pp. 1824–182686 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
York. How answer you to this argument? 1Rome hath known succession of Bishops which your church hath not. Ergo, that is the Catholic Church, and yours is not, because there is no such succession can be proved for your Church.
Yorke. How aunswere you to this argument? 1Rome hath knowne succession of Bishoppes whiche your church hath not. Ergo, that is the Catholick Church, and yours is not, because there is no suche succession can be proued for your Church.
Phil. I deny (my Lord) that succession of Bishops is an infallible point to know the church by: for there may be a succession of bishops known in a place,1 and yet there be no church, as at Antioch and at Jerusalem, and in other places, where the Apostles abode as well as at Rome. But if you put to the succession of bishops succession of doctrine withal (as S. Austen doth) I will grant it to be a good proof for the Catholic church:2 but a local succession only is nothing vayleable.
Phil. I denye (my Lorde) that succession of Bishoppes is an infallible point to know the church by: for there may be a succession of bishops knowne in a place,1 and yet there be no church, as at Antioche and at Hierusalem, and in other places, where ye Apostles abode as well as at Rome. But if you put to the succession of bishops succession of doctrine withall (as S. Austen doth) I will graunt it to be a good proofe for the Catholick church:2 but a locall successiō onely is nothing vayleable.
York. You will have no church then, I see well.
Yorke. You will haue no church then, I see well.
Phil. Yes, my Lord, I acknowledge the catholic church, as I am bound by my Creed: but I cannot acknowledge a false church for the true.
Phil. Yes, my Lord, I acknowledge the catholicke church, as I am bound by my Creed: but I cannot acknowledge a false church for the true.
Chich. Why, is there two catholic churches then?
Chich. Why, is there two catholicke churches then?
Phil. No, I know there is but one catholic Church, but there have been and be at this present, that take upon them the name of Christ & of his church, which be not so in deed, as it is written: That there be that call themselves Apostles & be not so in deed, but the Synagogue of Satan and liars. 1And now it is with us, as it was with the two women in Solomons time, which lay together,2 and the one suppressed her child, and afterward went about to challenge the true mothers child.
Phil. No, I know there is but one catholicke Church, but there haue bene and be at this present, that take vpō them the name of Christ & of his church, which be not so in deed, as it is written: That there be that call themselues Apostles & be not so in deed, but the Synagogue of Sathan and lyers. 1And now it is with vs, as it was with the two women in Salomons time, whiche lay together,2 and the one suppressed her childe, and afterward went about to challenge the true mothers childe.
Chich. What a babbling is here with you now? I see you lack humility. You will go about to teach, and not to learn.
Chich. What a babling is here with you nowe? I see you lacke humilitye. You will goe aboute to teache, and not to learne.
Phil. My lords, I must desire you to bear with my hasty speech: it is my infirmity of nature. All that I speak is to learn by. I would you did understand all my mind, that I might be satisfied by you through better authority.
Phil. My lords, I must desire you to beare with my hasty speech: it is my infirmity of nature. All that I speake is to learne by. I would you did vnderstād all my mind, that I might be satisfied by you through better authority.
Chich. My Lord, and it please your grace, turn the argument upon him, which you have made, and let him show the succession of the Bishops of his Church, as we can do. How say you, can you show the succession of Bishops in your Church from time to time? I tell you, this argument troubled Doctor *Ridley so sore, that he could never answer it: yet he was a man well learned, I dare say you will say so.
Chich. My Lord, and it please your grace, turne the argument vpon him, which you haue made, and let him shewe the succession of the Bishoppes of his Churche, as we can doe. How saye you, canne you shewe the succession of Byshops in your Church from time to time? I tell you, this argument trubled Doctour *Ridley so sore, that he coulde neuer answere it: yet he was a man well learned, I dare say you will say so.
Phil. He was a man so learned, that I was not worthy to carry his books for learning.
Phil. He was a man so learned, that I was not woorthye to cary his bookes for learning.
Chich. I promise you he was never able to answer that. He was a man that I loved well, and he me: for he came unto me divers times being in prison, and conferred with me.
Chich. I promise you he was neuer able to aunswere that. He was a man that I loued well, and he me: for he came vnto me diuers times being in prison, and conferred with me.
Phil. I wonder, my Lord, you should make this argument which you would turn upon me, for the trial of my church whereof I am, or that you would make bishop Ridley so ignorant that he was not able to answer it, since it is of no force. For behold, first I denied you that local succession of Bishops in one place, is a necessary point alone to prove the Catholic church by, and that which I have denied, you can not prove:1 and is it then reason that you should put me to the trial of that, which by you is unproved, and of no force to conclude against me.
Phil. I wonder, my Lord, you should make this argumēt which you would turne vpon me, for the trial of my churche whereof I am, or that you would make bishop Ridley so ignoraunt that he was not able to aunswere it, since it is of no force. For behold, first I denyed you that local succession of Bishops in one place, is a necessary poynt alone to proue the Catholicke church by, and that which I haue denyed, you can not proue:1 and is it then reason that you should put me to the triall of that, which by you is vnproued, and of no force to conclude agaynst me.
Chich. I see, my Lords, we do but loose our labours to reason with him: he taketh himself better learned then we.
Chich. I see, my Lordes, we doe but loose our labours to reason with him: he taketh himselfe better learned then wee.
Phil. I take upon me the name of no learning? I boast of no knowledge, but of faith & of Christ, & that I am bound undoubtedly to know, as I am sure I do.
Phil. I take vpon me the name of no learning? I boaste of no knowledge, but of fayth & of Christ, & that I am bound vndoubtedly to know, as I am sure I do.
Chich. These heretics take upon them to be sure of all things they stand in. You should say rather with humility, I trust I know Christ, then that you be sure thereof.1
Chich. These hereticks take vpō thē to be sure of al things they stād in. You should say rather with humility, I trust I know Christ, then that you be sure therof.1
Phil. Let him doubt of his faith that listeth: God give me always grace to believe that I am sure of true faith & favour in Christ.
Phil. Let hym doubte of his fayth that listeth: God geue me alwayes grace to beleue that I am sure of true fayth & fauour in Christ.
Bath. How will you be able to answer heretics, but by the determination of the known Catholic church?
Bath. How will you be able to answere heretickes, but by the determination of the knowne Catholicke church?
Phil. I am able to answer all heretics by the word of God and convince them by the same.
Phil. I am able to answere all heretickes by the woord of God and conuince them by the same.
Chich. Howe arrogantly is that spoken? I dare not say so.
Chich. Howe arrogantlye is that spoken? I dare not say so.
Phil. My Lord, I pray you bear with me: for I am bold on the truth side, & I speak somewhat by experience that I have had with heretics: and I know the Arians be the subtlest that ever were, & yet I have manifest scriptures to beat them down withal.
Phil. My Lord, I pray you beare with me: for I am bolde on the truth side, & I speake somewhat by experience that I haue had with hereticks: and I know the Arians be the subtlelest that euer were, & yet I haue manifest scriptures to beat them downe withall.
Chichester. I perceive now you are the same manner of man I have heard of, which will not be satisfied by learning.
Chichester. I perceiue nowe you are the same manner of man I haue heard of, whiche will not be satisfied by learning.
Phil. Alas, my Lord, why do you say so? I do desire most humbly to be taught, if there be any better way that I should learn: and hitherto you have showed me no bett•r: therefore I pray your Lordship not to misjudge without a cause.
Phil. Alas, my Lord, why do you say so? I do desire moste humbly to be taught, if there be any better way yt I should learne: and hitherto you haue shewed me no bett•r: therefore I praye your Lordshippe not to misiudge without a cause.
Bath. If you be the true Catholic church, then will you hold with the real presence of Christ in the sacrament, which the true church hath ever maintained.
Bath. If you be the true Catholicke church, then will you hold with the real presence of Christ in ye sacrament, which the true church hath euer mainteined.
Phil. And I my Lord, with the true Church do hold the same in the due ministration of the sacrament: but I desire you, my Lord, there may be made a better conclusion in our first matter, before we enter into any other: for if the Church ⟨p. 1826⟩be proved, we shall soon agree in the rest. In the mean while my Lord of York was turning his book for moe places to help forth his cause.
Phil. And I my Lord, with the true Churche doe holde the same in the due ministration of the sacrament: but I desire you, my Lord, there may be made a better conclusiō in our first matter, before we enter into any other: for if ye Church ⟨p. 1826⟩be proued, we shall soone agree in the rest. In the meane while my Lorde of Yorke was turning his booke for moe places to helpe forth his cause.
York. 1I have found at length a very notable place, which I have looked for all this while, of S. Austine De simplicitate credendi.
Yorke. 1I haue found at length a very notable place, which I haue looked for all this while, of S. Austine De simplicitate credendi.
Chich. It is but folly (my Lord) that your Grace do read him any moe places, for he esteemeth them not.
Chich. It is but folly (my Lorde) that your Grace doe read him any moe places, for he esteemeth them not.
Phil. I esteem them, in as much as they be of force: as your Lordship doth hear me deny no doctors you bring, but only require the true application of them, according to the writers meaning, & as by his own words may be proved.
Phil. I esteeme them, in as muche as they bee of force: as your Lordship doth heare me deny no doctors you bring, but onely require the true application of them, according to the writers meaning, & as by his owne wordes may be proued.
York. I will read him the place, and so make an end. After he had read the sentence▪ he said, that by four special points here S. Austine proveth the catholic church. The first is, by the consent of all nations, the second, by the Apostolic Sea, the third, by universality, & the fourth, by this word Catholic.
Yorke. I will reade him the place, and so make an end. After he had read the sentence▪ he sayde, that by foure speciall poynts here S. Austine proueth the catholick church. The first is, by the consent of all nations, the secōd, by the Apostolick Sea, the third, by vniuersalitie, & the fourth, by this word Catholicke.
Chich. That is a notable place in deed▪ and it please your Grace.
Chich. That is a notable place in deede▪ and it please your Grace.
Phil. I pray you, my Lord, of what church doth S. Austine write the same, of Rome, or not?
York. Yea, he writeth it of the Church of Rome.
Yorke. Yea, he writeth it of the Church of Rome.
Phil. I will lay with your Lordship as much as I can make, it is not so▪ and let the book be seen.
Phil. I will lay with your Lordshippe as much as I can make, it is not so▪ and let the booke be sene.
Bath. What art thou able to lay, that hast nothing.
York Doth he not make mention here of the Apostolic sea, whereby he meaneth Rome?
Yorke Doth he not make mention here of the Apostolicke sea, whereby he meaneth Rome?
Phil. That is very straitly interpreted my lord, as though the Apostolic Sea had been no where else but at Rome. But let it be Rome, and yet shall you never verify the same, unless all the other conditions do go therewith as S. Augustine doth proceed withal, whereof none except the Apostolic sea can now be verified of the Church of Rome. For the faith which that Sea now maintaineth hath not the consent of all nations neither hath had. Besides that, it cannot have the name of Catholic, because it differeth from the Catholic Churches which the Apostles planted, almost in all things.
Phil. That is very straitly interpreted my lord, as though the Apostolicke Sea had bene no where els but at Rome. But let it be Rome, and yet shall you neuer verify ye same, vnlesse all the other conditions do go therewith as S. Augustine doth proceed withal, wherof none except the Apostolicke sea can now bee verified of the Churche of Rome. For the fayth which that Sea now maynteineth hath not the consent of al nations neither hath had. Besides that, it cannot haue the name of Catholick, because it differeth frō the Catholicke Churches which the Apostles planted, almost in all thinges.
York. Nay, he goeth about here to prove the Catholic Church by universality:1 & how can you show your church to be universal fifty, or an hundred years ago?
Yorke. Nay, he goeth about here to proue the Catholicke Church by vniuersality:1 & how can you shew your church to be vniuersall fifty, or an hundreth yeares ago?
Phil. That is not material, neither any thing against S. Augustine. For my church (whereof I am) were to be counted universal, though it were but in x. persons, because it agreeth with the same that the Apostles universally did plant.
Phil. That is not materiall, neither any thing agaynst S. Augustine. For my church (wherof I am) were to be coū ted vniuersal, though it were but in x. persōs, because it agreeth wt the same that the Apostles vniuersally did plant.
York. I perceive you are an obstinate man in your opinion, & will not be taught: wherefore it is but lost labour to talk with you any longer: you are a member to be cut of.
Yorke. I perceiue you are an obstinate man in your opinion, & will not be taught: wherefore it is but lost labour to talke with you any lenger: you are a member to be cut of.
Chichester. I have heard of you before how you troubled the good Bishop of Winchester, and now I see in you that I have heard.
Chichester. I haue heard of you before how you troubled the good Bishop of Winchester, and now I see in you that I haue heard.
Phil. I trust you see no evil in me by this. I desire of you a sure ground to build my faith on, & if you show ne none, I pray you speak not ill of him that meaneth well.
Phil. I trust you see no euill in me by this. I desire of you a sure ground to build my fayth on, & if you shew ne none, I pray you speake not ill of him that meaneth well.