Answ. 1. Your enumeration is weak, for we know no Scandal justly taken, but proceeding from both these, weakness or wickedness of nature, is the nearest cause of all Scandal taken, because it is the cause of all sin, and to be scandalized is sin. Also it is here taken from the enormity of the deed, in that practising of things indifferent, if a scandal taken either weakly or maliciously thence arise, there is enormity in the deed, yet total abstinence is not hence concluded, because, cessante ratione scandali, when the ground of the Scandal is removed, there is no enormity in the fact. 2. You define to us, or rather divine, that then there is an irregularity in the fact that justly scandalizeth, when either the fact is a sin, or then hath a manifest show of sin. And we wonder where you learned this strange Divinity, for 1 Cor. 10. 27. To eat meat at a Feast that you are invited unto▪ is neither sin, because v. 23. 25. it is lawful: The earth is the Lords, nor is it such as hath a manifest show of sin, as all having sense knoweth. One of your prime Doctors defined to me, these only have manifest appearance of sinne, Quae pl•rumque fiunt malo fine, which for the most part are done for an evil •nd, such as is to lye in bed with another mans wife, to kneel before an Idol. The former, in the exposition of all is done for adultery, the latter for Idolatry. I am sure to eat meats at an Infidels feast, is not of that nature which is done ordinarily for an evil end, it is ordinarily done to refresh nature, and to sol••e it, which hath no manifest show of sin, and yet if there be a weak one beside, who saith, that meat is offered ⟨p. 17⟩to Idols, in that case to eat, is to scandalize 32. and is against the glory of God, v. 31. 3. You ask from whom we learned this strange doctrine to deny obedience to the laws of Superiors for scandal causelessly taken; And we answer, we learned it from the Apostle Paul, who saith 1 Cor. 8. 13. If meat offend my weak brother, I will eat no flesh (I will abstain totally and absolutely) while the world standeth. This abstinence for the date of the worlds standing, God be thanked, is longer then the time to a lawful General Assembly was at that time: yet the Apostle proveth, Rom. 14.
Answ. 1. Your enumeration is weake, for we know no Scandall justly taken, but proceeding from both these, weaknesse or wickedness of nature, is the neerest cause of all Scandall taken, because it is the cause of all sinne, and to be scandalized is sinne. Also it is here taken from the enormitie of the deed, in that practising of things indifferent, if a scandall taken either weakly or maliciously thence arise, there is enormitie in the deed, yet totall abstinence is not hence concluded, because, cessante ratione scandali, when the ground of the Scandall is removed, there is no enormitie in the fact. 2. You define to us, or rather divine, that then there is an irregularitie in the fact that justly scandaliz•th, when either the fact is a sinne, or then hath a manifest shew of sinne. And we wonder where you learned this strange Divinitie, for 1 Cor. 10. 27. To eat meat at a Feast that you are invited unto▪ is neither sinne, because v. 23. 25. it is lawfull: The earth is the Lords, nor is it such as hath a manifest shew of sinne, as all having sense knoweth. One of your prime Doctors defined to me, these onely have manifest appearance of sinne, Quae pl•rumque fiunt malo fine, which for the most part are done for an evill •nd, such as is to lye in bed with another mans wife, to kneele before an Idoll. The form•r, in the exposition of all is done for adulterie, the latter for Idolatrie. I am sure to eat meats at an Infidels feast, is not of that nature which is done ordinarily for an evill end, it is ordinarily done to refresh nature, and to sol••e it, which hath no manifest shew of sinne, and yet if there be a weake one beside, who saith, that meat is offered ⟨p. 17⟩to Idols, in that case to eat, is to scandalize 32. and is against the glory of God, v. 31. 3. You aske from whom we learned this strange doctrine to deny obedience to the lawes of Superiours for scandall causlesly taken; And we answer, we learned it from the Apostle Paul, who saith 1 Cor. 8. 13. If meat offend my weake brother, I will eat no flesh (I will abstaine totally and absolutely) while the world standeth. This abstinence for the date of the worlds standing, God be thanked, is longer then the time to a lawfull Generall Assembly was at that time: yet the Apostle proveth, Rom. 14