pp. 270–28493 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
THEN Dr. Chedsey, reciting his argument as it was made, took upon him to answer every part thereof severally. First, to the saying of the angel, That Christ is not here, and, Why seek ye the living among the dead? He answered that these sayings pertained nothing to the presence of Christ's natural body in the sacrament, but that they were spoke of Christ's body being in the sepulchre, when the three Maris thought him to have been in the grave still. And therefore the angel said, Why do ye seek him that liveth among the dead? And to the authority of St. John, where Christ saith, Now I leave the world and go to my Father; he meant that of his ascension. And so likewise did Cyril, interpreting the saying of the disciples, that they knew plainly that Christ would visibly ascend into heaven▪ but that doth not exclude the invisible presence of his natural body in the sacrament. For St. Chrysostom, writing to the people of Antioch, doth affirm the same, comparing Elijah and Christ together, and Elijah's cloak, and Christ's flesh. "When Elijah (saith he) was taken up in the fiery chariot, he left his cloak behind him unto his disciple Elis•ous. But Christ ascending into heaven, took his flesh with him, and left also his flesh behind him." From whence we may justly conclude, that Christ's flesh is visibly ascended into heaven, and abideth still invisibly in the sacrament of the altar.
THEN Dr. Chedsey, reciting his argument as it was made, took upon him to answer every part thereof severally. First, to the saying of the angel, That Christ is not here, and, Why seek ye the living among the dead? He answered that these sayings pertained nothing to the presence of Christ's natural body in the sacrament, but that they were spoke of Christ's body being in the sepulchre, when the three Marys thought him to have been in the grave still. And therefore the angel said, Why do ye seek him that liveth among the dead? And to the authority of St. John, where Christ saith, Now I leave the world and go to my Father; he meant that of his ascension. And so likewise did Cyril, interpreting the saying of the disciples, that they knew plainly that Christ would visibly ascend into heaven▪ but that doth not exclude the invisible presence of his natural body in the sacrament. For St. Chrysostom, writing to the people of Antioch, doth affirm the same, comparing Elias and Christ together, and Elias's cloak, and Christ's flesh. "When Elias (saith he) was taken up in the fiery chariot, he left his cloak behind him unto his disciple Elis•ous. But Christ ascending into heaven, took his flesh with him, and left also his flesh behind him." From whence we may justly conclude, that Christ's flesh is visibly ascended into heaven, and abideth still invisibly in the sacrament of the altar.
TO this Philpot replied, and said You have not directly answered to the saying of the angel, Christ is risen, and is not here, because you have omitted that which was the chief point of all. For, said he, I proceed further, as thus, He is risen, ascended, and sitteth at the right hand of God the Father: therefore, he is not remaining on earth. Neither […] your answer to Cyril, by me alleged, sufficient. But I will presently return to your interpretation of Cyril, and plainly declare it, after I have refuted the authority of Chrysostom, which is one of the chief principles that you alleged to make for your gross carnal presence in the sacrament; which being well weighed and understood, pertaineth nothing thereunto.
TO this Philpot replied, and said You have not directly answered to the saying of the angel, Christ is risen, and is not here, because you have omitted that which was the chief point of all. For, said he, I proceed further, as thus, He is risen, ascended, and sitteth at the right hand of God the Father: therefore, he is not remaining on earth. Neither 〈…〉 your answer to Cyril, by me alledged, sufficient. But I will presently return to your interpretation of Cyril, and plainly declare it, after I have refuted the authority of Chrysostom, which is one of the chief principles that you alledged to make for your gross carnal presence in the sacrament; which being well weighed and understood, pertaineth nothing thereunto.
AT this the prolocutor startled, that one of the chief pillars in this point should be overthrown; and therefore he recited the said authority, first in Latin, and afterwards he turned it into English, and desired all that were present to remark the saying of Chrysostom, which he thought invincible on their own side. But I will make it appear (said Philpot) by and by, that it doth make little for your purpose. And as he was decl•••ng his mind in this particular, the prolocutor inte•••pted him, as he frequently did. With which Philpot being displeased, said, Mr. Prolocutor thinketh he is in a sophistry school, where he well knoweth the manner is, that when the respondent perceiveth, that he is like to be enforced with an argument, which he is not able to answer, he doth what he can, by cavilling, and interruption, to drive him from the same. This saying of Philpot was ill taken by the prolocutor and his adherents; and the prolocutor said, •hat Philpot could bring nothing to avoid that authority, but his own vain imagination. Hear, said Philpot, and afterwards judge; for I will do in this, as in all other authorities, wherewith you shall take upon you to refute any of my arguments that I have to prosecute, answering the same either by sufficient authorities of scripture or else by some other testimony of like authority with your's, and not of my own imagination; which▪ I do, I desire it to be of no credit.
AT this the prolocutor startled, that one of the chief pillars in this point should be overthrown; and therefore he recited the said authority, first in Latin, and afterwards he turned it into English, and desired all that were present to remark the saying of Chrysostom, which he thought invincible on their own side. But I will make it appear (said Philpot) by and by, that it doth make little for your purpose. And as he was decl•••ng his mind in this particular, the prolocutor inte•••pted him, as he frequently did. With which Philpot being displeased, said, Mr. Prolocutor thinketh he is in a sophistry school, where he well knoweth the manner is, that when the respondent perceiveth, that he is like to be inforced with an argument, which he is not able to answer, he doth what he can, by cavilling, and interruption, to drive him from the same. This saying of Philpot was ill taken by the prolocutor and his adherents; and the prolocutor said, hat Philpot could bring nothing to avoid that authority, but his own vain imagination. Hear, said Philpot, and afterwards judge; for I will do in this, as in all other authorities, wherewith you shall take upon you to refute any of my arguments that I have to prosecute, answering the same either by sufficient authorities of scripture or else by some other testimony of like authority with your's, and not of my own imagination; which I do, I desire it to be of no credit.
AS to your authority from St. Chrysostom, I have two objections against that to propose; one drawn from scripture, the other from the very place of Chrysostom himself here by you alleged.
AS to your authority from St. Chrysostom, I have two objections against that to propose; one drawn from scripture, the other from the very place of Chrysostom himself here by you alledged.
FIRST, where he seemeth to say, that Christ ascending took his flesh with him, and left his flesh also behind him; it is true; for the fl•sh Christ took with him was that which he received from the virgin Mary, and the flesh he left behind was not his natural body, but the members of his visible ⟨p. 277⟩church; as St. Paul doth aptly testify, when he says, Eph. v. "We are flesh of his flesh, and bone of his bones." And if any one will reply, that he there treateth of the sacrament, and that this interpretation cannot so properly be applied to him in that place, then I will explain St. Chrysostom another way by himself, for a few lines before those now quoted, are these words: "That Christ, after he ascended into heaven, left to us, endued with his sacraments, his flesh in mysteries, that is, sacramentally; and that mystical flesh Christ leaveth as well to his church in the sacrament of baptism, as in the the sacramental bread and wine." "As many (saith St. Paul) as are baptized in Christ, have put on Christ." Hence you may perceive, that St. Chrysostom makes nothing for your gross carnal presence in the sacrament, as you wrongly interpret him.
FIRST, where he seemeth to say, that Christ ascending took his flesh with him, and left his flesh also behind him; it is true; for the fl•sh Christ took with him was that which he received from the virgin Mary, and the flesh he left behind was not his natural body, but the members of his visible ⟨p. 277⟩church; as St. Paul doth aptly testify, when he says, Eph. v. "We are flesh of his flesh, and bone of his bones." And if any one will reply, that he there treateth of the sacrament, and that this interpretation cannot so properly be applied to him in that place, then I will explain St. Chrysostom another way by himself, for a few lines be•fore those now quoted, are these words: "That Christ, after he ascended into heaven, left to us, indued with his sacraments, his flesh in mysteries, that is, sacramentally; and that mystical flesh Christ leaveth as well to his church in the sacrament of baptism, as in the the sacramental bread and wine." "As many (saith St. Paul) as are baptized in Christ, have put on Christ." Hence you may perceive, that St. Chrysostom makes nothing for your gross carnal presence in the sacrament, as you wrongly interpret him.
NOW in the mean time, while Mr. Philpot was speaking, Mr. Pie, whispering the prolocutor in the car, urged him to silence Philpot, fearing, if he held on longer, he would wholly overthrow their opinion of the carnal presence, seeing he had already given one of its main supporters such a blow. The prolocutor, therefore, said to Mr. Philpot, that he had reasoned long enough, and that some other should supply his room, at which Mr. Philpot, being much displeased, said, Why, sir, I have a dozen arguments to propose concerning this matter, and I have as yet scarce gone over the first; for being hitherto hindered, through your frequent interruptions, I have not, for confirmation, quoted any ancient writers, though I could a great man•. Well, returned the prolocutor, you shall sp••k no more now, and I command you to be silent. You perceive, said Mr. Philpot, that I am able to controvert your false supposition, and therefore you command me to be silent. If you will not give place, said Mr. Weston, I will send you to prison. This is not, replied Philpot, according to your promise made in this house, nor yet to your bra•s made at Paul's Cross, that men should be answered in this disputation to whatever they can say, sinc• of a dozen arguments you will not suffer me •o prosecute one. Here Mr. Pie took upon him to promise, that he should be answered another day. But Mr. Philpot, seeing he could not proceed as he designed, was justly offended thereat, and concluded with the following words:—"A sort of you here, who hitherto have lurked in corners, and dissembled with God and the world, are now gathered together to suppress the sincere truth of God's holy word, and to set forth every false device, which by the catholic doctrine of the scripture ye are not able to maintain."
NOW in the mean time, while Mr. Philpot was speaking, Mr. Pie, whispering the prolocutor in the car, urged him to silence Philpot, fearing, if he held on longer, he would wholly overthrow their opinion of the carnal presence, seeing he had already given one of its main supporters such a blow. The prolocutor, therefore, said to Mr. Philpot, that he had reasoned long enough, and that some other should supply his room, at which Mr. Philpot, being much displeased, said, Why, sir, I have a dozen arguments to propose concerning this matter, and I have as yet scarce gone over the first; for being hitherto hindered, through your frequent interruptions, I have not, for confirmation, quoted any ancient writers, though I could a great man. Well, returned the prolocutor, you shall spk no more now, and I command you to be silent. You perceive, said Mr. Philpot, that I am able to controvert your fals supposition, and therefore you command me to be silent. If you will not give place, said Mr. Weston, I will send you to prison. This is not, replied Philpot, according to your promise made in this house, nor yet to your bras made at Paul's Cross, that men should be answerd in this disputation to whatever they can say, sinc of a dozen arguments you will not suffer me o prosecute one. Here Mr. Pie took upon him to promise, that he should be answered another day. But Mr. Philpot, seeing he could not proceed as he designed, was justly offended thereat, and concluded with the following words:—"A sort of you here, who hitherto have lurked in orners, and dissembled with God and the world, are now gathered together to suppress the sincere truth of God's holy word, and to set forth every false device, which by the catholic doctrine of the scripture ye are not able to maintain."
THEN stood up Mr. Elmar, chaplain to the duke of Suffolk, whom Mr. Moreman took upon him to answer; but Mr. Elmar's allegations so encumbered his respondent, that he desired a day to overlook them, for at that instant he was without a proper answer.
THEN stood up Mr. Elmar, chaplain to the duke of Suffolk, whom Mr. Moreman took upon him to answer; but Mr. Elmar's allegations so incumbered his respondent, that he desired a day to overlook them, for at that instant he was without a proper answer.
THE prolocutor now called upon Mr. Haddon, dean of Exeter, and a chaplain to the duke of Suffolk, who prosecuted Mr. Elmar's argument. Dr. Watson, who attempted to answer him, was so confounded, that he was not able to explain sufficiently the word Mysterium (Mystery). But as he seemed to doubt therein, Mr. Haddon took out of his bosom a Latin author, to confirm what he had advanced, and, showing the same to Dr. Watson, asked him, whether he thought that translation to be a just one, or that the printer were in fault: to which Watson replied, there may be a fault in the printer, for I am not remembered of this word. Then Mr Haddon took out of his bosom a Greek book, wherein he pointed to the same word, which Mr. Watson could not deny. The further arguments that were made use of, we shall omit declaring, because they were mostly in Greek, as were those also of Mr. Elmar's.
THE prolocutor now called upon Mr. Haddon, dean of Exeter, and a chaplain to the duke of Suffolk, who prosecuted Mr. Elmar's argument. Dr. Watson, who attempted to answer him, was so confounded, that he was not able to explain sufficiently the word Mysterium (Mystery). But as he seemed to doubt therein, Mr. Haddon took out of his bosom a Latin author, to confirm what he had advanced, and, shewing the same to Dr. Watson, asked him, whether he thought that translation to be a just one, or that the printer were in fault: to which Watson replied, there may be a fault in the printer, for I am not remembered of this word. Then Mr Haddon took out of his bosom a Greek book, wherein he pointed to the same word, which Mr. Watson could not deny. The further arguments that were made use of, we shall omit declaring, because they were mostly in Greek, as were those also of Mr. Elmar's.
THEN Mr. Perne stood up, and argued against transubstantiation, confirming the authorities alleged by the two former speakers. When the prolocutor, interrupting, said, "I wonder, Mr. Porn, at your speaking thus, for no longer than last Friday you subscribed to the contrary." For which censure Mr. Elmar blamed the prolocutor, telling him, that he ought not to reprehend any man, because, said he, this house is a house of free liberty for every man to speak according to his conscience, and because but yesterday he promised this liberty to any man, notwithstanding he had subscribed.
THEN Mr. Perne stood up, and argued against transubstantiation, confirming the authorities alledged by the two former speakers. When the prolocutor, interrupting, said, "I wonder, Mr. Porne, at your speaking thus, for no longer than last Friday you subscribed to the contrary." For which censure Mr. Elmar blamed the prolocutor, telling him, that he ought not to reprehend any man, because, said he, this house is a house of free liberty for every man to speak according to his conscience, and because but yesterday he promised this liberty to any man, notwithstanding he had subscribed.
NIGHT now approaching, and the time being expired, the prolocutor, though he praised them ⟨p. 278⟩for their learning, concluded with observing, that, all reasoning set apart, the order of Holy Church must be received, and all things ordered thereby.
ON Friday, October 27th, the prolocutor opened the debate, with observing, that the convocation had spent two days in disputing about one father, which was Theodoret, and about one Greek word, ( •usia) and now they were assembled to answer all things that could be objected, therefore he desired they would shortly propound their arguments. Upon this Mr. Haddon dean of Exeter, requested leave to oppose Mr. Watson, who, with Morgan and Harpsfi••d, were appointed to answer him. Mr. Haddon then demanded, if any substance of bread and wine remained after consecration? To which Watson replied, by asking another question, namely, whether he thought there was a real presence of Christ's body or not? Mr. Haddon said, it was not agreeable to order, that one, who was appointed to be respondent should be opponent; nor should he, whose business was to object, answer. Mr. Haddon then proceeded to show, from the words of Theodoret, that the substance of bread and wine remained: for his words are, "The same they were before the sanctification, which they are after." Mr. Watson said, that Theodoret meant not the same substance, but the same essence. Whereupon they were driven again to a discussion of the Greek word above-mentioned; and Mr. Haddon proved it to mean a substance, both by its etymology, and by the words of Theodoret; for, said he, •usia cometh from the particle on, which descendeth to the verb […], and so cometh the noun •usia, which signifieth substance. Mr. Watson said, it had not that signification only: but, in that place, Mr. Haddon proved, it could not signify otherwise. He then asked Watson, when the bread and wine became symbols? Watson answered, After consecration, and not before. Then Mr. Haddon raised out of his author the following syllogism (being an argument of three propositions.)
ON Friday, October 27th, the prolocutor opened the debate, with observing, that the convocation had spent two days in disputing about one father, which was Theodoret, and about one Greek word, ( •usia) and now they were assembled to answer all things that could be objected, therefore he desired they would shortly propound their arguments. Upon this Mr. Haddon dean of Exeter, requested leave to oppose Mr. Watson, who, with Morgan and Harpsfi••d, were appointed to answer him. Mr. Haddon then demanded, if any substance of bread and wine remained after consecration? To which Watson replied, by asking another question, namely, whether he thought there was a real presence of Christ's body or not? Mr. Haddon said, it was not agreeable to order, that one, who was appointed to be respondent should be opponent; nor should he, whose business was to object, answer. Mr. Haddon then proceeded to shew, from the words of Theodoret, that the substance of bread and wine remained: for his words are, "The same they were before the sanctification, which they are after." Mr. Watson said, that Theodoret meant not the same substance, but the same essence. Whereupon they were driven again to a discussion of the Greek word above-mentioned; and Mr. Haddon proved it to mean a substance, both by its etymology, and by the words of Theodoret; for, said he, usia cometh from the particle on, which descendeth to the verb , and so cometh the noun usia, which signifieth substance. Mr. Watson said, it had not that signification only: but, in that place, Mr. Haddon proved, it could not signify otherwise. He then asked Watson, when the bread and wine became symbols? Watson answered, After consecration, and not before. Then Mr. Haddon raised out of his author the following syllogism (being an argument of three propositions.)
(1) THEODORET saith, that the same thing the bread and wine were, before they were symbols, the same they remain still, in nature and substance, after they are symbols,
(2) BREAD and wine they were before.
(3) THEREFORE, bread and wine they are after.
MR. WATSON, when he could not answer, had recourse to the shameful subterfuge of discrediting the authority of Theodoret, by saying, he was a Nestorian; at the same time, turning to Mr. Cheyney, who stood by, he desired to answer him, intimating, that he was more fit, than Mr. Haddon, to dispute upon this point, because he had granted and subscribed to the real presence. Being thus addressed with an insinuation that required an immediate reply, Mr, Cheyney applied to the house, and requested the patience of those honourable men to hear him, hoping so to open the matter, that the truth should appear; protesting, that he was no obstinate nor stubborn man, but would be conformable to all reason; and if they, by their learning, which he acknowledged to be much more than his, could answer his reasons, then he would be ruled by them, and say as they said; for he would be no author of schism, nor hold any thing contrary to the holy mother, the church, which is the spouse of Christ. Dr. Weston liking this very well, commended him highly, telling him, that he was a very learned and sober man, and well experienced in all good learning, and in the doctors; and finally a man, for his knowledge, fit to dispute in that place; I pray you hear him, quoth he. Then Mr. Cheyney desired those that were present to pray to God with him in two words, and to say, Vinc•t veritas, "Let truth take place, and have the victory;" and all that were present cried with a loud voice, Vinc•t veritas, Vincat veritas.
DR. WESTON told them it was hypocritical, and that they had better say, Vicit veritas, "Truth hath gotten the victory." Mr. Cheyney said again, If you will give me leave, I will come to the point, that you may truly say so. Then addressing himself particularly to Mr. Watson, he began after this manner.
YOU said that Mr. Haddon was not fit to dispute, because he had not granted the natural and ⟨p. 279⟩real presence; but I say you are much less fit to answer, because you, take away the substance of the sacrament. Watson said, that he had subscribed to the real presence, and should not go away from that: so said the prolocutor and the other priests; so that for a long time he could not have leave to proceed, till the lords desired that he should be heard. He now explained what he meant by subscribing to the real presence, far otherwise than they supposed. He then prosecuted Haddon's argument, proving that the Greek word before discussed was a substance, using the the same reason that Haddon did; and when he had received the same answer that was made to Haddon, he told them it was but a poor refuge, when they could not answer, to deny the author, and proved the author to be a catholic doctor; that being proved, he further confirmed what was said of the nature and substance. The similitude of Theodoret is this, said he, as the tokens of Christ's body and blood, after the invocation of the priest, do change their names, and yet continue the same substance; so the body of Christ after his ascension, changed his name, and was called immortal, yet it had his former fashion, figure, and circumscription, and, to speak in one word, the same substance of his body. Therefore, if in the former part of the similitude you deny the same substance to continue, th•n in the latter part of the similitude, which agreeth with it, I will deny the body of Christ, after […] ascension, to have the former nature and substance. But that were a great heresy: therefore it […] also a great heresy to take away the substance of bread and wine after consecration. In answer to this, Watson was obliged to say, that the substance of the body, in the former part of the similitude brought in by him, did signify quantity, and other accidents of the sacramental tokens which are seen, and not the very substance of the same; and therefore Theodoret says, Those things which are seen. For according to philosophy, the accidents of things are seen, and not the substances.
YOU said that Mr. Haddon was not fit to dispute, because he had not granted the natural and ⟨p. 279⟩real presence; but I say you are much less fit to answer, because you, take away the substance of the sacrament. Watson said, that he had subscribed to the real presence, and should not go away from that: so said the prolocutor and the other priests; so that for a long time he could not have leave to proceed, till the lords desired that he should be heard. He now explained what he meant by subscribing to the real presence, far otherwise than they supposed. He then prosecuted Haddon's argument, proving that the Greek word before discussed was a substance, using the the same reason that Haddon did; and when he had received the same answer that was made to Haddon, he told them it was but a poor refuge, when they could not answer, to deny the author, and proved the author to be a catholic doctor; that being proved, he further confirmed what was said of the nature and substance. The similitude of Theodoret is this, said he, as the tokens of Christ's body and blood, after the invocation of the priest, do change their names, and yet continue the same substance; so the body of Christ after his ascension, changed his name, and was called immortal, yet it had his former fashion, figure, and circumscription, and, to speak in one word, the same substance of his body. Therefore, if in the former part of the similitude you deny the same substance to continue, thn in the latter part of the similitude, which agreeth with it, I will deny the body of Christ, after ascension, to have the former nature and substance. But that were a great heresy: therefore it also a great heresy to take away the substance of bread and wine after consecration. In answer to this, Watson was obliged to say, that the substance of the body, in the former part of the similitude brought in by him, did signify quantity, and other accidents of the sacramental tokens which are seen, and not the very substance of the same; and therefore Theodoret says, Those things which are seen. For according to philosophy, the accidents of things are seen, and not the substances.
CHEYNEY then appealed to the nobility, and desired that they would give no credit to them in so saying: for if they think as they ••ach, after your lordships have ridden forty miles on horseback (as your business sometimes may require) you shall not be able to say at night, that you saw your horses all the day, but only the colour of them: and by this reason Christ must go to school, and learn of Aristotle how to speak. For when he saw Nathaniel under the fig-tree, if Aristotle had stood by, he would have said, No, Christ, thou didst not see him, but the colour of him. Then said Watson, suppose it were granted that Theodoret was on the other side, where there were one of that opinion, there were an hundred on the other.
THE prolocutor here perceiving, that Mr. Watson was closely attacked, called upon Mr. Morgan to help him out, who said, that Theodoret did no more than what he might lawfully do; for, first, he granted the truth, and then, for fear of such as were not fully instructed in the faith, he spake mystically: he granted the truth, by calling the bread and wine, the body and blood of Christ; after which he seems to give somewhat of the senses and to reason: but that Theodoret was of the same opinion with them, will appear from his words that follow, which are the cause of what went before; therefore he says, The immortality, &c. whereby it seemeth, that he meant the divine nature, and not the human. Morgan was then detected in misapplying the text; for the book had not this word [for] and the Greek word did rather signify [truly], whence it plainly appeared, that it was the beginning of a new matter, and not a sentence rendering a cause of that he had said before.
WATSON now repeated what he had before said: "Suppose Theodoret be on your side, of whom we never beard in print, before two or three years ago▪ yet he is but one; and what is one against the consent of the whole church?" Cheyney affirmed, that not only Theodoret was of his opinion, that the substance of bread and wine do remain, but many others also, particularly Irenaeus, who making mention of this sacrament, says thus: "When the cup which is mingled with wine, and the bread which is broken, do receive the word of God, it is made the Eucharist of the body and blood of Christ, by which the substance of our flesh is nourished, and doth consist." From whence I infer, that if the thanksgiving do nourish our body, then there is some substance besides Christ's body. To ⟨p. 280⟩this both Watson and Morgan replied, observing that [by which,] in that sentence of Irenaeus, was to be referred to the next antecedent, that is, to the body and blood of Christ; and not to the wine which is in the cup, and the bread which is broken. Mr. Cheyney said, that it was not the body of Christ which nourished our bodies; and granting that the flesh of Christ nourisheth to immortality, yet it doth not make for their argument, although it might be true; no more than that answer which was made to my allegation out of St. Paul, The bread which we break, &c. with many others; whereunto you answered, that bread was not to be taken there in its proper signification, that is, not for that it was bread, but for that it had been so; any more than the •od of Aaron was taken for a serpent, […] had been a serpent. After this, Mr. […] •esychius, and used the same reason that he did concerning the burning of symbols; and asked them, what was burnt? Mr. Watson said, we must not enquire no• ask, but if there wa• any fault, impute it to Christ. Then said Mr Cheyney, whence came those ashes, if not from substance? or can any substance arise from accidents?
WATSON now repeated what he had before said: "Suppose Theodoret be on your side, of whom we never beard in print, before two or three years ago▪ yet he is but one; and what is one against the consent of the whole church?" Cheyney affirmed, that not only Theodoret was of his opinion, that the substance of bread and wine do remain, but many others also, particularly Irenaeus, who making mention of this sacrament, says thus: "When the cup which is mingled with wine, and the bread which is broken, do receive the word of God, it is made the Eucharist of the body and blood of Christ, by which the substance of our flesh is nourished, and doth consist." From whence I infer, that if the thanksgiving do nourish our body, then there is some substance besides Christ's body. To
HERE Mr. Harpsfield was called in to the assistance of Watson, and to hear what he could say to this matter; who began with a fair preamble about the omnipotency of God, and the weakness of human reason as to the comprehension and attainment of religious matters; and said, that whatsoever we saw, felt, or tasted, it was not convenient to trust our senses — The very pith and marrow of popery this.) He also related a curious legend out of St. Cyprian, how a woman saw the sacrame•• burning in her coffer; and that which burned thus, said Harpsfield, burneth here, and becometh ashes; but what that was which burnt, he could not tell. Mr. Cheyney continued still to force them with this question—What was it that was burnt?—•t was either, said he, the substance of bread, or else the substance of the body of Christ, which was too great an absurdity to grant. At length they answered; it was a miracle▪ at which Mr. Cheyney smiling, said, that he would then say no more.
HERE Mr. Harpsfield was called in to the assistance of Watson, and to hear what he could say to this matter; who began with a fair preamble about the omnipotency of God, and the weakness of human reason as to the comprehensio• and attainme•t of religious matters; and said, that whatsoever we saw, felt, or tasted, it was not convenient to trust our senses — The very pith and marrow of popery this.) He also related a curious legend out of St. Cyprian, how a woman saw the sacrame•• burning in her coffer; and that which burned thus, said Harpsfield, burneth here, and becometh ashes; but what that was which burnt, he could not tell. Mr. Cheyney continued still to force them with this question—What was it that was burnt?—•t was either, said he, the substance of bread, or else the substance of the body of Christ, wh•ch was too great an absurdity to grant. At length they answered; it was a miracle▪ at which Mr. Cheyney smiling, said, that he would then say no more.
THEN Dr. Weston, the p•olocator, asked the company, whether those men had been sufficiently answered, or not? To which certain priests said, Yes; but as to the great multitude of people, these exclaimed—No, no• they were not heard; and the clamour was so great, that it was heard almost to the end of St. Paul's: whereat Dr. Weston, being much incensed, answered sharply, that he asked not the judgment of the rude multitude, and unlearned people, but such as were members of that house. Having said this with much acrimony, be asked Mr. Haddon and his fellow-disputants, whether they would answer them other three days? Mr. Haddon, Cheyney, and Elmar answered, No. Upon which the archdeacon of Winchester, Mr. Philpot, stood up, and said, they should be answered; and though all others refused to answer, yet he would not; but offered to answer them all in turns: with whose offer the prolocutor being dissatisfied▪ railed at him, saying that he should go to Bedlam; to whom the archdeacon returned gravely this •• swer, that he deserved much more to be sent thither, who behaved himself so furiously in the disputation, without any indifferent equality.
TO this Dr. Weston made no reply, but rising up addressed the house, saying▪ All the compa•• here have subscribed, these men whom you see one excepted. What their reasons are you have he•re. We have answered them three days, upon promis•, (which was a false assertion for no such promise was made that they should answer us again, as long as the order of disputation continued, and, if they be able to defend their doctrine, let them do so.
THEN stood up Mr. ••mar, and showed how va•• a man Mr. Weston wa• ▪ for he affirmed they never promised to dispute▪ but only to declare and testify to the world their consciences. For when they […] required to subscribe, they refused, alleging▪ that they would show good reasons which moved them, that they could not, agreeable to their […], subscribe; as they had partly done already, and were able to do more effectually. Therefore, continued he, it hath been ill called a disputation, and they are much to blame who called it so. We meant not to dispute, nor now intend to answer, before our arguments, which we have to propound, be s••ved, according as it was appointed: for, b• ⟨p. 281⟩answering, we should but encumber ourselves and profit nothing, since the matter is already decreed on, and determined, whatsoever we may prove by dispute to the contrary.
THEN stood up Mr. ••mar, and shewed how va•• a man Mr. Weston wa• ▪ for he affirmed they never promised to dispute▪ but only to declare and testify to the world their consciences. For when they 〈…〉 required to subscribe, they refused, alledging▪ that they would shew good reasons which moved them, that they could not, agreeable to their 〈…〉, subscribe; as they had partly done already, and were able to do more effectually. Therefore, continued he, it hath been ill called a disputation, and they are much to blame who called it so. We meant not to dispute, nor now intend to answer, before our arguments, which we have to propound, be s••ved, according as it was appointed: for, b
ON Monday following, October the 30th, the prolocutor demanded of M•. Philpot, whether, in the questions, before propounded, he would answer their objections or not? To whom he made this answer; that he would willingly do so, if, according to their former determination and promise, they would first answer fully some of his arguments, of which he had a dozen, not half the first being decided; and if they would answer but one of his arguments sufficiently, he would reply to all the objections they could bring. The prolocutor bid him state his argument, and it should be resolutely controverted by some of them; whereunto Morgan was appointed. Mr. Philpot then proceeded. On Wednesday last, said he, I was forced to silence before I had half prosecuted my argument, the sum of which was, that the human body of Christ was ascended into heaven, and placed at the right hand of God the Father: wherefore, after the imagination of man, it could not be situated upon earth invisibly in the sacrament of the altar. The argument was denied by Morgan; but for proof hereof, Philpot said, that this was what he had to confirm his first argument with, if they would have suffered him the other day, as he hoped they would now. He thus proceeded with his argument.
(1) O•• self-same nature receiveth not in itself any thing that is contrary to itself.
(2) BUT the body of Christ is a human nature, distinct from the deity, and is a proper nature of itself.
(3) ••GO, therefore it cannot receive any thing that is contrary to that nature, and that varieth from itself.
BUT bodily to be present, and to be absent bodily, to be on earth, and to be in heaven, and all at one present time, are things contrary to the nature of an human body. Therefore, it cannot be said of the human body of Christ, that the self-same body is both in heaven, and also on the earth at one instant, either visibly or invisibly. Morgan denied the first part of the argument, which Philpot supported out of Vigilius, an ancient writer; yet still Morgan cavilled thereat, and said it was no scripture, and desired him to prove the same from scripture. Philpot deduced the same from St. Paul, who says, that "Christ is like unto us in all points, except sin; therefore, like as one of our bodies cannot receive in itself any thing contrary to the nature of a body, as to be in St. Paul's church and at Westminster in one instant, or to be at London visibly, and at Lincoln invisibly at one time; so, in like manner, the body of Christ cannot be in more places than one, which is in heaven, and consequently is not included or contained in the sacrament of the altar. But, said the prolocutor, it is not true, that Christ was like unto us in all points, since he was not conceived by the seed of man as we are. Philpot replied, that Christ's conception was prophesied before by the angel to be supernatural, but after he had received our nature by the operation of the Holy Ghost in the virgin's womb, he became in all points like unto us, except sin.
BUT bodily to be present, and to be absent bodily, to be on earth, and to be in heaven, and all at one present time, are things contrary to the nature of an human body. Therefore, it cannot be said of the human body of Christ, that the self-same body is both in heaven, and also on the earth at one instant, either visibly or invisibly. Morgan denied the first part of the argument, which Philpot supported out of Vigilius, an ancient writer; yet still Morgan c•villed thereat, and said it was no scripture, and desired him to prove the same from scripture. Philpot deduced the same from St. Paul, who says, that "Christ is like unto us in all points, except sin; therefore, like as one of our bodies cannot receive in itself any thing contrary to the nature of a body, as to be in St. Paul's church and at Westminster in one instant, or to be at London visibly, and at Lincoln invisibly at one time; so, in like manner, the body of Christ cannot be in more places than one, which is in heaven, and consequently is not included or contained in the sacrament of the altar. But, said the prolocutor, it is not true, that Christ was like unto us in all points, since he was not conceived by the seed of man as we are. Philpot replied, that Christ's conception was prophesied before by the angel to be supernatural, but after he had received our nature by the operation of the Holy Ghost in the virgin's womb, he became in all points like unto us, except sin.
THEN Morgan affirmed, that these words of St. Paul did not plainly prove his purpose. Well, said Philpot, I perceive you answer only by cavilling, yet I am not destitute of other scriptures, though you refuse the testimony of so ancient and catholic a doctor as Vigilius is. St. Peter, making mention of Christ in the 3d chapter of the Acts, says, "Whom heaven must receive, until the consummation of all things," &c. which words are spoken of his humanity; and if heaven must hold Christ, then can he not be here on earth, in the sacrament, as is pretended. Morgan laughing at this, and giving no direct answer, Harpsfield, one of the bishop of London's chaplains, stood up, and demanded of Mr. Philpot, whether he would of necessity force Christ to any place, or not? Philpot returned, that he would no otherwise force Christ of necessity to any place, than what the words of the Holy Ghost teach, namely, that Christ's human body must abide in heaven until the day of judgment. To which Harpsfield replied, Do you know that God is a God omnipotent: Yes, said Philpot, I know that right well▪ but as to Christ's omnipotency, ⟨p. 282⟩what he can do, is not our question, but rather, what he actually doth: he may make worlds; but doth he therefore so? It were no good consequent to conclude, because he may or can do this or that, therefore he doth do it.
ONLY so much is to be believed of God's omnipotency, as is in the word expressed.
THAT Christ's body is both in heaven, and here also really in the sacrament, is not expressed in the word.
ERGO, (therefore) it is not to be believed, that the body of Christ, being in heaven, is here in the sacrament.
WHY, returned the prolocutor, then you will put Christ in prison in heaven. To which Philpot answered, Do you reckon heaven to be a prison? God grant us all to come to that prison.
AFTER this, Harpsfield affirmed, that the Latin word, oportet, in St. Peter, (in English, must) did not import, as Philpot would infer, a necessity, which might be made appear from other places of scripture, as in the first to Timothy, where St. Paul saith, A bishop must be the husband of one wife. Here the word oportet doth not mean necessity, but a possibility, that he, who never was married, may be a bishop. To which Philpot replied, that the two passages he compared were not alike; and that in comparing the scriptures we must not consider the bare words, but rather their import; and in one place, quoted by him, St. Paul declares of what quality a bishop ought to be; but in the other St. Peter refers to the place where Christ must necessarily be until the end of the world; which we ought to believe to be true. And this comparison of the Latin word, oportet, is no more an answer to my argument, than if I was to say of you, now being here, you must needs be here, which importeth such a necessity for the time, that you can no otherwise but be here; yet you would endeavour, in words, to avoid this necessity with another oportet in another sense, as for instance, you must be a good man, where must doth not indeed imply any such necessity, but that you may be an evil man. Thus your reasoning is not conclusive, and by no means an answer to my argument.
THE prolocutor, to help the matter out, if possible, brought up another oportet, saying, Oportet hareses esse; must heresies needs be therefore, because of this word oportet? Certainly, returned Philpot, it cannot otherwise be, if you will add what immediately followeth, ut qui electi sunt manifestentur, meaning, "that such as be the elect of God may be manifest and known." But, said the prolocutor, the time hath been that no such heresies were. I know not of any such time, said Philpot; for since the time of Abel and Cain heresies have been, and then began. Then said the prolocutor, Will you not now answer Morgan an argument or two? I will, said Philpot, if I may have my arguments first answered fairly, according to truth and learning. What! said the prolocutor, will you never be answered? How I am answered, returned Philpot, let all here present judge, especially men of learning, and with what cavilling you have trifled with me. First, to the ancient authority of Vigilius, you have answered nothing, except denying what he saith to be scripture. Secondly, to the words of St. Peter, in the Acts, ye have answered, by demanding, whether I would keep Christ in prison, or not? Let men now judge if this be a sufficient answer, or not? Upon this Morgan stood up again, and asked Philpot, whether he would be ruled by the universal church, or not? Ye•, said Philpot, if it be the true catholic church; and since you speak so much of the church, I would have you declare what the church is. The church, said Morgan, is diffused and dispersed throughout the whole world. That is a diffuse definition, said Philpot, for I am yet as uncertain as I was before, what you mean by the church; but is it not what was grounded and founded on the word of God, as St. Paul saith upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets? What! quoth Moreman, was the scripture before the church? Yes, answered Philpot. But I will prove the contrary, returned Moreman; and I will begin at the time of Christ. The church of Christ was before any scripture written: for Matthew was the first who wrote a gospel, about a dozen years after Christ: therefore, the church was before the scripture. Philpot denied his argument; ⟨p. 283⟩and showed it to be a fallacy; for he took the scripture to be only that which was written by men in letters:
THE prolocutor, to help the matter out, if possible, brought up another oportet, saying, Oportet hareses esse; must heresies needs be therefore, because of this word oportet? Certainly, returned Philpot, it cannot otherwise be, if you will add what immediately followeth, ut qui electi sunt manifestentur, meaning, "that such as be the elect of God may be manifest and known." But, said the prolocutor, the time hath been that no such heresies were. I know not of any such time, said Philpot; for since the time of Abel and Cain heresies have been, and then began. Then said the prolocutor, Will you not now answer Morgan an argument or two? I will, said Philpot, if I may have my arguments first answered fairly, according to truth and learning. What! said the prolocutor, will you never be answered? How I am answered, returned Philpot, let all here present judge, especially men of learning, and with what cavilling you have trifled with me. First, to the ancient authority of Vigilius, you have answered nothing, except denying what he saith to be scripture. Secondly, to the words of St. Peter, in the Acts, ye have answered, by demanding, whether I would keep Christ in prison, or not? Let men now judge if this be a sufficient answer, or not? Upon this Morgan stood up again, and asked Philpot, whether he would be ruled by the universal church, or not? Ye, said Philpot, if it be the true catholic church; and since you speak so much of the church, I would have you declare what the church is. The church, said Morgan, is diffused and dispersed throughout the whole world. That is a diffuse definition, said Philpot, for I am yet as uncertain as I was before, what you mean by the church; but is it not what was grounded and founded on the word of God, as St. Paul saith upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets? What! quoth Moreman, was the scripture before the church? Yes, answered Philpot. But I will prove the contrary, returned Moreman; and I will begin at the time of Christ. The church of Christ was before any scripture written: for Matthew was the first who wrote a gospel, about a dozen years after Christ: therefore, the church was before the scripture. Philpot denied his argument;
whereas in truth, all prophecy uttered by the Spirit of God, was counted to be scripture, before it was written in paper and ink, for it was written in the hearts, and graven in the minds, yea, and inspired in the mouths of good men, and of the apostles, by the Spirit of Christ. The salutation of the angel was the scripture of Christ, or the word of God, before it was written. Moreman cried, Fie, fie! wondering that the scripture of God should be counted scripture before it was written, and affirmed, he had no knowledge who said so. To whom Philpot replied, that as to knowledge in this matter, for the trial of truth, about the questions in controversy, he would wish himself no worse matched than with Moreman.