6. And indeed which may be a sixth instance of the thing in proof; though that which Peter and Paul said was a truth, that the Gentiles should not be pressed to the observation of Moses Law upon necessity of salvation, yet they did not so fully speak to the resolution of the Question; nor would that they said have satisfied the consciences of the Churches in their present practice, if James had seen no further, or spake no more in the resolving of the Question then they did. For, notwithstanding what Peter and Paul said, They might have eaten things offered to Idols, and blood, and things strangled, which at that time had been a sin against the law of nature, and a great scandal and offence to the Jews, and so notwithstanding this determination, the divisions would have been greater, the rents wider, the scandal more dangerous then before; the Jews they should have gone on in a total abstinence of all Ceremonies, which might have been scandalous to some Gentiles; and the Gentiles should have gone on in eating blood, meats offered to Idols, and things strangled, which had been highly scandalous to the Jews; which certainly had Paul or Peter acted here as Apostles, by virtue of the immediate inspired spirit, they could not have overseen, nor had they let it pass•. By all which to me it seems clear that the Apostles and Elders in this Convention, did not act by virtue of an immediate inspired spirit, nor had they any ⟨p. 301⟩further extraordinary assistance of the spirit,1 but as ordinary Pastors and Elders in this act. That this Synod or Convention was led by the holy Ghost, is evident by vers. 25, 28. where it is said, It seemeth good to the holy Ghost and us,—But that this was the holy Ghost immediately inspiring the Apostles and Elders upon these grounds alleged, I deny. But that it was the ordinary concurrence of the spirit, such as ordinary Pastors and Elders may have in the truth; And thus Whitaker himself (notwithstanding all those former passages) affirms, saying, That other lawful Councils may in like manner assert their decrees to be the decrees of the holy Ghost, if they were like to this Council, and if they did observe the same rule which the Apostles did observe and follow in this Council, meaning the word of truth.
6. And indeed which may be a sixth instance of the thing in proof; though that which Peter and Paul said was a truth, that the Gentiles should not be pressed to the observation of Moses Law upon necessity of salvation, yet they did not so fully speak to the resolution of the Question; nor would that they said have satisfied the consciences of the Churches in their present practice, if James had seen no further, or spake no more in the resolving of the Question then they did. For, notwithstanding what Peter and Paul said, They might have eaten things offered to Idols, and blood, and things strangled, which at that time had been a sinne against the law of nature, and a great scandall and offence to the Jews, and so notwithstanding this determination, the divisions would have been greater, the rents wider, the scandall more dangerous then before; the Jews they should have gone on in a totall abstinence of all Ceremonies, which might have been scandalous to some Gentiles; and the Gentiles should have gone on in eating blood, meats offered to Idols, and things strangled, which had been highly scandalous to the Jews; which certainly had Paul or Peter acted here as Apostles, by vertue of the immediate inspired spirit, they could not have overseen, nor had they let it pass•. By all which to me it seems clear that the Apostles and Elders in this Convention, did not act by vertue of an immediate inspired spirit, nor had they any ⟨p. 301⟩further extraordinary assistance of the spirit,1 but as ordinary Pastours and Elders in this act. That this Synod or Convention was led by the holy Ghost, is evident by vers. 25, 28. where it is said, It seemeth good to the holy Ghost and us,—But that this was the holy Ghost immediately inspiring the Apostles and Elders upon these grounds alledged, I deny. But that it was the ordinary concurrence of the spirit, such as ordinary Pastours and Elders may have in the truth; And thus Whitaker himself (notwithstanding all those former passages) affirmes, saying, That other lawfull Councels may in like manner assert their decrees to be the decrees of the holy Ghost, if they were like to this Councel, and if they did observe the same rule which the Apostles did observe and follow in this Councel, meaning the word of truth.
- 1Possunt alia legitima concilia similiter asserere decreta sua esse decre•a spiritus fancti, si huic concilio similia fuerint, & si eandem regulam servaverint, quam in hoc concilio servaverint & secuti sunt Apostoti. Wh•t cont. 3. q. •. c. 2. p. 610. a