Of the Dialogues arguments taken from the description of the torments of hell; and from the place of suffering the torments of the damned.
pp. 110–134108 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Guilt is either taken for the personal commission of sin, or for a personal obligation unto punishment (upon our voluntary taking thereof) for the sin committed by another; in the last sense only Christ was guilty of sin, that is, he was guilty imputatively, not inherently: as Christ was guilty of sin, so also he was sensible of an accusing Conscience. If Christ (saith D Willet) truly bare our sins, he sustained also the grief of conscience for them, which is the inseparable companion of our sin. The question is not, Whether Christ be polluted with our sin inherently, but only whether he may be said to be polluted with our sin imputatively. Desperation is not of the essence, but accidental, in penal wrath, The rest is but a repetition of what was said, and also answered a little before.
Answ. Guilt is either taken for the personal commission of sin, or for a personall obligation unto punishment (upon our voluntary taking thereof) for the sin committed by another; in the last sense only Christ was guilty of sin, that is, he was guilty imputatively, not inherently: as Christ was guilty of sin, so also he was sensible of an accusing Conscience. If Christ (saith D Willet) truly bare our sins, he sustained also the grief of conscience for them, which is the inseparable companion of our sin. The question is not, Whether Christ be polluted with our sin inherently, but only whether he may be said to be polluted with our sin imputatively. Desperation is not of the essence, but accidental, in paenal wrath, The rest is but a repetition of what was said, and also answered a little before.
Did Christ suffer the torments of hell in the proper place of hell? seeing none can suffer the torments of hell as long as they live in this world, none can suffer the second death till after this life is ended.
Answ. The place of punishment is not of the essence of punishment, as the place of the third heaven is not of the essence of blessedness, so neither is the place of the damned of the essence of misery.