet had I leuer perish at your handes, then to perishe eternally. And at this time I haue lost all my cōmodities of this worlde, and now lye in a colehouse, where a man would not lay a dog, with the whiche I am well contented.
Cole. Where are you able to prove, that the Church of Rome hath erred at any time? and by what History? certain it is by Eusebius, that the Church was stablished at Rome by Peter and Paul, and that Peter was bishop 25. years at Rome.
Cole. Where are you able to prooue, that the Churche of Rome hath erred at any time? and by what Historye? certayne it is by Eusebius, that the Church was stablished at Rome by Peter and Paul, and that Peter was bishop 25. yeares at Rome.
Phil. I know well that Eusebius so writeth: but if we con pare that which saint Paul writeth to the Galatians the first it will manifestly appear the contrary,1 that he was not half so long there. He lived not past 35. years after he was called to be an Apostle: and Paul maketh mention of his abiding at Jerusalem after Christs death more then 18. years.
Phil. I know well that Eusebius so writeth: but if we cō pare that which saynt Paul writeth to the Galathians the first it will manifestlye appeare the contrarye,1 that he was not halfe so long there. He liued not past 35. yeres after he was called to be an Apostle: and Paul maketh mention of his abiding at Hierusalem after Christes death more then 18. yeares.
Cole. What did Peter write to the Galatians.
Cole. What did Peter write to the Galathians.
Phil. No, I say Paul maketh mention of Peter writing to the Galatians, and of his abiding at Jerusalem. And further, I am able to prove, both by Eusebius & other Historiographers, that the church of Rome hath manifestly erred, and at this present doth err, because she agreeth not with that which they wrote. The primitive Church did use according to the Gospel, and there needeth none other proof but compare the one with the other.
Phil. No, I say Paule maketh mention of Peter writing to the Galathians, and of his abiding at Hierusalem. And further, I am able to proue, both by Eusebius & other Historiographers, that ye church of Rome hath manifestly erred, and at this present doth erre, because shee agreeth not with that which they wrote. The primitiue Church didde vse according to the Gospell, and there needeth none other proofe but compare the one with the other.
Bond. I may compare this man to a certain man I read of,1 which fell into a desperation, & went into a wood to hang himself, and when he came there, he went viewing of every tree, and could find none on the which he might vouchsafe to hang himself. But I will not apply it as I might. I pray you (M. Doctor) go forth with him.
Bon. I may compare this man to a certayne man I reade of,1 which fell into a desperation, & wēt into a wood to hang himselfe, and whē he came there, he went vewing of euery tree, and could find none on the which he might vouchsafe to hange himselfe. But I will not apply it as I mighte. I pray you (M. Doctor) go forth with him.
Cole. My Lord, there be on every side on me that be better able to answer him, and I love not to fall in disputation, for that now a days a man shall not but sustain shame and obloquy thereby of the people. I had lever show my mind in writing.
Cole. My Lord, there be on euery side on me that be better able to answere him, and I loue not to fall in disputation, for that now a daies a man shal not but susteine shame and obloquy thereby of the people. I had leuer shewe my mind in writing.
Phil. And I had lever that you should do so then otherwise, for then a man may better judge of your words then by argument, and I beseech you so to do. But if I were a rich man, I durst wager an hundred pounds, that you shall not be able to show that you have said,1 to be decreed by a general Council in Athanasius time. For this I am sure of, that it was concluded by a general Council in Africa many years after, that none of Africa (under pain of excommunication) should appeal to Rome: the which Decree I am sure they would not have made, if by the scriptures & by an universal Council it had been decreed, that all men should abide & follow the determination of the church at Rome.
Phil. And I had leuer that you should do so then otherwise, for then a man may better iudge of your words then by argument, and I beseeche you so to do. But if I were a rich man, I durst wager an hundred poūdes, that you shal not be able to shew that you haue sayde,1 to be decreed by a generall Counsell in Athanasius time. For this I am sure of, that it was concluded by a generall Councell in Africa many yeares after, that none of Africa (vnder payne of excommunication) should appeale to Rome: the which Decree I am sure they woulde not haue made, if by the scriptures & by an vniuersall Councell it had bene decreed, that al mē should abide & folow the determination of the churche at Rome.
Cole. But I can show that they revoked that error again.
Cole. But I can shew that they reuoked that error again.
Phil. So you say, M. Doctor, but I pray you show me where. I have hitherto heard nothing of you for my contentation, but bare words without any authority.
Phil. So you say, M. Doctour, but I pray you shewe me where. I haue hitherto heard nothing of you for my contē tation, but bare wordes without any authority.
Boner. What, I pray you, ought we to dispute with you of our faith? Justinian in the law hath a title, De fide Catholica, to the contrary.
Boner. What, I pray you, ought we to dispute with you of our fayth? Iustinian in the law hath a title, De fide Catholica, to the contrary.
Phil. I am certain the Civill law hath such a constitution: but our faith must not depend upon the civil law. For as saint Ambrose sayth:1 Non lex sed fides congregavit Ecclesiam: Not the law but the Gospel (saith he) hath gathered the church together.
Phil. I am certayne the Ciuill lawe hath such a constitution: but our fayth must not depend vpon the ciuil law. For as saynt Ambrose sayth:1 Non lex sed fides congregauit Ecclesiam: Not the lawe but the Gospell (sayth hee) hath gathered the church together.
Worcest. M. Philpot, you have the spirit of pride wherewith ye be led, which will not let you to yield to the truth: leave it for shame.
Worcest. M. Philpot, you haue the spirit of pride wherewith ye be led, which will not let you to yelde to the truth: leaue it for shame.
Phil. Sir, I am sure I have the spirit of faith, by the which I speak at this present: neither am I ashamed to stand in my faith.
Phil. Syr, I am sure I haue the spirite of fayth, by the which I speake at this present: neyther am I ashamed to stand in my fayth.
Glocest. What do you think your self better learned then so many notable learned men as be here?
Glocest. What do you thinke your selfe better learned then so many notable learned men as be here?
Worcest. Oh, you would be counted now for Elijah. And yet I tell thee he was deceived: for he thought there had been none good but himself, and yet he was deceived, for there were seven hundred besides him.
Worcest. Oh, you would be counted now for Helias. And yet I tel thee he was deceiued: for he thoght there had bene none good but himselfe, and yet he was deceiued, for there were seuen hundred besides him.
Phil. Yea but he was not deceived in doctrine, as the other seven hundred were.
Phil. Yea but he was not deceiued in doctrine, as the other seuen hundred were.
Worcest. By my faith you are greatly to blame: that you can not be content to be of the Church which ever hath •en of that faithful antiquity.
Worcest. By my fayth you are greatly to blame: that you can not be contēt to be of the Church which euer hath •en of that faythfull antiquity.
Phil. My Lord I know Rome, and have been there, where I saw your Lordship.
Phil. My Lord I know Rome, and haue bene there, wher I saw your Lordship.
Worcest. In deed I did flee from hence thither, and I remember not that I saw you there.1 But I am sorry that you have been there: for the wickedness which you have seen there, peradventure causeth you to do as you do.
Worcest. In deede I did flee from hence thither, and I remember not that I saw you there.1 But I am sory that you haue bene there: for the wickednesse which you haue seene there, peraduenture causeth you to do as you do.
Phil. No, my Lord, I do not as I do, for that cause: for I am taught otherwise by the Gospel, not altogether to refuse the minister for his evil living, so that he bring sound doctrine out of Gods book.
Phil. No, my Lord, I doe not as I do, for that cause: for I am taught otherwise by the Gospell, not altogether to refuse the minister for his euill liuing, so that he bring sound doctrine out of Gods booke.
Phil. S. Paul to the Thessalonians prophesieth that there should come an universal departing from the faith in the latter days before the coming of Christ, saying: Non veniet Christus nisi venerit defectio prius: that is: Christ shall not come, till there come a departing first.
Phil. S. Paul to the Thessalonians prophesieth that there should come an vniuersall departing from the faith in the latter dayes before the cōming of Christ, saying: Non veniet Christus nisi venerit defectio prius: that is: Christ shal not come, till there come a departing fyrst.