pp. 120–12516 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Vers. 13. And thou sayest, how doth God know?
As if Eliphaz had said, thou art so far from making that right improvement which thou oughtest of these truths, that the Lord is in the height of heaven, and that he hath made those high and glorious lights in heaven, that indeed thou doest quite pervert his meaning in making them; Thou sayest, how doth God know? In stead of honouring God who formed these lights, thou art darkening his honour, and eclipsing the light of his omniscience. For whereas thou shouldest have said, seeing God is on high, and hath made the Stars, which are so high, surely nothing can be hid from his knowledge, Thou sayest, How doth God know? And there is a twofold saying of this; first, a saying with the tongue; secondly, with the heart; The vain heart of man hath many sayings, and this among the rest,1 How doth God know? (Psal. 14.1.) The fool hath said in his heart, there is no God. And he that saith in his heart, How doth God know? speaks as foolishly as that fool doth, who saith, There is no God. To deny that or doubt whether God knoweth all things, is not only to doubt but to deny that God is at all; He is not God who knoweth not all things.
As if Eliphaz had said, thou art so farre from making that right improvement which thou oughtest of these truths, that the Lord is in the height of heaven, and that he hath made those high and glorious lights in heaven, that indeed thou doest quite pervert his meaning in making them; Thou sayest, how doth God know? In stead of honouring God who formed these lights, thou art darkning his honour, and ecclipsing the light of his omniscience. For whereas thou shouldest have sayd, seeing God is on high, and hath made the Starres, which are so high, surely nothing can be hid from his knowledge, Thou sayest, How doth God know? And there is a twofold saying of this; first, a saying with the tongue; secondly, with the heart; The vaine heart of man hath many sayings, and this among the rest,1 How doth God know? (Psal. 14.1.) The foole hath said in his heart, there is no God. And he that saith in his heart, How doth God know? speakes as foolishly as that foole doth, who saith, There is no God. To deny that or doubt whether God knoweth all things, is not onely to doubt but to deny that God is at all; He is not God who knoweth not all things.
And thou sayest, how doth God know? The conjunctive particle And, is here put as a causal, And thou sayest; that is, therefore thou sayest, how doth God know? So the sense is more clear, Is not God in the height of heaven, &c. He is. And what then? The use thou makest of it is this; Thou sayest, how doth God know? so the ⟨p. 121⟩particle is used (Gen. 49.16.) He saw that rest was good, and he gave his shoulders to the burden, &c. that is, therefore he gave his shoulders to the burden.
And thou sayest, how doth God know? The conjunctive particle And, is here put as a causal, And thou sayest; that is, therefore thou sayest, how doth God know? So the sense is more cleare, Is not God in the height of heaven, &c. He is. And what then? The use thou makest of it is this; Thou sayest, how doth God know? so the ⟨p. 121⟩particle is used (Gen. 49.16.) He saw that rest was good, and he gave his shoulders to the burthen, &c. that is, therefore he gave his shoulders to the burthen.
Thou sayest, How doth God know?
We may answer; First, Negatively, Not by sense, as we; eyes and ears are ascribed to God improperly in Scripture; nor doth God know by discourse, drawing one thing from another; but in the Affirmative, he knows intuitively, he knows every thing nakedly in it self.
Wee may answer; First, Negatively, Not by sence, as wee; eyes and eares are ascribed to God improperly in Scripture; nor doth God know by discourse, drawing one thing from another; but in the Affirmative, he knowes intuitively, he knowes every thing nakedly in it selfe.
Again, Some read, What doth God know? how far doth his eye extend? what are the objects of his knowledge? To this we may answer, God knoweth all things; even the hearts of all the children of men; There are no secrets to God. But whether we expound it of the manner or matter of divine knowledge, the sense is the same, either an affirmation that God did not know all things, or at least a doubt whether he did or no. Thou sayest, How doth God know? But where, and when did Job say this? Job might challenge Eliphaz; bring your proofs and witnesses against me; why do you impute such thoughts to me, and frame such imaginations in my breast? certainly Job never spake this, and as surely Job never thought this; yet Eliphaz puts it directly upon him. What was his ground?1 only as the former crimes of uncharitableness and injustice, his breaking the arms of the fatherless, &c. were fastened upon him, because of the fears, snares, and darkness, in which he was; as if he must needs have done those evils, because he endured so much evil. Jobs sufferings were great, and therefore according to the Logic of Eliphaz, his sins must needs be very great. So here, he hath only this to prove his supposition, that Job said, How doth God know? because Job had said, that God doth sometime prosper wicked men, and afflicts the righteous. As if he who saith, that God suffers wicked men to prosper in this life, must needs also say, that God regards not the things of this life; so that Eliphaz seems to speak thus; We have heard thee saying, that the wicked prosper, and that the godly are afflicted; what need we any further witness, that thy opinion is, God neither takes notice nor care of the things here below. Out of thine own mouth we condemn ⟨p. 122⟩thee as Guilty of this blasphemy, That, Thou sayest, How doth God know?
Againe, Some read, What doth God know? how farre doth his eye extend? what are the objects of his knowledge? To this we may answer, God knoweth all things; even the hearts of all the children of men; There are no secrets to God. But whether wee expound it of the manner or matter of divine knowledge, the sence is the same, eyther an affirmation that God did not know all things, or at least a doubt whether he did or no. Thou sayest, How doth God know? But where, and when did Job say this? Job might challenge Eliphaz; bring your proofes and witnesses against me; why doe you impute such thoughts to me, and frame such imaginations in my breast? certainly Job never spake this, and as surely Job never thought this; yet Eliphaz puts it directly upon him. What was his ground?
Hence observe; First, That good men are sometimes charged with saying and doing the worst and vilest things.
Thus (1 King. 21.13.) Naboth was accused of blaspheming God and the King. Christ himself was taxed with blasphemy more then once, (Matth. 9.3.) And behold certain of the Scribes said within themselves, this man blasphemes. There they did not openly aver it, but they said it within themselves. At other times they spake it openly, (Joh. 10.33.) The Jews answered and said, for a good deed we stone thee not, but for blasphemy, because thou being a man makest thy self God. And again (Matth. 26.65.) He hath spoken blasphemy, ye have heard his blasphemy. To speak or do well and hear ill was the portion of Christ, and may be the portion of the holyest of those who are Christs.
Thus (1 King. 21.13.) Naboth was accused of blaspheming God and the King. Christ himselfe was taxed with blasphemy more then once, (Matth. 9.3.) And behold certaine of the Scribes said within themselves, this man blasphems. There they did not openly averre it, but they said it within themselves. At other times they spake it openly, (Joh. 10.33.) The Jewes answered and sayd, for a good deed we stone thee not, but for blasphemy, because thou being a man makest thy selfe God. And againe (Matth. 26.65.) He hath spoken blasphemy, ye have heard his blasphemy. To speak or doe well and heare ill was the portion of Christ, and may be the portion of the holyest of those who are Christs.
Secondly, Note; That when men are heated in dispute, they are apt to make false inferences from the tenets and sayings of their opposers.
Eliphaz saith, Job denied providence, whereas Job adored it; that he denied Gods knowledge of the good and evil done in the world, because he maintained, that good men receive evil, and evil men good in the world. When we deny transubstantiation, or that the bread is changed into the very substance of the body of Christ; Papists infer, that we deny, that Christ spake truly, when at his Last Supper he said, This is my body; and they will hence force it upon us, that we say, God is not omnipotent, because we affirm that it is inconsistent with the nature of a true humane body (such as Christ hath now in heaven, though glorified and spiritual) to be in many places at once. For as some deny the omnipresence of the divine nature, so Papists affirm the omni-presence of the humane nature, And (say they) while we deny this, we deny the omnipotency of God. Others charge us that we make God the author of sin, and that, according to our tenet, all the impiety and wickedness that is in the world, lieth at his door; because we affirm, That God hath passed an Eternal absolute ⟨p. 123⟩and unchangeable decree concerning all the sons of men. When all other arguments fail, how usual is it to make the divinest truths guilty of the most uncomely and ugly consequences that are imaginable.
Eliphaz sayth, Job denied providence, whereas Job adored it; that he denyed Gods knowledge of the good and evil done in the world, because he maintained, that good men receive evill, and evill men good in the world. When we deny transubstantiation, or that the bread is changed into the very substance of the body of Christ; Papists inferre, that we deny, that Christ spake truely, when at his Last Supper he said, This is my body; and they will hence force it upon us, that we say, God is not omnipotent, because we affirme that it is inconsistent with the nature of a true humane body (such as Christ hath now in heaven, though glorified and spirituall) to be in many places at once. For as some deny the omnipresence of the divine nature, so Papists affirme the omni-presence of the humane nature, And (say they) while we deny this, we deny the omnipotency of God. Others charge us that we make God the author of sinne, and that, according to our tenet, all the impiety and wickednesse that is in the world, lyeth at his doore; because we affirme, That God hath passed an Eternal absolute ⟨p. 123⟩and unchangeable decree concerning all the sonnes of men. When all other arguments fayle, how usuall is it to make the divinest truths guilty of the most uncomely and ugly consequences that are imaginable.
Further, Thou sayest, How doth God know? Take it either of the inward or of the outward saying, either of the tongue or of the heart, saying so; Eliphaz would prove from it, that certainly Job was a wicked man. And his inference had been true, if he could have proved it true, that Job had said so.
Further, Thou sayest, How doth God know? Take it eyther of the inward or of the outward saying, eyther of the tongue or of the heart, saying so; Eliphaz would prove from it, that certainly Job was a wicked man. And his inference had been true, if he could have proved it true, that Job had sayd so.
Hence observe; That to have evil thoughts, or to speak evil of God, is the character of a wicked man.
Hence observe; That to have evill thoughts, or to speake evill of God, is the character of a wicked man.
He that is good, must needs both think, and speak good of God. David doth often aggravate the wickedness of his enemies, from the language of their hearts and tongues, (Psal. 10.11.) He hath said in his heart, God hath forgotten, he hides his face, he will never see. And again (Psal. 144.7, 8, 11.) Send thy hand from above, rid me and deliver me out of great waters, from the hands of strange children, whose mouth speaketh vanity, and their right hand, is a right hand of falsehood. If the mouth speaketh vanity, the hand is full of falsehood; we may even feel deceit in their hands, whose mouths speak any kind of vanity, but especially this, which is the vainest vanity of all, How doth God know? or surely God doth not know. Such the Psalmist rebukes (Psal. 94.4, 5.7.) How long shall they utter and speak hard things? What things were those? The next words show us; They break in pieces thy people, &c. yet they say, the Lord shall not see, &c. understand ye brutish, among the people, he that formed the eye, shall he not see? There is no greater argument of brutishness and ignorance, then to question the knowledge of God; or to say, How doth God know?
He that is good, must needs both thinke, and speake good of God. David doth often aggravate the wickednesse of his enemies, from the language of their hearts and tongues, (Psal. 10.11.) He hath said in his heart, God hath forgotten, he hides his face, he will never see. And againe (Psal. 144.7, 8, 11.) Send thy hand from above, rid me and deliver me out of great waters, from the hands of strange children, whose mouth speaketh vanity, and their right hand, is a right hand of falsehood. If the mouth speaketh vanity, the hand is full of falsehood; we may even feele deceite in their hands, whose mouthes speake any kinde of vanity, but especially this, which is the vainest vanity of all, How doth God know? or surely God doth not know. Such the Psalmist rebukes (Psal. 94.4, 5.7.) How long shall they utter and speake hard things? What things were those? The next words shew us; They breake in peeces thy people, &c. yet they say, the Lord shall not see, &c. understand ye brutish, among the people, he that formed the eye, shall he not see? There is no greater argument of brutishnes and ignorance, then to question the knowledge of God; or to say, How doth God know?
And (which is the same in other words) can he judge through the dark cloud?
As if Job had further argued thus; I am safe enough from the knowledge of God, for as he is high above me, so there are dark clouds between him and me; Can he judge through the dark cloud? My opinion is he cannot. For knowledge goeth before ⟨p. 124⟩judgement;1 He that knoweth not certainly, can never judge rightly. Justice is pictured blind, in reference to persons, but not in reference to things or causes; Justice must take no notice of this or that man, whether he be great or little, high or low, a near friend or a stranger; Justice is blind as to all these considerations, and knoweth no man; but Justice must know every mans case and cause; unless man know that, how can be judge? and if God know not that, how can he judge? He must have light to see what is done, before he pass Sentence upon what is done; therefore, Can he judge through the dark cloud? Surely he cannot. Thus the Atheist concludeth indeed; and thus Eliphaz represents Job concluding in his own heart; there is not only a great distance between God and me, not only is he in the height of heaven, and I below on earth, but there are many gloomy clouds between him and me; As he is high above me, so there are such impediments in the way that he cannot see me. The Vulgar reads,2 He judgeth as through darkness. Now the best of Saints see God through a Glass darkly, or in a riddle (1 Cor. 13.12.) And secure sinners think that God seeth them only through a cloud darkly, or (as Eliphaz speaketh) through a dark cloud; he knoweth not clearly, but dimly. To judge through a cloud, is to judge of things confusedly, not distinctly, by guess or conjecturally, not exactly or face to face. This is all the sight which an evil heart alloweth God (if he allow him any) concerning his ways and actions. They who do things which cannot abide the light, are willing to believe that all they do is in the dark. Theirs are works of moral darkness, and therefore they please themselves with thinking that their works are hid either in natural or artificial darkness. It is said of the Lord in Scripture (Psal. 97.2.) Clouds and darkness are round about him, while judgement and righteousness are the habitation of his throne; but these imagine that God cannot proceed in judgement and righteousness, because clouds and darkness are round about him. It is said (
The cloud filled the house of the Lord, so that the Priests could not stand to minister because of the cloud, for the glory of the Lord filled the house of the Lord. Then spake Solomon, the Lord said that he will dwell in the thick darkness. Read Exod. 20.21. Deut. 5.22. ⟨p. 125⟩Psal. 18.11. God is light (saith the Apostle, John 1 Ep: 1.) and he dwelleth in light which no man can approach unto (1 Tim. 6.16.) How then can he be said to dwell in thick darkness? I answer; those Scriptures which say that God dwells in darkness, that clouds and darkness are round about him, teach us, that God and his ways are much hid from us; we are not able to look up to him, or see clearly what he doth, much less can we see what his counsels are. The clouds and darkness which are about him, do not hinder his sight of us, but our sight of him. Our darkness is no darkness to him, but his darkness, yea his light is darkness to us. Again, God is said to dwell in a cloud, to reprove our boldness and curiosity, who are too apt to pry into what is not to be known, and to neglect our duty in what we know, or to neglect the knowledge of our duty. God hath some reserves in counsels; some of his providences are wrapped up in clouds. He will be trusted and honoured in what he is not seen or known. Not to know these things is indeed our nescience, but not our ignorance, and not to seek after the knowledge of these things, is our duty not our sloth. Thus God who dwells in light, dwells also in a cloud; for he dwells in light that no man can (no nor ought to) approach unto. We may come near his light by faith, but we cannot come near his light by knowledge. There is such an infinite, such an overcoming light in God, that it is a darkness to us; the most Eagle-like eyes of a humane understanding are not only dazzled, but quite blinded with his brightness. Now as no man can judge through this light of God, so some men are ready to say (and thus Eliphaz brings in Job saying) that God cannot judge through dark clouds, through clouds and darkness. Nor doth Eliphaz bring in Job saying thus only by way of doubt or question, but by way of averment and resolution in the next verse.
As if Job had further argued thus; I am safe enough from the knowledge of God, for as he is high above me, so there are dark clouds between him and me; Can he judge through the dark cloud? My opinion is he cannot. For knowledge goeth before ⟨p. 124⟩judgement;1 He that knoweth not certainly, can never judge rightly. Justice is pictured blind, in reference to persons, but not in reference to things or causes; Justice must take no notice of this or that man, whether he be great or little, high or low, a neere friend or a stranger; Justice is blinde as to all these considerations, and knoweth no man; but Justice must know every mans case and cause; unlesse man know that, how can be judge? and if God know not that, how can he judge? He must have light to see what is done, before he passe Sentence upon what is done; therefore, Can he judge through the darke cloud? Surely he cannot. Thus the Atheist concludeth indeed; and thus Eliphaz represents Job concluding in his owne heart; there is not onely a great distance between God and me, not onely is he in the height of heaven, and I below on earth, but there are many gloomy clouds between him and me; As he is high above me, so there are such impediments in the way that he cannot see me. The Vulgar reads,2 He judgeth as through darknes. Now the best of Saints see God through a Glasse darkly, or in a ridle (1 Cor. 13.12.) And secure sinners thinke that God seeth them onely through a cloud darkly, or (as Eliphaz speaketh) through a dark cloud; he knoweth not clearly, but dimly. To judge through a cloud, is to judge of things confusedly, not distinctly, by guesse or conjecturally, not exactly or face to face. This is all the sight which an evill heart alloweth God (if he allow him any) concerning his wayes and actions. They who doe things which cannot abide the light, are willing to beleeve that all they doe is in the darke. Theirs are works of moral darknes, and therefore they please themselves with thinking that their works are hid eyther in natural or artificiall darkness. It is sayd of the Lord in Scripture (Psal. 97.2.) Clouds and darknes are round about him, while judgement and righteousnesse are the habitation of his throne; but these imagine that God cannot proceed in judgement and righteousnesse, because clouds and darkness are round about him. It is sayd (1 King. 8.10, 11, 12.)