Ans. The antecedent is false; 1 Tim. 5. 17. as I have demonstrate in another place, I repeat it not here, let any disciple of Erastus answer if he can. 2. The consequence is vain, for if in every place of the New Testament, where mention is made of an Elder, the Holy Ghost mean only a Preaching Elder, it followeth only that any other officers, as Deacons, and those that labour not in the Word, & yet Govern well, are not called with the name of Presbyters: And so the Argument is against the name, not against the office and thing. What if the Presbytery be named from the most principal part, as is ordinary in Scripture, doth it follow that there be none members of the Presbytery, but only Preachers of the Word? In no sort. Paul saith of the visible Church of Corinth, Ye are bought with a price, ye are justified, ye are sanctified; Ergo, none were members of the visible Church, but those that are redeemed, justified, and sanctified, it is like the consequence of Erastus. 3. I retort this vain argument thus; none in Scripture have the name of Apostles, But the Eleven, and Mathias, none are called the witnesses of the Lord but they, 1 Joh. 1. 1, 2. Ergo, there be no preaching Ministers, neither Timothy, Titus, Epaphroditus that are to be called witnesses of the Lord, but the twelve Apostles; so where doth Erastus find that [Greek or Hebrew] a deaconry or office of labour in the Ministry is given to any, but to those that labour in the word? Rom. 11. 13. Ergo, must there be no deaconry, but labouring in the word, the plain contrary is Act. 6.
Ans. The antecedent is false; 1 Tim. 5. 17. as I have demonstrate in another place, I repeat it not here, let any disciple of Erastus answer if he can. 2. The consequence is vaine, for if in every place of the New Testament, where mention is made of an Elder, the Holy Ghost mean only a Preaching Elder, it followeth only that any other officers, as Deacons, and those that labour not in the Word, & yet Govern well, are not called with the name of Presbyters: And so the Argument is against the name, not against the office and thing. What if the Presbytery be named from the most principall part, as is ordinary in Scripture, doth it follow that there be none members of the Presbytery, but only Preachers of the Word? In no sort. Paul saith of the visible Church of Corinth, Ye are bought with a price, ye are justified, ye are sanctified; Ergo, none were members of the visible Church, but those that are redeemed, justified, and sanctified, it is like the consequence of Erastus. 3. I retort this vaine argument thus; none in Scripture have the name of Apostles, But the Eleven, and Mathias, none are called the witnesses of the Lord but they, 1 Ioh. 1. 1, 2. Ergo, there be no preaching Ministers, neither Timothy, Titus, Epaphroditus that are to be called witnesses of the Lord, but the twelve Apostles; so where doth Erastus finde that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 a deaconrie or office of labour in the Ministery is given to any, but to those that labour in the word? Rom. 11. 13. Ergo, must there be no deaconry, but labouring in the word, the plaine contrary is Act. 6.