A LETTER, &c.
pp. 1–84146 passagespart 4 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
You moreover mention the Judgment given in favour of Mr. B—, with Respect to his Orthodoxy, by some Ministers in Boston, of which the Rev. Mr. Cooper was one, before he was come as a Judge in this Case, as one Ground of your Result. Before this, you speak in Page 36, as tho' it were very strange that any should think that the Judgment then given should disqualify the Persons that gave it from sitting as Judges in this Case, representing as tho' that Judgment no Way concerned the present Case; but now it so much concerns the present Case, as justly to be made one Ground of a Judgment in the Case; which was the very Thing on the Account of which we objected against it, viz That Judges that have given their Judgment before, in an Affair that so nearly concern the Case, won't be likely to be impartial, but to be influenced by their former Judgment, and now it proves so in Fact by your own Confession; in so much that you publicly declare that that very Judgment was one Thing that you even founded your Judgment upon sitting in Council in this Case, and as such insert it in your very Result, and insist upon it afterwards as a very good Ground too.
You moreover mention the Judgment given in favour of Mr. B—, with Respect to his Orthodoxy, by some Ministers in Boston, of which the Rev. Mr. Cooper was one, before he was come as a Judge in this Case, as one Ground of your Result. Before this, you speak in Page 36, as tho' it were very strange that any should think that the Judgment then given should disqualify the Persons that gave it from sitting as Judges in this Case, representing as tho' that Judgment no Way concerned the present Case; but now it so much concerns the present Case, as justly to be made one Ground of a Judgment in the Case; which was the very Thing on the Account of which we objected against it, viz That Judges that have given their Judgment before, in an Affair that so nearly concern the Case, won't be likely to be impartial, but to be influenced by their former Judgment, and now it proves so in Fact by your own Confession; in so much that you publickly declare that that very Judgment was one Thing that you even founded your Judgment upon sitting in Council in this Case, and as such insert it in your very Result, and insist upon it afterwards as a very good Ground too.
But then as a further & a more abundantly satisfactory Ground of your Proceedings, you produce his Confession of Faith, and then when you have done, cry out of us, It is very strange those disapproving Gentlemen should say in their Defence, that the Council declare in their Result, there was nothing in the Way of his Ordination, without his ever openly making any Recantation, or any Reflection on himself, for the Errors he had vented. How he should make open Reflections on himself for Errors he has vented, without ever openly owning that he had ever held any Errors, is what we can't understand; this he never did at Springfield, nor in his Letter to Mr. Clap, nor any other Way that ever appeared: He indeed says, in his Letter to Mr. Clap, that tho' he had preached Errors, yet says at the same Time he did not believe them; and yet makes no Reflections on himself,