QUEST. II.
pp. 201–21953 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I proceed to answer other Arguments: As 1. We must not obey, Not only for wrath, but for conscience, the violation of a special Law, necessarily draweth with it the violation of the general Law of the fifth Commandment; But the violation of the general, (saith Learned tPareus) hurteth the Conscience; and the Magistrate punisheth not for general Violation, but for the Violation of this special Law; Ergo, this special Law obligeth in Conscience. And it seemeth to carry reason. Every just punishment presupposeth essentially a sin, else it is not a just punishment; but the Ruler doth justly punish the particular Transgression of an humane Law; Ergo, the Transgression of a particular Law of Rulers is sin. The Proposition is confirmed by grave School-men, uSoto, xSylvester, yand Joan, Eselius, Who think that there cannot be a Law obliging to a punishment, and not to a fault; because punishment hath an intrinsical relation to a sin, nor can it be a just punishment that is not proportioned to a sin; for the Law zsaith, That cometh not under damage, which cometh not under fault.
I proceed to answer other Arguments: As 1. We must not obey, Not only for wrath, but for conscience, the violation of a speciall Law, necessarily draweth with it the violation of the generall Law of the fift Commandment; But the violation of the generall, (saith Learned tPareus) hurteth the Conscience; and the Magistrate punisheth not for generall Violation, but for the Violation of this speciall Law; Ergo, this speciall Law obligeth in Conscience. And it seemeth to carry reason. Every just punishment presupposeth essentially a sin, else it is not a just punishment; but the Ruler doth justly punish the particular Transgression of an humane Law; Ergo, the Transgression of a particular Law of Rulers is sin. The Proposition is confirmed by grave School-men, u