pp. 28–316 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Last of all, when a man is peremptorily urged by his Superiors, to obey their lawful Commandments, and in the mean time feareth▪ that if he do the thing commanded by them▪ some, through weakness, shall be scandalized▪ by his carriage; in this case he is not only in difficulty and strait, betwixt the Commandment of men, and the Commandment ⟨p. 29⟩of God, who forbiddeth us to do that whereby our weak brother may be offended. But also he seemeth to be in a strait betwixt two Commandments of God, to wit, the precept that forbiddeth us to do that, whereby our weak brother may be scandalized and the other, which forbiddeth, the resisting of Authority.
LAst of all, when a man is perempt•rily urged by his Superiours, to obey their lawfull Commandements, and in the meane time feareth▪ that if he doe the thing commanded by them▪ some, through weaknesse, shall be scandalized▪ by his carriage; in this case he is not onely in difficultie and strait, betwixt the Commandement of men, and the Commandement ⟨p. 29⟩of God, who forbiddeth us to doe that whereby our weake brother may be offended. But also he seemeth to be in a strait betwixt two Commandements of God, to wit, the precept that forbiddeth us to doe that, whereby our weake brother may be scandalized and the other, which forbiddeth, the resisting of Authoritie.
Answer. 1. The question of purpose is perversely set do •ne, for they should say, whether the precept of obedience to Superiors, in a straw lifting, in things indifferent, and merely positive, and not necessary to salvation, be more obligatory, then the precept of God, in the law of nature, in a matter necessary to salvation, as a Commandment of God forbidding soul-murder, and scandalizing him for whom Christ died? Or thus; Whether am I obliged rather to obey God, forbidding me to murder my brother, or to obey man, commanding me to kneel towards Bread and Wine, and to cross the air with my thumb upon the face of a baptized infant.1
Answer. 1. The question of purpose is perversly set do •ne, for they should say, whether the precept of obedience to Superiours, in a straw lifting, in things indifferent, and meerely positive, and not necessarie to salvation, be more obligatorie, then the precept of God, in the law of nature, in a matter necessarie to salvation, as a Commandement of God forbidding soul-murther, and scandalizing him for whom Christ died? Or thus; Whether am I obliedged rather to obey God, forbidding me to murther my brother, or to obey man, commanding me to kneele towards Bread and Wine, and to crosse the aire with my thumbe upon the face of a baptized infant.1
2. The question seemeth to make a collision of Commandments, as if God could command things contradictory, and certainly, if the not obeying of Perth Articles be a scandal given, as you say, it is▪ I shall undertake to prove, that the practice of these Ceremonies is a Scandal given, and so it is not a seeming strait as you say, but a real strait by your doctrine. There be cases wherein, whether Rulers command things, or command the contrary, a passive scandal doth arise, but because a passive Scandal, is the sin of the scandal taker, and not of Rulers giving, the Church is not to regard it, as Matth▪ 11. 18▪ 19. The Jews are scandalized, at Christs eating and drinking, and are scandalized at John the Baptists not eating and drinking. But neither Christ, nor John do culpably give scandal. But there can be no such exigence of providence wherein non-practising of your commanded Ceremonies, is a given scandal, and the practising of them is also a given scandal. Because (as aBannes, and our own bAm•sius saith▪ There is not such a perplexity. 1. God should have brought a man then in some cases under an absolute necessity, by way of contradiction to sin, and murder his brother, whether he do such a thing or not do it. 2. Twenty Jews are scandalized, Rom. 14. Because Paul eateth such and such meats, which they conceive are forbidden ⟨p. 30⟩by Gods law. And twenty Christians are scandalized, because Paul eateth not such and such meats, then we suppose, and its very casual, for seeing, to be scandalized ariseth from the knowledge or ignorance of the mind, and divers men may have contrary opinions about one thing. Some think it unlawful for Paul to eat, some think it unlawful not to eat. Hence upon the use of a thing indifferent, twenty are scandalized, and upon the non-using of that same indifferent thing, twenty are also scandalized. What shall Paul do in this strait. I answer, he taketh Rom. 14
Some object, but if either of the sides be indifferent, to wit, either to use a thing indifferent, or not to use it. If ten take offence at the use of it, and ten take offence at the non-use of it, there is a necessity of scandalizing either of the sides, for the twenty weak Christians are scandalized at Pauls abstinence from such meats, conceiving that he Judaizeth, whereas the Profession of his Christian liberty in eating would edify them, and not scandalize them.
Some object, but if either of the sides be indifferent, to wit, either to use a thing indifferent, or not to use it. If ten take offence at the use of it, and ten take offence at the non-use of it, there is a necessitie of scandalizing either of the sides, for the twentie weake Christians are scandalized at Pauls abstinence from such meats, conceiving that he Judaizeth, whereas the Profession of his Christian libertie in eating would edifie them, and not scandalize them.
Answer. The use of a thing indifferent is not Gods lawful mean of edification, God hath appointed his Word, Works, the holy and blameless profession of his children to edify, and not the using of actions indifferent, yea, actions indifferent as they are such, and separated from necessity, and moral reason, are not lawful, and so the cessation from that action is lawful and necessary, and if the use scandalize, non-using of things indifferent, is not indifferent, but necessary, as non-scandalizing, and negative precepts always binding, abstinence, with Paul is necessary. It is vain that Paybodie saith, that Peter was Gal. 2. in danger of a double scandal, for (saith he) he was in danger to scandalize the Gentiles, in refusing their company, as if they had been no brethren, which was the greater scandal, and in danger to scandalize the Jews in eating with the Gentiles, which was a less ⟨p. 31⟩sin, and less scandal. But I answer, Paul did not then justly rebuke his Judaizing, Galat. 2. which doth gratify Barronius, Bellarmine, and Papists, who will have Peter, an Apostle who could not err. 2. It should follow that Paul rebuked Peter, because that of two evils of sin, he chose to commit the lesser sin. Whereas of two evils of sin, neither is to be chosen. One might then lawfully commit fornication to be free of adultery. and so fornication should be lawful, which is absurd. And Paul should call Gal. 2. 14. it upright walking according to the truth of the Gospel to choose a less sin. 3. Peter by eating with the Gentiles, should not have scandalized the Jews, but edified them, in showing the Christian liberty they had in Christ, as is clear, v. 5. To whom we gave no subjection, no not for an hour (by practising Jewish Ceremonies) that the truth of the Gospel might continue with you.
Answer. The use of a thing indifferent is not Gods lawfull mean of edification, God hath appointed his Word, Workes, the holy and blamelesse profession of his children to edifie, and not the using of actions indifferent, yea, actions indifferent as they are such, and separated from necessitie, and morall reason, are not lawfull, and so the cessation from that action is lawfull and necessarie, and if the use scandalize, non-using of things indifferent, is not indifferent, but necessarie, as non-scandalizing, and negative precepts alwayes binding, abstinence, with Paul is necessarie. It is vaine that Paybodie saith, that Peter was
2. The question seemeth to make a collision of Commandements, as if God could command things contradictorie, and certainly, if the not obeying of Pearth Articles be a scandall given, as you say, it is▪ I shall undertake to prove, that the practice of these Ceremonies is a Scandall given, and so it is not a seeming strait as you say, but a reall strait by your doctrine. There be cases wherein, whether Rulers command things, or command the contrary, a passive scandall doth arise, but because a passive Scandall, is the sinne of the scandall taker, and not of Rulers giving, the Church is not to regard it, as Matth▪ 11. 18▪ 19. The Jewes are scandalized, at Christs eating and drinking, and are scandalized at John the Baptists not eating and drinking. But neither Christ, nor John doe culpably give scandall. But there can be no such exigence of providence wherein nonpractising of your commanded Ceremonies, is a given scandall, and the practising of them is also a given scandall. Because (as aBannes, and our owne bAm•sius saith▪ There is not such a perplexiti•. 1. God should have brought a man then in some cases under an absolute necessitie, by way of contradiction to sinne, and murther his brother, whether he doe such a thing or not doe it. 2. Twentie Jewes are scandalized, Rom. 14. Because Paul eateth such and such meats, which they conceive are forbidden ⟨p. 30⟩by Gods law. And twentie Christians are scandalized, because Paul eateth not such and such meats, then we suppose, and its very casuall, for seeing, to be scandalized ariseth from the knowledge or ignorance of the minde, and divers men may have contrary opinions about one thing. Some thinke it unlawfull for Paul to eat, some thinke it unlawfull not to eat. Hence upon the use of a thing indifferent, twentie are scandalized, and upon the non-using of that same indifferent thing, twentie are also scandalized. What shall Paul doe in this strait. I answer, he taketh Rom. 14. 1 Cor. 8. the negative. I will not eat flesh, if meat offend my brother. Then the twentie that are scandalized by the non-practice of the thing indifferent, doe take scandall onely, whereas Paul giveth no scandall actively. Also, the othet twentie who are scandalized by Paul his practice of the thing indifferent, are justly scandalized, & it is both a scandall taken, and active, and a scandall given and passive.