The next thing comes in my way, is an argument brought for liberty of conscience, from Gamaliel's speech in favour of the Apostles, Act. 5. 38, 39. Refrain from these men & let them alone: for if this counsel or this work be of men, it will come to nought. But if it be of God ye cannot overthrow it, lest haply ye be found even to fight against God. The strength of his argumentation did lie in this Dilemma; this doctrine or way is either of men, or of God. If it be of men, you shall not need to repress it, for it will come to nought of it self, which he proves by two Historical instances of Judas and Theudas. If it be of God, it is in vain to strive against it, for it must prevail, and the counsel of heaven must stand. Therefore be what it will be, there is no danger to let it alone. But on the other side, if ye go about to repress it, ye run the hazard both of fighting against God, and of provoking the displeasure as well of the Romans who have not permitted ⟨p. 26⟩unto you the liberty of capital punishments, as of the people of the Jews who magnify these men and their way. This is the whole substance, sense, and scope of that speech of Gamaliel in the Council. Hence did some argue for a toleration to Servetus and other Heretics. And though this their way was then discovered to be their folly, yet their posterity approve their sayings. The same argument is used in that pamphlet called Liberty of Conscience, p. 34, 35. Upon the same foundation doth Mr Goodwin build in his [Greek or Hebrew], and the Paraenetic for Christian liberty, pag. 2. and 11. supposing the credit and authority of Gamaliel's speech, for matter of truth to be one and the same with other scriptures, and that there is nothing in all that speech but what is fully consonant with the word of God, unquestionably so acknowledged. So Mr Goodwin affirmeth, p. 10. and after him one P. P. which is by interpretation, Poor Pamphleteer, falls in the same ditch; he might well call it As you were, for he makes that party to be never a jot more in the right. First of all he will contend with us that Protestant Interpreters do commend Gamaliel's speech,1 and justify M• Goodwins Doctrine. Sure I am, Calvin takes Gamaliel to be a godless Politician, and a Neutralist, and his speech to have a great error in it. So saith Pelargus upon the place.
The next thing comes in my way, is an argument brought for liberty of conscience, from Gamaliels speech in favour of the Apostles, Act. 5. 38, 39. Refrain from these men & let them alone: for if this counsell or this work be of men, it will come to nought. But if it be of God ye cannot overthrow it, lest haply ye be found even to fight against God. The strength of his argumentation did lie in this D•lemma; this doctrine or way is either of men, or of God. If it be of men, you shall not need to represse it, for it will come to nought of it self, which he proves by two Historicall instances of Judas and Theudas. If it be of God, it is in vain to strive against it, for it must prevail, and the counsell of heaven must stand. Therefore be what it will be, there is no danger to let it alone. But on the other side, if ye goe about to represse it, ye runne the hazard both of fighting against God, and of provoking the displeasure as well of the Romanes who have not permitted ⟨p. 26⟩unto you the liberty of capitall punishments, as of the people of the Jews who magnifie these men and their way. This is the whole substance, sense, and scope of that speech of Gamaliel in the Councell. Hence did some argue for a toleration to Servetus and other Hereticks. And though this their way was then discovered to be their folly, yet their posterity approve their sayings. The same argument is used in that pamphlet called Liberty of Conscience, p. 34, 35. Upon the same foundation doth Mr Goodwin build in his 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and the Paraenetick for Christian liberty, pag. 2. and 11. supposing the credit and authority of Gamaliels speech, for matter of truth to be one and the same with other scriptures, and that there is nothing in all that speech but what is fully consonant with the word of God, unquestionably so acknowledged. So Mr Goodwin affirmeth, p. 10. and after him one P. P. which is by interpretation, Poor Pamphleter, fals in the same ditch; he might well call it As you were, for he makes that party to be never a jot more in the right. First of all he will contend with us that Protestant Interpreters doe commend Gamaliels speech,1 and justify M• Goodwins Doctrine. Sure I am, Calvin takes Gamaliel to be a godlesse Polititian, and a Neutralist, and his speech to have a great error in it. So saith Pelargus upon the place.
- 1Calv. Refut. Error. M. Serveti. Gamalielis authoritas perperam abillis adducitur, &c. Gamaliel amb•g•ns quid rectu• sit, quasi caecus in tenebras, neque buc n•que illuc see con•er•e audet: sed saspendi• senteatiam. In erim ex veris p•incipiis malam conseque•tiam clicit, nihil adbiben lum esse co•sisi•, quia deus quod suum est tuebitur: quod autem ab hominibus est, p•ssum ibit, &c. Putidius est quam ut refu•ati•ne ind•g•a•, quod quidam ex prophanorum ho•mnum dictis colligu•, Si de cultu dei & legis doctrina hab•tur quaestio, non esse crimen morte aut vinculis dignum. P•••rgus in Act. 5. Sic in causae qualitate s•spensus haeret; nec proba•e •n•c improbare potest apostolicam doctrinam. Et infra. Ex judicio hominis in foro prudentis, n•utiquam Theologice conclud•ndam, quod à paenis & correctionibus sit cessandu•, quia deus ad scandala tolle ida & m•la prorsus eradicanda ipse sufficiat. Magistratus enim officium ex 13 Rom. v. 4. & aliunde notum est.Calv. Refut. Error. M. Serveti. Gamalielis authoritas perperam abillis adducitur, &c. Gamaliel ambgns quid rectu sit, quasi caecus in tenebras, neque buc nque illuc se conere audet: sed saspendi senteatiam. In erim ex veris pincipiis malam consequetiam clicit, nihil adbiben lum esse cosisi, quia deus quod suum est tuebitur: quod autem ab hominibus est, pssum ibit, &c. Putidius est quam ut refuatine indga, quod quidam ex prophanorum homnum dictis colligu, Si de cultu dei & legis doctrina habtur quaestio, non esse crimen morte aut vinculis dignum. Prgus in