Text
1,075 passagespart 17 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1,075 passagespart 17 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
All these, & a great many more (as the Popes law testifieth) were the 1children of subdeacons, deacons, and Priests, and have borne rule in the Church of Rome. Wherefore I marvel very fore, that men do reckon it so new learning, that priests should have wives, seeing, that it standeth with Gods holy word, with the saying of the old doctors, with the determination of counsels, with yt Emperors law, and also with yt Popes old decrees.
All these, & a great many more (as the Popes lawe testifieth) were the 1children of subdeacons, deacons, and Priestes, and haue borne rule in the Church of Rome. Wherefore I meruayle very fore, that men doe recken it so new learning, that priests should haue wiues, séeing, that it standeth with Gods holy word, with the saying of the olde doctours, with the determination of counsels, with yt Emperours lawe, and also with yt Popes olde decrées.
Moreover, Christs holy Apostles, and many other holy men, since their days, have lived in the holy estate of matrimony. Finally, there hath been many holy men, and also holy women borne in the wedlock of Priests.
Moreouer, Christes holy Apostels, and many other holy men, since their dayes, haue liued in the holy estate of matrymony. Finally, there hath been many holy men, and also holy women borne in the wedlocke of Priestes.
By what reason now can, or will men damn all these things, that be of so great authority? If men will hear neither God nor man, nor yet no good reason, what need men then so much to speak of learning? seeing that they will hear nothing, but that they alonely judge good? Truly this is a great high mind of men, thus wrongfully to condemn other men for heretics, having so good learning for them: and yet they themselves are grounded only of their own sensual mind, having no learning, nor reason for them. But I will put this matter to Gods judgement. And let not men doubt (if they believe there is a God) but that God will be a revenger of such wrongful violence, as men do use in this case, both against him and against all his blessed company of Saints. But yet for to do men pleasure, and that they might be persuaded if it were possible, I will declare unto them, how that we do find old monuments, testifying clearly, that priests were in peaceable possession of matrimony, & their children gotten in that same matrimony were admitted to spiritual benefices.
By what reasō now can, or wil mē damne all these thynges, that bée of so great auctoritie? If men wyll heare neyther God nor mā, nor yet no good reason, what néede men then so much to speake of learning? séeing that they wyll heare nothyng, but that they alonely iudge good? Truely this is a great high minde of mē, thus wrongfully to condemne other men for heretikes, hauyng so good learnyng for them: and yet they themselues are grounded onely of their owne sensuall mynde, hauyng no learnyng, nor reason for them. But I wyll put this matter to Gods iudgement. And let not men doubt (if they béeléeue there is a God) but that God wyll bée a reuenger of such wrongfull violence, as men doe vse in thys case, both agaynst hym and agaynst all his blessed company of Saintes. But yet for to doe men pleasure, and that they myght bée perswaded if it were possible, I will declare vnto them, how yt wée doe finde old monuments, testifiyng clearely, that priests were in peaceable possessiō of matrimony, & their childrē gottē in that same matrimony were admitted to spiritual benefices.
In the time of Pope Alexander yt third, there was a controversy for the patronage of a benefice between the prior of Plympton in Devonshire, and one John de Valletorda. Now were there deputed judges, Richard Archbishop of Canterbury, & Roger Bishop of Winchester, before whom the prior of Plympton proved his patronage, by the reason that ⟨p. 327⟩he was in possession, and had given it unto divers persons. First (he saith) there was a Priest of Plympton called Alpheghe, which had by yt gift of the prior of Plympton, the benefice of Sutton, which is now called Plymouth. This Alpheghe had a son called Sadda, which had also the benefice after his father. And after Sadda, was there an other priest called Alnodus, which had the benefice likewise. This Alnodus had a son called Robert Dunprust, which after the decease of his father Alnode had also the same benefice. And after this Robert Dunpru•t, William Bacon his son, enjoyed the benefice likewise. Here men may see, that it is neither so new learning, nor yet so long ago since priests had lawful wives.
In the tyme of Pope Alexander yt thirde, there was a controuersie for the patronage of a benefice betwéene the pryor of Plimptō in Deuenshyre, and one Iohn de Ʋalletorda. Now were there deputed iudges, Rychard Archbyshop of Caunterbury, & Roger Byshop of Wynchester, béefore whome the pryor of Plympton prooued his patronage, by the reason that ⟨p. 327⟩hée was in possession, and had géeuen it vnto diuers persons. Fyrst (hée sayth) there was a Priest of Plymptō called Alpheghe, which had by yt gyft of the pryor of Plympton, the benefice of Sutton, which is now called Plymmouth. This Alpheghe had a sonne cauled Sadda, which had also the benefice after hys father. And after Sadda, was there an other priest cauled Alnodus, which had the benefice likewyse. This Alnodus had a sonne called Robert Dunprust, which after the discease of his father Alnode had also the same benefice. And after thys Robert Dunpru•t, William Bacon hys sonne, enioyed the benefice lykewyse. Here men may see, that it is neyther so new learnyng, nor yet so long agoe since priestes had lawful wyues.
Moreover, I read in our own Chronicles, that in the time of king 1Henry the iij. which reigned yt year of our Lord 1101. priests might lawfully marry wives, in so much that Anselm than Archbishop of Canterbury in a Sean that he held at London, did make a decree, that priests should forsake their wives, the which was both against Gods law, and mans. For the text of our Master Christ is cleare. Quos deus coniunxit, Homo non seperet. Mark these two words, Deus, and Homo. And how much the one passeth the other.
Moreouer, I reade in our owne Chronicles, that in the tyme of kyng 1Henry the iij. which raygned yt yeare of our Lord 1101. priestes myght lawfully marry wiues, in so much yt Anseline than Archbyshop of Caunterbury in a Seane that hée helde at London, did make a decrée, yt priestes should forsake their wiues, the which was both agaynst Gods lawe, and mans. For the texte of our Mayster Christ is cleare. Quos deus coniunxit, Homo non seperet. Marke these two wordes, Deus, and Homo. And howe much the one passeth the other.
Farthermore, the Pope himself hath not greatly regarded Priests chastity, if he might get any money for dispensations, in the which thing he could not have dispensed, if it had been of Gods law. And if it be but but mans law, what charity is in the Pope to compel men so sore to keep it, seeing that it is so great daū ger unto priests, and that so many souls been lost thorough it? Yea, what tyranny is in him, thus cruelly to kill men for breaking alonely of his commandment, the which is not in their power to keep? To our purpose, the Pope hath often times dispensed both with Priests, and religious men for their vow, & hath given them licence to marry.
Farthermore, the Pope hymselfe hath not greatly regarded Priestes chastitie, if hée myght get any money for dispensations, in the which thyng hée coulde not haue dispēsed, if it had béene of Gods lawe. And if it bée but but mans lawe, what charitie is in the Pope to compell men so sore to kéepe it, séeyng that it is so great daū ger vnto priestes, and that so many soules béene lost thorough it? Yea, what tyranny is in hym, thus cruelly to kill men for breakyng alonely of hys commaundement, the which is not in their power to kéepe? To our purpose, the Pope hath often tymes dispensed both wyth Priestes, and religious men for their vowe, & hath géeuen them licence to marry.
It is not unknown to many men 1that there was an Abbot of Reading, whom men for his perfect living, called Abbot Sancte. This man being in danger of a certain disease, 2by the reason he had no wife, sent unto the pope, desiring him to dispense with him for his vow, and yt pope dispensed with him, and gave him licence to marry a wife, but under a condition that it should be secretly done, and not In facie ecclesie. By this men may see, that the Pope himself holdeth not so much of priests chastity: for then he would not regard more money, then it. And if the pope may dispense with this Abbot for avoiding of a disease corporal: how much more ought he now to dispense with priests: seeing there be so many souls in danger? Yea, and also the order of priesthood is sore defamed and slandered, by the reason that priests hath no wives.
It is not vnknowen to many men 1that there was an Abbot of Reading, whom men for his perfecte lyuinge, called Abbot Sancte. This man béeyng in daunger of a certayne disease, 2by the reason hée had no wyfe, sente vnto the pope, desiring hym to dispense wyth hym for hys vowe, and yt pope dispensed wyth hym, and gaue hym licence to marry a wyfe, but vnder a condition that it shoulde bée secretly done, and not In facie ecclesie. By this men may sée, that the Pope himself holdeth not so much of priests chastitie: for then hée woulde not regarde more money, then it. And if the pope may dispence wyth thys Abbot for auoyding of a disease corporall: how much more ought hée now to dispense with priestes: séeing there bée so many soules in daunger? Yea, and also the order of priesthoode is sore defamed and sclaundered, by the reasō that priestes hath no wyues.
Moreover, we do read, that 1pope Celestine the third, did dispense with a Nun, whose name was called Constantia, King Rogers daughter of Cecil, and gave her licence to 2marry with Henry yt Emperor, the sixth of that name. This was about yt year of our Lord. 1186. So that men may perceive how the pope doth not greatly regard the vow of his spirituality, if any thing may be gotten, to pay for a dispensation. And it will not help to say, that the pope did dispense with this woman for a common wealth. For the stories maketh mention that the pope dispensed with him under a condition, that he should pay him a yearly pension for the kingdom of Cecil, and should recover it of his own charges, out of the hands of Tancredus, which was then in possession of it. And because that he might have the better title to the kingdom, he gave him the only daughter of Cecil. So that yt pope did it not for a common wealth, but for his own lucre. But now grant that it were for▪ a common wealth, therefore, first it was not Gods commandment, that priests should live sole. For gods word giveth no place ⟨p. 328⟩to no common wealth. And if y• pope did then dispense for a common wealth? why doth he not now dispense for avoiding of fornication, in so many innumerable priests? Doth not men reckon it for a common wealth to expel fornication, & all occasions thereunto? But now there is no common wealth to be regarded, because there is no shining gold offered. But at yt 3least ways me thinketh that priests which marry, be very far from heresy: for it is neither against Gods law, nor yet against the common wealth.
Moreouer, wée doe reade, that 1pope Celestine the third, did dispense with a Nunne, whose name was cauled Constatia, Kyng Rogers daughter of Cecyll, and gaue her licence to 2marry with Henry yt Emperour, the sixt of that name. This was about yt yeare of our Lorde. 1186. So that mē may perceaue how the pope doth not greatly regarde the vowe of hys spiritualtie, if any thing may bée gotten, to pay for a dispensation. And it wil not helpe to say, that the pope did dispense with this woman for a common wealth. For the stories maketh mention that the pope dispēsed with him vnder a cōdition, that hée should paye hym a yearely pencion for the kyngdome of Cecyll, and should recouer it of his owne charges, out of the handes of Tancredus, which was then in possession of it. And béecause that hée myght haue the better title to the kyngdome, hée gaue hym the onely daughter of Cecill. So that yt pope did it not for a common wealth, but for his owne lucre. But now graunt that it were for▪ a common wealth, therefore, first it was not Gods commaundemēt, that priestes should liue sole. For gods word géeueth no place ⟨p. 328⟩to no common wealth. And if y• pope did then dispence for a cōmō wealth? why doth hée not now dispence for auoyding of fornication, in so many innumerable priestes? Doth not mē recken it for a common wealth to expell fornication, & all occasions therevnto? But now there is no commō wealth to bée regarded, béecause there is no shyning golde offered. But at yt 3least wayes mée thinketh that priestes which marry, bée very farre from heresie: for it is neyther agaynst Gods lawe, nor yet agaynst the common wealth.
Here were many examples to be brought in, how the pope hath dispensed both with Monks, Friars, and Nuns, the which I will pass over, and will she we as near as I can out out of Chronicles, how long▪ it is, that the pope hath gone about to bring in the vow of chastity. Doctor Eckius doth say, that Calixtus primus did first make the statute, that priests should vow chastity, b•t that is false. For all Chronicles beareth witness, that priests had wives in the Council, of Nicene, the which was almost an hundred years after Calixtus days. Wherefore it can not be supposed, that yt statute was made before the Council of Nicene. But authentical histories doth make mention, that Nicholas the first, which was 1Bishop of Rome, the year of our Lord 860. did go about this thing: but he could not bring it to pass by the reason of an holy man S. Huldericke, Episcopus Augustensis, the which wrote a very sharp Epistle against him, reproving him sore, because he would compel priests to vow chastity. His words be these. Thou hast not swerved a little from discretion, that where as thou oughtest to have counselled priests to chastity, thou hast with a Lordly violence compelled them to it. Is not this after the judgement of all wise men, a 2great violence, when that thou against the institution of the Gospel, and against the decree of the holy ghost, wilt compel men to observe thy private decree? &c. He reciteth also against the Bishop of Rome all those same scriptures, that I have brought herein my book of this matter, and al•o certain of the counsels, to that purpose, that I have brought them. So that men ought not to think, that I am the first, that thus hath understand the Scriptures, nor yet the first, that hath spoken against priests vows.
Here were many examples to bée brought in, how the pope hath dispensed both with Monkes, Friers, and Nunnes, the which I will passe ouer, and will she we as neare as I can out out of Chronicles, how lōg▪ it is, that the pope hath gone about to bryng in the vow of chastitie. Doctour Eckius doth say, that Calixtus primus dyd firste make the statute, that priestes should vow chastitie, b•t that is false. For all Chronicles beareth witnesse, that priestes had wyues in the Councell, of Nicene, the which was almost an hundreth yeares after Calixtus dayes. Wherfore it can not bée supposed, that yt statute was made béefore the Councell of Nicene. But authenticall hystories doth make mention, that Nicholas the first, whiche was 1Byshop of Rome, the yeare of our Lord 860. did goe about this thyng: but hée could not bryng it to passe by the reason of an holy man S. Huldericke, Episcopus Augustensis, the which wrote a very sharpe Epistle agaynst hym, reproouyng hym sore, bycause hée would compell priestes to vow chastitie. Hys woords bée these. Thou hast not swarued a litle from discretion, yt where as thou oughtest to haue counsayled priestes to chastitie, thou hast with a Lordly violence compelled them to it. Is not this after the iudgement of all wise men, a 2great violence, whē that thou agaynst the institution of the Gospell, and agaynst ye decrée of the holy ghost, wilt compell men to obserue thy priuate decrée? &c. Hée reciteth also agaynst ye Byshop of Rome all those same scriptures, that I haue brought herein my booke of this matter, and al•o certain of the counsels, to that purpose, that I haue brought them. So that men ought not to thinke, that I am the first, that thus hath vnderstande the Scriptures, nor yet the first, that hath spoken agaynst priestes vowes.
Note also how this holy man saith, that priests ought to be admonished, & counselled to chastity, but not compelled. For that (saith he) is a great 1violence, and against Christs holy Gospel, and yt blessed spirit of God. These be as vehement words as I have spoken. For out of these words men may gather, that it is not far from heresy to compel priests to vow chastity. This holy man proceedeth farther with yt Bishop of Rome, and telleth a fact of S. Gregory, the which went about to compel priests to vow chastity.
Note also how this holy mā sayth, that priests ought to bée admonyshed, & counselled to chastitie, but not compelled. For that (sayth hée) is a great 1violence, and agaynst Christes holy Gospell, and yt blessed spirite of God. These bée as vehement wordes as I haue spokē. For out of these woordes men may gather, that it is not farre from heresie to compell priestes to vow chastitie. This holy man procéedeth farther with yt Bishop of Rome, and telleth a fact of S. Gregory, the which went about to compell priestes to vow chastitie.
Upon a day S. Gregory sent unto his ponds for fish, and in the nets 1that they fished withal, were brought up above six thousand young children's heads, the which thing, when S. Gregory saw, stroke him sore to the hart, & he was very heavy of that sight, and perceived anon, that his decree, that he made for priester chastity, was the occasion of this great murder: In that that priests could not live sole, nor yet they durst not avow their children, for fear of the decree. And so for safeguard of their honesty, they fell into a fearful, and abominable sin, to kill their own children. And for this cause S. Gregory (saith this holy Bishop) did revoke his decree again, and did greatly 2allow the saying of the Apostle: Iis better to marry then to burn. Adding unto it of his own: It is better to marry then to give occasion to murder.
Vpon a day S. Gregory sent vnto hys pondes for fish, and in the nettes 1that they fished withall, were brought vp aboue sixe thousand young childrens heades, the which thyng, when S. Gregory saw, stroke hym sore to the hart, & hée was very heauy of that sight, and perceyued anone, that hys decrée, that hée made for priester chastitie, was the occasion of this great murther: In that that priestes could not lyue sole, nor yet they durst not auow theyr children, for feare of the decrée. And so for sauegarde of theyr honesty, they fell into a fearefull, and abhominable sinne, to kyll theyr own children. And for this cause S. Gregory (sayth this holy Byshop) dyd reuoke hys decrée agayn, and did greattly 2alow the saying of the Apostle: Iis better to marry then to burne. Addyng vnto it of hys owne: It is better to marry then to geue occasion to murther.
Here note good reader, what a terrible, and a fearfully example this is? Is not this a piteous case, that so many thousands innocents be thus slain? When shall the chastity keeping of all the priests in the world be an occasion of so great goodness, as ⟨p. 329⟩the law of chastity hath been hereof mischief? Alas is there no pity in •ens hearts? that are nothing moved, when they read such horrible facts in holy mens writings? Or do men think, that there is no mischief now in our days done, by the reason that priests are compelled to chastity? If men think that there come any mischief by the reason of it, how can men reckon to avoid Gods vengeance, that will so stiffly and strongly maintain the same?
Here note good reader, what a terrible, and a fearefully example this is? Is not this a piteous case, that so many thousandes innocētes bée thus slayne? When shall the chastitie keepyng of all the priestes in the worlde bée an occasion of so great goodnes, as ⟨p. 329⟩the law of chastitie hath béene hereof mischief? Alas is there no pyty in •ēs hartes? that are nothyng moued, whē they read such horrible factes in holy mens writyngs? Or doe men thinke, that there is no mischief now in our dayes done, by the reason that priests are compelled to chastitie? If men thinke that there come any mischiefe by the reason of it, how can men recken to auoyde Gods vengeaūce, that will so stifly and strongly mayntayne the same?
I have been informed of credible persons, the which if need were, I could yet bring forth, that in a place of Religion within this few years, there was a religious man, that did 1get a woman with child, the which woman was brought a bed in the brothers chamber of a fair son. This child was Christened in the same chamber, and as soon as it was christened, he brake the neck of it, and buried it in the night, in the Churchyard. 2This is the trueth, I can prove it. Is not this a terrible thing? doth not nature abhor this? And yet men had rather here this abominableness, than for to release a little of their own will. But oh Lord God, how strictly shalt thou punish this?
I haue béene informed of credible persons, the whiche if néede were, I could yet bryng foorth, that in a place of Religion within this fewe yeares, there was a religious man, that dyd 1get a woman with child, the whiche woman was brought a bed in the brothers chamber of a fayre sonne. This child was Christened in the same chā ber, and as soone as it was christened, hée brake the necke of it, and buryed it in the night, in the Churcheyarde. 2This is the trueth, I cā prooue it. Is not this a terrible thyng? dooth not nature abhorre this? And yet men had rather here this abhominablenes, thē for to release a litle of theyr own will. But oh Lorde God, howe streightly shalt thou punish this?
It is not yet out of yt mind of man, sins that an honest man lost his daughter, by the reason that a priest defiled 1her, the which (because he would not be dishonested) killed the maid privily, and afterward cast her into a well. If men will not be moved at this? and such like other facts? I can not tell what will move them?
It is not yet out of yt minde of mā, sinnes yt an honest man lost his daughter, by the reason that a priest defiled 1her, the which (bycause hée would not bée dishonested) kylled the mayde priuely, and afterwarde cast her into a well. If men will not bée moued at this? and such lyke other factes? I can not tell what will moue them?
I could recite a great many of abominable, and detestable facts, if I were not more ashamed to tell them, then priests hath been to do them. Neither will I recite how shamefully that mens daughters, mens wives, mens servants hath been, and are daily cast away, by the▪ reason that priests are so hot of courage, and can not keep their chastity. Would it not abhor a Christen man, to hear tell of the innumerable bawds, that are made by yt reason that priests can not live chaste? What a piteous case is it to see so many young men cast away? th• which doth see daily their masters unclean living? Here were many 1things to be recited, but honesty compelleth me to pass them over. But I think there is no good man, but he will think as much in him self, as I either would say, or can say.
I could recite a great many of abhominable, and detestable factes, if I were not more ashamed to tell them, then priestes hath béene to doe them. Neither will I recite how shamefully that mens daughters, mens wyues, mens seruauntes hath béene, and are dayly cast awaye, by the▪ reason that priestes are so hoate of courage, and can not kéepe theyr chastitie. Would it not abhorre a Christen mā, to heare tell of the innumerable baudes, that are made by yt reason yt priests cā not lyue chaste? What a petious case is it to sée so many young men cast away? th• whiche doth sée dayly their maisters vncleane liuyng? Here were many 1thynges to bée recited, but honesty compelleth me to passe thē ouer. But I thinke there is no good man, but hée will thinke as much in hym selfe, as I either would say, or can say.
I could tell, if If I would, the occasion why that those Cardinals of Rome, which keepeth whores, be noted of the common people to be of the best sort of Cardinals? But I will pass it over. Nevertheless it grieveth me a little, that I may not somewhat open my hart. But this I promise them, if 1any of these projectors of this filthy chastity doth take in hand to defend it against me, I will not be ashamed to write•, that they have not been ashamed to do. Nor I will not keep secrete how certain bishops of England, and also of other countries doth let whores to farm unto priests. And all because they will not suffer them to marry. Yet hear will I tell you one pretty tale.
I could tell, if If I would, the occasion why yt those Cardinals of Rome, which kéepeth whores, bée noted of the common people to bée of the best sort of Cardinals? But I will passe it ouer. Neuertheles it gréeueth mée a lyttell, that I may not somewhat opē my hart. But this I promyse them, if 1any of these proiectours of this fylthy chastitie doth take in hand to defende it agaynst mée, I will not bée ashamed to write•, that they haue not béene ashamed to doe. Nor I will not kéepe secrete how certayne byshops of England, and also of other countries doth let whores to ferme vnto priests. And all béecause they will not suffer them to marry. Yet heare will I tell you one prety tale.
There is a bishop living at this same day in Germany, which had 1need of a great some of money (I could tell his name if I would) this bishop called unto him a gentleman, a great friend of his, which smelled a little of the new learning, so called. 2Unto this man he made his complaint how that he must needs make shift shortly for a great some of money, desiring him both to help him, and also of his counsel. This man said unto him, if he would follow his coū sell, he would shortly help him. The 3bishop was very glad, and granted to follow his counsel. Then said the gentleman.
There is a byshop lyuyng at this same day in Germanye, which had 1néede of a great some of money (I could tell his name if I would) this byshop called vnto hym a gentilman, a great frend of his, which smelled a littell of the new learning, so called. 2Ʋnto this mā hée made his complaint how that hee must néedes make shifte shortly for a great somme of money, desyring hym both to helpe hym, and also of his counsell. This man sayde vnto hym, if hée would folow his coū sell, hée would shortly helpe him. The 3byshop was very glad, and graūted to folowe his counsell. Then sayde the gentylman.
My Lord, your Lordship shall give a strait commandment, that all your Priests within your diocese, shall put away their whores within this two months, under the pain of heresy at the least. After this, your Lordship shall send. ij. of your counsellors, that be known to be greatly in your favour, to handle with the priests, in their own names, for to ⟨p. 330⟩take up this matter, between your Lordship and them. But under this condition, that the priests shall grant unto them a certain some of money and they shall promise the priests, that they will bring it to pass, that your Lordship (notwithstanding your strait commandment) shall be contented to suffer them to live, as they have done in times past, and after the old custom of the Church. The bishop 1was contented with this counsel, & incontinent gave out yt commandment, and afterward sent out two of his best friends, privily to treat with the Priests in their names, but not in his. For he would not be known of it, because he had vowed chastity.
My Lord, your Lordship shall geue a strayte commaundement, that all your Priestes within your diocese, shall put away their whores within this two monethes, vnder the payne of heresye at the least. After this, your Lordship shall send. ij. of your coūsellers, that bée knowen to bée greately in your fauour, to handle with the priestes, in their owne names, for to ⟨p. 330⟩take vp thys matter, betwéene your Lordeship and them. But vnder this condition, that the priests shall graūt vnto them a certayne some of money and they shall promise the priestes, yt they will bring it to passe, that your Lordship (notwithstāding your strait commaundement) shall bée contented to suffer them to liue, as they haue done in tymes past, and after the olde custome of the Church. The byshop 1was contented with this counsell, & incontinent gaue out yt commaundement, and afterward sent out two of his best frendes, priuelye to treate with the Priestes in their names, but not in his. For hée woulde not bée knowen of it, because hée had vowed chastitie.
But what think you, that these two men did gather in this one bishopric, within yt space of ij. months? Verily •xx. M. guyldens, the which money the bishop received very devoutly, and thought it not against the vow of chastity. What shall men say to these mens conscience? that will not stick to burn a poor priest, that marrieth a wife? but yet, they will receive. xx. M. guyldens to maintain open whoredom. O lord God thou knowest this, & yet doubtless thou sufferest it. And all because they should have space, and respite to amend, unto which, God give them grace. Amen.
But what thinke you, that these two mē did gather in this one byshoppricke, within yt space of ij. moneths? Ʋerely •xx. M. guyldens, the which money the byshop receiued very deuoutly, and thought it not against the vowe of chastitie. What shall men say to these mens conscience? that will not sticke to burne a poore priest, that maryeth a wife? but yet, they will receyue. xx. M. guyldens to mayntayne open whoredome. O lord God thou knowest this, & yet doubtles thou sufferest it. And all béecause they should haue space, and respite to amende, vnto which, God geue them grace. Amen.
But again to our purpose: men may perceive that this holy bishop Hulderyke was against the pope, & did also allow my doctrine, and declare that S. Gregory did repent him 1of yt statute that he had made for priests •astitie. Wherefore I conclude here yet again, that Gods holy word, old doctors, holy counsels, the Emperors law, old decrees of the Church, the practice of the holy Apostles, the living of holy men, Gods law, and mans law, nature & reason, doth allow this article of mine. Wherefore I trust no good nor reasonable man, will withstand me, in this case.
But agayne to our purpose: men may perceaue that this holy byshop Hulderyke was agaynst the pope, & dyd also alowe my doctrine, and declare that S. Gregorie did repēt him 1of yt statute yt hée had made for priests •astitie. Wherefore I conclude here yet agayne, that Gods holy worde, olde doctours, holy counselles, the Emperours lawe, olde decrées of the Church, the practice of the holy Apostels, the lyuing of holy men, Gods lawe, and mans lawe, nature & reason, doth alowe this article of myne. Wherefore I trust no good nor reasonable man, will withstand mée, in this case.
There runneth a great voice of 1me, that I have married a wife, and for that cause men doth reckon that I will something prove my wit, and also stretch my learning, to maintain that priests might have wives. But 2the very trueth is before God, & man that I have no wife, •or never went about to marry: I thank God of his grace. And of this I have as noble princes as be in Germany, to bear me witness, and also many other worshipful, and honest men, that doth know me, and my conversation. I have also the right worshipful man Doctor Lee, which was the kings Ambassador with us, and all his servants to testify for me, which be honest men, and sufficient in a greater cause then this is.
There runneth a greate voyce of 1mée, that I haue maried a wife, and for that cause men doth recken that I will something proue my witte, and also stretch my learning, to mayntain that priestes myght haue wyues. But 2the very trueth is béefore God, & mā that I haue no wife, •or neuer went about to marry: I thanke God of his grace. And of this I haue as noble princes as bée in Germany, to beare mée witnesse, and also many other worshipfull, and honest men, yt doth knowe mée, and my conuersation. I haue also the ryght worshipfull man Doctour Lée, which was the kinges Embassadour with vs, and all his seruauntes to testifye for mée, which bée honest men, and sufficient in a greater cause then this is.
Finally, here is also the bishop of our city, with whom I do dwell, & am most conversant with. Hear is also the Ambassadors of Lubycke, which doth also know me, and my conversation. And I doubt not, but all they will testify for me, as far as any law shall require. Yea I dare boldly say, that mine adversaries have not so good testimony, that they keep their vow of chastity, as I have, that I am not married. But all is done to bring me in defamation. Let God provide. Nevertheless, what if I had a wife? is y so great a crime? What can men make of it? Hath not many noble Princes, and good men wives? Will men make more articles of salvation for me, then for princes 1or for other Christen men? what have I deserved thus to be taken? Men will have to do with me, but I promise them, they shall get no good by it, if I may come to my answer, I will be able always to defend a wife (if I were disposed to marry) against all those that keep whores. Let them begin when they will. Notwithstanding, I do not abstain from a wife because that is evil, and unclean to marry: but I have other lawful considerations. Let no man doubt, but this is of trueth, if I had a wife, I would not have meddled with this article, because that men might have suspected me, that then I would have defended this article, for the maintenance ⟨p. 331⟩of my fact. But now on the other side, that men should not think how I despised marriage, or thought it unlawful for a Priest to marry, in as much as I my self do not marry. Therefore have I taken this labour on me, to write my meaning, & so much the more boldly, because that men have no cause to suspect me, that I speak to defend mine own cause, but all only to set out the verity, so God help me. Amen.
Finally, here is also the byshop of our citie, with whom I doe dwell, & am most conuersant with. Heare is also the Embassadours of Lubycke, which doth also know mée, and my conuersation. And I doubt not, but all they will testifye for mée, as farre as any lawe shall require. Yea I dare boldly say, yt myne aduersaries haue not so good testemony, that they kéepe theyr vowe of chastitie, as I haue, that I am not maryed. But all is done to bringe mée in defamation. Let God prouide. Neuertheles, what if I had a wyfe? is y so great a crime? What can men make of it? Hath not many noble Princes, and good men wyues? Will mē make more articles of saluation for mée, then for princes 1or for other Christen men? what haue I deserued thus to bée taken? Men will haue to doe with mée, but I promise them, they shall get no good by it, if I may come to my aunswere, I wil bée able alwayes to defend a wyfe (if I weare disposed to marry) agaynst all those that kéepe whores. Let them begin when they will. Notwithstandyng, I doe not abstayne from a wife béecause that is euell, and vncleane to marry: but I haue other lawfull considerations. Let no man doubt, but this is of trueth, if I had a wyfe, I would not haue medled with this article, because that men myght haue suspected mée, that then I would haue defended this article, for the maintenaunce ⟨p. 331⟩of my facte. But now on the other syde, that men should not think how I despised mariage, or thought it vnlawfull for a Priest to marry, in as much as I my selfe doe not marry. Therfore haue I takē this labour on mée, to wryte my meaning, & so much the more boldely, béecause that men haue no cause to suspect mée, that I speake to defende myne owne cause, but all onely to set out the veretye, so God helpe mée. Amen.
But now will I go to the Popes law, and see what time that this thing begun to take strength. It had been often times attempted, but it was always repelled by one good man or other, till after the days of Saint Gregory.
But now will I goe to the Popes lawe, and sée what tyme that thys thyng begunne to take strength. It had beene often times attempted, but it was alwayes repelled by one good man or other, tyll after the dayes of Saint Gregory.
After him came Pelagius the second, and he commanded, that those priests that had married wives should abstain from their wives.
After hym came Pelagius the seconde, and hée commaunded, that those priestes that had maryed wiues should abstayne from their wyues.
Next after him came S. Gregory, and he thought that statute of Pelagius to sore, that men should abstain from their wives, which had neither vowed chastity, nor yet had used them selves to continency. And therefore he decreed, that the Bishops should consecrate no Subdeacon, except he would first vow chastity. This is openly in the popes law. Here began the thing something to spring, 1and to take effect, but yet it was not fully established. For afterward S. Gregory himself repented him, as S. Hulderike beareth witness, by yt reason of the great murder that he saw come thereof. Wherefore it remained so still a great while, unto the coming of Leo the ix: and he saith, that priests may keep their 2wives, but they may not company with them, for the Apostles (saith he) did forsake the company of their wives: alonely they provided them meat and clothe.
Next after hym came S. Gregory, and hée thought that statute of Pelagius to sore, that men should abstaine from their wyues, which had neither vowed chastitie, nor yet had vsed thē selues to continencie. And therefore hée decréed, that the Byshops should consecrate no Subdeacon, except hée woulde first vowe chastitie. Thys is openly in the popes lawe. Here béegan the thyng somthyng to springe, 1and to take effecte, but yet it was not fully establyshed. For afterwarde S. Gregory hymselfe repented hym, as S. Hulderike beareth witnesse, by yt reason of the great murther thath hée sawe come thereof. Wherefore it remayned so styll a great whyle, vnto the commyng of Leo the ix: and hée sayth, that priestes may kéepe theyr 2wyues, but they may not company wyth them, for the Apostles (sayth hée) dyd forsake the company of their wyues: alonely they prouided them meate and clothe.
After him cometh Innocentius the second, the which (not regarding 1Gods ordinance) joineth priests that marrieth, and priests that keepeth whores, all under one damnation.
After hym commeth Innocentius the second, the which (not regarding 1Gods ordinaunce) ioyneth priestes that maryeth, and priestes that kéepeth whores, all vnder one damnation.
But all these yet could not bring this matter to pass as they would. For in many places (for all this) all priests had wives: till the time of Gregory the seventh, which was called 1Hildebrand, a man of evil living, as the chronicles testifieth, and also a great nygromancer, and very familiar with the devil. And as chronicles saith, a man that had poisoned 4. or 5. popes before, that he might come the sooner to it. This man (I say) in the year of our Lord. 1074. 2began to attempt this matter very sharply in Germany, where priests were then quietly suffered to have wives. This man sent his commandment unto Otto bishop of Constantinople, commanding to forbid priests that had not yet married, for to marry. And those that had married, to be separated from their wives. But bishop Otto perceiving this thing 3for to be devilish, would not exercise his commandment. Wherefore Pope Gregory cursed him, and assoiled all men from his obedience, and cited him unto Rome, where he had gathered a council, in the which he had made a decree, that no Priest should afterward marry. And they that had married before, should forsake their wives. Moreover, it was there decreed, that no man should receive holy orders afterward, except he first swear to live sole.
But all these yet coulde not bryng thys matter to passe as they woulde. For in many places (for all this) all priestes had wyues: tyll the tyme of Gregory the seuēth, which was cauled 1Hildebrande, a man of euill lyuyng, as the chronicles testifieth, and also a great nygromancer, and very familyar with the deuill. And as chronicles sayth, a man that had poysoned 4. or 5. popes before, that hée myght come the sooner to it. Thys man (I say) in the yeare of our Lord. 1074. 2began to attempte thys matter very sharpely in Germany, where priests were then quietly suffered to haue wyues. Thys man sent his commaū dement vnto Otto byshop of Constā tinople, commaundyng to forbydde priestes that had not yet maryed, for to marry. And those yt had maried, to bée separated from their wyues. But byshop Otto perceiuyng thys thyng 3for to bée deuillishe, woulde not exercise hys commaundement. Wherfore Pope Gregory cursed him, and assoiled all men from his obedience, and cited hym vnto Rome, where hée had gathered a counsell, in the which hée had made a decrée, that no Prieste shoulde afterwarde marry. And they that had maryed béefore, shoulde forsake their wyues. Moreouer, it was there decréed, that no man should receaue holy orders afterwarde, except hée first sweare to lyue sole.
These decrees were promulgated over all Italy. But the priests, and Bishops of France resisted this decree, 1and said, that this counsel was contrary to Gods word, and took from Priests, that God and nature had granted them. And therefore yt Pope (said they) was an heretic, and an author of damnable doctrine, and that this decree came not of God, but of the devil, and alleged for them the saying of our master Christ. No• omnes 2capiunt verbum hoc. And also S. Paule, De virginitate prec•ptum non 3habeo. They said also, that the pope would compel them to like like Angels, and how he did open a window ⟨p. 332⟩unto fornication & uncleanness. Wherefore they made him answer, that they had rather to forsake their benefices, then their wives. And if he would despise married priests, then should he go & provide him Angels to serve his cures. But the pope was 4nothing moved at all with their scriptures or reasons: but still wrote to yt bishops strait letters, commanding them, and threatening them under the pain of cursing, and privating them of their bishoprics, that they should bring this thing to pass. So that at yt last, the most part of the Bishops consented to him for fear, and laboured all that they could to persuade the priests to forsake their wives, and to vow chastity. But it was long ere the priests were persuaded: yea some of them would never agree thereunto as long as they lived.
These decrées were prouulgated ouer all Italy. But the priestes, and Byshops of Fraunce resisted this decrée, 1and sayde, that this counsel was contrary to Gods worde, and tooke from Priestes, that God and nature had graunted them. And therefore yt Pope (sayde they) was an hereticke, and an auctour ofdamnable doctrine, and that this decree came not of God, but of the deuil, and alleaged for them the saying of our mayster Christ. No• omnes 2capiunt verbum hoc. And also S. Paule, De virginitate prec•ptum non 3habeo. They saide also, that the pope woulde compell them to lyke lyke Angels, and how hée dyd opē a wyndow ⟨p. 332⟩vnto fornicatiō & vncleannes. Wherfore they made hym aunswere, that they had rather to forsake their benefices, then their wyues. And if hée woulde despise maryed priestes, then shoulde hée goe & prouide him Angels to serue his cures. But the pope was 4nothing moued at all with their scriptures or reasons: but still wrote to yt byshops straite letters, cōmaundyng them, and threatning them vnder the payne of cursing, and priuating them of their byshopprickes, yt they should bring this thing to passe. So that at yt last, the most parte of the Byshoppes consented to him for feare, and laboured all yt they coulde to perswade the priestes to forsake their wiues, and to vowe chastitie. But it was long ere the priests were perswaded: yea some of them woulde neuer agrée thereunto as long as they liued.
This Pope wrote also to the Archbishop of Mentz, commanding him as primate of all Germany, to compel married priests to forsake their wives, and to cause all other to vow chastity. This bishop called a convocation, in the which he declared the Popes pleasure. But yt priests resisted marvellous earnestly, alleging for them Scriptures, reasons, and counsels. So far they proceeded together, that there had like to have been a great 1tumult. Then the bishop being a wise man, considering how stiff, & earnest the priests •ere, desired them to take half a years deliberation, exhorting them to agree unto that thing with a good will, unto the which, he must else compel them, by the Popes authority. After the half year was come out, the bishops called a convocation at the University of Erfurt, and there required an answer of the priests, but they were stiffer than before, and said, how they had rather dye then forsake their wives contrary to Gods law. On the other side 2the archbishop was earnest in setting forth the popes commandment.
This Pope wrote also to the Archbyshop of Mentz, cōmaunding him as primate of all Germany, to compell maried priests to forsake their wiues, and to cause all other to vowe chastitie. This byshop called a conuocatiō, in the which hée declared the Popes pleasure. But yt priestes resisted meruaylous earnestly, alleaging for them Scriptures, reasons, and counsels. So farre they procéeded togither, that there had lyke to haue béene a greate 1tumulte. Then the byshop beynge a wyse man, consideryng how stiffe, & earnest the priestes •ere, desired thē to take halfe a yeares deliberation, exhorting them to agrée vnto that thing wyth a good will, vnto the which, hée must els compell them, by the Popes auctoritie. After the halfe yeare was come out, the byshops called a conuocation at the Ʋniuersitie of Erforde, and there required an aunswere of the priestes, but they were stiffer thē before, and sayde, how they had rather dye then forsake their wyues cō trary to Gods law. On the other side 2the archbishop was earnest in setting forth the popes commaundement.
Then the priests required to take their counsel, and so when they were departed out of the convocation they agreed (seeing that neither scriptures, reasons, counsels, nor yet intercession could •helpe as they said) that they would go in again, and kill the Bishop, that all other Bishops after him should be well advised, ere they set forth that thing any more. But the Bishop had some friends amongst them, the which revelated this thing unto him, and he straight ways sent certain of his friends unto yt priests, requiring them to come in again peaceably, and he would promise them so to entreat the pope, that he should be content to let it pass, and that they should keep their cures still as they had done before. Notwithstanding the Archbishop could not change the popes mind in any wise. For the year after the pope sent down his Legate Curiensen Episcopum, and joined the Bishop of Mentz with him, commanding them to gather a convocation in Mentz, and there to propound his decree again. But yet yt priests would in no wise agree unto them, but laid all Scriptures, and reasons for them, that they could. And when all these things would not help, then they fell to entreaty, and intercession. But the popes Legates 1were so stiff, that there was no remedy, but tyranny, and violence to be used.
Then the priestes required to take their counsel, and so when they were departed out of the conuocation they agreed (séeyng that neither scriptures, reasons, counsels, nor yet intercessiō could •helpe as they sayd) that they would go in agayne, and kyll the Byshop, that all other Byshops after hym should bée well aduised, ere they set foorth that thyng any more. But the Byshop had some frendes amōgst them, the which reuelated this thyng vnto hym, and hée streight wayes sent certaine of his frendes vnto yt priests, requiryng them to come in agayne peaceably, and hée would promise thē so to entreate the pope, that hée should bée contēt to let it passe, and that they should kéepe their cures still as they had done before. Notwithstandyng the Archbyshop could not chaūge the popes mynde in any wise. For the yeare after the pope sent downe hys Legate Curiensen Episcopum, and ioyned the Byshop of Mentz with hym, commaundyng them to gather a conuocation in Mentz, and there to propounde his decrée agayne. But yet yt priestes would in no wise agrée vnto them, but layde all Scriptures, and reasōs for them, that they could. And when all these thynges would not helpe, then they fell to entreatie, and intercession. But the popes Legates 1were so stiffe, that there was no remedy, but tyranny, and violence to bée vsed.
But as soon as the priests saw that, they gathered them together, & made a tumult, that the popes Legates scaped very hardly with their lives out of the convocation house, & so was the convocation broken. And the Archbishop of Mentz would never meddle more in it, but committed the matter to the popes discretion. So that the pope was fain to tarry a convenient time, till he had gotten certain Bishops, and certain priests of his party. The determinate time doth not yt stories declare, but alonely we see that now he is prevailed in mischief.
But as soone as the priestes sawe that, they gathered them togither, & made a tumulte, that the popes Legates scaped very hardely with their lyues out of the conuocation house, & so was the conuocation broken. And the Archbyshop of Mentz would neuer medle more in it, but committed the matter to the popes discretion. So that the pope was fayne to tary a conuenient tyme, till hée had gotten certaine Byshops, and certaine priestes of his partie. The determinate tyme doth not yt stories declare, but alonely we sée that nowe hée is preuayled in mischief.
Wherefore I will now proceed after my promise, and recite their Scriptures and reasons, whereby they prove Celibatum Sacerdotū. Their first scripture is. Be ye holy, for I am holy, 1saith the Lord. Upon this Scripture ⟨p. 333⟩disputeth yt pope on this manner. The priests of the old law did not company with their wives, in the time of their ministration. Wherefore the priests of the new law, which doth 2always minister, must much more always keep their chastity. First, the pope doth allege this Scripture 3wrong. For it is not Moses mind, where this text is spoken, to compel men from their wives, or not to marry (the which thing the pope hath taken upon him to prove.) For Moses speaketh there to the whole household of Israel.
Wherfore I will now procéede after my promise, and recite their Scriptures and reasōs, wherby they prooue Celibatum Sacerdotū. Their first scripture is. Bée ye holy, for I am holy, 1sayth the Lord. Ʋpon this Scripture ⟨p. 333⟩disputeth yt pope on this maner. The priestes of the old law did not company with their wyues, in the tyme of their ministration. Wherefore the priestes of the new law, whiche doth 2alwayes minister, must much more alwayes kéepe their chastitie. First, the pope doth alleage this Scripture 3wrong. For it is not Moyses mynde, where this text is spoken, to compell men from their wiues, or not to marry (the which thyng the pope hath taken vpō hym to prooue.) For Moyses speaketh there to the whole houshold of Israell.
Now was not the house of Israel compelled by the text, either to forsake their wives, or else to vow chastity. Wherefore this text can not make for the popes purpose. Farthermore, the text saith no more, but that we should be clean, and holy. Now is not matrimony, either unclean, or unholy: for it is a thing instituted, and sanctified of God. And the purest creatures 1that ever God made did use it, & was not thereby defiled. Ergo, this text maketh not for the popes purpose. And where as the pope saith, that yt priests of the new law shall be clean, we 2grant the same, and desire God with all our hearts, that they may be so. And because that we would, that it should be so: therefore do we exhort them to use Gods holy ordinance, that they may be holy. For all creatures of 3God be good. And unto them that be clean, nothing is unclean. Now is matrimony gods ordinance▪ Wherefore it must needs be clean of it self, and may be lawfully used with thanks.
Now was not the house of Israell cōpelled by the text, either to forsake their wyues, or els to vowe chastitie. Wherfore this text can not make for the popes purpose. Farthermore, the text sayth no more, but that we should bée cleane, and holy. Now is not matrimony, either vncleane, or vnholy: for it is a thyng instituted, and sanctified of God. And the purest creatures 1that euer God made dyd vse it, & was not therby defiled. Ergo, this text maketh not for the popes purpose. And where as the pope saith, that yt priests of the newe law shall bée cleane, we 2graūt the same, and desire God with all our hartes, that they may bée so. And béecause that we would, that it should bée so: therfore doe we exhorte them to vse Gods holy ordinaunce, that they may bée holy. For all creatures of 3God bée good. And vnto them that bée cleane, nothyng is vncleane. Now is matrimony gods ordinaūce▪ Wherefore it must néedes bée cleane of it selfe, and may bée lawfully vsed with thankes.
Farthermore, what argument is this of the popes? The priests of the old law, did abstain from their wives, 1the time of their ministration, Ergo, our priests must always abstain? How followeth this, always, out of the old priests, sometime? But me 2thinketh the pope should rather take an occasion of this place, to bind his priests to marriage, if they can not live sole. For the priests of the law, by Gods commandment had wives: Ergo, God would not reckon marriage unclean, and unpure. And if it were clean for them, it must much more be cleaner unto our priests. For all things be cleaner unto us, then to them. Wherefore me thinketh yt pope should rather dispute on this manner. The priests of yt old law had wives, and were not thereby defiled, Ergo, my priests must much rather have wives, for they shall be less defiled.
Farthermore, what argument is this of the popes? The priestes of the old law, did abstayne frō their wiues, 1the tyme of their ministration, Ergo, our priestes must alwayes abstayne? How foloweth this, alwayes, out of the old priestes, sometyme? But me 2thinketh the pope should rather take an occasiō of this place, to bynde hys priestes to mariage, if they can not lyue sole. For the priestes of the law, by Gods cōmaundement had wiues: Ergo, God would not recken mariage vncleane, and vnpure. And if it were cleane for them, it must much more bée cleaner vnto our priestes. For all thynges bée cleaner vnto vs, then to them. Wherfore me thinketh yt pope should rather dispute on this maner. The priestes of yt old law had wyues, and were not thereby defiled, Ergo, my priestes must much rather haue wyues, for they shall bée lesse defiled.
Moreover, it followeth not. The priests of the old law abstained from their wives, in the time of their ministration, Ergo, our priests must abstain always, because they be always in ministration. For many things were unclean to the priests of the old law, that be not unclean unto our priests. Also unto them it was a commandment so to do, or else it had been lawful for them to tarry by their wives. But our priests hath no commandment. Ergo, they are not bound to abstain. Finally, this text of Scripture did not bind the Apostles, nor all the holy fathers after the Apostles till Innocents time to abstain from their wives. Ergo, it bindeth not our priests now. For gods word was in as full strength before Innocents days, as after.
Moreouer, it foloweth not. The priestes of the old law abstained from their wyues, in the tyme of their ministration, Ergo, our priestes must abstayne alwayes, bycause they bée alwayes in ministration. For many thinges were vncleane to the priestes of the old law, that bée not vncleane vnto our priestes. Also vnto them it was a commaundement so to doe, or els it had béene lawfull for them to tary by their wyues. But our priestes hath no commaundement. Ergo, they are not bounde to abstayne. Finally, this text of Scripture dyd not bynde the Apostles, nor all the holy fathers after the Apostles till Innocentes tyme to abstayne from theyr wyues. Ergo, it byndeth not our priestes now. For gods word was in as full strēgth before Innocentes dayes, as after.
The second Scripture is this. Abstain 1for a time that ye may the better give attendance to prayer. On this text disputeth the pope on this manner. Paul commandeth (saith he) lay men to abstain for a time. Ergo, much more are priests bound to abstain always. The which must always pray, and be in a continual sacrificing. This argument is also false, and not concluded after Saint Pauls mind. For S. Paul would not by this text forbid marriage, by the reason of prayer. For how could he say then, Abstain for a time? Unmarried men must abstain always, and not for a time only. Nor it is no commandment unto lay men (as the pope saith) to abstain. For S. Paul will, that they shall not abstain, except that they be both agreed. Yea and also in a case, that is, where their abstaining should be an occasion of more prayer. But if ⟨p. 334⟩their abstaining may be the occasion of uncleanness: Or else, if the one party will abstain, and the other can not: Then will blessed S. Paul that neither of them shall defraud the other. For they are more bound in this case to use them selves in the office of matrimony, then pro illo loco, & tempore to pray. For yt text is clear Uxori vir debitum reddat. Let men mark my saying well. For though we be bound to pray by the Gospel, yet I think that the circumstance of time, and place, is of mans law, & reader debitum, is in this case of the Gospel. Wherefore the other must give place. Take my words charitably, and after learning. But yet grant it a commandment. How can it follow there out, that priests shall never marry? because that lay men are bound (as the pope saith) to abstain for a time? Why doth not the pope 2rather bind his priests in time, and place requisite to matrimony, for avoiding of fornication, as S. Paul doth? All the world knoweth, that priests doth not always pray. Wherefore then doth not the pope grant them that same liberty, that S. Paul doth. For he w•ll (lest yt devil should tempt them by incontinency) that they should return again after their prayer to yt office of matrimony.
The second Scripture is this. Abstayne 1for a tyme that ye may the better geue attendaunce to prayer. On this texte disputeth the pope on this maner. Paule commaundeth (sayth hée) laye men to abstayne for a tyme. Ergo, much more are priestes bounde to abstayne alwayes. The whiche must alwayes pray, and bée in a continuall sacrifiyng. This argument is also false, and not concluded after Saint Paules mynde. For S. Paule woulde not by this text forbydde mariage, by the reason of prayer. For howe could hée saye then, Abstayne for a tyme? Ʋnmaryed men must abstayne alwayes, and not for a tyme onely. Nor it is no commaundement vnto lay men (as the pope sayth) to abstayne. For S. Paule will, yt they shall not abstayne, except that they be both agréed. Yea and also in a case, yt is, where their abstayning should bée an occasyon of more prayer. But if ⟨p. 334⟩their abstayning may bée the occasyon of vncleanenes: Or els, if the one party will abstayne, and the other can not: Then will blessed S. Paule that neyther of them shall defraude the other. For they are more bounde in thys case to vse them felues in the offyce of matrimonye, then pro illo loco, & tempore to pray. For yt text is clere Ʋxori vir debitum reddat. Let men marke my saying well. For though we bée bound to pray by the Gospell, yet I thynke that the cercumstance of tyme, and place, is of mans lawe, & reddere debitum, is in this case of the Gospell. Wherefore the other must geue place. Take my wordes charitably, and after learning. But yet graūt it a commaundement. How can it folowe there out, that priestes shall neuer marry? because that lay men are bound (as the pope sayth) to abstaine for a tyme? Why doth not the pope 2rather bynde his priestes in tyme, and place requisite to matrimony, for auoyding of fornication, as S. Paule doth? All the world knoweth, yt priests doth not alwayes pray. Wherefore then doth not the pope graunt them that same lybertie, yt S. Paule doth. For he w•ll (lest yt deuyll should tēpt them by incontenency) yt they should returne againe after their prayer to yt office of matrimony.