The adversaries strive to prove that these laws oblige the conscience, we may hear rBellarmine sVasquez, tValentinian, and the Formalist and Arminian, vDoctor Jackson say, To resist the Rulers in giving, and making laws, is to resist God, as 1 Sam. 8. They have not refused thee, but they have refused me, that I should not reign over them. Suarez •aith, An humane law is the nearest cause of obligation of conscience, as the eternal law is the remote cause. And Jackson as the immediate interposition of divine ⟨p. 208⟩authority made the killing of Abraham's son, holy, which otherwise would have been cruelty; so the interposition of authority derived from God, make some actions that barely considered would be apparently evil, and desperate, to be honest and lawful; to strike a Prophet would seem sin, but when a Prophet commandeth to strike, not to strike is disobedience, 1▪ Kin. 20. 35, 36. to rob a Spaniard is Piracy, but to do it upon the Kings letter of Mart for wrongs done to the State, is obedience to the King. Answ. To resist the servant in that wherein he is a servant, and as a servant, is to resist God, as 1 Sam. 8. proveth well.5 But the assumption then is most false, for rulers in making laws, and creating by their sole pleasure, goodness moral, in particular matters without the word of God, are not Gods servants, nor is humane authority as humane, the nearest cause of obligation of conscience, instamped in these laws, nor is it the cause at all, and therefore to resist them, is not to resist God. They be Gods instruments and Ministers in 1. Propounding and expounding Gods laws. 2. In executing them, and defending them from the violence of men. 3. In making positive and directory civil laws, for civill government, that are laws improperly so called, which bind the conscience as above is said, in so far, as they have dependence upon Gods Law: for James saith, There is but one Law-giver. As for Church-canons, all, except Physical circumstances in them, are to be warranted by the word. Therefore it is a vain consequence of Valentia, humane laws oblige, dependenter a lege aeternâ, as they depend on the eternal law▪ Ergo, they oblige in Conscience, it followeth not.
The adversaries strive to prove that these lawes oblige the conscience, we may heare rBellarmine sVasquez, tValentinian, and the Formalist and Arminian, vDoctor Jackson say, To resist the Rulers in giving, and making lawes, is to resist God, as 1 Sam. 8. They have not refused thee, but they have refused me, that I should not raigne over them. Suarez •aith, An humane law is the neerest cause of obligation of conscience, as the eternall law is the remote cause. And •ackson as the immediate interposition of divine ⟨p. 208⟩authority made the killing of Abrahams sonne, holy, which otherwise would have been cruelty; so the interposition of authority derived from God, make some actions that barely considered would be apparently evill, and desperate, to be honest and lawfull; to strike a Prophet would seem sin, but when a Prophet cōmandeth to strike, not to strike is disobedience, 1▪ Kin. 20. 35, 36. to rob a Spaniard is Piracie, but to do it upon the Kings letter of Mart for wrongs done to the State, is obedience to the King. Answ. To resist the servant in that wherein he is a servant, and as a servant, is to resist God, as 1 Sam. 8. proveth well.5 But the assumption then is most false, for rulers in making lawes, and creating by their sole pleasure, goodnes morall, in particular matters without the word of God, are not Gods servants, nor is humane authoritie as humane, the nearest cause of obligation of conscience, instamped in these lawes, nor is it the cause at all, and therefore to resist them, is not to resist God. They be Gods instruments and Ministers in 1. Propounding and expounding Gods laws. 2. In executing them, and defending them from the violence of men. 3. In making positive and directory civil lawes, for civill government, that are lawes improperly so called, which bind the conscience as above is said, in so far, as they have dependance upon Gods Law: for Iames saith, There is but one Law-giver. As for Church-canons, all, except Physicall circumstances in them, are to be warranted by the word. Therefore it is a vaine consequence of Valentia, humane lawes oblige, dependenter a lege aeternâ, as they depend on the eternall law Ergo, they oblige in Conscience, it followeth not.
- rBellarm. tom. 1. cont. 5. l. 3. c. 11.
- sVasquez tom. 2 in 12. disp. 152. cap. 2.
- tValent. tom. 2. disp. 7. q. 5. punct. 6.
- vDoctor Jackson on the Creed, lib. 2. cap. 4Doctor Iackson on the Creed, lib. 2. cap. 4
- 5How inferior rulers are subordinate to God in commanding.How inferiour rulers are subordinate to God in commanding.