Now, if it be the first of these, viz. an act of apostolical power, as many conceive, who yet hold up this ordinance of Excommunication, yea, and from that place also, 1 Cor. 5.2, 7, 13. then did it die with the Apostles, and we have nothing to do with it: It is utterly inimitable and impracticable, by ordinary Elders and officers. And if it be the second, viz. That this delivering up to Satan be the formality of Excommunication, then it will follow, when there is not such a delivering up to Satan, there is no Excommunication: which I think few will say. And the condition of persons, not only censured, but censuring, doth prevail much with me not to think: and if it be the third, viz. a further degree of the censure, then either a degree prudentially to be annexed according to the atrocity and heinousness of the fact; of which I see not any warrant: or it is a degree necessarily to be added: and if so, then is it inseparable from the censure, nor can the censure be dispensed without it, and so it is of the formality of it; which to me is not so evident. But if this delivering up to Satan be the consequent and fruit of the censure, as the fourth opinion saith, and many upon good grounds do choose rather to affirm; then the controversy will be at an end in this particular. For those brethren of the Congregational way do affirm, That when a Synod met together in the Name of Christ, 1have in the authority of Christ solemnly judged, condemned, and censured such an erring Church, to be such an one as hath no right to any Church-ordinance, nor is to have any communion with the Churches of Christ: if this judgement be right, then such a Congregation is thereby put out of the kingdom of ⟨p. 308⟩Christ, and consequently is put under the power, and kingdom of Satan.
Now, if it be the first of these, viz. an act of apostolicall power, as many conceive, who yet hold up this ordinance of Excommunication, yea, and from that place also, 1 Cor. 5.2, 7, 13. then did it die with the Apostles, and we have nothing to doe with it: It is utterly inimitable and impracticable, by ordinary Elders and officers. And if it be the second, viz. That this delivering up to Satan be the formality of Excommunication, then it will follow, when there is not such a delivering up to Satan, there is no Excommunication: which I thinke few will say. And the condition of persons, not only censured, but censuring, doth prevail much with me not to thinke: and if it be the third, viz. a further degree of the censure, then either a degree prudentially to be annexed according to the atrocity and heinousnesse of the fact; of which I see not any warrant: or it is a degree necessarily to be added: and if so, then is it inseparable from the censure, nor can the censure be dispenced without it, and so it is of the formality of it; which to me is not so evident. But if this delivering up to Satan be the consequent and fruit of the censure, as the fourth opinion saith, and many upon good grounds doe chuse rather to affirm; then the controversie will be at an end in this particular. For those brethren of the Congregationall way do affirm, That when a Synod met together in the Name of Christ, 1have in the authority of Christ solemnly judged, condemned, and censured such an erring Church, to be such an one as hath no right to any Church-ordinance, nor is to have any communion with the Churches of Christ: if this judgement be right, then such a Congregation is thereby put out of the kingdome of ⟨p. 308⟩Christ, and consequently is put under the power, and kingdom of Satan.
- 1Borough. Heart division, p. 44.Burrough. Heart division, p. 44.