Ans. This is a mere conjecture as Erastus granteth most he1 saith against the place is; for he saith, Aliam conjecturam etiam addidi, such a violent remedy of repentance, as is the cutting off of a member from Christs body, being the most dreadful sentence of the King of the Church, nearest to the last sentence, was to Paul, and ought to be a matter of sorrow to all the Servants of God, as the foretelling of sad Judgements, moved Christ to tears, Matth. 23. 37▪ Luke 19. 41, 42. And moved Jeremiah to sorrow, cap. 9. 1. And yet Christ was glad at the home-coming of sinners, Luke 15. 6, 7, &c. These two are not contrary as Erastus dreameth, but subordinate; to wit, (That Christ should inflict the extremest vengeance of Excommunication, which also being blessed of God, is a saving, though a violent remedy of repentance,) and (To rejoice at the blessed fruit of Excommunication, which is the mans repentance:) And the Apostle 2 Cor. 7. professeth his sorrow, That he made them sad, ver. 8. and also rejoiceth at their gracious disposition who were made sorry: He is far from excusing himself, as if he had done any thing in weakness; this were enough, and it is an Argument of our Protestant Divines, to prove that the Books of the Maccabees, are not Dited by the Holy Ghost, as Canonic Scripture is; because the Author 2 Macab. 15. 38. excuseth himself in that History, as if he might have erred, which no Pen-man of holy Scripture can do: And Erastus layeth the like blame on Paul, as if he had repented that he made them sorry, by chiding them, for not praying for a miraculous killing of a Brother: This is enough to make the Epistles of Paul to be suspected as not Canonic Scripture; yea, Paul saith the ⟨p. 324⟩contrary, 2 Cor. 7. 9. Now I rejoice, not that ye were made sorry, but that ye sorrowed to repentance, for ye were made sorry after a godly manner, that ye might receive damage by us in nothing, and 2 Cor. 2. 8, 9. he exhorteth them to rejoicing, at the mans Repentance, and to confirm their love to him, (which demonstrates that he was now a living man, and not miraculously killed,) and commendeth their obedience, v. 9. in sorrowing, as he did chide them that they sorrowed not, 1 Cor. 5. 2. So that Paul is so far from accusing himself for making them sad, that by the contrary, he commends himself for that, and rejoiceth thereat.
Ans. This is a meer conjecture as Erastus granteth most he1 saith against the place is; for he saith, Aliam conjecturam etiam addidi, such a violent remedy of repentance, as is the cutting off of a member from Christs body, being the most dreadfull sentence of the King of the Church, nearest to the last sentence, was to Paul, and ought to be a matter of sorrow to all the Servants of God, as the foretelling of sad Iudgements, moved Christ to tears, Matth. 23. 37▪ Luke 19. 41, 42. And moved Ieremiah to sorrow, cap. 9. 1. And yet Christ was glad at the home-coming of sinners, Luke 15. 6, 7, &c. These two are not contrary as Erastus dreameth, but subordinate; to wit, (That Christ should inflict the extreamest vengeance of Excommunication, which also being blessed of God, is a saving, though a violent remedy of repentance,) and (To rejoyce at the blessed fruit of Excommunication, which is the mans repentance:) And the Apostle 2 Cor. 7. professeth his sorrow, That he made them sad, ver. 8. and also rejoyceth at their gracious disposition who were made sorry: He is far from excusing himself, as if he had done any thing in weaknesse; this were enough, and it is an Argument of our Protestant Divines, to prove that the Books of the Macabees, are not Dited by the Holy Ghost, as Canonick Scripture is; because the Author 2 Macab. 15. 38. excuseth himself in that History, as if he might have erred, which no Pen-man of holy Scripture can do: And Erastus layeth the like blame on Paul, as if he had repented that he made them sorry, by chiding them, for not praying for a miraculous killing of a Brother: This is enough to make the Epistles of Paul to be suspected as not Canonick Scripture; yea, Paul saith the ⟨p. 324⟩contrary, 2 Cor. 7. 9. Now I reioyce, not that yee were made sorry, but that yee sorrowed to repentance, for yee were made sorry after a godly manner, that ye might receive dammage by us in nothing, and 2 Cor. 2. 8, 9. he exhorteth them to rejoycing, at the mans Repentance, and to confirme their love to him, (which demonstrates that he was now a living man, and not miraculously killed,) and commendeth their obedience, v. 9. in sorrowing, as he did chide them that they sorrowed not,
- 1Thes. 58. p. 44. p. 225.