Quest. 10.
pp. 379–39842 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. If the Church be to try the penitency, or impenitency of the fact, and not to cognosce and try whether he hath done the fact, upon the same ground the Magistrate is to try and punish the disturbance of the peace of the Common-wealth, that adhereth to the fact, and not to try the fact. 2. It is not possible that the Church can know whether the man be penitent, or no, except by witnesses they know the fact, for they shall run a preposterous way, to work the man to a godly sorrow, for that sin which possibly he never committed; now that of which the Church is to convince the man, and from which they are to gain his soul, that they are to find out. 2. This is against the way of Erastus, who will have the Magistrate to exclude from the Sacraments, and none other. 3. The word knows no such thing, as that Ministers should be led in the acts of their Ministerial duties, to whom they should dispense the mysteries of the Gospel, and to whom they should deny them; by the Magistrate? by a good warrant the Magistrate is to lay a tie on the consciences of Elders, what they should dispense, as to whom they should dispense; sure if the Magistrate as the Magistrate must prescribe to Ministers, to what sort of persons they must dispense word and Sacraments, he must upon the same ground as a Magistrate prescribe what Doctrine they should preach to this man, not to this, whether Law or Gospel; and so the Magistrate as the Magistrate must be a Pastor to cut the word aright, 2 Tim. 2. 15. Eze. 3. 18, 19, 20. Eze. 13. 19. to command to preach life to this man, death to this man. 4. If the Church must cast him out, and judge him who has done this wickedness, 1 Cor. 5. 2, 12. and 4. 5, 6. 7. then must they judge of his scandal; that according to the quality of the scandal, they may proportion the measure of the punishment; Ergo, a pari they must judge whom they debar from the seals. 5. The debarring any from the seals, must be proportioned to the end of all spiritual censures, that the man be gained, and his sin loosed in heaven, Mat. 18. 15. 18. that his soul may be saved in the day of the Lord,