pp. 270–28493 passagespart 1 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WHEREAS divers and uncertain rumours be spread abroad of the disputation had in the convocation house; to the intent that all men may know the certainty of all things therein done and said, as much as the memory of him that was present thereat can bear away, he hath thought good, at request, thoroughly to describe what was said therein on both parties of the matters argued and had in question, and of the entrance thereof.
ON Wednesday, October 18, in the afternoon, the prolocutor, Dr. Weston, certified the house, it was the queen's pleasure, that the learned men there assembled should debate matters of religion, and for that end constitute laws, which her grace and the parliament would ratify. And because (said he) there was a book lately published, called the Catechism (which he produced) bearing the name of this honourable synod, and yet put forth without your consents, as I have learned, being a book very pestiferous, and full of heresies; and likewise an abominable book of Common Prayer; I thought it best, therefore, first to begin with the articles of the Catechism, concerning the sacrament of the altar, for confirming the natural presence of Christ in the same, and also transubstantiation: wherefore, it shall be lawful, on Friday next ensuing, for all men freely to speak their consciences in these m••ters, that all doubts may be removed, and they fully justified therein.
ON the 20th of October, being Friday, when it was expected they should have entered into disputation of the questions proposed, the prolocutor exhibiting two bills to the house, the one for the natural presence of Christ in the sacrament of the altar, and the other concerning the catechism, that it was not published by the consent of that house, and that they did not agree thereunto, requiring all them to subscribe to the same as he himself had done. Whereunto the whole house accordingly assented, except six, viz. the dean of Rochester, the dean of Exeter, the archdeacon of Winchester, archdeacon of Hereford, archdeacon of Stow, and one more. And whilst the rest were about subscribing to these two articles, John Philpot stood up and spoke first concerning the articles of the catechism, that he thought they were deceived in the title of the catechism, for that it bore the title of the synod before this, although as to publishing thereof several of them then present were not made privy thereunto; and that because this house had granted authority to certain persons appointed by the king's majesty to make ecclesiastical laws; and whatsoever ecclesiastical laws were thereupon published by the authority of them, or the major part of them, according to a statute in that behalf made and provided, it might well be said to be done by the consent of the synod of London, notwithstanding such as were members of this house now had no notice thereof before its promulgation. And therefore in this point he thought the publisher thereof had not in the least slandered the house, as they by their subscriptions were endeavouring to persuade the world, since they had one synodal authority for empowering them to make such spiritual laws, as they thought convenient and necessary.
ON the 20th of October, being Friday, when it was expected they should have entered into disputation of the questions proposed, the prolocutor exhibiting two bills to the house, the one for the natural presence of Christ in the sacrament of the altar, and the other concerning the catechism, that it was not published by the consent of that house, and that they did not agree thereunto, requiring all them to subscribe to the same as he himself had done. Whereunto the whole house accordingly assented, except six, viz. the dean of Rochester, the dean of Exeter, the archdeacon of Winchester, archdeacon of Hereford, archdeacon of Stow, and one more. And whilst the rest were about subscribing to these two articles, John Philpot stood up and spoke first concerning the articles of the catechism, that he thought they were deceived in the title of the catechism, for that it bore the title of the synod before this, although as to publishing thereof several of them then present were not made privy thereunto; and that because this house had granted authority to certain persons appointed by the king's majesty to make ecclesiastical laws; and whatsoever ecclesiastical laws were thereupon published by the authority of them, or the major part of them, according to a statute in that behalf made and provided, it might well be said to be done by the consent of the synod of London, notwithstanding such as were members of this house now had no notice thereof before its promulgation. And therefore in this point he thought the publisher thereof had not in the least slandered the house, as they by their subscriptions were endeavouring to persuade the world, since they had one synodal authority for impowering them to make such spiritual laws, as they thought convenient and necessary.
AND moreover he said, that as to the article of the natural presence in the sacrament, it was both contrary to teason and learning, and very prejudicial to truth, for men to be moved to subscribe before the matter was thoroughly examined and discussed. But when he saw his allegations were to no purpose, being like a man astonished at so many ancient and learned men being purposely assembled to maintain old traditions, preferable to the truth of God's holy word, he made it his request to the prolocutor, that whereas on that side there were present so many learned men, as the like were not to be found again in the whole realm, and that on the other side, of those that had not subscribed there were not above five or six, and they far inferior to them both in age and learning: in order, therefore, that there might be an equality of persons concerned in this disputation, he desired that the prolocutor would intercede with the lords, that some of those men that were learned, and occasioned the publishing of the catechism aforesaid, might be admitted into the house to show their learning that moved them to set forth the same, and that Dr. Ridley and Mr Rogers, with two or three more, might have the liberty of being present at this disputation, and associating with them
AND moreover he said, that as to the article of the natural presence in the sacrament, it was both contrary to teason and learning, and very prejudicial to truth, for men to be moved to subscribe before the matter was thoroughly examined and discussed. But when he saw his allegations were to no purpose, being like a man astonished at so many ancient and learned men being purposely assembled to maintain old traditions, preferable to the truth of God's holy word, he made it his request to the prolocutor, that whereas on that side there were present so many learned men, as the like were not to be found again in the whole realm, and that on the other side, of those that had not subscribed there were not above five or six, and they far inferior to them both in age and learning: in order, therefore, that there might be an equality of persons concerned in this disputation, he desired that the prolocutor would intercede with the lords, that some of those men that were learned, and occasioned the publishing of the catechism aforesaid, might be admitted into the house to shew their learning that moved them to set forth the same, and that Dr. Ridley and Mr Rogers, with two or three more, might have the liberty of being present at this disputation, and associating with them
THIS request was thought reasonable, and was therefore proposed to the bishops, who returned this answer; That it was out of their power to call such persons to the house, since some of them were prisoners; but they said, they would petition the council in this behalf, and in case any of them were absent that ought to be of the house, they were for their being admitted as they desired. After this, they minding to have entered into disputation, there came a gentleman with a message from the lord great master, signifying unto the prolocutor, that the lord great master and the […] of Devonshire would be present at the disputat•••s, and therefore he deferred the same till Monday, at one o'clock in the afternoon.
THIS request was thought reasonable, and was therefore proposed to the bishops, who returned this answer; That it was out of their power to call such persons to the house, since some of them were prisoners; but they said, they would petition the council in this behalf, and in case any of them were absent that ought to be of the house, they were for their being admitted as they desired. After this, they minding to have entered into disputation, there came a gentleman with a message from the lord great master, signifying unto the prolocutor, that the lord great master and the 〈…〉 of Devonshire would be present at the disputat•••s, and therefore he deferred the same till Monday, at one o'clock in the afternoon.
AT the time appointed, being Monday, October 23d, in the presence of many earls, lords, knights, and several gentlemen, both of the court and city, the prolocutor made a protestation, that the members of that house had appointed this public disputation, not to call the truth in question, to which they had already subscribed, except five or six, but that gainsayers, and heretics, might be resolved respecting their doubts, by their arguments, which they supposed would be sufficiently convincing to bring them over to their opinion.
THE prolocutor then demanded of Mr. Hadden, whether he would reason against the questions that had been proposed; and Mr. Hadden replied, he would not, because they could not have such learned co-adjutors as they desired. To which Mr. Elmar added, that they had done too much prejudice already to the truth, by their subscribing before the subjects to be debated were discussed, nor would it avail much to reason in defence of the true religion, against which they were now fully determined. Mr. Weston then, turning to Mr. Cheyney, desired to know, whether he (who believed with them the real presence) would propose his doubts concerning transubstantiation Mr. Cheyney answered, "I should be glad my doubts were resolved, that move me to disbelieve transubstantiation.
"The first of these arose from what St. Paul writes to the Corinthians, who, speaking of the body and blood of Christ, calls it bread after consecration.
"The first of these arose from what St. Paul writes to the Corinthians, who, speaking of the body and blood of Christ, calls it bread after consecretion.
"THE second from a passage out of Origen, who, speaking of this sacrament, saith, that the material part thereof goeth down to the excrements.
"THE third is out of Theodoret, who, speaking of the sacramental elements, after consecration, affirmeth, that they go not out of their former substance, form, and shape. These, among several others, are the doubts I require to be resolved."
THEN the prolocutor having appointed Dr. Moreman to answer, he began with observing, that the sacrament is called by St. Paul bread indeed, by which he meant the form of bread; but Mr. Cheyney alleged, that Hesychius called the sacrament both bread and flesh.
THEN the prolocutor having appointed Dr. Moreman to answer, he began with observing, that the sacrament is called by St. Paul bread indeed, by which he meant the form of bread; but Mr. Cheyney alledged, that Hesychius called the sacrament both bread and flesh.
YES, replied Moreman, Hesychius calleth it bread, because it was bread, not because it is so. Then, passing over Origen, he said, that men, mistook the authority of Theodoret, by interpreting a general into a special, as Peter Martyr had done, taking a Greek word, that signifies substance in its special signification, whereas, in the general, it may be applied to accidents, as well as substance; and therefore (said he) I answer Theodoret thus, that sacramental bread and wine do not go out of their former substance, form, and shape, that is, not out of their accidental substance and shape.
AFTER this, Mr. Cheyney sat down, and Mr. Elmar, who could not endure to hear so weak and childish an answer to so grave an authority, arose, declaring, that Moreman's answer to Theodoret was only an illusion, or mere subtle evasion, contrary to Theodoret'e meaning; for if the Greek word, that signifies substance, should, in the passage quoted, be taken for accident, then it was a superfluous word, especially, where there are two other Greek words, which sufficiently expound the accidents of the bread; and he proved out of the same author, by divers allegations, that the Greek word that signified substance in Theodoret, could not be so generally taken in that place; but Moreman still affirmed, that the Greek word that signified substance, must needs signify accidental substance properly. To whose obstinacy, since he could obtain no better proof, Elmar gave place.
AFTER this, Mr. Cheyney sat down, and Mr. Elmar, who could not endure to hear so weak and childish an answer to so grave an authority, arose, declaring, that Moreman's answer to Theodoret was only an illusion, or mere subtile evasion, contrary to Theodoret'e meaning; for if the Greek word, that signifies substance, should, in the passage quoted, be taken for accident, then it was a superfluous word, especially, where there are two other Greek words, which sufficiently expound the accidents of the bread; and he proved out of the same author, by divers allegations, that the Greek word that signified substance in Theodoret, could not be so generally taken in that place; but Moreman still affirmed, that the Greek word that signified substance, must needs signify accidental substance properly. To whose obstinacy, since he could obtain no better proof, Elmar gave place.
UPON which, Mr. John Philpot stood up, and said, he could make it appear, from the whole subject matter, in the place alleging, and from the similitude Theodoret uses, for proving his purpose, that Moreman's explanation of the Greek word for substance, could by no means be taken in the sense he would interpret it: for, he observed, Theodoret was in that place urging against the heretic Eutiches, who denied two natures of substance to remain in Christ as one person, and that his humanity, after the accomplishment of the mystery of our salvation, ascending into heaven, and being joined to the divinity, was absorbed thereby; so that, according to his opinion, Christ was no more but of one divine substance only: against which opinion Theodoret writeth, and by the similitude, of the sacrament proveth the contrary against that heretic: for like as in the sacrament of the body of Christ, after the consecration, there is the substance of Christ's humanity, with the substance of the bread remaining as before, not being absorbed by the humanity of Christ, but by divine operation joined thereunto, even so, in the person of Christ, being now in heaven, of whom this sacrament is a representation, there being two several substances, his humanity and divinity, united in one hypostacy or person, which is Christ: the humanity not being absorbed by the conjunction of the divinity, but remaining in its former substance: and Theodoret's similitude, continued Mr. Philpot, would prove nothing, if the substance of the sacramental bread remained not as it did before. The heretic therefore, according to Dr. Moreman's interpretation, would have a strong argument to support his error; and to prove himself an orthodox christian, might say to Theodoret thus: Like as thou Theodoret, if thou wert of Dr. Moreman's mind, dost say that, after the consecration in the sacrament, the substance of the bread is changed into the human body of Christ, coming thereunto, so that in the sacrament there is but one substance of the humanity alone, and not the substance of bread as it was before; even so, likewise, may I affirm and conclude from thine own similitude, that the humanity ascending up by the power of God into heaven, and adjoined to deity, was absorbed, and turned into one substance with the deity;
UPON which, Mr. John Philpot stood up, and said, he could make it appear, from the whole subject matter, in the place alledging, and from the similitude Theodoret uses, for proving his purpose, that Moreman's explanation of the Greek word for substance, could by no means be taken in the sense he would interpret it: for, he observed, Theodoret was in that place urging against the heretic Eutiches, who denied two natures of substance to remain in Christ as one person, and that his humanity, after the accomplishment of the mystery of our salvation, ascending into heaven, and being joined to the divinity, was absorbed thereby; so that, according to his opinion, Christ was no more but of one divine substance only: against which opinion Theodoret writeth, and by the similitude, of the sacrament proveth the contrary against that heretic: for like as in the sacrament of the body of Christ, after the consecration, there is the substance of Christ's humanity, with the substance of the bread remaining as before, not being absorbed by the humanity of Christ, but by divine operation joined thereuto, even so, in the person of Christ, being now in heaven, of whom this sacrament is a representation, there being two several substances, his humanity and divinity, united in one hypostacy or person, which is Christ: the humanity not being absorbed by the conjunction of the divinity, but remaining in its former substance: and Theodoret's similitude, continued Mr. Philpot, would prove nothing, if the substance of the sacramental bread remained not as it did before. The heretic therefore, according to Dr. Moreman's interpretation, would have a strong argument to support his error; and to prove himself an orthodox christian, might say to Theodoret thus: Like as thou Theodoret, if thou wert of Dr. Moreman's mind, dost say that, after the consecration in the sacrament, the substance of the bread is changed into the human body of Christ, coming thereunto, so that in the sacrament there is but one substance of the humanity alone, and not the substance of bread as it was before; even so, likewise, may I affirm and conclude from thine own similitude, that the humanity ascending up by the power of God into heaven, and adjoined to deity, was absorbed, and turned into one substance with the deity;
so that there remaineth but one divine substance in Christ, no more than in the sacramental signs of the Lord's supper, after the consecration, doth remain any more than one substance, according to your belief and construction. In attempting to answer this, Dr. Moreman was so closely pressed, that he began to stagger; which Philpot perceiving, spake in this manner, "Well, master Moreman, if you have no answer ready at present, consider of one, if you can conveniently, against our next meeting."
AT these words the prolocutor was exceedingly offended and troubled, telling him, that he should not brag there, but be fully answered. To which Philpot returned, "It is the only thing I desire, to be answered directly on this point of dispute▪ and I request of you, and of all the house here present, ⟨p. 273⟩that I may be sufficiently answered, which I am sure you cannot do, taking Theodoret's authority, and similitude, as they ought to be taken." Whereupon, without any further reply, or answer to his reasoning, Philpot was commanded to be silent.
AFTER he had sat down, the dean of Rochester arose, offering to dispute against the real presence, wishing that the scriptures, and the ancient doctors, might be weighed, believed, and followed, in this point, And he thought a sufficient argument against it, was that saying of Christ, in St. Matthew, where he says, that the poor we should have always with us, but him we should not have always, which the dean said, was spoken concerning the natural presence of Christ's body, and therefore Christ cannot be naturally present on earth in the sacrament of the altar. To this the prolocutor answered, that we should not have Christ present always to exercise alms deeds, but upon the poor.
THE dean then prosecuted his argument, and quoted St. Austin to prove, that the same interpretation of the scripture alleged by Mr. Weston was no sufficient answer; for St. Austin, in the 50th treatise on St. John, speaketh thus on the same sentence; "When Christ said, Me ye shall not have always with you he spake of the presence of his body. For by his majesty, by his providence, by his unspeakable and invisible grace, that is fulfilled which is said of him, Behold I am with you until the consummation of the world. But in the flesh which the word took upon him, in that which was born of the virgin, in that which was apprehended by the Jews, which was crucified on the cross▪ which was let down from the cross, which was wrapped in cloths, which was hid in the sepulchre, which was manifested in the resurrection, you shall not have me always with you. And why? For after a bodily presence he was conversant with his disciples forty days, and they accompanying him, seeing and not allowing him, he ascended and is not here; for there he sitteth at the right hand of the Father; and yet here he is because he is not departed in the presence of his majesty After another manner we have Christ always by the presence of his majesty; but after the presence of his flesh it is rightly said, you shall not verily […] me always with you. For the church had him in the presence of his flesh a few days, and now by faith it apprehendeth him, and seeth him not with eyes."
THE dean then prosecuted his argument, and quoted St. Austin to prove, that the same interpretation of the scripture alledged by Mr. Weston was no sufficient answer; for St. Austin, in the 50th treatise on St. John, speaketh thus on the same sentence; "When Christ said, Me ye shall not have always with you he spake of the presence of his body. For by his majesty, by his providence, by his unspeakable and invisible grace, that is fulfilled which is said of him, Behold I am with you until the consummation of the world. But in the flesh which the word took upon him, in that which was born of the virgin, in that which was apprehended by the Jews, which was crucified on the cross▪ which was let down from the cross, which was wrapped in cloths, which was hid in the sepulchre, which was manifested in the resurrection, you shall not have me always with you. And why? For after a bodily presence he was conversant with his disciples forty days, and they accompanying him, seeing and not allowing him, he ascended and is not here; for there he sitteth at the right hand of the Father; and yet here he is because he is not departed in the presence of his majesty After anoher manner we have Christ always by the presence of his majesty; but after the presence of his flesh it is rightly said, you shall not verily me always with you. For the church had him in the presence of his flesh a few days, and now by faith it apprehendeth him, and seeth him not with eyes."
TO this authority Dr. Watson answered, and said, he would answer St. Augustine by St. Augustine, and having a certain book in his hand of notes, he alleged out of the 70th treatise of St. John, that after that mortal condition and manner we have not now Christ on earth, as he was heretofore before his passion.
TO this authority Dr. Watson answered, and said, he would answer St. Augustine by St. Augustine, and having a certain book in his hand of notes, he alledged out of the 70th treatise of St. John, that after that mortal condition and manner we have not now Christ on earth, as he was heretofore before his passion.
Mr. Philpot replied, saying, that Mr. Watson had not fully answered St. Augustine by St Augustine, for that in the place mentioned by the dean of Rochester, he doth not only treat of the mortal state of Christ's body before his passion, but also the immortal condition of the same after his resurrection: in which mortal body St. Augustine seemeth plainly to affirm, that Christ is not present upon the earth, neither in form visibly, neither in corporal substance invisibly, as in a few lines after the place above alleged, St. Augustine doth more plainly declare by these words, "Now these two manners of Christ's presence declared, which is by his majesty, providence, and grace, now present in the world, which before his ascension was present in the flesh; and which being now placed at the right hand of the Father, is absent from the world, I think there remains no further dispute about the matter.
Mr. Philpot replied, saying, that Mr. Watson had not fully answered St. Augustine by St Augustine, for that in the place mentioned by the dean of Rochester, he doth not only treat of the mortal state of Christ's body before his passion, but also the immortal condition of the same after his resurrection: in which mortal body St. Augustine seemeth plainly to affirm, that Christ is not present upon the earth, neither in form visibly, neither in corporal substance invisibly, as in a few lines after the place above alledged, St. Augustine doth more plainly declare by these words, "Now these two manners of Christ's presence declared, which is by his majesty, providence, and grace, now present in the world, which before his ascension was present in the flesh; and which being now placed at the right hand of the Father, is absent from the world, I think there remains no further dispute about the matter.
THEREFORE, if St. Augustine allowed no other presence of Christ here on earth, but only his divine presence, and that his humanity was in heaven, we ought to confess and believe the same. But if we put a third presence of Christ, that is corporally to be present always in the sacrament of the altar, invisibly, according to your suppositions, whereof St. Augustine maketh no mention in all his works, you seem to judge that which St. Augustine did never comprehend.
WHY, said Watson, does not St. Augustine, in the place I alleged, make mention how St. Stephen, being in this world, saw Christ after his ascension.
WHY, said Watson, does not St. Augustine, in the place I alledged, make mention how St. Stephen, being in this world, saw Christ after his ascension.
IT is true, said Philpot, but he saw Christ as ⟨p. 274⟩the scripture saith, in the heavens, being open, standing at the right hand of God the Father: at which Watson was silent.
THE dean proceeded to support his argument, and, to this end, read out of a book of annotations sundry authorities, to which Moreman, who was appointed to answer him, made no direct answer, but desired him to frame an argument, saying, the dean had recited many doctors' words, but had not made one argument. Thus challenged, the dean made the following argument from the institution of the sacrament; "Do this in remembrance of me; and thus ye shall show forth the Lord's death till he come."
THE dean proceeded to support his argument, and, to this end, read out of a book of annotations sundry authorities, to which Moreman, who was appointed to answer him, made no direct answer, but desired him to frame an argument, saying, the dean had recited many doctors' words, but had not made one argument. Thus challenged, the dean made the following argument from the institution of the sacrament; "Do this in remembrance of me; and thus ye shall shew forth the Lord's death till he come."
THE sacrament is the remembrance of Christ; therefore, the sacrament is not the very Christ; for as yet he is not come, for these words, "until he come," do plainly signify the absence of Christ's body. Then the prolocutor went about to show, that these words, "until he come," did not import any absence of Christ on the earth, by other places of scripture, where the word, "until," was made use of: but directly to the purpose he answered nothing. In fine, the dean questioned Moreman, whether Christ did eat the paschal lamb with his disciples, or not? He answered, Yes. He further demanded, whether upon instituting the sacrament, he did eat the sacrament with them? Moreman answered, Yes. Then he asked what he did eat, and whether he did eat his own natural body, as they imagined it to be, or not? Which when Moreman had affirmed, then, said the dean, it is a great absurdity by you granted; and so he sat down.
THE sacrament is the remembrance of Christ; therefore, the sacrament is not the very Christ; for as yet he is not come, for these words, "until he come," do plainly signify the absence of Christ's body. Then the prolocutor went about to shew, that these words, "until he come," did not import any absence of Christ on the earth, by other places of scripture, where the word, "until," was made use of: but directly to the purpose he answered nothing. In fine, the dean questioned Moreman, whether Christ did eat the pascal lamb with his disciples, or not? He answered, Yes. He further demanded, whether upon instituting the sacrament, he did eat the sacrament with them? Moreman answered, Yes. Then he asked what he did eat, and whether he did eat his own natural body, as they imagined it to be, or not? Which when Moreman had affirmed, then, said the dean, it is a great absurdity by you granted; and so he sat down.
AFTERWARDS the prolocutor demanded of Mr. Philpot, whether he would argue against the natural presence, or not? He answered, Yes, if he would hear his argument without interruption, and assign one to answer him, and not many, which occasioned confusion, and especially to him who had but a bad memory. By this time the night approached: on which account the prolocutor put an end to the disputation, and appointed Mr. Philpot to begin the same the next day, concerning the presence of Christ in the sacrament.
ON Wednesday, October 25th, Mr. John Philpot was prepared to enter upon the disputation, intending first, to have made an oration in Latin; which being known by the prolocutor, he commanded him to make no declaration or oration in Latin, but to deliver his arguments in English. This is contrary, said Philpot, to your order at the beginning of this disputation; for then you appointed that all the arguments should be made in Latin, and thereupon I have drawn and devised all mine arguments in Latin: and because you, Mr. Prolocutor, have said heretofore, openly in this house, that I have no learning, I intended to show such learning as I have, in a brief oration, and short declaration of the questions now in controversy, thinking it so most convenient also, that in case I should speak otherwise in my declaration than should stand with learning, or than I were able to warrant, and justify God's word, it might the better be reformed by such as were learned of the house, so that the unlearned being present, might take the less offence thereat. But this prevailed nothing with the prolocutor, who still insisted upon his forming an argument in English, or else to hold his peace.
ON Wednesday, October 25th, Mr. John Philpot was prepared to enter upon the disputation, intending first, to have made an oration in Latin; which being known by the prolocutor, he commanded him to make no declaration or oration in Latin, but to deliver his arguments in English. This is contrary, said Philpot, to your order at the beginning of this disputation; for then you appointed that all the arguments should be made in Latin, and thereupon I have drawn and devised all mine arguments in Latin: and because you, Mr. Prolocutor, have said heretofore, openly in this house, that I have no learning, I intended to shew such learning as I have, in a brief oration, and short declaration of the questions now in controversy, thinking it so most convenient also, that in case I should speak otherwise in my declaration than should stand with learning, or than I were able to warrant, and justify God's word, it might the better be reformed by such as were learned of the house, so that the unlearned being present, might take the less offence thereat. But this prevailed nothing with the prolocutor, who still insisted upon his forming an argument in English, or else to hold his peace.
THEN said Philpot, you have much disappointed me, thus suddenly to go from your former order: but I will accomplish your commandments, leaving mine oration apart, and I will come to my arguments, which, as well as so sudden a warning will serve, I will make in English. But before I bring forth any argument, I will in one word declare what manner of presence I disallow in the sacrament, to the intent the hearers may the better understand to what end and effect mine arguments shall tend: not to deny utterly the presence of Christ in his sacrament, truly ministered according to his institution, but only to deny that gross and carnal presence, which you of this house have already subscribed unto, to be in the sacrament of the altar, contrary to the true and manifest meaning of the scriptures: that by transubstantiation of the sacramental bread and wine, Christ's natural body should, by virtue of the words pronounced by the priest, be contained and included under the forms or accidents of bread and wine. This kind of presence imagined by men, I do deny, and against this I will reason. But before he could make an end of what he was about, he was interrupted by the prolocutor, and commanded ⟨p. 275⟩to descend to his argument: at whose unjust importunity Philpot being offended, and hoping to find remedy, fell down upon his knees before the earls and lords which were there present, being a great number, whereof some were of the queen's council, beseeching them that he might have liberty to prosecute his arguments without interruption, which was readily granted by the lords. But the prolocutor making use of a point of the practice of prelates, would not condescend to it, but still cried, "Hold your peace, or else make a short argument." "I intend it," said Philpot, "if you will let me alone: but first I must ask a question of my respondent, Dr. Chedsey, concerning a word or two of your supposition, that is▪ of the sacrament of the altar, what he meaneth thereby." Dr. Chedsey answered, that, in their supposition, they took the sacrament of the altar, and the sacrament of the mass, to be all one. Then said Mr. Philpot, by Mr.
THEN said Philpot, you have much disappointed me, thus suddenly to go from your former order: but I will accomplish your commandments, leaving mine oration apart, and I will come to my arguments, which, as well as so sudden a warning will serve, I will make in English. But before I bring forth any argument, I will in one word declare what manner of presence I disallow in the sacrament, to the intent the hearers may the better understand to what end and effect mine arguments shall tend: not to deny utterly the presence of Christ in his sacrament, truly ministered according to his institution, but only to deny that gross and carnal presence, which you of this house have already subscribed unto, to be in the sacrament of the altar, contrary to the true and manifest meaning of the scriptures: that by transubstantiation of the sacramental bread and wine, Christ's natural body should, by virtue of the words pronounced by the priest, be contained and included under the forms or accidents of bread and wine. This kind of presence imagined by men, I do deny, and against this I will reason. But before he could make an end of what he was about, he was interrupted by the prolocutor, and commanded
Prolocutor's leave, I will speak plain English, and to be short, I say, that the sacrament of the altar, which ye reckon to be all one with the mass, once justly abolished, but now put in full force again, is no sacrament, neither is Christ in any manner present in it, and this he offered to prove before the queen, the council, or before six of the most learned men of that house, of a contrary opinion, and refused none: if, (said he) I shall not be able, by God's word, to maintain what I have asserted, and confound those six who shall withstand me in this point, let me be burned with as many faggots as can be found in London, before the court-gate. This he spake with the utmost zeal and courage.
AT this the prolocutor, with many others, were very much offended, demanding of him, whether he knew what he said. Yes, replied Mr. Philpot, I know very well what I say, and I desire that no man may be offended at it, for I speak no more than by the word of God I am able to prove; and praised be God, that the queen's grace hath granted us of this house (as our prolocutor hath informed us) the free liberty of declaring our opinions, agreeable •o our consciences in these matters of controversy in religion; and therefore I will here freely speak the dictates of my conscience▪ grounded upon God's holy […] for the truth, although some of you […] presen• do not like it.
AT this the prolocutor, with many others, were very much offended, demanding of him, whether he knew what he said. Yes, replied Mr. Philpot, I know very well what I say, and I desire that no man may be offended at it, for I speak no more than by the word of God I am able to prove; and praised be God, that the queen's grace hath granted us of this house (as our prolocutor hath informed us) the free liberty of declaring our opinions, agreeable •o our consciences in these matters of controversy in religion; and therefore I will here freely speak the dictates of my conscience▪ grounded upon God's holy 〈…〉 for the truth, although some of you 〈…〉 presen• do not like it.
THEN Mr. Weston, with others, taunted and reproved him, for speaking so indecently against the sacrament of the mass. The prolocutor also told him he was mad, and threatened to send him to prison.
MR. […] hearing himself abused, and not permitted the free liberty to speak his mind, thus exclaimed, casting his eyes towards heaven, O Lord! what a world is this, that the truth of thy holy word cannot be spoken and endured! And while he said these words, being full of sorrow, the tears were seen to trickle from his eyes.
MR. 〈…〉 hearing himself abused, and not permitted the free liberty to speak his mind, thus exclaimed, casting his eyes towards heaven, O Lord! what a world is this, that the truth of thy holy word cannot be spoken and endured! And while he said these words, being full of sorrow, the tears were seen to trickle from his eyes.
THE prolocutor, being moved by some that were about him, consented that he should make an argument, provided he would be brief. I will be as short, (said Philpot) as I can conveniently, in uttering all I have to say. And, first, I will lay the foundation of my arguments upon the authority of scripture, whereon all the buildings of our faith ought to be grounded; after which, I intend to confirm the same by the ancient fathers of the church. My first argument is drawn from the 28th chapter of St. Matthew, in which the angel says to Mary, who sought for Christ at the sepulchre, "He is risen, he is not here;" and again, St. Luke, chapter 23d, the angel asketh them, "Why seek ye the living among the dead?" In which places the scriptures testifieth, that Christ was risen, ascended into heaven, and now sitteth at the right hand of the Father: all which is spoken of his natural body; therefore, it cannot be on earth included in the sacrament, I will confirm this yet more effectually, from the 16th of St. John, where Christ saith, "I came from my Father into the world, and now I leave the world and go to my Father." Which coming and going he meant of his natural body; therefore we may consequently affirm, that it is not found in the world, nor can be in the sacrament.
BUT I expect here to be answered with a blind distinction; that he is visibly departed in his humanity, but remaineth invisibly in the sacrament; but that no such idle distinction can take away the force of my argument, will appear from the answer which Christ's disciples returned, saying, "Now thou speakest plainly, and utterest no proverb;" which words St. Cyril interpreting saith, that our Saviour ⟨p. 276⟩spake without any ambiguity, or figure of speech, and therefore I do from thence conclude, that if Christ spake plainly, and without parable, then that obscure, dark, and imperceptible presence of Christ's natural body remaining in the sacrament invisibly upon earth, contrary to the plain words of Christ, ought not to be allowed: for nothing can be more uncertain, parabolical, and absurd, than so to say. I will now give attention to your answer, and then descend to confirm what I have said by ancient writers.