Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. But why should they trust thus in Gods mercy alone? or why may they not trust safely enough in their own merits also? For so his Assertion was, that in them men might trust to; and that there was ground good enough for them so for to do.g In regard, saith ⟨p. 275⟩he, of the uncertainty of a mans own righteousness: hbecause a man may be mistaken in it, and imagine that he hath it, when he hath not. But certain or uncertain, how can mans merit be the ground of his salvation, if his salvation depend upon Gods mercy alone? Or how is mans merit necessarily required unto salvation, if by Gods mercy alone he may be saved without it?
3. But why should they trust thus in Gods mercy alone? or why may they not trust safely enough in their owne merits also? For so his Assertion was, that in them men might trust to; and that there was ground good enough for them so for to doe.g In regard, saith ⟨p. 275⟩he, of the uncertainty of a mans owne righteousnesse: hbecause a man may be mistaken in it, and imagine that he hath it, when he hath not. But certaine or uncertaine, how can mans merit bee the ground of his salvation, if his salvation depend upon Gods mercy alone? Or how is mans merit necessarily required unto salvation, if by Gods mercy alone he may be saved without it?
gPropter justitiae incertitudinem. Bellarm. ubi sup.
hQuia multi salluntur, dumb putaent se habere quod non habent. Idem de Justif. l. 3. c. 8.Quia multi salluntur, dum putaent se habere quod non habent. Idem de Iustif. l. 3. c. 8.
4.i In regard also, saith he, of the jeopardy of vain-glory. In which clause he acknowledgeth that this their Doctrine of mans merit is a dangerous Doctrine, (as Bernard also termethk the practice of it both foolish and perilous) and such as may soon puff up mens minds with vain-glory, yeal with pride and presumption, (he might well have said) the very bane of all true confidence, grace, goodness and godliness. And consequently as a most dreadful* rock threatening ship-wrack of salvation, to be most warily shunned and eschewed of all those that are jealous of miscarrying, and desirous of eternal well-doing.
4.i In regard also, saith he, of the jeopardie of vain-glory. In which clause he acknowledgeth that this their Doctrine of mans merit is a dangerous Doctrine, (as Bernard also tearmethk the practice of it both foolish and perillous) and such as may soone puffe up mens minds with vain-glory, yeal with pride and presumption, (hee might well have said) the very bane of all true confidence, grace, goodnesse and godlinesse. And consequently as a most dreadfull* rocke threatning ship-wracke of salvation, to be most warily shunned and eschewed of all those that are jealous of miscarying, and desirous of eternall well-doing.
iPropter periculum inanis gloriae. Idem ubi sup.
kStultum & periculosum est suis quenquam consider meritis Bern de Divers. 32. Periculosa habitatio eorum, qui in meritis suis sperant; periculosa quia ruinosa. Idem in Psal. 90. Serm 1.Stultum & periculosum est suis quenquam confidere meritis Bern de Divers. 32. Periculosa habitatio eorum, qui in meritis suis sperant; periculosa quia ruinosa. Idem in Psal. 90. Serm 1.
lDiscamus de nostra omninò industria, maegis autem de nostris diffidere meritis, Bern. de Temp. 75. Nam sibi quidem ipsi fidere, non fidei, sed perfidiae est: nec confidentiae, sed diffidentiae magis in semetipso habere fiduciam. Is verè fidelis est, qui nec sibi credit, nec in se sperat, factus sibi tanquam vas perditum. Id quod sola facit humil•tas cordis, ut non sibi fidelis anima innitatur, sed descrens semetipsam, & super dilectum innixa ascendat de deserto, Idem de Temp. 16.
I will add here but the Confession of one or two of their own Writers: †I am wholly of this mind (saith Cardinal Contarene) that it is a pious and a Christian-like saying, that we ought to rely, as on a thing steadfast and able to support us, on Christs righteousness bestowed upon us, not on holiness or grace inherent in us. On this alone, as certain and steadfast ought we to rest. And† All the Ancients with general consent, saith Cassander, deliver, that confidence for remission of sins, and hope of pardon and life eternal, is to be placed in Gods mercy alone and Christs merits. To which purpose also he allegeth a place of Pope Gregory, to this effect;“ We trust not in our own tears or deeds, but in our Advocates plea. And as for trust in ought else, saith Adrian of Utrecht, who was Bishop of Rome also afterward;† Our merits are but as a staff of reed, which if a man lean to or rely on, it knappeth asunder, and runneth through his hand that relieth on it. It is the surest course, saith Bellarmine; it is the only sure course, say we, to trust only in Gods mercy. So said the Ancients before us (as some of their own, you see confess) with us. And to teach men in stead of it to trust in their own merits, is to teach them* to exchange a rock for a reed. Nor can there be any safety at all in so doing; unless it be safe to rely on so deceitful and dangerous a stay as is sure to serve them all (by their own Adrians confession) that trust thereunto, as† Rabsake saith Egypt did, as“ the Spartan said Athens would have done, if Greece should have relied on it.
I will adde here but the Confession of one or two of their owne Writers: †I am wholly of this minde (saith Cardinall Contarene) that it is a pious and a Christian-like saying, that wee ought to rely, as on a thing stedfast and able to support us, on Christs righteousnesse bestowed upon us, not on holinesse or grace inherent in us. On this alone, as certaine and stedfast ought we to rest. And† All the Ancients with generall consent, saith Cassander, deliver, that confidence for remission of sinnes, and hope of pardon and life eternall, is to bee placed in Gods mercy alone and Christs merits. To which purpose also he alleageth a place of Pope Gregory, to this effect;“ We trust not in our owne teares or deeds, but in our Advocates plea. And as for trust in ought else, saith Adrian of Vtrech, who was Bishop of Rome also afterward;† Our merits are but as a staffe of reed, which if a man leane to or rely on, it knappeth asunder, and runneth thorow his hand that relieth on it. It is the surest course, saith Bellarmine; it is the only sure course, say we, to trust only in Gods mercie. So said the Ancients before us (as some of their owne, you see confesse) with us. And to teach men in stead of it to trust in their owne merits, is to teach them* to exchange a rocke for a reed. Nor can there be any safetie at all in so doing; unlesse it bee safe to rely on so deceitfull and dangerous a stay as is sure to serve them all (by their owne Adrians confession) that trust thereunto, as† Rabsake saith Aegypt did, as“ the Spartan said Athens would have done, if Greece should have relied on it.
†Ego prorsus existimo piè & Christianè dici, quod debeamus niti, tanquam restabili quae sustentat nos, sustitia Christi nobis donata, non autem sanctitate & gratia nobis inhaerente. Contaren. Card. de Justific.Ego prorsus existimo piè & Christianè dici, quod debeamus niti, tanquam restabili quae sustentat nos, sustitia Christi nobis donata, non autem sanctitate & gratia nobis inhaerente. Contaren. Card. de Iustific.
†Summo consensu vereres omnes tradunt, fiduciam remissionis peccatorum etiam eorum que post regenerationem admittuntur; & spem veniae & vitae eternae, in sola Dei mis•ricordia & merito Christi esse collocandam, Cassand. Consult. art. 6.
“Non in fletibus & actibus nostris, sed in Advocati nostri allegation considimus, Greg. in Ezech. hom. 1.Non in fletibus & actibus nostris, sed in Advocati nostri allegatione considimus, Greg. in Ezech. hom. 1.
†Sunt merita nostra veluti baculus arundineus; cui dum quis innixus fuerit, confringitur, & perforat manum innitentis, Adrian. de Traject. in 4. Sent.
Thus then sometime they seek to salve and qualify this their pestilent and poysonfull doctrine, which at other times, as not half, but wholly ashamed to own it, they do utterly deny and disclaim.
Thus then sometime they seeke to salve and qualifie this their pestilent and poysonfull doctrine, which at other times, as not halfe, but wholly ashamed to owne it, they doe utterly deny and disclaime.
It ism Philip Melanchthon's eighth lie, saith Bellarmine, that our Teachers ⟨p. 276⟩will men to merit remission of sins by their works. These words, I find not at all in the place out of which they are alleged. Neither know I what Edition of that Confession he followeth. But suppose that Philip say so. Why is it a lie? Is it not true that they teach so? Yes doubtless. Bellarmine himself else-where confesseth, thatn some of their Doctors teach, that men by their own works make satisfaction to God for the fault or offence it self. Others,o that they satisfy both for the fault or offence, and for the punishment also, yea even the eternal pains thereunto due: Others again (whom he giveth his voice with)p not for the fault it self indeed, but for the guilt of such penalties as remain due for the same, after that the fault is forgiven, qthat is, saith he, for the pains that a sinner should in Hell else have suffered, the eternity of them only taken away: that which he termeth out of somer places of Scripture boths mis-translated, andt mis-expounded,u a redeeming or buying out of mens sins; and maintainethx remission of sins to be by such redemption purchased and procured.
It ism Philip Melancthons eighth lie, saith Bellarmine, that our Teachers ⟨p. 276⟩will men to merit remission of sinnes by their workes. These words, I finde not at all in the place out of which they are alledged. Neither know I what Edition of that Confession hee followeth. But suppose that Philip say so. Why is it a lie? Is it not true that they teach so? Yes doubtlesse. Bellarmine himselfe else-where confesseth, thatn some of their Doctors teach, that men by their owne workes make satisfaction to God for the fault or offence it selfe. Others,o that they satisfie both for the fault or offence, and for the punishment also, yea even the eternall paines thereunto due: Others againe (whom he giveth his voyce with)p not for the fault it selfe indeed, but for the guilt of such penalties as remaine due for the same, after that the fault is forgiven, qthat is, saith he, for the paines that a sinner should in Hell else have suffered, the eternity of them onely taken away: that which he tearmeth out of somer places of Scripture boths mis-translated, andt mis-expounded,u a redeeming or buying out of mens sinnes; and maintainethx remission of sinnes to bee by such redemption purchased and procured.
mOctavum Philippi Mendacium. In art. 20. Confess. Jubent. Catholici Doctores mereri remissionem peccatorum operibus, Bellar. in Judic. de Libr. Concord.Octavum Philippi Mendacium. In art. 20. Confess. Iubent. Catholici Doctores mereri remissionem peccatorum operibus, Bellar. in Iudic. de Libr. Concord.
nAndr. Vega l. 13. in Concil. Trident. c. 36 contendit, satis fieri pro culpa. Bellar. de poenit. l 4. c. 1.
oDocet Rua•d Tapper. insignis Theologus in explic. art. 6. Lovan. posse hominem satusacere Deo pro culpa & poena aeterna per actus quosdam, &c. Bellarm. ibid.
pNos Concil. Trid. Sess. 6. c. 14 & Sess. 14. c. 13. sequentes, Per opera poenalia verè ac propriè Domino satisfieri pro reatu poenae, qui post culpam dumissam remanet expiandus. Idem ibid. l. 4 c. 7.
qId est, pro poena sensus, ut Cajetan. rectè de Contrit. q. 4. quam in Gehenna pati debuisset peccator, remota solum aeternitate. Ib. c. 1.
Again, thata men by their works make such condigne satisfaction for some sins, bthat thereby the offence and wrong done to God is truly recompensed, and his justice fully satisfied; and thatc through Gods grace they do in some sort by works of their own, which they owe not to God, truly or equally, and therefore justly also and condignly satisfy; for thatd such works have a kind of infiniteness (or infinite worth) in them, and consequently an equality with the wrong that they did God by their sins, in sundry places he himself avoweth: which what is it but to merit remission of sins? For hath not he merited remission that hath made such satisfaction?
Againe, thata men by their workes make such condigne satisfaction for some sinnes, bthat thereby the offence and wrong done to God is truly recompenced, and his justice fully satisfied; and thatc through Gods grace they doe in some sort by workes of their owne, which they owe not to God, truly or equally, and therefore justly also and condignly satisfie; for thatd such workes have a kinde of infinitenesse (or infinite worth) in them, and consequently an equality with the wrong that they did God by their sinnes, in sundry places he himselfe avoweth: which what is it but to merit remission of sinnes? For hath not he merited remission that hath made such satisfaction?
aApertissimè agnoscit satisfactionem condignam esse debere, & eam proportionem cum peccato exigere, ut verè per eam offensio compensetur, de Poenit. l. 4. c. 9.
bUt injuria Deo facta compensetur, & divinae justitiae satisfiat, Ibid.Vt injuria Deo facta compensetur, & divinae justitiae satisfiat, Ibid.
cAccedente gratia verè possumus aliquo modo exoperibus propriis Deo indebitis, & ad aequal tatem, ac per hoc justè & ex condigno satisfacere Ib. cap. 7.
dQuia quatenus à spiritu procedunt, habent quandam infinitatem, ac per hoc aequalitatem cum injuria, qua Deum peccando afficiebamus, ibid.
Yea the Objection being made, that thene either there must be two joint satisfactions, the one Christs, and the other ours; or but one only; and that either Christs, and then we do not satisfy; or ours, and then Christs is excluded; or else we divide the honour between Christ and our selves, that he pay for the fault, and we for the punishment: The Cardinal saith, that hereunto three Answers are given.
Yea the Objection being made, that thene either there must bee two joynt satisfactions, the one Christs, and the other ours; or but one onely; and that either Christs, and then wee doe not satisfie; or ours, and then Christs is excluded; or else wee divide the honour betweene Christ and our selves, that he pay for the fault, and we for the punishment: The Cardinall saith, that hereunto three Answers are given.
eVel sunt duae satisfactiones simul junctae, una Christi, altera nostra; vel una tantum. Si duae, ergo bis punitur eadem culpa. Si una tantum, vel illa est Chr•sti, & tunc nos non satisfacimus; vel nostra, & tunc exclud•tur Christus; aut verè dividemus cum Christo honorem, nam ille solvet pro culpa, nos propaena. Bellar. de Purgat l. 1. c. 14.
For 1. some say,f that there is one only satisfaction, and that is Christs: and that we, to speak properly, do not satisfy at all, but only do somewhat in regard whereof God applieth Christs satisfaction to us: Andg so, saith he, should our works be nothing but conditions, or dispositions at most, without which Christs satisfaction should not be applied to us. That which is indeed in effect the same that we say. Buth this he holdeth to be erroneous.
For 1. some say,f that there is one only satisfaction, and that is Christs: and that we, to speake properly, doe not satisfie at all, but only doe somewhat in regard whereof God applieth Christs satisfaction to us: Andg so, saith hee, should our workes be nothing but conditions, or dispositions at most, without which Christs satisfaction should not be applied to us. That which is indeed in effect the same that we say. Buth this he holdeth to be erronious.
fQuidam asserunt esse unam tantum. & illam Christi esse; ac nos propriè non satisfacere, sed solum facere aliquid cujus intuitu Deus applicat nobis Christi satisfactionem. Ita Michael Baius de Indulg cap ult.
gQuod est dicere, Nostra opera non esse nisi conditiones, sine quibus non applicaretur nobis Christi satisfactio, vel ad summum, esse dispositiones.
hQuae sententia erronea mihi videtur, Bellarm. ibid.
2. Some say, thati there are two satisfactions, but the one depending upon the other; the one Christs, and the other ours: kfor though the ⟨p. 277⟩one were sufficient; yet for greater honour to us, God will have ours added to his. Andl this he holdeth to be not improbable.
iAlii dicunt quod sunt duae, sed una ab altera dependent.
kNam etiamsi una sufficiat, tamen ad majorem gloriam Dei, cui satisfit, & majorem honorem hominis satisfacientis, placuit Christo conjungere nostram.
lQui modus non videtur mihi improbabilis, Bel. ibid.
3. Some say, andm that is the more probable, (and that therefore he goeth with) that there is but one actual satisfaction alone, and that ours. nAnd so Christ consequently is excluded, and shut out at doors, as in the Objection before was said. Yea he saith moreover, that aso the Saints may well be termed our Redeemers, because that by their sufferings they may redeem or buy out our sins: Sop a man may well be said to be his own Redeemer and Saviour, and yet no wrong done therein to Christ, when by his own worksq he maketh condigne satisfaction to God in this manner for his sins.
3. Some say, andm that is the more probable, (and that therefore he goeth with) that there is but one actuall satisfaction alone, and that ours. nAnd so Christ consequently is excluded, and shut out at doores, as in the Objection before was said. Yea he saith moreover, that aso the Saints may well bee tearmed our Redeemers, because that by their sufferings they may redeeme or buy out our sinnes: Sop a man may well be said to be his owne Redeemer and Saviour, and yet no wrong done therein to Christ, when by his owne worksq he maketh condigne satisfaction to God in this manner for his sinnes.
mTertius modus videtur probabili•r; quod una tantum sit actualis satisfactio, & ea sit nostra, Bellar. ibid.
nEt tunc Christus excluditur.
oNon erit absurdum si Sancti viri Re•emptores nostri esse dicantur, cum aliquo modo passionibus suis delicta nostra possint redimere. Bellarm. de Indulg. l. 1. c. 4.
pHomo sui ipsius Redemptor & Salvator appellatur: nec propterea ulla fit Christo injuria. Idem de Purgat. l. 1. c. 14.
And now judge you, whether Philip Melanchthon lied or no, when he said (if at least he did so say) that they will men to merit remission of their sins by their works. But let us hear further how not Melanchthon, but Bellarmine lieth himself, where he chargeth Melanchthon with lying.r We teach not, saith he, that by works done without faith or Gods free help, men may merit remission of sins. sNor do we ascribe even unto those works that are done of Faith and by Gods aid, such a merit, as that the reward doth of justice or right answer it; (that is, the merit of condignitie) but the merit of impetration only, as Augustine speaketh; which the Schoolmen are wont to call not the merit of condignity, but the merit of congruity. tNor is there any dissent among Catholics herein.
And now judge you, whether Philip Melancthon lied or no, when he said (if at least he did so say) that they will men to merit remission of their sinnes by their workes. But let us heare further how not Melancthon, but Bellarmine lieth himselfe, where hee chargeth Melancthon with lying.r We teach not, saith he, that by workes done without faith or Gods free helpe, men may merit remission of sinnes. sNor doe we ascribe even unto those workes that are done of Faith and by Gods aid, such a merit, as that the reward doth of justice or right answer it; (that is, the merit of condignitie) but the merit of impetration onely, as Augustine speaketh; which the Schoolemen are wont to call not the merit of condignity, but the merit of congruity. tNor is there any dissent among Catholiques herein.
rNon id habet Catholica doctrina ut operibus illis, quae fiunt sine fide & auxilio Dei gratuito mereri possint homines remissionem peccatorum. Bellarm. in Judic. de lib. Concord. Mendac. 8.Non id habet Catholica doctrina ut operibus illis, quae fiunt sine fide & auxilio Dei gratuito mereri possint homines remissionem peccatorum. Bellarm. in Iudic. de lib. Concord. Mendac. 8.
sHuc accedit, quod istis etiam operibus, quae fiunt ex fide & auxilio Dei, hon tale tribuimus meritum, ut ei respondeat ex justitia merces; sed meritum solum impetrationis, ut Augustinus loquitur, quod Scholastici meritum de congruo, non de condigno nominare solent. Bellar. ibid.
tNeque in hoc ulla est inter Catholicos differentia, ibid.
I might here take occasion to show somewhat largely, in what sense theu ancient Fathers, as alsox other Writers of those times do ordinarily use the word to Merit (because our adversaries so much press the use of that Phrase in them, as if it implied such Merit as they maintain) to wit, asy Bellarmine himself, withz others of his own side also acknowledgeth, for to achieve or obtain ought on any terms whatsoever, be it of free favour, or of due debt and desert: which is the Merit of Impetration, that he saith Augustine speaketh of; anda differeth much from Merit or Desert strictly and properly so termed, as Bellarmine himself also granteth: Since that, by their own confession,b it is one thing to impetrate or obtain, and another to merit, that is, to deserve: And therefore in such sense as they use the word Merit, ca man may be said sometime to merit, that is, obtain and impetrate, ⟨p. 278⟩what he deserveth not; and again,d not to merit, that is, obtain and impetrate what yet he hath well deserved. As also in this sensee they are wont (Bellarmine himself also acknowledging it) to call all good works Merits, for which we receive ought, though the reward be, asf he granteth also that it may be, not of desert, right, or due debt, but of favour and grace only. Wherein Bernard singularly well expounding their meaning, and his own too, where he useth those and the like terms;g If we speak properly, saith he, those things that we use to call Merits, are certain seeds of Hope, sparks of Love, signs of our hidden Predestination, presages of our future glorification; the way to the Crown, not the cause of our Crowning.
I might here take occasion to shew somwhat largely, in what sense theu ancient Fathers, as alsox other Writers of those times do ordinarily use the word to Merit (because our adversaries so much presse the use of that Phrase in thē, as if it implied such Merit as they maintain) to wit, asy Bellarmine himselfe, withz others of his owne side also acknowledgeth, for to atchieve or obtaine ought on any tearmes whatsoever, be it of free favour, or of due debt and desert: which is the Merit of Impetration, that he saith Augustine speaketh of; anda differeth much from Merit or Desert strictly and properly so tearmed, as Bellarmine himselfe also granteth: Since that, by their owne confession,b it is one thing to impetrate or obtaine, and another to merit, that is, to deserve: And therefore in such sense as they use the word Merit, ca man may bee said sometime to merit, that is, obtaine and impetrate, ⟨p. 278⟩what he deserveth not; and againe,d not to merit, that is, obtaine and impetrate what yet hee hath well deserved. As also in this sensee they are wont (Bellarmine himselfe also acknowledging it) to call all good workes Merits, for which we receive ought, though the reward be, asf he granteth also that it may be, not of desert, right, or due debt, but of favour and grace onely. Wherein Bernard singularly well expounding their meaning, and his owne too, where he useth those and the like tearmes;g If we speake properly, saith he, those things that we use to call Merits, are certaine seeds of Hope, sparkes of Love, signes of our hidden Predestination, presages of our future glorification; the way to the Crowne, not the cause of our Crowning.
uIta Hieron i• Hosh. 4.14. Grandis offensa, postquam peccaveris, iram Dei non mereri. Ambr. in Luc. l. 10. c. 22. O aqua, quae sacramentum Christi esse meruisti. Collatio Carth. cognit. 1. art. 8. Proponant, qui ista elicere meruerunt. Ibid. cognit. 3. art. 16. Quis s•pplicavit, quis legem meruit? Quis judicium postulavit? Et Sedul. & alius nescio quis Hieron. nomine in Rom 4. Magna beatitudo est sine labore legis & poenitentiae, Domini gratiam sola fide promereri; sicut siquis aliquam dignitatem gratis accipiat.
xPacem sub hac lege meruit, ut captivos nostros redderet. Ammian. hist. l. 17. Pacem quam ipse meruit, ei quoque debere proficere, Ibid.
yAugustinus explicat quom•do fides mereatur, cum dicit eam impetrare remissionem peccatorum. Bellar. de Justif. l. 1. c. 21. Sed & Bellarm. ipse ibid. l 5. c. 2. exponit illud Vulg. versionis Heb. 13.16. Talibus hostiis Deus promeretur, ī ut Oecumenius, placetur Deo.Augustinus explicat quom•do fides mereatur, cum dicit eam impetrare remissionem peccatorum. Bellar. de Iustif. l. 1. c. 21. Sed & Bellarm. ipse ibid. l 5. c. 2. exponit illud Vulg. versionis Heb. 13.16. Talibus hostiis Deus promeretur, ī ut Oecumenius, placetur Deo.
zQuodsi aliquis veterum vocabulo promerendi usus est, non aliter intellexit, quam consecutionem de facto. Stapleton. prompt. Fer. 5. post Passion. Dominic. Videatur Vega infra.
aMultum interest inter meritum & impetrationem, Bel de Bon oper. in particul. l. 1. c. 9.
bImpetramus etiam quae non meremur. Tho. sum par. prima secundae q. 114. a. 9. A man may impetrate, and not deserve: and a man may deserve and not impetrate, Anonymus Author contra Bellii Ruinam Papismi. Meritum enim inuititur justitiae; & non •otest Deus homini negare quod meruit, &c. Sed impetrare est liberalitatis divinae: si det, est gratiae; si non dei, non potest argui injustitiae. Adrian. quod lib. q. 8.
I might also insist on that which Bellarmine hath else-where, thath to merit, as they speak, is no more than that which the Greeks call [Greek or Hebrew], which word signifieth noti to be worthy, as he saith, contrary to all use and authority, butk to be vouchsafed, reputed or esteemed as worthy, as alsol Cajetan himself therein following their own vulgar Latin, expoundeth it. And whereas the same their vulgar Translation hath it in bad and barbarousm Latin, and their Rhemists version in as bad or worse English, nwith such hosts God is promerited: oThe meaning of it is, saith Bellarmine, that with such Sacrifices God is delighted, or pacified, as Chrysostoms Commentary hath it, (though indeed in Chrysostoms Commentary, there is no such word, or any one word of exposition, but the same word it self only) or is pleased, (well-pleased, it is word for word in the Original) as Oecumenius expoundeth it. Andp it signifieth, saith he, that God is delighted in good works, and is therewith conciliated, (that is, moved to befriend, as we say) and induced thereby to do good unto those that do well. Which is that that we mean, when we say that works are meritorious. Well it were indeed if they either meant or maintained no more than is here said. Little controversy would there then be between us and them.
I might also insist on that which Bellarmine hath else-where, thath to merit, as they speake, is no more than that which the Greeks call 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which word signifieth noti to be worthy, as he saith, contrarie to all use and authoritie, butk to be vouchsafed, reputed or esteemed as worthy, as alsol Cajetan himselfe therein following their owne vulgar Latine, expoundeth it. And whereas the same their vulgar Translation hath it in bad and barbarousm Latine, and their Rhemists version in as bad or worse English, nwith such hosts God is promerited: oThe meaning of it is, saith Bellarmine, that with such Sacrifices God is delighted, or pacified, as Chrysostomes Commentary hath it, (though indeed in Chrysostomes Commentarie, there is no such word, or any one word of exposition, but the same word it selfe onely) or is pleased, (well-pleased, it is word for word in the Originall) as Oecumenius expoundeth it. Andp it signifieth, saith he, that God is delighted in good workes, and is therewith conciliated, (that is, moved to befriend, as wee say) and induced thereby to doe good unto those that doe well. Which is that that we meane, when we say that works are meritorious. Well it were indeed if they either meant or maintained no more than is here said. Little controversie would there then be betwene us and them.
hQuod nos dicimus mereri, Graeci dicunt [Greek or Hebrew], Bellarm. de Justific. l. 5. c. 2.Quod nos dicimus mereri, Graeci dicunt 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Bellarm. de Iustific. l. 5. c. 2.
i[Greek or Hebrew], i. dignum esse. Idem ibid. imò dignari: ut Cicer. de orat. l. 3.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, i. dignum esse. Idem ibid. imò dignari: ut Cicer. de orat. l. 3.
k[Greek or Hebrew], Schol. Thucyd. [Greek or Hebrew], Suid [Greek or Hebrew]. Schol. Sopho. l.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Schol. Thucyd. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Suid 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Schol. Sopho. l.
lNon ait, ut digni sitis, sed ut digni habeamini, Cajetan. in 2 Thoss. 1.5.
oSensus est, talibus hostiis delectatur, sive placatur Deus, ut habet commentarius Chrysostomi: vel talibus hostiis placetur Deo, ut exponit Oecumenius, Bellarm. de Justific. l. 5. c. 2.Sensus est, talibus hostiis delectatur, sive placatur Deus, ut habet commentarius Chrysostomi: vel talibus hostiis placetur Deo, ut exponit Oecumenius, Bellarm. de Iustific. l. 5. c. 2.
pSignificat. Deum delectari bonis, eisque conciliari, & induci ad benefaciendum iis qui benè operantur, Ibid.
But to let these things pass, lest I be in this point over-long. Do all Catholics deny indeed even to works done of Faith and Grace all merit of condignity? And is there no difference at all among them therein? Yea doth not Bellarmine himself maintain the contrary? Or doth he not know that there is difference among them herein? and that the most of them (of later times especially) go the other way? Yes undoubtedly. But he dealeth herein, as he doth in the point of Adoration of Images. It is aq common Tenet among them, that Images are to be worshipped with the self same worship that those are worshipped with, whose Images they are: and so consequently the Images of God and Christ with divine Worship. And Bellarmine himself, though a little qualifying it, both alloweth and defendeth it,r that by accident, or improperly they may be and are so worshipped; to wit, either sas those Images are Gods or Christs Deputies, and so receive for ⟨p. 279⟩God or Christ himself the worship due to either; or tas men conceive God or Christ clad in that Image, as a King in his robes, and so worship the Image in the same worship together with either. But yet, saith he,u you must not in any wise tell the people so in the Pulpit, that any Images are to be worshipped with Divine worship; but the contrary rather, that they are not to be worshipped. And why so? Forsooth,x because many good Catholics cannot endure to hear that Images should so be adored: and again,y Because it giveth Heretics occasion to speak more freely evil of them.
But to let these things passe, lest I be in this point over-long. Doe all Catholikes deny indeed even to works done of Faith and Grace all merit of condignity? And is there no difference at all among them therein? Yea doth not Bellarmine himselfe maintaine the contrary? Or doth he not know that there is difference among them herein? and that the most of them (of later times especially) goe the other way? Yes undoubtedly. But he dealeth herein, as he doth in the point of Adoration of Images. It is aq common Tenent among them, that Images are to bee worshipped with the selfe same worship that those are worshipped with, whose Images they are: and so consequently the Images of God and Christ with divine Worship. And Bellarmine himselfe, though a little qualifying it, both alloweth and defendeth it,r that by accident, or improperly they may bee and are so worshipped; to wit, either sas those Images are Gods or Christs Deputies, and so receive for ⟨p. 279⟩God or Christ himselfe the worship due to either; or tas men conceive God or Christ clad in that Image, as a King in his roabes, and so worship the Image in the same worship together with either. But yet, saith hee,u you must not in any wise tell the people so in the Pulpit, that any Images are to be worshipped with Divine worship; but the conrtary rather, that they are not to be worshipped. And why so? Forsooth,x because many good Catholikes cannot endure to heare that Images should so be adored: and againe,y Because it giveth Heretikes occasion to speake more freely evill of them.
qImagines coli eadem cultu cum Prototypo, sive quo coluntur, quorum sunt imagines; Christi & Dei latria: est opinio communi Theologorum sententia recepta. Sic Thom. Albert. •alud. Almam. Marsil. Maiol. Capreol. Cajetan. & caeteri juniors. Azor. institut. lib. 8. cap. 6. & Greg. de Valent. de Idolatr. lib. 2. cap. 6.Imagines coli eadem cultu cum Prototypo, sive quo coluntur, quorum sunt imagines; Christi & Dei latria: est opinio communi Theologorum sententia recepta. Sic Thom. Albert. •alud. Almam. Marsil. Maiol. Capreol. Cajetan. & caeteri juniores. Azor. institut. lib. 8. cap. 6. & Greg. de Valent. de Idolatr. lib. 2. cap. 6.
rSi de reipsa agatur, admitti potest Imagines posse coli impropriè vel per accidens, eodem gene•e cultus, quo exemplar ipsum colitur, &c. Bellarmin. de cult. Sanct. lib. 2. cap. 23.
sQuando imago accipitur pro ipso exemplary, cujus vicem gerit, Ibid.Quando imago accipitur pro ipso exemplari, cujus vicem gerit, Ibid.
tCum exemplar consideramus quasi imagine vestitum, &c. Ibid.
uQuantum ad modum loquendi, praefertim in concione ad populum, non est dicendum imagines ulla• adorari debere latria; sed è conirario, non debere sic adorari. Bellarm. ibid c. 22.
And in like manner dealeth he in this matter of Merit. Because our Writers justly tax them for extreme arrogance therein. Bellarmine here flatly denieth it, and saith that none of them maintain it, and we do but belly them in charging them with it. And yet, to pass by what before was alleged out of him; and what he saith elsewhere again, thata the remission of some sins is even in Justice due to mans good merit; Where professedly he handleth the Controversy concerning the merits of mans works, he concludeth the direct contrary to what here he avoweth, and condemneth what he averreth here, as no better than Heresy.
And in like manner dealeth he in this matter of Merit. Because our Writers justly tax them for extreame arrogance therein. Bellarmine here flatly denyeth it, and saith that none of them maintaine it, and we doe but bely them in charging them with it. And yet, to passe by what before was alleaged out of him; and what he saith elsewhere againe, thata the remission of some sinnes is even in Iustice due to mans good merit; Where professedly he handleth the Controversie concerning the merits of mans workes, he concludeth the direct contrary to what here hee avoweth, and condemneth what he averreth here, as no better than Heresie.
aRemissio venialium justo Dei judicio redditur bonis meritis justorum. Bellarm. de Justific l. 1. c. 21.Remissio venialium justo Dei judicio redditur bonis meritis justorum. Bellarm. de Iustific l. 1. c. 21.
The very Title of his Discourse is,b That mens works done of charity do condignly merit or deserve Life eternal; and that,c not only in regard of Gods Covenant, but in regard of the works themselves.
The very Title of his Discourse is,b That mens works done of charity doe condignely merit or deserve Life eternall; and that,c not only in regard of Gods Covenant, but in regard of the works themselves.
bOpera justorum ex charitate facta esse meritoria vitae aeternae ex condigno. Bellar. de Justif. l. 5. c. 16.Opera justorum ex charitate facta esse meritoria vitae aeternae ex condigno. Bellar. de Iustif. l. 5. c. 16.
cNon solum ratione pacti, sed etiam ratione operum, Ibid. c. 17.
In the Discourse it self he telleth us, thatd All Catholics hold that they merit life eternal. Thate some of them indeed would have no mention made either of condignitie, or congruity; fSome go a middle way between congruity and condignity; andg some again would distinguish between dignity and condignity. But thath the common opinion of their Divines admitteth merit of condignity: which he also concludeth with.
In the Discourse it selfe he telleth us, thatd All Catholikes hold that they merit life eternall. Thate some of them indeed would have no mention made either of condignitie, or congruitie; fSome goe a middle way betweene congruity and condignity; andg some againe would distinguish betweene dignity and condignity. But thath the common opinion of their Divines admitteth merit of condignity: which hee also concludeth with.
dCatholici omnes agnoscunt, opera bona justorum esse meritoriá vitae aeternae, Ibid. cap. 16.
eAliqui censent non esse utendum vocibus his de condigno & de congruo. Sed absolutè esse dicendum, Opera justorum esse & meritoria vitae aeternae ex gratia Dei. Ita Thom. Waldens. de Sacram. tom. 3. cap 7. & Paul Burg. addit. ad Lyr. in Psal. 35.
fAlii volunt esse meritoria de condigno largo modo, quod respectu condigni propriè sumpti dicatur congruum, respectu congrui possit dici condignum. Itá Durand. in 2. Sent. d. 27. q. 2. Et Greg. Arimin. in 1. Sent. d. 17. q. 1. art. 2.
gQuidam distinguunt inter dignum & condignum, & meritum ex digno admittunt, non ex condigno.
hCommunis sententia Theologorum admittit simpliciter meritum de condigno. Bellarm. ibid.
Again he saith thati some of their Divines hold, that such works do not merit life eternal condignly, in regard of the work it self, or the worth of it, but in regard of Gods Covenant and his acceptation of them only; And thatk thus only the Ancient Schoolmen held. lOthers, that they merit it condignly in regard of the work it self, and the worth of it, albeit that God with man had made no such agreement at all. mHe himself thinketh best to go the middle way, as he saith the Council of Trent doth; to wit, that they merit it condignly, in regard both of the agreement and the work jointly together. And that we may not mistake his meaning herein, he telleth us further, that he dothn not thus determine, as if he held, that such works did not in regard of the dignity and worth of them well deserve life eternal, albeit no such agreement were; but merit it in regard of Gods gracious acceptance only: ofor it were a disgrace to God, if his grace in us should be so poor ⟨p. 280⟩and imperfect as to merit no otherwise: (as the Louvain Professors also, too base and beggarly for usp to crave it and have it as an alms:) and that they therefore deserve it, becauseq there is a kind of proportion and equality; yea notr a proportionable only, buts an absolute equality (for so he saith in express terms elsewhere) between the work and the wages: And that is properly merit of condignity indeed,t when the work is equal of it self to the wages: which merit of condignitie he saith therefore isu truly and properly, xsimply and absolutely so termed;y Merit in Justice, or of right and due debt: whicha that other of congruity is not. And such works therefore, say our Rhemists, areb truly and properly meritorious, and full worthy of everlasting life, so that Heaven is the due and just stipend or recompense, which God by his justice oweth to persons so working; and thatc so far forth, that he should be unjust, if he should not render Heaven for the same: Albeitd that assertion was by the Divines of Paris almost 300. years since condemned as false and heretical; and by Durandus, saith Bellarmine himself,e it is censured (and that not unjustly) not as bold only, but as blasphemous.
Againe hee saith thati some of their Divines hold, that such workes doe not merit life eternall condignely, in regard of the worke it selfe, or the worth of it, but in regard of Gods Covenant and his acceptation of them onely; And thatk thus onely the Ancient Schoolemen held. lOthers, that they merit it condignly in regard of the worke it selfe, and the worth of it, albeit that God with man had made no such agreement at all. mHe himselfe thinketh best to goe the middle way, as he saith the Councell of Trent doth; to wit, that they merit it condignely, in regard both of the agreement and the worke joyntly together. And that wee may not mistake his meaning herein, he telleth us further, that hee dothn not thus determine, as if he held, that such workes did not in regard of the dignity and worth of them well deserve life eternall, albeit no such agreement were; but merit it in regard of Gods gracious acceptance onely: ofor it were a disgrace to God, if his grace in us should be so poore ⟨p. 280⟩and imperfect as to merit no otherwise: (as the Lovaine Professors also, too base and beggerly for usp to crave it and have it as an almes:) and that they therefore deserve it, becauseq there is a kinde of proportion and equalitie; yea notr a proportionable onely, buts an absolute equality (for so he saith in expresse tearmes elsewhere) betweene the worke and the wages: And that is properly merit of condignity indeed,t when the worke is equall of it selfe to the wages: which merit of condignitie he saith therefore is
iQuidam existimant opera bona non esse meritoria vitae aeternae ex condigno ratione operis, sed tantum ratione pacti, & acceptationis divinae, Bellarm. de Justific. l. 5 c. 17.Quidam existimant opera bona non esse meritoria vitae aeternae ex condigno ratione operis, sed tantum ratione pacti, & acceptationis divinae, Bellarm. de Iustific. l. 5 c. 17.
kIta Scot. in 1. Sent. d. 17. qu. 2. quem alii quoque ex veteribus scholasticis sequuntur.
lNon defunt qui censent esse meritoria ex condigno ratione operis, etiamsi nulla extaret divina conventio. Ita Cajetan. in Thom. p. prima secundae q. 114. a. 1. & Dominic. à Soto de Nat. & Grat. cap. 7.
mNobis media sententia probabilior videtur, esse scil. meritoria ex condigno ratione pacti & operis simul, Bellar. ibid.
nNon quod sine pacto & acceptatione non habeat opus bonum proportionem ad vitam aeternam ex operis dignitate, Ibid.
oDetrabitur de gloria Christi, si merita nostra sint ita imperfecta, ut non sint meritoria ex condigno, nisi ratione acceptationis Dei, Ibid.
pAbsit ut justi vitam aeternam expectent sicut pauperes eleemosynam, multo namque gloriosius est ipsos quasi victores & triumphaetores eam possidere, tanquam palmam suu sudoribus debitam. Ruard. Tapper. explic. art. L•van. tom. 2. c. 9.
qIta ut in bono opere sit quaedam proportio & aequalitas ad praemium, vitae aeternae, Ibid.
rSatis est proportionalis aequalitas, Ibid. c. 18.
sModus futuri judicii erit sec. justitiam commutativam, quoniam Deus non solum constituet proportionalem aequalitatem inter merita & praemia, sed etiam absolutam aequalitatem inter opera & mercedes, Ibid. cap. 14.
tUbi opus est per se equal mercedi, Ibid. l. 1. c. 21. verè par mercedi, Ibid. l. 5. c. 17.Vbi opus est per se aequale mercedi, Ibid. l. 1. c. 21. verè par mercedi, Ibid. l. 5. c. 17.
But why is Gods agreement needful then? or why doth Bellarmine require that also? He telleth you himself; not for any defect or want of worth in the work; butf because that without some such agreement no reward or wages can of right be claimed for any work, albeit of it self otherwise it be never so worthy.
But why is Gods agreement needfull then? or why doth Bellarmine require that also? Hee telleth you himselfe; not for any defect or want of worth in the worke; butf because that without some such agreement no reward or wages can of right be claimed for any worke, albeit of it selfe otherwise it be never so worthy.
fRequiritur pactum & conventio: nisi enim id praecesserit, non potest ex justitia commutativa, neque ex distributiva etiam, opus alterum obligare, quantumvis eximium sit, & equal mercedi, Idem de Justific. l. 5. c. 14.Requiritur pactum & conventio: nisi enim id praecesserit, non potest ex justitia commutativa, neque ex distributiva etiam, opus alterum obligare, quantumvis eximium sit, & aequale mercedi, Idem de Iustific. l. 5. c. 14.
Lastly, he telleth us thatg there want not very grave Authors, who think that every good work of a just man endued with Charity, meriteth or deserveth life eternal. hWhich he thus far forth also subscribeth unto, if this condition be added, that not only the party doing it be endued with Charity, but the very work it self also do actually, or virtually at least proceed from Charity, and be done for Gods sake. So that not only the whole course and tenor of a godly mans life uprightly and religiously led, being laid altogether in one lump, but every particular such action of it, considered alone by it self, should by this their doctrine deserve no less than Heaven at Gods hands. And then belike so oft as they have done any good work merely for Gods sake, so oft have they deserved an Heaven at least of him. It were absurd and senseless for a sorry beggar to imagine (that I may use Bellarmines own comparison) that by weeding though a whole day in the Kings garden at White-hall, he had in regard of the worth of the work done by him, deserved an hundred Jacobuses, because his Majesty had promised for his days work to give him such wages.i Bellarmine himself will not deny it. But it were much more absurd for such an one to imagine, that for every weed that in ⟨p. 281⟩that his days work he had pulled up (were it done out of never so much love to his Sovereign) he had deserved, I say not an Earldom, or a Dukedom, but a Crown at least or a Kingdom. And yet is there far greater disproportion here between the work that we do, and the reward that we expect, than could there be between the work and the wages: Since thatk between finite and infinite there is no proportion at all. And therefore saith our Country-man Thomas of Walden, though no friend to Wycliffe; for he wrote professedly against him;l What can we do that should be worthy of heavenly things, which the Apostle saith, thatm The sufferings of this life are not worthy of? nI account him therefore the sounder Divine, the better Catholic, (and the Protestants belike then are the better Catholics herein), and one that agreeth more with Gods Word, that simply and utterly denieth such Merit.
Lastly, hee telleth us thatg there want not very grave Authors, who thinke that every good worke of a just man endued with Charitie, meriteth or deserveth life eternall. hWhich he thus farre forth also subscribeth unto, if this condition be added, that not onely the partie doing it be endued with Charitie, but the very worke it selfe also doe actually, or virtually at least proceed from Charitie, and be done for Gods sake. So that not only the whole course and tenour of a godly mans life uprightly and religiously led, being laid altogether in one lumpe, but every particular such action of it, considered alone by it selfe, should by this their doctrine deserve no lesse than Heaven at Gods hands. And then belike so oft as they have done any good worke meerly for Gods sake, so oft have they deserved an Heaven at least of him. It were absurd and senslesse for a sorry beggar to imagine (that I may use Bellarmines owne comparison) that by weeding though a whole day in the Kings garden at White-hall, hee had in regard of the worth of the worke done by him, deserved an hundred Iacobusses, because his Majestie had promised for his dayes worke to give him such wages.i Bellarmine himselfe will not deny it. But it were much more absurd for such an one to imagine, that for every weed that in ⟨p. 281⟩that his dayes worke he had pulled up (were it done out of never so much love to his Soveraigne) he had deserved, I say not an Earledome, or a Dukedome, but a Crowne at least or a Kingdome. And yet is there farre greater disproportion here betweene the worke that we doe, and the reward that we expect, than could there be between the worke and the wages: Since thatk betweene finite and infinite there is no proportion at all. And therefore saith our Country-man Thomas of Walden, though no friend to Wickliffe; for he wrote professedly against him;l What can we doe that should be worthy of heavenly things, which the Apostle saith, thatm The sufferings of this life are not worthy of? nI account him therefore the sounder Divine, the better Catholike, (and the Protestants belike then are the better Catholikes herein), and one that agreeth more with Gods Word, that simply and utterly denieth such Merit.
gNon desunt gravissimi Autores, qui sentiant, Omne opus bonum hominis justi & habitu charitatis praediti, vitae aeternae meritorium esse, Ibid. c. 15.
hProbabilius videtur ad meritum exigi, ut opus bonum, vel tunc cum fit, actu imperetur à charitate, atque in Deum ut finem ultimum referatur; vel certè nascatur ab actu imperato à charitate, atque in Deum ante relato; quod est virtute non actu in Deum referri, Ibid.
iSi opus aliquod sit multo inferius mercede ex conventione promissa, ut si Dominus vineae conduceret operariors, & non denarium diurnum, sed centum nummos aureos pro mercede promitteret, non esset meritumex condigno ratione operis, Bellar. de Justific. l. 5. c. 17.Si opus aliquod sit multo inferius mercede ex conventione promissa, ut si Dominus vineae conduceret operariors, & non denarium diurnum, sed centum nummos aureos pro mercede promitteret, non esset meritumex condigno ratione operis, Bellar. de Iustific. l. 5. c. 17.
kFiniti ad infinitum nulla est proportio. itaque rectè Fulgent. ad Monim lib. 1. Tantum ibi gratia, divinae retributions exub•rat, ut incomparabiliter atque ineffabiliter omne meritum quamvis bonae & ex Deo datae humanae voluntatis & operationis excedat.
lQuid dignum facimus ut participes coelestibus fieri inveniamur? &c. Thom. Wald. citante Vega de merit. q. 4.
oAnd though a man, saith an uncertain Author, but alleged commonly by them, as Eusebius Emissenus, should with all the strength of body and mind exercise himself to the utmost, in obedience to God all his life long, yet could he bring out nothing, that by way of condigne merit could countervail Heavens happiness. For, considering the extent and continuance of it,p if we cast our reckonings up aright, saith Augustine, it should be eternal travel at least, that should purchase eternal rest. And considering the dignity and excellency of it,q Though a man, saith Anselm, should serve God in most fervent manner for a thousand years together, yet should he not thereby condignly merit to be but half a day in Heaven. Andr though the godly have done a whole million of good deeds, saith Chrysostom, yet that such a Crown, such an Heaven, and so great Honour should for so small piddling matters (in comparison thereof) be conferred on them, it is of Gods free Grace, and (as he there also implieth) not of due debt, or of their desert. For,s It is of justice, saith he, that the other are punished; it is of grace that these are crowned, that is, there ist deserved pain, as Augustine speaketh, repaid the one, Grace undeserved freely bestowed on the other. Anselm, it seemeth, thought he could not in an hundred, nay in a thousand years, do that, that they are able to do in less than an hour. He thought and taught that a man could not in a thousand years, by all that ever he did, or could do, merit half a days abode in Heaven; and they think and teach (if they think at least as they teach) that a man may in much less than half a days space do that, that shall merit more than a thousand thousand years, even an eternal abode in Heaven. Chrysostom thought a man could not with a million of good works do that, that they think they can do with any one alone. For so many thousands of them, saith he, cannot in justice deserve the Kingdom of Heaven. Any one alone, say they, of those that we do, can do it. Jacob deemed himself unable with all that he had done or could do, to require those favours, even in his Temporal estate, that God had conferred upon him:
oAnd though a man, saith an uncertaine Author, but alleaged commonly by them, as Eusebius Emissenus, should with all the strength of body and minde exercise himselfe to the utmost, in obedience to God all his life long, yet could he bring out nothing, that by way of condigne merit could countervaile Heavens happinesse. For, considering the extent and continuance of it,p if we cast our reckonings up aright, saith Augustine, it should bee eternall travell at least, that should purchase eternall rest. And considering the dignity and excellency of it,q Though a man, saith Anselme, should serve God in most fervent manner for a thousand yeers together, yet should hee not thereby condignly merit to bee but halfe a day in Heaven. Andr though the godly have done a whole million of good deeds, saith Chrysostome, yet that such a Crowne, such an Heaven, and so great Honour should for so small pidling matters (in comparison thereof) be conferred on them, it is of Gods free Grace, and (as he there also implieth) not of due debt, or of their des•rt. For,s It is of justice, saith hee, that the other are punished; it is of grace that these are crowned, that is, there ist deserved paine, as Augustine speaketh, repaid the one, Grace undeserved freely bestowed on the other. Anselme, it seemeth, thought he could not in an hundred, nay in a thousand yeeres, doe that, that they are able to doe in lesse than an houre. Hee thought and taught that a man could not in a thousand yeers, by all that ever he did, or could doe, merit halfe a dayes abode in Heaven; and they thinke and teach (if they thinke at least as they teach) that a man may in much lesse than halfe a daies space doe that, that shall merit more than a thousand thousand yeers, even an eternall abode in Heaven. Chrysostome thought a man could not with a million of good works doe that, that they thinke they can doe with any one alone. For so many thousands of them, saith he, cannot in justice deserve the Kingdome of Heaven. Any one alone, say they, of those that wee doe, can doe it. Iacob deemed himselfe unable with all that hee had done or could doe, to require those favours, even in his Temporall estate, that God had conferred upon him:
oTotis licet animae & corporis laboribus desudemus, totis licet obedientiae viribus exerceamur, nihil tamen condignum merito pro coelestibus bonis compensare & offer valebimus, Eus. Emiss. nomine, hom. 3. ad Monach.Totis licet animae & corporis laboribus desudemus, totis licet obedientiae viribus exerceamur, nihil tamen condignum merito pro coelestibus bonis compensare & offerre valebimus, Eus. Emiss. nomine, hom. 3. ad Monach.
pQuanto labore digna est requies quae non habet finem? Si verum vis computare & verum judicare; aeterna requies aeterno labour rectè emitur. Sed noli timere: in sericors est Deus, Aug. in Psal. 93.Quanto labore digna est requies quae non habet finem? Si verum vis computare & verum judicare; aeterna requies aeterno labore rectè emitur. Sed noli timere: in sericors est Deus, Aug. in Psal. 93.
qSi homo mille annis serviret Deo etiam ferventissime, non meretur ex condigno dimidiam diem esse in regno caelorum, Anselm. de Mensur, c•uc. c. 2.
r[Greek or Hebrew], Chrysost. in Matth. hom 79.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Chrysost. in Matth. hom 79.
s[Greek or Hebrew]. Idem ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Idem ibid.
tNon tibi reddit debitam •oenam, sed donat indebitam gratiam, Aug. in Psal. 31.
These men hold that they can by some one good deed of theirs alone, not requite God only for what ⟨p. 282⟩they have already received of him, (foru that must be done first,x which no man indeed can do, ere they can merit ought at his hands) but engage him also to do further deservedly for them, even to the conferring of life eternal, and celestial glory on them.
These men hold that they can by some one good deed of theirs alone, not requite God onely for what ⟨p. 282⟩they have already received of him, (foru that must be done first,x which no man indeed can doe, ere they can merit ought at his hands) but engage him also to doe further deservedly for them, even to the conferring of life eternall, and celestiall glory on them.
uFacilius & minus est reddere aequivalens ejus quod quis accepit ab ali•, quameum constituere debitorem: quia ad constituendum eum debitorem requiritur quod plus reddat quam acceperit, ut sic ratione plurium alius efficiatur debitor, Durand. in 2. Sent d. 27. q. 2.
xEtsi proximo forte videatur quis reddere plus quam debeat; Deo tamea nemo unquam reddit quod debet. Bernard. de Divers. 36. Et hinc Thom. Bradward. de Caus. Dei, lib. 1. cap. 39. Nullus potest reddere plenarie debitum quod accepit à Deo, quare nec quicquam mereri ab eo ex pure debito & condigno.
Thus we have seen, both what they hold, howsoever they seem sometime ashamed of it, and therefore one while deny, what another while they affirm: As also how contrary their presumptuous conceits and positions in this kind are to the humble confessions and acknowledgements of Gods sincere Servants, as well recorded in the Word, as reported else-where, yeaa related, alleged, and taken notice of by themselves.
Thus we have seene, both what they hold, howsoever they seeme sometime ashamed of it, and therefore one while deny, what another while they affirme: As also how contrary their presumptuous conceits and positions in this kinde are to the humble confessions and acknowledgements of Gods sincere Servants, as well recorded in the Word, as reported else-where, yeaa related, alleaged, and taken notice of by themselves.
aVide supra ex Bellarm. de Justific. lib. 5. cap. 7.Vide supra ex Bellarm. de Iustific. lib. 5. cap. 7.
Use 4 But to leave them to theirb proud and Pharisaical fancies, and return home again to our selves; this lastly should persuade us with the Apostle Saint Paul, cto rest content with whatsoever estate God shall see good to place us in, with whatsoever he shall please to confer on us, and afford us, or whatsoever he shall think fit to call us unto; considering that we are not worthy of ought, but unworthy wholly of whatsoever we have, be it more or less. And if we be unworthy of what we have, be it never so little; then have we more than we are worthy of, even when we have least: And if we have more than we are worthy of; then have we no cause to repine, murmur, grow discontent, or complain, if we have not so much as such and such have; if we cannot go, or fare as such and such do; if we have not so good trading, or our houses so well furnished, our wives and children so apparelled, as such and such have.
Vse 4 But to leave them to theirb proud and Pharisaicall fancies, and returne home againe to our selves; this lastly should perswade us with the Apostle Saint Paul, cto rest content with whatsoever estate God shall see good to place us in, with whatsoever he shall please to confer on us, and afford us, or whatsoever he shall think fit to call us unto; considering that we are not worthy of ought, but unworthy wholly of whatsoever we have, be it more or lesse. And if we be unworthy of what we have, be it never so little; then have we more than we are worthy of, even when we have least: And if wee have more than wee are worthy of; then have wee no cause to repine, murmure, grow discontent, or complaine, if wee have not so much as such and such have; if we cannot goe, or fare as such and such doe; if we have not so good trading, or our houses so well furnished, our wives and children so apparelled, as such and such have.
bSuperbiae species est, qua quu credit habere pro meritis suis bona, quae à Deo habet. Gul. Perald sum. tom. 2. tract. 6. part. 3. c. 2.
Errors 2 This it is a great fault in the World, in this age of ours especially, Error 1 an age of excess; whereind each one striveth to go beyond another, in pride of apparel, in building, in expense in all kind of superfluity and excess; thate like men that run in a race, we cast our eyes forward on those that go before us, but we forget to look back unto those that come short of us.f Men and women look upon those many times that are of higher degree than themselves, and would fain match them, and go even with them. Or suppose it be but on those, that are of the same rank with themselves: they see how they go, how they fare, how they spend; (and it is many times much more than they are well able to do, or than their means will well afford) and because they are loth to come behind any of their own degree; (that they deem were a disgrace to them;) they begin to think thus with themselves; What difference is there betwixt us and them? and why should not we then do as they do? And hence arisethg a discontent in their minds, because they want means to do what they desire. Which their discontent, with their present estate, together with the inordinate and immoderate desire of that which they have not, and fain would have, only because they see others have it; is not only an occasion ⟨p. 283⟩hto deprive and bereave them (withi Haman, and k Ahab) of the comfort and benefit of what they have; butl it is as a grave also, to bury in the thankful remembrance of those manifold mercies that God hath vouchsafed them, above many other, (it may be) even of their own rank; as if God had done nothing for them, (as those murmuring Jews charged him,m Wherein hast thou loved us? that is, showed any love to us, done ought for us?) unless they may spend, and go, and be maintained in it, as such and such do. Yea so far oft doth this corruption prevail with not a few, that withn the Frog in the Fable, hthey stretch their states so far to get even with others, that at length all cracketh and cometh to nought, and both they and theirs rue it in the end.
Errours 2 This it is a great fault in the World, in this age of ours especially, Errour 1 an age of excesse; whereind each one striveth to goe beyond another, in pride of apparell, in building, in expence in all kinde of superfluitie and excesse; thate like men that runne in a race, we cast our eyes forward on those that goe before us, but we forget to look backe unto those that come short of us.f Men and women looke upon those many times that are of higher degree than themselves, and would faine match them, and goe even with them. Or suppose it bee but on those, that are of the same rancke with themselves: they see how they goe, how they fare, how they spend; (and it is many times much more than they are well able to doe, or than their means will well afford) and because they are loth to come behinde any of their owne degree; (that they deeme were a disgrace to them;) they beginne to thinke thus with themselves; What difference is there betwixt us and them? and why should not we then doe as they doe? And hence arisethg a discontent in their minds, because they want meanes to doe what they desire. Which their discontent, with their present estate, together with the inordinate and immoderate desire of that which they have not, and faine would have, onely because they see others have it; is not onely an occasion ⟨p. 283⟩hto deprive and bereave them (withi Haman, and k Ahab) of the comfort and benefit of what they have; butl it is as a grave also, to bury in the thankfull remembrance of those manifold mercies that God hath vouchsafed them, above many other, (it may be) even of their owne ranke; as if God had done nothing for them, (as those murmuring Iewes charged him,m Wherein hast thou loved us? that is, shewed any love to us, done ought for us?) unlesse they may spend, and goe, and be maintained in it, as such and such doe. Yea so farre oft doth this corruption prevaile with not a few, that withn
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Hesiod. Oper. lib. 1. Vicinus dives cupiditatem irritat. Sen. epist. 7.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Hesiod. Oper. lib. 1. Vicinus dives cupiditatem irritat. Sen. epist. 7.
eInstat equis auriga suis vincentibus; illum Fraeteritum temnens extremos inter euntem, Horat. Sat. 1.
f[Greek or Hebrew]. Plut. de Tranquil.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plut. de Tranquil.
g[Greek or Hebrew]. Chrysost. in 2 Thessal. Homil. 2. Quod enixe concupiscunt ut sit, centabescunt quod esse non possit, Gilbert. in Cant. 19.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Chrysost. in 2 Thessal. Homil. 2. Quod enixe concupiscunt ut sit, centabescunt quod esse non possit, Gilbert. in Cant. 19.
h[Greek or Hebrew], Plutarch. de Tranquil.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Plutarch. de Tranquil.
l[Greek or Hebrew]. Plut. ibid. Quantumlibet saepe obligati, si quid unum neges, hoc solum meminerunt quod negatum est, Plin. epist. 4. lib. 3. [Greek or Hebrew], Basil. Caesar. hom. 5. Qu•d facit oblivionem acceptorum? cupiditas accipiendorum, Senec. epist. 82. Non quid habeamus, sed quid petamus, inspicimus; non in id quod est, sed quod appetitur intenti. Nec ea intuemur que nos aliis praeposuere; sed ea solum quae praecedentium fortuna ostentat. Non potest quisquam & invidere & gratias agere. Idem de benef. lib. 3. cap. 3. Non quod habet numerat; tantum quod non habet, optat. Manil. Astronom. l.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plut. ibid. Quantumlibet saepe obligati, si quid unum neges, hoc solum meminerunt quod negatum est, Plin. epist. 4. lib. 3. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Basil. Caesar. hom. 5. Qud facit oblivionem acceptorum? cupiditas accipiendorum, Senec. epist. 82. Non quid habeamus, sed quid petamus, inspicimus; non in id quod est, sed quod appetitur intenti. Nec ea intuemur que nos aliis praeposuere; sed ea solum quae praecedentium fortuna ostentat. Non potest quisquam & invidere & gratias agere. Idem de benef. lib. 3. cap. 3. Non quod habet numerat; tantum quod non habet, optat. Manil. Astronom. l.
Again, others having sometime had more plentiful means, Error 2 and having then (as they might well do) proportioned their expense accordingly thereunto; when it pleaseth God to withdraw that their plenty in part, for causes best known to himself, and it may be among others, to try them, how they will take it, whether they will say with our Saviour,o Not my will, but thy will be done, and so practise what they dailyp pray; and with Job, qGod hath given, and God hath taken again; blessed be his Name; andr so return God his own with thanks: Yet out of a pride of heart and stoutness of stomach, (s Many are humbled, saith Bernard, yet are not humble:) not enduring to strike sail, or to stoop an inch, they will strive to live still according to their former means, and shape their expense not by what they have, but by what they have had: and so whereas the Lord in mercy had yet left them a competency still,t they cast the helve (as we say) after the hatchet, and overthrow all: Oru they grow into such inward grief and discontent, ⟨p. 284⟩because they cannot do still as formerly they have done, as either breaketh their hearts and shorteneth their days, or altogether disableth them unto the cheerful performance of any good office either to God or man.
Againe, others having sometime had more plentifull meanes, Errour 2 and having then (as they might well doe) proportioned their expence accordingly thereunto; when it pleaseth God to withdraw that their plenty in part, for causes best knowne to himselfe, and it may be among others, to trie them, how they will take it, whether they will say with our Saviour,o Not my will, but thy will bee done, and so practise what they daylyp pray; and with Iob, qGod hath given, and God hath taken againe; blessed be his Name; andr so returne God his owne with thankes: Yet out of a pride of heart and stoutnesse of stomacke, (s Many are humbled, saith Bernard, yet are not humble:) not enduring to strike saile, or to stoupe an inch, they will strive to live still according to their former meanes, and shape their expence not by what they have, but by what they have had: and so whereas the Lord in mercy had yet left them a competency still,t they cast the helve (as wee say) after the hatchet, and overthrow all: Oru they grow into such inward griefe and discontent, ⟨p. 284⟩because they cannot doe still as formerly they have done, as either breaketh their hearts and shortneth their dayes, or altogether disableth them unto the cheerfull performance of any good office either to God or man.
oMatth. 26.39. [Greek or Hebrew]; Epictet. Arian. dissert. l. 2. c. 17. Deus quae voluit qui vult, semper est foelix. Sic enim homo ab humanis in divina dirigitur, cum voluntati humanae voluntas divina praefertur. August. in Joan 52. Vide quid aequins sit, aut te voluntati divinae conformando subdere, aut quod ipsa tuae subserviat voluntati, Gerson. consol. Theol. l. 2. c. 1.Matth. 26.39. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Epictet. Arian. dissert. l. 2. c. 17. Deus quae voluit qui vult, semper est foelix. Sic enim homo ab humanis in divina dirigitur, cum voluntati humanae voluntas divina praefertur. August. in Ioan 52. Vide quid aequins sit, aut te voluntati divinae conformando subdere, aut quod ipsa tuae subserviat voluntati, Gerson. consol. Theol. l. 2. c. 1.
qJob 1.21. Abstulit: sed & dedit. Sen. ep. 87. Tulisti, quoniam tuus erat, Bern. de Temp. 110.Iob 1.21. Abstulit: sed & dedit. Sen. ep. 87. Tulisti, quoniam tuus erat, Bern. de Temp. 110.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. Epictet. Enchir. [Greek or Hebrew]; Idem Arian. dissert. l. 1. c. 11. Ita Hieron. ad Julian. Tulifti liberos quos ipse dederas. Non contristor quod recepisti; ago gratias quod dedisti. Et Julian. Imper. apud Ammian. l. 25 Vitam reposcenti naturae, tanquam debitor bonae fidei redditurus exulto.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Epictet. Enchir. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Idem Arian. dissert. l. 1. c. 11. Ita Hieron. ad Iulian. Tulifti liberos quos ipse dederas. Non contristor quod recepisti; ago gratias quod dedisti. Et Iulian. Imper. apud Ammian. l. 25 Vitam reposcenti naturae, tanquam debitor bonae fidei redditurus exulto.
sQuanti humiliantur, & humiles non sunt? Bern. in Cant. 34. Et nec fractis cer vicibus inclinantur, Hieron. ad Aug. ep. 26.
All which corruptions might soon be helped, if we could with Jacob here say, and think as we say; Non sum dignus, Domine; Lord I am not worthy of ought. If we would look out abroad, buta cast our eyes now and then on those that have far less than we have. As Aristippus, when a friend of his came to condole with him for some land that he had lost, demanded of him what he had to live on himself, and when he made answer that he had but some one small close only, he told him, thatb there was cause rather for Aristippus to bemoan him, than for him to bemoan Aristippus, who had more than thrice as much land still left him to live on than he had. It is hard but we should find some, withc the Cynic, yea not a few be we never so needy, that would be glad of our relics. Or▪ if we would butd cast our eyes home-ward, and consider our selves, and our own unworthiness of ought, we might soon see how little cause we have to be discontent in such cases. For have we but little left? It is more than we deserve. Hath God taken much from us? he might well have took more. As Anytus, a Gentleman of Athens, told his guests that were at table with him, when Alcibiades a young Gallant came in a revelling humour and took away the one half of his plate that stood either for show or service upon the cupboard, and they marvelled much at it, that Anytus could so take it, affirming that he had dealt very unkindly with them,e Nay rather, quoth he, he hath dealt very kindly with us, that he hath left us half, when he might have took all: for it was all his, or at his command. So it is here indeed. He taketh part, thatf gave all; and that might therefore as well take all as part; becauseg all is but his own. They tell of a Jewish Doctor, that was calledh Rabbi This-too, because he used always to say, whatsoever befell him,i This is good too, and this too, and this too, and this too, &c. And in like manner may we well say, how little soever be left us, This is more than I am worthy of, and this too, and this too, &c. If God shall again and again too, never so often, impair our estates, and by piece-meal withdraw from us what he hath formerly conferred on us:
All which corruptions might soone be helpt, if we could with Iacob here say, and thinke as we say; Non sum dignus, Domine; Lord I am not worthie of ought. If we would looke out abroad, buta cast our eyes now and then on those that have farre lesse than we have. As Aristippus, when a friend of his came to condole with him for some land that he had lost, demanded of him what he had to live on himselfe, and when he made answer that he had but some one small close onely, he told him, thatb there was cause rather for Aristippus to bemoane him, than for him to bemoane Aristippus, who had more than thrice as much land still left him to live on than he had. It is hard but wee should finde some, withc the Cynick, yea not a few be we never so needy, that would bee glad of our reliques. Or▪ if wee would butd cast our eyes home-ward, and consider our selves, and our owne unworthinesse of ought, we might soone see how little cause we have to be discontent in such cases. For have we but little left? It is more than we deserve. Hath God taken much from us? hee might well have tooke more. As Anytus, a Gentleman of Athens, told his guests that were at table with him, when Alcibiades a young Gallant came in a revelling humour and tooke away the one halfe of his plate that stood either for shew or service upon the cupboard, and they marvelled much at it, that Anytus could so take it, affirming that he had dealt very unkindly with them,e Nay rather, quoth he, he hath dealt very kindly with us, that he hath left us halfe, when he might have tooke all: for it was all his, or at his command. So it is here indeed. He taketh part, thatf gave all; and that might therefore as well take all as part; becauseg all is but his owne. They tell of a Iewish Doctor, that was calledh Rabbi This-too, because hee used alwayes to say, whatsoever befell him,i This is good too, and this too, and this too, and this too, &c. And in like manner may wee well say, how little soever be left us, This is more than I am worthie of, and this too, and this too, &c. If God shall againe and againe too, never so often, impaire our estates, and by peece-meale withdraw from us what hee hath formerly conferred on us:
a[Greek or Hebrew], Plut. de Tranquil. [Greek or Hebrew], Favorin. —majori see pauperiorum Turbae comparet, —Horat. Sat. 1. Si vis gratus esse adversus Deum, & adv. vitam tuam, cogita quam multos antecesseris. Cum aspexeris quot te antecedant, cogita quot sequantur, Senec. ep. 15. Aspice quanto major pars sit pauperum. Idem ad Helv. cap. 12.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Plut. de Tranquil. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Favorin. —majori se pauperiorum Turbae comparet, —Horat. Sat. 1. Si vis gratus esse adversus Deum, & adv. vitam tuam, cogita quam multos antecesseris. Cum aspexeris quot te antecedant, cogita quot sequantur, Senec. ep. 15. Aspice quanto major pars sit pauperum. Idem ad Helv. cap. 12.
b[Greek or Hebrew]; Aristip. apud Plut. de Tranquill.〈non-Latin alphabet〉; Aristip. apud Plut. de Tranquill.
c[Greek or Hebrew], Diogen. apud Plut. de prof. not. de muribus; quos & reliqis suis vescentes parasitos suos appestitabat, Laert.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Diogen. apud Plut. de prof. not. de muribus; quos & reliqis suis vescentes parasitos suos appestitabat, Laert.
d[Greek or Hebrew], —Homer. Odyss. [Greek or Hebrew]. & Diog. apud Laert. & Plut. de Sanit. tuend. Domum redeamus, Cic. Bruto.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, —Homer. Odyss. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. & Diog. apud Laert. & Plut. de Sanit. tuend. Domum redeamus, Cic. Bruto.
e[Greek or Hebrew], Athen. Dipnosoph. l. 12 Vel ut Plut. in Alcib. [Greek or Hebrew], Pulo, tamen Plut. ex Athen. castigandum: qui & in Erot. sic extulit, [Greek or Hebrew] Xyland.) [Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Athen. Dipnosoph. l. 12 Vel ut Plut. in Alcib. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Pulo, tamen Plut. ex Athen. castigandum: qui & in Erot. sic extulit, Xyland.) .
And consequently ask he said to one that though with loss of goods, had in safety yet escaped himself to the shore,l not repine or murmur for what is lost, but be thankful to Godm for what is left, andn for what formerly we have had.
And consequently ask he said to one that though with losse of goods, had in safety yet escaped himselfe to the shore,l not repine or murmur for what is lost, but be thankfull to Godm for what is left, andn for what formerly wee have had.
kDoles quod amisisti? gaude quod evasisti, Sen. excerpt. do remed. fortuit.
l[Greek or Hebrew], Plut. de Tranquil,〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Plut. de Tranquil,
Hitherto we have considered of Jacobs unworthiness, by himself Particular 2 here acknowledged:1 we come now to see Gods undeserved goodness to Jacob.
Hitherto wee have considered of Iacobs unworthinesse, by himselfe Particular 2 here acknowledged:1 wee come now to see Gods undeserved goodnesse to Iacob.
Unworthy of all thy Mercies; saith Jacob. And,o who pcrowneth, or qObserv. 3 environeth thee rather, with Mercies; saith the Psalmist: andr doth not deal with thee according to thy deserts. sFor if he should so do, he should damn thee; saith Augustine. And,t who so trusteth in the Lord, Mercy shall uencompass him on every side; saith David.
Vnworthie of all thy Mercies; saith Iacob. And,o who pcrowneth, or qObserv. 3 invironeth thee rather, with Mercies; saith the Psalmist: andr doth not deale with thee according to thy deserts. sFor if he should so doe, hee should damne thee; saith Augustine. And,t who so trusteth in the Lord, Mercie shall uencompasse him on every side; saith David.
pCoronat te. Vulg. & Vatabl. quia [Greek or Hebrew] corona. Unde Aug. de verb. Ap. 2. Post redemptionem ab omni corruptione quid restat nisi corona justitiae? Ipsa certè restat; sed etiam sub ipsa vel in ipsa non fit caput turgidum, ut recipiat coronam. Dicturus erat, Coronat me; merita mea fatetur, &c. debitum redditur non donatur. Audi, &c. De miscricordia te coronat, de miseratione te coronat. Non enim dignus fuisti quem vocaret, & vocatum justificaret, & justificatum glorificaret. Et de sp. & lit. c. 33. Hoe fiet in judicio, ubi necessarium fuit commemorare miseric. & miserat. Ubi jam exigi debita & ready merita sic possent videri, ut nullus esset misericordiae locus. Necessaria itaque est nobis Salvatoris misericordia, sive cum convertimur, sive cum praeliamur, sive cum coronamur. Idem de Corrept. & Grat. cap. 13.Coronat te. Vulg. & Vatabl. quia 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 corona. Vnde Aug. de verb. Ap. 2. Post redemptionem ab omni corruptione quid restat nisi corona justitiae? Ipsa certè restat; sed etiam sub ipsa vel in ipsa non fit caput turgidum, ut recipiat coronam. Dicturus erat, Coronat me; merita mea fatetur, &c. debitum redditur non donatur. Audi, &c. De miscricordia te coronat, de miseratione te coronat. Non enim dignus fuisti quem vocaret, & vocatum justificaret, & justificatum glorificaret. Et de sp. & lit. c. 33. Hoe fiet in judicio, ubi necessarium fuit commemorare miseric. & miserat. Vbi jam exigi debita & reddi merita sic possent videri, ut nullus esset misericordiae locus. Necessaria itaque est nobis Salvatoris misericordia, sive cum convertimur, sive cum praeliamur, sive cum coronamur. Idem de Corrept. & Grat. cap. 13.
qCingit, vel circumtegit, Jun. [Greek or Hebrew] sicut Psal. 5.12. Benevolentiâ tuâ tanquam umbone circumteges eum.Cingit, vel circumtegit, Iun. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 sicut Psal. 5.12. Benevolentiâ tuâ tanquam umbone circumteges eum.
sNam si secundum merita tibi daret, damnaret te, August. in Psal. 102. Si quod debetur redderet, utique damnaret. Idem in Psal. 31. Si vellet pro meritis agere, non inveniret, nisi quod damnaret. Idem in Psal. 94.
Now this point, 1that all that we either receive or expect is of Gods Mercy, howsoever it be by the former consideration sufficiently confirmed. Forx if we be not worthy of ought, then is nothing of merit. And if nothing of merit, then all consequently of mercy.
Now this point, 1that all that we either receive or expect is of Gods Mercie, howsoever it be by the former consideration sufficiently confirmed. Forx if we be not worthy of ought, then is nothing of merit. And if nothing of merit, then all consequently of mercie.
Consid. 1 First, the Promises of God run all upon Mercy. a2Showing mercy to thousands, with them that love him, and keep his Commandments. And,b His mercy is for ever and ever on those that fear him; cand keep Covenants with him, and think upon his Commandments to do them. And,d I will spare them (and there is mercy then) that fear me, and think on my Name, as a man spareth his Son that serveth him. eThere shall be judgement without mercy to those that show no mercy. And,f If without mercy to those that show no mercy; then with mercy even to those also that show mercy; saith Augustine. Yea so saith our Saviour himself;g Blessed are the merciful; for they shall have mercy showed them. And,h The grace of God is (i that is, bringeth) life eternal; saith the Apostle. Which place Augustine entreating of,k The Apostle, saith he, having said, the wages of sin is ⟨p. 286⟩Death; because everlasting death is repaid as of debt due to the service of Sin and Satan; he doth not say, albeit he might also so have said; but the reward of Righteousness is Life eternal: But he chose rather to say, Gods Grace (or lfree favour) is Life eternal; that thereby we might learn that God bringeth us to Life eternal, not for our Merits, but of his Mercy. In regard whereof Tertullian also very fitly termeth (alluding to military matters)m the one a Stipend, the other a Donative; because, as Bernard saith well,n it cannot be had but by donation, or free gift. Ando if of free gift, then not of due debt, or desert for any work done, saith Hilary. For,p gift and debt cannot stand together; saith Faber. Yea Cardinal Cajetan himself on those words of the Apostle, qHe saith not, The wages of righteousness is Life eternal; but the grace, that is, the gift of God, is life eternal; that we may understand that we attain life eternal not by our merits, but by Gods free gift. For which cause also he addeth, In Christ Jesus our Lord. rBehold the merit; behold the righteousness, the wages whereof is life eternal; but to us in regard of Christ himself it is a gift. And lastly, to add one place more of so many as might be added;s With thee is mercy, saith the Psalmist to God: for thou wilt reward every man according to his works. Concerning which words Gregory, (on that of the Psalmist, tMake me to hear thy mercy in the morning;
Consid. 1 First, the Promises of God run all upon Mercy. a2Shewing mercie to thousands, with them that love him, and keepe his Commandements. And,b His mercy is for ever and ever on those that feare him; cand keepe Covenants with him, and thinke upon his Commandements to doe them. And,d I will spare them (and there is mercy then) that feare me, and thinke on my Name, as a man spareth his Sonne that serveth him. eThere shall bee judgement without mercy to those that shew no mercy. And,f If without mercy to those that shew no mercie; then with mercie even to those also that shew mercy; saith Augustine. Yea so saith our Saviour himselfe;g Blessed are the mercifull; for they shall have mercie shewed them. And,h The grace of God is (i that is, bringeth) life eternall; saith the Apostle. Which place Augustine entreating of,k The Apostle, saith he, having said, the wages of sinne is ⟨p. 286⟩Death; because everlasting death is repaied as of debt due to the service of Sin and Satan; he doth not say, albeit he might also so have said; but the reward of Righteousnesse is Life eternall: But he chose rather to say, Gods Grace (or lfree favour) is Life eternall; that thereby wee might learne that God bringeth us to Life eternall, not for our Merits, but of his Mercy. In regard whereof Tertullian also very fitly tearmeth (alluding to militarie matters)m
eJam. 2.13. Misericordiam qui non praestat alteri, tollit sibi. Chrysol. ser. 42.Iam. 2.13. Misericordiam qui non praestat alteri, tollit sibi. Chrysol. ser. 42.
fIn illo judicio, in que justi coronantur, & injusti damnantur, alii cum misericordia, alii sine miseric. judicandi. Nam cum dicit, Judicium erit sine miseric. iis qui non fecerunt misericordiam manifestatur in his, in quibus inveniuntur bona opera misericordiae judicium cum misericordia fieri, ac per hoc ipsam etiam misericordiam meritis bonorum operum reddi, Aug. de Corrept. & Grat. c. 13.In illo judicio, in que justi coronantur, & injusti damnantur, alii cum misericordia, alii sine miseric. judicandi. Nam cum dicit, Iudicium erit sine miseric. iis qui non fecerunt misericordiam manifestatur in his, in quibus inveniuntur bona opera misericordiae judicium cum misericordia fieri, ac per hoc ipsam etiam misericordiam meritis bonorum operum reddi, Aug. de Corrept. & Grat. c. 13.
whichu he expoundeth the resurrection) having moved this Question; xIf the happiness of the Saints be of mercy, and not of merit, how is it said, Thou wilt render to each one according to his works? If according to mens works it be rendered, how may it be deemed mercy? He thus answereth;y It is one thing to render according to works, and another thing to render the reward for the works themselves. aIn the one is noted only the quality of the work, (a far other exposition thanb Bellarmine giveth of it) that those that have done well, shall receive a royal reward. (And in the other then consequently should be implied an equality between the work and the wages. But)c No labour or work of ours, (nothing that we can either do or endure) by the Apostles own testimony, can be equal to, or once compared with that blessed life, wherein men shall live of God and with God. For,d the sufferings of this life, (yeae all of them, if any one man could and should undergo them all, saith Bernard, ffrom the very beginning of the world too, saith Macarius, unto the worlds end) are not worthy, saith the Apostle, of the Glory that shall be revealed (g not, unto us, as he also well observeth, but) in us. And,h what are all mans merits then, saith Bernard, to it; that it should of right be due to them: or that God should do men wrong, if he bestowed it not ⟨p. 287⟩on them? asi our Rhemists before affirmed that he should.k The grace therefore of salvation is not due to works, saith Faber, (l which the Popish purgers cross out of him) but to the goodness of God alone. mNor doth mans salvation consist in mans merits, but in Gods mercy, saith Origen.
whichu he expoundeth the resurrection) having moved this Question; xIf the happinesse of the Saints be of mercy, and not of merit, how is it said, Thou wilt render to each one according to his works? If according to mens works it be rendred, how may it bee deemed mercy? Hee thus answereth;y It is one thing to render according to workes, and another thing to render the reward for the workes themselves. aIn the one is noted onely the quality of the worke, (a farre other exposition thanb Bellarmine giveth of it) that those that have done well, shall receive a royall reward. (And in the other then consequently should be implied an equalitie between the worke and the wages. But)c No labour or worke of ours, (nothing that we can either doe or endure) by the Apostles owne testimonie, can be equall to, or once compared with that blessed life, wherein men shall live of God and with God. For,d the sufferings of this life, (yeae all of them, if any one man could and should undergoe them all, saith Bernard, ffrom the very beginning of the world too, saith Macarius, unto the worlds end) are not worthy, saith the Apostle, of the Glory that shall bee revealed (g not, unto us, as he also well observeth, but) in us. And,h what are all mans merits then, saith Bernard, to it; that it should of right be due to them: or that God should doe men wrong, if hee bestowed it not ⟨p. 287⟩on them? asi our Rhemists before affirmed that he should.
xSi illa Sanctorum foelicitas &c. misericordia est, & non meritis •oquiritur, •bi erit, quod scriptum est, Et tu reddes &c. Si secundum opera redditur, quomodo misericordia aestimabitur?
ySed aliud est focund•m opera reddere, & aliud propter ipsa opera reddere, Greg. ibid.
aIn eo quod sec. opera dicitur, ipsa operum qualitas intelligitur, ut cujus apparuerint bona opera, ejus sit & retributio gloriosa, Ib.
b[Greek or Hebrew] rectè vertitur, second. in meritum, vel promerito & dignitate operum. Quid est enim reddere sec. opera, nisi reddere sicut opera merentur? Bellarm. de justific. l. 5 c. 2.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 rectè vertitur, secund. in meritum, vel promerito & dignitate operum. Quid est enim reddere sec. opera, nisi reddere sicut opera merentur? Bellarm. de justific. l. 5 c. 2.
cIlli namque beatae vitae, in qua cum Deo & de Deo vivitur, nullus poterit aequari labour, nulla opera comparari, &c. Greg. ibid.Illi namque beatae vitae, in qua cum Deo & de Deo vivitur, nullus poterit aequari labor, nulla opera comparari, &c. Greg. ibid.
dRom 8.18. Minora sunt omnia quae patimur & indigna, pro quorum laboribus tanta rependatu futurorum merces bonorum, Amb. epist. 12.
eNe si unus quidem universas sustineret, Bern. de Temp. 48.
f[Greek or Hebrew], Macar. homil. 15.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Macar. homil. 15.
g[Greek or Hebrew]. Non dicit, nobis, sed, in nobis. Neque enim crimus otiosi spectatores, sed participes gloiae, 1 Joan. 3.2. Bern. de Praecept. & Dispens.
Consider. 2 Again, the prayers of Gods Saints strike all upon this string. Of David, Chrysostom observeth,1 that though he weren a man of singular parts for sincerity and piety, byo Gods own testimony of him; andp had many good deeds that he might have alleged, yetq in all his prayers ordinarilyr he hath recourse only to Gods mercy, sthat alone he pleadeth, that alone he relieth upon, tand desireth to be saved by. uLet others, saith he, allege and plead what they list; xI will hope in thy mercy: that I plead and allege, and that do I hang all mine hope upon. And,y Have mercy on me, and hear me; andz Have mercy on me, for I am weak. And,a The same song, saith he, have we need to sing every one of us, albeit we had done ten thousand times ten thousand good deeds, and attained even to the very highest pitch and perfection of righteousness: bfor it is yet of mercy and loving kindness still that we are heard, and that we are saved for all that. So the same David again else-where,c But thou Lord deal mercifully with me for thy Names sake. And,d Save me for thy Mercy sake. eFor thy mercy, not for my merit, saith Augustine. fFor thy mercy, not for my righteousness, saith Ruffine. gNot because I am worthy, but because thou art merciful, saith Chrysostom. hHe flieth only to Gods goodness and his loving kindness: iCommending Gods free grace, not claiming ought as due to his good deeds, saith Prosper. It is as if he had said;k I entreat thee to save me, saith Gregory, not trusting to mine own merits, but presuming only to obtain that of thy mercy, which by mine own merits I have no hope to obtain: Or,l I entreat thee to hear me, not in thy judiciary severity, but in thy most merciful bounty; saith Augustine. mHe renounceth his own merit; andn he desireth to be heard, saith Cassiodore, not according to his merits, but for Gods mercy sake: whereon when our hope is fixed, pardon is the easilier obtained. And,o Let thy mercy also betide me, and thy salvation, according to thy Word. pAccording to thy Word, not according to my merit; qA child he would be not of pride, but of the promise, saith Augustine. And again;r For thy Name sake be merciful to my sin: for it is much. sFor thy Name, not for my merit; saith Ruffine: and Bernard; tBe I never so penitent, and afflict and macerate my self never so much.
Consider. 2 Againe, the prayers of Gods Saints strike all upon this string. Of David, Chrysostome observeth,1 that though he weren a man of singular parts for sincerity and piety, byo Gods owne testimony of him; andp had many good deeds that hee might have alleaged, yetq in all his prayers ordinarilyr he hath recourse onely to Gods mercy, sthat alone he pleadeth, that alone he relieth upon, tand desireth to be saved by. uLet others, saith he, alleage and plead what they list; xI will hope in thy mercie: that I plead and alleage, and that doe I hang all mine hope upon. And,y Have mercy on me, and heare me; andz Have mercy on me, for I am weake. And,a The same song, saith he, have we need to sing every one of us, albeit we had done ten thousand times tenne thousand good deeds, and attained even to the very highest pitch and perfection of righteousnesse: bfor it is yet of mercy and loving kindnesse still that wee are heard, and that wee are saved for all that. So the same David againe else-where,c But thou Lord deale mercifully with me for thy Names sake. And,d
1The Saints Prayers.
n[Greek or Hebrew], Chrysost. de Compunct. 2.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Chrysost. de Compunct. 2.
uHe attributeth his ⟨p. 288⟩whole salvation to the mercy of his Saviour, saith Cardinal Hugh. And,x In mercy remember me, or think upon me, for thy goodness sake, O Lord. yNot in wrath, as I am worthy; but as is worthy of thee in thy mercy; saith Augustine. zFor thy goodness, not for any merit of mine; saith Peter Lombard. For,a When he saith, For thy goodness, his meaning is, and he would so be understood, Not for my merit; saith Cassiodore. Who thence also observeth that,b No man without grievous error, may presume at anytime thereon. And yet again;c For thy Name sake guide and conduct me. dFor thy Name, not for my merit; saith Augustine, and Hugh the Cardinal after him:e Not for my worth, desert, or dignity, but for thy Glory. And Hilary on those words of his,f Hear my voice according to thy mercy, or thy loving kindness, O Lord. gWe, saith he, when we have fasted some once, out of vain-glory, or given ought to a beggar for his mere importunity, think that God is bound by and by to hear us; hWhereas David after all his hearty crying, his night watchings, his early meditations, his continency in his younger years, his diligent enquiry into Gods Statutes, and his careful keeping of his Testimonies, having attained to a perfection in all kind of goodness, yet hath his hope wholly in God, and expecteth all from his mercy, placeth all his hope in it, and desireth to be heard according to it. And Chrysostom preaching upon the Prayer of Eleazer, entreatingi mercy and kindness for his Master Abraham; (k and whose merits might better have been pleaded than his?)l That you may not imagine, saith he, that he demanded it as a debt, Deal mercifully or show mercy, saith he, to my master Abraham. mThough we had done ten thousand good deeds, saith he, yet is it of grace that we require to be saved, and of loving kindness, not of debt or desert, that we look to receive this. So the Apostle;n The Lord show mercy to Onesiphorus his family. (The Lord show him mercy, because he showed me mercy.) For he often refreshed me, and was not ashamed of my chains; but when he was at Rome he diligently sought me and found me; and in how many things he steaded me (or supplied me) at Ephesus, thou well knowest. And,o the Lord grant therefore, that he may find mercy with the Lord in that day. pThat as he sought me and found me;
uHe attributeth his ⟨p. 288⟩whole salvation to the mercy of his Saviour, saith Cardinall Hugh. And,x In mercie remember me, or think upon me, for thy goodnesse sake, O Lord. yNot in wrath, as I am worthy; but as is worthy of thee in thy mercy; saith Augustine. zFor thy goodnesse, not for any merit of mine; saith Peter Lombard. For,a When he saith, For thy goodnesse, his meaning is, and he would so be understood, Not for my merit; saith Cassiodore. Who thence also observeth that,b No man without grievous errour, may presume at anytime thereon. And yet againe;c For thy Name sake guide and conduct me. dFor thy Name, not for my merit; saith Augustine, and Hugh the Cardinall after him:e Not for my worth, desert, or dignitie, but for thy Glory. And Hilary on those words of his,f Heare my voyce according to thy mercy, or thy loving kindnes, O Lord. gWe, saith he, when wee have fasted some once, out of vaine-glory, or given ought to a begger for his meere importunitie, thinke that God is bound by and by to heare us; hWhereas David after all his hearty crying, his night watchings, his early meditations, his continency in his younger yeeres, his diligent enquirie into Gods Statutes, and his carefull keeping of his Testimonies, having attained to a perfection in all kinde of goodnesse, yet hath his hope wholly in God, and expecteth all from his mercy, placeth all his hope in it, and desireth to be heard according to it. And Chrysostome preaching upon the Prayer of Eleazer, entreating
uTotam salutem suam hic attribuit misericordiae salvatoris, Hugo in Psal. 24.
yNon secundum iram, qua ego dignus sum; sèd sec. misericordiam tuam, quae te digna est, Aug. in Psal 24.
zNon propter meritum meum, sed propter bonitatem tuam. Ex Aug. Alcuin. & Gloss. Ordin. Lomb. in Psal. 24.
aDicendo, Propter bon. t.D. fecit intelligi, Non propter mer. meum. Cassiod. ibid.
bUnde nullum fas est aliquando praesumere, nisi quem graviter contingit errare, Idem ibid.Vnde nullum fas est aliquando praesumere, nisi quem graviter contingit errare, Idem ibid.
gNos si semel jejunamus ut hominibus placeamus, aut exiguum nescio quid damus, dum pulsantem fores nostras inopem non sustinemus; deberi nobis ut audiamur existimamus, Hilar. in Psal. 118. part. 19.
hPost haec &c. in operibus bonitatis totius perfectus, totum de Deo sperat, totum ex misericordia ejus expectat, omnem in ea spem reponit, audiri secundum eam vocem suam rogat, Ibid.
cVeniam Arbitione precante meruerunt. Ammian. hist. l. 15. Quia Dei filium Judaea contemosit, Gentilit •s promeruit. Greg. in 1 Reg. 2. Maria sola mater Domini fieri meruit. Eusebii Emiss. nomine in Dominic. 4. Advent. Parere meruit eum, qu•m constat nullum habu•sse peccatum. Aug. de Nat. & Grat. c. 36. Ipsum Deum hominem fact•m & co•cipere & parere non h•manis meritis, sed concepti nascentisque ex ea summi Dei dignatione promeruit. Fulgent. de Grat. & Incarn. c. 7 Letiores interim quod virgas evaserint, quàm quod meruerint principatum, Bernardus De pueris ad praelaturam promotis, Epist. 42. Itaque ingenuè Vega de Justificat. lib. 8. cap. 8. agnoscit, usurpari apud Patres nomen Meriti, ubi nulla est ratio Meriti, neque de congruo, neque de condigno.Veniam Arbitione precante meruerunt. Ammian. hist. l. 15. Quia Dei filium Iudaea contemosit, Gentilit •s promeruit. Greg. in 1 Reg. 2. Maria sola mater Domini fieri meruit. Eusebii Emiss. nomine in Dominic. 4. Advent. Parere meruit eum, qu•m constat nullum habu•sse peccatum. Aug. de Nat. & Grat. c. 36. Ipsum Deum hominem fact•m & co•cipere & parere non h•manis meritis, sed concepti nascentisque ex ea summi Dei dignatione promeruit. Fulgent. de Grat. & Incarn. c. 7 Letiores interim quod virgas evaserint, quàm quod meruerint principatum, Bernardus De pueris ad praelaturam promotis, Epist. 42. Itaque ingenuè Vega de Iustificat. lib. 8. cap. 8. agnoscit, usurpari apud Patres nomen Meriti, ubi nulla est ratio Meriti, neque de congruo, neque de condigno.
dMiles Gallicanis sudoribus nec donativum meruit, nec stipendium. Ammian. histor. l. 17.
eSolent meritum appellare quemlibet actum bonum, ratione cujus aliquid aliud accipimus: ut ex Augustino perspicue patet, Bellar. de Grat. & lib. Arb. l. 1. c 14.
fMercedem quandam esse dicimus, quae magis debetur ex gratia, quam ex justitia; sive quae imputetur sec. gratiam, & non sec. debitum. Idem de Justific. l. 1. c. 21.Mercedem quandam esse dicimus, quae magis debetur ex gratia, quam ex justitia; sive quae imputetur sec. gratiam, & non sec. debitum. Idem de Iustific. l. 1. c. 21.
gSi propriè appellentur ea quae dicimus merita nostra, spei quaedam sunt seminaria, charitatis incentiva, occultae praedestinationis indicta, futurae glorificationis praesagia, via regni, non causa regnandi, Bernard. de Grat. & lib. arb.
truly and properly meritorious, and full worthy of everlasting life, so that Heaven is the due and just stipend or recompence, which God by his justice oweth to persons so working; and that
dDamnatum Parisiis an. Dom. 1354. Fr. Guidonis enunciatum hoc: Quod homo meretur vitam aeternam de condigno: quod si non daretur ei, fieret injuria, & quod Deus faceret sibi injuriam. In Bibliothec. Patr. tom. 4. edit. 2.
eTemerarium & blasphemum esse dicere, Deum fore injustum si meritis hominum justorum non reddat mercedem, &c. Ex Durando Bellarm. de Justific. l. 5. c. 16. Vide Durandum in 2. Sent. d. 27. q. 2. Nam quod Bellarm. promissam, addit, de suo est.Temerarium & blasphemum esse dicere, Deum fore injustum si meritis hominum justorum non reddat mercedem, &c. Ex Durando Bellarm. de Iustific. l. 5. c. 16. Vide Durandum in 2. Sent. d. 27. q. 2. Nam quod Bellarm. promissam, addit, de suo est.
they stretch their states so farre to get even with others, that at length all cracketh and commeth to nought, and both they and theirs rue it in the end.
•
mIn quo dilenisti nos? Malac. 1.2. Et sic isti, [Greek or Hebrew]; (ita quippe legendum.) [Greek or Hebrew], Plut. de Tranquil.In quo dilenisti nos? Malac. 1.2. Et sic isti, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; (ita quippe legendum.) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Plut. de Tranquil.
nInops potentem dumb vult imitari perit. In prato quodam rana conspexit bovem, Et tacta invidia tantae magnitudinis, Rugosam inflavit pellem; tum natos suos interrogavit, an bove esset latior. Illi negarant; rursus intendit cutem major nisu. —Novissimè indignata dumb vult validius inflare sese, rupto jacuit corpore. Phaedr. Fab. 28. Vide•tur & Horat. serm. l. 2. Sat. 3. Hinc Martial. l. 10. epist. 79. Grandis ut exiguam bos ranam ruperat slim; Sic, puto, Torquatus rumpet Otacilium. Sanum itaque Greg. Naz consilium de Eutax. [Greek or Hebrew].Inops potentem dum vult imitari perit. In prato quodam rana conspexit bovem, Et tacta invidia tantae magnitudinis, Rugosam inflavit pellem; tum natos suos interrogavit, an bove esset latior. Illi negarant; rursus intendit cutem majore nisu. —Novissimè indignata dum vult validius inflare sese, rupto jacuit corpore. Phaedr. Fab. 28. Vide•tur & Horat. serm. l. 2. Sat. 3. Hinc Martial. l. 10. epist. 79. Grandis ut exiguam bos ranam ruperat •lim; Sic, puto, Torquatus rumpet Otacilium. Sanum itaque Greg. Naz consilium de Eutax. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
[Greek or Hebrew], Plut. de Tranquil. Meritò itaque Comic. Stitch. 1. 2. Eam mulierem sapientem praedicat, quae aequo animo pati potest sibi esse pejus quam fuit.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Plut. de Tranquil. Meritò itaque Comic. Stich. 1. 2. Eam mulierem sapientem praedicat, quae aequo animo pati potest sibi esse pejus quam fuit.
u[Greek or Hebrew], Dion. Caff. hist. l. 57. Apicius cum sestertiûm millies in culinam congessisset, aere alieno oppressus, rationibus inspectis, superfuturum sibi festertiûm centies computavit, & velut in ultima fame victurus si festertiúm centies vixisset, veneno vitam finivit, Sen. ad Helv. c. 10. Hinc Martial. lib. 3. epist. 22. Dederas, Apici, ter trecenties ventri: Sed adhuc supererat centies tibi laxum. Hoc tu gravatus ut famem & sitim, far, summa venenum potion duxisti. Nil est, Apici, tibi gulosius factum.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Dion. Caff. hist. l. 57. Apicius cum sestertiûm millies in culinam congessisset, aere alieno oppressus, rationibus inspectis, superfuturum sibi festertiûm centies computavit, & velut in ultima fame victurus si festertiúm centies vixisset, veneno vitam finivit, Sen. ad Helv. c. 10. Hinc Martial. lib. 3. epist. 22. Dederas, Apici, ter trecenties ventri: Sed adhuc supererat centies tibi laxum. Hoc tu gravatus ut famem & sitim, ferre, summa venenum potione duxisti. Nil est, Apici, tibi gulosius factum.
i[Greek or Hebrew] Etiam hoc bonum est, Et hoc etiam; Et hoc; Sic Ezech. Esa. 39.8. Et Antigonus morbo correptus leviusculo, [Greek or Hebrew]. Plut. Apophth. [Greek or Hebrew], &c. Plut. de Tranquill.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Etiam hoc bonum est, Et hoc etiam; Et hoc; Sic Ezech. Esa. 39.8. Et Antigonus morbo correptus leviusculo, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Plut. Apophth. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. Plut. de Tranquill.
the one a Stipend, the other a Donative; because, as Bernard saith well,
He saith not, The wages of righteousnesse is Life eternall; but the grace, that is, the gift of God, is life eternall; that we may understand that we attaine life eternall not by our merits, but by Gods free gift. For which cause also he addeth, In Christ Iesus our Lord.
Behold the merit; behold the righteousnesse, the wages whereof is life eternall; but to us in regard of Christ himselfe it is a gift. And lastly, to adde one place more of so many as might bee added;
With thee is mercy, saith the Psalmist to God: for thou wilt reward every man according to his works. Concerning which words Gregorie, (on that of the Psalmist,
Sicut Ioan. 12.50. & 17.3. Quod & Piscator observat.
kMors meritò stipendium, quia militiae Diabolicae mors aeterna tanquam debitum redditur. Ubi cum posset dicere, & rectè dicere, Stipendium justitiae vita; maluit dicere, Gratia Dei vita aeterna, ut hinc intelligeremus, Deum nos ad vitam aternam, non pro meritis nostris, sed pro sua miseratione perducere, August. de Grat. & lib. arb. cap. 9. & Gloss. Ordin. in Rom. 6.Mors meritò stipendium, quia militiae Diabolicae mors aeterna tanquam debitum redditur. Vbi cum posset dicere, & rectè dicere, Stipendium justitiae vita; maluit dicere, Gratia Dei vita aeterna, ut hinc intelligeremus, Deum nos ad vitam aternam, non pro meritis nostris, sed pro sua miseratione perducere, August. de Grat. & lib. arb. cap. 9. & Gloss. Ordin. in Rom. 6.
lGratia nisi gratis sit, gratia non est, August. Enchir. c. 107. Gratia enim vocatur, quia gratis datur. Idem in Joan. 3. Quomodò est ergò gratia, si non gratis datur: quomodo est gratia, si ex debito redditur? Idem de Grat. Christi, c. 23. Nisi gratuita non est gratia. Ibid. c. 31. Nullo modo est gratia, nisi fuerit omni modo gratuita. Idem de pecc. Orig. cap. 24.Gratia nisi gratis sit, gratia non est, August. Enchir. c. 107. Gratia enim vocatur, quia gratis datur. Idem in Ioan. 3. Quomodò est ergò gratia, si non gratis datur: quomodo est gratia, si ex debito redditur? Idem de Grat. Christi, c. 23. Nisi gratuita non est gratia. Ibid. c. 31. Nullo modo est gratia, nisi fuerit omni modo gratuita. Idem de pecc. Orig. cap. 24.
mMortis stipendium; Vitae donativum. Tertul. de Resurr. carn. Quo vocabulo usus est & Durand. in 2. Sent. d. 27. q. 2.
nAeternam vitam nullis potes operibus promereri, nisi gratis detur & illa, Bern. de Temp. 48. Unde & scitè subjungit Idem ibid. Ipse enim peccata condonat, ipse donat merita, & praemia nihilominus ipse redonat.Aeternam vitam nullis potes operibus promereri, nisi gratis detur & illa, Bern. de Temp. 48. Vnde & scitè subjungit Idem ibid. Ipse enim peccata condonat, ipse donat merita, & praemia nihilominus ipse redonat.
oMerces ex dono nulla est, quae debetur ex opere. Hilur. in Matth. Can. 20.
pDebitum & donum non consistunt, Faber. in Rom. 8.
qNon dicit, quod stipendia justitiae vita aeterna: ut intelligamus non ex nostris meritis, sed ex gratuito Dei dono assequi nos vitam aeternam, Cajet. in Rom. 6.
rEcce meritum; ecce justitia, cujus stipendium est vita aelerna: nobis autem est don•m ratione ipsius Christi Jesu. Idem ibid.Ecce meritum; ecce justitia, cujus stipendium est vita aelerna: nobis autem est don•m ratione ipsius Christi Iesu. Idem ibid.
Nor doth mans salvation consist in mans merits, but in Gods mercy, saith Origen.
•
〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Non dicit, nobis, sed, in nobis. Neque enim crimus otiosi spectatores, sed participes glo•iae, 1 Ioan. 3.2. Bern. de Praecept. & Dispens.
hQuid sunt merita omnia ad tantam gloriam? Non sunt talia hominum merita, ut propter ca vita aeterna debeatur ex jure; aut Deus injuriam faceret, si eam non donaret, Bern. de Temp. 48. Itaque scitè Prosper. in Psal. 102. Per candem misericordiam dantur corona meritorum, per quam data sunt merita coronarum.
kNeque gratia salutis operibus debetur, sed solius Dei bonitati, Jac. Faber. in Luc. 3.Neque gratia salutis operibus debetur, sed solius Dei bonitati, Iac. Faber. in Luc. 3.
lDeleatur, Index expurg. Belgic.
mNon in Meritis, sed in misericordia Dei salus humana consistit, Origen. in Rom. l. 9. cap. 11.
I intreat thee to save me, saith Gregory, not trusting to mine owne merits, but presuming onely to obtaine that of thy mercy, which by mine owne merits I have no hope to obtaine: Or,
he desireth to be heard, saith Cassiodore, not according to his merits, but for Gods mercy sake: whereon when our hope is fixed, pardon is the easilier obtained. And,
ePropter misericordiam tuam, non propter meritum meum, August. in Psal. 6. & Ruffin. ibid.
fIn misericordia tua, non in justitia mea. Ruffin. in Psal. 30.
g[Greek or Hebrew], Chrysost. in Psal. 108. Non quia ego sum dignus, sed quia tu es misericors, August. in Psal. 30. Conc. 3.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Chrysost. in Psal. 108. Non quia ego sum dignus, sed quia tu es misericors, August. in Psal. 30. Conc. 3.
h[Greek or Hebrew], Chrysost. ibid.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Chrysost. ibid.
iGratuita gratia commendatur, non ex operum debito, Prosper. post Aug. in Psal. 108.
kNon de meis meritis conf•dens, ut me salvum facias supptico, sed de sola misericordia tua praesumens impetrare, quod non de meritis meis spero, Greg. in Psal. Foenit. 1.
lNoli me audire secundum judiciariam severitatem, sed sec. misericordissimam bonitatem, Aug. in Psal 30. & ex eodem Lombard. ibid.
nSalvum se petit fieri, non sec. merita sua, sed propter divinam misericordiam: in qua dum fixa spes ponitur, venia facilius impetratur, Idem in Psal. 6.
sPropter nomen tuum, non propter meritum meum, Ruffin. im Psal. 24.
tSed & quantumlibet poeniteat, quantumlibet see afflictet & maceret, Propter nomen tuum, non propter meritum meum propitiaberis peccato meo, ait justus, Bern. de Divers. 22.Sed & quantumlibet poeniteat, quantumlibet se afflictet & maceret, Propter nomen tuum, non propter meritum meum propitiaberis peccato meo, ait justus, Bern. de Divers. 22.
Though we had done ten thousand good deeds, saith he, yet is it of grace that we require to be saved, and of loving kindnesse, not of debt or desert, that we looke to receive this. So the Apostle;
The Lord shew mercy to Onesiphorus his family. (The Lord shew him mercy, because he shewed me mercy.) For he often refreshed me, and was not ashamed of my chaines; but when hee was at Rome he diligently sought me and found me; and in how many things he steeded me (or supplied me) at Ephesus, thou well knowest. And,
pUt sicut Apostolum requirens invenit, sic & misericordiam quaerens inveniat apud judicem, Ambr. nomine in 1 Tim. 1.Vt sicut Apostolum requirens invenit, sic & misericordiam quaerens inveniat apud judicem, Ambr. nomine in 1 Tim. 1.