pp. 49–536 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thirdly, these offices or duties, which we owe to others by way of Justice, are more strictly obligatory, then these which we owe to them, only by way of charity. But we owe the duty of obedience1 to our Superiors, by way of justice, and therefore it is more obligatory, then the duty of eschewing scandal causelessly taken, which is a duty only of charity. 1. The major is a maxim not only of Scholastics▪ and of Popish casuists, but also of our Divines. So Amesius, The major is clear for the duty of obedience which we owe to the public Laws of the Church and Kingdom is▪ Justitia legalis, a general legal Justice, and as it is in subjects, it is a virtue inclining them to the obedience of all laws made for the benefit of the Common-wealth, as Aristotle saith. 2. It is debitum obedientiae, the debt of obedience which we owe to our Superiors, grounded upon the proper right which our Superiors have to exact this right of us, so that they may accuse us of injury, and censure us, if we perform it not. Debitum justitiae fundatur in proprio jure alterius; and also it is debitum morale, a debt of duty unto which we are tied by moral honesty in Gods commandment. There is a great difference betwixt these two debts; As for example, a man oweth moneys to the poor by a moral debt, but to his creditors he oweth them by a legal debt, or debt of justice: and therefore he is more strictly obliged to pay his creditor then to give alms. Such like by moral honesty, and Gods precept also; a man oweth to his neighbour, a pious carefulness, to imped sin in him, by admonition, instruction, good example, and by omission even of things lawful, when he seeth that his neighbour in respect of his weakness, will be scandalized by them. But his neighbour hath not such a right to exact these duties of him, neither can he have action against him, for not performing of them, as our lawful Superiors have for our due obedience?
Thirdly, these offices or duties, which we owe to others by way of Justice, are more strictly obligatorie, then these which we owe to them, only by way of charitie. But we owe the dutie of obedience1 to our Superiours, by way of justice, and therefore it is more obligatorie, then the duty of eschewing scandall causlesly taken, which is a duty only of charity. 1. The major is a maxime not only of Scholasticks▪ and of Popish casuists, but also of our Divines. So Amesius, The major is cleare for the duty of obedience which wee owe to the publicke Lawes of the Church and Kingdome is▪ Justitia legalis, a generall legall Justice, and as it is in subjects, it is a vertue inclining them to the obedience of all lawes made for the benefit of the Common-wealth, as Aristotle saith. 2. It is debitum obedientiae, the debt of obedience which we owe to our Superiours, grounded upon the proper right which our Superiours have to exact this right of us, so that they may accuse us of injurie, and censure us, if we performe it not. Debitum justitiae fundatur in proprio jure alterius; and also it is debitum morale, a debt of dutie unto which we are tyed by morall honestie in Gods commandement. There is a great difference betwixt these two debts; As for example, a man oweth moneys to the poore by a morall debt, but to his creditours he oweth them by a legall debt, or debt of justice: and therefore he is more strictly obleiged to pay his creditour then to give almes. Such like by morall honestie, and Gods precept also; a man oweth to his neighbour, a pious carefulnesse, to imped sinne in him, by admonition, instruction, good example, and by omission even of things lawfull, when he seeth that his neighbour in respect of his weaknesse, will be scandalized by them. But his neighbour hath not such a right to exact these duties of him, neither can he have action against him, for not performing of them, as our lawfull Superiours have for our due obedience?
Ans. 1. Here be the white shifts of Mr. Sanderson, Paybodie, ⟨p. 50⟩Downham, who place Loyalty above Charity. We owe to our brother love, but to the Ruler (say they) love and justice. 1. Why do they not extend Loyalty to its utmost, even loyalty to the King of kings? whose royal law saith▪ (Thou shale not scandalize (Thou shalt not murder) they draw in loyalty to Rulers who shall die as men, and to their commandment of things indifferent, which God hath not commanded. 2. It is true, these duties which we owe to others by way of justice, are more obligatory then these which we owe only by way of charity, caeteris paribus, When duties of the law of Nature, and moral Law, are compared together, then indeed the duties which we owe, both by the tie of Justice and Charity, are more obligatory, then the duties that we owe only by the tie of Charity. As for example; My father is in danger, before my eyes, to be drowned, in one deep water; and before my eyes also, my neighbour and friend is in danger of the like kind; the two ties and bands of Justice and Charity, both by the fifth and sixth Commandments are more obligatorie, hic & nunc, and doe more strictly oblige, that I run to succour, and preserve the life of my father, then the life of my neighbour, for the obligation to my neighbour, is only charity, by the obligation of the sixth Commandment, which obligation ceaseth, hic & nunc, at this time, when my fathers life is in hazard; and thus far the Doctors argument goeth for strong, as Schoolmen, Casuists, and Divines teach. But it is not to a purpose for the Doctors; For all offices and duties generally, and universally, of what ever kind, which we owe by way of Justice, are not more obligatory, then duties which we owe, only by way of Charity, as when duties of a positive commandment of God, enjoined by our Superiors, and duties which we owe by charity only, are compared together, then the Doctors major Proposition is not clear of it self, as they dream, nor do Casuists or Amesius, or Divines say with them, but truth, and all our Divines say against them. Let us suppose that the King, and Convocation, and Assembly of Priests and Prophets of Israel make a Canon according to Gods Word. That no manner of man presume to eat show-bread, save the Priests only.
Ans. 1. Here be the white shifts of Mr. Sanderson, Paybodie, ⟨p. 50⟩Downham, who place Loyaltie above Charitie. We owe to our brother love, but to the Ruler (say they) love and justice. 1. Why doe they not extend Loyaltie to its utmost, even loyaltie to the King of kings? whose royall law saith (Thou shale not scandalize (Thou shalt not murther) they draw in loyaltie to Rulers who shall die as men, and to their commandement of things indifferent, which God hath not commanded. 2. It is true, these duties which we owe to others by way of justice, are more obligatorie then these which we owe only by way of charitie, caeteris paribus, When duties of the law of Nature, and morall Law, are compared together, then indeed the duties which we owe, both by the tye of Justice and Charitie, are more obligatorie, then the duties that we owe only by the tye of Charitie. As for example; My father is in danger, before my eyes, to be drowned, in one deepe water; and before my eyes also, my neighbour and friend is in danger of the like kind; the two tyes and bands of Justice and Charitie, both by the fifth and sixth Commandements are more obligatorie, hic & nunc, and doe more strictly obliege, that I run to succour, and preserve the life of my father, then the life of my neighbour, for the obligation to my neighbour, is only charitie, by the obligation of the sixth Commandement, which obligation ceaseth, hic & nunc, at this time, when my fathers life is in hazard; and thus farre the Doctors argument goeth for strong, as Schoolemen, Casuists, and Divines teach. But it is not to a purpose for the Doctors; For all offices and duties generally, and universally, of what ever kind, which we owe by way of Justice, are not more obligatorie, then duties which we owe, only by way of Charitie, as when duties of a positive commandement of God, enjoyned by our Superiours, and duties which we owe by charitie only, are compared together, then the Doctors major Proposition is not cleare of it selfe, as they dreame, nor doe Casuists or Amesius, or Divines say with them, but truth, and all our Divines say against them. Let us suppose that the King, and Convocation, and Assembly of Priests and Prophets of Israel make a Canon according to Gods Word. That no manner of man presume to eat shew-bread, save the Priests only.
All men owe obedience to this, both because it is Gods express Law, and by the band ⟨p. 51⟩of Justice, the Elders and Assembly of the Ancients have forbidden it. But if our Doctors argument stand strong, David at the point and hazard of famishing for hunger, sinned in eating show-bread, yet Christ acquiteth him of all sin, and saith Math. 12. 5. he and his followers are [Greek or Hebrew], blameless. Now David was under a duty by mercy, and love to his own life, and he lives of his followers, to eat show-bread, and he was under the band of Justice, by the law of the Ancients of Israel, and Gods law, not to eat. Therefore in some cases, when our Superiors commandments are only positive Laws, they are not more obligatory, then duties of Charity, only commanded in the law of nature. I clear it further thus, I see my neighbour in danger before my eyes of drowning, and my father commandeth me to go and labour, or sow his farm in that time, while I am to preserve the life of my neighbour in present danger, to lose his life, in a great water. By the Doctors maxim I am under the higher obligatory tie of Justice, to obey my father, who commandeth a thing both lawful and necessary by virtue of the higher Commandment, to wit, the first of the second Table, then I am obliged by the sixth Commandment, and of charity only, to give present succour and help to my dying neighbour, so I must let my neighbour die in the waters, to give a duty of justice to my father, of far less necessity. I would not commit my conscience to such Casuists, as are the Doctors of Aberdeen. But if the Doctors would see with some new light of reason; it is clear, that not only the tie of Justice maketh the precept more obligatory, but also the weightiness of the thing commanded; Yea, and if the positive Commandments of the Lord our God, who of Justice and kingly sovereignty▪ hath right to ask obedience of us above all earthly Superiors do yield and cede as less obligatory, then commandments of love only, that are commanded in the law of nature. What do our Doctors clatter and fable to us of a right of Justice, that mortal Rulers have to command in things indifferent, from which the destruction of souls doth arise?
All men owe obedience to this, both because it is Gods expresse Law, and by the band ⟨p. 51⟩
for these commandments of Rulers, (kneel religiously before bread, the vicegerent image of Christ crucified) (keep humane holy-days) Cross the air with your thumb above a baptized ⟨p. 52⟩infants face) at best, are but positive Commandments, not warranted by Gods word. But shall they be more obligatory by a supposed band of Justice that Prelates have over us to command, such toy's then this divine law of God and Nature, Rom. 14. For indifferent days, meats, surplice, destroy not him for whom Christ died? All the Casuists, and Schoolmen, Navarra, Sylvester, Sanchez, Raphael de la Torre, Meratius, Duvallius, Thomas, Scotus, Bonaventura, Suarez. Vasquez, Grego. de Valentia, Albertus, Richardus, Biel, Corduba, Angelus, Adrianus, Alphonsus, Becanus, yea, and all the host of our Divines cry with Scripture, that Mercy and the precepts of Love, and of the Law of nature, are more obligatory then Sacrifice, burnt offerings, and Gods own positive laws, yea, and that positive laws lose their obligatory power, and cease to be laws, when the laws of nature and necessary duties of mercy and love (as not to murder our brother) (not to scandalize) standeth in their way. I might weary the reader here with citations, and bewilder my self also, but it is a point of Divinity denied by none at all. 3. What we owe of Justice to our Superiors, is indeed both a moral debt of obedience, and a debt of justice, and law which Rulers may seek by their place, and ex jure, as Aristotle saith, but this right is limited, Rulers have no right to seek absolute obedience, but only in the Lord, not against charity. And though the place of Rulers be authoritative, yet their commanding power, as touching the matter of what they enjoin is only Ministerial, and they cannot but in Gods place exact, that which is Gods due, and seeing God himself, if he should immediately in his own person command, he would not urge a positive commandment, far less the commandment of light and vain Ceremonies, against and beyond the precept of love, not to destroy a soul for whom Christ died. Ergo, Superiors under God, who borrow all their right from God, cannot have a higher right then God hath. 4.
for these commandements of Rulers, (kneele religiously before bread, the vicegerent image of Christ crucified) (keepe humane holy-dayes) Crosse the aire with your thumb above a baptized ⟨p. 52⟩infants face) at best, are but positive Commandements, not warranted by Gods word. But shall they be more obligatorie by a supposed band of Justice that Prelates have over us to command, such toy's then this divine law of God and Nature,
The comparison of a man who oweth moneys to a Creditor, and oweth moneys to the poor, is close off the way, for he is obliged to pay the Creditor first, but the case here is far otherwise; The debt of practising indifferent feathers and straws, such as kneeling, crossing, wearing Surplice, is neither ⟨p. 53⟩like the debt owing to the poor, nor to the creditor; For natures law, and Gods word, 1 Cor. 10. 18, 19. maketh the nonpractise, non-murthering obedience to God, when the practise of indifferent things, is a soul-stumbling to the weak, and the practising is but at its best obedience to a positive Law, and ought to stoop, and go off the way, and disappear when natures Law (Murder not) doth come in its way. When the Doctors put Loyalty above Charity, they suppose obedience to commandments commanding scandalizing of souls to be loyalty to Superiors, which is questioned, it being treason to the Sovereign of heaven and earth, to destroy his Image, it is taken as loyalty by our Doctors, but not proven to be loyalty, and so a vain question here, whether Loyalty be above Charity or not. But I dismiss the Doctors till another occasion. Other things as Popish tenets, in their book are a thousand times answered by us.
The comparison of a man who oweth moneys to a Creditor, and oweth moneys to the poore, is close off the way, for he is obliged to pay the Creditour first, but the case here is farre otherwise; The debt of practising indifferent feathers and straws, such as kneeling, crossing, wearing Surplice, is neither ⟨p. 53⟩like the debt owine to the poore, nor to the creditour; For natures law, and Gods word, 1 Cor. 10. 18, 19. maketh the nonpractise, non-murthering obedience to God, when the practise of indifferent things, is a soule-stumbling to the weake, and the practising is but at its best obedience to a positive Law, and ought to stoope, and goe off the way, and disappeare when natures Law (Murther not) doth come in its way. When the Doctors put Loyaltie above Charitie, they suppose obedience to commandements commanding scandalizing of soules to be loyaltie to Superiours, which is questioned, it being treason to the Soveraigne of heaven and earth, to destroy his Image, it is taken as loyalty by our Doctors, but not proven to be loyaltie, and so a vaine question here, whether Loyaltie be above Charitie or not. But I dismisse the Doctors till another occasion. Other things as Popish tenents, in their booke are a thousand times answered by us.