But if you mean, that we are to forbear the thing commanded for eschewing the scandal of the weak, providing we do it without the offence of Superiors, that is without the active scandalizing of Superiors, then 1. your distinction is vain, for if we scandalize culpably our superiors by our forbearance, though it be inexpedient to all private persons, we are not to forbear, because in no case can we break the sixth Commandment, and scandalize our Superiors. 2. You shall be forced to give• case, wherein we are necessitated by Gods ⟨p. 42⟩providence, and that by way of contradiction, whether we forbear, or forbear not, to murder either the souls of some weak ones, or the souls of Superiors, by our forbearance of the practice of things judged expedient by Superiors, you make us to murder the souls of Superiors by the non-forbearance, or you will have us to murder the souls of weak brethren, if we practise. This is a wronging of Providence, and a Manichean tenet, that we can be under such a necessity of sinning. Yea, there must be two centra•y revealed wills in God, commanding, by forbearing the Ceremonies, not to murder Superiors, and commanding by not forbearing, not to murder weak brethren; and so God commandeth both to forbear, and also not to forbear. If you say, the weak may be informed, and then it is a passive scandal only, and practising is lawful at the commandment of Superiors. I answer, 1. Then your distinction hath no use here. 2. I answer. Let the Superiors, who have more knowledge, be informed, that to abstain from a practice, that may murder any one redeemed by Christ, is Christs commandment (Thou shalt do no murder) then it is but a passive scandal, and not an active, or culpably given scandal. Ergo, we are to forbear the thing commanded for eschewing of the scandall▪ (hic & nunc) of the weak, even though with the offence, that is the passive scandal of Superiors and others, which is contradictory to the Doctors. 3. If we may forbear obedience to Gods positive Commandements, hic & nunc, for eschewing of Scandal, far more may we, hic & nunc, not crosse, not kneel, hic & nunc, when crossing and kneeling murdereth one for whom Christ died, even though it offend our Superiors. Ergo, this provision of the Doctors is vain;
But if you meane, that wee are to forbeare the thing commanded for eschewing the scandall of the weake, providing we doe it without the offence of Superiours, that is without the active scandalizing of Superiours, then 1. your distinction is vaine, for if we scandalize culpably our superiours by our forbearance, though it be inexpedient to all private persons, we are not to forbeare, because in no case can we breake the sixt Commandement, and scandalize our Superiours. 2. You shall be forced to give• case, wherein we are necessitated by Gods ⟨p. 42⟩providence, and that by way of contradiction, whether we forbeare, or forbeare not, to murther either the soules of some weake ones, or the soules of Superiours, by our forbearance of the practice of things judged expedient by Superiours, you make us to murther the soules of Superiours by the non-forbearance, or you will have us to murther the soules of weake breathren, if we practise. This is a wronging of Providence, and a Ma•ichean tenent, that we can be under such a necessitie of sinning. Yea, there must be two centra•y revealed wills in God, commanding, by forbearing the Ceremonies, not to murther Superiours, and commanding by not forbearing, not to murther weak brethren; and so God commandeth both to forbeare, and also not to forbeare. If you say, the weake may be informed, and then it is a passive scandall onely, and practising is lawfull at the commandement of Superiours. I answer, 1. Then your distinction hath no use here. 2. I answer. Let the Superiours, who have more knowledge, be informed, that to abstaine from a practice, that may murther any one redeemed by Christ, is Christs commandement (Thou shalt doe no murther) then it is but a passive scandall, and not an active, or culpably given scandall. Ergo, we are to forbeare the thing commanded for eschewing of the scandall▪ (hic & nunc) of the weake, even though with the offence, that is the passive scandall of Superiours and others, which is contradictorie to the Doctours. 3. If we may forbeare obedience to Gods positive Commandements, hic & nunc, for esehewing of Scandall, farre more may we, hic & nunc, not crosse, not kneele, hic & nunc, when crossing and kneeling murthereth one for whom Christ died, even though it offend our Superiours. Ergo, this provision of the Doctors is vaine;