Ans. Beza answereth well to that. Manna and the water out of the Rock, as they had a spiritual Relation to Christ, were holy things and types of Christ, just as our Sacraments are signs of Christ already come in the flesh, and so agreed in the kind of holy signs with our Sacraments: yet Manna, and the water out of the Rock, were also ordained to be bodily food, for the famishing and thirsty people, good or bad, holy or unholy, these two, Manna and water out of the Rock were given by the Commandment of God and the Priests, to the people, both as Gods people in Covenant with God, and to them, as men starving in the wilderness, and dying for thirst; for they had not ploughing, earing, harvest, bread, vineyards, wine, fountains in the wilderness, and therefore no marvel then such holy things being; also beside that they were holy things, such as were necessary to keep them from starving and bodily death, as the shewbread, which was also a type of the word of life▪ revealed to the Ministers of God, was ⟨p. 277⟩given to keep David and his men from starving: No marvel (I say) then these bodily helps (though in another higher signification they were Sacramentals) were by Gods command bestowed on many wicked men, who often partake both of outward Ordinances and temporal deliverance from death and famishing, because they are mixed with the people of God. But Erastus, if he would prove any thing against us, should have proved that circumcision, the Passover, and other holy things of God, ordained for the visible Saints to show forth our spiritual Communion with Christ, and which were never ordained for necessary helps to sustain the natural life, were to be administered to those that were openly profane and wicked; and therefore we deny this connection: Manna signified the very same thing; to wit, Christ our food of life, which bread and wine signifies; Ergo, As Manna was given both as a holy sign to figure out Christ our life, and to feed the bodies of openly holy, or openly profane, to sustain their bodily life, so also baptism and the Lords Supper, which serve for no bodily use, should be administered to those that are openly profane.
Ans. Beza answereth well to that. Manna and the water ouf of the Rock, as they had a spirituall Relation to Christ, were holy things and types of Christ, just as our Sacraments are signes of Christ already come in the flesh, and so agreed in the kinde of holy signes with our Sacraments: yet Manna, and the water out of the Rock, were also ordained to be bodily food, for the famishing and thirsty people, good or bad, holy or unholy, these two, Manna and water out of the Rock were given by the Commandment of God and the Priests, to the people, both as Gods people in Covenant with God, and to them, as men starving in the wildernesse, and dying for thirst; for they had not plowing, earing, harvest, bread, vineyards, wine, fountains in the wildernesse, and therefore no marvell then such holy things being; also beside that they were holy things, such as were necessary to keep them from starving and bodily death, as the shewbread, which was also a type of the word of life▪ revealed to the Ministers of God, was ⟨p. 277⟩given to keep David and his men from starving: No marvell (I say) then these bodily helps (though in another higher signification they were Sacramentalls) were by Gods command bestowed on many wicked men, who often partake both of outward Ordinances and temporall deliverance from death and famishing, because they are mixt with the people of God. But Erastus, if he would prove any thing against us, should have proved that circumcision, the Passeover, and other holy things of God, ordained for the visible Saints to shew forth our spirituall Communion with Christ, and which were never ordained for necessiry helps to sustain the naturall life, were to be administred to those that were openly prophane and wicked; and therefore we deny this connexion: Manna signified the very same thing; to wit, Christ our food of life, which bread and wine signifies; Ergo, As Manna was given both as a holy signe to figure out Christ our life, and to feed the bodies of openly holy, or openly prophane, to sustain their bodily life, so also baptisme and the Lords Supper, which serve for no bodily use, should be administred to those that are openly prophane.