Whether the Rulers by their Office, in order to peace, are to stand to the Laws of Moses, for punishing seducing Teachers.Whether the Rulers by their Office, in order to peace, are to stand to the Lawes of Moses, for punishing seducing Teachers.
pp. 298–33462 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Judicial Laws may be judicial and Mosaical, and so not obligatory to us, according to the degree and quality of punishment, such as is Deut. 13. the destroying the City, and devoting all therein to a curse; we may not do the like in the like degree of punishment, to all that receive and defend Idolaters and blasphemers in their City: And yet that some punishment by the sword, be inflicted upon such a City, is of perpetual obligation; because the Magistrate bears the sword to take vengeance on ill doers, and so on these that are partakers of his ill deeds, who brings another Gospel, 2 Joh, v. 10.
JƲdiciall Lawes may be judiciall and Mosaicall, and so not obligatory to us, according to the degree and quality of punishment, such as is Deut. 13. the destroying the City, and devoting all therein to a curse; we may not do the like in the like degree of punishment, to all that receive and defend Idolators and blasphemers in their City: And yet that some punishment by the sword, be inflicted upon such a City, is of perpetuall obligation; because the Magistrate beares the sword to take vengeance on ill doers, and so on these that are partakers of his ill deeds, who brings another Gospell, 2 Ioh, v. 10.
2.1 Though Sauls destroying of the Amalekites in that cause was moral, in regard they lay in wait for Israel, when they came out of Egypt, and so of perpetual obligation, yet the destroying of them,
. is temporary, and obligeth not us; 1. because that generation were their Sons, not those same persons that oppressed Israel, when they came out of Egypt, and we may not punish the Sons for the sins of their fathers with death; therefore Gods positive command to Saul, and the reason, I remember what Amalek did (in Moses his time) therefore kill them, does not oblige us, except we had the like command. 2. Because the slaying of man, woman, infant, and suckling, ox and sheep, was temporary, and cannot have a perpetually obligatory ground in the Law of nature or natural justice obliging us. 3. Where there is an injury done to God, against the Law of nature, and against our brethren, in drawing them from serving the true God, and a punishment commanded by God to be inflicted once; that punishment, or the like in substance and nature,
must ever be such as obligeth us in the like cases. The Learned Professors in Leiden say, They can see no reason but they must oblige under the New Testament. I confess
⟨p. 299⟩
when the fault is ceremonial, though the punishment be real, as the cutting off of an infant not circumcised, and some punishments inflicted on the Leper, it is not reason the Law should oblige us in the New Testament, either as touching the punishment or the degree. Because these punishments for typical faults are ordained to teach, rather than to be punishments, and the Magistrate by no light of nature could make Laws against unbaptized Infants.
2.1 Though Sauls destroying of the Amalekites in that cause was morall, in regard they lay in wait for Israel, when they came out of Egypt, and so of perpetuall obligation, yet the destroying of them, 1 Sam. 15. is temporary, and obligeth not us; 1. because that generation were their Sons, not those same persons that oppressed Israel, when they came out of Egypt, and we may not punish the Sonnes for the sinnes of their fathers with death; therefore Gods po•itive command to Saul, and the reason, I remember what Amalek did (in Moses his time) therefore kill them, does not oblige us, except we had the like command. 2. Because the slaying of man, woman, infant, and suckling, oxe and sheep, was temporary, and cannot have a perpetually obligatory ground in the Law of nature or naturall justice obliging us. 3. Where there is an injury done to God, against the Law of nature, and against our brethren, in drawing them from serving the true God, and a punishment commanded by God to be inflicted once; that punishment, or the like in substance and nature,2 must ever be such as obligeth us in the like cases. The Learned Professors in Leidon say, They can see no reason but they must oblige under the New Testament. I confesse ⟨p. 299⟩when the fault is ceremoniall, though the punishment be reall, as the cutting off of an infant not circumcised, and some punishments inflicted on the Leper, it is not reason the Law should oblige us in the New Testament, either as touching the punishment or the degree. Because these punishments for typicall faults are ordained to teach, rather than to be punishments, and the Magistrate by no light of nature could make Lawes against unbaptised Infants.
1How Judicial Laws oblige to punishment.How Iudiciall Lawes oblige to puni••ment.
4. No man but sees the punishment of theft is of common moral equity, and obligeth all Nations, but the manner or degree of punishment is more positive: as to punish Theft by restoring four Oxen for the stealing of one Ox, doth not so oblige all Nations, but some other bodily punishment, as whipping, may be used against Thieves. Mr. Jo. Weemes, vo. 3. ca. 38. of the judicial Law, The determination (saith he) in Moses Law judicial, was divini juris, and they had greater force to bind the Sons, than any Municipal Laws have to bind Subjects new, in regard they were given by God himself; yet these judicial Laws (saith he) commanded the outward man, whereas the moral Law called [Greek or Hebrew] ignea lex, Deu. 33. This fiery law pierceth the heart.
4. No man but sees the punishment of theft is of common morall equity, and obligeth all Nations, but the manner or degree of punishment is more positive: as to punish Theft by restoring foure Oxen for the stealing of one Oxe, doth not so oblige all Nations, but some other bodily punishment, as whipping, may be used against Theeves. Mr. Jo. Weemes, vo. 3. ca. 38. of the judiciall Law, The determination (saith he) in Moses Law judiciall, was divini juris, and they had greater force to binde the Sonnes, than any Municipall Lawes have to binde Subjects new, in regard they were given by God himselfe; yet these judiciall Lawes (saith he) commanded the outward man, whereas the morall Law called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 ignea lex, Deu. 33. This fiery law pierceth the heart.
Gamachaeus saith,1 Judicials and Ceremonials are immediately deduced out of the principles of the Law of nature▪ by way of a more remote and obscure conclusion.
Gamachaeus saith,1 Iuditials and Ceremonials are immediately deduced out of the principles of the Law of nature▪ by way of a more remote and obscure conclusion.
Aquinas saith,1 by way of divine determination. But the truth is, the proposition might have some ground in the Law of nature, but why 39. stripes, not, 40. not 38. only should be inflicted on such an evil doer, and the assumption in many judicial Laws▪2seem to be an act of the mere positive will of God,3 therefore Aquinas saith, Ceremonials primo & per••se, first and chiefly were ordained to signify things, but Judicials secondary did signify things to come. And Swarez saith, That judicials necessarily, and by accident, did signify things. It is true, Cori•thus, […] and Jerome saith,4 and the Ebionites, as Irenaeus saith, and the Nazarer, as Augustine tells us, hold that Ceremonials and Judicials do yet oblige. Schoolmen deny their obligation ⟨p. 300⟩as Soto, 5Aquinas, Medina, Valentia, Gamacheus, because the Priesthood is changed.
Aquinas saith,1 by way of divine determination. But the truth is, the proposition might have some ground in the Law of nature, but why 39. stripes, not, 40. not 38. only should be inflicted on such an evill doer, and the assumption in many judiciall Lawes▪2seeme to be an act of the meere positive will of God,3 therefore Aquinas saith, Ceremonials primo & per••se, first and chiefly were ordained to signifie things, but Iudicials secundarie did signifie things to come. And Swarez saith, That judi•ials aecessarily, and by accident, did signifie things. It is true, Cori•thus, 〈…〉 and •erome saith,4 and the Ebionits, as Irenaeus saith, and the Nazarer, as Augustine tels us, hold that Ceremoniais and Judicials do yet oblige. Shoolemen deny their obligation ⟨p. 300⟩as Soto, 5Aquinas, Medina, Ʋalentia, Gamacheus, because the Priesthood is changed.
1Judicial Laws were deduced from the Moral Law.Iudiciall Lawes were deduced from the Morall Law.
2Thomas, 22. q. 104. art. 2.
3Swarez de legib. p. 9. c. 11. n. 2. Epiphanius de heres. 8 Augustinus de haeres. 8.
4Irenaeus, l 1. c. 26. Augus. de her. 9.
5Soto de insi•t. & Jurae l. 2 c. 5. Aquinas 12▪ q. 9. ar. 5.
Yet let not us go on with Egid-Coninck to say,1 that if it was lawful to make war with any nation for wrongs done to men, how much more for injuries done to God? for making of war is an act of Magistracy,2 and so suppose some jus, some power and authority, that we have either by the law of nature, to defend our life,3 peace, liberties, or for avenging of such heinous injuries done to the Nation as cannot in justice be decided, but by the sword. So that sin, as sin, or as greatest sins,4 are not the just cause of war, but sins as most destructive to humane society, for which by the Principles of the Law of nature,5 they may be convinced of fearful breaches; Now these that are Idolaters, the nations that worship God in Idolatrous way, and being of a strange Religion, worship a strange God, though they do the greatest injury to God that can be, yet in regard they being other nations as independent on us, as we are on them; and do it not in order to the destruction of our of our peace, liberty, and lives, we have not jus over them, nor authority to make War with them, except God gave us a Command to destroy them, nor is this a good consequence, we may by war revenge injuries done to men, erg•, far more, by war, may we revenge injuries done to God: for war is an act of revenging justice: that supposeth some authority given of God, over such a nation as we come out against in war.
Yet let not us go on with Egid-Coninck to say,1 that if it was lawfull to make war with any nation for wrongs done to men, how much more for injuries done to God? for making of war is an act of Magistracy,2 and so suppose some jus, some power and authority, that we have either by the law of nature, to defend our life,3 peace, liberties, or for avenging of such heineous in•uries done to the Nation as cannot in justice be decided, but by the sword. So that sin, as sin, or as greatest sinnes,4 are not the just cause of war, but sinnes as most distructive to humane society, for which by the Principles of the Law of nature,5 they may be convinced of fearfull breaches; Now these that are Idolators, the nations that worship God in Idolatrous way, and being of a strange Religion, worship a strange God, though they doe the greatest injury to God that can bee, yet in regard they being other nations as independent on us, as we are on them; and doe it not in order to the destruction of our of our paece, liberty, and lives, we have not jus over them, nor authority to make Warre with them, except God gave us a Command to destroy them, nor is this a good consequence, we may by war revenge injuries done to men, erg•, far more, by war, may we revenge injuries done to God: for war is an act of revenging justice: that supposeth some authority given of God, over such a nation as we come out against in war.
2 Every just war is some way defensive, in regard every act of Magistracy, is an act of defending of the peace, life, and liberty of the society, or the members thereof, and a propulsion of violence, by violence; and this is the intrinsical and of Magistracy, to hold off unjust violence, by just and harmless violence; for if the life of a murther•r be not taken away by the sword of a Magistrate, he will still take the life of another man, qui semel •alus, semper malus presumitur, •e that is once wicked, is still presumed to be wicked, except his wickedness be restrained, and to offend a nation or person that hath not offended us, must be unjust violence, and unlawful war: and to make war against a nation that ⟨p. 301⟩hath worshipped a strange God, and injured God, and not us, supposeth that we must instruct them of a wrong done to God, by teaching them, and instructing them in the true Religion: for suppose they worship the works of mens hands, and worship Satan as some Indians do and so by their own conscience may be convinced, and so are inexcusable in foro Dei, before Gods tribunal, yet are they not so inexcusable, in foro humano, before mans tribunal, as we can make war against them, till we inform and instruct them positively of the true Religion. But they that shed our blood, and invade our peace and liberties, are by the Law of nature convinced, and by demands of reparation made to them, quickly silenced, and need not to be instructed in the principles of the law of nature, which are written in their hearts. But it may be said, What if that Nation will not be informed of the true Religion, and will go on contumaciously to dishonour God, and reproach the true God? Shall we not upon a mere quarrel for Religion, make war against them, and avenge the injuries done to God, and defend his truth, no less then with the sword, we defend our own lives and liberties?
2 Every just war is some way defensive, in regard every act of Magistracy, is an act of defending of the peace, life, and liberty of the society, or the members thereof, and a propulsion of violence, by violence; and this is the intrinsecal and of Magistracy, to hold off unjust violence, by just and harmelesse violence; for if the life of a murther•r be not taken away by the sword of a Magistrate, he will still take the life of another man, qui semel •alus, semper malus presumitur, •e that is once wicked, is still presumed to be wicked, except his wickednesse be restrained, and to offend a nation or person that hath not offended us, must be unjust violence, and unlawfull war: and to make war against a nation that ⟨p. 301⟩hath worshiped a strange God, and injured God, and not us, supposeth that we must instruct them of a wrong done to God, by teaching them, and instructing them in the true Religion: for suppose they worship the workes of mens hands, and worship Sathan as some Indians do and so by their own conscience may be convinced, and so are inexcusable in foro Dei, before Gods tribunal, yet are they not so inexcusable, in foro humano, before mans tribunall, as we can make warre against them, till we informe and instruct them positively of the true Religion. But they that shed our blood, and invade our peace and liberties, are by the Law of nature convinced, and by demands of reparation made to them, quickly silenced, and need not to be instructed in the principles of the law of nature, which are written in their hearts. But it may be said, What if that Nation will not be informed of the true Religion, and will go on contumatiously to dishonour God, and reproach the true God? Shall we not upon a meer quarrell for Religion, make war against them, and avenge the injuries done to God, and defend his truth, no lesse then with the sword, we defend our own lives and liberties?
I Answer there is not the like reason: for God and nature have given to the strongest, a jus and authority over oppressors, to repel unjust violence, with innocent violence but that we should force the true Religion on Idolaters, we have not the like ground, except they did attempt to obtrude their false ways upon us, and injure our souls: for there is a vast difference between a people never receiving the true Religion, and a people who have embraced, and submitted to laws, that have enacted the profession of the true Religion: those that never professed the true Religion, cannot be compelled to receive it by the Sword of another Nation, except they first subdue them in a just war, and be masters of them, and they may educate the posterity of the subdued people, and discharge the duty of parents to them, and impose laws on themselves, to cast away the Idols of their fathers house, and to learn the knowledge of the true God: but they cannot make the not receiving of the true Religion the ground of a war: for we read not of any such ⟨p. 302⟩cause of war in the Scripture. It is true, God did command his people to destroy the Canaanites, but Idolatry was not the quarrel, Josh. 11. 19. There was not a nation that made pe••• with the Children of Israel, save the Hittites the inhabitants of Gibe on all (other) they took in battle, 20. For it was of the Lord to harden their heart, that they should come against Israel in battle, that he might destroy them utterly, and that they might have no favour, but that he might destroy them as the Lord commanded Moses. And those that they subdued in the Wilderness, denied them harmless passage through their Land.
I Answer there is not the like reason: for God and nature have given to the strongest, a jus and authority over oppressors, to repel unjust violence, with innocent violence but that we should force the true Religion on Idolators, we have not the like ground, except they did attempt to obtrude their false ways upon us, and injure our soules: for there is a vast difference between a people never receiving the true Religion, and a people who have imbraced, and submitted to lawes, that have inacted the profession of the true Religion: those that never professed the true Religion, cannot bee compelled to receive it by the Sword of another Nation, except they first subdue them in a just warre, and be masters of them, and they may educate the posterity of the subdued people, and discharge the duty of parents to them, and impose lawes on themselves, to cast away the Idols of their fathers house, and to learn the knowledge of the true God: but they cannot make the not receiving of the true Religion the ground of a war: for we read not of any such ⟨p. 302⟩cause of war in the Scripture. It is true, God did command his people to destroy the Canaanites, but Idolatry was not the quarrell, Josh. 11. 19. There was not a nation that made pe••• with the Children of Israel, save the Hittites the inhabitants of Gibe on all (other) they tooke in battell, 20. For it was of the Lord to harden their heart, that they should come against Israel in battell, that he might destroy them utterly, and that they might have no favor, but that he might destroy them as the Lord commanded Moses. And those that they subdued in the Wildernesse, denied them harmelesse passage through their Land.
It is true, some Popish writers, as Masius, Cornelius a lapide, Abulensis say,1 if the Canaanites would have sought peace, and embraced the worship of the true God, the Israelites would not have destroyed them,2 but the Text, Calvin and famous Papists, as Cajetanus, Swarez. Gamacha•s, and Augustine before them,3 say plainly, Israel made war against them, and Israel but defended themselves against the Canaanites. Libertines say the teaching of the Gospel, Mat. 28. and not the sword, is a means to spread the Gospel, so say we, I see no warrant we have to obtrude the Gospel in the purity thereof, upon Papists in France and Ireland: but we may lawfully avenge the blood of the people of God on Irish Murderers,4 who exercise extreme cruelty and Tyranny over persons and the Consciences of the Martyrs, and the oppressed people of God amongst the Papists.
It is true, some Popish writers, as Masius, Cornelius a lapide, Abulensis say,1 if the Canaanites would have sought peace, and imbraced the worship of the true God, the Israelites would not have destroyed them,2 but the Text, Calvin and famous Papists, as Cajetanus, Swarez. Gamacha•s, and Augustine before them,3 say plainly, Israel made warre against them, and Israel but defended themselves against the Canaanites. Libertines say the teaching of the Gospell, Mat. 28. and not the sword, is a means to spread the Gospell, so say we, I see no warrant wee have to obtrude the Gospell in the purity thereof, upon Papists in France and Ireland: but we may lawfully avenge the blood of the people of God on Irish Murtherers,4 who excercise extreame cruelty and Tyranny over persons and the Consciences of the Martyrs, and the oppressed people of God amongst the Papists.
1M•sius Cornelius a Lapide.
2Abulensis in Josh.
3Cajeta•us in Josh. c. 11 v. 2•. Swarez de v•r. Theo. disp. 18. sect. 4. n. 3. Gam•chaeus in 12, q. •o de infid. q. 32.
4Augustinus q 4•. in Num & in John q 3 10 Two Kingdoms, becoming […] a Religious Covenant if it be […], the one part may avenge the quarrel of the […] on the other in case of br••ch The new Altar […] by the 2 Tribes ••• the half […] Jordan Josh. 22. how […] cause of war.Augustinus q 4•. in Num & in John q 3 10 Two Kingdoms, becom•ing 〈…〉 a Re•igious Co••nant if it be 〈…〉, the one part may ave•ge the quarrell of the 〈…〉 on the oth•r in case of br••ch The new Altar 〈…〉 by the 2 Tribes ••• the halfe 〈…〉 Jordan Josh. 22. how 〈…〉 cause of war.
The question seems harder, when these of a false Religion, in regard of their nearness, and vicinity to a Kingdom professing the true Religion, when as they may infect them, or if they be in one National Covenant, and under the oath of God, to endeavour, the extirpation of all false religions, and what is contrary to sound doctrine. It is certain, the Kingdom of Judah might justly have avenged the Apostasy of the ten Tribes from Davids house, and from Jerusalem where the Lord had set his name, for the worshipping of the Golden Calves, if the Lord by his Prophet had not expressly forbidden them to fight against their brethren 1 Kings 12. And the children of Israel did justly attempt War against the two Tribes and the half, because they erected ⟨p. 303⟩a new Altar for worship, as they conceived, which was Apostasy from the Covenant of God, and the true Religion which they were to maintain by the Oath of Joshua 22. 12, 13, 15, 16. and to bring the wrath of God on all the Tribes as Achan did, Vers, 20, No doubt, saith Calvin on the place, They were angry with an holy Zeal, for saith he on Vers.1 12. The Sword is not given to every man in his hand, but every one according to his calling ought (by this place) manifestly and constantly to defend the true Religion. And if the wrath of God came on all the people (saith Calvin) for the secret sin of one man, much more the people shall not go unpunished, if they dissemble the manifest Idolatry of many. Piscator saith, It was piety in the Tribes that they resolve to make war with the two Tribes and the half, for their defection from the true God Such was their Zeal (say the Divines of England) that they would rather hazard their lives, then suffer Gods true Religion to be corrupted; for God had ordained there should be but one place for public service, and sacrifices, and but one Altar Leviticus 17. 8, 9. Deut. 12. 5. 7. 13. 27. Exodus 20. 24. Deut. 27. 5. For they were all in Covenant with one God, and this was a Schism and an Apostasy from the Church, (saith Diodat.2) in which alone is the true service of God and the participation of his grace, and Covenant. So also the Geneva Notes approves the lawfulness of the War, and the Dutch annotations.
The question seemes harder, when these of a false Religion, in regard of their neernesse, and vicinitie to a Kingdome professing the true Religion, when as they may infect them, or if they be in one Nationall Covenant, and under the oath of God, to indeavour, the extirpation of all false religions, and what is contrary to sound doctrin. It is certain, the Kingdom of Judah might justly have avenged the Apostacy of the ten Tribes from Davids house, and from Jerusalem where the Lord had set his name, for the worshipping of the Golden Calves, if the Lord by his Prophet had not expresly forbidden them to fight against their brethren 1 Kings 12. And the children of Israel did justly attempt Warre against the two Tribes and the halfe, because they erected ⟨p. 303⟩a new Altar for worship, as they conceived, which was Apostacy from the Covenant of God, and the true Religion which they were to maintaine by the Oath of Joshua 22. 12, 13, 15, 16. and to bring the wrath of God on all the Tribes as Achan did, Vers, 20, No doubt, saith Calvin on the place, They were angry with an holy Zeale, for sayth hee on Vers.1 12. The Sword is not given to every man in his hand, but every one according to his calling ought (by this place) manifestly and constantly to defend the true Religion. And if the wrath of God came on all the people (saith Calvin) for the secret sinne of one man, much more the people shall not goe unpunished, if they dissemble the manifest Idolatry of many. Piscator saith, It was piety in the Tribes that they resolve to make warre with the two Tribes and the halfe, for their defection from the true God Such was their Zeale (say the Divines of England) that they would rather hazzard their lives, then suffer Gods true Religion to bee corrupted; for God had ordained there should bee but one place for publique service, and sacrifices, and but one Altar Leviticus 17. 8, 9. Deut. 12. 5. 7. 13. 27. Exodus 20. 24. Deut. 27. 5. For they were all in Covenant with one God, and this was a Schisme and an Apostacy from the Church, (saith Diodat.2
1Calvin comment. in Josh. 22 Non dubium quin sancto zelo excanduerint, non omnibus quidam da•as gl•dius in manum sed pro su• quisque vocatione & officio viriliter & constanter asserere studet purum religionis statum contra omnes corruptelas.
2Calvin Ratiocinantur a minore ad majus. Piscator in Cor.
To this accord also, 1Popish Writers on the place, as Vatablus, Cajetanus, Cornelius a lapide, who commend this zeal, and say all the twelve Tribes made but on State and one Church,2 and Tostatus saith, there was a necessity of making War with the two Tribes,3 because the Law commanded it, Deut. 13. Therefore they took not counsel whither they should make War, but they consulted touching the manner. So agreeth Hugo Cardinalis,4⟨p. 304⟩So Masius.5 So Sorrarius. Lyra saith, War should not be undertaken, but upon a certain and just cause, especially against friend, therefore they send Messengers to the two Tribes, to try the cause of the new Altar. Menochius, Out of zeal they sent Messengers to try the crime of Idolatry, and to bring them to repentance, if not, to make destructive War against them. And Ferus, They were ready, if the two Tribes obeyed not, armis dicernere, […] decide the matter by war. Would God (saith he) there were such zeal in us,6 and we see not one Altar erected, but a number of superstitious Altars.
To this accord also, 1Popish Writers on the place, as Ʋatablus, Cajetanus, Cornelius a lapide, who commend this zeale, and say all the twelve Tribes made but on State and one Church,2 and Tostatus saith, there was a necessity of making War with the two Tribes,3 because the Law commanded it, Deut. 13. Therefore they tooke not councell whither they should make Warre, but they consulted touching the manner. So agreeth Hugo Cardinalis,4⟨p. 304⟩So Masius.5 So Sorrarius. Lyra saith, Warre should not be undertaken, but upon a certaine and just cause, especially against friend, therefore they send Messengers to the two Tribes, to try the cause of the new Altar. Menochius, Out of zeale they sent Messengers to try the crime of Idolatry, and to bring them to repentance, if not, to make destructive Warre against them. And Ferus, They were readie, if the two Tribes obeyed not, armis dicernere, 〈…〉 decide the matter by warre. Would God (saith he) there were such zeale in us,6 and we see not one Altar erected, but a number of superstitious Altars.
4Vat•b•us an. in Josh. 22. Cajetan come. in Josh. 22. Cornelius a lapide come. in Josh. 22. Venerunt ut dimicarent contra •os quasi. apostatas & schismaticos. Vide hic Z••um omnes enim duodecem. Tribus faciebant unam Rempublicam unamque Ecclesiam. Tostatus come. 2. in Josh. c. 22. q. 10. Necessitas autem pugnandi contra duas tribus incumbebat. Lex Deut. 13. id jubebat. Consilium autem est de contingentibus de modo. Hugo Cardinal. come. in Josh. 22.Vat•b•us an. in Josh. 22. Cajetan com. in Josh. 22. Cornelius a lapide com. in Josh. 22. Venerunt ut dimicarent contra •os quasi. apostatas & schismaticos. Vide hic Z••um omnes enim duodecem. Tribus faciebant unam Rempublicam unamque Ecclesiam. Tostatus com. 2. in
From this place it is clear, when a Kingdom, or two Kingdoms are united together, and confederate by the Oath of God in one Religious Covenant, they become an Ecclesiastic body, so as the whole may challenge any part that maketh defection, and labour to gain them, and if they contumaciously resist, they are with the sword to decide the matter, lest wrath from the Lord break out on the whole confederate body; as for the sin of one […], wrath came upon all Israel: Nor can I well see what can be answered on the contrary, except that that war for the new Altar, was undertaken upon judicial and temporary warrants, which do not bind us under the New Testament.
From this place it is cleere, when a Kingdome, or two Kingdomes are united together, and confederate by the Oath of God in one Religious Covenant, they become an Ecclesiastick body, so as the whole may challenge any part that maketh defection, and labour to gaine them, and if they contumaciously resist, they are with the sword to decide the matter, lest wrath from the Lord breake out on the whole confederate body; as for the sinne of one 〈…〉, wrath came upon all Israel: Nor can I well see what can be answered on the contrary, except that that warre for the new Altar, was undertaken upon judiciall and temporary warrants, which do not binde us under the New Testament.
But this is said, not proved, that new Altar was not a heap of stones; but if it had been made upon Religio•s grounds, and for the service of God, it had been no less than an Apostasy from that true Religion once delivered by God. Then if the third part of Scotland and England should turn Apostates from the Religion once sworn, after they had bound themselves in Covenant: the question remaineth, what should the State and Parliament do in that case? should they be indifferent beholders, and not use the sword against such Apostates?1 Swarez and others, not without reason, thinks that Infidels that are not Subjects, and not Apostates, cannot be compelled to embrace the true faith, even though it be sufficiently proposed to them, his reasons are, there is no lawful power given to the Church by Jesus Christ to compel such. 2. It is no tradition of the Church. 3. Those that are without cannot be judged; but the truth is, the sword is not given to the ⟨p. 305⟩Church, as the Church; and in the spreading of the Gospel, the Lord forbids the use of the sword. It is true, a Christian Prince may deny to Infidels liberty to dwell in his bounds. See Weemes, vo. 3. Expos. of the Judicial Law, cap. 15. And Subjects may be compelled not to blaspheme Christ, not to dishonour the true God with manifestly professed impieties;2 for if Asa made a Law, 2 Chron. 15. that they that would not seek the true God, should be put to death:3 If that be temporary and judaical, then the Christian Magistrate is not as a Christian Magistrate, or as a nurse-father, Isaiah. 49. 23. so much as to command any to serve Christ, nor to rebuke any for blasphemies. Sure this can be no part of the peaceableness of Christs Kingdom, not to rebuke sinners: But nurse-fathers and civill Tutors must do something for the defence of the truth from errors; for Constantine the great closed the Temples of Heathen Gods, to the end that heathenish Idolatry might be abolished, as Eusebius saith; see also Ruffinus, Jovianus, and Nicephorus, Justinian made many Laws against Idolaters. Before Constantine the great would pardon Arrius, [Greek or Hebrew] be exacted an Oath of him, that he should stand to the Nicene faith, and he sware, but dissembled. So Socrates; then Arrius was punishable by the Emperor.
But this is said, not proved, that new Altar was not a heap of stones; but if it had been made upon Religio•s grounds, and for the service of God, it had been no lesse than an Apostacy from that true Religion once delivered by God. Then if the third part of Scotland and England should turne Apostates from the Religion once sworne, after they had bound themselves in Covenant: the question remaineth, what should the State and Parliament doe in that case? should they be indifferent beholders, and not use the sword against such Apostates?1 Swarez and others, not without reason, thinkes that Infidels that are not Subjects, and not Apostates, cannot be compelled to imbrace the true faith, even though it be sufficiently proposed to them, his reasons are, there is no lawfull power given to the Church by Jesus Christ to compell such. 2. It is no tradition of the Church. 3. Those that are without cannot be judged; but the truth is, the sword is not given to the ⟨p. 305⟩Church, as the Church; and in the spreading of the Gospell, the Lord forbids the use of the sword. It is true, a Christian Prince may deny to Infidels liberty to dwell in his bounds. See Weemes, vo. 3. Expos. of the Iudiciall Law, cap. 15. And Subjects may be compelled not to blaspheme Christ, not to dishonour the true God with manifestly professed impieties;2 for if Asa made a Law, 2 Chron. 15. that they that would not seeke the true God, should be put to death:3 If that be temporary and judaicall, then the Christian Magistrate is not as a Christian Magistrate, or as a nurse-father, Esai. 49. 23. so much as to command any to serve Christ, nor to rebuke any for blasphemies. Sure this can be no part of the peaceablenesse of Christs Kingdome, not to rebuke sinners: But nurse-fathers and civill Tutors must do something for the defence of the truth from errors; for Constantine the great closed the Temples of Heathen Gods, to the end that heathenish Idolatry might be abolished, as Euschius saith; see also Ruffinus, Iovianus, and Nicephorus, Iustinian made many Lawes against Idolators. Before Constantine the great would pardon Arrius, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 be exacted an Oath of him, that he should stand to the Nicen faith, and he sware, but dissembled. So Socrates; then Arrius was punishable by the Emperour.
1Swarez de vir. the dis. 18. sect. 3.
2Augus. Epist. 166. ad donatistas.
3Constantinus prior contra partem Donati severissimam legem dedit, hanc imitati filii ejus talia praeceperunt Quibus succedens Julianus deser•or Christi & inimicus supplicantibus vestris Rogatiano & Pontio libertatem perditionis partis donati permisit, denique •eddidit Basilicas hereticis, quando templum daemoniis eo modo putans Christianum nomen posse perire de terris, si unitati Ecclesiae, de qua lapsus fuerat, invideret, & sacrilegas diffensiones liberas esse permittere•: deinde Valentinianus, legite quae contra vos jufferit▪ Inde Gratianus, & Theodosius legit quando vultis quae de vobis constituerint, Quid Ergo de filiis Theodosi• miramini, quasi allud de hac causa sequi debuerint quam Constantini judicium per tot Christianos Imperatores •••issi•• custoditum. Christian Princes Laws against errors and heresies. Eusebius in vita Co•stan. c. 43, 44. & l. 4 c. 13. Ruffinus Hist•r. p. 1. c. 19. Jovian. l. 10. c. 39. Nicephor. l. 8. c. 33. Ruffinus, c. 22. 25, 26. Nicephor, l. 12. c. 25. Socrates, l. 1. •. 26. Theodo•us Anagnostes collect. l. 2. The unconstancy of Timotheus Cotton Bishop of Constantinople, of Petr. Mongus Bishop of Alexandria.Constantinus prior contra partem Donati severissimam legem dedit, hanc imitati filii ejus talia praeceperunt Quibus succedens Iulianus deser•or Christi & inimicus supplicantibus vestris Rogatiano & Pontio libertatem perditionis partis donati permisit, denique •eddidit Basilicas hereticis, quando templum daemoniis eo modo putans Christianum nomen posse perire de terris, si unitati Ecclesiae, de qua lapsus fuerat, invideret, & sacrilegas diffensiones liberas esse permittere•: deinde Valentinianus, legite quae contra vos jufferit▪ Inde Gratianus, & Theodosius legite quando vultis quae de vobis constituerint, Quid Ergo de filiis Theodosi miramini, quasi allud de hac causa sequi debuerint quam Constantini judicium per tot Christianos Imperatores issi custoditum. Christian Princes Lawes against errors and resies. Eusebius in vita Costan. c. 43, 44. & l. 4 c. 13. Ruffinus Histr. p. 1. c. 19. Iovian. l. 10. c. 39. Nicephor. l. 8. c. 33. Ruffinus, c. 22. 25, 26. Nicephor, l. 12. c. 25. Socrates, l. 1. . 26. Theodous Anagnostes collect. l. 2. The unconstancy of Timotheus Coton Bishop of Constantinople, of Petr. Mongus Bishop of Alexandria.
So Timotheus Colo•, Bishop of Constantinople, under Anastius first Emperor, was an Euty•hen, and cursed such as rejected the Synod of Chalcedon, and before the Emperor cursed such as approved the Synod of Chalcedon; so Theod. Anagnostes, Petrus Mongus, Bishop of Alexandria under Zeno the Emperor, was an Eutichen, then again Orthodox, a little after ⟨p. 306⟩he rejected the Council of Chalcedon; a little after in an Epistle to Acacius Bishop of Alexandria, he professed the sound faith, and denied that he rejected the council of Chalcedon; again he rejects that council, and the sound faith;1 therefore Evagrius tells him, [Greek or Hebrew] A shoe, for every foot, a turn-coat, and a time-server. Ergo, such heretics, beside that they have not been innocent and godly (as Arminians say) they feared the sword of the Magistrate. But as touching the practice of Emperors, and the Imperial Laws for ratifying Church constitutions, there be but too many of them; as also for gathering Councils; which proveth the coactive power of Princes, Kings, and Emperors, over heretics and seducing teachers. Constantius, I grant, made a Law, that some godly men should be tolerated, ut pa•em cum fidelibus i• qui errant (he saith not heretics) pacis est quietis fruitionem gaudentes accipiant. Eusebius in vita Constan. and though the Emperor Grotian decreed, Ut quam quisque vellet Religionem sequerentur, That all Religions should be free, he had much ad• in wars with the Goths, who wasted Thracia, and was therefore careful that Ambrose should draw up a short confession, yet did he except from the Toleration the Manichees, the Phocinians, the Eunomians. But see, codice prima lege. Cunctos populos de sum. trinit. Martianus ibid lege. 4. Synod Chalcedo, Leo imperator, cons. 15. C. Const. 17. Heracl•us Imperator, const. 1. de fide Justinianus Novellus 123. c. 32. Novel 137. c. 6. Honorius, l. 4. c. 55. Eccle. Valentinianus, l. 9. de Episc. cler. Novel. 123. c. 18. Novella 123. c. 29. &c. Le. const. 87. Novel. 131. c. 4. Eusebius Pamphil de vita, Constan. l. 3. c. 13. Surius tom. 2. Concil. c. 20. p. 362. Codic. l. 1. Tit. de heret. lex 2. 1•6. Justinian codex l. 1. Tit. 4. de sum. Trinit lex 2. Surius concil. tom. 2. p. 469 421, 494. & tom. 2. p. 668, 669, 670. Socra Scholastic. his. l. 2. c. 37. Nicepher• hist. l. 9. c. 4. Contur. Magdeburque 4 col. 558.
So Timotheus Colo•, Bishop of Constantinople, under Anastius first Emperour, was an Euty•hen, and cursed such as rejected the Synod of Chalcedon, and before the Emperour cursed such as approved the Synod of Chalcedon; so Theod. Anagnostes, Petrus Mongus, Bishop of Alexandria under Zonon the Emperour, was an Eutichen, then againe Orthodox, a little after ⟨p. 306⟩he rejected the Councell of Chalcedon; a little after in an Epistle to Acacius Bishop of Alexandria, he professed the sound faith, and denyed that he rejected the councell of Chalcedon; againe he rejects that counsell, and the sound faith;1 therefore Evagrius tels him, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 A shoe, for every foot, a turne-coat, and a time-server. Ergo, such hereticks, beside that they have not been innocent and godly (as Arminians say) they feared the sword of the Magistrate. But as touching the practice of Emperors, and the Imperiall Laws for ratifying Church constitutions, there be but too many of them; as also for gathering Councels; which proveth the coactive power of Princes, Kings, and Emperours, over hereticks and seducing teachers. Constantius, I grant, made a Law, that some godly men should be tolerated, ut pa•em cum fidelibus i• qui errant (he saith not hereticks) pacis est quietis fruitionem gaudentes accipiant. Eusebius in vita Constan. and though the Emperour Grotian decreed, Ʋt quam quisque vellet Religionem sequerentur, That all Religions should be free, he had much ad• in warres with the Gothes, who wasted Thracia, and was therefore carefull that Ambrose should draw up a short confession, yet did he except from the Toleration the Manichees, the Phocinians, the Eunomians. But see, codice prima lege. Cunctos populos de sum. trinit. Martianus ibid lege. 4. Synod Chalcedo, Leo imperator, cons. 15. C. Const. 17. Heracl•us Imperator, const. 1. de fide Justinianus Novellus 123. c. 32. Novell 137. c. 6. Honorius, l. 4. c. 55. Eccle. Valentinianus, l. 9. de Episc. cler. Novell. 123. c. 18. Novella 123. c. 29. &c. Le. const. 87. Novell. 131. c. 4. Eusebius Pamphil de vita, Constan. l. 3. c. 13. Surius tom. 2. Concil. c. 20. p. 362. Codic. l. 1. Tit. de heret. lex 2. 1•6. Justinian codex l. 1. Tit. 4. de sum. Trinit lex 2. Surius concil. tom. 2. p. 469 421, 494. & tom. 2. p. 668, 669, 670. Socra Scholastic. his. l. 2. c. 37. Nicepher hist. l. 9. c. 4. Contur. Magdeburque 4 col. 558.
So for his power to convene Councils, as the Nicene, by Constanti, Euseb. l. 3. c. 6. Sozom, l. 1. c. 17. So•rat. l. 1. c. 6. Ruff. l. 10. c. 1. Theodor. l. 1. c. 7. the Council of Tyre by Constant. Eusebius, de vit. cons. l. 4. c. 41. Sozom. l. 1. c. 9. Theodosius elder, made a Law of death against the Anabaptists, and banished Eu••mius ⟨p. 307⟩Socrat. l. 7. c. 12. It is true, Constantinus and Licinius, as Eusebius tells us, l. 10. c. 5. say in a Law, now therefore we freely will and command, That every man have a free liberty to observe the Christian Religion, and that, without any grief or molestation, he may be suffered to do the same. But the practice of heathen Emperors, is no rule.
So for his power to conveene Councels, as the Nicen, by Constanti, Euseb. l. 3. c. 6. Sozom, l. 1. c. 17. So•rat. l. 1. c. 6. Ruff. l. 10. c. 1. Theodor. l. 1. c. 7. the Councell of Tyre by Constant. Eusebius, de vit. cons. l. 4. c. 41. Sozom. l. 1. c. 9. Theodosius elder, made a Law of death against the Anabaptists, and banished Eu••mius ⟨p. 307⟩Socrat. l. 7. c. 12. It is true, Constantinus and Licinius, as Eusebius tels us, l. 10. c. 5. say in a Law, now therefore we freely will and command, That every man have a free liberty to observe the Christian Religion, and that, without any griefe or molestation, he may be suffered to do the same. But the practice of heathen Emperous, is no rule.
4. The Heathen Law in the Letter would prove that none should be rebuked, or argued against, whatever Religion he chose; Maximius proclaimed, That all men should use what Religion they like best, Eus. l. 9. c. 10. But 1. Maximius, out of natural pity, because he had before persecuted Christians, did this. 2. Diocletian and Maximianus took Churches from them, he restored them; hence followed peace till an. 130. The Council of Constantinople, 1. by Theodosius senior, Theodoret, l. 5• c. 7. Socrates, l. 5. c. 8. The Council of Ephesus, 1. By Theodos. junior. Evagrius, l. 1. c. 2. So Imperator Justinus. l. 44. ad Maenam Patriarcham de Monachis & Monasteriis separandis & de Episc. & cler. Eusebius de vita cons. l. 3. c. 25. Epistolam libella ad Synoda constitutionem. The Bishops of the second general Council (if there was any of them general) writ to the Emperor Theodosius, We desire your clemency, that you by your Letters would confirm the Decrees of the Council (of Chalcedon) and command that it be ratified and established: which he did. See also Constantius his power, prescribing to the Councils of Ariminum and Seleucia the subject matter they should treat upon, and commanded ten of each Council to come and give him an account of their proceedings. S•zomen, l. 4. c. 6. Theodosius and Valentin• command the Council of Ephesus to send them some Bishops to acquaint them with the causes and motives of their deliberations. Relatio Synodi Ephesinae, quae est tom. 1. concil. The second Council of Nice, which some call the seventh General Council, relate the like to the Emperor at Constantinople, Theodoret, l. 5. c. 8. Zonaras, tom. 3. anat. There be two edicts of the Emperors, Valentinian and Martian, confirming the ⟨p. 308⟩Council of Chalcedon, so act. 3. Chalc. to. 1. Conc. all which say, the Emperours, de facto, commanded as Magistrates, Church-men to determine according to the word; and corrected such as contravened.1 And though Picus Mirandula saith well, No man hath power of opinions so, as if he will, he may have another opinion, which though it may bear, that opinions fall not under free-will, yet the venting of them to others, is to Mirancula, a free act and punishable. We know the Edict of Vale•inian and Martian, of capital punishment against Such as shall attempt to teach things unlawful.
4. The Heathen Law in the Letter would prove that none should be rebuked, or argued against, whatever Religion he chose; Maximius proclaimed, That all men should use what Religion they like best, Eus. l. 9. c. 10. But 1. Maximius, out of naturall pity, because he had before persecuted Christians, did this. 2. Dioclesian and Maximianus tooke Churches from them, he restored them; hence followed peace till an. 130. The Councell of Constantinople, 1. by Theodosius senior, Theodoret, l. 5• c. 7. Socrates, l. 5. c. 8. The Councell of Ephesus, 1. By Theodos. junior. Evagrius, l. 1. c. 2. So Imperator Iustinus. l. 44. ad Maenam Patriarcham de Monachis & Monasteriis separandis & de Episc. & cler. Eusebius de vita cons. l. 3. c. 25. Epistolam libella ad Synoda constitutionem. The Bishops of the second generall Councell (if there was any of them generall) writ to the Emperour Theodosius, We desire your clemency, that you by your Letters would confirme the Decrees of the Councell (of Chalcedon) and command that it be ratified and established: which he did. See also Constantius his power, prescribing to the Councels of Arimimon and Seleucea the subject matter they should treat upon, and commanded ten of each Councel to come and give him an account of their proceedings. S•zomen, l. 4. c. 6. Toeodosius and Valentin• command the Councell of Ephesus to send them some Bishops to acquaint them with the causes and motives of their deliberations. Relatio Synodi Ephesinae, quae est tom. 1. concil. The second Councell of Nice, which some call the seventh Generall Councell, relate the like to the Emperour at Constantinople, Theodoret, l. 5. c. 8. Zonaras, tom. 3. anat. There be two edicts of the Emperours, Valentinian and Martian, confirming the ⟨p. 308⟩Councel of Chalcedon, so act. 3. Chalc. to. 1. Conc. all which say, the Emperours, de facto, commanded as Magistrates, Church-men to determine according to the word; and corrected such as contravened.1 And though Picus Mirandula saith well, No man hath power of opinions so, as if hee will, he may have another opinion, which though it may beare, that opinions fall not under free-will, yet the venting of them to others, is to Mirancula, a free act and punishable. We know the Edict of Ʋale•inian and Martian, of capitall punishment against Such as shall attempt to teach things unlawfull.
1Pic•s Mirandula in apoloq. q. 8. Nemo sanae mentis ita opinatur. Ut alio modo opinari posset, quia ita vult opinare.Pic•s Mirandula in apoloq. q. 8. Nemo sanae mentis ita opinatur. Vt alio modo opinari posset, quia ita vult opinare.
Let false teachers according to Justinian, have no leave to live and dwell in Roman bounds, 1saith Pametius. Augustine saith, Heretics kill souls, let them be afflicted in body, they bring on men death eternal, and they complain that they suffer temporal deaths. And why (saith Augustine) should Sorcerers find the rigour of the Law from Emperors, and Heretics and Schismatics go free? Constantius gave out Edicts against Heretics, as Eusebius saith. h. 2. c. 27. And also made laws of pecuniary fines,2 and mulcts against them.
Let false teachers according to Justinian, have no leave to live and dwel in Roman bounds, 1saith Pametius. Augustine saith, Hereticks kill soules, let them be afflicted in body, they bring on men death eternal, and they complaine that they suffer temporall deaths. And why (saith Augustine) should Sorcerers find the rigor of the Law from Emperors, and Hereticks and Schismaticks go free? Constantius gave out Edicts against Hereticks, as Eusebius saith. h. 2. c. 27. And also made lawes of pecuniary fines,2 and mulcts against them.
1Edictum Valentiniani & Martiani lex 8. Quicunque Cod. de heret. Ultimo supplicio coerecantur qui illicita docere tentaverin•.
2Pametius c. 18. de diversis religionibus non admittendis. Augustinus, Epis. 50. ad Boni••• Occidunt animas affligantur in tempore, senipeternas mortes faciunt, & temporals see perpeti conqueruntur. August. contra Epist. Parmen•ani. c. 10.Pametius c. 18. de diversis religionibus non admittendis. Augustinus, Epis. 50. ad Boni••• Occidunt animas affligantur in tempore, senipeternas mortes faciunt, & temporales se perpeti conqueruntur. August. contra Epist. Parmen•ani. c. 10.
Honorius made laws against Donatists of fining and of banishing preachers of Donatism. Martianus did the like. The like saith Nazianz▪1of Theodosius the great. Banishment and other punishment, the Emperors inflicted upon Arrius, Macedonius, Nestorius, Futiches and their followers. Which the Arch-Bishop of Spalato M•de dominis granteth; though he says Augustine excepteth capital punishment, for such (saith he) he will not have to be inflicted for the conscience, which is a manifest depraving of the mind of Augustine, who will have such punishment according to the quality of the fault inflicted on them,2 as upon Sorcerers and Murderers. Let Augustine be considered in these and other places,3 after he retracted his too meek sentence, That they should not be punished at all. Alexander Alexandrinus said, Arrius and his followers ought to be punished with excommunication, and a curse, Theodoret. lib. 1. c. 4. But for the point in hand the Christian Magistrate is tied and obliged to these punishments ⟨p. 309⟩to be inflicted for moral offences, that the Law of God hath ordained, at least in nature: I prove.
Honorius made lawes against Donatists of fining and of banishing preachers of Donatisme. Martianus did the like. The like saith Nazianz▪1of Theodosius the great. Banishment and other punishment, the Emperours inflicted upon Arrius, Macedonius, Nestorius, Futiches and their followers. Which the Arch-Bishop of Spalato M•de dominis granteth; though he sayes Augustine excepteth capitall punishment, for such (saith he) he will not have to be inflicted for the conscience, which is a manifest depraving of the mind of Augustine, who will have such punishment according to the quality of the fault inflicted on them,2 as upon Sorcerers and Murtherers. Let Augustine be considered in these and other places,3 after hee retracted his too meeke sentence, That they should not be punished at all. Alexander Alexandrinus said, Arrius and his followers ought to bee punished with excommunication, and a curse, Theodoret. lib. 1. c. 4. But for the point in hand the Christian Magistrate is tyed and obliged to these punishments ⟨p. 309⟩to bee inflicted for morall offences, that the Law of God hath ordained, at least in nature: I prove.
1M▪ Actinius de domin•s de R•p. Eccles. l. 7. c. 8.
2Augustin. con. Crescom. Gra. l. 3. c. 5.
3Desid & operib. 148. 159 epist. ad Marc••••a. Epist. 150.
1 That which is moral,1 and cannot be determined by the wisdom and will of man, must be determined by the revealed will of God in his word; but the punishment of a seducing Prophet, that ruineth the soul of our brother, and makes him twofold more the child of Satan than before, is moral and cannot be determined by the wisdom and will of man: Ergo, such a punishing of a seducing Prophet, must be by the revealed will of God in his word. The Proposition is proved. 1. Because God only, not Moses, nor any other law-giver under him, taketh on him to determine death to be the adulterers punishment, Levit. 20. 10. And the same he determineth to be the punishment of wilful murder, Exod. 21. 12. of smiting of the Father or Mother, v. 15. of Man-stealing, vers. 16. of Sorcery, Exod. 22. 18. of Bestiality. 19. Of sacrificing to a strange God, vers. 10. And upon the same reason, God only, not any mortal man, must determine the punishment due to such as seduce souls to eternal perdition.2 For what reason can be imagined, why God can be the only determiner of such a punishment of killing, and not for the ruining the soul and making him the child of perdition. Let not any say by this reason, to tempt to any sin, by any evil counsel •• provocation to immoderate anger or envy, should deserve death, for every tempting to sin is a ruining of the soul of such as we give bad counsel unto, and tempt to sin.
1 That which is morrall,1 and cannot be determined by the wisdome and will of man, must be determined by the revealed will of God in his word; but the punishment of a seducing Prophet, that ruineth the soule of our brother, and makes him twofold more the childe of Sathan than before, is morrall and cannot be determined by the wisdome and will of man: Ergo, such a punishing of a seducing Prophet, must be by the revealed will of God in his word. The Proposition is proved. 1. Because God only, not Moses, nor any other law-giver under him, taketh on him to determin death to be the adulterers punishment, Levit. 20. 10. And the same he determineth to be the punishment of willfull murther, Exod. 21. 12. of smiting of the Father or Mother, v. 15. of Man-stealing, vers. 16. of Sorcery, Exod. 22. 18. of Beastiality. 19. Of sacrificing to a strange God, vers. 10. And upon the same reason, God only, not any mortall man, must determine the punishment due to such as seduce soules to eternall perdition.2 For what reason can be imagined, why God can be the onely determiner of such a punishment of killing, and not for the ruining the soul and making him the childe of perdition. Let not any say by this reason, to tempt to any sin, by any evill counsel •• provocation to immoderate anger or envy, should deserve death, for every tempting to sinne is a ruining of the soul of such as we give bad counsell unto, and tempt to sin.
1As Constantine g•ve out severe l•ws against Donatists, so did Julianus the apostate restore temples to heretics, and granted liberty of Conscience to them, that so he might destroy the name and Religion of Christians, as is before observed. So Augustin. Ep•. 166 ad Donatistas.As Constantine g•ve out severe l•ws against D•natists, so did Iulianus the apostate restore temples to heretickes, and granted liberty of Conscience to them, that so he might destroy the name and Religion of Christians, as is before observed. So Augustin. Ep•. 166 ad Donatistas.
2God only determineth punishments for sin.God only determineth punishments for sinne.
Answ. If we do so tempt them by a sinful way, as a sinful injuring, and railing on them, or by a wicked course, it is sure it doth deserve punishment by the Magistrate; but the act of so counselling and tempting to sin, though E• conditione operis, it be soul-ruin, yet it is not such as deserveth death. Otherwayes, killing, adultery, sorcery, bestiality, tempt also to sin and soul-ruin, besides the other injury in them, against the life and chastity of men.
Answ. If we do so tempt them by a sinfull way, as a sinfull injuring, and railing on them, or by a wicked course, it is sure it doth deserve punishment by the Magistrate; but the act of so counselling and tempting to sin, though E• conditione operis, it be soule-ruin, yet it is not such as deserveth death. Otherwayes, killing, adultery, sorcery, beastiality, tempt also to sinne and soule-ruine, besides the other injury in them, against the life and ch•stity of men.
2 The Proposition is proved, because the will of God can be the Creator, and first Author of nothing, but which is morally good. For the Scripture is as full in the duties ⟨p. 301⟩of the second table touching mercy and righteousness, as in the duties of the first, touching piety and religion, and any thing pretended to be moral, hath God for its author, in either the first or the second table of the Law, nor can the will of man be the author of any thing morally good, and will-righteousness, is as unlawful as will-worship, or will-piety, since the word is a perfect rule in matters of doctrine, or faith, or of life, manners and conversation, and teacheth the Judge what he should do, Deut. 17. 18, 19, 20. Psalm. 119. 9. Psalm. 19. 8, 9. Prov. 3. 21, 22, 23, &c.
2 The Proposition is proved, because the will of God can be the Creator, and first Author of nothing, but which is morrally good. For the Scripture is as full in the duties ⟨p. 301⟩of the second table touching mercy and righteousnesse, as in the duties of the first, touching piety and religion, and any thing pretended to be morrall, hath God for its authour, in either the first or the second table of the Law, nor can the will of man be the author of any thing morrally good, and will-righteousnesse, is as unlawfull as will-worship, or will-piety, since the word is a perfect rule in matters of doctrine, or faith, or of life, manners and conversation, and teacheth the Judge what he should doe, Deut. 17. 18, 19, 20. Psalm. 119. 9. Psalm. 19. 8, 9. Prov. 3. 21, 22, 23, &c.
3 What ever by order of justice, doth concern the life and death of our neighbour, rewarding or punishing him in name, body, goods, so as if it be justly inflicted, it is justice; and if unduly and undeservedly, it is unjustice, and murder: as wronging of him in his body by stripes, wounding, death; in his liberty by prison; in his goods, by fines; that must be determined in the word by him that is Lord of life, death, liberty, of our name and goods, otherwayes the word should not teach us when the Judge sins, when not, when he makes just Laws, when unjust, when he exceeds in punishing, when he is deficient.
3 What ever by order of justice, doth concerne the life and death of our neighbour, rewarding or punishing him in name, body, goods, so as if it bee justly inflicted, it is justice; and if unduely and undeservedly, it is unjustice, and murther: as wronging of him in his body by stripes, wounding, death; in his liberty by prison; in his goods, by fines; that must be determined in the word by him that is Lord of life, death, libertie, of our name and goods, otherwayes the word should not teach us when the Judge sinnes, when not, when he makes just Lawes, when unjust, when he exceeds in punishing, when he is deficient.
I come to the assumption, The punishing of a seducing Prophet is moral.1 In that it is commanded to father and mother, not to pity him, Deut. 13. 6. holden forth as the zeal of God, in father and mother, under the Messiahs Kingdom, Zach. 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. and every one is forbidden, To bid him God speed, yea, and commanded to deny him an act of humanity, and hospitality, and not receive him in his house, 2 Joh. 1. If we be commanded to put any shame on him, far more must the Ruler be taught of God, what shame he should put on him. For what ever under the New Testament is capable of a command, is moral. And if moral, what the Magistrate should do to him can no more be determined by the will and wit of man, than it can be determined what punishment the Magistrate must inflict upon the murderer, the adulterer, the Sorcerer, the Sodomite; which all the wisdom of God hath determined: in the word, otherways God hath left the Magistrate in the dark, that from the word he hath no direction, when he committeth murder, or when he doth acts of justice. And ⟨p. 311⟩that it is a moral act also to seduce souls is clear, in that, 1. We are commanded to beware of such. Matth. 7. 5. and avoid them, Tit. 3. 10. Rom. 16. 17. 2. That the Lord condemneth them in his word, as such as make their followers the children of perdition, Yea Matth. 22. 15. They subvert the hearers; their word cate as a Canker, 2 Tim. 2. 15, 17. Lead silly women Captive, 2 Tim. 3. are Deceivers, Tit. 1. 10. Now that God hath appointed a punishment for this of old, and hath spoken against this sin so much in the New Testament, and bidden private Christians, cry shame on Seducers, and fly them, and yet left the Magistrate under a discharge, and inhibition to draw a sword against such: who can believe it? except that inhibition given to the Christian Magistrate were written in the Testament of our Lord. To say the new Testament-dispensation is so spiritual that God will have no remedying of seducing, but by the spiritual armour of the word, is said without ground, when the New Testament-dispensation is as spiritual to gain the Sorcerer, the The•fe, the Sodomite, the drunkard, the Reviler, as the Idolater by the spiritual armour of the Word, Act. 19. 19. 1 Cor. 6. 9, 10, 11. and by this reason the Magistrate may draw the sword against no thief, Sodomite, Drunkard, Sorcerer, contrary to Rom. 13.
I come to the assumption, The punishing of a seducing Prophet is morrall.1 In that it is commanded to father and mother, not to pitty him, Deut. 13. 6. holden forth as the zeale of God, in father and mother, under the Messia•s Kingdome, Zach. 13. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. and every one is forbidden, To bid him God speed, yea, and commanded to deny him an act of humanity, and hospitality, and not receive him in his house, 2 Joh. 1. If we be commanded to put any shame on him, far more must the Ruler bee taught of God, what shame he should put on him. For what ever under the New Testament is capable of a command, is morall. And if morall, what the Magistrate should doe to him can no more be determined by the will and wit of man, than it can be determined what punishment the Magistrate must inflict upon the murtherer, the adulterer, the Sorcerer, the Sodomite; which all the wisdom of God hath determined: in the word, otherways God hath left the Magistrate in the dark, that from the word he hath no direction, when he committeth murther, or when he doth acts of justice. And ⟨p. 311⟩that it is a morall act also to seduce soules is cleare, in that, 1. We are commanded to beware of such. Matth. 7. 5. and avoid them, Tit. 3. 10. Rom. 16. 17. 2. That the Lord condemneth them in his word, as such as make their followers the children of perdition, Yea Matth. 22. 15. They subvert the hearers; their word cate as a Canker, 2 Tim. 2. 15, 17. Lead silly women Captive, 2 Tim. 3. are Deceivers, Tit. 1. 10. Now that God hath appointed a punishment for this of old, and hath spoken against this sinne so much in the New Testament, and bidden private Christians, cry shame on Seducers, and fly them, and yet left the Magistrate under a discharge, and inhibition to draw a sword against such: who can beleeve it? except that inhibition given to the Christian Magistrate wer written in the Testament of our Lord. To say the new Testament-dispensation is so spirituall that God wil have no remedying of seducing, but by the spirituall armor of the word, is said without ground, when the New Testament-dispensation is as spirituall to gaine the Sorcerer, the Thefe, the Sodomite, the drunkard, the Reviler, as the Idolater by the spirituall amor of the Word,
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. 1 Pet. 2. 14. Especially since the Magistrate is not indifferent towards ill-doers, and well-doers, since he must punish the one as a Nurse-Father, praise and reward the other, 1 Peter 2. 14. gaining of souls is well-doing, Matthew 25. 21, 23. And seducing of souls is by the Law of Nature and Nations, the worst of injuries done to men.1
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. 1 Pet. 2. 14. Especially since the Magistrate is not indifferent towards ill-doers, and well-doers, since hee must punish the one as a Nurse-Father, praise and reward the other, 1 Peter 2. 14. gaining of soules is well-doing, Matthew 25. 21, 23. And seducing of soules is by the Law of Nature and Nations, the worst of injuries done to men.1
1To punish the seducing teacher is an act of justice morally obliging men ever, and every where.
2 Argument, That which is perpetually moral, and one act of Justice at all times and places, must oblige us Christians, and the Christian Magistrate, as well as the Jewish Rulers: But to punish the seducing Prophet is perpetually moral, and an act of justice at all times, and in all places, as the rewarding of such as teach truth, is a commendable act of justice, Ergo,
2 Argument, That which is perpetually morall, and one act of Justice at all times and places, must oblige us Christians, and the Christian Magistrate, as well as the Jewish Rulers: But to punish the seducing Prophet is perpetually morall, and an act of justice at all times, and in all places, as the rewarding of such as teach truth, is a commendable act of justice, Ergo,
The proposition is clear, in regard the moral Law doth therefore oblige us Christians, because it is morally perpetual, and perpetually moral; and that in all times and places▪ as to serve God, honour our parents, not to murder, ⟨p. 312⟩&c. is perpetually moral now, as among Jews, with us, as among the Indians and Tartarians: but to punish the seducing Prophet is such; 1. because the Heretic is condemned by his own conscience,1Tit. 3. 10. in believing lies Ergo, Far more by his own conscience, by leading others into that same condemnation with himself; and if he apprehend the vengeance of a God-head, there must be a conscience naturally apprehending such: as we see the conscience of murderers, and of Cain, fear some revenging hand. If therefore the Minister of God, the Magistrate, inflict this, it must be nothing else but an act of natural Justice, which the natural conscience doth apprehend. But what acts of Justice the conscience naturally fears, must be acts of Justice perpetually moral, not respecting one man or Nation more than another. 2. All Countries by an instinct, apprehend a God,2 and conceive their Priests and Prophets are to be entertained and rewarded, as Egypt, Gen. 47. 22. Midian, F•xed, 2. 16. Exod. 18. 1. Judg. 17. 5. c. 18. 4. 2 King. 15. 18. The Philistines, 1 Sam. 5. 5. c. 6. 2. Baal and the Zidonians had their Priests, 2 King. 10. 8, 19, Lycaonia, Act 14. 13. And if their Rulers feed their Priests, the false Prophets and Priests that deceive them, and mis-lead them, they must punish: So the King of Babylon roasted in a fire two false Prophets, Jer. 29. 21, 22. And it is clear, that Jeremiah argues not from any judicial Law, when he saith, The Prophets that speak lies in the name of the Lord, shall die by the sword, c. 14. v. 14, 15. It was by the sword of the Chaldeans, (who had nothing but the Law of nature) that they perished; for no Judicial Law of God taught them, that he ought to die by the sword of the Magistrate, who speaks lies in the name of the Lord; whereas the Chaldeans knowing that Jeremiah had prophesied truth, and was sent of God, they entreated him well, as the Lord had fore-told, Jer. 15. 8. Nor can it be said, that the consequence is null, and that that cannot oblige Christian Magistrates, which hath no better warrant than the corrupt practises of Heathens;
The proposition is cleare, in regard the morall Law doth therefore oblige us Christians, because it is morally perpetuall, and perpetually morall; and that in all times and places▪ as to serve God, honour our parents, not to murder, ⟨p. 312⟩&c. is perpetually morall now, as among Jewes, with us, as among the Indians and Tartarians: but to punish the seducing Prophet is such; 1. because the Heretick is condemned by his owne conscience,1Tit. 3. 10. in believing lies Ergo, Farre more by his owne conscience, by leading others into that same condemnation with himselfe; and if he apprehend the vengeance of a God-head, there must be a conscience naturally apprehending such: as we see the conscience of murtherers, and of Cain, feare some revenging hand. If therefore the Minister of God, the Magistrate, inflict this, it must be nothing else but an act of naturall Justice, which the naturall conscience doth apprehend. But what acts of Justice the conscience naturally feares, must be acts of Justice perpetually morall, not respecting one man or Nation more than another. 2. All Countries by an instinct, apprehend a God,2 and conceive their Priests and Prophets are to be entertained and rewarded, as Egypt, Gen. 47. 22. Midian, F•xed, 2. 16. Exod. 18. 1. Judg. 17. 5. c. 18. 4. 2 King. 15. 18. The Philistims, 1 Sam. 5. 5. c. 6. 2. Baal and the Zidonians had their Priests, 2 King. 10. 8, 19, Lycainia, Act 14. 13. And if their Rulers feed their Priests, the false Prophets and Priests that deceive them, and mis-lead them, they must punish: So the King of Babylon roasted in a fire two false Prophets, Jer. 29. 21, 22. And it is cleare, that Jeremiah argues not from any judiciall Law, when he saith, The Prophets that speake lies in the name of the Lord, shall die by the sword, c. 14. v. 14, 15. It was by the sword of the Chaldeans, (who had nothing but the Law of nature) that they perished; for no Judiciall Law of God taught them, that he ought to die by the sword of the Magistrate, who speaks lies in the name of the Lord; whereas the Chaldeans knowing that Jeremiah had prophecied truth, and was sent of God, they intreated him well, as the Lord had fore-told,
1False Teachers in seducing others, apprehend th•• hand of divine vengeance pursuing them; as other ill doers do; and so it must be natural Justice in the Magistrate to punish them.False Teachers in seducing others, apprehend th•• hand of divine vengeance pursuing them; as other ill doers do; and so it must be naturall Iustice in the Magistrate to punish them.
2The punishing of false Prophets, is of the Law of nature.
for they persecuted the true Prophets and Apostles that spake in the name of the Lord; as Herod beheaded James, Acts 12. and apprehended Peter. Nero persecuted Paul, and ⟨p. 313⟩Domitian confined John to the Isle Patmos for the Word of God. To which I answer, That the Argument is not drawn simply from the practice of Heathen Magistrates, but from the light of nature, that teacheth all Magistrates, Heathen and Christian, to punish public impostors, false Prophets and liars, as most pernicious enemies to the peace of all humane Societies. And if the Law of nature and Nations dictate to all Societies, That deceivers, and such as raise false reports and lies upon earthly Judges, should be punished; far more is it a principle of the Law of nature, that public liars, and such as speak lies in the name of the Lord, and deceive and seduce the souls of father and mother, King and Ruler, and of all ranks of men in the Society, should not be tolerated in the society. And what though Emperors and Kings have abused the power that God gave them for the truth, to persecute the servants of Christ for the truth, it follows not, but they had just power, as the Ministers of God, to punish seducing Prophets, as well as other ill-doers, by the law of nature and Nations. And this I take is holden forth by Job, 131, 26, 27, 28. who being under no Judicial Law, obliging the Jews, but a Gentile, and so in this led by the Law of nature and Nations, maketh Idolatry and worshipping of the Sun and Moon,2 to be an iniquity to be punished by the Judge. That this is not an iniquity to be punished by God (as if heresy be innocency, as Libertines say, it must neither be punished by God nor man) but by the Judge on earth is clear. For 1. the expression, v. 28. varies only in the number from that which is v. 11. Now there Job saith of Adultery [Greek or Hebrew] & ipsum iniquitas Judicum. 3And ver. 98 [Greek or Hebrew] etiam hoc iniquitas Judie is. The English Divines do well observe,4 That adultery is a capital crime to be punished by the Judge, Gen. 38. 24. Levit. 20. 10. Deut. 22. 22. And they expound ver.5 28. the same way. Pagnin. est iniquites Judicanda, Judice di•na, vel Juditiaria. Mercerus, Exod. 21. 22, He shall give [Greek or Hebrew] according to the Judges, 6Isai. 16. 3. do, ⟨p. 314⟩Judgement. Shimlerus, [Greek or Hebrew] Judges that cognos•• of causes. Deut. 31. 31.
for they persecuted the true Prophets and Apostles that spake in the name of the Lord; as Herod beheaded Iames, Acts 12. and apprehended Peter. Nero persecuted Paul, and ⟨p. 313⟩D•mitian confined Iohn to the Isle Pathutos for the Word of God. To which I answer, That the Argument is not drawn simply from the practice of Heathen Magistrates, but from the light of nature, that teacheth all Magistrates, Heathen and Christian, to punish publike impostors, false Prophets and liers, as most pernitious enemies to the peace of all humane Societies. And if the Law of nature and Nations dictate to all Societies, That deceivers, and such as raise false reports and lies upon earthly Judges, should be punished; far more is it a principle of the Law of nature, that publike lyers, and such as speake lies in the name of the Lord, and deceive and seduce the soules of father and mother, King and Ruler, and of all ranks of men in the Society, should not be tollerated in the society. And what though Emperours and Kings have abused the power that God gave them for the truth, to persecute the servants of Christ for the truth, it followes not, but they had just power, as the Ministers of God, to punish seducing Prophets, as well as other ill-doers, by the law of nature and Nations. And this I take is holden forth by Iob, 131, 26, 27, 28. who being under no Judiciall Law, obliging the Jewes, but a Gentile, and so in this led by the Law of nature and Nations, maketh Idolatry and worshipping of the Sunne and Moone,2 to be an iniquity to be punished by the Iudge. That this is not an iniquity to be punished by God (as if heresie be innocency, as Libertines say, it must neither be punished by God nor man) but by the Judge on earth is cleare. For 1. the expression, v. 28. varies onely in the number from that which is v. 11. Now there Iob saith of Adultery 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 & ipsum iniquitas Iudicum. 3And ver. 98 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 etiam hoc iniquitas Iudie is. The English Divines do well observe,4
1Idolatry is to be punished by the Judge, and that by the testimony of Job c. 31.
2Who was obliged to observe no Judicial law but only the law moral and the law of nature.Who was obliged to observe no Judicial law but only the law morall and the law of nature.
Our enemies being Judges, Job 31. 11. Inquitas dignaque Judicetur & puniatur. 1It is true, the LXX, expound it,2 [Greek or Hebrew]; and the Chaldee Paraphrase, [Greek or Hebrew], est enim iniquitas maxima. But it is taken for a crime that comes before an earthly Judge.3 So Hieronimus. And Exod. 21. 22. If a man strike a woman with child, and she live, he shall give according to the sentence of the Judges. 4Hieronimus quantum arbitri Judicaverint. The Chaldee Paraphrase, [Greek or Hebrew],5 & dabit per sent•ntiam Judicum.
Our enemies being Iudges, Job 31. 11. Inquitas dignaque Iudicetur & puniatur. 1It is true, the LXX, expound it,2〈non-Latin alphabet〉; and the Chalde Paraphrase, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, est enim iniquitas maxima. But it is taken for a crime that comes before an earthly Judge.3 So Hieronimus. And Exod. 21. 22. If a man strike a woman with childe, and she live, he shall give according to the sentence of the Iudges. 4Hieronimus quantum arbitri Iudicaverint. The Chalde Paraphrase, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉,5 & dabit per sent•ntiam Iudicum.
LXX. [Greek or Hebrew]. The Syriac, Dabit quantum decernent Judices. The Samaritan, Dabitque ex sententia Judicum. Vatablus,1Job 31. v. 11. Iniquitas capitali supplicio persequind•, v. 28. Nam & ea iniquitas capitali supplicio digna. Junius, Iniquitas à Judicibus animadvertenda. 2Piscator, Iniquitas Judiciaria. Complutentes, 3Iniquitas Judicanda. Pineda in Job 31. 28.4 Iniquitas digna Judicio, Judicumque sententiâ severissima & gravissimo supplicio. 5All agree to this, That Idolatry, according to Job, from the Law of nature, deserveth capital punishment to be inflicted by the Judge. And Pi•eda saith, this agreeth with the Law of God. Especially, Deut. 4.6 25. & 23. Sanctius gathereth from Job 31. 11. That Adulterers in Jobs time were, by the sentence of the Judge burnt. Now the same expression is, v. 28. spoken of Idolatry. Hence is Socrates condemned to die for his false Religion, as is supposed by the people. Maximus condemned the Priscillia•s, 7as Hieronimus observes for Heresy. Nor is it much to be valued, that Jer. Taylor saith, That Maximus was a Tyrant, and put to death Catholic Heretics. Without choice, it proves punishing of Heretics,8 as supposed of old to be warranted by law.9 Ursatus and Stacius procured at Court, Law to death against Priscillianists. And the Nicene Fathers, that Arrius should be banished. Nor doth Spalato cite Tertullian, Cyprian, Lactantius, Hi•rome, Severus, Sulpitius, Minutius, Hilary, Damascene, Chrysostom, Theophilact, 10Bernard, for any other purpose (whatever Taylor say on the contrary) but 1. To prove, that forcing of men to Religion, is not to the way of God, which also ⟨p. 315⟩I teach; for the preaching of the Word; not the using of the sword,11 is the means of conversion of sinners 2. That killing is not to be practised on all Heretics. 3. That the Law and the Sword, are not to go without convincing of the conscience by the Word of God. 4. That to deliver up godly men to persecuting Tyrants, because of some errors, hath more scandal to cause men stumble at truth, than to make truth victorious. 5. That neither Church nor State can judge heart-opinions, nor punish them, but only professed and taught opinions, that are both unnecessary and unsound. 6. That Pastors have not the Sword, to compel to Religion. 7. That Nations of another Religion are not gained to Christ by the Sword;
LXX. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. The Syriak, Dabit quantum decernent Iudices. The Samaritan, Dabitque ex sententia Iudicum. Vatablus,1Job 31. v. 11. Iniquitas capitali supplicio persequind•, v. 28. Nam & ea iniquitas capitali supplicio digna. Junius, Iniquitas à Iudicibus animadvertenda. 2Piscator, Iniquitas Iudiciaria. Complutentes, 3Iniquitas Judicanda. Pineda in Job 31. 28.4 Iniquitas digna Iudicio, Iudicumque sententiâ severissima & gravissimo supplicio. 5All agree to this, That Idolatry, according to Iob, from the Law of nature, deserveth canitall punishment to be inflicted by the Judge. And Pi•eda saith, this agreeth with the Law of God. Especially, Deut. 4.6 25. & 23. Sanctius gathereth from Job 31. 11. That Adulterers in Iobs time were, by the sentence of the Judge burnt. Now the same expression is, v. 28. spoken of Idolatry. Hence is Socrates condemned to die for his false Religion, as is supposed by the people. Maximus condemned the Priscillia•s, 7as Hieronimus observes for Heresie. Nor is it much to be valued, that Ier. Taylor saith, That Maximus was a Tyrant, and put to death Catholike Hereticks. Without choyce, it proves punishing of Hereticks,8 as supposed of old to be warranted by law.9
not can we make war against them, because they are Idolaters, and follow a false Religion; nor was Idolatry the ground of the war that Israel raised against the Ca•aanitos and other Nations.1 To all which I add the words of Jer. Taylor. The best and ablest Doctors in Christendom have been deceived actually in […] of Religion, in that all sorts of Christians dissent from the error• of Papias, Irenaeus, Lactantius, Justin Martyr, Cyprian, Firmilian, &c. Ergo, by Tailors sentence, we are not rest, much upon the Fathers, whether they be for or against liberty of conscience.
not can we make warre against them, because they are Idolators, and follow a false Religion; nor was Idolatry the ground of the warre that Israel raised against the Ca•aanitos and other Nations.1 To all which I adde the words of Ier. Taylor. The best and ablest Doctors in Christendome have been deceived actually in 〈…〉 of Religion, in that all sorts of Christians dissent from the error• of Papias, Irenaeus, Lactantius, Iustin Martyr, Cyprian, Firmilian, &c. Ergo, by Taylors sentence, we are not rest, much upon the Fathers, whether they be for or against liberty of conscience.
1Taylor liberty of prophesying sect. 13. p. 13.Taylor liberty of prophecying sect. 13. p. 13.
For course to be taken with Pagans (to speak by the way) all that Lactantius, l. 5. c. 20. Tertulli ad Scap•lam, c. 2. Augustine, ser. 6. de verb. dom. c. 7. cont. lite▪ Petitian▪ lib. 2. c. 83. we approve, and what famous Schoolmen, […], Thomas, Bannes, Durandus, Palud••• Richardus, […], Paluda, and that of Augustine▪ s••. 6. de verb Dom. c. 7. Glandiendum est Paganu, ut audiant veritatem, in Christianis vero secanda putredo. Pagans must be allured, and not compelled by Wars to the faith. Because the just cause of War must either be an open breach of Nations against the Law of nature; for it must be a sin, of which a multitude may easily be, or are convinced of; as is clear in the Amalekites, and all the Nations who invaded Israel, Josh. 11. v. 19, 20. or then in a visible Church, it must be for manifest Apostasy from the Covenant of God, and […] Religion, as the new Altar supposed to be erected by the two Trib•• and ⟨p. 316⟩the half against the only one Altar commanded by God See Cavarruvias in Regnum paccatum part 2. sect. 4. Setus in 4. distin. 5. 4. 1. art. 10. Molina de Justitia disp. 106, and Bann•s 11. g. 10. art. 11. saith, that Paul the third defined well, that the Western Indians being capable of life eternal, were true Lords of their possessions, and could not be justly deprived thereof.
For course to be taken with Pagans (to speake by the way) all that Lactantius, l. 5. c. 20. Tertulli ad Scap•lam, c. 2. Augustine, ser. 6. de verb. dom. c. 7. cont. lite▪ Petitian▪ lib. 2. c. 83. we approve, and what famous Schoolmen, 〈…〉, Thomas, Bannes, Durandus, Palud••• Richardus, 〈…〉, Paluda, and that of Augustine▪ s••. 6. de verb Dom. c. 7. Glandiendum est Paganu, ut audiant veritatem, in Christianis vero secanda putredo. Pagans must be allured, and not compelled by Warres to the faith. Because the just cause of Warre must either be an open breach of Nations against the Law of nature; for it must be a finne, of which a multitude may easily be, or are convinced of; as is cleare in the A••lekites, and all the Nations who invaded Israel, Josh. 11. v. 19, 20. or then in a visible Church, it must be for manifest Apostacy from the Covenant of God, and 〈…〉 Religion, as the new Altar supposed to be erected by the two Trib•• and ⟨p. 316⟩the halfe against the only one Altar commanded by God See Cavarruvias in Regnum paccatum part 2. sect. 4. Setus in 4. distin. 5. 4. 1. art. 10. Molina de Justitia disp. 106, and Bann•s 11. g. 10. art. 11. saith, that Paul the third defined well, that the Westerne Indians being capable of life eternall, were true Lords of their possessions, and could not be justly deprived thereof.
To tolerate Jews openly blaspheming Christ, or to receive them in the Common-Wealth, cannot be allowed, or to suffer them to have Synagogues, In regard they blaspheme the God we are in Covenant with, and do no less deny him, then Goliath and Sennacherib did, 2. But simply seduced Jews are to be instructed, for there is a peculiar prophecy touching the Jews, Rom. 11. Jer. 50. 5, 6. That they shall be brought in to know Christ, and believe in him.
To tollerate Jewes openly blaspheming Christ, or to receive them in the Common-Wealth, cannot be allowed, or to suffer them to have Synagogues, In regard they blaspheme the God we are in Covenant with, and doe no lesse deny him, then Goliah and Senacharib did, 2. But simply seduced Jewes are to bee instructed, for there is a peculiar prophecy touching the Jewes, Rom. 11. Jer. 50. 5, 6. That they shall bee brought in to know Christ, and beleeve in him.
3 Argument, That which was a mere judicial law, and not only in no force now, as touching any obligation to bodily punishment from the Christian Magistrate, is now under the Gospel, either a sin offensive to humane society Or, 2. No sin, but innocency, as some say, Or then 5. • thing lndifferent. If it be a sin offensive to humane society, and the people of God, to drive them away from the Lord their God, and an abomination that Israel should fear to do, in the days of Moses and before Christ came, as is clear, Deut. 13. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. It must be so now: for since it is not a Typical, but a moral sin, it is at all times, and in all places to us, and now, and to them, and then, an abomination.1 Ergo the Argument of the holy Ghost being perpetual, that it is destructive to humane society, the Lord must provide the same, or as effectual means, for the remedying thereof. But if the Christian Magistrate have no place or power to repress such abominations, but Israel may seduce men after false gods, and not fear the stroke of […] sword, then hath the Lord left the Church to the lust of ravenous Wolves that destroy the flock, and hath left these wolves to the Lords immediate hand of judgement: for rebukes, Church-censures are not to be used against them, upon the same ground that the sword should not be drawn against them, by the ground of Libertines: ⟨p. 317⟩for rebukes and Church-censures do. 1. Force the conscience no less than the sword. 2. They beget Hypocrites. 3. Are as contrary to the law of meekness and gentleness of Christ and his servants, who used no such way to gain the Samaritans, and other gain-sayers, as the sword is repugnant to Christs meek administration, who did not use either sword, crying, rebukes, or excommunication, against broken reeds, though both these may be used against Seducers in great gentleness and tenderness toward their souls, by fathers in State or Church. 4. They are no less against liberty of prophesying, believing with a reserve to believe the contrary, than the sword.
3 Argument, That which was a meere judiciall law, and not onely in no force now, as touching any obligation to bodily punishment from the Christian Magistrate, is now under the Gospell, either a sin offensive to humane society Or, 2. No sin, but innocency, as some say, Or then 5. • thing lndifferent. If it be a sin offensive to humane society, and the people of God, to drive them away from the Lord their God, and an abomination that Israel should feare to doe, in the dayes of Moses and before Christ came, as is cleare, Deut. 13. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. It must be so now: for since it is not a Typicall, but a morall sin, it is at all times, and in all places to us, and now, and to them, and then, an abomination.1 Ergo the Argument of the holy Ghost being perpet•all, that it is destructive to humane society, the Lord must provide the same, or as effectuall means, for the remedying thereof. But if the Christian Magistrate have no place or power to represse such abominations, but Isreal may seduce men after false gods, and not feare the stroke of 〈…〉 sword, then hath the Lord left the Church to the lust of •avenous Wolves that destroy the flocke, and hath left these wolves to the Lords immediate hand of judgement: for rebukes, Church-censures are not to be used against them, upon the same ground that the sword should not be drawne against them, by the ground of Libertines: ⟨p. 317⟩for rebukes and Church-censures doe. 1. Force the conscience no lesse than the sword. 2. They beget Hypocrites. 3. Are as contrary to the law of meeknesse and gentlenesse of Christ and his servants, who used no such way to gaine the Samaritans, and other gaine-sayers, as the sword is repugnant to Christs meek administration, who did not use either sword, crying, rebukes, or excommunication, against broken reeds, though both these may be used against Seducers in great gentlenesse and tendernesse toward their soules, by fathers in State or Church. 4. They are no lesse against liberty of prophecying, beleiving with a reserve to beleeve the contrary, than the sword.
1Church cens•res and rebukes for conscience inferi•• most of all the absurdities that Libertines imp to us.Church cens•res and rebukes for conscience inferi•• most of all the absurdities that Libertines imp•e to us.
For how can we in the name of the Lord, rebuke, threaten eternal wrath, deliver to, Satan, seducers, more than the Magistrate can use the sword against them, yea, or refute their errors, in the name and authority of Christ, or strike with his rod, since we are not infallibly persuaded more than these we call Seducers, for they may upon the same grounds call us Seducers, threaten us with eternal wrath, and deliver us to Satan, in the same name and authority that the sound Church proceedeth against them; for neither side had the infallibility of divine authority, in a reflex knowledge, more than others, by the Doctrine of Libertines. 5. They are no less contrary to growing up in knowledge and new light; for contrary reasons, and rebukes, and threatenings are as apt to expel new light, and to reduce the Seducer to old darkness, for any certainty of persuasion any of the sides have, for both may see beside their book, and dream the moon is made of wax, by this way, and instructing of teachers that see but on this, and the yonder side of truth with e••s of flesh, as they say, is as uneffectuall a remedy against Teachers, as the sword. 6. Since the sword and stoning, when used by the Jews, Deut. 13. presupposeth infallibility. What warrant do our Lords of licence of conscience give us, that all the Commons, and Lads, and Girls that lifted a stone against the Seducer, had Prophetical, infallibility: or that every wife, to whom her husband might say, Let us go and follow Baal and Dagon, for sure the Zid•nians and Philistines are a people taught of God as well as we, was infallible in ⟨p. 318⟩her knowledge and unerrable, and the husband an erring Seducer according to the principles that masters of licence would lead us on: for there must be a response given to all and every one to believe this is the Seducer, from the light of Moses law, else they had no more right to stone the Seducer, then the Seducer to stone them. For as we may err in persecuting true Prophets, I hope so did the people kill the Prophets, 1and stone them that were sent, Matth. 23. 27 and 2 Chron.2 36. 16. they mocked and misused the Prophets of God, and did as foully err in persecuting, as now we under the Gospel. Yet Mr. Goodwin gives to the Jews an infallibility of an Oracle to tell them who was the man to be stoned, as a Seducer. But let him answer these Queries.
For how can we in the name of the Lord, rebuke, threaten eterned wrath, deliveto, Sathan, seducers, more than the Magistrate can use the sword against them, yea, or refute their errors, in the name and authority of Christ, or strike with his rod, since wee are not infallibly perswaded more than these we call Seducers, for they may upon the same grounds call us Seducers, threaten us with eternall wrath, and deliver us to Sathan, in the same name and authority that the sound Church proceedeth against them; for neither side had the infallibility of divine authority, in a reflex knowledge, more than others, by the Doctrine of Libertines. 5. They are no lesse contrary to growing up in knowledge and new light; for contrary reasons, and rebukes, and threatnings are as apt to expell new light, and to reduce the Seducer to old darknesse, for any certainty of perswasion any of the sides have, for both may see beside their book, and dreame the moone is made of wax, by this way, and instructing of teachers that see but on this, and the yonder side of truth with e••s of flesh, as they say, is as uneffectuall a remedy against Teachers, as the sword. 6. Since the sword and stoning, when used by the Jewes, Deut. 13. presupposeth infallibility. What warrant doe our Lords of licence of conscience give us, that all the Commons, and Lads, and Girles that lifted a stone against the Seducer, had Proph•ticall, infallibility: or that every wife, to whom her husband might say, Let us go and follow Baal and Dagon, for sure the Zid•nians and Philistines are a people taught of God as well as we, was infallible in ⟨p. 318⟩her knowledge and unerrable, and the husband an erring Seducer according to the principles that masters of licence would lead us on: for there must be a response given to all and every one to beleeve this is the Seducer, from the light of Moses law, else they had no more right to stone the Seducer, then the Seducer to stone them. For as wee may erre in persecuting true Prophets, I hope so did the people kill the Prophets, 1and stone them that were sent, Matth. 23. 27 and 2 Chron.2 36. 16
1 Did the Oracle speak immediately to all the actors in the stoning?1 I think no: then the Oracle spake to the Priest only. To Pashur; then the Officers had but the word of Peshur to put Jeremiah in the stocks, and the people had but the Priests word for stoning the man.
1 Did the Oracle speak immediately to all the actors in the stoning?1 I thinke no: then the Oracle spake to the Priest only. To Pashur; then the Officers had but the word of Peshur to put Jeremiah in the stockes, and the people had but the Priests word for stoning the man.
1That there was an immediate response of Gods oracle telling who was the false teacher, is an unwarranted forgery of Libertines.
2 Query, Were the people infallible in discerning the Priest to be a true relater of the mind of God from the Oracle? How believed they then some lying Priests who persecuted the Prophets of God?
2 Query, Were the people infallible in discerning the Priest to be a true relater of the mind of God from the Oracle? How beleeved they then some lying Priests who persecuted the Prophets of God?
3 Query, Was the Priest infallible in discerning the Oracle and relating the mind of God to the people? How then did they say, he is worthy to dye? How did Caiaphas say, What need we any more witness, We have heard himself blaspheme?
3 Query, Was the Priest infallible in discerning the Oracle and relating the mind of God to the people? How then did they say, he is worthy to dye? How did Caiaphas say, What need we any more witnesse, We have heard himself blaspheme?
) in which alone is the true service of God and the participation of his grace, and Covenant. So also the Geneva Notes approves the lawfullnesse of the Warre, and the Dutch annotations.
Josh. c. 22
. q. 10. Necessitas autem pugnandi contra duas tribus incumbebat. Lex
5Masius in Josh. in loc. Se•rar. in loc. Nicho. de lyra. Menochius anno•▪ in Josh. 22. v. 13. Ferns in Declama. in Josh. c. ••.Masius in Iosh. in loc. Se•rar. in loc. Nicho. de lyra. Menochius anno•▪ in Iosh. 22. v. 13. Fer•s in Declama. in Iosh. c. ••.
6Utinam talis zelus in nobis esset & quidem non unum altare erectum videmus sed innumera.
. Nor can it be said, that the consequence is null, and that that cannot oblige Christian Magistrates, which hath no better warrant than the corrupt practises of Heathens;
28. the same way. Pagnin. est iniquites Iudicanda, Iudice di•na, vel Iuditiaria. Mercerus, Exod. 21. 22, He shall give 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 according to the Iudges,
Iudgement. Shimlerus, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Judges that cognos•• of causes. Deut. 31. 31.
Ʋrsatus and Stacius procured at Court, Law to death against Priscillianists. And the Niceue Fathers, that Arrius should be banished. Nor doth Spalato cite Tertullian, Cyprian, Lactantius, Hi•rome, Severus, Sulpitius, Minutius, Hilary, Damascen, Chrysestome, Theophilact,
Bernard, for any other purpose (whatever Taylor say on the contrary) but 1. To prove, that forcing of men to Religion, is not to the way of God, which also
⟨p. 315⟩
I teach; for the preaching of the Word; not the using of the sword,
is the meanes of conversion of sinners 2. That killing is not to be practised on all Hereticks. 3. That the Law and the Sword, are not to go without convincing of the conscience by the Word of God. 4. That to deliver up godly men to persecuting Tyranes, because of some errors, hath more scandall to cause men stumble at truth, than to make truth victorious. 5. That neither Church nor State can judge heart-opinions, nor punish them, but only professed and taught opinions, that are both unnecessary and unsound. 6. That Pastors have not the Sword, to compell to Religion. 7. That Nations of another Religion are not gained to Christ by the Sword;
How the fathers deny the sword is to be used against men for their conscience.
How the fathers deny the sword is to bee used against men for their conscience.
. they mocked and misused the Prophets of God, and did as foully erre in persecuting, as now we under the Gospell. Yet Mr. Goodwin gives to the Jewes an infallibility of an Oracle to tell them who was the man to be stoned, as a Seducer. But let him answer these Queries.