pp. 1760–176224 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
All these articles I thought good here to place together, that as often as hereafter rehearsal shall be of any of them, the reader may have recourse hither, and peruse the same, and not to trouble the story with several repetitions thereof.
ALl these articles I thought good here to place together, that as often as hereafter rehearsall shall be of any of them, ye reader may haue recourse hether, and peruse the same, and not to trouble the storye with seuerall repeticions thereof.
Lincoln. After these Articles were read, the Bishops took counsel togethers. At the last the Bishop of Lincoln said:1 these are the very same Articles which you in open disputation here in the University did maintain and defend. What say you unto the first? I pray you answer affirmatively, or negatively.
Lincolne. After these Articles were read, the Bishoppes tooke counsayle togethers. At the last the Bishop of Lincolne sayde:1 these are the very same Articles whiche you in open disputation here in the Uniuersitie did mayntayn and defend. What say you vnto the first? I praye you aunswere affirmatiuely, or negatiuely.
Ridley. Why my Lord, I supposed your gentleness, had been such, that you would have given me space until to morrow, that upon good advisement, I might bring a determinate answer.
Ridly. Why my Lorde, I supposed your gentlenes, had bene such, that you would haue geuen me space vntyll to morow, that vpon good aduisement, I might bring a determinate aunswere.
Lincoln. Yea M. Ridley, I mean not that your answers now shall be prejudicial to your answers to morrow. I will take your answers at this time, and yet notwithstanding it shall be lawful to you to add, diminish, alter, and change of these answers to morrow what you will.
Lincoln. Yea M. Ridley, I meane not that youre aunsweres nowe shall be preiudiciall to your aunsweres to morow. I will take your aunsweres at this tyme, and yet notwithstāding it shalbe lawfull to you to adde, diminish, alter, and chaunge of these answeres to morow what you will.
Ridley. In deed, in like manner at our last disputations I had many things promised, and few performed.1 It was said that after disputations, I should have a copy thereof, and licence to change mine answers, as I should think good, It was meet also that I should have seen what was written by the Notaries at that time.2 So your Lordship pretended great gentleness in giving me a time, but this gentleness is the same, that Christ had of the high priests: for you, as your Lordship saith, have no power to condemn me, neither at any time to put a man to death, so in like sort the high Priests said, that it was not lawful for them to put any man to death. but committed Christ to Pilate, neither would suffer him ⟨p. 1761⟩to absolve Christ, although he sought all the means therefore that he might. Then spake Doctor Weston, one of the audience.
Ridly. In deede, in like maner at our laste disputations I hadde many thinges promised, and fewe performed.1 It was sayde that after disputations, I shoulde haue a copye thereof, and licence to chaunge myne aunsweres, as I should thinke good, It was meete also that I should haue seene what was writtē by the Notaries at that time.2 So your Lordship pretended great gentlenes in geuyng me a tyme, but this gentlenes is the same, that Christ had of the high priestes: for you, as youre Lordshippe saythe, haue no power to condemne me, neyther at anye tyme to put a man to death, so in like sorte the high Priestes sayd, that it was not lawfull for them to put any man to death. but committed Christ to Pilate, neyther would suffer him ⟨p. 1761⟩to absolue Christ, although he sought all the meanes therfore that he might. Then spake Doctour Weston, one of the audience.
West. What? do you make the king Pilate?
Rid. 1No master Doctor, I do but compare your deeds with Caiaphas his deeds and the high Priests, which would condemn no man to death, as ye will not, and yet would not suffer Pilate to absolve and deliver Christ.
Rid. 1No mayster Doctor, I doe but compare youre deedes with Cayphas his deedes and the high Priestes, whiche woulde condemne no manne to deathe, as ye will not, and yet would not suffer Pilate to absolue and deliuer Christ.
Lincol. M. Ridley, we mind not but that you shall enjoy the benefit of answering to morrow, and will take your answers now as now, to morrow you shall change take out, add, and alter what you will. In the mean season we require you to answer directly to every Article, either affirmatively, or negatively.
Lincol. M. Ridley, we minde not but that you shal enioy the benefite of aunswering to morow, and will take your aunsweres now as now, to morow you shal change take out, adde, and alter what you will. In the meane season we require you to aunswere directly to euery Article, either affirmatiuely, or negatiuely.
Ridley. Seeing you appoint me a time to answer to morrow,1 and yet will take mine answers out of hand, first I require the Notaries, to take and write my protestation, that in no point I acknowledge your authority, or admit you to be my Judges, in that point you are authorised from the Pope. Therefore what soever I shall say or do, I protest, I neither say it, neither do it willingly, thereby to admit the authority of the Pope: & if your Lordship will give me leave, I will show the causes, which moveth me thereunto.
Ridly. Seyng you appoynt me a time to aunswere to morow,1 and yet will take mine aunsweres out of hande, first I require the Notaryes, to take and write my protestation, that in no poynt I acknowledge your authority, or admit you to be my Iudges, in that poynt you are authorised from the Pope. Therefore what soeuer I shall say or doe, I protest, I neither say it, neither do it willingly, thereby to admit the authoritie of the Pope: & if your Lordship will geue me leaue, I wil shew the causes, whiche moueth me thereunto.
Lincol. No M. Ridley, we have instructions to the contrary. We may not suffer you.
Lincol. No M. Ridley, wee haue instructions to the contrary. We may not suffer you.
Linc. No M. Ridley, we may not abuse the hearers ears.
Linc. No M. Ridley, wee may not abuse the hearers eares.
Rid. Why my Lord, suffer me to speak three words.
Rid. Why my Lord, suffer me to speake three words.
Linc. Well M. Ridley, to morrow you shall speak 40. The time is far paste: therefore we require your answer determinately. What say you to the first article? and thereupon rehearsed the same.
Linc. Well M. Ridley, to morow you shall speake 40. The time is farre paste: therefore wee require your aunswere determinately. What say you to the first article? and thereupon rehearsed the same.
Rid. 1My protestation always saved, that by this mine answer I do not condescend, to your authority, in that you are Legate to the Pope, I answer thus: In a sense the first article is true, and in a sense it is false: for if you take really for verè, for spiritually by grace and efficacy, then is it true that the natural body and blood of Christ is in the sacrament verè & realiter, in deed and really: but if you take these terms so grossly, that you would conclude thereby a natural body having motion, to be contained under the forms of bread and wine verè & realiter, then really is not the body and blood of Christ in the Sacrament, no more then the holy Ghost is in the element of water in our Baptism. Because this answer was not understood, the Notaries wist not how to note it: wherefore the Bishop of Lincoln willed him to answer either affirmatively, or negatively, either to grant the Article, or to deny it.
Rid. 1My protestation alwaies saued, that by this mine aunswere I do not condescend, to your authoritie, in that you are Legate to the Pope, I aunswere thus: In a sense the first article is true, and in a sense it is false: for if you take really for verè, for spiritually by grace and efficacye, then is it true that the naturall body and bloud of Christe is in the sacrament verè & realiter, in deede and really: but if you take these termes so grossely, that you woulde conclude thereby a naturall body hauing motion, to be contayned vnder the formes of bread and wine verè & realiter, then really is not the body and bloud of Christ in the Sacrament, no more then the holy Ghost is in the element of water in our Baptisme. Because this aunswere was not vnderstoode, the Notaries wist not how to note it: wherfore the Bishop of Lincolne willed him to aunswere either affirmatiuely, or negatiuely, either to graunt the Article, or to deny it.
Rid. My Lord, you know that where any equivocation (which is a word having two significations) is, except distinction be given, no direct answer can be made: for it is one of Aristotle's fallacies, containing two questions under one, the which cannot be satisfied with one answer. For both you and I agree herein, that in the sacrament is the very true and natural body and blood of Christ, even that which was borne of the Virgin Mary,1 which ascended into heaven, which sitteth on the right hand of God the Father, which shall come from thence to judge the quick and the dead, only we differ in modo:2 in the way and manner of being: we confess all one thing to be in the sacrament, and dissent in the manner of being there. I being fully by Gods word thereunto persuaded, confess Christs natural body to be in the sacrament in deed by spirit and grace, because that whosoever receiveth worthily that bread and wine, receiveth effectually Christs body and drinketh his blood, that is, he is, made effectually partaker of his Passion: and you make a grosser kind of being, enclosing a natural, a lively and moving body under the shape or form of bread and wine. Now, this difference considered, to the question thus I answer:3 that in the sacrament of the altar is the natural body and blood of Christ verè & realiter, in deed and really, if you take these terms in deed and really for spiritually by grace and efficacy: for so every worthy receiver receiveth the very true body of Christ: but if you mean really and in deed, so that thereby you would include a lively and a movable body under the forms of bread and wine, then in that sense is not Christs body in the sacrament really and in deed. This answer taken and penned of the Notaries, the Bishop of Lincoln proposed the second question or Article. To whom he answered.
Rid. My Lorde, you know that where anye aequiuocation (whiche is a woorde hauyng two significations) is, excepte distinction bee geuen, no direct aunswere can bee made: for it is one of Aristotles fallacies, containing two questions vnder one, the whiche cannot bee satisfied with one aunswere. For both you and I agree herein, that in the sacrament is the verye true and naturall bodye and bloud of Christ, euen that whiche was borne of the Uirgine Marye,1
Rid. Always my protestation reserved, I answer thus: that in the sacrament is a certain change in the•r the Bread which was before was common bread, is now made a lively representation of Christs Body,1 and not only a figure, but effectually representeth his body, that even as the mortal body was nourished by that visible bread, so is the internal soul fed with the heavenly food of Christs body, which the eyes of faith seethe, as the bodily eyes seeth only bread. Such a sacramental mutation I grant to be in the bread and wine, which truly is no small change, but such a change as no mo tall man can make but only that omnipotency of Christs word. ¶Then the Bishop of Lincoln willed him to answer directly, either affirmatively or negatively, without further declaration of the matter. Then he answered:
Rid. Alwayes my protestation reserued, I aunswere thus: that in the sacrament is a certayne chaunge in the•r ye Bread whiche was before was common bread, is nowe made a liuely representation of Christes Bodye,1 and not onely a figure, but effectuously representeth his body, that euen as the mortall bodye was nourished by that visible bread, so is the internall soule fed with the heauenly foode of Christes body, whiche the eyes of faythe seethe, as the bodily eyes seeth onely breade. Such a sacramental mutation I graunt to be in the bread and wyne, whiche truely is no small chaunge, but suche a chaunge as no mo tall man can make but onely that omnipotencie of Chrystes worde. ¶Then the Byshoppe of Lincolne willed hym to answere directly, eyther affirmatiuely or negatiuely, without further declaration of the matter. Then hee aunswered:
Rid. That notwithstanding this sacramental mutation of the which he spake,1 and all the Doctors confessed the true substance and nature of bread and wine remaineth, with the which the body is in like sort nourished as the soul by grace and spirit with the body of Christ. Even so in Baptism the body is washed with the visible water, and the soul is cleansed from all filth by the invisible holy Ghost, and yet the water ceaseth not to be water but keepeth the nature of water still: In like sort in the sacrament of the Lords supper the bread ceaseth not to be bread, Then the Notaries penned, that he answered affirmatively to the second article. The Bishop of Lincoln declared a difference between the sacrament of the altar and Baptism,2 because that Christ said not by the water this is the holy Ghost, as he did by the bread: this is my body. Then master Ridley recited saint Austen, which conferred both the sacraments the one with the other: but the Bishop of Lincoln notwithstanding thereupon recited the third article, and required a direct answer. To whom Ridley said.
Rid. That notwithstanding this sacramentall mutation of the whiche he spake,1 and all the Doctours confessed the true substaunce and nature of bread and wine remaineth, with the whiche the bodye is in like sorte nourished as the soule by grace and spirite with the body of Chryste. Euen so in Baptisme the body is washed with the visible water, and the soule is clensed from all filth by the inuisible holy Ghost, and yet the water ceaseth not to be water but keepeth the nature of water still: In like sort in the sacrament of the Lordes supper the bread ceaseth not to bee bread, Then the Notaryes penned, that he aunswered affirmatiuely to the second article. The Byshop of Lincolne declared a difference betweene the sacramente of the altar and Baptisme,2 because that Chryste sayde not by the water this is the holy Ghost, as he did by the bread: thys is my body. Then mayster Ridley recited saynct Austen, whiche conferred both the sacramentes the one with the other: but the Byshoppe of Lincolne notwithstanding therevpon recited the third article, and required a directe aunswere. To whom Ridley sayd.
Rid. Christ as saint Paul writeth, made one perfect sacrifice for the sins of the whole world, neither can any man reiterate that sacrifice of his,1 and yet is the Communion an acceptable sacrifice to God of praise and thanksgiving: but to say that thereby sins are taken away (which wholly and perfectly was done by Christs passion, of the which the Communion is only a memory) that is a great derogation of the merits of Christs passion:2 for the sacrament was instituted that we receiving it, and thereby recognising and remembering his Passion, should be partakers of the merits of the same. For otherwise doth this sacrament take upon it the office of Christs Passion, whereby it might follow that Christ dyed in vain. ¶The Notaries penned this his answer to be affirmatively. Then said the Bishop of Lincoln:
Rid. Chryst as saynct Paule wryteth, made one perfecte sacrifice for the sinnes of the whole worlde, neyther can anye man reiterate that sacrifice of his,1 and yet is the Communion an acceptable sacrifice to God of prayse and thanksgeuing: but to say that thereby sinnes are taken away (whiche wholy and perfectly was done by Christes passion, of the whiche the Communion is onely a memory) that is a great derogation of the merites of Chrystes passion:2 for the sacrament was instituted that wee receyuing it, and thereby recognising and remembryng hys Passion, shoulde be partakers of the merites of the same. For otherwise doth this sacrament take vpon it the office of Christes Passion, whereby it might follow that Christe dyed in vayne. ¶The Notaryes penned this hys aunswere to be affirmatiuely. Then sayd the Byshop of Lincolne:
Lin. In deed as you allege out of Saint Paul, Christ made one perfect oblation for all the whole world, that is, that bloody sacrifice upon the cross:1 yet nevertheless he hath left this sacrifice, but not bloody, in the remembrance of that, by the which sins are forgiven: the which is no derogation of Christs Passion. ¶Then recited the Bishop of Lincoln the fourth article. To the which M. Ridley answered:
Lin. In deede as you alledge out of Sayncte Paule, Christ made one perfecte oblation for all the whole world, that is, that bloudy sacrifice vpon the crosse:1 yet neuerthelesse he hath lefte this sacrifice, but not bloudy, in the remembraunce of that, by the whiche sinnes are forgeuen: the whiche is no derogation of Christes Passion. ¶Then recited the Byshop of Lincolne the fourth article. To the which M. Ridley aunswered:
Rid. That in some part the fourth was true, & in some part false, true in that those his assertions were condemned as heresies, although unjustly:1 false in that it was said they were condemned scientia scholastica, in that the disputations were in such sort ordered, that it was far from any school act. ¶This answer penned of the Notaries, the Bishop of Lincoln rehearsed the fifth Article. To the which he answered:
Rid. That in some part the fourth was true, & in some parte false, true in yt those hys assertions were condemned as heresies, although vniustly:1 false in that it was sayde they were condemned scientia scholastica, in that the disputations were in suche sorte ordered, that it was farre from any schole acte. ¶This aunswere penned of the Notaryes, the Byshop of Lincolne rehearsed the fift Article. To the whiche he aunswered:
Rid. That the premisses were in such sort true, as in these his answers he had declared. Whether that all men spake evil of them he knew not, in that he came not so much abroad to hear what every man reported. ¶This answer also written of the Notaries, the bishop of Lincoln said:
Rid. That the premisses were in suche sorte true, as in these his aunsweres he had declared. Whether that al men spake euill of them he knew not, in that hee came not so much abroad to heare what euery man reported. ¶This aunswere also written of the Notaryes, the bishop of Lincolne sayde:
Lin. To morrow at eight of the clock you shall appear before us in S. Mary's Church,1 and then because we cannot well agree upon your answer to the first article (for it was long before he was understood) if it will please you to write your answer, you shall have pen, ink, and paper, & books such as you shall require: but if you write any thing saving your answers to these Articles, we will not receive it: so he charging ⟨p. 1762⟩the Major with him, declaring also to the Major that he should suffer him to have pen and ink dismissed M. Ridley, and sent for Master Latimer, who being brought to the Divinity School, there tarried till they called for him.
Lin. To morow at eyght of the clocke you shall appeare before vs in S. Maryes Churche,1 and then because wee cannot well agree vpon your aunswere to the first article (for it was long before hee was vnderstoode) if it wyll please you to wryte youre aunswere, you shall haue penne, inke, and paper, & bookes suche as you shall require: but if you wryte any thing sauing your aunswers to these Articles, wee will not receaue it: so hee charging ⟨p. 1762⟩the Maior with him, declaryng also to the Maior that he shoulde suffer hym to haue penne and inke dimissed M. Ridley, and sent for Master Latimer, who being brought to the Diuinitie Schole, there taryed tyll they called for hym.