Ans. 1. Its most false, that all the precepts of the Decalogue are1 all of them spoken to all and every man: Honour thy Father and mother that begat thee, is one of the Commandments; and it is not spoken to those that are only Parents themselves, and have their natural parents dead: but doth it follow that that Command doth enjoin private obedience, and forbid only private, not public disobedience to natural Parents: So the sixth Command saith, If thy brother fall in a Lyons den to the hazard of his life, pull him out; if thou cannot rescue him thy self alone, take three with thee and assay it; if thou cannot so rescue him, tell it to twenty: The man is not to rescue every brother here, but only the brother that is in danger to be devoured with the Lyon: will any say the Law of the sixth Commandment is given here, to one private man to help another in a private danger? This (rebuke thy brother) is the Law of nature, and it is under this, Levit. 19. 17. Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart: And if I rebuke him not for sin, any sin, and the most public, and so most offensive and scandalous to many; I hate him; nay, I am not so much to rebuke him and gain his soul, because the sin is an injury done to me, as because it is done against the Majesty of God, and destructive to the offenders soul, and I must labour to gain his soul. 2. Erastus dreams that that is a private sin, which is done to one man, or one rank of men; to a Magistrate, ⟨p. 295⟩not a subject; he is beguiled, an offence and public stumbling-block may be laid before one man, and it is often a public sin. 3. The speaking of it in the second person is nothing, for, If thou believe thou art saved, Rom. 10. 9. is as public and universal, as John 3. 16. Whosoever believeth he is saved. The second person in all precepts of Law and Gospel (and this, rebuke an offending brother, is both,) is as broad as the third person, and as large in extent, except you say the verse John 3. 16. comprehendeth some more believers that are saved, then Rom. 10. 9. which is against sense. 4. Christ ought not to have spoken to his Disciples as a Church, because he is directing them as members and parts of a Church, how to deal with an offender: but if he hear not the Church, that is,2 the Christian Magistrate, he should die, saith Beza.
Ans. 1. Its most false, that all the precepts of the Decalogue are1 all of them spoken to all and every man: Honour thy Father and mother that begat thee, is one of the Commandments; and it is not spoken to those that are onely Parents themselves, and have their naturall parents dead: but doth it follow that that Command doth injoyne private obedience, and forbid onely private, not publick disobedience to naturall Parents: So the sixth Command saith, If thy brother fall in a Lyons den to the hazard of his life, pull him out; if thou cannot rescue him thy self alone, take three with thee and assay it; if thou cannot so rescue him, tell it to twenty: The man is not to rescue every brother here, but onely the brother that is in danger to be devoured with the Lyon: will any say the Law of the sixth Commandment is given here, to one private man to help another in a private danger? This (rebuke thy brother) is the Law of nature, and it is under this, Levit. 19. 17. Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart: And if I rebuke him not for sinne, any sinne, and the most publick, and so most offensive and scandalous to many; I hate him; nay, I am not so much to rebuke him and gain his soul, because the sin is an injury done to me, as because it is done against the Majesty of God, and destructive to the offenders soule, and I must labour to gaine his soule. 2. Erastus dreames that that is a private sin, which is done to one man, or one ranke of men; to a Magistrate, ⟨p. 295⟩not a subject; he is beguiled, an offence and publick stumbling-block may be laid before one man, and it is often a publick sin. 3. The speaking of it in the second person is nothing, for, If thou beleeve thou art saved, Rom. 10. 9. is as publike and universall, as Iohn 3. 16. Whosoever beleeveth he is saved. The second person in all precepts of Law and Gospel (and this, rebuke an offending brother, is both,) is as broad as the third person, and as large in extent, except you say the verse Iohn 3. 16. comprehendeth some more beleevers that are saved, then Rom. 10. 9. which is against sense. 4. Christ ought not to have spoken to his Disciples as a Church, because he is directing them as members and parts of a Church, how to deale with an offender: but if he heare not the Church, that is,
- 1Christs speaking in the second person, argueth not the privacy of the scandal.Christs speaking in the second person, argueth not the privacy of the scandall.
- 2Page 158.