pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 10 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
BUT the words spoken upon the cup, have not virtue to transubstantiate.
THEREFORE, it followeth, that the words spoken upon the bread have no such virtue.
THE circumstances of the scripture, the analogy and proportion of the sacraments, and the testimony of the faithful fathers, ought to rule us in taking the meaning of the holy scripture touching the sacrament.
BUT the words of the Lord's supper, the circumstances of the scripture, the analogy of the sacraments, and the sayings of the fathers, do most effectually and plainly prove a figurative speech in the words of the Lord's supper.
ERGO, A figurative sense and meaning is specially to be received in these words, "This is my body."
THE circumstances of the scripture are, "Do this in remembrance of me. As oft as ye shall eat of this bread, and drink of this cup, ye shall show forth the Lord's death. Let a man prove himself, and so eat of this bread, and drink of this cup. They came together to break bread; and they continued in breaking of bread. The bread which we break, &c. For we being many, are all one bread and one body," &c.
THE circumstances of the scripture are, "Do this in remembrance of me. As oft as ye shall eat of this bread, and drink of this cup, ye shall shew forth the Lord's death. Let a man prove himself, and so eat of this bread, and drink of this cup. They came together to break bread; and they continued in breaking of bread. The bread which we break, &c. For we being many, are all one bread and one body," &c.
THE analogy of the sacraments is necessary: for if the sacraments had not some similitude, or likeness of the things whereof they be sacraments, they could in no wise be sacraments. And this similitude in the sacrament of the Lord's supper is taken three manner of ways.
THE analogy of the sacraments is necessary: for if the sacraments had not some similitude, or like•ness of the things whereof they be sacraments, they could in no wise be sacraments. And this similitude in the sacrament of the Lord's supper is taken three manner of ways.
1. THE first consisteth in nourishing, as ye shall read in Rabana, Cyprian, Augustine, Irene, and most plainly in Isidore out of Bertram.
2. THE second in uniting and joining of many into one, as Cyprian teacheth.
3. THE third is a similitude of unlike things; where, like as the bread is turned into one body, so we, by the right use of this sacrament, are turned through faith into the body of Christ.
THE sayings of the fathers declare it to be a figurative speech, as it appeareth in Origen, Tertullian, Chrysostom in an unfinished work, Augustine, Ambrose, Basil, Gregory, Nazianzen, Hilary, and most plainly of all in Bertram. Moreover, the sayings and places of all the fathers, whose names I have before recited against the assertion of the first proposition, do quite overthrow transubstantiation. But of all most evidently and plainly, Irene, Origen, Cyprian, Chrysostom to Cesarius the monk, Augustine against Adamatus, Gelasius, Cyril, Epiphanius, Chrysostom again on the xx. Matthew, Rabana, Damascene, and Bertram.
HERE, right worshipful Mr. Prolocutor, and ye the rest of the commissioners, it may please you to understand, that I do not lean to these things only, which I have written in my former answers and confirmations, but that I have also, for the proof of that I have spoken, whatsoever Bertram, a man learned, of sound and upright judgment, and ever counted a catholic for these seven hundred years until this our age, hath written. His treatise, whosoever shall read and weigh, considering the time of the writer, his learning, godliness of life, the allegations of the ancient fathers, and his manifold and most grounded arguments, I cannot (doubtless) but much marvel, if he have any fear of God at all, how he can with good conscience speak against him in this matter of the sacrament. This Bertram was the first that brought me from the common error of the Romish church, and caused me to search more diligently and exactly both the scriptures and the writings of the old ecclesiastical fathers in this matter. And this I protest before the face of God, who knoweth I lye not in the things I now speak.
IN the mass is the lively sacrifice of the church, propitiable and available for the sins as well of the quick as of the dead.
I answer to this third proposition as I did to the first. And moreover I say, that being taken in such sense as the words seem to import, it is not only erroneous, but withal so much to the derogation and defacing of the death and passion of Christ, that I judge it may and ought most worthily to be counted wicked and blasphemous against the most precious blood of our Saviour Christ.
CONCERNING the Romish mass which is used at this day, or the lively sacrifice thereof, propitiatory and available for the sins of the quick and the dead, the holy scripture hath not so much as one syllable.
THERE is ambiguity also in the •ame of [mass,] what it signifieth, and whether at this day there be any such indeed as the ancient fathers used; seeing that now there be neither Catechists nor Penitents to be sent away.
THERE is ambiguity also in the •ame of [mass,] what it signifieth, and whether at this day there be any such indeed as the ancient fathers used; seeing that now there be neither Catechists nor Poenitentes to be sent away.
AGAIN, touching these words, [the lively sacrifice of the church,] there is doubt whether they are to be understood figuratively and sacramentally, for the sacrament of the lively sacrifice (after which sort we deny it not to be in the Lord's supper) or properly and without any figure; of the which manner there was but one only sacrifice, and that once offered, namely upon the altar of the cross.
MOREOVER, in these words, [as well as,] it may be doubted whether they be spoken in mockage; as men are wont to say in sport, of a foolish and ignorant person, that he is apt as well in conditions as in knowledge; being apt indeed in neither of them both.
THERE is also a doubt in the word [propitiable,] whether it signify here that which taketh away sin, or that which may be made available for the taking away of sin, that is to say, whether it is to be taken in the active, or in the passive signification.
NOW the falseness of the proposition, after the meaning of the schoolmen and the Romish church, and impiety in that sense which the words seem to import, is this; that they leaning to the foundation of their fond transubstantiation, would make the quick and lively body of Christ's flesh, (united and knit to the divinity) to lie hid under the accidents and outward appearances of bread and wine; and they building upon this foundation, do hold, that the same body is offered unto God by, the priest, in his daily massings, to put away the sins of the quick and the dead; whereas, by the apostle to the Hebrews, it is evident, that there is but one oblation, and one only true and lively sacrifice, of the church, offered upon the altar the cross, which was, is, and shall be for ever, the propitiation for the sins of the whole world▪ and where there is remission of the same, there is (saith the apostle) no more offering for sin.
(1) NO sacrifice ought to be done, but where the priest is meet to offer the same.
(2) ALL other priests are unmeet to offer propitiatory sacrifices, save only Christ.
(3) THEREFORE, no other priests ought to sacrifice for sin, but Christ alone. See Heb. chap. v.
THE second part of my argument is thus proved.
(1) No honour in God's church ought to be taken, where a man is not called, as Aaron was.
(2) It is a great honour in God's church to sacrifice for sin.
(3) THEREFORE no other priest but Christ ought to sacrifice for sin, who only was called to that honour.
THAT no man is called to this degree of honour, but Christ alone, is evident: for there are but two orders of priesthood allowed in the word of God; ⟨p. 335⟩namely, the order of Aaron, and that of Melchizedek: but now the order of Aaron is come to an end, by reason that it was unprofitable; and of the order of Melchizedek there is but one priest alone, even Christ the Lord, who hath a priesthood that cannot pass to any other. See Heb. chap. vii.
THAT no man is called to this degree of honour, but Christ alone, is evident: for there are but two orders of priesthood allowed in the word of God; ⟨p. 335⟩namely, the order of Aaron, and that of Melchisedek: but now the order of Aaron is come to an end, by reason that it was unprofitable; and of the order of Melchisedek there is but one priest alone, even Christ the Lord, who hath a priesthood that cannot pass to any other. See Heb. chap. vii.
(1) THAT thing is in vain, and to no effect, where there is no necessity it should be done.
(2) TO offer up any more sacrifice propitiatory for the quick and the dead, there is no necessity; for Christ our Saviour did that fully and perfectly once for all.
(3) ERGO, To do the same in the mass, is in vain.
(1) AFTER that eternal redemption is found and obtained, there needeth no more daily offering for the same.
(2) BUT Christ coming an high bishop, &c. found and obtained for us eternal redemption.